The rate of the CD8-dependent initial reduction in tumor volume is not limited by contact-dependent perforin, Fas ligand, or TNF-mediated cytolysis

Immunotherapy-activated T cells recruit and skew late-stage activated M1-like macrophages that are critical for therapeutic efficacy

Total tumor clearance through immunotherapy is associated with a fully coordinated innate and adaptive immune response, but knowledge on the exact contribution of each immune cell subset is limited. We show that therapy-induced intratumoral CD8+ T cells recruited and skewed late-stage activated M1-like macrophages, which were critical for effective tumor control in two different murine models of cancer immunotherapy. The activated CD8+ T cells summon these macrophages into the tumor and their close vicinity via CCR5 signaling. Exposure of non-polarized macrophages to activated T cell supernatant and tumor lysate recapitulates the late-stage activated and tumoricidal phenotype in vitro. The transcriptomic signature of these macrophages is also detected in a similar macrophage population present in human tumors and coincides with clinical response to immune checkpoint inhibitors. The requirement of a functional co-operation between CD8+ T cells and effector macrophages for effective immunotherapy gives warning to combinations with broad macrophage-targeting strategies.

Dynamic CD8+ T Cell Cooperation with Macrophages and Monocytes for Successful Cancer Immunotherapy

Simple Summary

Innate and adaptive immunity mutually regulate one another in a dynamic fashion during immune responses. In infectious contexts, positive interactions between macrophages, monocytes and T cells are well recognized, but this is not the case in the field of cancer, where the growth of tumors disturbs the immune response. However, recent advances revealed that successful immunotherapy profoundly remodels the tumor microenvironment, promoting the activation of both T cells and myeloid cells. This review highlights the studies that hint at positive CD8⁺ T cell cooperation with monocytes and macrophages in this context, and discusses the potential mechanisms behind this.

Abstract

The essential roles endorsed by macrophages and monocytes are well established in response to infections, where they contribute to launching the differentiation of specific T-lymphocytes for long-term protection. This knowledge is the result of dynamic studies that can inspire the cancer field, particularly now that cancer immunotherapies elicit some tumor regression. Indeed, immune responses to cancer have mainly been studied after tumors have escaped immune attacks. In particular, the suppressive functions of macrophages were revealed in this context, introducing an obvious bias across the literature. In this review, we will focus on the ways inwhich monocytes and macrophages cooperate with T-lymphocytes, leading to successful immune responses. We will bring together the preclinical studies that have revealed the existence of such positive cooperation in the cancer field, and we will place particular emphasis on proposing the underlying mechanisms. Finally, we will give some perspectives to decipher the functional roles of such T-cell and myeloid cell interactions in the frame of human cancer immunotherapy.

Eomesodermin Increases Survival and IL-2 Responsiveness of Tumor-specific CD8+ T Cells in an Adoptive Transfer Model of Cancer Immunotherapy

Tumor-specific CD8 T cells often fail to elicit effective antitumor immune responses due to an inability to expand into a substantial effector population and persist long-term in vivo. Using an adoptive transfer model of cancer immunotherapy, we demonstrate that constitutive eomesodermin (Eomes) expression in tumor-specific CD8 T cells improves tumor rejection and survival. The increase in tumor rejection was associated with an increased number and persistence of CD8 T cells in lymphoid tissues during acute tumor rejection, tumor regrowth, and in mice that remained tumor-free. Constitutive Eomes expression increased expression of CD25, and this was associated with enhanced interleukin-2 responsiveness and tumor-specific CD8 T-cell proliferation. Moreover, constitutive Eomes expression improved cell survival. Taken together, our data suggest that constitutive Eomes expression enhances CD8 T-cell proliferation and survival, in part through the enhancement of interleukin-2 responsiveness through CD25 induction.

Contact-Dependent Killing by Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes Is Insufficient for EL4 Tumor Regression In Vivo

Immunotherapies are an emerging strategy for treatment of solid tumors. Improved understanding of the mechanisms employed by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) to control tumors will aid in the development of immunotherapies. CTLs can directly kill tumor cells in a contact-dependent manner or may exert indirect effects on tumor cells via secretion of cytokines. Here, we aim to quantify the importance of these mechanisms in murine thymoma EL4/EG7 cells. We developed an agent-based model (ABM) and an ordinary differential equation model of tumor regression after adoptive transfer of a population of CTLs. Models were parameterized based on in vivo measurements of CTL infiltration and killing rates applied to EL4/EG7 tumors and OTI T cells. We quantified whether infiltrating CTLs are capable of controlling tumors through only direct, contact-dependent killing. Both models agreed that the low measured killing rate of CTLs in vivo was insufficient to cause tumor regression. In our ABM, we also simulated CTL production of the cytokine IFNγ in order to explore how an antiproliferative effect of IFNγ might aid CTLs in tumor control. In this model, IFNγ substantially reduced tumor growth compared with direct killing alone. Collectively, these data demonstrate that contact-dependent killing is insufficient for EL4 regression in vivo and highlight the potential importance of cytokine-induced antiproliferative effects in T-cell-mediated tumor control. SIGNIFICANCE: Computational modeling highlights the importance of cytokine-induced antiproliferative effects in T-cell-mediated control of tumor progression.

Vaccine-induced tumor regression requires a dynamic cooperation between T cells and myeloid cells at the tumor site

Most cancer immunotherapies under present investigation are based on the belief that cytotoxic T cells are the most important anti-tumoral immune cells, whereas intra-tumoral macrophages would rather play a pro-tumoral role. We have challenged this antagonistic point of view and searched for collaborative contributions by tumor-infiltrating T cells and macrophages, reminiscent of those observed in anti-infectious responses. We demonstrate that, in a model of therapeutic vaccination, cooperation between myeloid cells and T cells is indeed required for tumor rejection. Vaccination elicited an early rise of CD11b⁺ myeloid cells that preceded and conditioned the intra-tumoral accumulation of CD8⁺ T cells. Conversely, CD8⁺ T cells and IFNγ production activated myeloid cells were required for tumor regression. A 4-fold reduction of CD8⁺ T cell infiltrate in CXCR3KO mice did not prevent tumor regression, whereas a reduction of tumor-infiltrating myeloid cells significantly interfered with vaccine efficiency. We show that macrophages from regressing tumors can kill tumor cells in two ways: phagocytosis and TNFα release. Altogether, our data suggest new strategies to improve the efficiency of cancer immunotherapies, by promoting intra-tumoral cooperation between macrophages and T cells.

Interleukin-12 enhances the function and anti-tumor activity in murine and human CD8(+) T cells

Mouse CD8(+) T cells conditioned with interleukin (IL)-12 ex vivo mediate the potent regression of established melanoma when transferred into lymphodepleted mice. However, the quantitative and qualitative changes induced by IL-12 in the responding mouse CD8(+) T cells have not been well defined. Moreover, the mechanisms by which IL-12-conditioning impacts human CD8(+) T cells, and how such cells might be expanded prior to infusion into patients is not known. We found that ex vivo IL-12-conditioning of mouse CD8(+) T cells led to a tenfold-100-fold increase in persistence and anti-tumor efficacy upon adoptive transfer into lymphodepleted mice. The enhancing effect of IL-12 was associated with maintenance of functional avidity. Importantly, in the context of ongoing ACT clinical trials, human CD8(+) T cells genetically modified with a tyrosinase-specific T cell receptor (TCR) exhibited significantly enhanced functional activity when conditioned with IL-12 as indicated by heightened granzyme B expression and elevated peptide-specific CD107a degranulation. This effect was sustainable despite the 20 days of in vitro cellular expansion required to expand cells over 1,000-fold allowing adequate cell numbers for administration to cancer patients. Overall, these findings support the efficacy and feasibility of ex vivo IL-12-conditioning of TCR-modified human CD8(+) T cells for adoptive transfer and cancer therapy.

Myeloid-derived suppressor cell impact on endogenous and adoptively transferred T cells

Novel models of autochthonous tumorigenesis and adoptive T cell therapy (ATT) are providing new clues regarding the pro-tumorigenic and immunosuppressive effects of myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSC), and their interaction with T cells. New findings are shifting the perception of the main level at which MDSC act, from direct cell-to-cell suppression to others, such as limiting T cell infiltration. Adoptively transferred, high-avidity T cells recognizing peptides with high-affinity for MHC-I eliminated large tumors. However, low-avidity T cells or low-affinity peptides resulted in failure to eradicate tumors. Manipulation of intratumoral myeloid cells improved the outcome of otherwise unsuccessful ATT. Therefore, therapeutic intervention directed at the tumor stroma might be required when using suboptimal T cells for ATT.

T-cell modulatory properties of CD5 and its role in antitumor immune responses

The destruction of tumor cells by the immune system is under the control of positive and negative receptors that tightly regulate T-cell effector functions. The T-cell receptor (TCR) inhibitory molecule CD5 critically contributes to the regulation of antitumor immune responses. Indeed, the modulation of CD5 within the tumor microenvironment corresponds to a strategy adopted by tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) to optimize their cytotoxic and cytokine secretion functions. In this review, we provide insights into the immunobiology of CD5 and its role in regulating antitumor CD8 T-cell responses, and suggest the possibility of targeting CD5 to improve the efficacy of current immunotherapeutic approaches against cancer.

Splenectomy promotes indirect elimination of intraocular tumors by CD8+ T cells that is associated with IFNγ- and Fas/FasL-dependent activation of intratumoral macrophages

Ocular immune privilege (IP) limits the immune surveillance of intraocular tumors as certain immunogenic tumor cell lines (P815, E.G7-OVA) that are rejected when transplanted in the skin grow progressively when placed in the anterior chamber of the eye. As splenectomy (SPLNX) is known to terminate ocular IP, we characterized the immune mechanisms responsible for rejection of intraocular tumors in SPLNX mice as a first step toward identifying how to restore tumoricidal activity within the eye. CD8(+) T cells, IFNγ, and FasL, but not perforin, or TNFα were required for the elimination of intraocular E.G7-OVA tumors that culminated in destruction of the eye (ocular phthisis). IFNγ and FasL did not target tumor cells directly as the majority of SPLNX IFNγR1(-/-) mice and Fas-defective lpr mice failed to eliminate intraocular E.G7-OVA tumors that expressed Fas and IFNγR1. Bone marrow chimeras revealed that IFNγR1 and Fas expression on immune cells was most critical for rejection, and SPLNX increased the frequency of activated macrophages (Mϕ) within intraocular tumors in an IFNγ- and Fas/FasL-dependent manner, suggesting an immune cell target of IFNγ and Fas. As depletion of Mϕs limited CD8 T cell-mediated rejection of intraocular tumors in SPLNX mice, our data support a model in which IFNγ- and Fas/FasL-dependent activation of intratumoral Mϕs by CD8(+) T cells promotes severe intraocular inflammation that indirectly eliminates intraocular tumors by inducing phthisis, and suggests that immunosuppressive mechanisms that maintain ocular IP interfere with the interaction between CD8(+) T cells and Mϕs to limit the immunosurveillance of intraocular tumors.

Cytokine-like molecule CCDC134 contributes to CD8⁺ T-cell effector functions in cancer immunotherapy

CCDC134 is a poorly characterized secreted protein that may act as an immune cytokine. Here, we show that CCDC134 is differentially expressed on resting and activated immune cells and that it promotes CD8(+) T-cell activation, proliferation, and cytotoxicity by augmenting expression of the T-cell effector molecules IFNγ, TNFα, granzyme B, and perforin. CCDC134 facilitated infiltration of CD8(+) T cells with enhanced cytolytic activity into tumors, demonstrating strong antitumor effects in a CD8(+) T-cell-dependent manner. Mechanistically, in CD8(+) T cells, exposure to CCDC134 promoted cell proliferation through the JAK3-STAT5 pathway, a classic feature of many cytokines of the common γ-chain (γ(c)) cytokine receptor family. Overall, our results provide evidence that CCDC134 may serve as a member of the γ(c) cytokine family and illustrate its potent antitumor effects by augmenting CD8(+) T-cell-mediated immunity.

DICE: A novel tumor surveillance mechanism-a new therapy for cancer?

The conventional view of CD95 (Fas/APO-1) is that it is a dedicated apoptosis-inducing receptor with important functions in immune cell homeostasis and in viral and tumor defense. There is an emerging recognition, however, that CD95 also has multiple non-apoptotic activities. In the context of cancer, CD95 was shown to have tumor-promoting activities, and the concept of this new function of CD95 in cancer is gaining traction. Recently, we showed that not only is CD95 a growth promoter for cancer cells, but, paradoxically, when either CD95 or CD95 ligand (CD95L) is removed, that virtually all cancer cells die through a process we have named DICE (death induced by CD95R/L elimination). In this perspective, I outline a hypothesis regarding the physiological function of DICE, and why it may be possible to use induction of DICE to treat many, if not most, cancers.

Nanoparticle conjugation of CpG enhances adjuvancy for cellular immunity and memory recall at low dose

In subunit vaccines, strong CD8(+) T-cell responses are desired, yet they are elusive at reasonable adjuvant doses. We show that targeting adjuvant to the lymph node (LN) via ultrasmall polymeric nanoparticles (NPs), which rapidly drain to the LN after intradermal injection, greatly enhances adjuvant efficacy at low doses. Coupling CpG-B or CpG-C oligonucleotides to NPs led to better dual-targeting of adjuvant and antigen (codelivered on separate NPs) in cross-presenting dendritic cells compared with free adjuvant. This led to enhanced dendritic cell maturation and T helper 1 (Th1)-cytokine secretion, in turn driving stronger effector CD8(+) T-cell activation with enhanced cytolytic profiles and, importantly, more powerful memory recall. With only 4 μg CpG, NP-CpG-B could substantially protect mice from syngeneic tumor challenge, even after 4 mo of vaccination, compared with free CpG-B. Together, these results show that nanocarriers can enhance vaccine efficacy at a low adjuvant dose for inducing potent and long-lived cellular immunity.

Influence of CD8+ T regulatory cells on intraocular tumor development

The interior of the eye, or uvea, is a site of immune privilege where certain immune responses are attenuated or completely excluded to protect non-regenerating tissues essential for vision. One consequence of this immunoregulation is compromised immune mediated elimination of intraocular tumors. For example, certain murine tumor cell lines which are rejected by host immune responses when transplanted in the skin grow progressively when placed in the anterior chamber (a.c.) of the eye. Progressive ocular tumor growth occurs despite induction of tumor-specific CD8+ T cell responses capable of eliminating a subsequent tumor challenge in the skin or opposite eye. Why these CD8+ T effectors fail to eliminate established ocular tumors is not known. It is well appreciated that growth of tumors in the a.c. induces the generation of immunosuppressive CD8+ T regulatory (Treg) cells. However, the contribution of CD8+ Treg in ocular tumor progression remains unclear. Several studies indicate that these CD8+ Treg target responding CD4+ T cells to inhibit their induction of macrophage-dependent delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses to tumor antigens (Ags). However, induction of tumor-specific CD4+ T cell responses does not assure intraocular tumor elimination. This review is focused on how CD8+ Treg could influence the tumoricidal activity of ocular tumor-specific CD8+ T effector cells.

CTL induction of tumoricidal nitric oxide production by intratumoral macrophages is critical for tumor elimination

To characterize mechanisms of CTL inhibition within an ocular tumor microenvironment, tumor-specific CTLs were transferred into mice with tumors developing within the anterior chamber of the eye or skin. Ocular tumors were resistant to CTL transfer therapy whereas skin tumors were sensitive. CTLs infiltrated ocular tumors at higher CTL/tumor ratios than in skin tumors and demonstrated comparable ex vivo effector function to CTLs within skin tumors indicating that ocular tumor progression was not due to decreased CTL accumulation or inhibited CTL function within the eye. CD11b(+)Gr-1(+)F4/80(-) cells predominated within ocular tumors, whereas skin tumors were primarily infiltrated by CD11b(+)Gr-1(-)F4/80(+) macrophages (Ms), suggesting that myeloid derived suppressor cells may contribute to ocular tumor growth. However, CD11b(+) myeloid cells isolated from either tumor site suppressed CTL activity in vitro via NO production. Paradoxically, the regression of skin tumors by CTL transfer therapy required NO production by intratumoral Ms indicating that NO-producing intratumoral myeloid cells did not suppress the effector phase of CTL. Upon CTL transfer, tumoricidal concentrations of NO were only produced by skin tumor-associated Ms though ocular tumor-associated Ms demonstrated comparable expression of inducible NO synthase protein suggesting that NO synthase enzymatic activity was compromised within the eye. Correspondingly, in vitro-activated Ms limited tumor growth when co-injected with tumor cells in the skin but not in the eye. In conclusion, the decreased capacity of Ms to produce NO within the ocular microenvironment limits CTL tumoricidal activity allowing ocular tumors to progress.

A caveat for T cell transfer studies: generation of cytotoxic anti-Thy1.2 antibodies in Thy1.1 congenic mice given Thy1.2+ tumors or T cells

Thy1.1 congenic B6.PL mice were used to simultaneously monitor Thy1.2+ E.G7-OVA tumors transplanted in the a.c. of the eye and i.v.-transferred tumor-specific Thy1.2+ CTLs to determine mechanisms that inhibit the tumoricidal activity of CTL responses in mice with established ocular tumors. Transferred CTLs were systemically deleted in mice with established ocular tumors. However, this deletion was not a unique mechanism of immune evasion by ocular tumors. Rather, development of Thy1.2+ tumors in the eye or skin of B6.PL mice generated cytotoxic anti-Thy1.2 antibodies that eliminated a subsequent Thy1.2+ T cell transfer. Anti-Thy1.2 immune responses in B6.PL mice were influenced by the route of antigen administration, as the serum concentration of cytotoxic anti-Thy1.2 antibodies was 92-fold greater in mice with eye tumors in comparison with mice with skin tumors. In addition, anti-Thy1.2 immune responses were detected in B6.PL mice given naïve Thy1.2+ T cells i.p. but not i.v. Anti-Thy1.2 responses were augmented in B6.PL mice with ocular Thy1.2+ EL-4 tumors that did not express OVA, suggesting immunodominance of OVA antigen over Thy1.2. Thy1.1+ T cells given i.p. was not immunogenic in Thy1.2 congenic mice. These data reaffirm that the introduction of antigens in the a.c. induces robust antibody responses. Experimentation using allotypic differences in Thy1 between donor cells and recipient mice must consider cytotoxic anti-Thy1 antibody generation in the interpretation of results.

Influence of immune privilege on ocular tumor development

Mechanisms that maintain ocular immune privilege may contribute to ocular tumor progression by inhibiting tumoricidal immune responses. Consistent with that notion are observations from transplantable tumor models in mice demonstrating that the tumoricidal activity of CD8(+) cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) may be inhibited directly by interfering with CTL effector function in the eye or indirectly by abrogating the effector function of CD8+ T cell-activated intratumoral macrophages that are critical for ocular tumor rejection. In addition, epigenetic gene regulation by factors within the ocular tumor environment favors the generation of tumor variants that are resistant to CD8(+) CTL. Intratumoral macrophages may be essential for eliminating these variants because, unlike CTL, their tumoricidal activity is nonspecific. Hence, the inhibition of macrophage effector function within the eye, presumably to preserve immune privilege by minimizing ocular immunopathology, may hasten the outgrowth of tumor escape variants which contributes to ocular tumor progression.

Tumor rejection by local interferon gamma induction in established tumors is associated with blood vessel destruction and necrosis

It has been shown that injecting a suspension of IFN-γ-secreting tumor cells results in their rejection. This effect has been attributed to IFN-γ preventing tumor stroma formation but not to a direct effect on the cancer cells. However, it is not known, which influence IFN-γ has on tumors with an established stroma. To address this question, the plasmacytoma cell line J558L was transduced with a vector allowing doxycycline-inducible IFN-γ gene expression. After the injection of the tumor cells into mice, IFN-γ was induced at different time points. Tumors did not grow when inducing IFN-γ immediately after tumor cell inoculation, while approximately half of the tumors were rejected when IFN-γ was induced in early established tumors within 2 weeks. Induction of IFN-γ 2-3 weeks after tumor cell inoculation was less efficient (0-17% rejection). IFN-γ induction in established tumors led to a reduction of CD146(+) endothelial cells and massive necrosis. Together, we show that vascularized tumors can be rejected by local IFN-γ expression, but that rejection of established tumors was less efficient over time. This suggests that transplanted tumors became less susceptible to local IFN-γ treatment the better they are established.

Adoptive transfer of tumor-specific Tc17 effector T cells controls the growth of B16 melanoma in mice

In vitro generated OVA-specific IL-17-producing CD8 T effector cells (Tc17) from OT-1 mice, adoptively transferred into B16-OVA tumor-bearing mice, controlled tumor growth in early and late stage melanoma. IL-17, TNF, and IFN-gamma from the Tc17 effectors all played a role in an enhanced recruitment of T cells, neutrophils, and macrophages to the tumor. In addition, Tc17 cells and recently recruited, activated neutrophils produced further chemokines, including CCL3, CCL4, CCL5, CXCL9, and CXCL10, responsible for the attraction of type 1 lymphocytes (Th1 and Tc1) and additional neutrophils. Neutrophils were rapidly attracted to the tumor site by an IL-17 dependent mechanism, but at later stages the induction of the chemokine CXCL2 by Tc17-derived TNF and IFN-gamma contributed to sustain neutrophil recruitment. Approximately 10-50 times as many Tc17 effectors were required compared with Tc1 effectors to exert the same level of control over tumor growth. The recruitment of neutrophils was more prominent when Tc17 rather than Tc1 were used to control tumor and depletion of neutrophils resulted in a diminished capacity to control tumor growth.

Multiphoton imaging of cytotoxic T lymphocyte-mediated antitumor immune responses

The actual contribution of T lymphocytes to protection against tumors is still unclear. In vitro imaging experiments show that tumor specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are competent to kill target cells by conventional cytotoxic pathways. The emergence of multiphoton imaging in the past decade now allows real time in vivo imaging of CTLs. New insights are available on the behavior of antitumor T cells during the priming phase, during their traffic within the tumor tissue, and on their interactions with tumor cells during the effector phase. Recent reports suggest that direct killing of tumor cells by CTLs is a slow process, suggesting that the ratio of effector to target cells is determinant, or that additional cytotoxic contribution by other cell types is required to induce efficient tumor rejection. This review will focus on the publications that have imaged antitumor immune responses dynamically and discuss how this new information contributes to understand the implication of CTLs in tumor rejection.

Two-photon imaging of intratumoral CD8+ T cell cytotoxic activity during adoptive T cell therapy in mice

CTLs have the potential to attack tumors, and adoptive transfer of CTLs can lead to tumor regression in mouse models and human clinical settings. However, the dynamics of tumor cell elimination during efficient T cell therapy is unknown, and it is unclear whether CTLs act directly by destroying tumor cells or indirectly by initiating the recruitment of innate immune cells that mediate tumor damage. To address these questions, we report real-time imaging of tumor cell apoptosis in vivo using intravital 2-photon microscopy and a Förster resonance energy transfer-based (FRET-based) reporter of caspase 3 activity. In a mouse model of solid tumor, we found that tumor regression after transfer of in vitro-activated CTLs occurred primarily through the direct action of CTLs on each individual tumor cell, with a minimal bystander effect. Surprisingly, the killing of 1 target cell by an individual CTL took an extended period of time, 6 hours on average, which suggested that the slow rate of killing intrinsically limits the efficiency of antitumor T cell responses. The ability to visualize when, where, and how tumor cells are killed in vivo offers new perspectives for understanding how immune effectors survey cancer cells and how local tumor microenvironments may subvert immune responses.

IFN-gamma- and TNF-dependent bystander eradication of antigen-loss variants in established mouse cancers

Tumors elicit antitumor immune responses, but over time they evolve and can escape immune control through various mechanisms, including the loss of the antigen to which the response is directed. The escape of antigen-loss variants (ALVs) is a major obstacle to T cell-based immunotherapy for cancer. However, cancers can be cured if both the number of CTLs and the expression of antigen are high enough to allow targeting of not only tumor cells, but also the tumor stroma. Here, we showed that IFN-gamma and TNF produced by CTLs were crucial for the elimination of established mouse tumors, including ALVs. In addition, both BM- and non-BM-derived stromal cells were required to express TNF receptors and IFN-gamma receptors for the elimination of ALVs. Although IFN-gamma and TNF were not required by CTLs for perforin-mediated killing of antigen-expressing tumor cells, the strong inference is that tumor antigen-specific CTLs must secrete IFN-gamma and TNF for destruction of tumor stroma. Therefore, bystander killing of ALVs may result from IFN-gamma and TNF acting on tumor stroma.

Augmentation of anti-tumor responses of adoptively transferred CD8+T cells in the lymphopenic setting by HSV amplicon transduction

Treatment of cancer with cytotoxic agents may induce lymphopenia. Adoptively transferred T cells have been reported to display enhanced anti-tumor efficacy in the lymphopenic setting. We reasoned that the anti-tumor effects of adoptively transferred cells in the lymphopenic host could be further augmented through local provision of an innate stimulus in the tumor bed. Utilizing a model in which mice were irradiated to induce lymphopenia, with limited shielding to allow tumor growth, we demonstrate that "triple" therapy consisting of radiation-induced lymphopenia, adoptive transfer of naïve CD8+ T cells, and intra-tumoral HSV amplicon injection resulted in reduced tumor growth compared to the combination of any two of the aforementioned interventions. To gain insight into the mechanism underlying this effect we studied the effects of HSV amplicon transduction into tumors on cytokine expression and on anti-tumor specific T cells. HSV amplicon transduction specifically induced several cytokine mRNAs including IFN-gamma, and IP-10. Adoptively transferred transgenic OT-1 T cells directed against Ovalbumin were more effective against Ovalbumin-expressing tumors when combined with intra-tumoral HSV amplicon injections in the lymphopenic host. Following intra-tumoral HSV-amplicon injections, anti-tumor T cells secreted higher levels of interferon-gamma in response to in-vitro re-stimulation with tumor cells, implying that HSV amplicon injection provided a strong signal for T cell activation. Combining adoptive transfer of naïve T cells in the lymphopenic setting with local T cell stimulation may facilitate expansion and activation of anti-tumor T cell populations in vivo, resulting in enhanced anti-tumor responses without the need to resort to prolonged in vitro T cell culture and/or manipulation.

Rapid maturation of effector T cells in tumors, but not lymphoid organs, during tumor regression

Increasing the efficacy of adoptively transferred, tumor antigen specific T cells is a major goal of immunotherapy. Clearly, a more thorough understanding of the effector phase of T cell responses, within the tumor site itself, would be beneficial. To examine this issue, we adoptively transferred tumor antigen-specific effector T cells into tumor-bearing mice, then performed kinetic evaluations of their phenotype, function, and survival in tumors, draining lymph nodes (dLNs), and spleens during regression of murine fibrosarcomas. Effector function in tumors was quantitated through the use of a novel intratumoral cytolytic assay. This approach revealed dynamic changes in the phenotype, cytolytic capacity, and viability of tumor infiltrating effector T cells during the course of tumor regression. Over a period of days, T cells within tumors rapidly transitioned from a CD25(hi)/CD27(hi) to a CD25(low)/CD27(low) phenotype and displayed an increase in cytolytic capacity, indicative of effector maturation. Simultaneously, however, the viability of maturing T cells within tumors diminished. In contrast, transferred T cells trafficking through lymphoid organs were much more static, as they maintained a stable phenotype, robust cytolytic activity, and high viability. Therefore, there exists a marked phenotypic and functional divergence between tumor-infiltrating effector T cells and their counterparts in lymphoid organs. Our results indicate that the population of tumor-infiltrating T cells is unique in experiencing rapid effector maturation post-transfer, and suggest that strategies aimed at prolonging the survival of CD25(low)/CD27(low) full effectors, which displayed the highest levels of intratumoral cytolytic activity, should enhance the efficacy of T cell based tumor immunotherapies.

Signal 3 availability limits the CD8 T cell response to a solid tumor

CD8 T cells need a third signal, along with Ag and costimulation, for effective survival and development of effector functions, and this can be provided by IL-12 or type I IFN. Adoptively transferred OT-I T cells, specific for H-2K(b) and OVA, encounter Ag in the draining lymph nodes of mice with the OVA-expressing E.G7 tumor growing at a s.c. site. The OT-I cells respond by undergoing limited clonal expansion and development of effector functions (granzyme B expression and IFN-gamma production), and they migrate to the tumor where they persist but fail to control tumor growth. In contrast, OT-I T cells deficient for both the IL-12 and type I IFN receptors expand only transiently and rapidly disappear. These results suggested that some signal 3 cytokine is available, but that it is insufficient to support a CTL response that can control tumor growth. Consistent with this, administration of IL-12 at day 10 of tumor growth resulted in a large and sustained expansion of wild-type OT-I cells with enhanced effector functions, and tumor growth was controlled. This did not occur when the OT-I cells lacked the IL-12 and type I IFN receptors, demonstrating that the therapeutic effect of IL-12 results from direct delivery of signal 3 to the CD8 T cells responding to tumor Ag in the signal 3-deficient environment of the tumor.

In vivo imaging of cytotoxic T cell infiltration and elimination of a solid tumor

Although the immune system evolved to fight infections, it may also attack and destroy solid tumors. In most cases, tumor rejection is initiated by CD8⁺ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs), which infiltrate solid tumors, recognize tumor antigens, and kill tumor cells. We use a combination of two-photon intravital microscopy and immunofluorescence on ordered sequential sections to analyze the infiltration and destruction of solid tumors by CTLs. We show that in the periphery of a thymoma growing subcutaneously, activated CTLs migrate with high instantaneous velocities. The CTLs arrest in close contact to tumor cells expressing their cognate antigen. In regions where most tumor cells are dead, CTLs resume migration, sometimes following collagen fibers or blood vessels. CTLs migrating along blood vessels preferentially adopt an elongated morphology. CTLs also infiltrate tumors in depth, but only when the tumor cells express the cognate CTL antigen. In tumors that do not express the cognate antigen, CTL infiltration is restricted to peripheral regions, and lymphocytes neither stop moving nor kill tumor cells. Antigen expression by tumor cells therefore determines both CTL motility within the tumor and profound tumor infiltration.

Protection against polyoma virus-induced tumors is perforin-independent

CD8 T cells are necessary for controlling tumors induced by mouse polyoma virus (PyV), but the effector mechanism(s) responsible have not been determined. We examined the PyV tumorigenicity in C57BL/6 mice mutated in Fas or carrying targeted disruptions in the perforin gene or in both TNF receptor type I and type II genes. Surprisingly, none of these mice developed tumors. Perforin/Fas double-deficient radiation bone marrow chimeric mice were also resistant to PyV-induced tumors. Anti-PyV CD8 T cells in perforin-deficient mice were found not to differ from wild type mice with respect to phenotype, capacity to produce cytokines or maintenance of memory T cells, indicating that perforin does not modulate the PyV-specific CD8 T cell response. In addition, virus was cleared and persisted to similar extents in wild type and perforin-deficient mice. In summary, perforin/granzyme exocytosis is not an essential effector pathway for protection against PyV infection or tumorigenesis.

IFN-γ Regulates Donor CD8 T Cell Expansion, Migration, and Leads to Apoptosis of Cells of a Solid Tumor

We previously reported that IFN-gamma secreted by donor cytotoxic T cell 1 (Tc1) cells was the most important factor in promoting EG7 (an OVA transfection the EL4 thymoma) rejection in mice. In this study, we show that the ability of the host to respond to Tc1-secreted IFN-gamma is critical for promoting acute tumor rejection, while host production of IFN-gamma is not important. CFSE-labeled wild-type and IFN-gamma-deficient Tc1 cells divide rapidly in secondary lymphoid organs, indicating no defect in rate of cell division. However, wild-type Tc1 cells accumulate to significantly greater numbers in the tumor than deficient Tc1 cells. Hosts injected with wild-type Tc1 effectors had more T cells within the tumor at day 4, had higher levels of MCP-1, IFN-gamma-inducible protein-10, MIP-1alpha, and MIP-1beta mRNA transcripts, had greater numbers of CD11b+ and Gr-1+ cells within the tumor, and had massive regions of tumor cell apoptosis as compared with IFN-gamma knockout Tc1 cell-treated hosts. NO has a cytostatic effect on EG7 growth in vitro, and NO is important for tumor eradication by day 22. These observations are compatible with a model in which the donor CD8 Tc1 effectors expand rapidly in the host, migrate to the tumor site, and induce the secretion of a number of chemokines that in turn recruit host cells that then attack the tumor.

Perforin and Fas induced by IFNgamma and TNFalpha mediate beta cell death by OT-I CTL

Direct interaction between auto-reactive CTL and specific peptide-MHC class I complexes on pancreatic beta cells is critical in mediating beta cell destruction in type I diabetes. We used mice with genetic modifications in three major pathways used by CTL, perforin, Fas and pro-inflammatory cytokines to assess the relative contribution of these mechanisms to beta cell death. In vitro-activated ovalbumin (OVA)-specific CTL, from OT-I TCR-transgenic mice, specifically killed transgenic beta cells expressing OVA (from RIP-mOVA mice) in a 16-h cytotoxicity assay. Perforin-deficient CTL had a reduced ability to kill OVA-expressing islets in vitro (22.1 +/- 3.8%) compared with wild-type CTL (71.4 +/- 4.6%). Fas-deficient islets were only slightly protected from wild-type CTL but were completely protected from the residual killing observed with perforin-deficient CTL. Residual cytotoxicity in perforin-deficient CTL was also prevented by overexpression of SOCS-1, which blocks multiple cytokine signaling pathways. It was also prevented by pre-incubation with anti-tumor necrosis factor-alpha (anti-TNFalpha) antibody or by blocking IFNgamma responsiveness through expressing a dominant negative IFNgamma receptor. Perforin-deficient CTL produced IFNgamma and TNFalpha that was shown to directly induce islet Fas expression during the assays. This suggests that Fas-deficiency, SOCS-1 overexpression and blockade of IFNgamma and TNFalpha all protect beta cells from residual cytotoxicity of perforin-deficient CTL by blocking Fas upregulation. These findings indicate that wild-type CTL destroy antigen-expressing islets via a perforin-dependent mechanism. However, in the absence of perforin, the Fas/FasL pathway provides an alternative mechanism dependent on islet cell Fas upregulation by cytokines IFNgamma and TNFalpha.

Solid tumors “melt” from the inside after successful CD8 T cell attack

Adoptive transfer of tumor-specific T cells represents a promising approach for cancer immunotherapy. Here, we visualized the anti-tumor response of CD8 T cells from P14 TCR-transgenic mice specific for the model antigen GP33 by immunohistology. P14 T cells, adoptively transferred into tumor-bearing hosts, induced regression of established 3LL-A9(GP33) and MCA102(GP33) tumors that express GP33 as a tumor-associated model antigen. Strikingly, the visible effects of P14 T cell attack, such as the destruction of the tumor vasculature and accumulation of granulocytes, were predominantly detected inside the tumor mass. In regressing tumors, P14 T cells were found in the intact rim zone but not in central areas that were infiltrated with granulocytes and lacked CD31(+) endothelial cells. The rim of P14 T cell-treated tumors showed an increase in vascular density and decrease in hypoxia compared to untreated tumors. Hypoxic areas of tumors are known to exhibit decreased sensitivity to radiation therapy or chemotherapy. Thus, our data also imply that adoptive transfer of tumor-specific CD8 T cells might synergize with radiation therapy or chemotherapy in the elimination of solid tumors in vivo.

OX40 and Bcl-xL promote the persistence of CD8 T cells to recall tumor-associated antigen

The molecular signals that allow primed CD8 T cells to persist and be effective are particularly important during cancer growth. With response to tumor-expressed Ag following adoptive T cell transfer, we show that CD8 effector cells deficient in OX40, a TNFR family member, could not mediate short-term tumor suppression. OX40 was required at two critical stages. The first was during CD8 priming in vitro, in which APC-transmitted OX40 signals endowed the ability to survive when adoptively transferred in vivo before tumor Ag encounter. The second was during the in vivo recall response of primed CD8 T cells, the stage in which OX40 contributed to the further survival and accumulation of T cells at the tumor site. The lack of OX40 costimulation was associated with reduced levels of Bcl-x(L), and retroviral expression of Bcl-x(L) in tumor-reactive CD8 T cells conferred greatly enhanced tumor protection following adoptive transfer. These data demonstrate that OX40 and Bcl-x(L) can control survival of primed CD8 T cells and provide new insights into both regulation of CD8 immunity and control of tumors.

The role of tumor stroma in the interaction between tumor and immune system

It is often assumed that tumor rejection is mainly the result of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) killing the tumor cells. However, recent studies have demonstrated that the rejection process is not as simple as this. In some models, tumors are rejected in the absence of lytic mechanisms (e.g. perforin or Fas ligand), and in others CTLs kill tumor stromal cells that cross-present antigen. T cells with lytic function but IFN-gamma deficiency rarely reject tumors. IFN-gamma and, in some models, other T-cell cytokines such as TNF-alpha, IL-4 or IL-10 contribute to tumor rejection by inhibition of tumor stroma formation. These cytokines inhibit tumor-induced angiogenesis, probably through different cellular targets.

Immunotherapy: target the stroma to hit the tumor

For decades it has been assumed that T cells reject tumors essentially by direct killing. However, solid tumors are composed of malignant cells and a variety of different nonmalignant cells, referred to as tumor stroma. Stromal cells, such as endothelial cells, fibroblasts and inflammatory cells, often support tumor growth. Here, we discuss new findings showing that the tumor stroma is an important target during T-cell-mediated tumor rejection. Cytotoxic molecules and cytokines produced by T cells inhibit or destroy the stromal 'infrastructure', thereby withdrawing essential resources and leading to tumor infarction and subsequent T-cell-mediated elimination of residual tumor cells. These findings are important for the development of more effective and specific immunotherapies for cancer.

Gender dimorphism in the progressive in vivo growth of a T cell lymphoma: involvement of cytokines and gonadal hormones

The present investigation was carried out to investigate gender dimorphism with respect to the progressive in vivo growth a of T cell lymphoma in a murine system. It was observed that in vivo progression of a transplantable T cell lymphoma of spontaneous origin, designated as Dalton's lymphoma (DL), shows differential growth kinetics in male and female mice. DL growth was observed to be faster in female mice as compared to male mice. We demonstrate the involvement of gender specific gonadal hormones, tumor-associated macrophage (TAM)-derived IL-1 and differential level of IL-4, IL-10 and TNF-alpha in the ascitic fluid of DL-bearing male and female mice. The study has a clinical significance, as the results will help in understanding the mechanism of gender dimorphism with respect to the progression of T cell tumors and in the designing of immunotherapy for such tumors.