Influence of animal pain and distress on judgments of animal research justifiability among university undergraduate students and faculty

Acceptance of animal research by the public depends on several characteristics of the specific experimental study. In particular, acceptance decreases as potential animal pain or distress increases. Our objective in this study was to quantify the magnitude of pain/distress that university undergraduate students and faculty would find to be justifiable in animal research, and to see how that justifiability varied according to the purpose of the research, or the species to which the animal belonged. We also evaluate how demographic characteristics of respondents may be associated with their opinions about justifiability. To accomplish this goal, we developed and administered a survey to students and faculty at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Our survey employed Likert-style questions that asked them to designate the level of animal pain or distress that they felt was justifiable for each of the following six purposes—animal disease, human disease, basic research, human medicine, chemical testing, or cosmetic testing. These questions were asked about five different species of animals including monkeys, dogs/cats, pig/sheep, rats/mice, or small fish. We used the data to establish a purpose-specific pain/distress scale, a species-specific pain/distress scale, and a composite pain/distress scale that, for each respondent, averaged the extent of justifiable pain/distress across all purposes and species. For purpose, students were more likely to choose higher levels of pain for animal disease research, followed by human disease, basic research, human medicine, chemical testing, and cosmetic testing. Faculty were more likely to choose the same level of pain for the first four purposes, followed by lower levels of pain for chemical and cosmetic testing. For species, students were more likely to choose higher levels of pain for small fish and rats/mice (tied), pigs/sheep and monkeys (tied), than for dogs/cats. For faculty, order from least to most justifiable pain/distress was small fish, rats/mice, pigs/sheep, then dogs/cats and monkeys (the latter two tied). Interestingly, exploratory factor analysis of the pain/distress scales indicated that when it comes to justifying higher levels of pain and distress, respondents identified two distinct categories of purposes, chemical and cosmetic testing, for which respondents were less likely to justify higher levels of pain or distress as compared to other purposes; and two distinct categories of species, small fish and rats/mice, for which respondents were more likely to justify higher levels of pain/distress than other species. We found that the spread of acceptance of animal research was much smaller when survey questions included pain/distress compared to when only purpose or species were part of the question. Demographically, women, vegetarians/vegans, and respondents with no experience in animal research justified less animal pain/distress than their counterparts. Not surprisingly, a lower level of support for animal research in general was correlated with lower justifiability of pain/distress. Based on these findings, we discuss the role of animal pain/distress in regulatory considerations underlying decisions about whether to approve specific animal uses, and suggest ways to strengthen the ethical review and public acceptance of animal research.

Towards a reconsideration of the use of agree-disagree questions in measuring subjective evaluations

Agree-disagree (AD) or Likert questions (e.g., "I am extremely satisfied: strongly agree … strongly disagree") are among the most frequently used response formats to measure attitudes and opinions in the social and medical sciences. This review and research synthesis focuses on the measurement properties and potential limitations of AD questions. The research leads us to advocate for an alternative questioning strategy in which items are written to directly ask about their underlying response dimensions using response categories tailored to match the response dimension, which we refer to as item-specific (IS) (e.g., "How satisfied are you: not at all … extremely"). In this review we: 1) synthesize past research comparing data quality for AD and IS questions; 2) present conceptual models of and review research supporting respondents' cognitive processing of AD and IS questions; and 3) provide an overview of question characteristics that frequently differ between AD and IS questions and may affect respondents' cognitive processing and data quality. Although experimental studies directly comparing AD and IS questions yield some mixed results, more studies find IS questions are associated with desirable data quality outcomes (e.g., validity and reliability) and AD questions are associated with undesirable outcomes (e.g., acquiescence, response effects, etc.). Based on available research, models of cognitive processing, and a review of question characteristics, we recommended IS questions over AD questions for most purposes. For researchers considering the use of previously administered AD questions and instruments, issues surrounding the challenges of translating questions from AD to IS response formats are discussed.

Patient perceptions, opinions and satisfaction of telehealth with remote blood pressure monitoring postpartum

Background

Our aim was to conduct a post participation survey of respondent experiences with in-home remote patient monitoring via telehealth for blood pressure monitoring of women with postpartum hypertension. We hypothesized that the in-home remote patient monitoring application will be implemented with strong fidelity and have positive patient acceptability.

Methods

This analysis was a planned secondary analysis of a non-randomized controlled trial of telehealth with remote blood pressure patient monitoring for postpartum hypertension compared to standard outpatient monitoring in women with a hypertension-related diagnosis during pregnancy. In collaboration with survey experts, we developed a 41-item web-based survey to assess 1) perception of quality of care received, 2) ease of use/ease to learn the telehealth program, 3) effective orientation of equipment, 4) level of perceived security/privacy utilizing telehealth and 5) problems encountered. The survey included multiple question formats including Likert scale responses, dichotomous Yes/No responses, and free text. We performed a descriptive analysis on all responses and then performed regression analysis on a subset of questions most relevant to the domains of interest. The qualitative data collected through open ended responses was analyzed to determine relevant categories. Intervention participants who completed the study received the survey at the 6-week study endpoint.

Results

Sixty six percent of respondents completed the survey. The majority of women found the technology fit easily into their lifestyle. Privacy concerns were minimal and factors that influenced this included age, BMI, marital status, and readmissions. 95% of women preferred remote care for postpartum follow-up, in which hypertensive type, medication use and ethnicity were found to be significant factors in influencing location of follow-up. Most women were satisfied with the devices, but rates varied by hypertensive type, infant discharge rates and BMI.

Conclusions

Postpartum women perceived the telehealth remote intervention was a safe, easy to use method that represented an acceptable burden of care and an overall satisfying method for postpartum blood pressure monitoring.

Trial registration

ClinicalTrials.gov identification number: NCT03111095 Date of registration: April 12, 2017.

Effects of Sequential Prepaid Incentives on Response Rates, Data Quality, Sample Representativeness, and Costs in a Mail Survey of Physicians

While collecting high quality data from physicians is critical, response rates for physician surveys are frequently low. A proven method for increasing response in mail surveys is to provide a small, prepaid monetary incentive in the initial mailing. More recently, researchers have begun experimenting with adding a second cash incentive in a follow-up contact in order to increase participation among more reluctant respondents. To assess the effects of sequential incentives on response rates, data quality, sample representativeness, and costs, physicians (N = 1,500) were randomly assigned to treatments that crossed the amount of a first ($5 or $10) and second ($0, $5, or $10) incentive to form the following groups: Group $5/$5; Group $5/$10; Group $10/$0; Group $10/$5; and Group $10/$10. Overall, second incentives were associated with higher response rates and lower costs per completed survey, and while they had no effect on item nonresponse, they increased sample representativeness.

Assessing undergraduate student and faculty views on animal research: What do they know, whom do they trust, and how much do they care?

Research using animals is controversial. To develop sound public outreach and policy about this issue, we need information about both the underlying science and people’s attitudes and knowledge. To identify attitudes toward this subject at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, we developed and administered a survey to undergraduate students and faculty. The survey asked respondents about the importance of, their confidence in their knowledge about, and who they trusted to provide information on animal research. Findings indicated attitudes varied by academic discipline, especially among faculty. Faculty in the biological sciences, particularly those who had participated in an animal research project, reported the issue to be most important, and they reported greater confidence in their knowledge about pro and con arguments. Among students, being female, a vegetarian/vegan, or participating in animal research were associated with higher ratings of importance. Confidence in knowledge about regulation and its adequacy was very low across all groups except biological science faculty. Both students and faculty identified university courses and spokespersons to be the most trusted sources of information about animal research. UW-Madison has a long history of openness about animal research, which correlates with the high level of trust by students and faculty. Nevertheless, confidence in knowledge about animal research and its regulation remains limited, and both students and faculty indicated their desire to receive more information from courses and spokespersons. Based on these findings, we argue that providing robust university-wide outreach and course-based content about animal research should be considered an organizational best practice, in particular for colleges and universities.

[Insulin resistance and alteration of cardiac vagal activity in obese patients]

We have previously shown that alterations of vagal control of heart rate variations are found in more than half of non diabetic obese subjects (Int J Obes 1995) and are associated with a more severe insulin resistance in noninsulin dependent diabetic patients (Metabolism 1998). The aim of this study was to examine whether parasympathetic alterations are also associated with a more severe insulin resistance in non diabetic obese subjects. 245 obese subjects (BMI = 34.2 +/- 0.4 kg/m2) aged 38.6 +/- 0.8 years, with a normal oral glucose tolerance test were included. Parasympathetic activity was evaluated by heart rate variations during three standardised tests: Valsalva, deep-breathing and active lying-to-standing, with age being taken into account. The Valsalva maneuver was abnormal in 17.5%, the deep-breathing test in 18% and the lying-to-standing test in 30.3% of the cases. One hundred and thirty subjects (52.1%) had at least one abnormal test. Compared with those with three normal tests, the obese subjects with parasympathetic alterations had very similar BMI and blood pressure, but significantly higher values of heart rate (75.5 +/- 1.4 vs 71.3 +/- 1.1 beats/min, p = 0.02), fasting blood glucose (5.0 +/- 0.1 vs 4.8 +/- 0.1 mmol/L, p = 0.03) and plasma insulin (98 +/- 6 vs 82 +/- 4 pmol/L, p = 0.03). In the whole series of obese subjects, heart rate variations during the deep-breathing and lying-to-standing tests correlated negatively with blood glucose (p = 0.001 and p = 0.03 respectively), and during the deep-breathing test they correlated negatively with the waist/hip ratio (p = 0.004). This data suggests that cardiac parasympathetic alterations should take part in the insulin-resistance syndrome and might account for the poor cardiovascular prognosis linked to this syndrome.

Angiotensinase A gene expression and enzyme activity in isolated glomeruli of diabetic rats

One of the characteristics of early diabetic nephropathy is glomerular hyperfiltration and hyperperfusion. Many factors have been suggested to induce glomerular hyperperfusion among which are an increased production of vasodilatory prostanoids, an increased synthesis of nitric oxide, a reduced responsiveness of afferent glomerular arterioles to vasoconstrictor stimuli due to diabetic metabolic disturbances and a decreased receptor density for angiotensin II. It has been known for years that angiotensin II is formed locally due to the local activation of the renin angiotensin system. The local angiotensin II concentration, however, is not only regulated by the synthesis rate but also by the local degradation through activation of an aminopeptidase. The main finding of the present study was that the mRNA expression and activity of the angiotensin II degrading enzyme, angiotensinase A, was increased twofold in diabetic rats at 5 weeks and that the increase in mRNA expression was suppressed by insulin therapy and short-term treatment with the angiotensin II antagonist saralasin, whereas angiotensinase A enzyme activity was only reduced by saralasin and not by insulin. These results demonstrate that the angiotensin II degrading exopeptidase angiotensinase A is activated in diabetic glomeruli. This increased activity may be an additional mechanism to explain glomerular hyperfiltration and hyperperfusion in early diabetic nephropathy.

Expression of one of the members of the Arabidopsis chaperonin 60 beta gene family is developmentally regulated and wound-repressible

To study the pattern of gene regulation of the plastid chaperonin 60 beta gene family a chimaeric gene was constructed fusing the 5'-flanking region of the chaperonin 60 beta B3 gene to the beta-glucuronidase reporter gene. Histochemical and fluorometric analysis of the GUS activity present in transgenic plants harbouring this gene construct showed that the B3 promoter is expressed in leaves, stem, petioles and several flower tissues. The pattern of cell type-specific expression in stems and flowers was found to be developmentally regulated. Expression of the B3 promoter was found not to be heat-inducible, but highly repressed by wounding. The rapid decay in GUS activity upon wounding indicates that, at least under some physiological conditions, the gene product of this reporter gene is not as stable as has been previously thought.

[Comparison of isobaric effects of hypertension and diabetes mellitus on geometric and elastic properties of human arteries]

Hypertensive and diabetic mellitus diseases are known to increase stiffness of the arterial wall. However these alterations probably involve different mechanisms. To this end, we compared the effect of hypertension and diabetes on large artery caliber and elasticity at real pressure conditions and at the same level of pressure. Nine poorly controlled non insulino-dependent diabetic men without hypertension and 9 non-diabetic essential hypertensive men underwent measures of lumen diameter (pulsed Doppler) and segmental compliance (Bramwell and Hill formula; pulse wave velocity) at the brachial artery. Isobaric diameter and compliance were deduced from a non linear model, comparing diameter and pressure on one part, and compliance and pressure on the other. Pulse wave velocity was similarly increased in both diseases (11.5 +/- 1 vs 12.8 +/- 1 m/s; NS; respectively in diabetes and hypertension). Both measured and isobaric diameters were smaller in diabetic patients (4.05 +/- 0.2 vs 5.03 +/- 0.2 mm, p less than 0.1% for the measured diameters respectively in diabetes and hypertension and 4.06 +/- 0.2 vs 5.01 +/- 0.2 mm, p less than 1% for isobaric diameters). The measured and isobaric compliances were not significantly different (2.38 +/- 0.4 vs 2.08 +/- 0.2 cm/mmHg10(-4), NS, for the measured compliance respectively in diabetes and hypertension; 2.28 +/- 0.4 vs 2.4 +/- 0.2, NS for the isobaric compliance). After correction of the effect of mechanical arterial stretch induced by the different blood pressure level of the two groups, significant reduction of diameter in diabetic subjects persisted and isobaric and measured compliances remained unchanged between groups.

[Beliefs in diabetics about the etiology of their disease. Influence of ethnicity]

The education of diabetics often affects the patient's life-style and habits, and the beliefs of his socio-professional and socio-cultural environment. The patient's knowledge is often satisfactory, while his behavior is inadequate. In this study, a sociologist conducted a semi-structured interview for 40 non-obese diabetic patients: 35 IDD and 5 NIDD, who had a knowledge/behavior gap. Emphasis was placed on the study of their subjective etiological beliefs. Four categories beliefs were found: stress, heredity, food and drink transgression, and fatality. Stress, which can lead to deresponsabilization, was the most frequently mentioned etiology (24 patients). Europeans cited several etiological beliefs. North-Africans, in contrast, cited only one, either stress or fatality, but never heredity or food and drink transgression, probably because genetics and genealogy are not superimposable realities and because of their belief in the symbolic benefits of sugar. In conclusion, the patient's etiological beliefs may contribute to the knowledge/behavior gap. Correct information about a more rational etiology for diabetes could improve patient compliance.

Serological survey of toxoplasmosis in the northern part of Iran, using indirect fluorescent antibody technique

A total of 1,779 persons from the Caspian Sea area, Iran, were serologically examined by the indirect fluorescent antibody technique for Toxoplasma antibodies. 55.7% were positive with titres of 1:20 or higher. No significant difference was demonstrated between the sexes. The highest antibody level as well as a high geometric mean of reciprocal titres were observed in the population between the ages of two and 19 years.