Cost-effectiveness of IVF with PGT-M/A to prevent transmission of spinal muscular atrophy in offspring of carrier couples

PURPOSE

To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of in-vitro fertilization with preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy and monogenic disorders (IVF with PGT-M/A) to prevent transmission of spinal muscular atrophy to offspring of carrier couples.

METHODS

A decision-analytic model was created to compare the cost-effectiveness of IVF with PGT-M/A to unassisted conception with prenatal diagnostic testing and termination (if applicable). IVF with PGT-M/A costs were determined using a separate Markov state-transition model. IVF outcomes data was derived from 76 carriers of monogenic disorders who underwent IVF with PGT-M/A at a single academic REI center. Other probabilities, costs, and utilities were derived from the literature. Costs were modeled from healthcare perspective. Utilities were modeled from the parental perspective as quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs).

RESULTS

The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for IVF with PGT-M/A compared to unassisted conception is $22,050 per quality-adjusted life-year. The average cost of IVF with PGT-M/A is $41,002 (SD: $8,355). At willingness-to-pay thresholds of $50,000 and $100,000, IVF with PGT-M/A is cost-effective 93.3% and 99.5% of the time, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to unassisted conception, IVF with PGT-M/A is cost-effective for preventing the transmission of spinal muscular atrophy to the offspring of carrier couples. These findings support insurance coverage of IVF with PGT-M/A for carriers of spinal muscular atrophy.

Drugs, genes and screens: The ethics of preventing and treating spinal muscular atrophy

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is the most common genetic disease that causes infant mortality. Its treatment and prevention represent the paradigmatic example of the ethical dilemmas of 21st-century medicine. New therapies (nusinersen and AVXS-101) hold the promise of being able to treat, but not cure, the condition. Alternatively, genomic analysis could identify carriers, and carriers could be offered in vitro fertilization and preimplantation genetic diagnosis. In the future, gene editing could prevent the condition at the embryonic stage. How should these different options be evaluated and compared within a health system? In this paper, we discuss the ethical considerations that bear on the question of how to prioritize the different treatments and preventive options for SMA, at a policy level. We argue that despite the tremendous value of what we call 'ex-post' approaches to treating SMA (such as using pharmacological agents or gene therapy), there is a moral imperative to pursue 'ex-ante' interventions (such as carrier screening in combination with prenatal testing and preimplantation genetic diagnosis, or gene editing) to reduce the incidence of SMA. There are moral reasons relating to autonomy, beneficence and justice to prioritize ex-ante methods over ex-post methods.

The Protective Effects of Levetiracetam on a Human iPSCs-Derived Spinal Muscular Atrophy Model

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is an inherited disease characterized by progressive motor neuron death and subsequent muscle weakness and is caused by deletion or mutation of survival motor neuron (SMN) 1 gene. Protecting spinal motor neuron is an effective clinical strategy for SMA. The purpose of this study was to investigate the potential effect of an anti-epileptic drug levetiracetam on SMA. In the present study, we used differentiated spinal motor neurons (MNs) from SMA patient-derived induced pluripotent stem cells (SMA-iPSCs) to investigate the effect of levetiracetam. Levetiracetam promoted neurite elongation in SMA-iPSCs-MNs. TUNEL-positive spinal motor neurons were significantly reduced by levetiracetam in SMA-iPSCs-MNs. In addition, the expression level of cleaved-caspase 3 was decreased by levetiracetam in SMA-iPSCs-MNs. Furthermore, levetiracetam improved impaired mitochondrial function in SMA-iPSCs-MNs. On the other hand, levetiracetam did not affect the expression level of SMN protein in SMA-iPSCs-MNs. These findings indicate that levetiracetam has a neuroprotective effect for SMA.

Denervation-activated STAT3-IL-6 signalling in fibro-adipogenic progenitors promotes myofibres atrophy and fibrosis

Fibro-adipogenic progenitors (FAPs) are typically activated in response to muscle injury, and establish functional interactions with inflammatory and muscle stem cells (MuSCs) to promote muscle repair. We found that denervation causes progressive accumulation of FAPs, without concomitant infiltration of macrophages and MuSC-mediated regeneration. Denervation-activated FAPs exhibited persistent STAT3 activation and secreted elevated levels of IL-6, which promoted muscle atrophy and fibrosis. FAPs with aberrant activation of STAT3-IL-6 signalling were also found in mouse models of spinal cord injury, spinal muscular atrophy, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and in muscles of ALS patients. Inactivation of STAT3-IL-6 signalling in FAPs effectively countered muscle atrophy and fibrosis in mouse models of acute denervation and ALS (SODG93A mice). Activation of pathogenic FAPs following loss of integrity of neuromuscular junctions further illustrates the functional versatility of FAPs in response to homeostatic perturbations and suggests their potential contribution to the pathogenesis of neuromuscular diseases.

Deliberative Discussion Focus Groups

This article discusses a new approach for the conduct of focus groups in health research. Identifying ways to educate and inform participants about the topic of interest prior to the focus group discussion can promote more quality data from informed opinions. Data on this deliberative discussion approach are provided from research within three federally funded studies. As healthcare continues to improve from scientific and technological advancements, educating the research participants prior to data collection about these complexities is essential to gather quality data.

Protective effects of butyrate-based compounds on a mouse model for spinal muscular atrophy

Proximal spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a childhood-onset degenerative disease resulting from the selective loss of motor neurons in the spinal cord. SMA is caused by the loss of SMN1 (survival motor neuron 1) but retention of SMN2. The number of copies of SMN2 modifies disease severity in SMA patients as well as in mouse models, making SMN2 a target for therapeutics development. Sodium butyrate (BA) and its analog (4PBA) have been shown to increase SMN2 expression in SMA cultured cells. In this study, we examined the effects of BA, 4PBA as well as two BA prodrugs-glyceryl tributyrate (BA3G) and VX563-on the phenotype of SMNΔ7 SMA mice. Treatment with 4PBA, BA3G and VX563 but not BA beginning at PND04 significantly improved the lifespan and delayed disease end stage, with administration of VX563 also improving the growth rate of these mice. 4PBA and VX563 improved the motor phenotype of SMNΔ7 SMA mice and prevented spinal motor neuron loss. Interestingly, neither 4PBA nor VX563 had an effect on SMN expression in the spinal cords of treated SMNΔ7 SMA mice; however, they inhibited histone deacetylase (HDAC) activity and restored the normal phosphorylation states of Akt and glycogen synthase kinase 3β, both of which are altered by SMN deficiency in vivo. These observations show that BA-based compounds with favorable pharmacokinetics ameliorate SMA pathology possibly by modulating HDAC and Akt signaling.

Modulation of inflammation by vitamin E and C supplementation prior to anterior cruciate ligament surgery

Muscle atrophy commonly follows anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury and surgery. Proinflammatory cytokines can induce and exacerbate oxidative stress, potentiating muscle atrophy. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the influence of prior antioxidant (AO) supplementation on circulating cytokines following ACL surgery. A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial was conducted in men undergoing ACL surgery, who were randomly assigned to either: (1) AO (200 IU of vitamin E (50% d-alpha-tocopheryl acetate and 50% d-alpha-tocopherol) and 500 mg ascorbic acid), or (2) matching placebos (PL). Subjects took supplements twice daily for 2 weeks prior to and up to 12 weeks after surgery. Each subject provided five blood samples: (1) baseline (Bsl, prior to supplementation and approximately 2 weeks prior to surgery), (2) presurgery (Pre), (3) 90 min, (4) 72 h, and (5) 7 days postsurgery. Following surgery, inflammation and muscle damage increased in both groups, as assessed by increased circulating IL-6, C-reactive protein, and creatine kinase. During AO supplementation, plasma alpha-T and AA increased while gamma-T concentrations decreased significantly (P< 0.05). At 90 min the AO group displayed a significant decrease in AA, an inverse correlation between AA and (interleukin) IL-8 (r(2)= 0.50, P< 0.05), and a significantly lower IL-10 response than that of the PL group. IL-10 was significantly elevated at 90 min and 72 h in the PL group. In summary, our findings show that circulating inflammatory cytokines increase and AO supplementation attenuated the increase in IL-10 in patients post-ACL surgery.

Mildly affected patients with spinal muscular atrophy are partially protected by an increased SMN2 copy number

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a recessive neuromuscular disorder caused by loss of the SMN1 gene. The clinical distinction between SMA type I to IV reflects different age of onset and disease severity. SMN2, a nearly identical copy gene of SMN1, produces only 10% of full-length SMN RNA/protein and is an excellent target for a potential therapy. Several clinical trials with drugs that increase the SMN2 expression such as valproic acid and phenylbutyrate are in progress. Solid natural history data for SMA are crucial to enable a correlation between genotype and phenotype as well as the outcome of therapy. We provide genotypic and phenotypic data from 115 SMA patients with type IIIa (age of onset <3 years), type IIIb (age of onset >3 years) and rare type IV (onset >30 years). While 62% of type IIIa patients carry two or three SMN2 copies, 65% of type IIIb patients carry four or five SMN2 copies. Three type IV SMA patients had four and one had six SMN2 copies. Our data support the disease-modifying role of SMN2 leading to later onset and a better prognosis. A statistically significant correlation for > or =4 SMN2 copies with SMA type IIIb or a milder phenotype suggests that SMN2 copy number can be used as a clinical prognostic indicator in SMA patients. The additional case of a foetus with homozygous SMN1 deletion and postnatal measurement of five SMN2 copies illustrates the role of genotypic information in making informed decisions on the management and therapy of such patients.

Should gamete donors be tested for spinal muscular atrophy?

OBJECTIVE

To report two cases of spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) after artificial insemination and to discuss why genetic screening of the disease may be justified in gamete donors.

DESIGN

Case report.

SETTING

Academic departments of genetics and obstetrics.

PATIENT(S)

A 32-year-old woman with two successive assisted pregnancies.

INTERVENTION(S)

Molecular studies of the SMN1 (survival motor neuron), the determining gene of the disease. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S); Prenatal testing to detect a homozygous deletion of the SMN1 gene; carrier diagnosis by quantitative analysis to detect a single or double dose of exon 7 in the SMN1 gene.

RESULT(S)

After a first assisted pregnancy, an SMA child with a homozygous deletion of the SMN1 gene was born. In the second assisted pregnancy, using sperm from a different donor, a fetus with a homozygous deletion of SMN1 was detected. Carrier status in the donor was confirmed by a single dose of SMN1 in the quantitative analysis.

CONCLUSION(S)

Genetic screening of SMA carrier status by quantitative analysis of the SMN1 gene should be performed in gamete donors when the recipient is a known carrier. Cost-benefit analysis should be made to consider the inclusion of the test in prospective gamete donor programs.

[Genetic diagnosis of IVF embryos: preliminary results from 'preimplantation genetic diagnoses' in the Netherlands]

Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) is a very early form of genetic testing. It involves testing one or two cells taken from a recent embryo of eight cells produced by in vitro fertilization, and selective transfer of genetically normal embryos. So far in the Academic Hospital Maastricht, the Netherlands, 20 couples have undergone PGD, resulting in 6 ongoing pregnancies (one twin pregnancy). In three women the indications for PGD were: cystic fibrosis, sex-linked Pelizaeus-Merzbacher disease and chromosomal translocation, respectively. In the Netherlands PGD is only allowed if there is a high risk of a serious genetic disease. PGD can be carried out in Maastricht for: cystic fibrosis, sex-linked diseases, chromosomal abnormalities, fragile X syndrome, spinal muscular atrophy and myotonic dystrophy. The advantage of PGD is that it excludes the necessity of a therapeutic abortion. Disadvantages ages are the requirement of in vitro fertilization, which has only a 15-20% pregnancy rate, and the experimental nature of the PGD procedure. To date, about 200 children have been born worldwide following PGD.