Utility of two-compartment models of exhaled nitric oxide in patients with asthma

Flow-independent nitric oxide parameters in asthma: a systematic review and meta-analysis

INTRODUCTION

Fractional exhaled nitric oxide (F_ENO) has been proposed as a non-invasive marker of inflammation in the lungs. Measuring F_ENO at several flow rates enables the calculation of flow independent NO-parameters that describe the NO-exchange dynamics of the lungs more precisely. The purpose of this study was to compare the NO-parameters between asthmatics and healthy subjects in a systematic review and meta-analysis.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed in Ovid Medline, Web of Science, Scopus and Cochrane Library databases. All studies with asthmatic and healthy control groups with at least one NO-parameter calculated were included.

RESULTS

From 1137 identified studies, 33 were included in the meta-analysis. All NO-parameters (alveolar NO concentration (C_ANO), bronchial flux of NO (J_awNO), bronchial mucosal NO concentration (C_awNO) and bronchial wall NO diffusion capacity (D_awNO)) were found increased in glucocorticoid-treated and glucocorticoid-naïve asthma. J_awNO and C_ANO were most notably increased in both study groups. Elevation of D_awNO and C_awNO seemed less prominent in both asthma groups.

DISCUSSION

We found that all the NO-parameters are elevated in asthma as compared to healthy subjects. However, results were highly heterogenous and the evidence on C_awNO and D_awNO is still quite feeble due to only few studies reporting them. To gain more knowledge on the NO-parameters in asthma, nonlinear methods and standardized study protocols should be used in future studies.

Optimal flow rate sampling designs for studies with extended exhaled nitric oxide analysis

INTRODUCTION

The fractional concentration of exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) is a biomarker of airway inflammation. Repeat FeNO maneuvers at multiple fixed exhalation flow rates (extended NO analysis) can be used to estimate parameters quantifying proximal and distal sources of NO in mathematical models of lower respiratory tract NO. A growing number of studies use extended NO analysis, but there is no official standard flow rate sampling protocol. In this paper, we provide information for study planning by deriving theoretically optimal flow rate sampling designs.

METHODS

First, we reviewed previously published designs. Then, under a nonlinear regression framework for estimating NO parameters in the steady-state two compartment model of NO, we identified unbiased optimal four flow rate designs (within the range of 10-400 ml s^-1) using theoretical derivations and simulation studies. Optimality criteria included NO parameter standard errors (SEs). A simulation study was used to estimate sample sizes required to detect associations with NO parameters estimated from studies with different designs.

RESULTS

Most designs (77%) were unbiased. NO parameter SEs were smaller for designs with: more target flows, more replicate maneuvers per target flow, and a larger range of target flows. High flows were most important for estimating alveolar NO concentration, while low flows were most important for the proximal NO parameters. The Southern California Children's Health Study design (30, 50, 100 and 300 ml s^-1) had ≥1.8 fold larger SEs and required 1.1-3.2 fold more subjects to detect the association of a determinant with each NO parameter as compared to an optimal design of 10, 50, 100 and 400 ml s^-1.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a class of reasonable flow rate sampling designs with good theoretical performance. In practice, designs should be selected to balance the tradeoffs between optimality and feasibility of the flow range and total number of maneuvers.

Inflammatory patterns in asthmatic children based on alveolar nitric oxide determination

INTRODUCTION

Nitric oxide (NO) levels can be measured at proximal (maximum airway NO flux [J'aw(NO)]) and distal (alveolar NO concentration [C(ANO)]) levels. Four inflammatory patterns have been described in asthmatic individuals, although their relevance has not been well established. The objective was to determine J'aw(NO) and C(ANO) in order to establish four inflammatory categories in asthmatics.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Cross-sectional study of a sample consisting of healthy and asthmatic children. Exhaled NO was determined at multiple flows. J'aw(NO) and C(ANO) were obtained according to the two-compartment model. The asthma control questionnaire (ACQ) and spirometry were administered to asthmatic children. Patients were categorized as type I (normal J'aw(NO) and C(ANO)), type II (elevated J'aw(NO) and normal C(ANO)), type III (elevated J'aw(NO) and C(ANO)) and type IV (normal J'aw(NO) and elevated C(ANO)). Correlation between FE(NO,50), J'aw(NO) and C(ANO) was analyzed using Spearman's R Correlation Test. Analysis of variance and paired comparisons were performed using the Bonferroni correction.

RESULTS

One hundred sixty-two children were studied, of whom 49 (32.23%) were healthy controls and 103 (67.76%) asthmatics. In the control subjects, FE(NO,50) (ppb)(median and range) was 11.5 (1.6 to 27.3), J'aw(NO) (pl/s) was 516 (98.3 to 1470) and C(ANO) (ppb) was 2.2 (0.1 to 4.5). Forty-four (42.7%) of the asthmatic participants were categorized as type I, 41 (39.8%) as type II, 14 (13.5%) as type III and 4 (3.88%) as type IV. Good correlation was observed between J'aw(NO) and FE(NO,50) (r=0.97). There was no association between J'aw(NO) and C(ANO). FEV1/FVC decreased significantly in type III (mean 79.8±7.5). Morbidity was significantly higher in types III and IV.

CONCLUSIONS

Normal values obtained are similar to those previously reported. Asthmatics with high C(ANO) showed higher morbidity. No correlation was found between proximal and distal inflammation.

Alveolar nitric oxide and its role in pediatric asthma control assessment

Background

Nitric oxide can be measured at multiple flow rates to determine proximal (maximum airway nitric oxide flux; Jaw_NO) and distal inflammation (alveolar nitric oxide concentration; CA_NO). The main aim was to study the association among symptoms, lung function, proximal (maximum airway nitric oxide flux) and distal (alveolar nitric oxide concentration) airway inflammation in asthmatic children treated and not treated with inhaled glucocorticoids.

Methods

A cross-sectional study with prospective data collection was carried out in a consecutive sample of girls and boys aged between 6 and 16 years with a medical diagnosis of asthma. Maximum airway nitric oxide flux and alveolar nitric oxide concentration were calculated according to the two-compartment model. In asthmatic patients, the asthma control questionnaire (CAN) was completed and forced spirometry was performed. In controls, differences between the sexes in alveolar nitric oxide concentration and maximum airway nitric oxide flux and their correlation with height were studied. The correlation among the fraction of exhaled NO at 50 ml/s (FE_NO50), CA_NO, Jaw_NO, forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV₁) and the CAN questionnaire was measured and the degree of agreement regarding asthma control assessment was studied using Cohen’s kappa.

Results

We studied 162 children; 49 healthy (group 1), 23 asthmatic participants without treatment (group 2) and 80 asthmatic patients treated with inhaled corticosteroids (group 3). CA_NO (ppb) was 2.2 (0.1-4.5), 3 (0.2-9.2) and 2.45 (0.1-24), respectively. Jaw_NO (pl/s) was 516 (98.3-1470), 2356.67 (120–6110) and 1426 (156–11805), respectively. There was a strong association (r = 0.97) between FE_NO50 and Jaw_NO and the degree of agreement was very good in group 2 and was good in group 3. There was no agreement or only slight agreement between the measures used to monitor asthma control (FEV₁, CAN questionnaire, CA_NO and Jaw_NO).

Conclusions

The results for CA_NO and Jaw_NO in controls were similar to those found in other reports. There was no agreement or only slight agreement among the three measure instruments analyzed to assess asthma control. In our sample, no additional information was provided by CA_NO and Jaw_NO.

Estimation of parameters in the two-compartment model for exhaled nitric oxide

The fractional concentration of exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) is a biomarker of airway inflammation that is being increasingly considered in clinical, occupational, and epidemiological applications ranging from asthma management to the detection of air pollution health effects. FeNO depends strongly on exhalation flow rate. This dependency has allowed for the development of mathematical models whose parameters quantify airway and alveolar compartment contributions to FeNO. Numerous methods have been proposed to estimate these parameters using FeNO measured at multiple flow rates. These methods—which allow for non-invasive assessment of localized airway inflammation—have the potential to provide important insights on inflammatory mechanisms. However, different estimation methods produce different results and a serious barrier to progress in this field is the lack of a single recommended method. With the goal of resolving this methodological problem, we have developed a unifying framework in which to present a comprehensive set of existing and novel statistical methods for estimating parameters in the simple two-compartment model. We compared statistical properties of the estimators in simulation studies and investigated model fit and parameter estimate sensitivity across methods using data from 1507 schoolchildren from the Southern California Children's Health Study, one of the largest multiple flow FeNO studies to date. We recommend a novel nonlinear least squares model with natural log transformation on both sides that produced estimators with good properties, satisfied model assumptions, and fit the Children's Health Study data well.

Multiple-flow exhaled nitric oxide, allergy, and asthma in a population of older children

"Extended" (multiple-flow) measurements of exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) potentially can distinguish proximal and distal airway inflammation, but have not been evaluated previously in large populations. We performed extended NO testing within a longitudinal study of a school-based population, to relate bronchial flux (J'awNO) and peripheral NO concentration (CalvNO) estimates with respiratory health status determined from questionnaires. We measured FeNO at 30, 50, 100, and 300 ml/sec in 1,640 subjects aged 12-15 from eight communities, then estimated J'awNO and CalvNO from linear and nonlinear regressions of NO output versus flow. J'awNO, as well as FeNO at all flows, showed influences of asthma, allergy, Asian or African ancestry, age, and height (positive), and of weight (negative), generally corroborating past findings. By contrast, CalvNO results were inconsistent across different extended NO regression models, and appeared more sensitive to small measurement artifacts.

CONCLUSIONS

Extended NO testing is feasible in field surveys of young populations. In interpreting results, size, age, and ethnicity require attention, as well as instrumental and environmental artifacts. J'awNO and conventional FeNO provide similar information, probably reflecting proximal airway inflammation. CalvNO may give additional information relevant to peripheral airway, alveolar, or systemic pathology. However, it needs additional research, including testing of populations with independently verifiable peripheral or systemic pathology, to optimize measurement technique and interpretation.

Lung oxidative damage by hypoxia

One of the most important functions of lungs is to maintain an adequate oxygenation in the organism. This organ can be affected by hypoxia facing both physiological and pathological situations. Exposure to this condition favors the increase of reactive oxygen species from mitochondria, as from NADPH oxidase, xanthine oxidase/reductase, and nitric oxide synthase enzymes, as well as establishing an inflammatory process. In lungs, hypoxia also modifies the levels of antioxidant substances causing pulmonary oxidative damage. Imbalance of redox state in lungs induced by hypoxia has been suggested as a participant in the changes observed in lung function in the hypoxic context, such as hypoxic vasoconstriction and pulmonary edema, in addition to vascular remodeling and chronic pulmonary hypertension. In this work, experimental evidence that shows the implied mechanisms in pulmonary redox state by hypoxia is reviewed. Herein, studies of cultures of different lung cells and complete isolated lung and tests conducted in vivo in the different forms of hypoxia, conducted in both animal models and humans, are described.