Determination of the economically justifiable price of cenobamate in the treatment of focal-onset seizures in adult patients with drug-resistant epilepsy in Spain

OBJECTIVE

To determine the economically justifiable price (EJP) of cenobamate to become a cost-effective alternative compared with third-generation anti-seizure medications in the treatment of focal-onset seizures (FOS) in adult patients with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) in Spain.

METHODS

Cost-effectiveness analysis comparing cenobamate with brivaracetam, perampanel, eslicarbazepine acetate and lacosamide. Markov model simulation of treatment pathway over a 60-year time horizon. Determination of effectiveness and quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) of each health status, and disutilities associated with treatment-related adverse events. Acquisition costs and use of medical resources were obtained from published literature and expert opinion. Base-case of cenobamate's EJP calculated applying a willingness-to-pay (WTP) threshold of €21,000/QALY. Analyses performed at different thresholds, including dominant price scenario. Results robustness were assessed through sensitivity analyses.

RESULTS

Base-case shows that cenobamate's daily EJP of €7.30 is cost-effective for a threshold of €21,000/QALY. At a daily price of €5.45, cenobamate becomes dominant over all treatment alternatives producing cost-savings for the national health system (NHS). Sensitivity analyses supported the robustness of base-case findings.

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment with cenobamate produces incremental clinical benefit over third generation ASMs and at the base-case EJP could represent a cost-effective option for the adjunctive treatment of FOS in adult patients with DRE in Spain.

[«Apuntes en Neurologia» (Notes in Neurology): a synthesis of the evidence on common paroxysmal neurological disorders and on neurodegenerative disorders]

«Apuntes en Neurologia» is an initiative in which prominent national and international leaders, with broad academic recognition, came together to synthesise the most outstanding clinical aspects within their area of interest and to discuss the latest developments in a more accessible language. Understanding the factors that affect the onset and progression of any neurological disease through a review is important to be able to develop strategies to reduce the burden of these diseases. Moreover, knowledge of the clinical aspects is essential to solve the problems of daily clinical practice. The data collected here reflect the weight of evidence and some of them anticipate a promising future in the treatment of these diseases. This first edition focuses on common paroxysmal neurological disorders such as migraine, epilepsy and sleep disorders, as well as neurodegenerative disorders such as Parkinson's disease and cognitive impairment. These are clearly different pathologies, although some of them such as migraine and epilepsy, may share clinical symptoms. Sleep disorders, however, are important manifestations of neurodegenerative diseases that are sometimes clinically apparent long before the onset of other neurological symptoms. After recalling pathophysiology and diagnosis, the current review focuses on bringing together the main advances in five of the major neurological diseases.

[The importance of amygdala removal in the surgical treatment of mesial temporal lobe epilepsy]

Even though amygdalar lesions are a known epilepsy model in laboratory animals, the role of the amygdala in mesial temporal sclerosis is not well-known. To date, most interest has been paid to the role of the hippocampal formation. The aim of this article is to emphasize the role of the amygdala in order to render a patient seizure free. Two patients are presented who were 50 and 42 years old at the time of surgery. They suffered from seizures since childhood and were diagnosed with mesial temporal sclerosis. A temporal lobectomy with hippocampectomy and partial amygdalectomy was performed on both patients in the year 2000, with one patient operated on the right side and the other one on the left side. Both patients were seizure free after surgery for 6 years, but presented again with seizures after that time. They were evaluated again for surgery, and subdural grids were placed, together with a deep electrode in the remnants of the amygdala. The amygdalar electrode showed to be the seizure onset in the two cases, and its resection rendered both patients seizure free. These two patients show that a complete amygdalar resection is necessary to render some patients seizure free. It might be the amygdala has a greater role than previously thought.

Novel mutation in STXBP1 gene in a patient with non-lesional Ohtahara syndrome

INTRODUCTION

Ohtahara syndrome (OS, OMIM#308350, ORPHA1934) is an early-onset epileptic encephalopathy (EOEE) characterised by spasms, intractable seizures, suppression-burst pattern on the electroencephalogram, and severe psychomotor retardation. Mutations in STXBP1 -a gene that codes for syntaxin binding protein 1 and is involved in synaptic vesicle exocytosis- has been identified in most patients with OS.

PATIENT AND RESULTS

We report the case of a 19-month-old child with OS who displays a previously unreported mutation in STXBP1 (c.1249+2T>C, G417AfsX7). This mutation is located in a donor splice site and eliminates exon 14, resulting in a truncated protein.

CONCLUSION

This previously unreported STXBP1 mutation in a subject with Ohtahara syndrome and non-lesional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) broadens the mutational spectrum associated with this devastating epileptic syndrome.

Long-term safety and efficacy of eslicarbazepine acetate in patients with focal seizures: results of the 1-year ESLIBASE retrospective study

BACKGROUND

Eslicarbazepine acetate (ESL) is a new antiepileptic drug (AED) licensed as adjunctive therapy in adults with partial-onset or focal seizures.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate in a clinical practice setting the long-term efficacy and safety of ESL in patients with focal seizures.

METHODS

ESLIBASE was a retrospective study that included all patients with focal seizures who started ESL between January 2010 and July 2012 at 12 hospitals. ESL was prescribed individually according to real-life practice. Efficacy and safety were evaluated over 1 year. Switching from carbamazepine (CBZ) and oxcarbazepine (OXC) was assessed.

RESULTS

Three hundred and twenty-seven patients were included; 78% of patients were taking ≥2 other AEDs at baseline. Most (87%) began ESL because of poor seizure control and 13% because of adverse events (AEs) with CBZ or OXC. After 1 year, 237 patients (72.4%) remained on ESL. At 3, 6 and 12 months, the responder rate was 46.3%, 57.9%, and 52.5%, and 21.0%, 28.0%, and 25.3% of patients were seizure free. The responder rate significantly increased when ESL was combined with a non-sodium channel-targeting drug (non-SC drug) (66.7%) versus an SC drug (47.7%; p<0.001). At 12 months, 40.7% of patients had ≥1 AE; AEs led to treatment discontinuation in 16.2%. Dizziness, nausea, and somnolence were the most common AEs. The tolerability profile improved in >50% of the patients who switched from CBZ or OXC to ESL because of AEs.

CONCLUSIONS

ESL was well tolerated and effective in a real-world setting over 1 year. Side-effect profile improved when OXC and CBZ recipients were switched to ESL.

GLUT1 mutations are a rare cause of familial idiopathic generalized epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

The idiopathic generalized epilepsies (IGE) are the most common genetically determined epilepsies. However, the underlying genes are largely unknown. We screened the SLC2A1 gene, encoding the glucose transporter type 1 (GLUT1), for mutations in a group of 95 European patients with familial IGE.

METHODS

The affected individuals were examined clinically by EEG and brain imaging. The coding regions of SLC2A1 were sequenced in the index cases of all families. Wild-type and mutant transporters were expressed and functionally characterized in Xenopus laevis oocytes.

RESULTS

We detected a novel nonsynonymous SLC2A1 mutation (c.694C>T, p.R232C) in one IGE family. Nine family members were affected mainly by absence epilepsies with a variable age at onset, from early childhood to adulthood. Childhood absence epilepsy in one individual evolved into juvenile myoclonic epilepsy. Eight affected and 4 unaffected individuals carried the mutation, revealing a reduced penetrance of 67%. The detected mutation was not found in 846 normal control subjects. Functional analysis revealed a reduced maximum uptake velocity for glucose, whereas the affinity to glucose and the protein expression were not different in wild-type and mutant transporters.

CONCLUSION

Our study shows that GLUT1 defects are a rare cause of classic IGE. SLC2A1 screening should be considered in IGE featuring absence epilepsies with onset from early childhood to adult life, because this diagnosis may have important implications for treatment and genetic counseling.

Self-reported memory problems in everyday activities in patients with epilepsy treated with antiepileptic drugs

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this study was to assess everyday memory complaints in a large cohort of patients with epilepsy treated with antiepileptic drugs and to determine demographic, clinical, and emotional state factors associated with patients' self-perception of memory disturbances.

METHODS

This cross-sectional epidemiological study was carried out in routine clinical practice using the Questionnaire of Memory Efficiency (QME) and the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS).

RESULTS

Six hundred sixty-one patients were recruited. The time since epilepsy diagnosis was 17.3 years (SD=12.5); the number of seizures in the past year 13.8 (SD=4.8); the proportion of patients free of seizures in the last year 42.5%; the proportion of patients with partial seizures 73.2%; and the proportion of patients on monotherapy 56.3%. Total QME score was 110.0 (SD=18.6). Depression and anxiety scores and polytherapy explained 38.7% of the QME variance.

CONCLUSIONS

Subjective memory functioning in this cohort of patients with epilepsy was relatively good. Complaints expressed by these patients are explained mainly by the presence of depressive and anxiety symptoms.

[Open-label, prospective and observational study of efficacy and tolerability with levetiracetam during one year of follow-up]

OBJECTIVE

Analyze efficacy and tolerability of levetiracetam under clinical practice conditions.

METHODS

An open-label, observational and prospective study with a one-year follow-up period, was conducted. All the patients in whom treatment was initiated with levetiracetam between January 2002 and January 2004 in the site where the study was conducted were included. The patients were evaluated in the baseline visit and months 1, 3, 6 and 12. The following were collected in the baseline visit: age, gender, age at onset of the episode, types of episodes, type of epilepsy, etiology, monthly rate of episodes and number of anti-epileptic drugs (AED) used. During the follow-up visits, episodes, adverse effects and concomitant AED were counted. Analysis was conducted by intention-to-treat (ITT) and in the patients who completed one year of follow-up.

RESULTS

One hundred eight patients were enrolled in the study. Most had partial complex seizures (63.1 %) and partial epilepsy (88 %). Eighty-one patients completed the one year of follow-up (75 %). In relationship to the ITT, the percentage of responders was 63 % and the percentage of seizure-free patients 35.2 %. These percentages remained stable during the study. Secondary effects were maintained in 21 patients (19.4 %), resulting in withdrawal in 9 patients (8.3 %). The most frequent adverse event was somnolence. Monotherapy was achieved with levetiracetam at the end of the one year of follow-up in 18 patients (16.7%)

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows the efficacy and tolerability, which rarely led to withdrawal, of levetiracetam under conditions of clinical practice.

Hepatic disease as the first manifestation of progressive myoclonus epilepsy of Lafora

BACKGROUND

Lafora disease (LD; progressive myoclonus epilepsy type 2; EPM2) is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by mutations in the EPM2A and EPM2B genes. LD is characterized by the presence of strongly PAS-positive intracellular inclusions (Lafora bodies) in several tissues. Glycogen storage disease type IV (GSD-IV; Andersen disease) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterized by cirrhosis leading to severe liver failure. GSD-IV has been associated with mutations in the glycogen branching enzyme gene (GBE). Histopathologic changes of the liver in both diseases show an identical appearance, although cirrhosis has never been described in patients with LD. We report a LD family in which the proband presented severe liver failure at onset of the disease.

METHODS

Clinical histories, physical and neurologic examination, laboratory tests, EEGs, MRI of the brain, and liver or axillary skin biopsies were performed in the two affected siblings. The diagnosis was confirmed by molecular genetic analysis of the EPM2A, EPM2B, and GBE genes and loci.

RESULTS

During the first decade of life, abnormalities in liver function tests were detected in the two affected siblings. The proband's liver dysfunction was severe enough to require liver transplantation. Subsequently, both sibs developed LD. Mutation analysis of EPM2A revealed a homozygous Arg241stop mutation in both patients.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first description of severe hepatic dysfunction as the initial clinical manifestation of LD. The phenotypic differences between the two affected siblings suggest that modifier genes must condition clinical expression of the disease outside the CNS.

Effect of lamotrigine on sexual function in patients with epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

To assess the course of sexual function in epilepsy patients treated with lamotrigine.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This open study included 141 patients treated with lamotrigine for a period of 8 months: 79 patients initiated treatment with lamotrigine monotherapy, and 62 were switched to lamotrigine because of lack of efficacy or adverse events to a previous antiepileptic drug (AED). Patients were assessed at baseline and after 4 and 8 months of treatment. In the baseline and final visits the Changes in Sexual Functioning Questionnaire (CSFQ) was applied. Analysis was performed in an intent-to-treat population.

RESULTS

In women who started treatment with lamotrigine, a significant improvement was observed, both in total CSFQ score (increase of 5.39 +/- 6.95 points; p < 0.05), and in the five dimensions of the scale (desire/frequency, desire/interest, pleasure, arousal/excitement and orgasm). In men, a significant improvement was only observed in the pleasure dimension. In the group of patients in whom a previous AED was substituted by lamotrigine, significant improvement was recorded in the dimensions of pleasure and orgasm in men and desire/frequency in women, whilst in women the desire/interest dimension showed a decrease.

CONCLUSIONS

In this observational study, an improvement in sexual dysfunction was observed in association with lamotrigine. This could have been the result of improvement of the epilepsy, changes in quality of life, elimination of side effects from other AEDs, or a mood-stabilizing effect of lamotrigine.

Arrangement and Mobility of Water in Vermiculite Hydrates Followed by 1H NMR Spectroscopy

The arrangement of water molecules in one- and two-layer hydrates of high-charged vermiculites, saturated with alkaline (Li(+), Na(+)) and alkali-earth (Mg(2+), Ca(2+), Ba(2+)) cations, has been analyzed with (1)H NMR spectroscopy. Two different orientations for water molecules have been found, depending on the hydration state and the sites occupied by interlayer cations. As the amount of water increases, hydrogen bond interactions between water molecules increase at expenses of water-silicate interactions. This interaction favors water mobility in vermiculites. A comparison of the temperature dependence of relaxation times T(1) and T(2) for one and two-layer hydrates of Na-vermiculite shows that the rotations of water molecules around C(2)-axes and that of cation hydration shells around the c-axis is favored in the two-layer hydrate. In both hydrates, the anisotropic diffusion of water takes place at room temperature, preserving the orientation of water molecules relative to the silicate layers. Information obtained by NMR spectroscopy is compatible with that deduced by infrared spectroscopy and with structural studies carried out with X-ray and neutron diffraction techniques on single-crystals of vermiculite.

Lafora disease due to EPM2B mutations: a clinical and genetic study

OBJECTIVE

To study EPM2B gene mutations and genotype-phenotype correlations in patients with Lafora disease.

METHODS

The authors performed a clinical and mutational analysis of 25 patients, from 23 families, diagnosed with Lafora disease who had not shown mutations in the EPM2A gene.

RESULTS

The authors identified 18 mutations in EPM2B, including 12 novel mutations: 4 nonsense mutations (R265X, C26X, W219X, and E67X), a 6-base pair (bp) microdeletion resulting in a two amino acid deletion (V294_K295del), a 4-bp insertion resulting in a frameshift mutation (S339fs12), and 6 missense mutations (D308A, I198N, C68Y, E67Q, P264H, and D233A). In our data set of 77 families with Lafora disease, 54 (70.1%) tested probands have mutations in EPM2A, 21 (27.3%) in EPM2B, and 2 (2.6%) have no mutations in either gene. The course of the disease was longer in patients with EPM2B mutations vs patients with EPM2A mutations.

CONCLUSIONS

Genetic allelic heterogeneity is present in Lafora disease associated with mutations in EPM2B. Patients with mutations in EPM2A and EPM2B express similar clinical manifestation, although patients with EPM2B-associated Lafora disease seem to have a slightly milder clinical course. The lack of mutations in EPM2A and EPM2B in two families could be because of the presence of mutations in noncoding, nontested regions or the existence of an additional gene associated with Lafora disease.

Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and periventricular nodular heterotopia in a Spanish family with a single FLNA mutation

BACKGROUND

The Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) comprises a group of hereditary connective tissue disorders. Periventricular nodular heterotopia (PNH) is a human neuronal migration disorder characterised by seizures and conglomerates of neural cells around the lateral ventricles of the brain, caused by FLNA mutations. FLNA encodes filamin A, an actin binding protein involved in cytoskeletal organisation. The amino-terminal actin binding domain (ABD) of filamins contains two tandem calponin homology domains, CHD1 and CHD2.

OBJECTIVE

To report clinical and genetic analyses in a Spanish family affected by a connective tissue disorder suggestive of EDS type III and PNH.

METHODS

A clinical and molecular study was undertaken in the three affected women. Clinical histories, physical and neurological examinations, brain magnetic resonance imaging studies, and skin biopsies were done. Genetic analysis of the FLNA gene was undertaken by direct sequencing and restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis.

RESULTS

Mutation analysis of the FLNA gene resulted in the identification of a novel mutation in exon 3 (c.383C-->T) segregating with the combination of both syndromes. This mutation results in a substitution of an alanine residue (A128V) in CHD1.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings suggest that the Ala128Val mutation causes the dual EDS-PNH phenotype. This association constitutes a new variant within the EDS spectrum. This is the first description of a familial EDS-PNH association with a mutation in FLNA.

[Safety of levetiracetam as adjunctive therapy in epilepsy: the SKATE trial in Spain]

AIM

To continue assessing safety and to evaluate the efficacy of levetiracetam and to assess the optimal dose in community based practice.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Single-arm, open label, multicenter, observational and prospective trial lasting 16-22 weeks. Criteria for inclusion: patients > 16 years experiencing epilepsy with partial seizures taking at least one concomitant antiepileptic drug. The initial dose was 1,000 mg/day, up to the maximal dose of 3,000 mg/day. Safety evaluation was adverse events reporting. Efficacy evaluation were reduction in seizure frequency; QOLIE-10 questionnaire and global evaluation scale of disease severity.

RESULTS

Of the 342 subjects, 296 (86.5%) completed the treatment period. 103 subjects (30.1%) experienced at least one adverse event. The most frequently adverse events reported were somnolence (11.7%), dizziness (5.8%) and headache (3.5%). The events were majority (93.1%) of mild to moderate intensity. The median percent reduction in partial seizure frequency per week was 55%. 51.2% of patients experienced a reduction 50% in partial seizure frequency. Similar results were observed for total seizures. An increase of QOLIE-10 total score was observed (10.2 +/- 17.8). A total of 63.5% patients were rated as having moderate or marked improvement in their disease severity.

CONCLUSIONS

These data confirm and provide additional support of levetiracetam safety and efficacy demonstrated in phase III trials.

[Prognostic factors in temporal lobe epilepsy surgery]

INTRODUCTION

Temporal lobe epilepsy surgery represents the majority of surgical interventions in patients with refractory epilepsy. In consequence, knowledge of prognostic factors in this type of epilepsy surgery is of major importance. The objective of this study is to study series of prognostic factors in a group of patients who underwent temporal lobe epilepsy surgery and to correlate Engel's Classification of Postoperative Outcome, now used in most epilepsy centers, and the Proposal for New Classification in regards to Epileptic Seizures Following Epilepsy Surgery of the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE).

METHODS

We analyzed 41 consecutive patients who underwent temporal lobe epilepsy surgery in the Epilepsy Surgery Program of the Epilepsy Unit in the Fundación Jiménez Díaz. The following prognostic factors were analyzed: age at surgery, time since the first seizure (excluding febrile seizures), risk factors for the development of epilepsy, presence of simple partial seizures, presurgical complex partial seizure frequency, findings in brain magnetic resonance imaging, interictal and ictal electroencephalogram, neuropsychological assessment, Wada test and neuropathological study of the surgical specimen. Two outcome classifications were used: Engel's classification of postoperative outcome and the proposal for a new classification of outcome in regards to epileptic seizures following epilepsy surgery of the ILAE. Statistical analysis was performed using non-parametric tests.

RESULTS

The presence of temporal unilateral interictal epileptiform activity and the presence of less than 20 seizures complex partial seizures per month before surgery were associated with a better prognosis using both classifications. The electronencephalographic unilateral temporal ictal onset recording was associated with a better prognosis using Engel's classification but not ILAE's outcome classification. The presence of febrile seizures was associated with a better prognosis in regards to ILAE's outcome classification but not in regards to Engel's classification. The remaining factors were not associated with outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

The following factors were associated with a good prognosis: presence of unilateral temporal interictal epileptiform activity, presurgery seizure frequency below 20 complex partial seizures per month, unilateral temporal ictal onset, and presence of febrile seizures. A good correlation was found between both outcome classifications in regards to most of the analyzed prognostic factors.

Laforin, the dual-phosphatase responsible for Lafora disease, interacts with R5 (PTG), a regulatory subunit of protein phosphatase-1 that enhances glycogen accumulation

Progressive myoclonus epilepsy of Lafora type (LD, MIM 254780) is a fatal autosomal recessive disorder characterized by the presence of progressive neurological deterioration, myoclonus, epilepsy and polyglucosan intracellular inclusion bodies, called Lafora bodies. Lafora bodies resemble glycogen with reduced branching, suggesting an alteration in glycogen metabolism. Linkage analysis and homozygosity mapping localized EPM2A, a major gene for LD, to chromosome 6q24. EPM2A encodes a protein of 331 amino acids (named laforin) with two domains, a dual-specificity phosphatase domain and a carbohydrate binding domain. Here we show that, in addition, laforin interacts with itself and with the glycogen targeting regulatory subunit R5 of protein phosphatase 1 (PP1). R5 is the human homolog of the murine Protein Targeting to Glycogen, a protein that also acts as a molecular scaffold assembling PP1 with its substrate, glycogen synthase, at the intracellular glycogen particles. The laforin-R5 interaction was confirmed by pull-down and co-localization experiments. Full-length laforin is required for the interaction. However, a minimal central region of R5 (amino acids 116-238), including the binding sites for glycogen and for glycogen synthase, is sufficient to interact with laforin. Point-mutagenesis of the glycogen synthase-binding site completely blocked the interaction with laforin. The majority of the EPM2A missense mutations found in LD patients result in lack of phosphatase activity, absence of binding to glycogen and lack of interaction with R5. Interestingly, we have found that the LD-associated EPM2A missense mutation G240S has no effect on the phosphatase or glycogen binding activities of laforin but disrupts the interaction with R5, suggesting that binding to R5 is critical for the laforin function. These results place laforin in the context of a multiprotein complex associated with intracellular glycogen particles, reinforcing the concept that laforin is involved in the regulation of glycogen metabolism.

[The course of the catastrophic epilepsies]

INTRODUCTION

Catastrophic epilepsy is a term applied to epilepsies with early onset, frequent and refractory seizures and cognitive impairment. The prognosis of these epilepsies is usually unfavorable. However, only a suitable diagnosis will allow the right treatment and a better prognosis.

DEVELOPMENT

At the time of this writing there are a wide range of diagnostic tests, such as RMI, PET and video EEG that may lead right diagnostic of patients.

CONCLUSION

The spectrum of therapies has also been widened. New antiepileptic drugs, with new mechanisms of action are being developed as well as improved surgical techniques. The rational use of these procedures will optimize control of seizures and improve cognitive impairment.

[Lafora disease. A new case of confirmation of diagnosis on molecular genetic studies]

INTRODUCTION

Lafora s disease is a type of progressive myoclonic epilepsy with bad prognosis. Until now diagnosis was based on finding characteristic intracytoplasmatic polyglucosan bodies in biopsies of sweat secreting cells in the skin. Recently the gene responsible has been discovered. This permits firm diagnosis and screening of carriers. We present the case of a child diagnosed on molecular genetic studies.

CLINICAL CASE

A 12 year old boy with a clinical history of three febrile seizures at the age of one year but no other abnormalities, presented a seizure of visual disorder with secondary generalization. There was no family history of seizures. Following a period of normality he had further seizures (clonic, visual and generalized myoclonic). The EEG showed generalized spike and wave activity, which was more marked after stimulation by light and became progressively worse. Neuroimaging studies were normal. In spite of treatment there was a progressive increase in visual and generalized myoclonic seizures together with deterioration of cognitive function and ataxia. Histological studies of the sweat glands showed homogeneous nodular deposits of intracytoplasmatic PAS+. Molecular studies of the EPM2A gene linked to chromosome 6q24 showed the presence of two mutations on the 1 and 4 exons.

CONCLUSIONS

We describe a 12 year old patient with all the clinical features of Lafora type progressive myoclonic epilepsy in whom characteristic cytoplasmic bodies were found in the sweat gland biopsy. Molecular genetic studies of the EPM2A gene confirmed diagnosis of the disorder.

Mutational spectrum of the EPM2A gene in progressive myoclonus epilepsy of Lafora: high degree of allelic heterogeneity and prevalence of deletions

Progressive myoclonus epilepsy of the Lafora type (Lafora disease) is an autosomal recessive disease characterised by epilepsy, myoclonus, progressive neurological deterioration and the presence of glycogen-like intracellular inclusion bodies (Lafora bodies). We recently cloned the major gene for Lafora disease (EPM2A) and characterised the corresponding product, a putative protein tyrosine phosphatase (LAFPTPase). Here we report the complete coding sequence of the EPM2A gene and the analysis of this gene in 68 Lafora disease chromosomes. We describe 11 novel mutations: three missense (F84L, G240S and P301L), one nonsense (Y86stop), three < 40 bp microdeletions (K90fs, Ex1-32bpdel, Ex1-33bpdel), and two deletions affecting the entire exon 1 (Ex1-del1 and Ex1-del2). In addition, we have identified three patients with a null allele in non-exonic microsatellites EPM2A-3 or EPM2A-4, suggesting the presence of two distinct > 3 kb deletions affecting exon 2 (Ex2-del1 and Ex2-del2). Considering these mutations, a total of 25 mutations, 60% of them generating truncations, have been described thus far in the EPM2A gene. In spite of this remarkable allelic heterogeneity, the R241stop EPM2A mutation was found in approximately 40% of the Lafora disease patients. We also report the characterisation of five new microsatellite markers and one SNP in the EPM2A gene and describe the haplotypic associations of alleles at these sites in normal and EPM2A chromosomes. This analysis suggests that both founder effect and recurrence have contributed to the relatively high prevalence of R241stop mutation in Spain. The data reported here represent the first systematic analysis of the mutational events in the EPM2A gene in Lafora disease patients and provide insight into the origin and evolution of the different EPM2A alleles.

[Analysis of cost minimization of monotherapy antiepileptic treatment in patients with recent diagnosed epilepsy : the situation in Spain]

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the cost of monotherapeutic treatment of patients with newly diagnosed epilepsy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We analysed the cost of treatment with lamotrigine (LTG), carbamazepine (CBZ), phenytoin (PHT) and valproic acid (VPA) using published data regarding the efficacy and tolerability of comparative clinical trials of monotherapy. We established a model of treatment for newly diagnosed patients during the first 12 months after diagnosis. A panel of doctors reached a consensus on the use of resources, costs and model of treatment in Spain. We made a cost minimization analysis for economic assessment of the data based on the fact that randomized trials indicated that CBZ, LTG, PHT and VPA ware of similar efficacy. Analysis was done as 'intention to treat'. Only direct medical costs were considered.

RESULTS

In Spain treatment with LTG is twice or three times as expensive as treatment with the other drugs. Sensitivity analysis showed that variations in the interval of use of resources and of costs (defined by the panel of doctors) did not significantly alter the results.

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment with LTG is more expensive than treatment with the classical drugs. In view of the methodological limitations of this study, further analysis is necessary, particularly of the methodology of cost-benefit, to evaluate the economic impact of the new antiepileptic drugs and determine whether their use is justified as drugs of first choice.

The molecular genetic bases of the progressive myoclonus epilepsies

Among the epilepsies, the progressive myoclonus epilepsies (PMEs) form a heterogeneous group of rare diseases characterized by myoclonus, epilepsy, and progressive neurologic deterioration, particularly dementia and ataxia. The success of the Human Genome Project and the fact that most PMEs are inherited through a mendelian or mitochondrial mode have resulted in important advances in the definition of the molecular basis of PME. The gene defects for the most common forms of PME (Unverricht-Lundborg disease, the neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses, Lafora disease, type I sialidosis, and myoclonus epilepsy with ragged-red fibers) have been either identified or mapped to specific chromosome sites. Unverricht-Lundborg disease has been shown to be caused by mutations in the gene that codes for cystatin B, an inhibitor of cysteine protease. The most common mutation in Unverricht-Lundborg disease is an expansion of a dodecamer repeat located in a noncoding region upstream of the transcription start site of the cystatin B gene, making it the first human disease associated with instability of a dodecamer repeat. Juvenile neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis is caused by mutations in the CLN3 gene, a gene of unknown function that encodes a 438-amino-acid protein of possible mitochondrial location. Other forms of neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis that occur as PME and Lafora disease have been mapped by means of linkage analysis, but the corresponding gene defects remain unknown. Sialidosis has been shown to be caused by mutations in the sialidase gene, and myoclonus epilepsy with ragged-red fibers is well known to be caused by mutations in the mitochondrial gene that codes for tRNA(Lys). How the different PME gene defects described produce the various PME phenotypes, including epileptic seizures, remains unknown. The development of animal models that bear these mutations is needed to increase our knowledge of the basic mechanisms involved in the PMEs. This knowledge should lead to the development of new and effective forms of therapy, which are especially lacking for the PMEs.

[New epileptic syndromes]

The recent and increasing interest for previously undescribed forms of epilepsy has been due to the description of families in which several affected members presented specific forms of epilepsy. Most epilepsies representing the description of new epilepsy phenotypes are partial epilepsies, although a new form of generalized epilepsy (generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures plus or GEFS+) has also been described. Our understanding of the clinical and genetic characteristics of the new familial epilepsy syndromes and the identification of informative families should accelerate the discovery of the basic mechanisms implicated in the production of partial seizures. The recent description of the syndrome of autosomal dominant nocturnal frontal lobe epilepsy, its localization to chromosome 20, the identification of the responsible gene (the alpha 4 subunit of the nicotinic cholinergic receptor) and the characterization of a mutation in two families are a good example. The recognition of the new epilepsy syndromes is of great interest for clinical neurologists and should lead to the establishment of more precise prognoses and therapies. In those families with several affected members, genetic knowledge may be important for genetic counseling purposes.

Genetic locus heterogeneity in Lafora's progressive myoclonus epilepsy

In 1995, we mapped a gene for Lafora's progressive myoclonus epilepsy in chromosome 6q23-25. In 1997 and 1998, we reduced the size of the locus to 300 kb, and an international collaboration identified mutations in the protein tyrosine phosphatase gene. Here, we examine for heterogeneity through the admixture test in 22 families and estimate the proportion of linked families to be 75 to 85%. Extremely low posterior probabilities of linkage (Wi), exclusionary LOD scores, and haplotypes identify 4 families unlikely to be linked to chromosome 6q24.

A novel protein tyrosine phosphatase gene is mutated in progressive myoclonus epilepsy of the Lafora type (EPM2)

Progressive myoclonus epilepsy of the Lafora type or Lafora disease (EPM2; McKusick no. 254780) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterized by epilepsy, myoclonus, progressive neurological deterioration and glycogen-like intracellular inclusion bodies (Lafora bodies). A gene for EPM2 previously has been mapped to chromosome 6q23-q25 using linkage analysis and homozygosity mapping. Here we report the positional cloning of the 6q EPM2 gene. A microdeletion within the EPM2 critical region, present inhomozygosis in an affected individual, was found to disrupt a novel gene encoding a putative protein tyrosine phosphatase (PTPase). The gene, denoted EPM2, presents alternative splicing in the 5' and 3' end regions. Mutational analysis revealed that EPM2 patients are homozygous for loss-of-function mutations in EPM2. These findings suggest that Lafora disease results from the mutational inactivation of a PTPase activity that may be important in the control of glycogen metabolism.

Mapping and positional cloning of common idiopathic generalized epilepsies: juvenile myoclonus epilepsy and childhood absence epilepsy

Among the 40 to 100 million persons with epilepsy worldwide and the 2 to 2.5 million persons with epilepsies in the United States, approximately 50% have generalized epilepsies. Among all epilepsies, the most common are juvenile myoclonus epilepsy (JME) with 10% to 30% of cases, childhood absence epilepsy (CAE) with 5% to 15% of cases, and pure grand mal on awakening with 22% to 37% of cases. In the last decade, six different chromosomal loci for common generalized epilepsies have been identified. These include two separate loci for JME in chromosomes 6p and 15q. The epilepsy locus in chromosome 6p expresses the phenotypes of classic JME, pure grand mal on awakening, and possibly JME mixed with absences. Two separate loci also are present for pyknoleptic CAE, namely, CAE that evolves to JME in chromosome 1p and CAE with grand mal in chromosome 8q24. Pandolfo et al. from the Italian League Against Epilepsy have reported two other putative susceptibility loci for idiopathic generalized epilepsies, namely, grand mal and generalized spike waves 35l in chromosome 3p and generalized epilepsies with febrile convulsions, grand mal, JME, absences, and electroencephalographic spike waves in 8q24. This chapter reports on the debate concerning whether there may be two separate epilepsy loci in chromosome 6p, one in the HLA region and one below HLA. The chapter then discusses the progress made in our laboratories as a result of the Genetic Epilepsy Studies (GENES) International Consortium. We discuss (a) the 2 to 6 cM critical region for classic JME located some 20 cM below HLA in chromosome 6p, (b) the 7-cM area for pyknoleptic CAE that evolves to JME in chromosome 1p, and (c) the 3.2 cM area for pyknoleptic CAE with grand mal and irregular 3 to 4 Hz spike waves in chromosome 8q24. We discusses efforts underway to refine the genetic map of JME in chromosome 6p11 and the advances in physical mapping and positioning of candidate genes, such as the gamma-aminobutyric acid receptor gene, the potassium channel gene of the long-QT family (KvLQT), named KCNQ3, and the human homologue of the mouse jerky gene for CAE in chromosome 8q24 and JME in chromosome 6p11.

[Molecular genetics of epilepsy: present and future implications in clinical practice]

INTRODUCTION

Recent advances in mapping and isolating human epilepsy genes are having an increasing importance in the field of epileptology.

DEVELOPMENT AND CONCLUSIONS

As the molecular bases of the genetic epilepsies are elucidated, more precise diagnoses and therapies are possible. Characterization of the genes responsible for several types of epilepsy will allow the clinician to increase diagnostic precision, offer more exact prognoses, and develop more efficient therapies. At the same time, the search for families with several affected members with some form of epilepsy has lead to the description of previously unnoticed epilepsies and epileptic syndromes. Both the precision in diagnosis and the description of new epilepsy syndromes should be of major importance for the development of the next version of the International Classification of Epilepsies and Epileptic Syndromes. Understanding the pathogenic mechanisms involved in different epilepsies may allow the rational development of 'design' antiepileptic drugs and, in the case of the poor-prognosis progressive myoclonus epilepsies, effective gene therapy treatments. Finally, the possibility of offering prenatal diagnosis and genetic counseling to families exposed to some forms of epilepsy may reduce their incidence in the future.

Childhood absence epilepsy with tonic-clonic seizures and electroencephalogram 3-4-Hz spike and multispike-slow wave complexes: linkage to chromosome 8q24

Childhood absence epilepsy (CAE), a common form of idiopathic generalized epilepsy, accounts for 5%-15% of childhood epilepsies. To map the chromosomal locus of persisting CAE, we studied the clinical and electroencephalographic traits of 78 members of a five-generation family from Bombay, India. The model-free affected-pedigree member method was used during initial screening with chromosome 6p, 8q, and 1p microsatellites, and only individuals with absence seizures and/or electroencephalogram 3-4-Hz spike- and multispike-slow wave complexes were considered to be affected. Significant P values of .00000-.02 for several markers on 8q were obtained. Two-point linkage analysis, assuming autosomal dominant inheritance with 50% penetrance, yielded a maximum LOD score (Zmax) of 3.6 for D8S502. No other locus in the genome achieved a significant Zmax. For five smaller multiplex families, summed Zmax was 2.4 for D8S537 and 1.7 for D8S1761. Haplotypes composed of the same 8q24 microsatellites segregated with affected members of the large family from India and with all five smaller families. Recombinations positioned the CAE gene in a 3.2-cM interval.

[Genetics of the partial epilepsy]

Until recently, research in the field of genetics of the epilepsies had mainly focused on the idiopathic generalized epilepsies and the progressive myoclonic epilepsies. Interest in the genetics of the partial epilepsies has now increased due to the identification of several forms of partial epilepsies with a strong genetic component. The genetic partial epilepsies appear to be more common than expected and each description of a new syndrome is followed by reports of more patients and families. Understanding the clinical and genetic characteristics of the new familial partial epilepsy syndromes and identifying informative families will accelerate the discovery of the basic mechanisms implicated in the production of partial seizures. The recent description of the syndrome of autosomal dominant nocturnal frontal lobe epilepsy, its localization to chromosome 20, and the identification of the responsible gene and mutation in the alpha 4 subunit of the nicotinic cholinergic receptor in an Australian family are a good example. Future discoveries in the genetics of the partial epilepsies will have important diagnostic, prognostic and therapeutic implications and will allow us to apply more specific treatments for each syndrome, offer a prognosis to patients and develop novel forms of therapy.

Cortical myoclonus in Angelman syndrome

Angelman syndrome (AS) results from lack of genetic contribution from maternal chromosome 15q11-13. This region encompasses three GABAA receptor subunit genes (beta3, alpha5, and gamma3). The characteristic phenotype of AS is severe mental retardation, ataxic gait, tremulousness, and jerky movements. We studied the movement disorder in 11 AS patients, aged 3 to 28 years. Two patients had paternal uniparental disomy for chromosome 15, 8 had a >3 Mb deletion, and 1 had a microdeletion involving loci D15S10, D15S113, and GABRB3. All patients exhibited quasicontinuous rhythmic myoclonus mainly involving hands and face, accompanied by rhythmic 5- to 10-Hz electroencephalographic (EEG) activity. Electromyographic bursts lasted 35 +/- 13 msec and had a frequency of 11 +/- 2.4 Hz. Burst-locked EEG averaging in 5 patients, generated a premyoclonus transient preceding the burst by 19 +/- 5 msec. A cortical spread pattern of myoclonic cortical activity was observed. Seven patients also demonstrated myoclonic seizures. No giant somatosensory evoked potentials or C-reflex were observed. The silent period following motor evoked potentials was shortened by 70%, indicating motor cortex hyperexcitability. Treatment with piracetam in 5 patients significantly improved myoclonus. We conclude that spontaneous, rhythmic, fast-bursting cortical myoclonus is a prominent feature of AS.

Juvenile myoclonic epilepsy in chromosome 6p12-p11: locus heterogeneity and recombinations

We recently analyzed under homogeneity a large pedigree from Belize with classic juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME). After a genome wide search with 146 microsatellites, we obtained significant linkage between chromosome 6p markers, D6S257 and D6S272, and both convulsive and EEG traits of JME. Recombinations in two affected members defined a 40 cM JME region flanked by D6S313 and D6S258. In the present communication, we explored if the same chromosome 6p11 microsatellites also have a role in JME mixed with pyknoleptic absences. We allowed for heterogeneity during linkage analyses. We tested for heterogeneity by the admixture test and looked for more recombinations. D6S272, D6S466, D6S294, and D6S257 were significantly linked (Zmax > 3.5) to the clinical and EEG traits of 22 families, assuming autosomal dominant inheritance with 70% penetrance. Pairwise Zmax were 4.230 for D6S294 (theta m = f at 0.133) and 4.442 for D6S466 (theta m = f at 0.111). Admixture test (H2 vs. H1) was significant (P = 0.0234 for D6S294 and 0.0128 for D6S272) supporting the hypotheses of linkage with heterogeneity. Estimated proportion of linked families, alpha, was 0.50 (95% confidence interval 0.05-0.99) for D6S294 and D6S272. Multipoint analyses and recombinations in three new families narrowed the JME locus to a 7 cM interval flanked by D6S272 and D6S257.

Clinical and genetic analysis of a large pedigree with juvenile myoclonic epilepsy

Juvenile myoclonic epilepsy is a common type of idiopathic generalized epilepsy characterized by myoclonic, generalized tonic-clonic, and in 30% of patients, absence seizures. We studied a three-generation pedigree of 33 members, 10 of whom were clinically affected with juvenile myoclonic epilepsy or presented with subclinical electroencephalographic (EEG) 3.5- to 6.0-Hz diffuse polyspike-wave or spike-wave complexes. Juvenile myoclonic epilepsy and the EEG trait segregated as an autosomal dominant trait with 70% penetrance. Linkage analysis using this model showed significant linkage to four microsatellite markers centromeric to human leukocyte antigen (HLA) in chromosome 6p. Maximum lod scores of 3.43 at theta(m=f)=0.00 for D6S272, D6S466, D6S257, and D6S402 were obtained. Recombinant events in 2 affected members defined the gene region to a 43-cM interval flanked by D6S258 (HLA region) and D6S313 (centromere). Our results in this large family provide evidence that a gene responsible for juvenile myoclonic epilepsy and the subclinical, 3.5- to 6.0-Hz, polyspike-wave or spike-wave EEG pattern is located in chromosome 6p.

The gene for progressive myoclonus epilepsy of the Lafora type maps to chromosome 6q

Progressive myoclonus epilepsy of the Lafora type (Lafora's disease) is an autosomal recessive disease characterized by epilepsy, myoclonus, dementia, and periodic acid-Schiff-positive intracellular inclusion bodies. The inclusion deposits consist of branched polysaccharides (polyglucosans) but the responsible biochemical defect has not been identified. Onset is during late childhood or adolescence and the disease leads to a fatal outcome within a decade of first symptoms. We studied nine families in which Lafora's disease had been proven by biopsy in at least one member. In order to locate the responsible gene, we screened the human genome with microsatellite markers spaced an average of 13 cM. We used linkage analysis in all nine families and homozygosity mapping in four consanguineous families to define the Lafora's disease gene region. Two point linkage analysis resulted in a total peak lod score of 10.54 for marker D6S311. Six additional chromosome 6q23-25 microsatellites yielded lod scores ranging from 5.92 to 9.60 at theta m = f = 0. An extended pedigree with five affected members independently proved linkage with peak lod scores over 3.8 at theta m = f = 0 for D6S292, D6S403, and D6S311. The multipoint one-lod-unit support interval covered a 2.5 cM region surrounding D6S403. Homozygosity mapping defined a 17 cM region in chromosome 6q23-25 flanked by D6S292 and D6S420 that contains the Lafora's disease gene.

Juvenile myoclonic epilepsy locus in chromosome 6p21.2-p11: linkage to convulsions and electroencephalography trait

Despite affecting 4 million Americans and 100-200 million persons worldwide, the precise molecular mechanisms of human epilepsies remain unknown. Juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME) is the most frequent and, hence, most important form of hereditary grand mal epilepsy. In this epilepsy, electroencephalographic (EEG) 15-30-Hz multispikes produce myoclonic and tonic-clonic convulsions beginning at 8-20 years of age. Moreover, EEG 3.5-6-Hz multispike wave complexes appear in clinically asymptomatic family members. We first studied 38 members of a four-generation LA-Belize family with classical JME but with no pyknoleptic absences. Five living members had JME; four clinically asymptomatic members had EEG multispike wave complexes. Pairwise analysis tightly linked microsatellites centromeric to HLA, namely D6S272 (peak lod score [Zmax] = 3.564-3.560 at male-female recombination [theta m = f] = 0-.001) and D6S257 (Zmax = 3.672-3.6667 at theta m = f = 0-.001), spanning 7 cM, to convulsive seizures and EEG multispike wave complexes. A recombination between D6S276 and D6S273 in one affected member placed the JME locus within or below HLA. Pairwise, multipoint, and recombination analyses in this large family independently proved that a JME gene is located in chromosome 6p, centromeric to HLA. We next screened, with the same chromosome 6p21.2-p11 short tandem-repeat polymorphic markers, seven multiplex pedigrees with classic JME. When lod scores for small multiplex families are added to lod scores of the LA-Belize pedigree, Zmax values for D6S294 and D6S257 are > 7 (theta m = f = .000). Our results prove that in chromosome 6p21.2-p11 an epilepsy locus exists whose phenotype consists of classic JME with convulsions and/or EEG rapid multispike wave complexes.

Progress in mapping human epilepsy genes

The chromosomal loci for seven epilepsy genes have been identified in chromosomes 1q, 6p, 8q, 16p, 20q, 21q, and 22q. In 1987, the first epilepsy locus was mapped in a common benign idiopathic generalized epilepsy syndrome, juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME). Properdin factor or Bf, human leukocyte antigen (HLA), and DNA markers in the HLA-DQ region were genetically linked to JME and the locus, named EJM1, was assigned to the short arm of chromosome 6. Our latest studies, as well as those by Whitehouse et al., show that not all families with JME have their genetic locus in chromosome 6p, and that childhood absence epilepsy does not map to the same EJM1 locus. Recent results, therefore, favor genetic heterogeneity for JME and for the common idiopathic generalized epilepsies. Heterogeneity also exists in benign familial neonatal convulsions, a rare form of idiopathic generalized epilepsy. Two loci are now recognized; one in chromosome 20q (EBN1) and another in chromosome 8q. Heterogeneity also exists for the broad group of debilitating and often fatal progressive myoclonus epilepsies (PME). The gene locus (EPM1) for both the Baltic and Mediterranean types of PME or Unverricht-Lundborg disease is the same and is located in the long arm of chromosome 21. Lafora type of PME does not map to the same EPM1 locus in chromosome 21. PME can be caused by the juvenile type of Gaucher's disease, which maps to chromosome 1q, by the juvenile type of neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses (CLN3), which maps to chromosome 16p, and by the "cherry-red-spot-myoclonus" syndrome of Guazzi or sialidosis type I, which has been localized to chromosome 10. A point mutation in the mitochondrial tRNA(Lys) coding gene can also cause PME in children and adults (MERFF).