Single molecule studies of multiple-fluorophore labeled antibodies. Effect of homo-FRET on the number of photons available before photobleaching

Advancements in single molecule detection (SMD) continue to unfold powerful ways to study the behavior of individual and complex molecular systems in real time. SMD enables the characterization of complex molecular interactions and reveals basic physical phenomena underlying chemical and biological processes. We present here a systematic study of the quenching efficiency of Förster-type energy-transfer (FRET) for multiple fluorophores immobilized on a single antibody. We simultaneously monitor the fluorescence intensity, fluorescence lifetime, and the number of available photons before photobleaching as a function of the number of identical emitters bound to a single IgG antibody. The detailed studies of FRET between individual fluorophores reveal complex through-space interactions. In general, even for two or three fluorophores immobilized on a single protein, homo-FRET interactions lead to an overall non-linear intensity increase and shortening of fluorescence lifetime. Over-labeling of protein in solution (ensemble) results in the loss of fluorescence signal due to the self-quenching of fluorophores making it useless for assays applications. However, in the single molecule regime, over-labeling may bring significant benefits in regards to the number of available photons and the overall survival time. Our investigation reveals possibilities to significantly increase the observation time for a single macromolecule allowing studies of macromolecular interactions that are not obscured by ensemble averaging. Extending the observation time will be crucial for developing immunoassays based on single-antibody.

Fluorescence polarization standard for near infrared spectroscopy and microscopy

We present studies of polarized absorption [linear dichroism (LD)] and fluorescence polarization of the styryl derivative (LDS 798) embedded in oriented poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) films. These films were oriented by progressive stretching up to eight folds. Both vertical and horizontal components of absorptions and fluorescence were measured and dichroic ratios were determined for different film stretching ratios. The dichroic ratio and fluorescence anisotropy values were analyzed as a function of PVA film stretching ratio by fitting according to the previously developed theory. For maximum stretching ratios, exceptionally high anisotropy (approximately 0.8) and polarization (approximately 0.9) values have been measured. The stretched films have high polarization values also for isotropic excitation in a wide spectral range (500-700 nm). Such films can be conveniently used as high polarization standards and we envision they will also have applications in near infrared (NIR) imaging microscopy, where they can be used for correcting an instrumental factor in polarization measurements.

Anisotropy decays of indole, melittin monomer and melittin tetramer by frequency-domain fluorometry and multi-wavelength global analysis

We used frequency-domain fluorescence spectroscopy to measure the fluorescence lifetime and anisotropy decays of indole in propylene glycol, and of the tryptophan emission of melittin monomer and tetramer in water solutions at 5 degrees C. We obtained an increase in resolution of the anisotropy decays by using multiple excitation wavelengths, chosen to provide a range of fundamental anisotropy values. The multi-excitation wavelength anisotropy decays were analyzed globally to recover a single set of correlation times with wavelength-dependent anisotropy amplitudes. Simulated data and kappaR2 surfaces are shown to reveal the effect of multi-wavelength data on the resolution of complex anisotropy decays. For both indole and melittin, the anisotropy decays are heterogeneous and require two correlation times to fit the frequency-domain data. For indole in propylene glycol at 5 degrees C we recovered correlation times of 0.59 and 4.10 ns, which appear to be characteristic of the rigid and asymmetric indole molecule. For melittin monomer the correlation times were 0.13 and 1.75 ns, and for melittin tetramer 0.12 and 3.96 ns. The shorter and longer correlation times of melittin are due to segmental motions and overall rotational diffusion of the polypeptide.

Distribution of distances between the tryptophan and the N-terminal residue of melittin in its complex with calmodulin, troponin C, and phospholipids

We used frequency-domain measurements of fluorescence resonance energy transfer to measure the distribution of distances between Trp-19 of melittin and a 1-dimethylamino-5-sulfonylnaphthalene (dansyl) residue on the N-terminal-alpha-amino group. Distance distributions were obtained for melittin free in solution and when complexed with calmodulin (CaM), troponin C (TnC), or palmitoyloleoyl-L-alpha-phosphatidylcholine (POPC) vesicles. A wide range of donor (Trp-19)-to-acceptor (dansyl) distances was found for free melittin, which is consistent with that expected for the random coil state, characterized by a Gaussian width (full width at half maxima) of 28.2 A. In contrast, narrow distance distributions were found for melittin complexed with CaM, 8.2 A, or with POPC vesicles, 4.9 A. A somewhat wider distribution was found for the melittin complex with TnC, 12.8 A, suggesting the presence of heterogeneity in the mode of binding between melittin and TnC. For all the complexes the mean Trp-19 to dansyl distance was near 20 A. This value is somewhat smaller than expected for the free alpha-helical state of melittin, suggesting that binding with CaM or TnC results in a modest decrease in the length of the melittin molecule.

Intensity and anisotropy decays of [Leu5] enkephalin tyrosyl fluorescence by 10 GHz frequency-domain fluorometry

The technique of 10 GHz frequency-domain fluorometry was used to resolve the complex picosecond intensity and anisotropy decays of the tyrosyl emission of [Leu5] enkephalin. Enhanced resolution of anisotropy decay was obtained by using acrylamide quenching of the tyrosyl fluorescence and global analysis of the frequency-domain anisotropy data obtained with different amounts of acrylamide. The data indicates a 44 ps correlation time for local tyrosine motions, and a 219 ps correlation time for overall rotational diffusion of the pentapeptide. Our data are consistent with an initial loss of fluorescence anisotropy from r0 = 0.4 to a value of r0 = 0.326 occurring during the first two picoseconds after excitation.

Effects of temperature on the fluorescence intensity and anisotropy decays of staphylococcal nuclease and the less stable nuclease-conA-SG28 mutant

Frequency-domain fluorescence spectroscopy was used to investigate the effects of temperature on the intensity and anisotropy decays of the single tryptophan residues of Staphylococcal nuclease A and its nuclease-conA-SG28 mutant. This mutant has the beta-turn forming hexapeptide, Ser-Gly-Asn-Gly-Ser-Pro, substituted for the pentapeptide Tyr-Lys-Gly-Gln-Pro at positions 27-31. The intensity decays were analyzed in terms of a sum of exponentials and with Lorentzian distributions of decay times. The anisotropy decays were analyzed in terms of a sum of exponentials. Both the intensity and anisotropy decay parameters strongly depend on temperature near the thermal transitions of the proteins. Significant differences in the temperature stability of Staphylococcal nuclease and the mutant exist; these proteins show characteristic thermal transition temperatures (Tm) of 51 and 30 degrees C, respectively, at pH 7. The temperature dependence of the intensity decay data are shown to be consistent with a two-state unfolding model. For both proteins, the longer rotational correlation time, due to overall rotational diffusion, decreases dramatically at the transition temperature, and the amplitude of the shorter correlation time increases, indicating increased segmental motions of the single tryptophan residue. The mutant protein appears to have a slightly larger overall rotational correlation time and to show slightly more segmental motion of its Trp than is the case for the wild-type protein.

Distance distributions and anisotropy decays of troponin C and its complex with troponin I

We used frequency domain measurements of fluorescence resonance energy transfer to recover the distribution of distances between Met 25 and Cys 98 in rabbit skeletal troponin C. These residues were labeled with dansylaziridine as energy donor and 5-(iodoacetamido)eosin as acceptor and are located on the N- and C-terminal lobes of the two-domain protein, respectively. We developed a procedure to correct for the fraction of the sample that was incompletely labeled with the acceptor independent of chemical data. At pH 7.5 and in the presence of Mg2+, the mean distance was near 15 A with a half-width of the distribution of 15 A; when Mg2+ was replaced by Ca2+, the mean distance increased to 22 A with a decrease in the half-width by 4 A. Similar but less pronounced differences in the mean distance and half-width between samples containing Mg2+ and Ca2+ were also observed with troponin C complexed to troponin I. The results suggest that the conformation of troponin C is altered by Ca2+ binding to the Ca(2+)-specific sites and displacing bound Mg2+ at the Ca2+/Mg2+ sites. This alteration may play an important role in Ca2+ signaling in muscle. At pH 7.5, the anisotropy decays of the donor-labeled troponin C showed two components, with the long rotational correlation time (12 ns) reflecting the overall motion of the protein. When the pH was lowered from 7.5 to 5.2, the mean distribution distance of apotroponin C increased from 22 to 32 A and the half-width decreased by a factor of 2 from 13 to 7 A. The long correlation time of apotroponin C increased to 19 ns at the acidic pH. These results are discussed in terms of a model in which skeletal troponin C is a dimer at low pH and enable comparison of the solution conformation of the protein at neutral pH with a crystal structure obtained at pH 5.2. While the conformation of the monomeric unit of troponin C dimer at pH 5.2 is extended and consistent with the crystal structure, the conformation at neutral pH is likely more compact than the crystal structure predicts.

Conformational distributions of melittin in water/methanol mixtures from frequency-domain measurements of nonradiative energy transfer

We used fluorescence energy transfer to examine the effects of solvent composition on the distribution of distances between the single tryptophan residue of melittin (residue 19) to the N-terminal alpha-amino group, which was labeled with a dansyl residue. The tryptophan intensity decays, with and without the dansyl acceptor, were measured by the frequency-domain method. The data were analyzed by a least-squares algorithm which accounts for correlation between the parameters. A wide distribution of tryptophan to dansyl distances was found for the random-coil state, with a Gaussian half-width of 25 A. Increasing concentrations of methanol, which were shown to induce and alpha-helical conformation, resulted in a progressive decrease in the width of the distribution, reaching a limiting half-width of 3 A at 80% (v/v) methanol. The distance from the indole moiety of Trp-19 to the dansyl group in 80% (v/v) methanol/water was found to be 25 A, as assessed from the center of the distance distribution. A distance of 24-25 A was recovered from the X-ray crystal structure of the tetramer, which is largely alpha-helical. At low ionic strength (less than 0.01) the CD spectra revealed a small fraction or amount of alpha-helix for melittin in water, which implies a small fraction of residual structure. This residual structure is apparently lost in guanidine hydrochloride as demonstrated by a further broadening in the distribution of distances. These results demonstrate the usefulness of frequency-domain measurements of resonance transfer for resolution of conformational distributions of proteins.

Time-resolved emission spectra of hemoglobin on the picosecond time scale

We used front-face illumination to examine the steady-state and time-resolved emission from the intrinsic tryptophan emission of human hemoglobin (Hb). Experimental conditions were identified which eliminated all contributions of scattered light. The sensitivity obtained using front-face optics was adequate to allow measurement of the wavelength-dependent frequency response of the emission to 2 GHz. The intensity decays displayed pico- and nanosecond components in the emission at all wavelengths from 315 to 380 nm. The contribution of the picosecond component decreased from 72 to 37% over this range of wavelengths. Frequency-domain measurements were used to calculate the time-resolved emission spectra and decay-associated emission spectra. These spectra indicate that the picosecond components of the emission display maxima near 320 nm, whereas the nanosecond components are centered at longer wavelengths near 335 nm. The nanosecond components appear to be due to residual impurities which remain even in highly purified samples of Hb. However, we cannot eliminate the possibility that some of these components are due to Hb itself.

Gigahertz frequency-domain fluorometry: resolution of complex decays, picosecond processes and future developments

We describe the principles, instrumentation and applications of frequency-domain fluorescence spectroscopy. This method is useful for the resolution of multi-exponential decays and complex anisotropy decays on the picosecond timescale. The present instrumentation allows measurements to 2 GHz, which has been used to measure rotational correlation times as short as 7 ps. In the future it may be possible to extend the frequency range to 10 GHz, which should allow still faster processes to be quantified. It should be emphasized that resolution of fast processes is not obtained at the expense of losing information on the nanosecond timescale. Additionally, the GHz frequency-domain measurements are performed using low excitation intensities, which do not damage the samples.

Transient Effects in Fluorescence Quenching Measured by 2-GHz Frequency-Domain Fluorometry

We used harmonic-content frequency-domain fluorometry to investigate the quenching of indole fluorescence by iodide and acrylamide in aqueous solution. The time-resolved intensity decays were recovered from the frequency response of the fluorescence emission, measured over a frequency range from 10 to 2000 MHz. In the absence of collisional quenching the decay of indole in water is predominately a single exponential. The intensity decays became increasingly nonexponential when quenched by either iodide or acrylamide. We attribute the complex decays to transient effects, as predicted originally by Smoluchowski. At quencher concentrations below 0.1 M the decays are of the form exp(-t/τ - 2bt 1/2), which is known to be an approximate model. At quencher concentrations above 0.1 M this decay law does not account for the data. The data are in better agreement with the radiation model, and the diffusion coefficients and interaction radii are more reasonable. However, in aqueous solution above 0.5 M acrylamide there appear to be deviations from the radiation model. The deviations are less apparent at high iodide concentrations. For comparison with future theoretical developments, the intensity decay laws are reported up to 0.5 M iodide or 0.7 M acrylamide. Evidently, the resolution and sensitivity of the frequency-domain method are adequate to recover the complex subnanosecond decays found at high concentrations of quenchers.

Picosecond resolution of tyrosine fluorescence and anisotropy decays by 2-GHz frequency-domain fluorometry

We extended the technique of frequency-domain fluorometry to an upper frequency limit of 2000 MHz. This was accomplished by using the harmonic content of a laser pulse train (3.76 MHz, 5 ps) from a synchronously pumped and cavity-dumped dye laser. We used a microchannel plate photomultiplier as the detector to obtain the 2-GHz bandwidth. This new instrument was used to examine tyrosine intensity and anisotropy decays from peptides and proteins. These initial data sets demonstrate that triply exponential tyrosine intensity decays are easily recoverable, even if the mean decay time is less than 1 ns. Importantly, the extended frequency range provides good resolution of rapid and/or multiexponential tyrosine anisotropy decays. Correlation times as short as 15 ps have been recovered for indole, with an uncertainty of +/- 3 ps. We recovered a doubly exponential anisotropy decay of oxytoxin (29 and 454 ps), which probably reflects torsional motions of the phenol ring and overall rotational diffusion, respectively. Also, a 40-ps component was found in the anisotropy decay of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor, which may be due to rapid torsional motions of the tyrosine residues and/or energy transfer among these residues. The rapid component has an amplitude of 0.05, which is about 16% of the total anisotropy. The availability of 2-GHz frequency-domain data extends the measurable time scale for fluorescence to overlap with that of molecular dynamics calculations.

Picosecond resolution of oxytocin tyrosyl fluorescence by 2 GHz frequency-domain fluorometry

The technique of frequency-domain fluorometry has been extended to 2000 MHz using the harmonic content of a picosecond laser source and a microchannel plate photomultiplier tube. This new instrument was used to resolve complex subnanosecond intensity and anisotropy decays of the tyrosyl emission of oxytocin. The intensity decay was found to contain at least three exponential components, 80, 359 and 927 ps. The anisotropy analysis revealed a 29 ps torsional motion of the tyrosine residue as well as a 454 ps overall rotational correlation time. The time resolution of this method should permit the comparison of experimental results with theoretical models for motions of proteins.

Measurement of subnanosecond anisotropy decays of protein fluorescence using frequency-domain fluorometry

We report the first anisotropy decays of protein fluorescence obtained using a frequency-domain fluorometer. The ultraviolet light source (300 nm) was a ring dye laser equipped with an intracavity frequency doubler, pumped by an argon ion laser. The data, measured at modulation frequencies from 2 to 200 MHz, reveal the presence of subnanosecond motions (0.1-0.2 ns) of the single tryptophan residues in melittin and monellin. For melittin the data also indicate the presence of slower motions near 1 ns, which may be the result of concerted motions of several peptide units. Smaller amplitude motions, on a similar timescale, were observed for the single tryptophan residue in staphylococcal nuclease. We demonstrate using N-acetyl-L-tryptophanamide in water that the method of frequency-domain fluorometry is capable of measuring correlation times as short as 50 ps. This method can provide data for the direct comparison of measured anisotropy decays with those predicted from molecular dynamics calculations.

Analysis of fluorescence decay kinetics from variable-frequency phase shift and modulation data

Recently it has become possible to measure fluorescence phase-shift and modulation data over a wide range of modulation frequencies. In this paper we describe the analysis of these data by the method of nonlinear least squares to determine the values of the lifetimes and fractional intensities for a mixture of exponentially decaying fluorophores. Analyzing simulated data allowed us to determine those experimental factors that are most critical for successfully resolving the emissions from mixtures of fluorophores. The most critical factors are the accuracy of the experimental data, the relative difference of the individual decay times, and the inclusion of data measured at multiple emission wavelengths. After measuring at eight widely spaced modulation frequencies, additional measurements yielded only a modest increase in resolution. In particular, the uncertainty in the parameters decreased approximately as the reciprocal of the square root of the number of modulation frequencies. Our simulations showed that with presently available precision and data for one emission bandpass, two decay times could be accurately determined if their ratio were greater than or equal to 1.4. Three exponential decays could also be resolved, but only if the range of the lifetimes were fivefold or greater. To reliably determine closely-spaced decay times, the data were measured at multiple emission wavelengths so that the fractional intensities of the components could be varied. Also, independent knowledge of any of the parameters substantially increased the accuracy with which the remaining parameters could be determined. In the subsequent paper we present experimental results that broadly confirm the predicted resolving potential of variable-frequency phase-modulation fluorometry.

Resolution of mixtures of fluorophores using variable-frequency phase and modulation data

We measured fluorescence phase shift and modulation data for one-, two- and, three-component mixtures of fluorophores at modulation frequencies ranging from 1 to 140 MHz. These data were analyzed using the least-squares procedure described in the preceding paper (Lakowicz, J. R., G. Laczko, M. Cherek, E. Gratton, and M. Limkeman, 1984, Biophys. J., 46:463-477). Using data obtained at a single emission bandpass, the lifetimes and preexponential factors of two-component mixtures could be easily resolved if the lifetimes differed by a factor of 2. With currently available instrumental stability, three-component mixtures could be resolved when the overall range of decay times was 10-fold, (e.g., 1.3, 4.4, and 12 ns). Measurement of phase and modulation data at several emission wavelengths, where the ratio of the preexponential factors varied, enhanced our ability to resolve closely spaced two and three-component decays. Two-component mixtures could then be resolved if the lifetimes differed by 30% (4.4 and 6.2 ns). Also, the multiple-wavelength data allowed the lifetimes and emission spectra of the three-components of a mixture to be resolved. These results demonstrated that resolution of multiexponential decay laws was possible using frequency-domain phase-modulation fluorometry.

Determination of time-resolved fluorescence emission spectra and anisotropies of a fluorophore-protein complex using frequency-domain phase-modulation fluorometry

We report the first time-resolved fluorescence emission spectra and time-resolved fluorescence anisotropies obtained using frequency-domain fluorescence spectroscopy. We examined the fluorophore p-2-toluidinyl-6-naphthalenesulfonic acid (TNS) in viscous solvents and bound to the heme site of apomyoglobin using multifrequency phase fluorometers. Fluorescence phase shift and modulation data were obtained at modulation frequencies ranging from 1 to 200 MHz. For time-resolved emission spectra, the impulse response for the decay of intensity at each emission wavelength was obtained from the frequency response of the sample at the same emission wavelength. The decays have negative pre-exponential factors, consistent with a time-dependent spectral shift to longer wavelengths. These multiexponential decays were used to construct the time-resolved emission spectra, which were found to be in good agreement with earlier spectra obtained from time-domain measurements. Additionally, time-resolved anisotropies were obtained from the frequency-dependent phase angle differences between the parallel and perpendicularly polarized components of the emission. The rotational correlation times of TNS bound to apomyoglobin are consistent with those expected for this probe rigidly bound to the protein. TNS in propylene glycol also displayed a single exponential decay of anisotropy. These results, in conjunction with the previous successful resolution of multiexponential decays of fluorescence intensity (Lakowicz, J. R., Gratton, E., Laczko, G., Cherek, H., and Limkeman, M. (1984) Biophys. J., in press; Gratton, E., Lakowicz, J. R., Maliwal, B. P., Cherek, H., Laczko, G., and Limkeman, M. (1984) Biophys. J., in press) demonstrate that frequency-domain measurements provide information which is, at a minimum, equivalent to that obtainable from time-domain measurements.

Torsional rearrangements of aryl-substituted anthracenes measured by phase fluorometry

We examined the fluorescence phase angle spectra of aryl-substituted anthracenes in viscous solvents. These phase angles reflect the wavelength-dependent lifetimes displayed by the fluorophores. At intermediate viscosities the phase angles increased and decreased in accordance with the valleys and peaks of the structured emission spectra. At lower and higher temperatures the phase angles were independent of emission wavelength, which is equivalent to decay times which are independent of emission wavelength. We attribute the wavelength-dependent phase angles to rotation of the unsaturaled side chains towards a conformation more coplanar with the anthracene ring. By comparative studies with 9,10-di(alpha-naphthylanthracene), 9,10-di-phenylanthracene, and 9-vinylanthracene we showed that lower temperatures are required to inhibit rotation of the smaller phenyl and vinyl substitutents. Since these excited-state rearrangements are sensitive to the motional freedom allowed by the surrounding solvent, we suggest that this phenomenon may serve as a probe of volume fluctuations in macromolecules.