The Fragility of Statistical Findings in the Femoral Neck Fracture Literature: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

OBJECTIVES

Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in the femoral neck fracture literature frequently report P -values for outcomes, which have substantial implications in guiding surgical management. This study used the fragility index (FI), reverse fragility index (rFI), and fragility quotient (FQ) to assess the statistical stability of outcomes reported in RCTs evaluating the management and treatment of femoral neck fractures.

METHODS

DATA SOURCES

DESIGN

PubMed, Embase, and MEDLINE were queried for RCTs (January 1, 2010 to February 28, 2023).

SETTING

RCTs that evaluated surgical management or treatment of femoral neck fractures were included.

STUDY SELECTION CRITERIA

RCTs with 2 treatment arms reporting categorical dichotomous outcomes were included. Non-RCT studies, RCTs with greater than 2 treatment arms, and RCTs without a femoral neck fracture cohort were excluded.

DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS

OUTCOME MEASURES AND COMPARISONS

The FI and rFI were calculated as the number of outcome event reversals required to alter statistical significance for significant ( P < 0.05) and nonsignificant ( P ≥ 0.05) outcomes, respectively. The FQ was calculated by dividing the FI by the sample size for the study.

RESULTS

Nine hundred eighty-five articles were screened, with 71 studies included for analysis. The median FI across a total of 197 outcomes was 4 [interquartile range (IQR) 2-5] with an associated FQ of 0.033 (IQR 0.017-0.060). Forty-seven outcomes were statistically significant with a median FI of 2 (IQR 1-4) and associated FQ of 0.02 (IQR 0.014-0.043). One hundred fifty outcomes were statistically nonsignificant with a median rFI of 4 (IQR 3-5) and associated FQ of 0.037 (IQR 0.019-0.065).

CONCLUSIONS

Statistical findings in femoral neck fracture RCTs are fragile, with reversal of a median 4 outcomes altering significance of study findings. The authors thus recommend standardized reporting of P -values with FI and FQ metrics to aid in interpreting the robustness of outcomes in femoral neck fracture RCTs.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

The Statistical Fragility of Tranexamic Acid Use in the Orthopaedic Surgery Literature: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

INTRODUCTION

Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) represent the highest level of evidence in orthopaedic surgery literature, although the robustness of statistical findings in these trials may be unreliable. We used the fragility index (FI), reverse fragility index (rFI), and fragility quotient (FQ) to evaluate the statistical stability of outcomes reported in RCTs that assess the use of tranexamic acid (TXA) across orthopaedic subspecialties.

METHODS

PubMed, EMBASE, and MEDLINE were queried for RCTs (2010-present) reporting dichotomous outcomes with study groups stratified by TXA administration. The FI and rFI were defined as the number of outcome event reversals needed to alter the significance level of significant and nonsignificant outcomes, respectively. FQ was determined by dividing the FI or rFI by sample size. Subgroup analyses were conducted based on orthopaedic subspecialty.

RESULTS

Six hundred five RCTs were screened with 108 studies included for analysis comprising 192 total outcomes. The median FI of the 192 outcomes was 4 (IQR 2 to 5) with an associated FQ of 0.03 (IQR 0.019 to 0.050). 45 outcomes were reported as statistically significant with a median FI of 1 (IQR 1 to 5) and associated FQ of 0.02 (IQR 0.011 to 0.034). 147 outcomes were reported as nonsignificant with a median rFI of 4 (IQR 3 to 5) and associated FQ of 0.04 (IQR 0.023 to 0.051). The adult reconstruction, trauma, and spine subspecialties had a median FI of 4. Sports had a median FI of 3. Shoulder and elbow and foot and ankle had median FIs of 6.

DISCUSSION

Statistical outcomes reported in RCTs on the use of TXA in orthopaedic surgery are fragile. Reversal of a few outcomes is sufficient to alter statistical significance. We recommend reporting FI, rFI, and FQ metrics to aid in interpreting the outcomes reported in comparative trials.

The Variability of MCID, SCB, PASS, and MOI Thresholds for PROMs in the Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty Literature: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RTSA) is a common procedure utilized to address degenerative pathologies of the glenohumeral joint and rotator cuff. Increased reliance on patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) has placed emphasis on the utilization of the minimum clinically important difference (MCID), substantial clinical benefit (SCB), patient acceptable symptom state (PASS), and maximal outcome improvement (MOI) thresholds to assess the clinical efficacy of RTSA. In this study, we systematically reviewed the MCID, SCB, PASS, and MOI thresholds reported for PROMs following RTSA.

METHODS

PubMed, Embase, MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar were queried for articles from Jan. 1, 2000-Aug. 31, 2023 reporting MCID, SCB, PASS, or MOI values for PROMs following RTSA. Patient demographic data, study characteristics, MCID/SCB/PASS/MOI thresholds, and threshold calculation methods were extracted.

RESULTS

141 articles were screened with 39 ultimately included, comprising 11,984 total patients that underwent RTSA. 34 (87%) studies reported MCID thresholds, 20 (51%) reported SCB, 5 (13%) reported PASS, and 2 (5%) reported MOI. 25/39 (64%) studies referenced a previous study when reporting MCID, SCB, PASS, or MOI values, 11 (28%) used an anchor-based method to calculate threshold values, 1 (3%) used a distribution-based method, and 2 (5%) used both anchor and distribution methods. There were 19 newly calculated MCID (11), SCB (5), PASS (1), and MOI (2) thresholds. For five of the six most utilized PROMs (ASES, SST, Constant, UCLA, SPADI), the range of reported MCID values exceeded 50% of the most common threshold. For three of the six, the range of SCB values exceeded 25% of the most common threshold.

CONCLUSION

There is substantial variability in the MCID and SCB threshold values reported in the RTSA literature. Standardizing the methodologic calculation and utilization of MCID, SCB, PASS, and MOI thresholds for RTSA may allow for improved assessment of PROMs.

The Delayed Presentation and Diagnosis of Youth Wrestling Injuries: A 20-Year Analysis of National Injury Data

INTRODUCTION

The nature of wrestling may lead athletes to mask injuries with the delayed presentations of youth wrestling-related injuries not being well characterized.

METHODS

This descriptive epidemiological study queried the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System database to characterize delayed presentations of wrestling-related injuries in middle and high-school athletes. Data collection consisted of national estimates, demographics, and injury characteristics of patients with delayed (D) presentations (≥1 day) and same-day (S) presentations to US emergency departments after sustaining a wrestling-related injury during the scholastic wrestling season (December to February, 2000 to 2019).

RESULTS

Of middle and high-school wrestlers presenting to US emergency departments, 5.6% (95% confidence interval [CI] 4.3% to 7.1%) reported delayed presentations for a total of 1,110 patients (CI, 591 to 1,630) annually. Most commonly (P < 0.001), injuries were sustained on Saturdays in both cohorts (D, 28.2%; CI, 22.4% to 34.8%; S, 29.6%; CI, 24.3% to 35.5%). Patients reporting delayed presentations were less likely to sustain fractures (D, 11.5%; CI, 8.3% to 15.6%; S, 18.9%; CI, 15.0% to 23.5%; P = 0.019) and injuries of the head/neck (D, 20.0%; CI, 16.5 to 24.1%; S, 26.2%; CI, 21.4% to 31.7%; P = 0.011).

DISCUSSION

A substantial proportion of adolescent wrestlers report delayed presentations of injuries. This emphasizes the need for vigilance in detecting subtle signs of injury.

Postoperative Strength Differences at Short-Term Follow-Up Vary Based on Autograft Harvest Site After Adolescent Transphyseal Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

PURPOSE

To compare the clinical and patient-reported outcomes of adolescent patients who underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) with quadriceps tendon (QT) versus hamstring tendon (HT) autograft.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study of adolescent patients aged 18 years or younger treated at a single tertiary care children's hospital who underwent primary transphyseal ACLR using QT or HT between January 2018 and December 2019. All patients had minimum 6-month follow-up. Outcomes included isokinetic strength testing, postoperative Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System and International Knee Documentation Committee scores, and complications; these were compared between the QT and HT cohorts.

RESULTS

A total of 84 patients (44 HT and 40 QT patients) were included. The QT cohort had a higher proportion of male patients (62.5% vs 34.1%, P = .01). At 3 months, HT patients had a lower hamstring-quadriceps (H/Q) strength ratio (60.7 ± 11.0 vs 79.5 ± 18.6, P < .01) and lower Limb Symmetry Index in flexion (85.6 ± 16.1 vs 95.5 ± 15.7, P = .01) whereas QT patients had a lower Limb Symmetry Index in extension (67.3 ± 9.5 vs 77.4 ± 10.7, P < .01). The H/Q ratio at 6 months was lower in HT patients (59.4 ± 11.5 vs 66.2 ± 7.5, P < .01). Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System and International Knee Documentation Committee scores were not different at 3 months or latest follow-up. QT patients had more wound issues (20.0% vs 2.3%, P = .01). Patients receiving HT autograft had more ipsilateral knee injuries (18.2% vs 2.5%, P = .03), but there was no difference in graft failure for ACLR using HT versus QT (9.1% vs 2.5%, P = .36).

CONCLUSIONS

There were no differences in patient-reported outcome measures between patients receiving QT autografts and those receiving HT autografts. Patients with QT grafts had more postoperative wound issues but a lower rate of ipsilateral knee complications (graft failure or meniscal tear). Differences in quadriceps and hamstring strength postoperatively compared with the contralateral limb were observed for adolescent ACLR patients receiving QT and HT autografts, respectively. This contributed to higher H/Q ratios seen at 3 and 6 months postoperatively for patients receiving QT autografts.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, retrospective comparative therapeutic study.

Lower Extremity Surfing Injuries Seen at United States Emergency Departments From 2002 to 2022

Background

Surfing is an increasingly popular sport with a high propensity for both traumatic and atraumatic injuries.

Purpose

To analyze the trends, etiologies, and diagnoses of lower extremity orthopaedic-related surfing injuries presenting to United States (US) emergency departments (EDs) within a 21-year study period.

Study Design

Descriptive epidemiology study.

Methods

The National Electronic Injury Surveillance System database was queried for data on lower extremity surfing injuries presenting to US EDs from January 1 to December 31, 2022. Data collected included year, injury mechanism, injury location, diagnosis, and disposition. The raw data were used to calculate national estimates (NEs) based on each hospital's assigned statistical sample weight. Linear regressions were performed to analyze annual trends.

Results

A total of 776 lower extremity surfing injuries were included (NE = 49,218 injuries). The mean age of the patients was 29.4 ± 13.6 years. The most common injured areas were the foot (NE = 17,411; 35.4%), lower leg (NE = 8673, 17.6%), and knee (NE = 8139; 16.5%). The most common mechanism of injury was impact with board (NE = 17,144; 34.8%), and the most common fracture locations were the lower leg (NE = 1195; 29.5%), ankle (NE = 1594; 24.5%), and foot (NE = 1495; 23.0%). There were statistically significant decreases in weighted estimates for lower extremity surfing injuries by 108 per year (P < .001), for lacerations by 76 per year (P < .001), and for sprains by 18 per year (P = .01). Impact-with-board injuries decreased by 59 injuries per year (P < .001) and constituted 63.5% of lacerations and 12.1% of fractures. Only 3.9% of patients were admitted for hospitalization.

Conclusion

There was a decreasing trend in lower extremity surfing injuries presenting to US EDs during the 21-year study period.

Fragile Statistical Findings in Randomized Controlled Trials Evaluating Autograft Versus Allograft Use in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Systematic Review

PURPOSE

To analyze the statistical stability of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating the surgical management of autografts versus allografts in the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) literature and calculate the fragility index (FI) and fragility quotient and explore a subgroup analysis by calculating the proportion of outcome events where the FI was less than the number of patients lost to follow-up.

METHODS

Using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, we conducted a systematic search in the PubMed and Cochrane databases to identify RCTs published between 2000 and 2022 that investigated the use of autografts versus allografts in ACLR literature and reported dichotomous data. The fragility index of each dichotomous variable was calculated through the reversal of a single outcome event until significance was reversed. The fragility quotient was calculated by dividing each fragility index by the study sample size. The interquartile range also was calculated.

RESULTS

Of the 4407 articles screened, 23 met the search criteria, with 11 RCTs evaluating ALCR using autografts and allografts included for analysis. Two hundred and 18 outcome events with 32 significant (P < .05) outcomes and 186 nonsignificant (P ≥ .05) outcomes were identified. The overall fragility index and fragility quotient for all 218 outcomes were 6 subjects (interquartile range 5-8) and 0.058 (interquartile range 0.039-0.077). Fragility analysis of statistically significant outcomes and nonsignificant outcomes had a fragility index of 3.5 (interquartile range 1-5.5) and 6 (interquartile range 5-8), respectively. All of the studies reported a loss to follow-up where 45.5% (5) reported a loss to follow-up greater or equal to 6.

CONCLUSIONS

The RCTs in the ACLR peer-reviewed literature evaluating autograft versus allograft use are vulnerable to a small number of outcome event reversals and exemplify significant statistical fragility in statistically significant findings.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level I, systematic review of Level I studies.

Randomized Controlled Trials Comparing Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone Versus Hamstring Tendon Autografts in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Surgery Are Statistically Fragile: A Systematic Review

PURPOSE

To assess the statistical fragility of recently published randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing the use of hamstring tendon autograft with bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

METHODS

The PubMed, Embase, and MEDLINE databases were queried for RCTs published since 2010 comparing autograft type (bone-patellar tendon-bone vs hamstring tendon) in ACL reconstruction surgery. The fragility index (FI) and reverse FI (rFI) were determined for significant and nonsignificant outcomes, respectively, as the number of outcome reversals required to change statistical significance. The fragility quotient (FQ) and reverse FQ, representing fragility as a proportion of the study population, were calculated by dividing the FI and rFI, respectively, by the sample size.

RESULTS

We identified 19 RCTs reporting 55 total dichotomous outcomes. The median FI of the 55 total outcomes was 5 (interquartile range [IQR], 4-7), meaning a median of 5 outcome event reversals would alter the outcomes' significance. Five outcomes were reported as statistically significant with a median FI of 4 (IQR, 2-6), meaning a median of 4 outcome event reversals would change outcomes to be nonsignificant. Fifty outcomes were reported as nonsignificant with a median rFI of 5 (IQR, 4-7), meaning a median of 5 outcome event reversals would change outcomes to be significant. The FQ and reverse FQ for significant and nonsignificant outcomes were 0.025 (IQR, 0.018-0.045) and 0.082 (IQR, 0.041-0.106), respectively. For 61.8% of outcomes, patients lost to follow-up exceeded the corresponding FI or rFI.

CONCLUSIONS

There is substantial statistical fragility in recent RCTs on autograft choice in ACL reconstruction surgery given that altering a few outcome events is sufficient to reverse study findings. For over half of outcomes, maintaining patients lost to follow-up may have been sufficient to reverse study conclusions.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

We recommend co-reporting FIs and P values to provide a more comprehensive representation of a study's conclusions when conducting an RCT.

The Statistical Fragility of Marrow Stimulation for Cartilage Defects of the Knee: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

OBJECTIVE

Marrow stimulation is used to address knee cartilage defects. In this study, we used the fragility index (FI), reverse fragility index (rFI), and fragility quotient (FQ) to evaluate statistical fragility of outcomes reported in randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating marrow stimulation.

DESIGN

PubMed, Embase, and MEDLINE were queried for recent RCTs (January 1, 2010-September 5, 2023) assessing marrow stimulation for cartilage defects of the knee. The FI and rFI were calculated as the number of outcome event reversals required to alter statistical significance for significant and nonsignificant outcomes, respectively. The FQ was determined by dividing the FI by the study sample size.

RESULTS

Across 155 total outcomes from 21 RCTs, the median FI was 3 (interquartile range [IQR], 2-5), with an associated median FQ of 0.067 (IQR, 0.033-0.010). Thirty-two outcomes were statistically significant, with a median FI of 2 (IQR, 1-3.25) and FQ of 0.050 (IQR, 0.025-0.069). Ten of the 32 (31.3%) outcomes reported as statistically significant had an FI of 1. In total, 123 outcomes were nonsignificant, with a median rFI of 3 (IQR, 2-5). Studies assessing stem cell augments were the most fragile, with a median FI of 2. In 55.5% of outcomes, the number of patients lost to follow-up was greater than or equal to the FI.

CONCLUSION

Statistical findings in RCTs evaluating marrow stimulation for cartilage defects of the knee are statistically fragile. We recommend combined reporting of P-values with FI and FQ metrics to aid in the interpretation of clinical findings in comparative trials assessing cartilage restoration.

Statistical Outcomes Guiding Periprosthetic Joint Infection Prevention and Revision Are Fragile: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

BACKGROUND

Dichotomous outcomes are frequently reported in orthopaedic research and have substantial clinical implications. This study utilizes the fragility index (FI) and fragility quotient (FQ) metrics to determine the statistical stability of outcomes reported in total joint arthroplasty randomized controlled trials (RCTs) relating to periprosthetic joint infection (PJI).

METHODS

The RCTs that reported dichotomous data related to PJI published between January 1, 2010, and December 31, 2022, were evaluated. The FI and reverse FI (RFI) were defined as the number of outcome event reversals required to reverse the significance of significant and nonsignificant outcomes, respectively. The FQ was determined by dividing the FI or RFI by the respective sample size. There were 108 RCTs screened, and 17 studies included for analysis.

RESULTS

A total of 58 outcome events were identified, with a median FI of 4 (interquartile range [IQR] 2 to 5) and associated FQ of 0.0417 (IQR 0.0145 to 0.0602). The 13 statistically significant outcomes had a median FI of 1 (IQR 1 to 2) and FQ of 0.00935 (IQR 0.00629 to 0.01410). The 45 nonsignificant outcomes had a median RFI of 4 (IQR 3 to 5) and FQ of 0.05 (IQR 0.0361 to 0.0723). The number of patients lost to follow-up was greater than or equal to the FI in 46.6% of outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

Statistical outcomes in RCTs analyzing PJI are fragile and may lack statistical integrity. We recommend a comprehensive fragility analysis, with the reporting of FI and FQ metrics, to aid in the interpretation of outcomes in the total joint arthroplasty literature.

Variability of MCID, SCB, and PASS Thresholds in Studies Assessing Patient-Reported Outcomes After Rotator Cuff Repair: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

An increasing reliance on patient-reported outcomes has led to greater emphasis on minimal clinically important difference (MCID), substantial clinical benefit (SCB), and Patient Acceptable Symptom State (PASS) thresholds in assessing rotator cuff repairs.

PURPOSE

To review the MCID, SCB, and PASS thresholds reported for patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) after rotator cuff repair.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

The PubMed, Embase, Ovid, Cochrane, and Google Scholar databases were queried for full-text journal articles in English published between January 1, 2000, and May 31, 2022. Studies with MCID, SCB, and PASS thresholds reported for patients with rotator cuff repair and a minimum of 12 months of follow-up were included. Reported MCID, SCB, and PASS thresholds and associated calculation methods were extracted.

RESULTS

There were 41 unique studies (6331 shoulders) that met the inclusion criteria. Of these, 37 (90%) reported MCID; 16 (39%), PASS; and 11 (27%), SCB values. The most common PROMs were the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score and the Constant-Murley score. In total, 71% (29/41) of these studies referenced values in the literature, usually studies of patients undergoing rotator cuff repair (21/29). Twelve studies calculated MCID, SCB, or PASS thresholds using anchor-based approaches, whereas 6 studies also calculated thresholds using distribution-based methods. The use of MCID, SCB, and PASS in the rotator cuff repair literature is increasing, with half of the included studies published within the final 17 months of the studied period.

CONCLUSION

Significant variability was seen in the reporting of MCID, SCB, and PASS threshold values after rotator cuff repair. Researchers should prioritize studies that report clinical outcome thresholds calculated using anchor-based methods and should critically review both the anchor question and its response choices. Standardization of MCID, SCB, and PASS values and calculation methods will allow for a more reliable assessment of PROMs in rotator cuff repair moving forward.

The Finger, Wrist, and Shoulder are the Most Commonly Injured Areas in Youth Volleyball Players but the Incidence of Injuries Decreased Overall Between 2012 and 2022

Purpose

To analyze epidemiology, mechanisms, and diagnoses of upper extremity volleyball injuries in youth who present to United States emergency departments.

Methods

Data from the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System were analyzed for upper extremity volleyball injuries in patients ≤18 years old from January 1, 2012, to December 31, 2022. Data were collected for body part, diagnosis, mechanism of injury, and disposition. Weighted national estimates were calculated using the hospitals' corresponding statistical sample weights. Linear regressions were used to analyze annual trends. χ2 tests were used to analyze categorical variables.

Results

A weighted national estimate of 131,624 upper extremity volleyball-related injuries occurred in the study period. Average age was 13.9 ± 2.3 years. Female patients constituted 77.6% of patients; 99.3% of patients did not require admission. The most common body parts injured were fingers (43.0%), wrists (22.8%), and shoulders (12.2%). The most common identifiable mechanisms of injury were impacts with the floor (19.4%), impacts with the ball (14.7%), and spikes/serves (5.7%). Most common diagnoses were strains/sprains (42.6%) and fractures (19.5%). Most common locations of fracture were fingers (57.4% of all fractures), wrists (16.6%), and lower arms (12.4%). There was a decrease of 544 overall injuries per year (P = .03, 95% confidence interval [CI] -1031 to -58). Female players experienced more contusions/abrasions (16.0% vs 9.9%, P < .001) and strains/sprains (46.1% vs 30.4%, P < .001) compared with male players. Female patients had decreases of 513 overall injuries (P = .01, 95% CI -881 to -144), 349 strains/sprains (P = .002, 95% CI -530 to -168), 102 contusions/abrasions (P = .008, 95% CI 170 to -34), and 92 fractures per year (P = .03, 95% CI -175 to -10).

Conclusions

Youth volleyball players are at risk of upper extremity injury, particularly involving the fingers, wrist, and shoulder. Despite increasing national participation in youth volleyball, there is a decreasing incidence of upper extremity injuries.

Level of Evidence

Level IV, prognostic case series.

Epidemiology and Sex-Specific Analysis of Basketball-Related Lower Extremity Fractures: A 10-Year Analysis of National Injury Data

BACKGROUND

Basketball-related fractures involving the lower extremities frequently present to emergency departments (ED) in the United States (US). This study aimed to identify the primary mechanisms, distribution, and trends of these injuries.

HYPOTHESIS

We hypothesize that (1) lower extremity fracture frequency will decrease from 2013 to 2022, (2) the ankle will be the most common fracture site, and (3) noncontact twisting will be the most common injury mechanism.

STUDY DESIGN

Descriptive epidemiological.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 3.

METHODS

The National Electronic Injury Surveillance System (NEISS) was queried for lower extremity fractures from basketball presenting to US EDs from January 1, 2013 to December 31, 2022. Patient demographics, injury location, and disposition were recorded. The injury mechanism was characterized using the provided narrative. National estimates (NEs) were calculated using the NEISS statistical sample weight. Injury trends were evaluated by linear regression.

RESULTS

There were 6259 cases (NE: 185,836) of basketball-related lower extremity fractures. Linear regression analysis of annual trends demonstrated a significant decrease in lower extremity fractures over the study period (2013-2022: P = 0.01; R2 = 0.64). The most common injury mechanism was a noncontact twisting motion (NE: 49,897, 26.9%) followed by jumping (NE: 39,613, 21.3%). The ankle was the most common fracture site (NE: 69,936, 37.6%) followed by the foot (NE: 49,229, 26.49%). While ankle and foot fractures decreased significantly (P < 0.05), fractures of the lower leg, knee, toe, and upper leg showed no significant trends (P = 0.09, 0.75, 0.07, and 0.85, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Basketball-related lower extremity fractures decreased from 2013 to 2022, with the ankle being the most common fracture site and most fractures arising from a noncontact twist. Increasing utilization of outpatient clinics may have contributed to the decline, particularly for ankle and foot fractures. The prevalence of ankle fractures and twisting-related injuries reinforces the importance of protective footwear and targeted strengthening protocols.

The fragility of statistical findings in the reverse total shoulder arthroplasty literature: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials

BACKGROUND

Reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RTSA) has seen increasing utilization as an effective intervention for a wide variety of shoulder pathologies. The scope and indications for growth are often driven by findings from randomized controlled trials (RCTs) guiding surgical decision-making for RTSA. In this study, we utilized the fragility index (FI), reverse fragility index (rFI), and fragility quotient (FQ) to assess the robustness of outcomes reported in RCTs in the RTSA literature.

METHODS

PubMed, Embase, and MEDLINE were queried for RCTs (Jan. 1, 2010-Mar. 31, 2023) in the RTSA literature reporting dichotomous outcomes. The FI and rFI were defined as the number of outcome reversals required to alter statistical significance for significant and nonsignificant outcomes, respectively. The FQ was determined by dividing the FI by the sample size of each study. Subgroup analysis was performed based on outcome category.

RESULTS

One hundred seventy-six RCTs were screened with 18 studies included. The median FI across 59 total outcomes was 4 (interquartile range [IQR]: 3-5) with an associated FQ of 0.051 (IQR: 0.029-0.065). Thirteen outcomes were statistically significant with a median FI of 3 (IQR: 1-4) and FQ of 0.033 (IQR: 0.012-0.066). Forty-six outcomes were nonsignificant with a median rFI of 4 (IQR: 3-5) and FQ of 0.055 (IQR: 0.032-0.065). The most fragile outcome category was revision/reoperations with a median FI of 2.50 (IQR: 1.00-3.25), followed by clinical score/outcome (median FI: 3.00), complications (median FI: 4.00), "other" (median FI: 4.00), and radiographic findings (median FI: 5.00). Notably, the number of patients lost to follow-up was greater than or equal to the FI for 59% of outcomes.

CONCLUSION

The statistical findings in RTSA RCTs are fragile and should be interpreted with caution. Reversal of only a few outcomes, or maintaining postoperative follow-up, may be sufficient to alter significance of study findings. We recommend standardized reporting of P values with FI and FQ metrics to allow clinicians to effectively assess the robustness of study findings.

The statistical fragility of outcomes in calcaneus fractures: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials

INTRODUCTION

The purpose of this study was to utilize the fragility index to assess the robustness of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating the management of calcaneus fractures. We hypothesize that the dichotomous outcomes in calcaneus fracture literature will be statistically fragile and comparable to other orthopedic specialties.

METHODS

We performed a PubMed search for calcaneus fracture RCTs from 2000 to 2022 using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA). The fragility index (FI) of each outcome was calculated through the reversal of a single outcome event until significance was reversed. The fragility quotient (FQ) was calculated by dividing each fragility index by study sample size. The interquartile range (IQR) was also calculated for the FI and FQ.

RESULTS

Of the 3003 studies screened, 97 met the search criteria, with 19 RCTs evaluating calcaneus fractures included in the analysis. Seventy-nine dichotomous outcomes with 30 significant (P < 0.05) outcomes and 49 with nonsignificant (P> 0.05) outcomes were identified. The overall FI and FQ of all outcomes were 6 (IQR 3-8) and 0.067 (IQR 0.032-0.100), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The literature surrounding calcaneus fractures may not be as statistically stable as previously thought. The sole reliance on the P value may depict misleading results. We, therefore, recommend reporting the P value in conjunction with the FI and FQ to give a robust contextualization of clinical findings in the calcaneus fracture literature.

The Fragility of Statistical Significance in Sham Orthopaedic Surgery: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to determine the stability of statistical findings among sham surgery randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in orthopaedic surgery using fragility analysis.

METHODS

PubMed systematic review was conducted to include studies reporting dichotomous outcomes pertaining to sham surgery. The final review included eight RCTs involving only partial meniscectomies and vertebroplasties from 2009 to 2020. With a fixed sample size with dichotomous outcome measures (events versus non-events), the Total Fragility Index (TFI), which is composed of the fragility index (FI) and reverse fragility index (RFI), was calculated by altering the ratio of events to non-events in an iterative fashion until results were reversed from significant to nonsignificant findings (FI) or vice versa (RFI). The TFI, FI, and RFI were divided by their sample sizes to obtain the respective total fragility quotient, fragility quotient (FQ), and reverse fragility quotient. Median fragility indices and quotients were reported for all studies.

RESULTS

The eight RCTs included 50 dichotomous outcomes involving either partial meniscectomies or vertebroplasties, with a median TFI and total fragility quotient of 5 [interquartile range (IQR) 4 to 6] and 0.035 (IQR 0.028 to 0.048), respectively, indicating that a median of five total patients or 3.5 per 100 patients would need to experience a different outcome to reverse significant or insignificant findings for each of the eight trials. Among the 8 statistically significant ( P < 0.05) outcome events (16%), the respective FI and FQ were 2 (IQR 1 to 5) and 0.018 (IQR 0.010 to 0.044). Among the 42 statistically insignificant outcome events (84%), the respective RFI and reverse fragility quotient were 5 (IQR 4 to 6) and 0.04 (IQR 0.034 to 0.048). The median number of patients lost to follow-up was 1.5 (IQR 0.5 to 2).

CONCLUSION

The unstable findings in partial meniscectomy and vertebroplasty sham surgical RCTs undermine their study conclusions and recommendations. We recommend using fragility analysis in future sham surgical RCTs to contextualize statistical findings.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV; Systematic Review.

Decreasing Trend in Upper Extremity Surfing Injuries Presenting to United States Emergency Departments - A 20-Year Analysis

Surfing is a globally popular recreational sport with limited epidemiologic data. Currently, there is a paucity of literature regarding injury profiles and mechanisms of orthopaedic-related injuries. This study analyzed trends, etiologies, and diagnoses of upper extremity orthopaedic-related surfing injuries presenting to United States (US) emergency departments. The National Electronic Injury Surveillance System database was accessed to query upper extremity surfing-related injuries presenting to US emergency departments from January 1, 2002 to December 31, 2021. Data were analyzed for year, body part, mechanism of injury, diagnosis, and disposition. National estimates were calculated based on the assigned statistical sample weight of each hospital. A total of 33 323 surfing-related injuries were included. The most common upper extremity body parts involved 15 169 shoulders (45.5%), 4220 fingers (12.7%), and 3753 hands (11.3%). The most common identifiable mechanisms of injuries were 7474 board-to-body (22.4%), 4188 impact with sand (12.6%), and 2639 impact with water (7.9%). Overuse constituted 7.2% of overall upper extremity injuries but 40% of strains. Only 2.2% of injuries required hospital admission. Between 2002 and 2021, there was a decreasing annual trend in upper extremity surfing-related injuries (P=.01). The decreasing trend in emergency department visits may be due to urgent care utilization and training for surfers and lifeguards to manage these injuries on-site, as the majority were minor given the small proportion requiring hospital admission. Chronic stress on rotator cuff and peri-scapular musculature while paddling in the prone position likely contributed to the large proportion of overuse injury.

Statistical Fragility of Randomized Controlled Trials Evaluating Platelet-Rich Plasma Use for Knee Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review

Background

Numerous studies have been published on the use of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) for knee osteoarthritis (OA), with conflicting results.

Purpose

To determine the fragility index (FI) and fragility quotient (FQ) of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that evaluated the use of PRP to treat knee OA.

Study Design

Systematic review.

Methods

RCTs evaluating the efficacy of PRP injections for knee OA from 2000 to 2020 were included for analysis according to PRISMA guidelines. The FI was determined by calculating the number of outcome event reversals required to change the statistical significance. The associated FQ was determined by dividing the FI by the sample size.

Results

Our initial search resulted in 41,149 studies, of which 8 RCTs (678 patients, 72 outcome events) were included in the analysis. One study failed to report PRP formulation details, whereas 87.5% of studies reported using either leukocyte-rich or leukocyte-poor PRP. The platelet concentration was reported in 25% of the included trials. The overall FI of the 72 outcome events was 8.5. Accounting for sample size, the associated FQ was determined to be 0.14, suggesting that the reversal of 14% of outcome events was required to change outcome significance. There were 51 statistically significant outcomes, of which the FI and FQ were 12 and 0.164, respectively.

Conclusion

Comprehensive fragility analysis suggested that the published literature evaluating the efficacy of PRP use for knee OA may lack statistical stability. We recommend the reporting of both an FI and FQ in addition to P value analysis to provide a clear and thorough understanding of the statistical integrity of studies reporting on PRP use for knee OA.

The Fragility of Tourniquet Use in Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

BACKGROUND

Physicians utilize P-values to interpret clinical trial data and guide patient-care decisions. Fragility analysis assesses the stability of statistical findings in relation to outcome event reversals. This study assessed the statistical fragility of recent randomized controlled trials (RCTs) investigating tourniquet use in total knee arthroplasty (TKA).

METHODS

We queried PubMed, EMBASE, and MEDLINE for RCTs comparing outcomes in TKA based on tourniquet use. Fragility index (FI) and reverse fragility index (reverse FI) were calculated - for significant and nonsignificant outcomes, respectively - as the number of outcome reversals required to change statistical significance. The fragility quotient (FQ) was calculated by dividing the FI or reverse FI by the sample size. Median overall FI and FQ were calculated for all included outcomes, and sub-analyses were performed by reported significance. The literature search yielded 23 studies reporting 91 total dichotomous outcomes.

RESULTS

Overall median FI was 4 with an interquartile range (IQR) of 3 to 6. Overall median FQ was 0.0476 (IQR 0.0291 to 0.0867). A total of 11 outcomes were statistically significant with a median FI and FQ of 2 (IQR 1.5 to 5) and 0.0200 (IQR 0.0148 to 0.0484), respectively. There were 80 outcomes that were nonsignificant with a median reverse FI of 4 (IQR 3 to 6). Loss to follow-up was greater than the median FI in 17.6% of outcomes.

CONCLUSION

Altering a small number of outcomes is often sufficient to reverse findings in RCTs evaluating tourniquet use in TKA. We recommend including fragility analyses to increase reliability in the interpretation of study conclusions.

The Fragility of Statistical Findings in Distal Biceps Tendon Repairs: a Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this present study was to perform a fragility analysis to assess the robustness of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating the distal biceps tendon repairs. We hypothesize that the dichotomous outcomes will be statistically fragile and higher fragility will exist among statistically significant outcomes comparable to other orthopedic specialties.

METHODS

Following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA), randomized controlled trials from 4 orthopedic journals indexed on PubMed from 2000 to 2022 reporting dichotomous measures relating to distal biceps tendon repairs were included. The fragility index (FI) of each outcome was calculated through the reversal of a single outcome event until significance was reversed. The fragility quotient (FQ) was calculated by dividing each fragility index by study sample size. The interquartile range (IQR) was also calculated for the FI and FQ.

RESULTS

Of the 1038 articles screened, seven RCTs containing 24 dichotomous outcomes were included for analysis. The fragility index and fragility quotient of all outcomes was 6.5 (IQR 4-9) and 0.077 (IQR 0.031-0.123), respectively. However, statistically significant outcomes had a fragility index and fragility quotient of 2 (IQR 2-7) and 0.036 (IQR 0.025-0.091), respectively. The average number of patients lost to follow-up was 2.7 patients with 28.6% of the included studies reporting loss to follow-up (LTF) greater than or equal to 6.5.

CONCLUSIONS

The literature surrounding distal biceps tendon repair may not be as stable as previously thought and presents a similar fragility index to other orthopedic subspecialties. We therefore recommend triple reporting the P value, fragility index and fragility quotient to aid in the interpretation of clinical findings reported in biceps tendon repair literature.

The statistical fragility of the distal fibula fracture literature: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to apply both the fragility index (FI) and fragility quotient (FQ) to evaluate the degree of statistical fragility in the distal fibular fracture (DFF) literature. We hypothesized that the dichotomous outcomes within the DFF literature are statistically fragile.

METHODS

We performed a PubMed search for distal fibular fractures clinical trials from 2000 to 2022 reporting dichotomous outcomes. The FI of each outcome was calculated through the reversal of a single outcome event until significance was reversed. The FQ was calculated by dividing each fragility index by study sample size. The interquartile range (IQR) was also calculated for the FI and FQ.

RESULTS

Of the 1158 articles screened, 23 met the search criteria, with six RCTs included for analysis. Forty-five outcome events with 5 significant (p < 0.05) outcomes and 40 nonsignificant (p ≥ 0.05) outcomes were identified. The overall FI and FQ was 5 (IQR 4-6) and 0.089 (IQR 0.061-0.107), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The randomized controlled trials in the peer-reviewed distal fibular fracture literature may not be as robust as previously thought, as incorporating statistical analyses solely on a P value threshold is misleading. Standardized reporting of the P value, FI and FQ can help the clinician reliably draw conclusions based on the fragility of outcome measures.

The Statistical Fragility of Orbital Fractures: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

BACKGROUND

The P value has often been used as a tool to determine the statistical significance and evaluate the statistical robustness of study findings in orthopedic literature. The purpose of this study is to apply both the fragility index (FI) and the fragility quotient (FQ) to evaluate the degree of statistical fragility in orbital fracture literature. We hypothesized that the dichotomous outcomes within the orbital fracture literature will be vulnerable to a small number of outcome event reversals and will be statistically fragile.

METHODS

Using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA), the authors identified all dichotomous data for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in orbital fracture literature and performed a PubMed search from 2000 to 2022. The FI of each outcome was calculated through the reversal of a single outcome event until significance was reversed. The FQ was calculated by dividing each FI by study sample size. The interquartile range (IQR) was also calculated for the FI and FQ.

RESULTS

Of the 3,329 studies screened, 28 met the criteria with 10 RCTs evaluating orbital fractures included for analysis. A total of 58 outcome events with 22 significant (P < .05) outcomes and 36 nonsignificant (P ≥ .05) outcomes were identified. The overall FI and FQ for all 58 outcomes was 5 (IQR: 4 to 5) and 0.140 (IQR: 0.075 to 0.250), respectively. Fragility analysis of statistical significant outcomes and nonsignificant outcomes had an FI of 3.5 with no IQR and 5 (IQR 4-5), respectively. All of the studies reported a loss to follow-up data, where 20% (2) was greater than the overall FI of 5.

CONCLUSION

The orbital fracture literature provides treatment guidance by relying on statistical significant results from RCTs. However, the RCTs in the orbital fracture peer-reviewed literature may not be statistically stable as previously thought. The sole reliance of the P value may depict misleading results. Thus, we recommend standardizing the reporting of the P value, FI, and FQ in the orbital fracture literature to aid readers in reliably drawing conclusions based on fragility outcome measures impacting clinical decision-making.

Open and arthroscopic management of femoroacetabular impingement: a review of current concepts

Femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) is a common femoral and/or acetabular abnormality that can cause progressive damage to the hip and osteoarthritis. FAI can be the result of femoral head/neck overgrowth, acetabular overgrowth or both femoral and acetabular abnormalities, resulting in a loss of native hip biomechanics and pain upon hip flexion and rotation. Radiographic evidence can include loss of sphericity of the femoral neck (cam impingement) and/or acetabular retroversion with focal or global overcoverage (pincer impingement). Operative intervention is indicated in symptomatic patients after failed conservative management with radiographic evidence of impingement and minimal arthritic changes of the hip, with the goal of restoring normal hip biomechanics and reducing pain. This is done by correcting the femoral head-neck relationship to the acetabulum through femoral and/or acetabular osteoplasty and treatment of concomitant hip pathology. In pincer impingement cases with small lunate surfaces, reverse periacetabular osteotomy is indicated as acetabular osteoplasty can decrease an already small articular surface. While surgical dislocation is regarded as the traditional gold standard, hip arthroscopy has become widely utilized in recent years. Studies comparing both open surgery and arthroscopy have shown comparable long-term pain reduction and improvements in clinical measures of hip function, as well as similar conversion rates to total hip arthroplasty. However, arthroscopy has trended toward earlier improvement, quicker recovery and faster return to sports. The purpose of this study was to review the recent literature on open and arthroscopic management of FAI.

Clinical and Functional Outcomes by Graft Type in Superior Capsular Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

In recent years, superior capsular reconstruction (SCR) has emerged as a promising treatment for massive rotator cuff tears and has been performed with an array of graft options, most commonly dermal allograft and tensor fascia lata (TFL) autograft.

PURPOSE

To compare the clinical outcomes, functional outcomes, and complication rates after SCR performed with dermal allograft, TFL autograft, long head of the biceps tendon (LHBT) autograft, and porcine xenograft.

STUDY DESIGN

Meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

PubMed, Cochrane Library, and Embase were systematically reviewed for studies that enrolled ≥10 patients who underwent SCR and presented clinical outcome data at a minimum follow-up of 12 months. When available, pre- and postoperative patient-reported outcome scores and clinical examination data were extracted. Outcome data were then compared by graft type. A meta-analysis was also conducted of graft tear and reoperation rates after SCR with dermal allograft and TFL autograft.

RESULTS

Human dermal allograft and TFL autograft were each utilized in 7 studies, LHBT autograft in 2 studies, and porcine xenograft in 1 study. Dermal allograft, TFL autograft, and LHBT autograft demonstrated comparable median (range) postoperative American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons scores of 85.3 (77.5-89), 88.6 (73.7-94.3), and 82.7 (80-85.4), respectively. The median postoperative pain scores per visual analog scale for dermal allograft, TFL autograft, and LHBT autograft were 0.8, 2.5, and 1.4. Median postoperative forward elevation was 159.0°, 147.0°, 163.8°, and 151.4° for dermal allograft, TFL autograft, LHBT autograft, and porcine xenograft. Meta-analysis demonstrated a comparable pooled graft tear rate between TFL autograft (9%; 95% CI, 4%-16%) and dermal allograft (7%; 95% CI, 2%-13%). Similarly, the pooled reoperation rate was similar for TFL autograft (3%; 95% CI, 0%-7%) and dermal allograft (6%; 95% CI, 2%-12%). Among the 3 studies with pre- and postoperative information on pseudoparalysis, 73 of 76 (96%) patients with an intact/repairable subscapularis had a reversal of their pseudoparalysis after SCR.

CONCLUSION

Dermal allograft, TFL autograft, and LHBT autograft are all suitable options for SCR and demonstrate significant improvements in American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score, pain score per visual analog scale, and forward elevation. Moreover, dermal allograft and TFL autograft have comparable rates of graft tear and reoperation.

The Fragility of Statistical Significance in Patellofemoral Instability Research: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Fragility analysis is increasingly utilized to evaluate the robustness of results within the orthopaedic literature and has frequently revealed instability of reported outcomes.

PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS

The purpose of this investigation was to utilize a fragility analysis to evaluate the stability of reported results in the patellofemoral instability (PFI) literature. We hypothesized the demonstration of significant fragility in patellofemoral research to be similar to that identified throughout other areas of the orthopaedic literature.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

The PubMed database was queried from January 1, 2000, to October 10, 2020 for comparative trials in 10 prominent orthopaedic journals that reported dichotomous outcomes related to the management of PFI. The fragility index (FI) and the fragility quotient (FQ) were calculated for each individual outcome event, and the overall FI and FQ were determined for all included studies.

RESULTS

A total of 22 comparative studies comprising 11 randomized controlled trials and 11 nonrandomized trials were included for the analysis. A total of 75 outcome events underwent a fragility analysis and revealed a median FI and FQ of 3 (interquartile range [IQR], 1-5) and 0.043 (IQR, 0.018-0.081), respectively. Also 27% of included studies reported loss to follow-up greater than the overall FI, therefore suggesting the maintenance of the follow-up may have resulted in the reversal of significance.

CONCLUSION

The result of the comprehensive fragility analysis demonstrated a lack of robustness in PFI research with the alteration of only a few outcome events required to reverse statistical significance. We therefore recommend the triple reporting of the P value, the FI, and the FQ to aid in the interpretation of the statistical integrity of future comparative trials in the PFI literature.

The Statistical Fragility of Operative vs Nonoperative Management for Achilles Tendon Rupture: A Systematic Review of Comparative Studies

BACKGROUND

The statistical significance of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and comparative studies is often conveyed utilizing the P value. However, P values are an imperfect measure and may be vulnerable to a small number of outcome reversals to alter statistical significance. The interpretation of the statistical strength of these studies may be aided by the inclusion of a Fragility Index (FI) and Fragility Quotient (FQ). This study examines the statistical stability of studies comparing operative vs nonoperative management for Achilles tendon rupture.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed of 10 orthopaedic journals between 2000 and 2021 for comparative studies focusing on management of Achilles tendon rupture reporting dichotomous outcome measures. FI for each outcome was determined by the number of event reversals necessary to alter significance (P < .05). FQ was calculated by dividing the FI by the respective sample size. Additional subgroup analyses were performed.

RESULTS

Of 8020 studies screened, 1062 met initial search criteria with 17 comparative studies ultimately included for analysis, 10 of which were RCTs. A total of 40 outcomes were examined. Overall, the median FI was 2.5 (interquartile range [IQR] 2-4), the mean FI was 2.90 (±1.58), the median FQ was 0.032 (IQR 0.012-0.069), and the mean FQ was 0.049 (±0.062). The FI was less than the number of patients lost to follow-up for 78% of outcomes.

CONCLUSION

Studies examining the efficacy of operative vs nonoperative management of Achilles tendon rupture may not be as statistically stable as previously thought. The average number of outcome reversals needed to alter the significance of a given study was 2.90. Future analyses may benefit from the inclusion of a fragility index and a fragility quotient in their statistical analyses.

Rock climbing confers distinct injury risk in pediatric versus adult populations: an analysis of twenty-year national trends

OBJECTIVES

The sport of rock climbing has recently gained in popularity due in part to its adoption by noncompetitive athletes as a physical activity with a level of intensity that can be self-regulated. However, the epidemiology of rock climbing injuries is poorly described at the national level.

METHODS

We report demographic and injury characteristics from 85,235 national weighted estimates of rock climbing injuries presenting to United States (US) emergency departments (EDs) between 2000 and 2019 in the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System, stratifying by whether patients were ≤18 years of age (A) or ≥19 years of age (B).

RESULTS

The national weighted estimate of patients presenting to US EDs with injuries associated with rock climbing rose significantly (p < 0.001) from 2000 (2,667, CI 1,777-3,557) to 2019 (7,087, CI 4,544-9,630). Patients ≤18 years of age were significantly less likely to be male (A: 56.3%, CI 52.0-60.6%; B: 64.7%; CI 60.4-69.0%; p = 0.003), sustain injuries on weekends (A: 29.8%, 24.5-35.1%; B: 64.7%, CI 60.4-69.0%; p = 0.002), or sustain injuries during summer seasons (A: 26.6%, CI 22.1-31.1%; B: 33.2%, CI 28.1-38.3%; p = 0.049). Multivariate logistic regression demonstrated that patients ≤18 years of age were significantly more likely to present to EDs with head and neck (OR: 1.52, CI 1.04-2.21; p = 0.032) or upper extremity (OR: 1.55; CI 1.24-1.93; p < 0.001) injuries associated with rock climbing.

CONCLUSION

We identified a significant increase in the annual estimated number of patients presenting to US EDs with rock climbing injuries compared to what has previously been reported. As the number of climbers continues to grow, standardized safety policies may be implemented that specifically target injury mechanisms and patterns unique to both adult and pediatric populations.

Targeting rule implementation decreases neck injuries in high school football: a national injury surveillance study

OBJECTIVES

Neck injuries in football are attributed to helmet-to-helmet contact with youth players being at greatest risk. In 2014, the National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS) implemented rules defining illegal contact against a defenseless player above the shoulders to reduce head and neck injuries in football players. This study evaluates whether rule implementation decreased rates of high school football neck injuries presenting to the emergency department (ED) pre-rule implementation (2009-2013) to post-rule implementation (2015-2019).

METHODS

Data were queried from the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System for high school football players 14 to 18 years old diagnosed with a neck injury from 1 January 2009 to 31 December 2019. Narratives in the data were reviewed for mechanism of injury, setting, loss of consciousness (LOC), and type of injury.

RESULTS

Between 2009 and 2019, an estimated 47,577 high school football neck injuries were diagnosed in EDs across the United States. 52.0% of neck injuries were sustained during competition compared to 48.0% during practice. A statistically significant (P = 0.004) decrease in neck injuries was realized from pre-rule implementation to post-rule implementation with averages of 5,278 and 3,481 injuries per year, respectively. Helmet-to-helmet neck injuries significantly (P = 0.04) decreased from pre- to post-rule implementation with averages of 851 and 508 injuries per year, respectively. Neck injuries sustained via other mechanisms were not affected by the 2014 rule implementation.

CONCLUSION

This study is the first to identify a decrease in overall and helmet-to-helmet related neck injuries diagnosed in the ED following the 2014 NFHS targeting rule implementation. These findings add to the growing literature regarding the importance and efficacy of rule implementation in reducing sports-related neck injuries.

Acute Vertebral Fractures in Skiing and Snowboarding: A 20-Year Sex-Specific Analysis of National Injury Data

Background:

The epidemiology of acute vertebral fractures (AVFs) sustained while skiing and snowboarding remains poorly defined in the United States.

Hypothesis:

It was hypothesized that there would be no significant differences across sex and a greater number of AVFs in younger age groups associated with skiing and snowboarding.

Study Design:

Descriptive epidemiological study.

Methods:

The authors utilized the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System to identify patients who were reported in emergency departments in the United States from 2000 to 2019. All patients were noted to have sustained AVFs during skiing or snowboarding. National estimates and demographic analysis were performed.

Results:

A total of 466 AVFs were identified, or roughly 23.3 AVFs per year. Compared with women, men accounted for the majority of AVFs sustained in both skiing and snowboarding: 67.8% (95% CI, 62.6%-73.0%) during skiing and 82.1% (95% CI, 76.3%-87.8%) during snowboarding. This represented a significantly larger percentage of AVFs while snowboarding compared with skiing (P = .002). Women accounted for 32.2% (95% CI, 27.0%-37.4%) of AVFs while skiing and 17.9% (95% CI, 12.2%-23.7%) while snowboarding, which indicated a significantly larger percentage of AVFs sustained during skiing compared with snowboarding (P = .002). Snowboarders were more likely than skiers to sustain an AVF in the region of the coccyx (21.5% [95% CI, 14.3%-28.7%] vs 11.5% [95% CI, 3.5%-16.9%], respectively; P = .003) and as a result of a fall at ground level (69.2% [95% CI, 62.1%-76.4%] vs 52.8% [95% CI, 43.2%-62.4%], respectively; P = .009). A significant decrease in the number of snowboarding-related AVFs was identified over the 20-year study period: 899 in 2000-2003 versus 283 in 2016-2019 (P < .01). The change in skiing-related AVFs over the study period was not statistically significant (694 vs 462; P = .5).

Conclusion:

This national study of AVFs sustained while skiing and snowboarding identified critical sex- and age-specific differences in the population at risk, anatomic location of injury, and mechanism of injury. The national data generated from this study over a 20-year period may be utilized to better inform public health injury awareness and prevention initiatives in the rapidly growing sports of skiing and snowboarding.

Comorbidity scores reported in anatomic and reverse total shoulder arthroplasty: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Due to the aging population, the number of reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) and anatomic shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) continue to increase annually. Although outcome measures are frequently reported in literature for patients who undergo shoulder arthroplasty, no studies have analyzed reporting of patient comorbidities in this population. The purpose of this study was to evaluate reporting of comorbidity indices in shoulder arthroplasty literature and assess how this reporting may inform management and outcomes.

METHODS

A database was compiled systematically using PubMed to identify articles pertaining to shoulder arthroplasty published between 2019 and 2021. The search terms, "reverse shoulder arthroplasty" and "anatomic shoulder arthroplasty," were used to identify clinical studies. Non-clinical (e.g., translational and basic science) and review articles were excluded. Included studies were then analyzed for reporting of comorbidity indices.

RESULTS

A total of 199 articles were included in this review and reported comorbidities. Of these, 15.6% (31 of 199) pertained to TSA, while 84.4% (168 of 199) pertained to RSA. Within this review, 57.8% (115 of 199) articles utilized comorbidity scores, while 42.2% (84 of 199) reported only comorbid diagnoses. Among the scores utilized, the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) physical status classification system was the most widely used among both the TSA (52.9%, 9 of 17) and the RSA studies (58.2%, 57 of 98). Additional scores within the RSA literature included the Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI) (35.3%, 6 of 17), the Charlson Comorbidity Index by Deyo et al. (J Clin Epidemiol. 45(6):613-9, 1992) (CCI-Deyo; 5.9%, 1 of 17), the Modified Charlson Comorbidity Index (modified-CCI) (5.9%, 1 of 17), the Elixhauser et al. (Med Care. 36(1):8-27, 1998) Comorbidity Measure (ECM) (11.8%, 2 of 17), and the Modified Frailty Index (mFI) (5.9%, 1 of 17). With the TSA literature, the additional comorbidity scores included the CCI (30.6%, 30 of 98), the CCI-Deyo (6.1%, 6 of 98), the modified-CCI (1.0%, 1 of 98), the ECM (8.2%, 8 of 98), the Factor-5 modified Frailty Index (mFI-5) (1.0%, 1 of 98), and the mFI (1.0%, 1 of 98).

CONCLUSION

The reporting of comorbidity indices is an important factor when considering patient outcomes and complications reported in shoulder arthroplasty literature. Although the reporting of these scores appears to be more prevalent in current literature, there is no standard or consistency in terms of which scores are reported. Given this diversity in comorbidity scores, further research is necessary to develop a single standardized score to properly analyze the effect of comorbidities on shoulder arthroplasty patient outcomes.

Statistical Fragility of Single-Row Versus Double-Row Anchoring for Rotator Cuff Repair: A Systematic Review of Comparative Studies

Background:

Comparative studies and randomized controlled trials (RCTs) often use the P (probability) value to convey the statistical significance of their findings. P values are an imperfect measure, however, and are vulnerable to a small number of outcome reversals to alter statistical significance. The inclusion of a fragility index (FI) and fragility quotient (FQ) may aid in the interpretation of a study’s statistical strength.

Purpose/Hypothesis:

The purpose of this study was to examine the statistical stability of studies comparing single-row to double-row rotator cuff repair. It was hypothesized that the findings of these studies would be vulnerable to a small number of outcome event reversals, often fewer than the number of patients lost to follow-up.

Study Design:

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods:

We analyzed comparative studies and RCTs on primary single-row versus double-row rotator cuff repair that were published between 2000 and 2021 in 10 leading orthopaedic journals. Statistical significance was defined as a P < .05. The FI for each outcome was determined by the number of event reversals necessary to alter significance. The FQ was calculated by dividing the FI by the respective sample size.

Results:

Of 4896 studies screened, 22 comparative studies, 10 of which were RCTs, were ultimately included for analysis. A total of 74 outcomes were examined. Overall, the median FI was 2 (interquartile range [IQR], 1-3), and the median FQ was 0.035 (IQR, 0.020-0.057). The mean FI was 2.55 ± 1.29, and the mean FQ was 0.043 ± 0.027. In 64% of outcomes, the FI was less than the number of patients lost to follow-up.) Additionally, 81% of significant outcomes needed just a single outcome reversal to lose their significance.

Conclusion:

Over half of the studies currently used to guide clinical practice have a number of patients lost to follow-up greater than their FI. The results of these studies should be interpreted within the context of these limitations. Future analyses may benefit from the inclusion of the FI and the FQ in their statistical analyses.

Outcomes and failure rates after revision meniscal repair: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

The purpose of this meta-analysis is to determine the outcomes and failure rates for revision meniscus repairs in patients with re-tears after primary repair failure.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted using PubMed and Embase with the terms "Meniscus," "Meniscal," "Revised," and "Revision." The search strategy was based on the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Meta-Analyses) protocol and included four articles (79 patients). The search criteria were limited to studies reporting outcomes and failure rates. The exclusion criteria included languages other than English, biomechanical studies, letters to editors, non-full text, review articles, meta-analysis, and case reports.

RESULTS

Four comparative studies with 79 patients (53 males, 26 females) with a mean age of 23.9 ± 6.4 years treated with a revision meniscus repair were included in the final analysis. Within this analysis, we found a failure rate of 25.3% (20 of 79 patients). Of these failed repairs, 30.95% (13 of 42) were of the medial meniscus, and 18.9% (7 of 37) were of the lateral meniscus. In the four articles, the postoperative Tegner sports activity score was found to be 6.1 ± 1.6 (range, 2 to 10). The post-operative Lysholm score was reported in three articles (45 patients). At a mean follow-up of 58.3 ± 23.9 months, the mean post-operative Lysholm score was 89.1 ± 7.6 (range, 38 to 100). The Coleman score for the included articles ranged between 52 and 59.

CONCLUSION

This analysis found that revision meniscus repairs in patients with re-tears after primary repair failure result in clinical outcomes similar to that of primary repairs.

The Effect of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the Mental and Emotional Health of Athletes: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has caused the cancellation or postponement of virtually every sporting event, resulting in training disruptions, income loss, and career uncertainties for athletes around the world. At present, the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on the mental and emotional health of athletes is not well understood.

PURPOSE

To investigate the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on the mental and emotional health of athletes and to identify risk factors associated with poor mental health outcomes.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

The PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library databases were searched to identify all articles reporting on athletes' mental and emotional health during the COVID-19 pandemic. Articles were selected based on relevant inclusion and exclusion criteria. Study characteristics, athlete demographics, and COVID-19 mental health data (sex-, type of sport-, and level of play-specific differences) were collected from each included article and analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 35 studies were included in the final analysis, comprising athletes around the world and across numerous sports and levels of play. Most studies utilized at least 1 validated mental health questionnaire and assessed for outcomes such as depression, anxiety, stress, motivation, and athletic identity. Overall, athletes reported worse mental and emotional health during the COVID-19 pandemic, although these effects were attenuated by home training programs and quarantine training camps. Female sex and more elite levels of play were associated with an increased risk for poor mental health outcomes. Type of sport was associated with mixed results, with individual and team sports carrying different increased risks for poor mental and emotional health. Nearly all studies recommended the need for increased psychological support of athletes during the COVID-19 pandemic.

CONCLUSION

The effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on the mental and emotional health of athletes is complex and multifaceted. Increased social interactions with coaches and teammates, continued access to training facilities and mental health professionals, and active utilization of healthy coping mechanisms can improve mental health outcomes for athletes in the era of COVID-19.

Socioeconomic Status Impacts Access to Orthopaedic Specialty Care

»

Financial, personal, and structural barriers affect access to all aspects of orthopaedic specialty care.

»

Disparities in access to care are present across all subspecialties of orthopaedic surgery in the United States.

»

Improving timely access to care in orthopaedic surgery is crucial for both health equity and optimizing patient outcomes.

»

Options for improving orthopaedic access include increasing Medicaid/Medicare payments to physicians, providing secondary resources to assist patients with limited finances, and reducing language barriers in both clinical care and patient education.

The risk of COVID-19 transmission upon return to sport: a systematic review

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate COVID-19 transmission rates in athletes upon return to sport (RTS), as well as the effectiveness of preventive and surveillance measures associated with RTS.

METHODS

In accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, the PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library databases were searched to identify all articles reporting on RTS during COVID-19. Articles were excluded on the basis of the following criteria: (1) non-English text, (2) only abstract available, (3) population not athlete-specific, (4) outcome not RTS-specific, (5) COVID-19 transmission data not quantified, (6) editorial, or (7) review article or meta-analysis. Study characteristics; athlete demographics; COVID-19 preventive, surveillance, and diagnostic measures; COVID-19 transmission outcomes; and RTS recommendations were collected from each included article and analyzed.

RESULTS

10 studies were included in the final analysis, comprising over 97,000 athletes across a wide variety of sports, levels of play, and RTS settings. Of the 10 studies, eight identified low transmission rates and considered RTS to be safe/low risk. Overall, COVID-19 transmission rates were higher in athletes than in contacts, and more prevalent in the greater community than in athletes specifically. The risk of COVID-19 did not appear to be necessarily higher for athletes who played high-contact team sports, shared common facilities, or lived in communities impacted by high transmission rates, provided that rigorous COVID-19 safety and testing protocols were implemented and followed. Mask wearing and physical distancing during active play presented the greatest challenge to athletes.

CONCLUSION

Rigorous preventive and surveillance measures can mitigate the risk of COVID-19 transmission in athletes upon RTS. However, the heterogeneity of RTS playing conditions, availability of COVID-19 resources, rise of unforeseen novel variants, and undetermined long-term impact of vaccination on athletes remain a challenge to safe and effective RTS in the era of COVID-19.

Improving Radiographic Fracture Recognition Performance and Efficiency Using Artificial Intelligence

Background Missed fractures are a common cause of diagnostic discrepancy between initial radiographic interpretation and the final read by board-certified radiologists. Purpose To assess the effect of assistance by artificial intelligence (AI) on diagnostic performances of physicians for fractures on radiographs. Materials and Methods This retrospective diagnostic study used the multi-reader, multi-case methodology based on an external multicenter data set of 480 examinations with at least 60 examinations per body region (foot and ankle, knee and leg, hip and pelvis, hand and wrist, elbow and arm, shoulder and clavicle, rib cage, and thoracolumbar spine) between July 2020 and January 2021. Fracture prevalence was set at 50%. The ground truth was determined by two musculoskeletal radiologists, with discrepancies solved by a third. Twenty-four readers (radiologists, orthopedists, emergency physicians, physician assistants, rheumatologists, family physicians) were presented the whole validation data set (n = 480), with and without AI assistance, with a 1-month minimum washout period. The primary analysis had to demonstrate superiority of sensitivity per patient and the noninferiority of specificity per patient at -3% margin with AI aid. Stand-alone AI performance was also assessed using receiver operating characteristic curves. Results A total of 480 patients were included (mean age, 59 years ± 16 [standard deviation]; 327 women). The sensitivity per patient was 10.4% higher (95% CI: 6.9, 13.9; P < .001 for superiority) with AI aid (4331 of 5760 readings, 75.2%) than without AI (3732 of 5760 readings, 64.8%). The specificity per patient with AI aid (5504 of 5760 readings, 95.6%) was noninferior to that without AI aid (5217 of 5760 readings, 90.6%), with a difference of +5.0% (95% CI: +2.0, +8.0; P = .001 for noninferiority). AI shortened the average reading time by 6.3 seconds per examination (95% CI: -12.5, -0.1; P = .046). The sensitivity by patient gain was significant in all regions (+8.0% to +16.2%; P < .05) but shoulder and clavicle and spine (+4.2% and +2.6%; P = .12 and .52). Conclusion AI assistance improved the sensitivity and may even improve the specificity of fracture detection by radiologists and nonradiologists, without lengthening reading time. © RSNA, 2021 Online supplemental material is available for this article. See also the editorial by Link and Pedoia in this issue.

Comparative Studies in the Shoulder Literature Lack Statistical Robustness: A Fragility Analysis

Purpose

Evidenced-based decision-making is rooted in comparative clinical studies; however, a small number of outcome event reversals have the potential to change study significance. The purpose of this study was to determine the utility of applying fragility analysis to comparative studies in the published orthopaedic shoulder literature.

Methods

Comparative clinical shoulder research studies reporting 1:1 dichotomous categorical data were analyzed in 6 leading orthopaedic journals between 2006 and 2016. Statistical significance was defined as a P value of less than .05. The fragility index (FI) for each study outcome was determined by the number of event reversals required to change the P value to either greater or less than 0.05, thus changing the study conclusions. The associated fragility quotient (FQ) was determined by dividing the FI by the total population comprising a particular outcome.

Results

Of the 23,897 studies screened, 3,591 met search criteria, with 198 comparative studies ultimately included for analysis, 67 of which were randomized controlled trials. There were 357 total outcome events with 74 reported as significant and 283 as not significant. The FI was 4 (IQR 2-6) with an associated FQ of 0.066 (interquartile range [IQR] 0.038-0.102). There was no difference in statistical fragility between randomized and nonrandomized trials with both revealing a FI of 4 and FQ of 0.068 (IQR 0.044-0.107) and 0.065 (IQR 0.031-0.101), respectively.

Conclusions

This current analysis reveals that comparative shoulder studies published in six leading orthopaedic journals are at risk of statistical fragility. As such, contemporary clinical shoulder literature may not be as robust as traditionally perceived with the reversal of only a few outcome events required to change study significance. Therefore, we advocate the reporting of both FI and FQ in addition to the P value as statistical complements to all comparative investigations to provide a more comprehensive understanding of trial stability and significance in the published shoulder literature.

Clinical Relevance

Comparative study designs are commonly employed in shoulder research. Several studies in both the general medical and orthopaedic literature have identified a lack of statistical robustness through comprehensive fragility analysis. Our findings demonstrate the P value may be an inadequate independent statistical metric requiring the complement of a FI and FQ to aid in the interpretation and understanding of study significance for clinical decision-making.

The Fragility of Statistical Significance in Cartilage Restoration of the Knee: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to utilize fragility analysis to assess the robustness of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating the management of articular cartilage defects of the knee. We hypothesize that the cartilage restorative literature will be fragile with the reversal of only a few outcome events required to change statistical significance.

DESIGN

RCTs from 11 orthopedic journals indexed on PubMed from 2000 to 2020 reporting dichotomous outcome measures relating to the management of articular cartilage defects of the knee were included. The Fragility Index (FI) for each outcome was calculated through the iterative reversal of a single outcome event until significance was reversed. The Fragility Quotient (FQ) was calculated by dividing each FI by study sample size. Additional statistical analysis was performed to provide median FI and FQ across subgroups.

RESULTS

Nineteen RCTs containing 60 dichotomous outcomes were included for analysis. The FI and FQ of all outcomes was 4 (IQR 2-7) and 0.067 (IQR 0.034-0.096), respectively. The average number of patients lost to follow-up (LTF) was 3.9 patients with 15.8% of the included studies reporting LTF greater than or equal to 4, the FI of all included outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

The orthopedic literature evaluating articular cartilage defects of the knee is fragile as the reversal of relatively few outcome events may alter the significance of statistical findings. We therefore recommend comprehensive fragility analysis and triple reporting of the P value, FI, and FQ to aid in the interpretation and contextualization of clinical findings reported in the cartilage restoration literature.

Humeral Head Morphology Influences Outcomes of Arthroscopic Interposition Glenoid Patch Allograft for Glenohumeral Arthritis

Purpose

To determine short- to midterm patient-reported outcomes of arthroscopic soft-tissue interposition arthroplasty using acellular dermal allograft with a minimum follow-up of 1 year and to assess outcomes in patients with and without flattening of the humeral head.

Methods

Patients with a diagnosis of primary glenohumeral arthritis who underwent arthroscopic soft-tissue interposition arthroplasty with an acellular dermal allograft from July 2010 to November 2019 were retrospectively enrolled. Inclusion criteria were a primary diagnosis of glenohumeral arthritis and Outerbridge 4 full-thickness cartilage loss of ≥50% of the glenoid articular surface. Patients underwent arthroscopic debridement, microfracture, and biological arthroscopic soft-tissue interposition arthroplasty with an acellular dermal matrix. Postoperative outcomes included American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeon (ASES) score, Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation (SANE) score, Penn Shoulder Score (PSS), numeric rating scale (NRS) pain score, analgesic use, and conversion to total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA). Results were stratified according to humeral head morphology on preoperative radiographs.

Results

A total of 25 patients were included, with a mean age of 56.0 years (range 19.2 to 74.8) and a mean follow-up of 3.36 years (range 1.03 to 8.98). The mean postoperative ASES score was 64.1 (range 11.7 to 100.0), SANE score was 62% (range 5% to 100%), and PSS was 61.2 (range 10.6 to 97.9). Additionally, 56% of patients rated their shoulder function as improved or much improved, and 36% of patients converted to TSA at a mean of 2.35 years. Patients with and without humeral flattening had similar postoperative ASES scores (P = .44), SANE scores (P = .90), PSS (P = .73), and conversions to TSA (P = .83). Patients with humeral flattening were more likely to have shoulder pain at night (83.3% versus 28.6%, P = .02).

Conclusion

Arthroscopic soft-tissue interposition arthroplasty with an acellular dermal allograft resulted in satisfactory short- to mid-term postoperative outcomes for younger patients with glenohumeral arthritis but demonstrated a TSA conversion rate of 36%. Patients with humeral head flattening also had satisfactory shoulder function but were more likely to experience shoulder pain at night.

Level of Evidence

Level IV, therapeutic case series

The Fragility of Significance in the Hip Arthroscopy Literature: A Systematic Review

The purpose of the present study was to perform the first examination of the utility of p values and the degree of statistical fragility in the hip arthroscopy literature by applying both the Fragility Index (FI) and the Fragility Quotient (FQ) to dichotomous comparative trials. We hypothesized that dichotomous comparative trials evaluating categorical outcomes in the hip arthroscopy literature are statistically fragile.

Targeting Rule Implementation Decreases Concussions in High School Football: A National Concussion Surveillance Study

Background:

Concussions occur at higher rates in high school football as compared with all other high school sports. In 2014, the National Federation of State High School Associations implemented rules defining illegal contact against a defenseless player above the shoulders to reduce concussions in football players in the United States. To the best of our knowledge, rates of emergency department (ED)—diagnosed concussions of high school football players before and after the 2014 rule implementation have not been compared.

Hypothesis:

It was hypothesized that (1) there would be lower rates of helmet-to-helmet and helmet-to-body-part concussions after rule implementation and (2) alternative mechanisms of concussion would not differ, as these would be less influenced by rule implementation.

Study Design:

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods:

Data from the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System (NEISS) were analyzed for high school football players 14 to 18 years old sustaining a concussion from January 1, 2009, to December 31, 2019. Data were collected on mechanism of injury, setting, and loss of consciousness. Raw data were used to calculate national estimates based on the assigned statistical sample weight of each hospital by the NEISS.

Results:

A total of 4983 (national estimate = 154,221) high school football concussions were diagnosed in US EDs; 58.8% of concussions occurred during competition and 41.2% during practice. Between 2009 and 2013 the rate of concussions diagnosed in EDs rose 10.7% as compared with a 6.2% decrease between 2015 and 2019 (P = .04). Between 2009 and 2013, the rate of helmet-to-helmet concussions rose 17.6% as compared with a 5.6% decrease between 2015 and 2019 (P = .03). There were no significant changes between other mechanisms of concussion before and after the 2014 rule implementation.

Conclusion:

We identified a decreased trend in overall and helmet-to-helmet high school football concussions diagnosed in the ED after implementation of the targeting rule. This study adds to the growing literature regarding the importance and efficacy of rule implementation in reducing sports-related concussions.

Diagnostic Accuracy of Ultrasonography for Rotator Cuff Tears: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Background

With recent improvements in transducer strength, image resolution, and operator training, ultrasound (US) provides an excellent alternative imaging modality for the diagnosis of rotator cuff tears.

Purpose

To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of US for partial- and full-thickness rotator cuff tears and biceps tendon tears, compare diagnostic values with those of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) using arthroscopy as the reference standard, assess longitudinal improvements in accuracy, and compare diagnostic values from operators with different training backgrounds.

Study Design

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods

The PubMed and Cochrane Library databases were systematically searched for full-text journal articles published between January 1, 2010, and April 1, 2020. The inclusion criteria were studies that evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of US for rotator cuff tears or biceps tendon tears utilizing arthroscopy as the reference standard. The exclusion criteria were studies with <10 patients, studies including massive tears without reporting diagnostic data for specific tendons, and studies lacking diagnostic outcome data. Extracted outcomes included diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, negative predictive value, and positive predictive value. The mean difference and 95% confidence interval were calculated for both US and MRI diagnostic values, and meta-analysis was conducted using the Mantel-Haenszel random-effects model.

Results

In total, 23 eligible studies involving 2054 shoulders were included. US demonstrated a higher median diagnostic accuracy for supraspinatus tendon tears (0.83) and biceps tendon tears (0.93) as compared with subscapularis tendon tears (0.76). US was found to have a higher median accuracy (0.93) for full-thickness supraspinatus tears than partial-thickness tears (0.81). US had superior median sensitivity for partial-thickness supraspinatus tears when performed by radiologists as opposed to surgeons (0.86 vs 0.57). Meta-analysis of the 5 studies comparing US and MRI demonstrated no statistically significant difference in diagnostic sensitivity, specificity, or accuracy for any thickness supraspinatus tears (P = .31-.55), full-thickness tears (P = .63-.97), or partial-thickness tears (P = .13-.81).

Conclusion

For experienced operators, US is a highly sensitive and specific diagnostic modality for the diagnosis of supraspinatus tears and demonstrates statistically equivalent capability to MRI in the diagnosis of both full- and partial-thickness rotator cuff tears.

Venous Thromboembolism Requiring Anticoagulation Following Knee Arthroscopy in a Young Woman With an Intravaginal Contraceptive Device

Venous thromboembolism following elective knee arthroscopy remains relatively rare. NuvaRing (Merck & Co), an intravaginal contraceptive device, has received attention recently due to reports detailing unexpected catastrophic pulmonary embolism and further suggesting an increased risk of venous and arterial thrombotic events in women who use it. A healthy, 30-year-old woman with a NuvaRing contraceptive device presented to the sports medicine clinic with knee pain, swelling, and mechanical symptoms. She was diagnosed with a lateral meniscus tear via magnetic resonance imaging and subsequently underwent a routine partial lateral meniscectomy. Her postoperative course was complicated by a rare deep venous thrombosis requiring anticoagulation therapy. This case highlights the risk of NuvaRing contraception and raises awareness within the orthopedic community regarding its use among patients undergoing arthroscopic outpatient surgery. [Orthopedics. 2021;44(5):e687-e690.].

The Statistical Fragility of Platelet-Rich Plasma in Rotator Cuff Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

The practice of evidence-based medicine relies on objective data to guide clinical decision-making with specific statistical thresholds conveying study significance.

PURPOSE

To determine the utility of applying the fragility index (FI) and the fragility quotient (FQ) analysis to randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating the utilization of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) in rotator cuff repairs (RCRs).

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review and meta-analysis.

METHODS

RCTs pertaining to the utilization of PRP in surgical RCRs published in 13 peer-reviewed journals from 2000 to 2020 were evaluated. The FI was determined by manipulating each reported outcome event until a reversal of significance was appreciated. The associated FQ was determined by dividing the FI by the sample size.

RESULTS

Of the 9746 studies screened, 19 RCTs were ultimately included for analysis. The overall FI incorporating all 19 RCTs was only 4, suggesting that the reversal of only 4 events is required to change study significance. The associated FQ was determined as 0.092. Of the 43 outcome events reporting lost to follow-up data, 13 (30.2%) represented lost to follow-up >4.

CONCLUSION

Our analysis suggests that RCTs evaluating PRP for surgical RCRs may lack statistical stability with only a few outcome events required to alter trial significance. Therefore, we recommend the reporting of an FI and an FQ in conjunction with P value analysis to carefully interpret the integrity of statistical stability in future comparative trials.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Clinical decisions are often informed by statistically significant results. Thus, a true understanding of the robustness of the statistical findings informing clinical decision-making is of critical importance.

Implementation of an Injury Prevention Program in NCAA Division I Athletics Reduces Injury-Related Health Care Costs

Background:

The estimated cost per year of injuries in collegiate athletics has been reported to be billions of dollars in the United States. Injury prevention programs are often assessed only by their ability to reduce injuries, and there is little evidence of any potential reduction in associated health care costs.

Purpose:

To investigate changes in injury-related health care costs at a National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division I university after the implementation of an injury prevention program.

Study Design:

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods:

Included were 12 sports teams that used the injury prevention program (user group) and 16 teams that did not implement the program (nonuser group). The injury surveillance and prevention system (Sparta Science) utilized a commercially available force-plate system to assess kinematic variables, flag high-risk athletes, and guide individual conditioning programs. Data were obtained from 3 academic years before (2012-2014) and 2 academic years after (2015-2016) implementation of the Sparta Science system. The number of injuries and associated health care costs (surgery, clinic visits, imaging, and physical therapy) were compared between users and nonusers.

Results:

Total average annual injuries did not change significantly between users and nonusers after implementation of the program; however, users demonstrated a 23% reduction in clinic visits as compared with a 14% increase for nonusers (P = .049). Users demonstrated a 13% reduction in associated health care encounters, compared with a 13% increase for nonusers (P = .032). Overall health care costs changed significantly for both groups, with an observed 19% decrease ($2,456,154 to $1,978,799) for users and an 8% increase ($1,177,542 to $1,270,846) for nonusers (P < .01 for both). Costs related to associated health care encounters also decreased by 20% for users as compared with a 39% increase for nonusers (P = .027).

Conclusion:

This study demonstrated the ability to significantly reduce injury-related health care costs in NCAA Division I athletes via a comprehensive injury surveillance and prevention program utilizing force-plate technology. Given the substantial and appropriate focus on value of care delivery across the US health care system, we recommend the continued study of sports injury surveillance and prevention programs for reducing injury-related health care costs.

Sports-related concussions in high school females: an epidemiologic analysis of twenty-year national trends

The epidemiology of sports-related concussions (SRCs) and closed head injuries (CHIs) in high school females remains undefined at the national level, especially for unorganized sports and recreational activities. This study examines 1,176,092 national weighted estimates of SRCs or CHIs in female patients 14-18 years of age presenting to United States (US) emergency departments (EDs) between 2000 and 2019 in the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System (NEISS). The national weighted estimate of female patients in our study increased significantly (p < 0.001) between 2000 (9,835; 95% Confidence Interval [CI] 7,105-12,566) and 2019 (31,751; CI 26,392-37,110). The top five ranked sports and recreational activities most commonly associated with concussions and CHIs in female patients 14-18 years of age were: soccer (20.6%; CI 17.6%-23.6%); basketball (18.5%; CI 16.9%-20.1%); cheerleading (10.4%; CI 8.9%-11.9%); softball (10.1%; CI 9.0%-11.3%); volleyball (6.5%; CI 5.7%-7.2%). Simple univariate regression models showed that an increase of 10,000 annual female participants across all high school sports and recreational activities was associated with 308.7 (SE = 20.8, p < 0.001, R2 = 0.92) additional annual SRCs and CHIs presenting to US EDs. The promotion of concussion awareness and educational programs may help minimize SRCs and CHIs.

Management of Chronic Quadriceps Tendon Rupture: A Critical Analysis Review

»

Chronic quadriceps tendon (QT) ruptures are uncommon injuries that present treatment challenges due to their complex nature and the limited evidence to guide management.

»

Timely diagnosis and surgical management of acute QT injury are imperative to optimize patient outcomes as delayed diagnosis leads to poorer results regardless of treatment modality.

»

Elements of chronic QT ruptures that may complicate surgical management include patient age, comorbidity, scar-tissue formation, amount of quadriceps muscle/ tendon retraction, and distalmigration of the patella with contraction of the tendon.

»

Treatment options for chronic QT ruptures include primary repair with or without vastus advancement, V-Y tendon lengthening with or without tissue augmentation, and autograft or allograft reconstruction.

Pathologic Hip Fracture by Virtue of a Rare Osseous Manifestation of Gout: A Case Report

CASE

A 76-year-old woman without a personal or family history of gout presented with complaints of left hip pain after a mechanical fall from her wheelchair. Advanced imaging revealed a nonspecific lesion and nondisplaced fracture of the femoral neck. Intraoperative biopsy from the lesion/fracture demonstrated tophaceous gout.

CONCLUSION

Fractures resulting from osseous manifestations of the gout are rare with this report describing a hip fracture secondary to tophaceous gout. We emphasize the importance of including this potential etiology in the differential diagnosis of elderly patients presenting with hip pain, with or without a known history of gout.

Arthroscopic Diagnosis of Occult Posterolateral Meniscocapsular Separations: Another Hidden Lesion

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to describe the surgical findings and clinical outcomes in a series of patients with occult posterolateral meniscocapsular separations diagnosed arthroscopically after a negative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan.

Methods

A retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data of consecutive patients who underwent surgical arthroscopy with repair of an occult posterolateral meniscocapsular separation by 2 fellowship-trained orthopaedic sports medicine surgeons at a single institution was performed. All lesions were identified arthroscopically in the posterolateral aspect of the lateral compartment as a distinct pathologic separation between the posterolateral capsule and adjacent meniscal tissue with increased excursion on probing. Clinical examination notes, MRI scans, and operative reports were reviewed. Patient-reported outcome measures were assessed via patient questionnaire.

Results

A total of 6 patients were included for analysis. MRI evaluation of the lateral meniscus was unrevealing in 4 patients, suggesting a possible tear of the body of the lateral meniscus in one patient and demonstrating a parameniscal cyst abutting the anterior root of the lateral meniscus in another patient. Arthroscopic examination revealed meniscocapsular separations of the posterolateral meniscus in all 6 knees, with 2 knees demonstrating concomitant bucket-handle meniscus tears. Patient-reported outcomes were determined for 67% of study patients. The average reported International Knee Documentation Committee score was 63.8, the average Knee Outcome Survey Activities of Daily Living Scale score was reported as 63, the 12-Item Short Form Survey (SF-12) Physical score averaged 46.8 with an average SF-12 Mental score of 59.9.

Conclusions

The diagnosis of occult posterolateral meniscocapsular separations (MCS) could be missed on advanced imaging, such as MRI, so arthroscopic diagnosis may be required. This study indicates that arthroscopic diagnosis and repair of occult posterolateral MCS results in good functional and clinical outcomes.

Level of Evidence

IV, therapeutic case series.

Osteosarcoma Mimicking Tenosynovial Giant Cell Tumor of the Hip in a Pediatric Patient: A Case Report

CASE

A 17-year-old boy presented to the clinic complaining of right hip pain after soccer participation. Clinical findings and imaging studies led to the diagnoses of femoroacetabular impingement and diffuse tenosynovial giant cell tumor (TGCT). Comprehensive arthroscopic management and biopsy revealed a diagnosis of osteosarcoma. The patient subsequently underwent chemotherapy, surgical resection, and reconstruction.

CONCLUSION

Osteosarcoma of the proximal femur may mimic TGCT on imaging studies because osteosarcoma may show changes suggestive of inflammation. We recommend heightened clinical awareness and a comprehensive differential workup in the management of presumed TGCT about the hip in the pediatric patient population.