Replicated divergent selection of broiler chickens for high or low early antibody response to Escherichia coli vaccination

Direct and maternal genetic effects for preinflection point growth traits and humoral immunity in quail

Early growth traits in quails are considered as the growth performances before the inflection point which are genetically different from body weights (BW) at later stages. Moreover, in addition to growth performance, humoral immunity is moderately heritable and is considered in some breeding programs. However, estimating the direct genetic, particularly the maternal genetic correlations between growth and immunity in quail, are not studied sufficiently, which were the aims of the present study. The quails' BW were recorded at hatch (BW0) to 25 d of age with a 5-d interval and body weight gains (BWG) were measured as average growth performance of the birds in a 5-d period. Antibody titer against Newcastle disease virus (IgN) was measured through the hemagglutination inhibition (HI) test. For titration of anti-SRBC antibodies (IgY and IgM), a hemagglutination microtiter assay was used. In general, growth records in 4,181 birds and humoral immune responses in 1,023 birds were assigned to the study. The genetic parameters were estimated by single-trait analysis via Gibb's sampling. After finding the best model for each trait, multi-trait analysis was done to estimate the direct and maternal genetic correlations. Direct heritabilities (h²) were estimated to be moderate for BW (0.481-0.551) and BWG (0.524-0.557), while h² for immune responses were low (0.035-0.079). Maternal environmental effect (c²) was only significant for BW0, BW5, and BWG0-5. Maternal heritabilities (m²) for BW and BWG were all lower than corresponding h², ranging from 0.072 (BW25) to 0.098 (BW0). The m² for IgN (0.098) was more than 2.5 times greater than h² (0.040) for this trait. Direct (r_a) and maternal (r_m) genetic correlations between IgN-BW, IgY-BW, and IgY-BWG were negative, while ra and rm for IgM-BW, IgN-BWG, and IgM-BWG were positive. The r_a between humoral immune responses were low to moderate and rm was significant only for IgY-IgM (0.339). Given positive genetic correlations in BWG-IgN and BWG-IgM as well as positive genetic correlations between both IgN and IgM with IgY, it is suggested that including the BWG in the breeding programs would directly result in the improvement of the birds' growth performance. It would also contribute indirectly to the improvement of the birds' humoral immune responses.

Genetic resistance to avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC): current status and opportunities

Infections with avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) can be extremely detrimental to poultry health and production. Investigating host genetic variation could identify the biological mechanisms that control resistance to this pathogen and allow selection for improved resistance in experimental and commercial poultry populations. In this review, the current knowledge of how host genetics contributes to APEC resistance and future opportunities that would benefit the understanding or application of genetic resistance are discussed. Phenotypes, such as antibody responses, lesion scores, and mortality, revealed that genetic background impacts APEC resistance and interacts with other factors including the environment and challenge conditions. Experiments have used divergent selection for APEC-specific antibody levels to facilitate genetic studies, estimated heritabilities in relevant traits, detected quantitative trait loci using microsatellites, and made associations with sequence variation in the major histocompatibility complex, which collectively suggest that improving APEC resistance through selection is feasible, although genetic control is partial, complex, and highly polygenic. Additionally, functional genomics techniques have identified antimicrobial responses, toll-like receptor and cytokine signalling, and the cell cycle as central pathways in the host response to APEC challenge. Opportunities for future research are discussed, including the expansion of existing lines of research and the application of new technologies that are relevant to the study of host genetics and APEC. This review closes with prospective strategies for improvement of host genetic resistance to APEC.

Evaluation of genetic resistance to Salmonella Pullorum in three chicken lines

Resistance to diseases varies considerably among populations of the same species and can be ascribed to both genetic and environmental factors. Salmonella Pullorum (SP) is responsible for significant losses in the poultry industry, especially in developing countries. To better understand SP resistance in chicken populations with different genetic backgrounds, we orally challenged 3 chicken lines with SP-a highly selected commercial breed (Rhode Island Red, RIR), a local Chinese chicken (Beijing You, BY), and a synthetic layer line (dwarf, DW)-at 4 d of age. Two traits related to SP resistance, survival, and bacterial carriage in the spleen were evaluated after infection. Survival rates were recorded up to 40 d of age when all chickens still alive were killed to verify the presence of SP in the spleen to determine carrier state. Mortalities for RIR, BY, and DW chicks were 25.1%, 8.3%, and 22.7%, respectively, and the corresponding carrier-states in the spleens were 17.9%, 0.6%, and 15.8%. Survival and carrier-state heritabilities were estimated using an animal threshold model. Survival heritability was 0.197, 0.091, and 0.167 in RIR, BY, and DW populations, respectively, and the heritabilities of carrier state for DW and RIR were 0.32 and 0.16, respectively. This is the first time that the heritability of the SP carrier state has been evaluated in chickens. Our study provides experimental evidence that chickens with various genetic background exhibited significantly different SP-resistant activities and heritabilities. These results may be useful for selecting lines with better disease resistance.

Genetics of immunocompetent traits in a synthetic broiler dam line

Three hundred and three chicks of both sexes, from a synthetic dam line (SDL) of broiler chickens, were studied for economic traits (body weights at 4, 5 and 6 weeks of age) and immunological traits (humoral and cell mediated immune responses, and serum lysozyme concentration). The objective was to evaluate these traits and to estimate their genetic and non-genetic parameters. The humoral immune response was assessed by estimating the antibody response to sheep red blood cells using the haemagglutination (HA) test and serum IgG concentration using single radial immunodiffusion (SRID). The cell mediated immune (CMI) response was estimated as in vivo response to a mitogen (PHA-P). Serum lysozyme was measured by lysoplate assay. Least squares means for body weight at 4, 5 and 6 weeks were 684 +/- 20, 920 +/- 19 and 1205 +/- 28 g, HA titre was 6.289 +/- 0.246, CMI was 0.438 +/- 0.015 mm, lysozyme was 1.860 +/- 0.047 microg/ml and IgG was 6.287 +/- 0.194 mg/ml. There was an effect of sire on HA titre and on body weight at 4, 5 and 6 weeks of age; males were heavier than females. Heritability estimates were high for body weights but low for immunological traits. Phenotypic correlations (rp) among body weights were high and positive but were very low between body weights and most immunological traits. Among the immunological traits all rp were very low. Genetic correlations (rg) of body weights were positive and medium to high with CMI and HA and negative with serum IgG.

Breeding to reduce susceptibility to Escherichia coli in layers

Colibacillosis is a bacterial disease of great concern in the layer industry causing substantial animal and economic losses worldwide. Breeding for resistance to colibacillosis is an important control strategy that would complement traditional management strategies such as vaccinations and therapeutic treatments. Because antibiotic use in animal production is expected to substantially decrease in the future to meet not only consumer demands but also regulations, it is expected that bacterial diseases such as colibacillosis will become even more important. A challenge test was carried out on 353 pedigreed White Leghorn female chickens of 1 pure line. The birds were inoculated with Escherichia coli at an age of 93 to 95 wk (3 hatches) and symptoms of disease and mortality were constantly monitored for up to 6 d after inoculation. The cumulative mortality was 64%, the majority of which took place in the first 2 d. In the present study, genetic parameters of resistance to colibacillosis were estimated to judge the value of genetic selection. The heritability for survival rate was 0.17+/-0.07. Both for quantitative as well as for qualitative traits of economic interest, there was no remarkable difference between survivors and hens that died. Data showed that it is in principle possible to breed for colibacillosis resistance without penalizing the improvement in other key traits. The B21 marker for MHC in this study was associated with a lower colibacillosis susceptibility. In this study, it was demonstrated that it is possible to breed for Escherichia coli resistance. However, due to the inconveniences of a challenge test, it would be very interesting to make use of MAS.

Passive immunity of progeny from broiler breeders vaccinated with oil-emulsion bacterin against Salmonella enteritidis

Young poultry are very susceptible to Salmonella Enteritidis (SE) infections because of the absence of complete intestinal flora colonization and an immature immune system. This study evaluated the role of passive immunity on the resistance of young birds against early infections caused by SE. The progeny of broiler breeders vaccinated with an oil-emulsion bacterin was compared to the progeny of unvaccinated birds. Efficacy was determined by challenging birds at 1 and 14 days of age with SE Nal Spc strain, phage type 4. After challenge at 1 day of age, the progeny of vaccinated birds presented a significantly lower number (log10) of SE Nal Spc reisolation (P < 0.05) in liver (2.21), spleen (2.31), and cecal contents (2.85) compared with control groups (2.76, 3.02, and 6.03, respectively). The examination of the internal organs, 3 days after infection, revealed that 28% of the birds (7/25) from vaccinated breeders were positive, whereas 100% (25/25) of the chicks derived from unvaccinated birds were positive. Birds challenged at 14 days of age presented a lower number of positive samples compared with those challenged at 1 day of age, and the progeny of vaccinated birds presented statistically lower numbers (log10) of colony-forming units/ml of SE Nal Spc only in the cecal contents compared with nonvaccinated breeder progeny (2.11 vs. 2.94). Age seems to influence the susceptibility of birds to SE infections: in control groups, the number of positive birds at 14 days of age (9/25) was lower when compared with the group infected at 1 day of age (25/25). The number of positive fecal samples of the progeny of vaccinated birds was significantly lower (36) than those of the control group (108) after challenge at 1 day of age. Unchallenged progeny of vaccinated birds presented passive antibodies detectable by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) up to 21 days of age. On the other hand, antibodies of the control group were detected by ELISA 14 days after challenge. These results show a significant contribution of breeder vaccination by increasing the resistance of the progeny against early SE infections. However, the bacteria were not completely eliminated, suggesting that additional procedures are needed to effectively control SE infections.

Modeling variability in immunocompetence and immunoresponsiveness

The purposes of this paper were to 1) develop a stochastic model that would reflect observed variation between animals and across ages in immunocompetence and responsiveness; and 2) illustrate consequences of this variability for the statistical power of genotype comparisons and selection. A stochastic model of immunocompetence development and responsiveness kinetics was developed. This model enabled variability in immunological variables to be taken into account in the evaluation of challenge and measurement strategies for selection. The characteristics of the variation in model output reflect those observed in the literature, to the extent that variation in the literature shows a consistent pattern; knowledge of true variation and patterns of variation in immunological variables is limited. The model created correlations between immunocompetence and immunoresponsiveness components, as well as correlations within each component across time. These correlations were generally in agreement with literature estimates, where available. The model enabled predictions of the effectiveness of selection for improved health through immunocompetence or immunoresponsiveness. It was predicted that effective selection for increased general immunocompetence to improve health should be done only when baseline immunity has matured. Further, the model implied that selection is unlikely to be successful if it is based only on a single measurement. Problems with low statistical power to detect differences between genotypes can be reduced by increasing challenge age in the experimental design, and one should ensure that the effects of maternal immunity are minimal when the challenge is done. The ability to detect differences between different groups of animals differs substantially with measurement timing because of low repeatabilities of immunocompetence and responsiveness across time. In general, the probability of detecting differences becomes higher when the challenge age is increased. Consequently, both the age at selection and the age at which information is gathered for selection must be considered carefully when designing genetic evaluations.

Modeling Immunocompetence Development and Immunoresponsiveness to Challenge in Chicks

The purpose of this study was 2-fold: 1) to develop a deterministic model that describes the development of immunocompetence and the kinetics of immunoresponsiveness to a pathogenic challenge in chicks and 2) to use this model to illustrate the importance of factors in experimental design, such as type of variable measured, measurement timing, and challenge age. Difficulties in evaluating immunological variables hinder attempts to improve animal health through selection on immunological variables. In young chicks, evaluating immunological variables is additionally complicated by immune system development and maternal immunity. The evaluation of immunocompetence and immunoresponsiveness and the definition of appropriate challenge and measurement strategies may be enabled through a mathematical model that captures the key components of the immune system and its development. Therefore, a model was developed that describes the development of immunocompetence as well as the kinetics of immunoresponsiveness to a pathogenic extracellular bacterial challenge in an individual chick from 0 to 56 d of age. The model consisted of 4 components describing immunocompetence (maternal and baseline immunity) and immunoresponsiveness (acute phase and antibody response). Individual component equations generally fit published data adequately. Four scenarios that represented combinations of challenge age and measurement timing were simulated. In each scenario, the immunoresponsiveness to a particular challenge was compared for 3 different levels of baseline immunity, representing 3 broiler genotypes. It was illustrated that experimental design (type of immunoresponsiveness measured, measurement timing, and challenge age) can have an important effect on the ranking of genotypes, groups, or individuals and on the reliability of extrapolations based on this ranking. It is concluded that this model is a potentially useful tool in the definition of appropriate challenge and measurement strategies when evaluating immunocompetence and immunoresponsiveness. Further, it may be used as a generator of hypotheses on global immunological relationships to be tested experimentally.

Genetic variation among broiler genotypes in susceptibility to colibacillosis

Selection for reduced susceptibility to colibacillosis in broilers may contribute to the prevention of colibacillosis. Such selection should focus on the responses to Escherichia coli rather than the associated primary agent(s). The purpose of the current study was to examine whether genetic variation is present in the susceptibility to colibacillosis. This was achieved through an evaluation of the susceptibility to primary colibacillosis in 5 pure broiler lines, a slow-growing line, and two 2-way crosses of the pure lines (altogether referred to as genotypes). A challenge experiment was executed in 2 trials. Per trial, 24 chicks per genotype were challenged and 20 chicks per genotype were controls. At 7 d of age, challenged chicks were intratracheally inoculated with 0.3 mL of E. coli O78K80 solution, and controls with 0.3 mL of PBS. All chicks were euthanized at 14 or 15 d. Traits measured were mortality, lesion scores (airsacculitis, pericarditis, and perihepatitis) at 14 or 15 d, and BW at 1, 4, 7, 10, 12, and 14 or 15 d. An effect of genotype on mortality, lesion prevalence, and growth retardation was found, indicating the presence of genetic variation in susceptibility to colibacillosis, and suggesting that selection for reduced susceptibility is possible. There were large between-genotype differences in mortality (up to 46%) and in lesion prevalence (up to 41%). Growth retardation was not observed for any genotype in chicks without lesions, whereas genotypes differed from none to 20% growth retardation for chicks with airsacculitis but no systemic lesions, and up to 13% for chicks with systemic lesions. The heterosis in susceptibility and growth retardation was found to be either negative or absent, indicating that crossbreeding would not be an advantage for the selection for reduced susceptibility, and that test crossing is essential.

Genetic variation in major histocompatibility complex class I alpha2 gene among broilers divergently selected for high or low early antibody response to Escherichia coli

The MHC genes have a profound effect on animal abilities to respond to specific antigens because they play a role in presenting foreign antigens to T cells during the course of the humoral or cellular immune response. In the current study, polymorphism in the MHC class I alpha2 domain was compared in 2 lines divergently selected for high (HH) or low (LL) antibody response to Escherichia coli vaccine. These lines also differ markedly in their antibody response to natural E. coli exposure and to vaccination with Newcastle disease virus, infectious bronchitis virus, and infectious bursa disease virus. Recent trials have shown that the LL chicks exhibit a significantly higher percentage of CD8+ T lymphocytes in their peripheral blood lymphocytes and spleen than HH chicks. Despite symmetrical selection intensity in both lines, polymorphism of the alpha2-domain gene was higher in the LL line than in the HH line. Among 29 single-nucleotide polymorphism positions found, 3 were unique to the HH line, 15 were unique to the LL line, and 11 were polymorphic in both lines. These single nucleotide polymorphism positions were not 100% line specific and were in agreement with the genetic variation in antibody level or cellular response still found within the selection lines. Five amino acid positions showed significant differences in polymorphism between the selection lines. These were located within the antigen-binding cleft, suggesting that these positions might influence the ability of MHC class I to bind foreign antigens and leading to differences in immunocompetence between the lines.

Stress response differences and disease susceptibility reflected by heterophil to lymphocyte ratio in turkeys selected for increased body weight

Three genetic lines of turkeys were compared for their responses to Escherichia coli challenge following dexamethasone injection (Dex) or E. coli challenge preceding transport stress (TS). The turkey lines were a slow growing line selected for increased egg production (Egg line), a fast growing line selected for increased 16-wk BW (F line), and a commercial line (Comm line). At 14 wk of age, the Dex group was treated with 3 injections of 2 mg of Dex/kg of BW followed by airsac challenge with 100 cfu of E. coli. The TS group was given the same E. coli challenge at 1 x 10(4) cfu/bird without Dex treatment, and was subjected to transport stress, including 12 h of holding time in a transport vehicle, 8 d after the challenge. All treated birds and untreated control birds were bled at the same time, which was 1 d after transport and 9 d after challenge with E. coli. The main effect mean (MEM) total leukocyte counts (WBC) and the percentages of eosinophils (Eos) and basophils (Baso) were the same for all 3 lines; however, the MEM percentages of heterophils (Het) and monocytes (Mono) and the heterophil/lymphocyte ratio (H/L) were lower and the percentage of lymphocytes (Lym) was higher in the Egg line compared with the 2 fast-growing lines. Both stress treatments increased WBC, Het, and H/L and decreased Lym in all 3 lines; however, these effects were significantly greater in both fast growing lines compared with the Egg line. Sixteen-week BW was unaffected by either treatment in the Egg line and was decreased by both treatments in the Comm line and by the Dex treatment in the F line. Main effect mean airsacculitis score (AS) was not affected by line and was significantly increased by TS and Dex treatments. Neither treatment affected AS of the Egg line birds, whereas Dex treatment increased AS of the F line, and both Dex and TS increased AS of the Comm line. Mortality was significantly higher in the Comm line compared with the Egg line and was intermediate in the F line. The differences between these lines in their disease resistance and physiological response to stress in 2 stress models suggests that increasing selection for BW of turkeys is accompanied by changes in the stress response resulting in increased susceptibility to opportunistic bacterial infection.

Microsatellite markers associated with quantitative trait loci controlling antibody response to Escherichia coli and Salmonella enteritidis in young broilers

A unique resource population was produced to facilitate detection of microsatellite markers associated with quantitative trait loci controlling antibody (Ab) response in broiler chickens. Three F1 males were produced by mating two lines divergently selected on Ab response to Escherichia coli vaccination. Each F1 male was mated with females from four genetic backgrounds: F1, high-Ab line (HH), low-Ab line and commercial line, producing three resource families, each with four progeny types. About 1700 chicks were immunized with E. coli and Salmonella enteritidis vaccines. Selective genotyping was conducted on the individuals with highest or lowest average Ab to E. coli and S. enteritidis within each progeny type in each sire family. Twelve markers were significantly associated with Ab to E. coli and six of them were also associated with Ab to S. enteritidis, mostly exhibiting a similar low effect (approximately 0.35 phenotypic SD) in all progeny types. Four markers exhibited a highly significant and much larger effect (approximately 1.7 SD), but only in progeny of females from the HH, suggesting that a backcross to the high parental line should be preferred over the commonly used F2 population. Results from two markers suggested a quantitative trait locus on chromosome 2 around 400 cM. The marker MCW0083, significant in two sire families, is closely linked to the bone morphogenetic protein 2 (BMP2) gene, known to be associated with the control of T-cell transformation in humans.

Associations of interferon-gamma genotype and protein level with antibody response kinetics in chickens

Although previous studies have demonstrated an association between interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) promoter genotype and antibody response kinetics in chickens, the protein levels that may mediate such a gene-trait association have not been determined. The objective of this study, therefore, was to determine the correlation of circulating IFN-gamma levels with both the IFN-gammaIFN-gamma promoter polymorphisms and antibody response in order to evaluate the potential role of IFN-gamma protein in mediating genetic control of antibody response in chickens. Antibody response after Salmonella enteritidis (SE) vaccination at day 10, antibody response to sheep red blood cells (SRBCs) and killed Brucella abortus after immunizations at 19 wk and 22 wk, and serum IFN-gamma protein level were measured in an F2 population derived from inbred lines. A single nucleotide polymorphism in the IFN-gamma promoter region was associated with IFN-gamma protein expression as measured by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay after both primary and secondary immunizations. Higher IFN-gamma protein level was correlated with higher antibody level to SE and with increased maximum level and decreased time to reach the maximum secondary antibody response to SRBCs. These results suggest that one of the mechanisms by which promoter polymorphism of IFN-gamma affects antibody production in chickens may involve the circulating level of IFN-gamma protein.

Genetic resistance to Salmonella typhimurium in two lines of chickens selected as resistant and sensitive on the basis of heterophil/lymphocyte ratio

1. A study was conducted to test for the validity of the heterophil/lymphocyte (H/L) ratio as a criterion for selection for resistance to Salmonella typhimurium in chickens. 2. An infective dose of S. typhimurium was given, directly in the crop, to two groups of chicken selected as Resistant (R) and Sensitive (S) on the bases of H/L ratio. The 99% lower confidence limit was used as a borderline; individuals below the limit were considered R and those above S. Many aspects of immune response were compared, namely: H/L ratio, antibody titre, cellular immunity, phagocytic activity, cortisol concentration, bursa and body weight. 3. The R group exceeded the S in all the studied variables of the immune response, indicating the possibility of using the H/L ratio and its confidence limit to select for general resistance. 4. Due to the within-strain variability in resistance, it seems that immunological and genetic studies should take into consideration separation of individuals into R and S before grouping. Failing to do so might lead to erroneous conclusions as a difference may simply be due to the different numbers of R and S included in each group.

Genetic and phenotypic correlations between antibody responses to Escherichia coli, infectious bursa disease virus (IBDV), and Newcastle disease virus (NDV), in broiler lines selected on antibody response to Escherichia coli

The genetic control of antibody (Ab) response to Escherichia coli (EC), infectious bursa disease virus, and Newcastle disease virus and the genetic and phenotypic correlation between these Ab responses, were evaluated under farm conditions in which chicks were simultaneously exposed to these antigens. The experimental population comprised five groups: two lines divergently selected for high (HH) or low (LL) Ab response to EC vaccination; a commercial broiler dam-line (CC), from which HH and LL had been derived; and the HH x CC and LL x CC hybrid groups (HC and LC, respectively). Lines LL and HH expressed similar symmetric divergence to all three antigens. The ranking of the LL, LC, CC, HC, and HH genetic groups according to their mean Ab responses and their very high linear correlation with the LL vs. HH genomic scale clearly indicate the additive nature of the genetic divergence between these lines. Several estimates of correlation were calculated between Ab responses of each pair of antigens and between BW and Ab to each antigen. The high correlation between group means, the near-zero within-group correlation, and the low phenotypic correlation indicate the strongly positive genetic correlation between Ab responses and no correlation with BW. The results of this study suggest that overall immunocompetence of commercial broilers can be improved by selection for high Ab response of young chicks to controlled immunization with a single antigen, without counteracting further selection for high BW.

Antibody responses and morbidity following infection with infectious bronchitis virus and challenge with Escherichia coli, in lines divergently selected on antibody response

We evaluated the association between antibody (Ab) production and disease resistance. A controlled-challenge protocol was developed to mimic natural infection and to yield a higher rate of mortality following Escherichia coli (EC) challenge. Chicks were first infected with infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) by injecting a high dose of vaccine (attenuated virus) into their air sacs and then were infected with pathogenic EC introduced intratracheally. The experimental population consisted of lines divergently selected for high (HH) or low (LL) Ab response to EC vaccination, an HH x LL cross (HL), and commercial broilers (CC). When chicks were vaccinated with EC vaccine, mean Ab titer 15 d post-EC challenge was threefold higher in HH than LL lines, but both lines exhibited very low mortality (approximately 2%). When chicks were not vaccinated prior to EC challenge, high mortality (8 to 20%) occurred in the slow-growing HH, LL, and HL lines, and much higher mortality (approximately 40%) occurred among the CC broilers that were 38% heavier than the HH, LL, and HL lines. Mean level of Ab to EC, 7 d after EC challenge, was about twofold higher in HH vs. LL chicks and intermediate in HL and CC chicks. Within each line, Ab levels were higher in chicks exhibiting colibacillosis than in healthy ones, suggesting that these Ab were produced as a result of ongoing infection but were too late to fully prevent morbidity and mortality. These results indicate that rapid growth rate substantially reduces broiler viability, whereas Ab levels produced in response to acute pathogenic challenge without prior vaccination do not contribute to disease resistance. Among the relatively slow-growing lines, mortality was about twofold higher in HH than in LL lines. This finding may confirm previous reports that without prior vaccination, high Ab response to acute challenge increases consequent mortality; alternatively, the LL line may be superior in nonspecific defense mechanisms.

Salmonella enterica serovar enteritidis burden in broiler breeder chicks genetically associated with vaccine antibody response

The relationship between antibody response to Salmonella enteritidis vaccine and internal organ burden of S. enteritidis is not fully understood. The genetic relationship, therefore, between postchallenge S. enteritidis burden and antibody response to S. enteritidis vaccine was determined in broiler breeder chicks. Sibling chicks from a broiler breeder male line were either inoculated with a pathogenic S. enteritidis or vaccinated with a commercial S. enteritidis vaccine. Spleen, liver, cecal wall, and cecal content samples from S. enteritidis-challenged chicks (n = 120) were cultured for enumeration of bacteria. Unchallenged chicks (n = 314) were vaccinated at 11 days of age, and serum samples were taken at 10 days postvaccination. Antibody response to vaccination and number of S. enteritidis in cecal content cultures were negatively correlated (-0.772), demonstrating that genetic potential for greater antibody response to S. enteritidis vaccine is associated with lesser S. enteritidis bacterial burden in cecal content of broiler breeder chicks. The findings suggest that genetic selection for vaccine antibody responsiveness can lower bacterial burden in the gut lumenal content and, thus, potentially reduce contamination of poultry products at processing.

Candidate gene promoter polymorphisms and antibody response kinetics in chickens: interferon-gamma, interleukin-2, and immunoglobulin light chain

An F2 population was produced from mating G0 highly inbred (>99%) males of two MHC-congenic Fayoumi lines with G-B1 Leghorn hens. The F2 population was essentially a full-sibship with the F1 sire line reflecting MHC effect. Adult F2 hens (n = 158) were injected twice with SRBC and whole fixed Brucella abortus (BA). Agglutinating antibody titer at 7 d after primary immunization and mean titer of the final three samples (Days 18, 32, and 63 after the second immunization) were used as parameters for primary and equilibrium phases, respectively. Secondary phase parameters of minimum (Ymin), maximum titers (Ymax) and time needed to achieve minimum (Tmin) and maximum (Tmax) titers were estimated from seven postsecondary titers with a nonlinear regression model. Three candidate genes, interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), interleukin-2 (IL-2), and immunoglobulin G light chain (IgL) were studied. Primers for the promoter regions were designed from EMBL chicken genomic sequences. Polymorphisms between parental lines were detected by direct sequencing. Polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism methods were then developed to directly detect the polymorphism. There were significant main effects (P < 0.05, general linear model analysis) of IFN-gamma polymorphism on Ymax of BA antibody and interaction of IFN-gamma by IgL on primary antibody response to SRBC and BA, and on Tmin and Ymin of antibody response to SRBC in F2 offspring of M5.1 grandsires. There were significant main effects of IFN-gamma polymorphism on Tmax of BA and interaction of IFN-gamma by IL-2 on Ymin to SRBC in F2 offspring of M15.2 grandsires. The results suggest that IFN-gamma genes play an important role in chicken primary and secondary antibody response to SRBC and BA antigens, and there exists interaction among genes for antibody production.

Immune response and resistance to infectious bursal disease virus of chicken lines selected for high or low antibody response to Escherichia coli

Two experimental broiler lines were developed by divergent selection for high (HH) and low (LL) antibody response to Escherichia coli. Antibody response of these lines to immunization with a commercial vaccine (whole inactivated virus, WIV) against infectious bursal disease virus (IBDV) or with proteins VP2 and VP3 of that virus, and their resistance to challenge with a virulent IBDV, were tested. The study was performed with 213 male and female chicks from the tenth generation of the HH and LL lines. At 15 d of age, after disappearance of maternal antibodies, chicks from each line were randomly divided into four groups and injected with WIV, VP2, VP3, or adjuvant alone as a negative control. Chicks were bled 18 d postinjection, and antibody titers were determined by ELISA. Ten days later, the chicks were challenged with a virulent strain of the virus and killed after 10 d; the ratio of bursa of Fabricius to 100 g BW was determined for each bird. Significant differences in antibody titers were found among immunized and control chicks. Chicks from the HH line exhibited significantly higher antibody titers than LL chicks in response to WIV and VP2 vaccines but not to VP3 vaccine. Following challenge, bursa weight (relative to BW) of HH and LL chicks vaccinated with WIV and VP2 was significantly higher (P < 0.01) than that of chicks vaccinated with VP3 or the challenged unvaccinated control. No difference was found in this parameter between the latter two groups. Possible explanations for the differences in the line response to VP2 and VP3 are discussed.

Effect of selection for increased body weight in turkeys on lymphoid organ weights, phagocytosis, and antibody responses to fowl cholera and Newcastle disease-inactivated vaccines

The influence of selection was studied for increased 16-wk BW in turkeys on in vivo phagocytic activity, antibody responses to vaccines, and weight of the spleen and bursa of Fabricius. A line (F) of turkeys selected long term for increased 16-wk BW and its corresponding randombred control (RBC2) were compared. Phagocytic activity was evaluated by the carbon clearance assay. Antibody responses to inactivated Newcastle disease virus and Pasteurella multocida vaccines were examined by ELISA. Body weight and relative weights of spleen and bursa of Fabricius of the two lines were also compared. The F line had lower phagocytic activity than the RBC2 line (P < 0.05). In addition, the F line had greater BW, relative weight of spleen, and ratio of spleen to bursa of Fabricius weight (P < 0.01) but had a lower relative weight of bursa of Fabricius at 9 wk of age. However, there were no line differences in the antibody responses to Newcastle disease virus or P. multocida vaccines at 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, or 12 wk after vaccination. Based on the present results, it is suggested that long-term selection for increased 16-wk BW might have resulted in changes in the immune system, as indicated by changes in the relative weights of the spleen and bursa of Fabricius and phagocytic activity. The decreased phagocytic activity in the F line may be partially responsible for increased susceptibility to specific diseases in this line.

Effect and repeatability of Ascaridia galli egg output in cockerels following a single low dose infection

Three groups of caged 20 Tetra-SL cockerels aged 1 day were orally infected with 30, 60 or 125 embryonated Ascaridia galli eggs. After 11, 12 and 13 weeks, faecal egg counts (FECs) were determined. All birds were slaughtered after the last sampling. A group of 25 control birds was sampled and slaughtered in parallel. The gastrointestinal tracts were examined for the presence of adult stages of A. galli. A random sample of 10% was also examined for the presence of immature stages of A. galli. The group with an infection dose of 125 eggs showed the highest average worm burden (p<0.05) and number of females (p<0.05), but the mean establishment rate was the lowest in this group. There was no significant difference in the mean logFEC between the groups. The logFEC per female worm was the highest in the low infection group (p<0.05). The average worm length and weight and the birds body weight were not significantly different among the groups. The estimated repeatabilities for mean logFEC of the different samples were reasonably high (0.55-0.87). This may open a way of genetic selection for A. galli resistance in chickens, which will be of importance for birds kept in alternative and organic farming systems.

DNA microsatellites linked to quantitative trait loci affecting antibody response and survival rate in meat-type chickens

Selection for immune response parameters may lead to improved general disease resistance. Because disease resistance and immune response are hard-to-measure quantitative traits with low to moderate heritability, they may respond more efficiently to marker-assisted selection (MAS) than to phenotypic selection. To detect DNA markers linked to quantitative trait loci (QTL) associated with immune response, a resource half-sib family of 160 backcross (BC1) and intercross (F2) birds was derived from a cross between two meat-type lines divergently selected for high or low antibody (Ab) response to Escherichia coli. By using 25 microsatellite DNA markers covering approximately 25% of the chicken genome, initial genotyping of 40% of the resource family was followed by complete genotyping of the entire family with four suggestive markers. Three of these markers exhibited significant association with immune response: (1) ADL0146 on Chromosome 2 associated with Ab to SRBC and Newcastle disease virus (NDV), (2) ADL0290 on linkage group 31 affecting Ab to NDV, and (3) ADL0298 on linkage group 34 associated with Ab to E. coli and survival. The family was also genotyped with five linked markers from two of the suggested regions, and interval mapping was applied. The results confirmed the significant effects, suggested the location of the QTL, and confirmed the genetic association between immune responses and disease resistance. These findings support the idea of improving poultry immunocompetence by MAS.

The dynamics of antibody response to Escherichia coli vaccination in meat-type chicks

The dynamics of serum antibody (Ab) response in young broilers were studied in lines divergently selected for high (HC) or low (LC) Ab response to Escherichia coli vaccination at an early age, and their cross (HL). Chicks were divided into three vaccination-age (VA) groups: 8, 10, and 12 d of age (VA8, VA10, and VA12, respectively). Antibody response was determined five times for each chick, at 6, 8, 10, 12, and 14 d postvaccination (dPV). The effects of line, VA, and dPV on Ab titers were highly significant. The HC and LC chicks exhibited the highest and lowest mean titers, respectively, in all VA groups. The HL chicks exhibited midparent Ab values for all VA and dPV combinations, indicating additive inheritance of early Ab production. In LC, the highest mean Ab titer was obtained on Day 26 (14 dPV of the VA12 group), whereas in HC, the same titer had already been obtained on Day 18 (VA8-10 dPV and VA10-8 dPV combinations). The VA8 and VA12 chicks differed markedly in their Ab titer dynamics curves, and the VA10 chicks exhibited an intermediate curve. The three VA groups exhibited a similar change in Ab level from 6 to 10 dPV, but they differed in Ab change from 10 to 14 dPV. This significant dPV x VA interaction suggests that the VA12 and VA10, but not VA8, chicks maintained the capability to produce persisting Ab.

Systemic and local immune response of cows to intramammary infection with Staphylococcus aureus

The association between Staphylococcus aureus chronic mammary gland infection and the resulting immune response expressed by the production of specific IgG and IgA antibodies in blood and milk was studied in Israeli Holstein cows. Specific antibodies of the IgG class were detected in sera of 82.6 per cent of the cows chronically infected by S aureus, while in 17.4 per cent no such antibodies could be detected. Specific IgG antibodies to S aureus were neither detected in sera of cows free of mammary infection nor in those infected with different coagulase-negative staphylococci (CNS) such as S intermedius, S chromogenes or S haemolyticus. In milk, specific IgG antibodies to S aureus were detected only in cows with positive serology. The end point dilutions in the milk were 5 to 30 per cent of that of blood from the same cow. No significant difference in IgG titres was found in the same cow if the quarter was infected with S aureus or not. Specific antibodies to S aureus of the IgA class could not be detected in the sera of any of the cows included in this study. In milk, a specific IgA antibody was detected only in the samples from the S aureus infected quarters in which S aureus was isolated at the time of the experiment. In the same cow, quarters infected by S aureus were found to have a significantly higher IgA titre (P < 0.0001) than that of the non-infected ones.

Immunocompetence and viability under commercial conditions of broiler groups differing in growth rate and in antibody response to Escherichia coil vaccine

Mortality and morbidity due to infectious diseases are an increasing source of losses to the broiler industry. Breeding chickens for improved disease resistance may reduce these losses. A study was designed to evaluate the contribution of selection for immune response to viability of broilers under farm conditions. The experimental populations consisted of six groups: two lines divergently selected for high (HH) or low (LL) antibody (Ab) response to Escherichia coli vaccination; commercial broilers (CC); and the HH x CC, LL x CC, and HH x LL crosses. Chicks were tested under standard vaccination program and management on commercial farms in two years (1997 and 1998). Mortality was recorded in the whole groups, each consisting of several hundred or thousand of chicks, whereas BW and Ab to natural exposure to E. coli and to vaccination with Newcastle disease virus (NDV) were determined in samples of 50 to 120 chicks/group per yr. Groups were clustered into three levels of BW: CC representing contemporary fast-growing broilers; HH, LL, and HL representing broilers 10 yr earlier; and HC and LC with intermediate BW. The HH and LL groups exhibited the highest and lowest E. coli Ab titers, respectively. Mean Ab of the CC group equaled the average of the selected lines, and all crosses exhibited mid-parent Ab titers, indicating additive genetic control. Group means for Ab to NDV were highly correlated with those of E. coli, suggesting a common genetic control for the immune response to these two antigens. In both years, the highest mortality was found in the fast-growing group (CC), and the lowest mortality was in the slow-growing HH, LL, and HL groups. In the crosses, despite their similar mean BW, mortality was one-third higher among LC vs. HC birds. These results suggest that Ab response and potential growth rate interact in their effect on mortality due to infectious diseases.

Antibody responses to sheep red blood cell and Brucella abortus antigens in a turkey line selected for increased body weight and its randombred control

Turkeys from a randombred control line (RBC2) and its subline (F) selected for increased 16-wk BW were tested for primary and secondary antibody responses to SRBC antigen and Brucella abortus antigen (BA). Previous studies have shown that the F line was more susceptible to Pasteurella multocida and Newcastle disease virus than was the RBC2 line. Individuals from the RBC2 and F lines were intravenously injected with 1 mL 5% SRBC antigen or 0.1 mL undiluted BA at 4 and 6 wk of age; blood samples were collected at 0, 4, 7, and 10 d post-immunization. Total, IgG, and IgM titers were measured by agglutination assays. Compared with the RBC2 line, the F line had generally higher total anti-SRBC titers; the differences were significant at 14 d postprimary immunization (PPI) (females); at 10 d postsecondary immunization (PSI) (males); and 4, 7, and 10 d PSI (females) (P < or = 0.05). The F line also had higher IgM titers at 14 d PPI (females) and at 10 d PSI (males) (P < or = 0.05). For IgG titers, a line difference was evident in females at 4 and 10 d PSI (P < or = 0.05); the F line had higher titers than did the RBC2 line. For the antibody response to BA in males, the F line had lower total and IgM titers at 10 d PPI (P < 0.05) than did the RBC2 line. No significant line differences in response to the BA were found in total and IgM titers in female turkeys or in IgG titers in both sexes at any time. These results suggest that selection for fast growth rate of turkeys might have resulted in changes in humoral immunity to the SRBC antigen and BA.

Kinetics of antibody responses in hens from chicken lines divergently selected for response to sheep red blood cells

Changes in antibody titers to SRBC were monitored for 180 d after inoculation in hens from two lines divergently selected for 24 generations for high (HAS) or low (LAS) antibody response to SRBC. The HAS hens not only had a higher peak of antibody response (12.9 vs 9.4), but also showed greater persistence in maintaining antibody levels than LAS hens. As a result, HAS hens exhibited higher antibody titers for the 180-d assay period than LAS hens. Antibodies to SRBC were detected in all day-old chicks hatched from HAS eggs collected 10 to 14 d after inoculation as well as 92 to 119 d after inoculation. Only a portion (20 to 75%) of progeny for LAS hens had detectable levels of antibody during the same periods. Among responders, antibody titers were higher for HAS than for LAS progeny. There was a positive correlation among antibody titers taken at different times after the inoculation with SRBC.

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) related cDNA probes associated with antibody response in meat-type chickens

The major histocompatibility complex (MHC) region was examined as a set of candidate genes for association between DNA markers and antibody response. Intercross F2 families of chickens were generated from a cross between high (HC) and low (LC) Escherichia coli(i) antibody lines. Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis was conducted by using three MHC-related cDNA probes: chicken MHC class IV (B-G), chicken MHC class I (B-F), and human MHC-linked Tap2. Association between RFLP bands and three antibody response traits (E. coli, sheep red blood cells and Newcastle disease virus) were determined by two methods: by statistically analyzing each band separately and also by analyzing all bands obtained from the three probes by using multiple regression analysis to account for the multiple comparisons. The MHC class IV probe was the highest in polymorphisms but had the lowest number of bands associated with antibody response. The MHC class I probe yielded 15 polymorphic bands of which four exhibited association with antibody response traits. The Tap2 probe yielded 20 different RFLP bands of which five were associated with antibody production. Some Tap2 bands were associated with multiple antibody response traits. The multiband analysis of the three probes' bands revealed more significant effects than the analysis of each band separately. This study illustrates the efficacy of using multiple MHC region probes as candidate markers for quantitative trait loci (QTLs) controlling antibody response in chickens.

Direct and correlated response to divergent selection for serum immunoglobulin M and G levels in chickens

Two pairs of chicken lines were divergently selected for serum immunoglobulin M and G levels at 10 wk of age to examine the effect of selection on direct and correlated traits. After three generations of selection, the lines were tested for their ability of antibody production against SRBC, a T cell dependent antigen. At 14 and 17 wk of age, the lines were immunized intravenously with 1 mL of 5% SRBC solution. Blood samples were collected at 7 and 14 d of post primary immunization (PPI) and post secondary immunization (PSI). Selection was effective (P < 0.01) in changing the serum immunoglobulin M levels. The G levels were changed in a downward direction initially in the high line. The differences between the high immunoglobulin M (HIM) and low immunoglobulin M (LIM) lines as well as high immunoglobulin G (HIG) and low immunoglobulin G (LIG) lines became larger during the course of selection. Selection differentials varied considerably during the selection, but the selection response was almost constant. Realized heritability was relatively high, ranging from 0.58 to 0.66 and from 0.40 to 0.60 for the IgM and IgG selected lines, respectively. Total antibody titers to SRBC differed significantly (P < 0.01) between the HIM and LIM lines at 7 and 14 d PPI, and 7 d PSI. The HIM line also produced significantly higher mercaptoethanol resistant antibody titers to SRBC than the LIM line at 7 and 14 d PPI and PSI. The LIG line had significantly higher total antibody titers to SRBC than the HIG line at both 7 and 14 d of PPI and PSI. From these results, it is suggested that selection of chickens on the basis of serum immunoglobulin isotypes may change antibody producing cells as well as other immunocompetent cells that modulate the immune response of the selected lines.

The genetics of mortality and survival of broiler chicks infected as embryos by subgroup A Rous sarcoma virus

A study using two high-performance broiler lines, a synthetic male line (SML) and a synthetic dam line (SDL), was undertaken to investigate the pattern of mortality due to induced liver tumours (LT) and the immune response to subgroup A virus inoculated via the chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) route. The distribution patterns of the four possible phenotypes were similar in both sire and dam lines. The occurrence of conversely associated phenotypes was about 30S, in both the lines. The percentages of CAM(+) LT(-) and CAM(-) LT(+) were 14.26%, and 14.46% in the dam line and 20.0% and 9.57% in the male line. The LT mortality was 30-50% in the birds with low pock counts, whereas it was 80-93% in the birds with high pock counts. The group specific antigen shedding status did not influence death due to LT. In birds in the high pock count group, 98% of deaths due to LT were completed by the sixth week, whereas in those in the low pock count group, death due to LT was spread over 24 weeks. The SDL birds survived better than SML birds in the high pock count groups. In both lines, about 20% of deaths occurred owing to non-specific causes. The average survival time after hatching before death from LT was 26 days, whereas that for non-specific death was 81 days.

Impact of genetics on disease resistance

The genetics of a bird or flock has a profound impact on its ability to resist disease, because genetics define the maximum achievable performance level. Careful attention should be paid to genetics as an important component of a comprehensive disease management program including high-level biosecurity, sanitation, and appropriate vaccination programs. Some specific genes (e.g., the MHC) are known to play a role in disease resistance, but resistance is generally a polygenic phenomenon. Future research directions will expand knowledge of the impact of genetics on disease resistance by identifying non-MHC genetic control of resistance and by further elucidating mechanisms regulating expression of genes related to immune response.

Effect of genetics, vaccine dosage, and postvaccination sampling interval on early antibody response to Salmonella enteritidis vaccine in broiler breeder chicks

Broiler breeder chicks of two different genetic lines were evaluated for early antibody response to Salmonella enteritidis (SE) vaccine. Antibody responses to three dosages of SE vaccine administered at 22 d of age were measured at 3, 6, and 10 d postvaccination. Within each line, antibody levels at 10 d postvaccination were significantly higher than at either 3 or 6 d postvaccination. At all vaccine dosages, there was a significant antibody-response difference between the genetic lines at 6 and 10 d postvaccination. The vaccine dosage significantly affected antibody levels in one of the two genetic lines. These results demonstrate a genetic component of early antibody response to SE vaccine in broiler breeder chicks.

Application of a nonlinear regression function to evaluate the kinetics of antibody response to vaccines in chicken lines divergently selected for multitrait immune response

To evaluate the kinetics of immune response to vaccines in chickens, antibody response curves were approximated to the observed antibody ratios by using a nonlinear regression function. New parameters, the curve maximum (ymax) and the time of the maximum (tmax), were calculated. The method was applied to analyze the kinetics of the serum antibody response to Mycoplasma gallisepticum (MG) and Pasteurella multocida (PM) vaccines in White Leghorn lines selected, in replicate, for 10 generations for high (High) and low (Low) multitrait immune response. Chicks were immunized at 6 wk of age with both vaccines. Serum antibody levels were analyzed before (0) and 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 12, and 21 wk postvaccination (wpv). The High lines displayed a significantly higher response than Low to both MG and PM. The difference in ymax between High and Low lines was 3.25-fold for PM response and 1.5-fold for MG response. Low lines had a significantly (P < 0.05) later tmax than High lines to MG, but not to PM. There was a significant (P < 0.05) positive correlation between the antibody responses to MG and PM, in High lines for the antibody ratios 0, 3, and 21 wpv and in Low lines for 0, 12, and 21 wpv. The ymax and tmax of antibody responses to the two vaccines were not correlated. The results on the kinetic differences of the antibody responses to MG and PM suggest that the kinetics and persistence of antibody reaction have different genetic regulation in response to each vaccine.

Dietary effects on immune response of fast-growing chicks to inoculation of sheep erythrocytes and Escherichia coli

Responses to SRBC and Escherichia coli inoculations were measured during the early posthatch period in broiler cockerels fed diets differing in nutrient density. Diet A consisted of 20% protein and 2,685 kcal ME/kg and Diet B consisted of 24% protein and 3,146 kcal ME/kg. There was no effect of diet on antibody response of chicks inoculated at 10 d of age with 0.25, 2.50, 5.00, or 25.00% suspensions of SRBC. A significantly larger proportion of chicks, however, produced antibody at the 25.00% than at the 0.25% dosage of SRBC. When inoculated at 15 d of age with 10(-6), 10(-4), or 10(-2) dosage of E. coli, there were no significant diet by dosage interactions for lesion scores, or relative change in BW 24, 48, and 120 h after inoculation. There were differences among E. coli dosages for severity of lesions and mortality, with rankings being 10(-2) > 10(-4) > 10(-6). Lesion scores and mortality were higher for the chicks fed Diet B than those fed Diet A. Also, deleterious effects of E. coli on BW 24, 48, and 120 h after inoculation were greater for chicks fed Diet B than for chicks fed Diet A. Responses to inoculations of SRBC and E. coli of broilers fed a diet with a lower nutrient density were equal or superior to those of broilers fed a diet with a higher nutrient density.

Effects of gonadal steroids and their antagonists on the humoral immune response of immune-selected broiler chicks

The effects of gonadal hormones, testosterone (Te) and estrogen (E2) as factors in the development of the immune system in two lines, high response (HC) and low response (LC), of broiler chickens divergently selected for early or late immune maturation were studied. For this purpose, plasma Te and E2 levels were tested and correlated with immune response. Also, the effects of exogenous administration of gonadal steroids testosterone propionate (TP), dihydrotestosterone (DHT), and estradiol 3-benzoate (EB), and the nonsteroidal androgen antagonist flutomide (Flu) and anti-estrogen tamoxifen (Tam) on the immune system were studied. Male chicks of the LC line had a higher level of endogenous Te during first 30 d posthatch. The administration of TP or DHT had no noticeable effect on the humoral immune response, whereas DHT suppressed growth of the bursa of Fabricius of both sexes of HC line. No differences in the endogenous E2 level were observed between sexes in either line. Administration of EB inhibited comb and testicle growth and enhanced significantly the humoral immune response to Escherichia coli and sheep erythrocytes (SRBC). The anti-androgen Flu and anti-estrogen Tam strongly inhibited humoral immune response to E. coli and SRBC antigen, whereas no effects on comb and testicle growth were observed. The experimental results suggest that gonadal hormones have similar principal posthatch effects in avian as in mammals; however, the gonadal steroids prehatch effects and the genetic-physiological-environmental effects require further study.

Genetic differences and heritability of antibody response to Escherichia coli vaccination in young broiler chicks

Broiler chicken lines, selected divergently for high (HC) or low (LC) antibody titer to Escherichia coli vaccination at an early age, were evaluated for antibody response at the S5 and S9 generations of selection. The full-pedigreed populations consisted of about 300 and 400 chicks per line in S5 and S9, respectively. At S5, all chicks were vaccinated at 10 d of age (VA10) and antibody titer was determined twice for each chick, at 8 and 12 d postvaccination (dPV). At S9, each line was divided into two equal groups; in the HC line, one group was vaccinated at 8 d of age (VA8), and the other at 10 d of age (VA10), whereas in the LC line, one group was VA10 and the other was VA12. Antibody titers were determined twice for each chick, 8 and 10 dPV. The effects of line, age at vaccination (VA), and days for antibody development (dPV) were tested, and the heritability of antibody titer was estimated for each line-VA-dPV set of data. The HC and LC lines differed significantly in the maturation process of their immune systems. The percentage of chicks with detectable antibody at 18 d of age (VA10-8 dPV) among HC chicks was significantly higher than among LC chicks (85 vs 48% in S5 and 96 vs 63% in S9). In S9, 90% of the HC chicks had already responded at 16 d of age and 100% at 18 d of age, whereas among the LC chicks, only 62% were positive at 18 d of age, increasing to no more than 98% at 22 d of age. The results demonstrates that selection of antibody titer to E. coli vaccination at 20 d of age actually affects the earliest age of immune response, as the immune system of the HC chicks matures earlier than that of the LC chicks. The HC S9 chicks at 8 dPV exhibited a fourfold higher antibody titer than their LC 8 counterparts. This difference further increased at 10 dPV, indicating that the lines differed not only in the level of antibody at a specific age, but also in their rate of antibody titer development. The highest estimate of heritability was very similar in both lines (0.44 and 0.42 in HC and LC, respectively). However, in the HC line this heritability was exhibited at 18 d of age, and only at 22 d in the LC line. Thus, both lines have a similar amount of genetic variation for early immune response, but in the HC line this variation is fully expressed 4 d earlier than in the LC line. These results suggest that selection for high or low antibody response in young chicks results in early or late antibody production, respectively. To maximize the efficiency of selection for early immune response, one must determine the best vaccination age and timing of antibody evaluation in any given population, and these values must be revalidated and updated as selection proceeds.

Growth, immunoresponsiveness, and disease resistance of diverse stocks of chickens reared under two nutritional regimens

Growth, immunocompetence, and disease resistance were measured in a commercial broiler stock (BC), a commercial white-egg-layer stock (LC), and a White Plymouth Rock line selected for high juvenile BW (HW) under dietary regimes differing in protein and energy content. Diet E had 20% more protein and 17% more ME than Diet A. Stock by sex interactions were significant for BW at 28 and 36 d of age because sexual dimorphism occurred at younger ages in the meat than in the layer stocks. When inoculated with .1 mL of a .25 or 2.50% suspension of SRBC, diet by stock interactions were significant for antibody titers 6 d postinoculation (PI) at the lower dosage. Interactions were not present at the higher dosage or for either dosage 13 d PI. Diet by stock interactions were significant at both dosages for change in SRBC titers from 6 to 13 d PI. The interactions resulted from a significantly smaller decline in BC than HW or LC chicks fed Diet A, whereas all stocks responded similarly when fed Diet E. A significant decline in rate of BW gain was observed in chicks inoculated with marble spleen disease virus (MSDV), with the increase in relative weight of spleen significantly greater for LC than HW or BC chicks 6 d PI. When heterophil to lymphocyte ratios were used as an assay of response to MSDV challenge, rations were significantly higher for HW chicks fed Diet A than for chicks fed Diet E and for LC chicks fed Diet E than for chicks fed Diet A, but not different for BC chicks on the two diets.

Sheep red blood cell and Brucella abortus antibody responses in chickens selected for multitrait immunocompetence

Chickens from replicated lines divergently selected for multitrait immunocompetence were tested for their antibody responses to sheep red blood cells and Brucella abortus antigen. All birds were injected with sheep red blood cells and B. abortus antigens at 4 and 9 wk of age, and blood samples were taken 6, 8, and 10 d postimmunization. Antibody titers were determined by using agglutination assays. For sheep red blood cell responses, the most marked difference was between the high and low lines postsecondary immunization. The high line titer was still rising at 10 d, whereas the low line had reached its peak at 8 d and was decreasing. This may be a result of the selection process in which the high line is selected for a high, persistent response to two T cell-dependent antigens at 3 wk postimmunization. For B. abortus responses, the only differences were between high and low lines postsecondary immunization. The high lines were always higher than the low lines, with differences getting smaller as time postimmunization increased. In summary, selection for multitrait immunocompetence resulted in changes in antibody response to unrelated antigens.

Response of three class-IV major histocompatibility complex haplotypes to Eimeria acervulina in meat-type chickens

1. The importance of MHC genes and background genes in controlling disease resistance, including resistance to avian coccidiosis, has not been clarified in meat-type chickens. 2. The role of class IV MHC genes in resistance to Eimeria acervulina was assessed in F2 progeny of a cross between 2 meat-type lines, selected divergently for immune response to Escherichia coli. 3. Disease susceptibility was assessed by lesion score, body weight, packed cell volume and carotene absorption. 4. Chickens with the "K" class IV MHC haplotype had lower lesion scores than chickens with "F" and "A" haplotypes. 5. Plasma carotene concentrations were higher in chickens with "K" haplotype and lower in chickens with "F" and "A" haplotypes whereas body weight and packed cell volume were less sensitive measures of Eimeria infection. 6. Eimeria acervulina resistance appears to be associated with MHC class IV genes; information about MHC haplotypes may be useful in selecting for increased resistance of meat-type chickens to coccidiosis.

Parental effect on the humoral immune response to Escherichia coli and Newcastle disease virus in young broiler chicks

Genetic and environmental variables influence animal resistance to disease infection. In addition, maternal effects were also found in studies with egg-type chicken lines. In our laboratory, meat-type chicken lines were divergently selected for either early or late maturation of the immune system, based on family and individual antibody responsiveness at 10 d of age. The high-antibody (HC) and low-antibody (LC) lines differed significantly in the early immune response to Escherichia coli, to Newcastle disease virus (NDV) vaccination, and to several other immune functions. Reciprocal crosses between the HC and LC lines were performed over 2 yr at three different locations. Immune responses to E. coli and NDV vaccination provided separate estimates of maternal and paternal effects. Dam effect on immune response to E. coli vaccine was significantly larger than sire effect; the antibody titer in both reciprocal crosses was intermediate between the parental lines, but the mean titer of the HC x LC cross was significantly lower than that of the LC x HC cross. Similar, but not significant, ranking of crosses was observed for the response to NDV. Evidently, the level of the offspring humoral immune response was more a dam than a sire effect.

Poultry immunogenetics: which way do we go?

A major goal in poultry immunogenetics is the enhancement of innate immunoresponsiveness and resistance to disease. This may be pursued by studying either single genes or polygenic traits. The MHC is perhaps the best-characterized family of host genes that modulates response to a variety of antigens and pathogenic challenges. The association of different MHC alleles with disease resistance has been known for decades. But only recently has analysis at the DNA level opened new avenues of understanding and new opportunities for application of genetic variation in the MHC with immunoresponsiveness. An alternate approach to molecular analysis is selection for a desired phenotype controlled by polygenes. Several studies have illustrated the successful alteration of immunoresponsiveness by genetic selection for antibody production. Recently, a selection program based upon multiple traits of immune response was conducted. Results of this project demonstrated that selection on multiple immune-response traits altered immunophysiology, MHC allelic frequencies, and disease resistance. Several areas for future pursuits in poultry immunogenetics research are proposed.

Direct and correlated responses to multitrait, divergent selection for immunocompetence

Leghorn lines had been selected for an immunocompetence index based on four traits: antibody production to Mycoplasma gallisepticum (MG) and Pasteurella multocida (PM) vaccines, reticuloendothelial clearance of colloidal carbon (CCA), and cell-mediated, wing web response to phytohemagglutinin (PHA). The purpose of this study was to produce replicated lines of chickens with divergent levels of multitrait immunocompetence by index selection. The objectives of analyses of Generations 5 to 7 of this study was to characterize these lines with respect to immune-response traits, correlations among these traits, and correlated responses in other important production traits. Differences (P < .05) existed between the lines selected for high or low immune response and between the two replicates in mean breeding values and in individual immune-response traits. Averages of heritability estimates, weighted by number of offspring and pooled across three generations (two cycles of selection), estimated by using sire variance components and parent-offspring correlations were, respectively, .16 and .09 for the index, .31 and .08 for MG, .21 and -.02 for PM, .06 and .05 for CCA, and .08 and .12 for PHA. Realized heritabilities (response divided by effective selection differential) pooled across the two selection cycles, were .19 and .11 for the index, .06 and -.01 for MG, .44 and .32 for PM, 1.52 and -1.21 for CCA, and .48 and .15 for PHA, for Replicates 1 and 2, respectively. Phenotypic correlations among traits were generally small, and several estimates were negative. Estimates of genetic correlation varied widely. Juvenile and adult body weights, age of first egg, 32-wk egg weight, and rate of egg production were analyzed to evaluate effects of selection on these traits of direct economic importance. Very few differences were noted.

Differences in major histocompatibility complex frequencies after multitrait, divergent selection for immunocompetence

White Leghorn chickens from lines selected for four immune-response traits (IR lines) were serotyped for B system alloantigens characterizing the haplotypes and genotypes to examine the effect of divergent selection for multitrait immunocompetence on MHC haplotype and genotype frequencies. The selected lines were derived from the Ottawa Strain 7. The selection index included four immunocompetence traits: antibody production against Mycoplasma gallisepticum (MG) and Pasteurella multocida, inflammatory response to phytohemagglutinin, and reticuloendothelial carbon clearance. The four lines include two replicates of high and low multitrait-immunocompetence lines. After four cycles of selection, significant differences (P < .05) in several B system haplotype frequencies were observed, both among IR lines and between the IR lines and the Ottawa Strain 7. The B2 haplotype frequency was greater in all IR lines than in the Ottawa Strain 7. The B21 frequency was less in both high lines than in the Ottawa Strain 7. In comparisons among lines, frequencies of B21 were greater in both replicates of the low lines and the B12 and B19 frequencies were significantly greater (P < .05) in the high lines. A gene substitution model showed effects (P < .10) of specific haplotypes on MG and on the index. The B2 haplotype had a positive effect associated with MG. Haplotype B21 was positively associated with the multitrait index. Haplotype B13 had a negative effect on both MG and the index. Significant differences (P < .01) in genotype frequencies were also noted among the IR lines. Associations between specific MHC haplotypes or genotypes and immune-response traits may offer insight into MHC-mediated mechanisms of disease resistance.

Designation by restriction fragment length polymorphism of major histocompatibility complex class IV haplotypes in meat-type chickens

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class IV haplotypes were identified in a population of meat-type chickens by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis. Fourteen different haplotypes were designated on the basis of restriction patterns obtained from Southern blots of PvuII- or BglII-digested DNA, hybridized with the MHC class IV cDNA probe bg32.1. Digestion with each restriction enzyme yielded the same level of polymorphism among individuals. For each haplotype, 4-10 restriction fragments ranging from 0.8 to 8 kb were observed. Such a designation of meat-type chicken MHC class IV haplotypes enables a rapid recognition of previously defined haplotypes, is readily adjustable to additional, newly found restriction patterns and could prove useful in practical breeding programmes.

Major histocompatibility complex class IV restriction fragment length polymorphism markers in replicated meat-type chicken lines divergently selected for high or low early immune response

Information on MHC may improve the efficiency of selection for immunological traits via the application of marker assisted selection or by selecting directly for a specific restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) band or MHC haplotype. An experimental procedure is presented here for identifying MHC genes that are related to early immune response. A Class IV cDNA clone was used to probe Southern blots of erythrocyte genomic DNA from chickens. Chickens were taken from the second (S2) and third (S3) generations of replicated lines divergently selected for high antibody response (HC1, HC2) or low antibody response (LC1, LC2) to Escherichia coli vaccination at 10 days of age. These selection criteria have been found to be associated with other immunological parameters. The hypothesis that these selected lines differ in their MHC loci was evaluated by comparing the frequencies of MHC RFLP markers (single RFLP bands) and haplotypes (patterns of RFLP bands). The significant differences between LC and HC in the frequency of many MHC RFLP bands and of five MHC haplotypes indicate that early antibody production is influenced by MHC genes. The reliability of the association between the selection and frequency differences was tested and proven in most cases by analysis of the replicated lines. These differences in RFLP markers represent a change in allelic frequencies in MHC genes, probably due to selection. The results imply a connection between the Class IV genes and early antibody production, and they show the potential of prospective breeding not only by immunological phenotype but also by genotype (i.e., using RFLP markers of the MHC).

Immunological parameters in meat-type chicken lines divergently selected by antibody response to Escherichia coli vaccination

Our group has established two lines of meat-type chickens divergently selected for early (HC line) and late (LC line) antibody responsiveness at 10 days of age to immunization with inactivated pathogenic Escherichia coli bacteria. The question addressed in the study presented here is whether this selection has changed other immunological responses, increasing the overall 'early' immunocompetence. Broilers of the third and fourth generations (S3 and S4) of the selected lines (HC and LC) and a control, unselected line (CT) were vaccinated at 10 days of age with E. coli vaccine, Newcastle virus vaccine (NDV), sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) or bovine serum albumin (BSA). Line-HC chicks exhibited higher antibody titers to E. coli, NDV and SRBC than CT or LC chicks. At 20 days of age HC chicks demonstrated a higher total protein and a higher beta- and gamma-globulin levels in their serum. At 21 days of age, HC chicks cleared carbon particles faster than LC chicks. Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from HC chicks vaccinated with E. coli vaccine, proliferated in vitro more actively in the presence of the stimulating antigen than the PBL of LC chicks. Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) obtained from HC-line chicks exhibited a higher proliferative response to concanavalin A (Con A)-, phytohemagglutinin (PHA)- or pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-stimulation than LC PBL. These results demonstrate that the selection for high or low antibody response to E. coli at a young age resulted also in a significant change in the response of other parameters of the immune system. The high response to E. coli was found to be associated with a high antibody response to other antigens (NDV and SRBC), increased phagocytic activity and increased proliferative response to antigen or mitogens. The selection most probably affected early immunocompetence.