Healthcare Resource Utilization and Cost Associated with Allogeneic Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation: A Scoping Review

This scoping review summarizes the evidence regarding healthcare resource utilization (HRU) and costs associated with allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (allo-HSCT). This study was conducted in accordance with the Joanne Briggs Institute methodology for scoping reviews. The PubMed, Embase, and Health Business Elite Electronic databases were searched, in addition to grey literature. The databases were searched from inception up to November 2022. Studies that reported HRU and/or costs associated with adult (≥18 years) allo-HSCT were eligible for inclusion. Two reviewers independently screened 20% of the sample at each of the 2 stages of screening (abstract and full text). Details of the HRU and costs extracted from the study data were summarized, based on the elements and timeframes reported. HRU measures and costs were combined across studies reporting results defined in a comparable manner. Monetary values were standardized to 2022 US Dollars (USD). We identified 43 studies that reported HRU, costs, or both for allo-HSCT. Of these studies, 93.0% reported on costs, 81.4% reported on HRU, and 74.4% reported on both. HRU measures and cost calculations, including the timeframe for which they were reported, were heterogeneous across the studies. Length of hospital stay was the most frequently reported HRU measure (76.7% of studies) and ranged from a median initial hospitalization of 10 days (reduced-intensity conditioning [RIC]) to 73 days (myeloablative conditioning). The total cost of an allo-HSCT ranged from $63,096 (RIC) to $782,190 (double umbilical cord blood transplantation) at 100 days and from $69,218 (RIC) to $637,193 at 1 year (not stratified). There is heterogeneity in the reporting of HRU and costs associated with allo-HSCT in the literature, making it difficult for clinicians, policymakers, and governments to draw definitive conclusions regarding the resources required for the delivery of these services. Nevertheless, to ensure that access to healthcare meets the necessary high cost and resource demands of allo-HSCT, it is imperative for clinicians, policymakers, and government officials to be aware of both the short- and long-term health resource requirements for this patient population. Further research is needed to understand the key determinants of HRU and costs associated with allo-HSCT to better inform the design and delivery of health care for HSCT recipients and ensure the quality, safety, and efficiency of care.

Estimating the Lifetime Medical Cost Burden of an Allogeneic Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation Patient

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (allo-HCT) has the potential for curative outcomes for a variety of hematologic malignancies. Current allo-HCT studies often describe the outcomes and costs in the near term; however, research on the lifetime economic burden post-allo-HCT remains limited. This study was conducted to estimate the average total lifetime direct medical costs of an allo-HCT patient and the potential net monetary savings from an alternative treatment associated with improved graft-versus-host disease (GVHD)-free, relapse-free survival (GRFS). A disease-state model was constructed using a short-term decision tree and a long-term semi-Markov partitioned survival model to estimate the average per-patient lifetime cost and expected quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) for an allo-HCT patient from a US healthcare system perspective. Key clinical inputs included overall survival, GRFS, incidence of both acute and chronic GVHD, relapse of the primary disease, and infections. Cost results were reported as ranges based on varying the percentage of chronic GVHD patients that remained on treatment after 2 years (15% or 39%). Over a lifetime, the average per-patient medical cost of allo-HCT was estimated to range from $942,373 to $1,247,917. The majority of the costs were for chronic GVHD treatment (37% to 53%), followed by the allo-HCT procedure (15% to 19%). The expected lifetime QALYs of an allo-HCT patient were estimated as 4.7. Lifetime per-patient treatment costs often exceed $1,000,000 for allo-HCT patients. Innovative research efforts focused on the reduction or elimination of late complications, particularly chronic GVHD, may provide the greatest value to improved patient outcomes.

Increasing access to allotransplants in the United States: the impact of race, geography, and socioeconomics

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) is particularly susceptible to racial, socioeconomic, and geographic disparities in access and outcomes given its specialized nature and its availability in select centers in the United States. Nearly all patients who need HCT have a potential donor in the current era, but racial minority populations are less likely to have an optimal donor and often rely on alternative donor sources. Furthermore, prevalent health care disparity factors are further accentuated and can be barriers to access and referral to a transplant center. Research has primarily focused on defining and quantifying a variety of social determinants of health and their association with access to allogeneic HCT, with a focus on race/ethnicity and socioeconomic status. However, research on interventions is lacking and is an urgent unmet need. We discuss the role of racial, socioeconomic, and geographic disparities in access to allogeneic HCT, along with policy changes to address and mitigate them and opportunities for future research.

Increasing access to allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplant: an international perspective

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (allo-HCT) is a highly complex, costly procedure for patients with oncologic, hematologic, genetic, and immunologic diseases. Demographics and socioeconomic status as well as donor availability and type of health care system are important factors that influence access to and outcomes following allo-HCT. The last decade has seen an increase in the numbers of allo-HCTs and teams all over the world, with no signs of saturation. More than 80 000 procedures are being performed annually, with 1 million allo-HCTs estimated to take place by the end of 2024. Many factors have contributed to this, including increased numbers of eligible patients (older adults with or without comorbidities) and available donors (unrelated and haploidentical), improved supportive care, and decreased early and late post-HCT mortalities. This increase is also directly linked to macro- and microeconomic indicators that affect health care both regionally and globally. Despite this global increase in the number of allo-HCTs and transplant centers, there is an enormous need for increased access to and improved outcomes following allo-HCT in resource-constrained countries. The reduction of poverty, global economic changes, greater access to information, exchange of technologies, and use of artificial intelligence, mobile health, and telehealth are certainly creating unprecedented opportunities to establish collaborations and share experiences and thus increase patient access to allo-HCT. A specific research agenda to address issues of allo-HCT in resource-constrained settings is urgently warranted.

Are Allogeneic Transfusions Decreasing in Total Knee Arthroplasty Patients? National Inpatient Sample 2009-2013

BACKGROUND

Allogeneic transfusions are commonly used for substantial blood loss in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), but have been associated with adverse effects and increased costs. The purpose of this study is to provide a detailed description of (1) trends of allogeneic blood transfusion; (2) risk factors and adverse events; and (3) discharge disposition, length-of-stay (LOS), and cost/charge analysis for primary TKA patients who received an allogeneic blood transfusion from 2009-2013.

METHODS

A cohort of 3,217,056 primary TKA patients was identified from the National Inpatient Sample database from 2009-2013. Demographic, clinical, economic, and discharge data were analyzed for patients who received allogeneic blood products, and for those who did not receive any type of blood transfusion. Other parameters analyzed include risk factors, adverse events, discharge disposition, and costs/charges.

RESULTS

There was a significant decline in use of allogeneic transfusion from 2009-2013 incidence (13.9%-7.3%; P < .001). All comorbidities examined were associated with significantly increased risk of receiving allogeneic transfusion with exception of patients with AIDS, metastatic cancer, and peptic ulcer disease. Allogeneic transfusion was associated with worse outcomes during hospitalization. Patients also had a greater likelihood of discharge to short-term care, greater LOS, and greater median costs/charges. Among TKA patients who received an allogeneic transfusion, costs varied based on hospital ownership and characteristics, primary-payer, region, and bed-size.

CONCLUSION

Given the poor outcomes and higher costs associated with allogeneic transfusions, efforts must be undertaken to minimize this risky practice. With the projected increase in demand for TKAs, orthopedists must understand effective blood management strategies.

Cost structure and clinical outcome of a stem cell transplantation program in a developing country: the experience in northeast Mexico

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) in developing countries is cost-limited. Our primary goal was to determine the cost structure for the HSCT program model developed over the last decade at our public university hospital and to assess its clinical outcomes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Adults and children receiving an allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplant from January 2010 to February 2011 at our hematology regional reference center were included. Laboratory tests, medical procedures, chemotherapy drugs, other drugs, and hospitalization costs were scrutinized to calculate the total cost for each patient and the median cost for the procedure. Data regarding clinical evolution were incorporated into the analysis. Physician fees are not charged at the institution and therefore were not included.

RESULTS

Fifty patients were evaluated over a 1-year period. The total estimated cost for an allogeneic HSCT was $12,504. The two most expensive diseases to allograft were non-Hodgkin lymphoma ($11,760 ± $2,236) for the malignant group and thalassemia ($12,915 ± $5,170) for the nonmalignant group. Acute lymphoblastic leukemia ($11,053 ± 2,817) and acute myeloblastic leukemia ($10,251 ± $1,538) were the most frequent indications for HSCT, with 11 cases each. Median out-of-pocket expenses were $1,605, and 1-year follow-up costs amounted to $1,640, adding up to a total cost of $15,749 for the first year. The most expensive components were drugs and laboratory tests.

CONCLUSION

Applying the cost structure described, HSCT is an affordable option for hematological patients living in a developing country.

[STATE OF DEVELOPMENT OF HEMATOPOIETIC STEM CELL TRANSPLANTATION IN THE EUROPE AND WORLD]

In this review, we summarize information about the current trends in hematopoietic stem cells transplantation (HSCT) in Europe and world. HSCT has represented one of the most innovative and highly expensive method of treatment for a set of malignant and non-malignant disorders. Differences in the number of HSCT and transplant rates (number of HSCT per 10 million inhabitants), indications and types of transplantations between countries have been reported. They were attributed mainly to differences in the economic situation of the countries and differences in prevalence of certain types of diseases. The gross national income per capita, health care expenditures per capita, number of transplant teams per 1 million inhabitants and team experience are the main impact factors influencing on transplant activity. These data provide a basis for health care planning, preparation of normative acts and future research in Ukraine for rapid expansion HSCT

Costs of allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation using reduced intensity conditioning regimens

Reduced intensity conditioning (RIC) regimens have allowed older patients and those with comorbidities to receive hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). We analyzed medical costs from the beginning of conditioning to 100 days after HCT for 484 patients and up to 2 years for 311 patients who underwent a RIC HCT at two institutions from January 2008 to December 2010. Multiple linear regression was used to analyze the association between clinical variables, center effect, and costs. Patient and transplant characteristics were comparable between the sites, although differences were seen in pretransplant performance scores. Significant predictors for lower costs for the first 100 days included a diagnosis of lymphoma/myeloma and use of human leukocyte antigen-matched related donors. Grade II-IV acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) was associated with higher costs. The overall short-term costs between the two institutions were comparable when adjusted for clinical variables (p = .43). Late costs between 100 days and 2 years after HCT were available for one cohort (n = 311); median costs during this period were $39,000 and accounted for 39% of costs during the first 2 years. Late costs were not associated with any pretransplant variables, but were higher with extensive chronic GVHD and death. After adjustment for clinical characteristics, the overall costs of the RIC transplants were similar between the two institutions despite different management approaches (inpatient vs. outpatient conditioning) and accounting methodologies. Use of unrelated/alternative donors, transplant for diseases other than lymphoma or myeloma, and acute GVHD were predictors for higher early costs, and extensive chronic GVHD and death were associated with higher late costs.

Early allograft dysfunction is associated with excess resource utilization after liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

There are limited data on length of stay (LOS) following liver transplantation (LT), yet this is an important health services metric that directly correlates with early post-LT health care costs. The primary objective of this study was to examine the relationship between early allograft dysfunction (EAD) and LOS after LT. The secondary objective was to identify additional recipient, donor, and operative factors associated with LOS.

METHODS

Adult patients undergoing primary LT over a 32-month period were prospectively examined at a single center. Subjects fulfilling standard criteria for EAD were compared with those not meeting the definition. Variables associated with increased LOS on ordinal logistic regression were identified.

RESULTS

Subjects with EAD had longer mean hospital LOS than those without (42.5 ± 38.9 days vs 27.4 ± 31 days; P = .003). Subjects with EAD also had longer mean intensive care LOS (8.61 ± 10.28 days vs 5.45 ± 11.6 days; P = .048). Additional factors significantly associated with LOS included Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) score, recipient location before LT, and postoperative surgical complications.

CONCLUSIONS

EAD is associated with longer hospitalization after LT. MELD score, preoperative recipient location, and postoperative complications were significantly associated with LOS. From a cost-containment perspective, these findings have implications on resource allocation.

The economic impact of addressing the organ shortage with clinically high-risk allografts

Expanding gaps between the number of patients awaiting transplantation and the number who receive organs in the United States has been associated with heightened disease severity among transplant candidates and more common use of organs from non-standard donors. We summarize data on the economic consequences of liver and renal allograft quality in contemporary practice. Policy makers and providers must work together to ensure that financial disincentives do not lead to wastage of lifesaving organs.

Cost utility of allogeneic stem cell transplantation with matched unrelated donor versus treatment with imatinib for adult patients with newly diagnosed chronic myeloid leukaemia

OBJECTIVE

To estimate, from the perspective of the German statutory health insurance, the cost utility of allogeneic stem cell transplantation with matched unrelated donor (MUD-SCT) in newly diagnosed, chronic-phase chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML) patients aged 40 years or younger, relative to the treatment with imatinib.

METHODS

The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of the additional cost of imatinib versus MUD-SCT per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained was chosen as a target assessment. ICER was quantified using a Markov cohort modelling approach. The evaluation encompassed 5 years of treatment with either approach, and only direct medical costs (in euro, year 2005) were considered.

RESULTS

There were incremental costs of euro77,410 for imatinib therapy per QALY gained versus MUD-SCT. No strategy was clearly dominant; on average, during 5 years, cost savings of euro63,433 were obtained and 0.82 QALY lost by SCT compared to treatment with imatinib. QALYs gained in CML patients with either treatment resulted in considerable cost to the third-party payer in Germany. The results were particularly sensitive to the price of imatinib.

CONCLUSIONS

The analysis finds that imatinib is more costly but more effective (as measured in QALYs) over a 5-year time horizon. The resulting ICER of euro77,410 per QALY is higher than commonly cited thresholds. The cost utility of MUD-SCT to treat CML in patients with a European Group for Blood and Marrow Transplantation score < or = to 2 compares with that of the imatinib strategy.

A literature review of autograft and allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Knee anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery has significantly evolved and now includes the option of using an allograft. This has resulted in numerous studies evaluating the advantages and disadvantages of allografts. The purpose of this literature review is to evaluate this research and present important findings to allow the selection of the most appropriate graft source when considering allograft versus autograft reconstruction.

Cost-effectiveness of postremission intensive therapy in patients with acute leukemia

BACKGROUND

We assessed the cost-effectiveness of high-dose arabinoside (HiDAC)-based and allogeneic stem-cell transplantation (alloSCT)-based therapy in patients with acute leukemia.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We analyzed the outcome, cost and cost-effectiveness of 106 patients treated from January 1994 to January 2002 [94 acute myelogenous leukemia (AML)/12 acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL)]. Forty-two young patients at either intermediate or unknown cytogenetic risk received postremission intensive therapy (24 HiDAC-based/18 alloSCT-based therapy).

RESULTS

After a median follow-up of 50 months, the estimated 7-year overall survival for the HiDAC-based group showed a tendency to be higher than the alloSCT-based group (48% versus 28%, P = 0.1452). The HiDAC-based group spent a significantly lower total cost ($US51,857 versus 75,474, P = 0.004) than the alloSCT-based group. Cost-effectiveness analysis showed that the mean cost per year of life saved for the HiDAC-based group is considerably less expensive than the alloSCT-based group ($US11,224 versus 21,564). The reduced total cost for the HiDAC-based group originated from lower cost in room fees, medication, laboratory and procedure, but not in blood transfusion and professional manpower fees.

CONCLUSION

For the postremission therapy in young AML patients at either intermediate or unknown cytogenetic risk, cost-effectiveness of HiDAC-based therapy compares favorably with that of alloSCT-based therapy, which deserves further clinical trials.

The ESRD uninsured matter

Health-care insurance is the key to health-care access, yet the number of uninsured in the United States grows by a million persons per year and consists, in large part, of those who are financially unable to obtain medical coverage. Their unpaid medical bills add significantly to the cost of health insurance for those who do pay. Those without insurance receive care on a sporadic basis, and the risk of poor health-care outcomes is well established. The end-stage renal disease (ESRD) uninsured face unique problems related to chronicity of care and the system of chronic dialysis-care delivery. This article addresses the growing challenge of the ESRD uninsured in the United States and describes how the current system copes with the ESRD uninsured. More broadly, it discusses who the uninsured are (including undocumented immigrants), the health-care consequences of being without coverage, and how their care is currently financed. It also presents a health-care reform measure in Massachusetts designed to provide affordable insurance to those without coverage.

Clinical outcomes and direct hospital costs of reduced-intensity allogeneic transplantation in chronic myeloid leukemia

A reduced-intensity conditioning allogeneic stem cell transplantation was given to 19 patients (aged 15-59 years) in the first chronic phase and one patient in the accelerated phase with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) after a regimen consisting of fludarabine (Flu), busulfan (Bu) and ATG Fresenius. The median follow-up was 27 months. Until day +100, no transplant-related mortality was recorded. The incidence of acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) was 55 and 75%, respectively. Two patients (10%) died from GvHD. Fourteen (70%) patients achieved molecular remission. Additional post-transplant intervention (donor lymphocyte infusion, imatinib) was necessary, however, in 10 patients (50% of the patients; non-achievement of stable molecular remission or later relapses). The total direct cost of the transplantation treatment for all of the patients came to 1,572,880 euro. If the patients had been treated with imatinib and followed-up with the same time period as they were following a transplantation, the direct cost of the imatinib treatment would have been 2,005,117 euro. The transplantation treatment appears to be less expensive after approximately 2 years of follow-up. Flu+Bu+ATG is a low-toxicity regimen for patients with CML. However, a close follow-up is necessary and about 50% of the patients require further therapeutic intervention.

Autologous blood transfusion--a review

The discovery of HIV and other transfusion-transmissible infections has increased the demand for alternatives to allogeneic blood transfusion. One such alternative is autologous transfusion. This review presents an analysis of autologous transfusion. We conclude that autologous transfusion should form part of a strategy to minimise the risk associated with allogeneic transfusion in Nigeria and other developing countries.

Treatment Costs and Survival in Patients with Grades III-IV Acute Graft-Versus-Host Disease after Allogenic Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation During Three Decades

To determine development of treatment, costs, and survival for patients with grades III/IV acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), data from 88 patients with grades III/IV acute GVHD were collected. The patients were divided into three groups: patients who received transplants from 1977 through 1989 (group A), 1990 through 1999 (group B), and 2000 through 2004 (group C). The costs for treatment, enumerated to year 2003 costs, were calculated. An increased 1-year survival rate was found in group C, at 21% versus 9% and 8% for groups A and B, respectively (P=0.02). Death by acute GVHD was increased by repeat transplantation (P<0.001), grade IV acute GVHD (P<0.001), human leukocyte antigen mismatch (P=0.009), and transplantation before 2000 (P=0.015). Transplantation after 1990 (P=0.003) and grade IV acute GVHD (P=0.03) were associated with higher treatment costs. It was found that the time the patients had GVHD did not differ among the three groups. In conclusion, the costs and survival rates associated with severe acute GVHD has increased in recent years.

Alemtuzumab, fludarabine and melphalan as a conditioning therapy in severe aplastic anemia and hypoplastic myelodysplastic syndrome--single center experience

BACKGROUND

Allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation is the treatment of choice in young patients with severe aplastic anemia. The main causes of failure after this procedure are graft versus host disease, infections and graft failure, often exacerbated by large numbers of transfusions and prolonged disease duration before transplant.

METHODS

We report the results of allografting following conditioning with fludarabine, alemtuzumab and melphalan in: five patients with severe aplastic anemia and one with hypoplastic myelodysplastic syndrome. All patients had matched sibling donors. Source of hematopoietic stem cell was: bone marrow-2, blood-3, bone marrow and blood-1. The age of recipients was 18-26 years. Four patients received their graft as the first line therapy and two after failure of cyclosporine and antithymocyte globulin treatment. Number of transfused units including red blood cells and platelets before transplantation was 8-100 (median: 22) and 10-32 (median: 11), respectively. All donors and recipients were CMV-seropositive. Conditioning consisted of: alemtuzumab 30 mg/d (day -7 to -5), fludarabine 30 mg/m(2) (days -7 to -3) and melphalan 140 mg/m(2) at the day -2.

RESULTS

The time to granulocytes and platelets recovery was 15 and 25 days, respectively. All patients achieved full donor chimerism on day +60. Only two patients needed ganciclovir as preemptive therapy. Recurrent parvovirus B19 infection with pure red cell aplasia and acute viral B hepatitis was observed in one case. Pure red cell aplasia was successfully treated with immunoglobulins and cyclosporine discontinuation. With a follow-up of 16-39 (median: 29) months all patients are alive, and neither graft failure nor graft versus host disease, or any no other severe complications, was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study suggests that transplantation of hematopoietic stem cell using alemtuzumab, fludarabine and melphalan as a conditioning therapy is safe, inexpensive and effective treatment for patients with severe aplastic anemia, including multi-transfused adults having their disease for a long time.

Autologous blood transfusion after primary unilateral total knee replacement surgery

A prospective study was undertaken to assess the efficacy and financial cost of the use of an autologous blood transfusion device in the reduction of allogeneic blood requirements of patients undergoing primary unilateral total knee arthroplasty. Forty-nine consecutive patients received either the CellTrans blood salvage device (group A of 32 patients) or the Redivac high vacuum drainage system (group B of 17 patients). The preoperative and postoperative haemoglobin levels were recorded at 72 or 96 hours. Nine percent of group A patients received an allogeneic blood transfusion compared to 59% in group B. There was an average saving of 1.1 unit of allogeneic blood per patient in group A (p<0.001). The total cost per patient was about Euro 111 less for the group A patients. Autologous re-infusion was found in this study to be an effective method of reducing allogeneic blood requirements and to afford significant cost savings in primary unilateral knee arthroplasty.

Do minitransplants have minicosts? A cost comparison between myeloablative and nonmyeloablative allogeneic stem cell transplant in patients with acute myeloid leukemia

Allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (SCT) is a widely used, cost-intensive procedure. Although pretransplant nonmyeloablative (NMA) or reduced-intensity conditioning regimens appear very promising, prospective studies comparing this approach with the conventional myeloablative (MA) approach in specific hematologic diseases are necessary, especially in patients in whom the conventional approach is not contraindicated. Cost may be an important factor in the decision-making process. We compared the costs of MA and NMA transplants in patients with acute myeloid leukemia (AML). We estimated 1-year resource utilization in 12 consecutive MA patients (median age: 39 years) and in 11 consecutive NMA patients (median age: 58 years) who underwent HLA-identical sibling SCT for AML. Resources care expenses were valued using the average daily rate for personnel costs, supplies, and room costs. Other data were directly collected from the patients' charts. Despite a trend for lower costs in NMA patients during the first 6 months, costs during the 6-12-month period were significantly higher after NMA due to late complications and readmissions (P=0.03). Finally, mean 1-year costs were not different in MA and NMA patients (P=0.75). Prospective studies comparing conventional and NMA approaches in homogeneous populations should include economic items.

Autologous Blood Donation in Cardiac Surgery: Reduction of Allogeneic Blood Transfusion and Cost-Effectiveness

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to assess transfusion requirements in patients undergoing cardiac surgery with and without autologous blood donation and to calculate the costs of predonation from the hospital perspective.

DESIGN

Observational study.

SETTING

Single university hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Four thousand three hundred twenty-five patients undergoing elective cardiac surgery with and without autologous blood donation.

INTERVENTIONS

Eight hundred forty-nine patients (20%) underwent autologous blood donation, whereas 3,476 (80%) did not. Perioperative allogeneic blood transfusion was recorded as the primary endpoint. To avoid selection bias, patients were stratified according to their preoperative risk score. A decision model was derived from acquired data for the optimization of autologous blood donation.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Allogeneic blood transfusion rate was 13% in patients with predonation versus 48% without predonation (p < 0.05). This difference remained statistically significant even after risk stratification. The predonation of 1, 2, or 3 units reduced the probability of receiving allogeneic blood to 24%, 14%, and 9%, respectively. An efficient program of predonation within the department of anesthesiology allowed keeping the costs of predonation low. Decision-tree analysis revealed that predonation of 2 autologous units of blood saved the most allogeneic blood for the smallest increase in costs. Incremental cost for male patients predonating 2 units was dollars 33 (US), whereas for females predonation could be done at no extra cost in comparison to patients without predonation.

CONCLUSION

Autologous blood donation significantly reduces allogeneic blood requirement in cardiac surgery. If adjusted for diagnosis and gender, autologous blood donation is a cost-effective alternative to reduce allogeneic blood consumption.

Cost-effective manufacture of an allogeneic GM-CSF-secreting breast tumor vaccine in an academic cGMP facility

BACKGROUND

GM-CSF-secreting, allogeneic cell-based cancer vaccines have shown promise for the treatment of a variety of solid tumors. We have now applied this approach to breast cancer. The aim of these studies was to optimize expansion parameters, qualify the manufacturing process, and establish expected outcomes for cGMP-compliant manufacturing of two GM-CSF-secreting breast tumor cell lines.

METHODS

The variables affecting the efficiency of expanding and formulating two allogeneic GM-CSF-secreting cell lines, 2T47D-V and 3SKBR3-7, were systematically evaluated. Production criteria investigated included alternative cell culture vessels (flasks vs. cell factories), centrifugation time and speed variables for large volume cell concentration, cell seeding density, the minimal concentration of FBS required for maximal cell expansion, and the dose and timing of irradiation in relation to cryopreservation.

RESULTS

These studies demonstrate that, in comparison with standard 150-cm2 tissue culture flasks, Nunc 10-Stack Cell Factories are a more efficient and practical cell culture vessel for vaccine cell line manufacture. Centrifugation optimization studies using the COBE 2991 Cell Processor established that a speed of 2000 r.p.m. (450 g) for 2 min reliably concentrated the cells while maintaining acceptable viability and bioactivity. Radiation studies established that lethal irradiation prior to cryopreservation does not compromise the quality of the product, as measured by post-thaw cell viability and GM-CSF cell line-specific secretion levels. Finally, studies aimed at optimizing the production of one vaccine cell line, 3SKBR3-7, demonstrated that seeding the cells at a higher density and maintaining them in half the initial concentration of FBS maximized the yield of bioactive cells, resulting in significant cost savings.

DISCUSSION

A manufacturing process that simultaneously maximizes cell yield, minimizes cell manipulation and maintains vaccine cell potency is critical for producing cell-based cancer vaccines in an academic setting. These studies define a feasible, reproducible and cost-effective methodology for production of a GM-CSF-secreting breast cancer vaccine that is cGMP compliant.

Cost comparison of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: autograft versus allograft

PURPOSE

To compare the economic costs associated with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction using either autograft or allograft. The surgical costs are reported, including charge categories, for each procedure. All operations were performed in the Southern United States of America.

TYPE OF STUDY

Evaluation of cost data collected from a group of patients participating in a prospective, nonrandomized trial.

METHODS

A total of 122 patients with ACL-deficient knees undergoing surgical reconstruction using either bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft (n = 86) or freeze-dried Achilles tendon allograft (n = 37) were analyzed (1 patient underwent 2 allograft reconstructions). Patient selection for groups was based on the physician performing the surgery (2 surgeons performed autografts and 1 performed allografts). Groups were compared with respect to age, sex, race, and occupation. Hospital charge data were retrieved from the billing department and divided into various categories for comparison of the 2 groups.

RESULTS

The mean hospital charge for ACL reconstruction was 4,622 dollars for allograft and 5,694 dollars for autograft (P < .0001). Differences included increased operating room time and a greater likelihood of overnight hospitalization for autograft procedures. This was slightly offset by higher charges for operating room supplies for allograft reconstructions owing to the cost of the graft itself.

CONCLUSIONS

Allograft reconstruction of the ACL was significantly less expensive than autograft bone-patellar tendon-bone reconstruction. Allograft ACL reconstruction is a less costly alternative to autograft reconstruction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, economic analysis with no sensitivity analysis.

Correction of pincer-nail deformities with autograft or homograft dermis: modified surgical technique

The pincer-nail deformity is characterized by an excessively curved and distorted nail across the transverse dimension. Forty-nine sides (paronychial folds) were dissected off the distal phalanx periosteum with scissors and/or a small elevator. The dermis was placed between the paronychial fold and the plalanx to flatten the germinal and sterile matrix. Direct comparison of autograft dermis to homograft dermis did not show any significant differences in postcorrection appearance of the nail or relief of symptoms. Surgical time averaged 22 minutes less in those patients having reconstruction on both sides of one nail with homograft dermis.

PREDICTING THE COSTS OF ALLOGENEIC SIBLING STEM-CELL TRANSPLANTATION: RESULTS FROM A PROSPECTIVE, MULTICENTER, FRENCH STUDY

BACKGROUND

Allogeneic hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation is a widely used, cost-intensive procedure. Our purpose was to estimate costs and determine cost predictors.

METHODS

We used data from a prospective French study comparing four doses of immunoglobulins. Resource use of hematopoietic stem-cell transplant recipients during the first 6 months posttransplant, both inpatient and ambulatory costs, in 85 patients from five centers were collected prospectively and costed. Baseline data and clinical events were retrieved. Protocol-driven costs were excluded. Multivariable analysis evaluated the association between costs and patient's pretransplant status and transplant-related complications. Because of the absence of differences in outcome among the four randomization groups, cost data for all patients were pooled.

RESULTS

Total costs per patient were the following: mean 76,237 Euros; standard deviation 32,565 Euros; median 69,516 Euros; range 183,758 to 14,761Euros. The major cost driver was hospital days. No association was found between costs and baseline status. The "predictors" of higher costs (adding an average 20,000 Euros/patient) were the occurrence of transplant-related complications: graft-versus-host disease and repeated infections that were unpredictable before transplant in this homogeneous group of patients.

CONCLUSION

Our data highlight the discrepancy between the Diagnosis Related Group prospective payment system and actual costs. The actual cost of geno-identical stem-cell transplantation results from posttransplant complications that cannot be predicted prospectively and require ex post cost adjustment.

[The role of cost analysis in the evaluation of the development of medical technology. The case of allogenic stem-cell transplantation]

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the real costs of allogeneic haematopoetic stem-cell transplantation and to compare these with the historically determined budgets that are made available for this purpose ([symbol: see text] 70,038 for genetically related donors and [symbol: see text] 76,826 for unrelated donors).

DESIGN

Cost analysis.

METHODS

In the period 1994-1999, the direct medical costs (price level of 1998) of bone-marrow transplantation from related donors (BMT), stem-cell transplantation from unrelated donors (VUD-SCT) and allogeneic peripheral-blood stem-cell transplantation (PBSCT) from related donors were determined on the basis of data on adult patients with either acute myeloid leukaemia (n = 66) or acute lymphocytic leukaemia (n = 31). First, the medical resource use by these patients was determined and multiplied by the unit costs of each of the items. Second, a structural programme for allogeneic stem-cell transplantation brings along costs that are not evident from the registration of the medical resource use (e.g., the costs of pretransplantation screening and the selection of the donor). The costs of these items were calculated by taking inventory in the hospitals and assessed by experts.

RESULTS

The average costs per transplanted patient were [symbol: see text] 98,334 (BMT), [symbol: see text] 151,754 (VUD-SCT) and [symbol: see text] 98,977 (PBSCT) during the first two years after transplantation. The greater part of the costs was incurred in the transplantation phase. In VUD-SCT, one-third of the total cost was due to the costs of finding a suitable donor.

CONCLUSION

The current budget for allogeneic stem-cell transplantation is insufficient to perform the transplantations adequately. Periodic evaluation of the budgets for complicated procedures based on cost analyses has added value for the evaluation of the development of these procedures in time and can thereby contribute to the quality and continuity of care.

Allogeneic stem cell transplantation using non-myeloablative conditioning regimens: results of the Mexican approach

We have used a novel method to conduct non-myeloablative stem cell transplantation (NST), making the following changes in previous methods: Use of the cheapest conditioning drugs, tailored number of apheresis sessions in the donors, elimination of ganciclovir and IgG, outpatient conduction when possible, diminished number of transfusions of blood products and diminished number of donor lymphocyte infusions. With this method, we have prospectively conducted 70 allografts in patients with different diseases: Chronic myelogenous leukemia, acute myelogenous leukemia, acute lymphoblastic leukemia, myelodysplasia, thalassemia major, relapsed Hodgkins disease, Blackfan-Diamond syndrome and aplastic anemia. In them, the median granulocyte recovery time to 0.5 x 10(9)/L was 11 d, whereas the median platelet recovery time to 20 x 10(9)/L was 12 d. Twenty patients did not need red blood cell transfusions and 17 did not need platelet transfusions. In 55 individuals (78%), the procedure could be completed fully on an outpatient basis. Follow-up times range between 30 and 800 d.: Four patients failed to engraft and recovered endogenous hemopoiesis; 16 patients (23%) developed acute graft versus-host disease (GVHD) whereas 28 (49%) developed chronic GVHD. Thirty two patients (47%) have died: 21 with a relapsing disease and seven as a result of GVHD; the median post-trasplant survival (SV) was 420 d., whereas the 12-mo. SV was 42%. The 100-day mortality was 3.8% and the transplant-related mortality was 14.2%. The median cost of the allografts was 18,000.00 US dollars. This method could be particularly adequate in developing countries, where very few individuals can afford the cost of a conventional bone marrow transplantation procedure.

Cost analysis of HLA-identical sibling and voluntary unrelated allogeneic bone marrow and peripheral blood stem cell transplantation in adults with acute myelocytic leukaemia or acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

Allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT) is one of the most expensive medical procedures. However, only a few studies to date have addressed the costs of HLA-identical sibling transplantation and only one study has reported costs of unrelated transplantation. No recent cost analysis with a proper follow-up period and donor identification expenses is available on related or voluntary matched unrelated donor (MUD) SCT for adult AML or ALL. Therefore, we calculated direct medical (hospital) costs based on 97 adults who underwent HLA-identical sibling bone marrow transplantation (BMT) or peripheral blood stem cell transplantation (PBSCT), and patients who received a graft from a MUD between 1994 and 1999. The average costs per transplanted patient were Euro 98,334 (BMT), Euro 151,754 (MUD), and Euro 98,977 (PBSCT), including donor identification expenses, 2 years follow-up and costs of patients who were not transplanted after they had been planned to receive an allograft. The majority of these costs was generated during the hospitalisation for graft infusion. For MUD transplants, nearly one-third of these costs was spent on the search for a suitable donor. For patients who were alive after 2 years, cumulative expenses were calculated to be Euro 103,509 (BMT), Euro 173,587 (MUD), and Euro 105,906 (PBSCT).

Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation in the developing world: experience from a center in India

We describe our experience of setting up an allogeneic BMT program at the Christian Medical College Hospital, Vellore over a period of 13 years, from October 1986 to December 1999. Two hundred and twenty-one transplants were performed during this period in 214 patients, with seven patients undergoing second transplants. Indication for BMT were thalassemia major - 106 (48%), CML - 30, AML - 35, ALL - 10, SAA - 22, MDS - six and six for other miscellaneous disorders. The mean age of this patient cohort was 15.6 years (range 2-52). Graft-versus-host disease of grades III and IV was seen in 36 patients (17%) and this was the primary cause of death in 20 patients (9.2%). All patients and donors were CMV IgG positive. Sepsis was the primary cause of death in 16 patients (7.4%), 10 bacterial, four fungal and two viral. One hundred and ten of this series of patients are alive and disease free (50%) with a median follow-up of 24 months (range 2-116). These results are comparable to those achieved for patients with similar disease status in transplant units in the Western world and cost a mean of US$15 000.

Results of an outpatient-based stem cell allotransplant program using nonmyeloablative conditioning regimens

Using nonmyeloablative, immunosuppressive, fludarabine (FLU)-based conditioning regimens, we have performed allogeneic peripheral blood stem cell transplants in 26 patients (8 with chronic myelogenous leukemia, 6 with acute myelogenous leukemia, 10 with acute lymphoblastic leukemia, 1 with myelodysplasia, and 1 with thalassemia major). Conditioning consisted of FLU/busulphan/cyclophosphamide/cyclosporin-A (CyA)/methotrexate, or FLU/melphalan/CyA/methotrexate. The median granulocyte recovery time to 0.5 x 10(9)/l was 11 days, whereas the median platelet recovery time to 20 x 10(9)/l was 12 days. Twelve patients did not need red blood cell transfusions, and 8 did not need platelet transfusions. In 21 individuals (81%), the procedure could be completed fully on an outpatient basis. Follow-up times range between 30 and 600 days: one patient failed to engraft and recovered endogenous hemopoiesis; six out of 26 patients developed acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) whereas 7/22 developed chronic GVHD. Twelve patients (46%) have died, nine of them with a relapsing disease and three with GVHD; median post-transplant survival (SV) was 300 days, whereas the 12-month SV was 42%. The 100-day mortality was 3.8% and the transplant-related mortality was 11.5%. This procedure is substantially less costly than its counterpart, using in-hospital myeloablative conditioning regimens, and it may represent another approach in the management of patients requiring an allogeneic stem cell transplant.

Valuing clinical strategies early in development: a cost analysis of allogeneic peripheral blood stem cell transplantation

Allogeneic peripheral blood stem cell transplantation (alloPBSCT) is an emerging technology. As this technology develops, transplant centers are concerned with looking for technologic advances that will result in improvements in clinical outcomes and lower costs. We provide comparative estimates of costs and resource use for alloPBSCT in comparison to allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (alloBMT) for persons with hematologic malignancies from the time of harvest to 100 days post transplant. A retrospective, cost-identification analysis was conducted for patients in two consecutive phase II clinical trials at the University of Nebraska Medical Center. Identical preparative regimens, graft-versus-host disease prophylaxis, post-transplant hematopoietic colony-stimulating factor treatment regimens, and discharge criteria were used. Total median costs were $18,304 lower for alloPBSCT, with lower costs during recovery; specifically for hospitalization, platelet products, hematopoietic growth factors, intravenous hyperalimentation, supportive care agents, supplies, and antibacterial agents. This study provides preliminary evidence for short-term cost savings associated with alloPBSCT. However, concerns exist over the potential for higher costs due to preliminary reports of higher rates of chronic graft-versus-host disease, as well as more intensive induction regimens that may result in lower relapse rates. The premature adoption of new technologies based on short-term economic factors, in the absence of adequate clinical trial data, may prove to be ill-advised, particularly for complex medical treatments such as allogeneic transplantation.

Cryopreserved arterial allografts in the treatment of major vascular infection: a comparison with conventional surgical techniques

OBJECTIVE

Recent findings with cryopreserved heart valve allografts in the treatment of infectious endocarditis suggest that the use of cryopreserved arterial allografts may improve the outcome in patients with vascular infections.

METHODS

Seventy-two patients with mycotic aneurysms (n = 29) or infected vascular prostheses (n = 43) of the thoracic (n = 26) or abdominal aorta (n = 46) were treated with in situ repair and extra-anatomic reconstruction using prosthetic material (n = 38) or implantation of a cryopreserved arterial allograft (n = 34). Disease-related survival and survival free of reoperation were assessed. Morbidity, cumulative lengths of intensive care, hospitalization, antibiotic treatment, and costs were calculated per year of follow-up.

RESULTS

The use of cryopreserved arterial allografts was superior to conventional surgery in terms of disease-related survival (P =.008), disease-related survival free of reoperation (P =.0001), duration of intensive care per year of follow-up (median 1 vs 11 days; range 1 to 42 vs 2 to 120 days; P =.001), hospitalization (14 vs 30 days; range 7 to 150 vs 15 to 240 days; P =.002), duration of postoperative antibiotic therapy (21 vs 40 days; range 21 to 90 vs 60 to 365 days; P =.002), incidence of complications (24% vs 63%; P =.005), and elimination of infection (91% vs 53%; P =.001). In addition, costs were 40% lower in the group treated by allografts (P =.005).

CONCLUSIONS

The use of cryopreserved arterial allografts is a more effective treatment for mycotic aneurysms and infected vascular prostheses than conventional surgical techniques.

Efficacy and costs of granulocyte colony-stimulating factor in allogeneic T-cell depleted bone marrow transplantation

Hematopoietic growth factors have shown clinical benefits in patients undergoing chemotherapy and stem cell transplantation, but few studies have been performed to assess whether the benefits are worth the costs. We reviewed 196 patients undergoing T-cell depleted related donor bone marrow transplantation (BMT) between 1990 and 1996 to assess the effect of growth factor use on time to engraftment and costs of hospitalization. Beginning in 1994, based on encouraging results in autologous transplantation, patients (n = 81) were treated with granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF) starting at day +1 after marrow infusion until engraftment. Between January 1, 1990 and January 1, 1994, patients (n = 115) did not receive growth factor. CD6 depletion of donor marrow was the only form of prophylaxis against graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Despite receiving a lower stem cell dose (P = .004), the group receiving G-CSF had a decreased time to engraftment (20 days v 12 days, P < .0001) and time from marrow infusion to discharge (23 days v 17 days, P < .0001). In multivariate modeling, the use of G-CSF was the most significant factor predicting time to engraftment and discharge. Incidence of grades II-IV GVHD, early mortality, percentage of patients who engrafted, and relapse rates did not differ between the groups. Inpatient charges during the first 50 days after marrow infusion (including readmissions) were available on 110 patients and were converted to costs using departmental ratios of costs of charges. Median costs were significantly lower in the group receiving G-CSF ($80,600 v $84,000, P = .0373). Thus, use of G-CSF in this setting allows earlier hospital discharge with lower costs.

A detailed analysis of charges for hematopoietic stem cell transplantation at a children's hospital

We analyzed hospital charges for pediatric hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) to understand better the medical origin of these charges. Forty-nine patients undergoing HSCT at Kosair Children's Hospital between January 1992 and August 1995 had hospital charges analyzed by cost center, donor type and clinical outcome. Thirty-three autologous, two syngeneic and 14 allogeneic transplants were performed. Twenty-four transplants were performed for hematological malignancies, 22 for solid tumors, and three for non-malignant diseases. Pharmaceutical charges comprised the largest single component of total hospital charges (THC), accounting for 38.9%. Room charges were the next largest group at 33.7% of THC. Other cost centers, in order of magnitude, were central supply (7.9%), transfusion services (7.5%), laboratory (5.8%), microbiology (3.6%), miscellaneous (1.9%), and radiology (1.4%). Within the pharmaceutical cost center, colony-stimulating factors comprised the largest single item, making up 18% of total pharmacy charges and 7% of THC. Antibiotics were the second largest component, at 16% of pharmacy charges and 6% of THC. Patients transferred to the intensive care unit (ICU) had charges 68% greater than non-ICU patients. Allogeneic transplant patients had THC 35% greater than autologous transplant patients, but also a four-fold greater chance of becoming an ICU patient. THC for non-ICU allogeneic transplant patients were 18% greater than for autologous non-ICU patients. THC for allogeneic ICU patients were 21% greater than for autologous ICU patients. Patients who died of transplant-related toxicity prior to day 100 had THC 83% greater than those who survived beyond day 100. This is the first published comprehensive and detailed analysis of charges associated with hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. With increased emphasis on the provision of cost-effective care in both Europe and the USA, medical practices must be examined with the goal of reducing inefficiencies while preserving quality of care. Understanding the genesis of charges in expensive procedures such as stem cell transplantation is an initial step in cost containment.

Cost analysis of autologous blood transfusion, using cell salvage, compared with allogeneic blood transfusion

Autologous transfusion is an option infrequently used in the UK, partly because the direct costs are greater than for allogeneic transfusion. An analysis of the cost consequences of substituting autologous for allogeneic blood, by using cell salvage, was undertaken from a hospital perspective. Direct costs were estimated for two different cell salvage devices and sensitivity analysis performed on the key variables. Allogeneic transfusion may be associated with increased rates of postoperative infection due immunomodulation and immunosuppression. As a result, one of the short-term benefits of autologous transfusion is a possible reduction in length of hospital stay. This was the most important variable affecting the cost of autologous transfusion. Cost equivalence for autologous and allogeneic blood was reached at reductions in hospital stay of between 0.3 and 2 days across a range of variables. Reductions in length of hospital stay of this magnitude have been reported in several small studies. The results of our cost analysis suggest that autologous transfusion should not be rejected on the grounds of cost and we recommend a large-scale randomized controlled trial of autologous vs. allogeneic transfusion.

The cost effectiveness of preoperative autologous blood donations

BACKGROUND

Since the recognition that human immunodeficiency virus is transmissible by blood transfusion there has been increasing public and professional support for autologous blood donations before elective surgery. Autologous blood donation is, however, a more expensive process than the donation of allogeneic blood by community volunteers. Furthermore, there have been recent improvements in the safety of the volunteer blood supply.

METHODS

We used a decision-analysis model to assess the cost effectiveness of donating autologous blood for four surgical procedures. Cost data were collected from the observation of transfusion practice at the University of California, Los Angeles, in 1992. Estimates of the risks of transfusion-associated diseases and the costs of treating them came from the medical literature. Cost effectiveness was expressed in dollars per quality-adjusted year of life saved. We performed sensitivity analyses of the variables in our model and examined the effect of strategies suggested to reduce costs.

RESULTS

Substituting autologous for allogeneic blood resulted in little expected health benefit (0.0002 to 0.00044 quality-adjusted year of life saved) at considerable additional cost ($68 to $4,783 per unit of blood). The additional cost of autologous blood was primarily a function of the discarding of units that were donated but not transfused and of a more labor-intensive donation process. The cost-effectiveness ratios ranged from $235,000 to over $23 million per quality-adjusted year of life saved.

CONCLUSIONS

Given the improved safety of allogeneic transfusions today, the increased protection afforded by donating autologous blood is limited and may not justify the increased cost.

Stratifying the causes of death in liver transplant recipients. An approach to improving survival

The causes of death in 21 adults and 23 children in a consecutive series of 180 liver transplantations were reviewed and classified into four categories. A previously described preoperative risk score was applied prospectively to estimate the relative risk of mortality following liver transplantation in adults. Categorization of the causes of death allowed for a systematic search for errors in management and technique. Comparison of the preoperative risk score with the cause of death category revealed that higher-risk adults were most likely to die of causes related to preoperative morbidity. They also accrued higher hospital costs, regardless of outcome. The data are useful for designing strategies to reduce mortality. However, the inexorable role that preoperative morbidity has on outcome was also emphasized. This has important implications in developing strategies to reduce the costs of liver transplantation and to provide optimal distribution of scarce donor organs.

[Heart-lung transplantation]

To date, more than 200 human heart-lung transplantations (HLT) have been performed in USA and Europe. The main indications are still primary pulmonary hypertension and Eisenmenger's syndrome but the intervention has also been employed in cases of parenchymatous pulmonary disease. At operation, the thoracic organ is replaced. The recipient's heart can frequently be donated. Recent reviews suggest acceptable two-year survival following HLT of approximately 60%. The direct economical costs of transplantation have been stated to be approximately 17,000 pounds but to this must be added the expenses for life-long immunosuppressive treatment and follow up control together with hospitalization during the time waiting for a suitable donor. The annual requirement for transplantation in Denmark is estimated at present to be approximately ten patients. The immediate requirement for transplantation will probably be covered by referral to the European centres via national or provincial hospitals and with the permission of the Danish Board of Health. The case reports of the first two Danes (both with emphysema secondary to alpha-1-antitrypsin deficiency) who underwent successful heart-lung transplantations in England are presented. In the long run, it will prove necessary to utilize Danish donors which necessitates alterations in the criteria of death.

Amelioration of chronic renal allograft dysfunction in cyclosporine-treated patients by addition of azathioprine

Management of chronic renal allograft dysfunction in cyclosporine-prednisone treated renal allograft recipients remains problematic. We therefore initiated a protocol of azathioprine addition (1.0-1.5 mg/kg/day) to ongoing CsA/Pred therapy. Three groups were treated. Group A (n = 21) had chronic progressive renal dysfunction (serum creatinine greater than or equal to 2.5 mg/dl or more than 15% above baseline) four or more months after transplantation. Group B (n = 8) had frequent or severe rejection episodes occurring despite adequate CsA levels. Group C (n = 7) had constitutional side effects of CsA with or without renal dysfunction persisting despite drug taper or financial difficulty in affording CsA. Aza was initiated 17.8 +/- 2.8 months after transplantation in group A, the mean serum creatinine having risen from 2.55 +/- 27 mg/dl to 3.04 +/- .20 mg/dl (P = .07) over the six months preceding Aza initiation, despite stable and low therapeutic range HPLC whole-blood CsA levels (118 +/- 10 ng/ml vs. 133 +/- 11 ng/ml, P = NS). Renal function declined at a rate of -0.20 +/- .06 Cr1/year in the six-month period before addition of Aza, and then improved at a rate of 0.09 +/- .04 Cr-1/year after addition of Aza (P = .002). These changes in renal function occurred without a decrease in CsA levels (118 +/- 10 six months before Aza vs. 126 +/- 26 six months after Aza, P = NS). In group B Aza was initiated at 58 +/- 8 days after transplantation when mean sCr was 3.56 +/- .29 mg/dl and mean CsA level was 222 +/- 17 ng/ml. At least follow-up 12.7 +/- 2.0 months after addition of Aza, all group B grafts were functioning, mean sCr was 2.69 +/- .31 mg/dl (P = .09 compared with baseline), and mean CsA level was 128 +/- 34 ng/ml (P = .07 compared with baseline). Group C patients had addition of Aza at 43 +/- 19 months after transplantation when mean sCr was 2.97 +/- .60 and mean CsA level was 125 +/- 30 ng/ml; addition of Aza had no influence on the rate of decline in renal function in this group. Of these 36 patients, 6 received therapy for acute rejection over the entire follow-up period of 12.3 +/- 1.4 months after addition of Aza; 4 of these retain graft function. Infectious complications consisted of 2 urinary tract infections, 1 bacterial pneumonia, and one case of otitis media.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Cost of allogeneic bone marrow transplantation in four diseases

The cost of bone-marrow transplantation is compared in 4 diseases: acute myelogenous leukaemia, severe combined immunodeficiency, severe aplastic anaemia and chronic granulocytic leukaemia. Hospital cost components directly related to the clinical protocols applied are valorized. Results confirm the well-known fact that bone-marrow transplantation is a costly technique. The unit cost of a transplantation can vary from 1 to 2 between departments for the sole reason that patients treated are not suffering from the same illness. For one disease, the unit cost may vary from 1 to 2.7 when post-graft complications arise. Furthermore, in the health-care sector, as well as in every other economic sector, costs do not remain stable: they vary in time most especially when treatment protocols evolve. This type of cost information is the basis for management control systems without which physicians, hospital managers and health-care authorities cannot communicate effectively. In countries where health care is largely financed by the community, what is at stake is the future of advanced technologies in medicine.