Characterisation of protective vaccine antigens from the thiol-containing components of excretory/secretory material of Ostertagia ostertagi

Previous vaccination trials have demonstrated that thiol proteins affinity purified from Ostertagia ostertagi excretory-secretory products (O. ostertagi ES-thiol) are protective against homologous challenge. Here we have shown that protection induced by this vaccine was consistent across four independent vaccine-challenge experiments. Protection is associated with reduced cumulative faecal egg counts across the duration of the trials, relative to control animals. To better understand the diversity of antigens in O. ostertagi ES-thiol we used high-resolution shotgun proteomics to identify 490 unique proteins in the vaccine preparation. The most numerous ES-thiol proteins, with 91 proteins identified, belong to the sperm-coating protein/Tpx/antigen 5/pathogenesis-related protein 1 (SCP/TAPS) family. This family includes previously identified O. ostertagi vaccine antigens O. ostertagi ASP-1 and ASP-2. The ES-thiol fraction also has numerous proteinases, representing three distinct classes, including: metallo-; aspartyl- and cysteine proteinases. In terms of number of family members, the M12 astacin-like metalloproteinases, with 33 proteins, are the most abundant proteinase family in O. ostertagi ES-thiol. The O. ostertagi ES-thiol proteome provides a comprehensive database of proteins present in this vaccine preparation and will guide future vaccine antigen discovery projects.

Variations in T Cell Transcription Factor Sequence and Expression Associated with Resistance to the Sheep Nematode Teladorsagia circumcincta

This study used selected lambs that varied in their resistance to the gastrointestinal parasite Teladorsagia circumcincta. Infection over 12 weeks identified susceptible (high adult worm count, AWC; high fecal egg count, FEC; low body weight, BW; low IgA) and resistant sheep (no/low AWC and FEC, high BW and high IgA). Resistance is mediated largely by a Th2 response and IgA and IgE antibodies, and is a heritable characteristic. The polarization of T cells and the development of appropriate immune responses is controlled by the master regulators, T-bet (TBX21), GATA-3 (GATA3), RORγt (RORC2) and RORα (RORA); and several inflammatory diseases of humans and mice are associated with allelic or transcript variants of these transcription factors. This study tested the hypothesis that resistance of sheep to T. circumcincta is associated with variations in the structure, sequence or expression levels of individual master regulator transcripts. We have identified and sequenced one variant of sheep TBX21, two variants of GATA3 and RORC2 and five variants of RORA from lymph node mRNA. Relative RT-qPCR analysis showed that TBX21, GATA3 and RORC2 were not significantly differentially-expressed between the nine most resistant (AWC, 0; FEC, 0) and the nine most susceptible sheep (AWC, mean 6078; FEC, mean 350). Absolute RT-qPCR on all 45 animals identified RORVv5 as being significantly differentially-expressed (p = 0.038) between resistant, intermediate and susceptible groups; RORCv2 was not differentially-expressed (p = 0.77). Spearman’s rank analysis showed that RORAv5 transcript copy number was significantly negatively correlated with parameters of susceptibility, AWC and FEC; and was positively correlated with BW. RORCv2 was not correlated with AWC, FEC or BW but was significantly negatively correlated with IgA antibody levels. This study identifies the full length RORA variant (RORAv5) as important in controlling the protective immune response to T. circumcincta infection in sheep.

Metagenome plasticity of the bovine abomasal microbiota in immune animals in response to Ostertagia ostertagi infection

Infections in cattle by the abomasal nematode Ostertagia ostertagi result in impaired gastrointestinal function. Six partially immune animals were developed using multiple drug-attenuated infections, and these animals displayed reduced worm burdens and a slightly elevated abomasal pH upon reinfection. In this study, we characterized the abomasal microbiota in response to reinfection using metagenomic tools. Compared to uninfected controls, infection did not induce a significant change in the microbial community composition in immune animals. 16S rRNA gene-based phylogenetic analysis identified 15 phyla in the bovine abomasal microbiota with Bacteroidetes (60.5%), Firmicutes (27.1%), Proteobacteria (7.2%), Spirochates (2.9%), and Fibrobacteres (1.5%) being the most predominant. The number of prokaryotic genera and operational taxonomic units (OTU) identified in the abomasal microbial community was 70.8±19.8 (mean ± SD) and 90.3±2.9, respectively. However, the core microbiome comprised of 32 genera and 72 OTU. Infection seemingly had a minimal impact on the abomasal microbial diversity at a genus level in immune animals. Proteins predicted from whole genome shotgun (WGS) DNA sequences were assigned to 5,408 Pfam and 3,381 COG families, demonstrating dazzling arrays of functional diversity in bovine abomasal microbial communities. However, none of COG functional classes were significantly impacted by infection. Our results demonstrate that immune animals may develop abilities to maintain proper stability of their abomasal microbial ecosystem. A minimal disruption in the bovine abomasal microbiota by reinfection may contribute equally to the restoration of gastric function in immune animals.

Vaccination against Ostertagia ostertagi with subfractions of the protective ES-thiol fraction

Previous vaccination trials against Ostertagia ostertagi in cattle have demonstrated the protective capacity of a protein fraction termed ES-thiol, which is enriched for activation-associated secreted proteins (ASPs) and cysteine proteases. In this study, ES-thiol was subfractionated through Q-Sepharose anion exchange chromatography to determine whether the ASPs and/or the cysteine proteases are responsible for the induced protection. Calves (seven/group) were immunized three times intramuscularly with 100 microg of ES-thiol or equivalent amounts of an ASP-enriched fraction, a cysteine protease-enriched fraction or a rest fraction, with QuilA adjuvant. A negative control group only received QuilA. After the final immunization the animals were challenged with a trickle infection of 25,000 infectious L3 larvae (1000 L3/day; 5 days/week). During a 2-month period the geometric mean cumulative faecal egg count (FEC) of the ES-thiol group was reduced by 62% compared to the QuilA control group (P<0.05). Groups injected with the ASP-enriched, the cysteine protease-enriched and the rest fraction demonstrated a reduction in cumulative FEC of 74, 80 and 70%, respectively (P<0.01). Although no significant reductions in worm burdens were observed, adult male and female worms were significantly smaller in all vaccinated groups (P<0.05), except for male worms from the ES-thiol group. These results suggest the protective capacity of ASPs and the presence of other protective antigens in the ES-thiol fraction.

Local inflammation as a possible mechanism of resistance to gastrointestinal nematodes in Angus heifers

Understanding mechanisms of resistance to gastrointestinal nematodes is important in developing effective and sustainable control programs. A resource population of Angus cattle consisting of approximately 600 animals with complete pedigree records has been developed. The majority of these animals were completely characterized for their resistance to natural challenge by gastrointestinal nematodes. As the first step towards understanding the molecular basis of disease resistance, we investigated expression profiles of 17 cytokines, cytokine receptors, and chemokines using real-time RT-PCR in animals demonstrating resistance or susceptibility to pasture challenge. The animals exposed to natural infection for approximately 6 months were treated to remove existing parasites and then experimentally challenged with both Ostertagia ostertagi and Cooperia oncophora. The mRNA expression profiles of these genes in abomasal and mesenteric lymph nodes (ALN, MLN), fundic and pyloric abomasa (FA, PA), and small intestine (SI) were compared between resistant and susceptible animals. Resistant heifers exhibited elevated expression of inflammatory cytokines such as TNFalpha, IL-1beta, and MIP-1alpha in fundic and pyloric abomasa 7 days post infection. Expression levels of IL-10, polymeric immunoglobullin receptor gene (PIGR), and WSX-1 were also 2.7-19.9-folds higher in resistant than susceptible heifers in these tissues. No difference in expression of CXCL6, CXCL10, IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-8, IL-12 p40, IL-13, IL-15 and IL-18 was observed between the two groups. The expression of MIP-1alpha, IL-6, and IL-10 was also elevated in small intestines in resistant animals. In contrast, little difference in expression of these genes was detected between resistant and susceptible groups in the draining lymph nodes. These data indicate that resistant animals can better maintain inflammatory responses at the site of infection, suggesting a possible novel mechanism of resistance.

A longitudinal survey of anti-Ostertagia ostertagi antibody levels in individual and bulk tank milk in two dairy herds in Normandy

The Ostertagia-specific antibody levels in milk were monitored in 2 dairy herds to investigate seasonal variations and the relationship between individual and bulk tank milk antibody levels. Bulk tank and individual milk samples from all lactating animals were collected over a 1-year period at weekly and monthly intervals, respectively. The Ostertagia-specific antibody levels were measured with an indirect ELISA and the test results were expressed as optical density ratios (ODR). A clear seasonal pattern that followed the expected intake of infectious larvae was observed in the individual and bulk tank milk antibody levels of both herds. Within each herd, there was a large variation in the individual ODRs. This variation remained large when the distribution of individual ODRs was plotted according to high and low bulk tank milk ODR categories. The results suggest that the effect of seasonal variations on cut-off levels that predict production responses after anthelmintic control, needs to be assessed.

The establishment rate of a sheep nematode: Revisiting classics using a meta-analysis of 87 experiments

Strongyle nematode establishment rate in their host is a highly variable life history trait, which makes it difficult to estimate. A meta-analysis was applied to the nematode Teladorsagia circumcincta of sheep in order to acquire a general framework of the factors modulating this life trait. A linear model was built with individual data on 540 infected lambs extracted from 13 articles. Lambs breed and age, time lag between last infection and the interaction between infection mode, infective dose and the number of repeated infective doses were significantly related with the establishment rate. The influence of infection mode on nematode establishment rate was also evaluated by comparing nematode establishment rate distributions within lamb populations infected under different conditions. Natural and repeated experimental infections lead to similar distribution of establishment rate. Conversely, these infection conditions resulted in different parasite establishment rates in average (12.7 and 23.4%, respectively). Three hypotheses are discussed to explain this result: immune protective response, host avoidance behaviour and parasite virulence.

An immunogenic cathepsin F secreted by the parasitic stages of Teladorsagia circumcincta

Teladorsagia circumcincta is a common, pathogenic abomasal nematode of sheep. In order to improve disease control in parasite isolates resistant to several anthelmintics, alternative methods must be sought. Sheep develop acquired immunity to T. circumcincta so vaccination is a valid option for control. For this reason, we are investigating parasite excretory/secretory products for molecules, which have potential to invoke protective immunity against T. circumcincta. Here, we describe experiments in which we identified a novel, immunogenic cathepsin F secreted by L4 T. circumcincta. This protease, initially identified by mass spectrometry analysis, is the most abundant molecule in excretory/secretory products released in vitro by T. circumcincta harvested at 5, 6 or 9 days p.i. and is a target of specific, local IgA responses in sheep which are immune to challenge infection. The full-length cDNA encoding this secreted protease was isolated. Sequence and phylogenetic analyses indicated that the protease (designated T. circumcincta cathepsin F-1, Tci-CF-1) belongs to the cathepsin F class and exhibits greatest identity (>60%) to expressed sequence tags present in the Ostertagia ostertagi and Haemonchus contortus expressed sequence tag databases. Tci-CF-1 also displays high identity to hypothetical proteins identified in the genomes of Caenorhabditis elegans and Caenorhabditis briggsae, both proteins having been described as cathepsin F enzymes. Specific inhibitor binding assay of larval excretory/secretory products confirmed the classification of this excretory/secretory component as a cathepsin F. Reverse transcription-PCR studies indicated that Tci-cf-1 is developmentally regulated and is particular to the host parasitic stages of T. circumcincta. The abundance, immunogenicity and temporal expression pattern of Tci-CF-1 make this a potential vaccine candidate for teladorsagiosis.

Rapid improvement of immunity to Teladorsagia circumcincta is achieved through a reduction in the demand for protein in lactating ewes

Protein supplementation can improve the resistance to parasites of periparturient ewes, as indicated by reduced nematode egg excretion and worm burdens. However, the rate at which this improvement can occur is largely unknown. We investigated the rate of improvement by assessing temporal changes in faecal egg counts after we experimentally reduced nutrient demand. Three groups of nine pregnant ewes each were trickle infected with Teladorsagia circumcincta from day(-70) to day(16) (parturition is day0). Two groups of twin-rearing ewes were fed at 0.8 (L22) or 1.2 (H22) times their assumed metabolizable protein requirements, and a third group was fed the same daily food allowances as L22 ewes, but one of their lambs was removed on day10 (L21). Ewes were slaughtered on day21 to assess worm burdens, in vitro larval establishment on abomasal explants, and mucosal inflammatory cells. Faecal egg counts of L22 ewes were higher than H22 ewes throughout lactation. After the removal of one lamb, faecal egg counts of L21 ewes decreased within 5 days to levels similar to H22 ewes. Relative to L22 ewes, L21 and H22 ewes had lower worm burdens, parasite per capita fecundity and in vitro establishment rates of both T. circumcincta and Haemonchus contortus. Mucosal mast cell and eosinophil counts were similar for all ewes, but H22 ewes had higher globule leukocyte counts than L22 and L21 ewes. The data suggest that a reduction in protein demand can rapidly improve periparturient immunity to T. circumcincta. This may be associated with increased parasite expulsion, reduced fecundity and non-parasite specific reduction of in vitro larval establishment.

Cytokine responses in immunized and non-immunized calves after Ostertagia ostertagi infection

The objective of this study was to evaluate abomasal cytokine responses in helminth-naive calves and calves vaccinated with protective antigen fractions from Ostertagia ostertagi after an experimental challenge infection with infective third stage (L3) larvae. Abomasal lymph nodes and/or abomasal mucosa were collected and messenger RNA for the Th1 cytokines (IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-12 p40 subunit), the Th2 cytokines (IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, IL-10, IL-13, IL-15) and the Th3/Tr cytokine TGF-beta was quantified by real-time RT-PCR. Vaccination had no effect on cytokine profiles in either the abomasal lymph nodes or the abomasal mucosa. However, following infection all calves showed a significant decrease in the Th1 cytokines, IFN-gamma and IL-12 p40, and a significant increase in the Th2 cytokines, IL-4, IL-5, IL-10 and IL-13 in the lymph nodes, compared to non-infected calves. No correlation between the Th2 response and protection induced by vaccination could be demonstrated. In contrast, a Th2 pattern was not observed in the mucosa of the infected calves, which exhibited an increase in IFN-gamma as well as in the Th2 cytokines IL-4, IL-5 and IL-10 mRNA. No significant association was observed in the abomasal mucosa between any examined cytokine mRNA level and immune effector responses such as parasite-specific antibodies or the number of mucosal mast cells or eosinophils.

The effect of dietary polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) on infection with the nematodes Ostertagia ostertagi and Cooperia oncophora in calves

Diet-induced changes in the polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) content of immune cells influences the immune phenotype that develops following infection. The aim of this study was to examine the effect of manipulating dietary PUFA supply on tissue fatty acids composition and immunity to a mixed infection with an abomasal and an intestinal nematode parasite in calves. Calves (n=24) were allocated into two treatment groups and fed 25 g/day of either fish oil (n-3 group) or a binary mixture of palm/rapeseed oil (normal group) as a supplement in milk replacer. Within each treatment group eight calves were infected with 2000 L3 Ostertagia ostertagi and Cooperia oncophora, three times per week for 8 weeks, the remaining calves were pair-fed uninfected controls. Faecal egg counts (FEC) were carried out twice weekly. At slaughter, the whole gut was removed intact for worm counts and tissue samples were taken for fatty acid analysis. Samples of abomasum, duodenum and mid-gut were also collected for immunohistological analysis. FEC were not significantly influenced by oil supplement but tended to remain higher in the palm/rapeseed oil-fed group (normal infected). The number of intestinal immature worms was significantly (p<0.05) higher in the n-3 group. Mucosal mast cell (MMC) and eosinophil numbers were significantly increased (p<0.05) by infection and were significantly lower (p<0.05) in the intestinal tissue of the fish oil supplemented and infected group (n-3 infected group). These results suggest that feeding an n-3 PUFA-rich supplement (fish oil) can influence cellular mediators of immunity to nematode infection. This is the first report of the establishment of patency and the subsequent development of immunity to a mixed infection with O. ostertagi and C. oncophora in calves undergoing early rumen development. The trend in the FEC, MMC and eosinophil numbers in the n-3 group suggests that decreasing the dietary n-6/n-3 PUFA ratio may be a worthwhile immunonutritional strategy for potentiating the immune response to nematode parasite infection in the calf.

An aspartyl protease inhibitor of Ostertagia ostertagi: Molecular cloning, analysis of stage and tissue specific expression and vaccine trial

Protease inhibitors are thought to protect intestinal parasitic nematodes from their hostile proteolytic environment. In a previous study, screening of Ostertagia ostertagi cDNA libraries with local antibody probes of the abomasal lymph nodes and mucus revealed a (28 kDa) aspartyl protease inhibitor (API), which was exclusively recognised by antibodies from immune calves. Here we report the molecular characterization of Oo-API (sequence analysis, developmental expression and localization) and a vaccine trial in cattle with the native and recombinant baculo-expressed antigen. The full-length open reading frame of api encodes a protein of 28 kDa. The sequence showed 82% significant homology to an Aspin homologue from Trichostrongylus colubriformis (AA034715). The cDNA encoding the full-length sequence was cloned in a bacterial pET expression vector and the pVec 35 baculovirus vector. Polyclonal rabbit serum against the Escherichia coli-expressed protein was used to develop Western Blots of extracts and ES and to localize the antigen on L3, L4 and adult worm sections. The protein was expressed in all life stages, which was confirmed by real-time polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), and was mainly localized in the cuticle of L3, the intestinal cells of L4, and the gut and sphincter of adult worms. Polyclonal serum was also used to affinity purify the native protein. Vaccination of calves with native Oo-API and baculovirus-expressed Oo-rbAPI in combination with QuilA resulted in no protection against Ostertagia challenge infections.

A survey to determine relationships between bulk tank milk antibodies against Ostertagia ostertagi and milk production parameters

In temperate climate regions, gastrointestinal nematodes are still widespread in adult dairy cows, but until now there exists no reliable diagnostic tool that can identify herds where the infection interferes with productivity. The objective of this study was to investigate the relationships between levels of antibodies against Ostertagia ostertagi in bulk tank milk and milk production. Bulk tank milk samples of 2553 dairy herds were obtained in spring and 2104 of these herds were sampled a second time in autumn. The antibody levels against O. ostertagi were determined with a milk ELISA and test results were expressed as an optical density ratio (ODR). The effect of bulk tank milk ODR on three different production parameters, kg milk, % and kg fat, % and kg protein was assessed by a multivariable linear regression model on the herds for which production data were available (n = 1063 and 867 in spring and autumn, respectively). The mean and standard deviation for ODRautumn (0.972+/-0.238) were higher than for ODRspring (0.825+/-0.201). Significant negative relationships were found between ODR and milk yield. An increase in ODRspring and ODRautumn from the 25th to the 75th percentile of the available ODR data was associated with a drop in the annual milk yield of 1.1 kg/cow/day, respectively 0.9 kg/cow/day. When a herd's ODR increased between spring and autumn with 0.142, it produced on average 0.4 kg/cow/day less in September than in April, in comparison with herds where the ODR did not increase. A significant negative association was found between ODRautumn and % protein averaged over the period of a year. No significant associations were found between ODR and % fat averaged over the year. When protein and fat production of September were expressed in kg an increase in ODRautumn from the 25th to the 75th percentile was associated with a decrease of 0.037 kg protein/cow/day and 0.042 kg fat/cow/day.

Protection studies with a globin-enriched protein fraction of Ostertagia ostertagi

The protective capacity of an adult stage Ostertagia ostertagi globin antigen was tested in four vaccination experiments in cattle. In a preliminary experiment, calves were vaccinated three times intraperitoneally with 250 microg globin in Freund's adjuvant and challenged with a trickled infection of 25,000 infective larvae. In three subsequent field studies, calves were vaccinated twice or three times intramuscularly with 80-100 microg globin in Quil A and challenged with a natural gastrointestinal nematode infection on pasture. Higher globin-specific antibody levels were detected in the vaccinated calves than in the control animals in all vaccine trials. In the preliminary experiment, geometric mean cumulative egg counts in the globin group were reduced by 52% and total worm burdens were reduced by 28%, compared to the controls. In the first field trial cumulative faecal egg counts were reduced by 63% in the vaccinated calves. However, the reduction in faecal egg output in these two experiments was not statistically significant and no reduction in faecal egg counts was observed in the vaccinated animals in the two last field trials. In conclusion, vaccination of calves with O. ostertagi globin resulted in highly variable protection levels after challenge infection.

Vaccination with an Ostertagia ostertagi polyprotein allergen protects calves against homologous challenge infection

As an alternative to antihelminthic drugs, we are exploiting vaccination to control infections with the abomasal nematode Ostertagia ostertagi in cattle. Our focus for vaccine targets is excretory-secretory (ES) products of this parasite. One of the most abundant antigens in larval and adult Ostertagia ES products is a protein homologous to nematode polyprotein allergens. We found that the Ostertagia polyprotein allergen (OPA) is encoded by a single-copy gene. OPA comprises three or more repeated units, and only the 15-kDa subunits are found in ES products. The native antigen is localized in the intestinal cells of third-stage larvae and in the hypodermis and cuticle of fourth-stage larvae and adult parasites. Vaccination of cattle with native OPA (nOPA) in combination with QuilA resulted in protection against Ostertagia challenge infections. The geometric mean cumulative fecal egg counts in the nOPA-vaccinated animals were reduced by 60% compared to the counts in the control group during the 2-month course of the experiment. Both male and female adult worms in nOPA-vaccinated animals were significantly shorter than the worms in the control animals. In the abomasal mucus of vaccinated animals the nOPA-specific immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) and IgG2 levels were significantly elevated compared to the levels in the control animals. Reductions in the Ostertagia egg output and the length of the adult parasites were significantly correlated with IgG1 levels. IgG2 titers were only negatively associated with adult worm length. Protected animals showed no accumulation of effector cells (mast cells, globular leukocytes, and eosinophils) in the mucosa. In contrast to the native antigen, recombinant OPA expressed in Escherichia coli did not stimulate any protection.

Milk antibodies against Ostertagia ostertagi: relationships with milk IgG and production parameters in lactating dairy cattle

The present study was carried out to evaluate the relationship between milk optical density ratios (ODRs) from an indirect Ostertagia ostertagi ELISA, total milk IgG levels and milk production and then establish a correction factor to adjust ODR. Five hundred and sixty composite milk samples collected from 358 cows on four dairy herds in June and August 2002 were used in this analysis. The average ODR was 0.34. A positive correlation was found between ODR and IgG values in milk, days in milk, age and log transformed somatic cell counts (SCC). However, ODR was negatively correlated with milk production. The IgG levels and ODR values were constant from 30 to 200 days in milk. However, ODRs increased from 200 days until the end of the lactation. After controlling for age, season, herd and SCC, an increase in milk production of 13 kg/day was associated with a reduction in ODR values of 0.052. The results of the present study suggest that ODR values are not greatly influenced by production factors. ODR follow the same pattern as the IgG variation across lactation and could be adjusted in order to compare ODR values obtained from high producing cows with those obtained from low producing animals.

Validation of the protective Ostertagia ostertagi ES-thiol antigens with different adjuvantia

Intramuscular immunization of calves with an excretory-secretory antigen fraction enriched for cysteine proteinase activity (ES-thiol) and QuilA as adjuvant induces a protective immune response against the abomasal nematode Ostertagia ostertagi. The objectives of the present study were to confirm the protective capacity of ES-thiol in combination with QuilA, to test Al(OH)(3) as adjuvant for vaccination against O. ostertagi and to look for correlations between protection and immunological effector responses. Calves(seven animals/group) were vaccinated three times intramuscularly with 100 micro g antigen and/or adjuvant (ES-thiol with QuilA, ES-thiol with Al(OH)(3), QuilA alone and Al(OH)(3) alone) and subsequently challenged with a trickled oral infection of 25 000 infective larvae in total over 25 days. Faecal egg counts in the ES-thiol QuilA group were reduced by 56% during the two-month period of the trial compared to the QuilA control group (P < 0.002). Calves immunized with ES-thiol QuilA had significantly smaller adult worms (P < 0.002) and less eggs/female worm (P < 0.05) compared to the QuilA control group. No differences in egg output, worm counts or parameters of worm fitness were observed in the ES-thiol Al(OH)(3) group compared to the Al(OH)(3) control group. Although the protective immune mechanism against O. ostertagi remains unknown, protection in the ES-thiol QuilA group was associated with high levels of parasite-specific antibodies in the abomasal mucosa.

Current research and future prospects in the development of vaccines against gastrointestinal nematodes in cattle

Vaccination is being considered as the most feasible alternative for anthelmintic drugs to control gastrointestinal nematode infections in cattle. However, despite the identification of several candidate protective antigens, no vaccines against gastrointestinal nematode parasites are currently available. The main problems that hamper the development of nematode vaccines in ruminants are that vaccination with recombinant nematode proteins produced in bacterial or eukaryotic expression systems did not induce a protective immune response and no suitable antigen delivery system is available for presentation of protective worm antigens to the bovine mucosal immune system. The present review will focus on recent advances and remaining obstacles in vaccine development against gastrointestinal nematodes in cattle, in particular against the abomasal parasite Ostertagia ostertagi.

Protein disulphide isomerase of Ostertagia ostertagi: an excretory-secretory product of L4 and adult worms?

A pepstatin A-agarose column was used in an attempt to purify a previously described antibody-degrading aspartyl proteinase from excretory-secretory material from the L4 and the adult stages of the bovine abomasal nematode Ostertagia ostertagi. However, no aspartyl proteinase activity was detected in the eluted fractions (L4Pepst and AdPepst). Screening of cDNA libraries with polyclonal antibodies raised against L4Pepst and AdPepst showed that a protein disulphide isomerase (Ost-PDI2) was present in both antigen fractions. This multifunctional enzyme was detected in extracts of L3, L4 and adult parasites and, interestingly, also in excretory-secretory material of L4 and adult O. ostertagi. By immunohistochemistry, the Ost-PDI2 enzyme was localised in some parts of the hypodermis of L4 and adult worms and in the intestinal cells of all three parasitic life stages. Two-dimensional Western blot analysis indicated that Ost-PDI2 is recognised by calves during a natural O. ostertagi infection, which suggests that Ost-PDI2 could be used for immunological control of ostertagiosis.

Evaluation of the repeatability of a crude adult indirect Ostertagia ostertagi ELISA and methods of expressing test results

An indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the detection of antibodies against Ostertagia ostertagi using a crude adult worm antigen was evaluated using serum and milk samples from adult cows, as well as from bulk tank milk. Within and between plate repeatabilities were determined. In addition, the effects of factors such as antigen batch, freezing, preserving of the samples and somatic cell counts (SCCs) of the samples were evaluated. Raw optical densities (ODs) and normalized values were compared using the concordance correlation coefficient (CCC), the coefficient of variation (CV), Bland-Altman plots (BA). Based on raw OD values, there was a high repeatability within a plate (CCC approximately 0.96 and CV<10%). Repeatability between plates was evaluated following normalization of OD values by four methods. Computing normalized values as (OD-Nt)/(Pst-Nt), gave the most repeatable results, with the CCC being approximately 0.95 and the CV approximately 11%. When the OD values were higher than 1.2 and 0.3 for the positive and the negative controls, respectively, none of the normalization methods evaluated provided highly repeatable results and it was necessary to repeat the test. Two batches of the crude antigen preparation were evaluated for repeatability, and no difference was found (CCC=0.96). The use of preservative (bronopol) did not affect test results, nor did freezing the samples for up to 8 months. A significant positive relationship between ELISA OD for milk samples and SCC score was found. Therefore, the use of composite milk samples, which have less variable SCC than samples taken from each quarter, would be more suitable when the udder health status is unknown. The analytical methods used to evaluate repeatability provided a practical way to select among normalization procedures.

Identification of potential protective antigens of Ostertagia ostertagi with local antibody probes

The identification of protective helminth antigens remains the most important challenge in the development of parasitic vaccines. To identify protective antigens of Ostertagia ostertagi, an important abomasal parasite of cattle, parasite-specific local antibodies from the abomasal mucus and from the draining lymph nodes were collected from calves immunized with multiple infections and from 'primary infected' animals. With these probes, Western blots of extracts and excretion/ secretion (E/S) material from L3, L4 and adult life-stages as well as cDNA expression libraries were screened to identify antigens that were exclusively recognized by antibodies from 'immunized' calves. In the adult stage, a protein of 32 kDa was specifically detected on Western blot by mucus antibodies from 'immunized' animals. In the L3 and L4 larval stages, proteins situated in the regions of 28-29 kDa were recognized by mucus antibodies and a 59 kDa antigen was specifically recognized by lymph node antibodies from 'immunized' animals. Screening E/S material revealed no specific difference in recognition pattern between 'immunized' and 'primary infected' animals. Screening of the cDNA libraries revealed 26 relevant clones, coding for 15 proteins, among these several with potential protective capacity, immunodominant properties or functional and physiological importance e.g. metalloproteases, an aspartyl protease inhibitor and collagen.

A bulk tank milk survey of Ostertagia ostertagi antibodies in dairy herds in Prince Edward Island and their relationship with herd management factors and milk yield

The objective of this study was to quantify the relationship of the levels of antibodies to Ostertagia ostertagi in bulk-tank milk samples from Prince Edward Island (PEI) dairy farms to milk production and to herd-management practices potentially related to gastrointestinal nematode infections. The milk samples were obtained from 289 to 322 dairy farms during 2000; production and management data were available from 197 and 200 farms, respectively. Cow exposure to pasture and whole-herd anthelmintic treatment were the only herd management variables significantly associated with antibody levels in the fall of 2000. An increase in antibody levels from the observed 25th percentile to the 75th percentile (interquartile range) was associated with a drop in milk production of 1.2 kg/cow/day. The results of this study indicate that the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for O. ostertagi antibody is a potentially useful technique to measure parasite exposure in adult dairy cows and that parasite burdens in lactating cattle in PEI have an important impact on milk production.

Genomic tools to improve parasite resistance

The natural genetic variability of the ruminant immune system provides a feasible means to control gastrointestinal (GI) parasite infection without anthelmintics. However, the paradigm of traditional selection has not been effectively applied to the moderately heritable traits of parasite resistance (h approximately equal to 0.3) due to the difficulty and expense of gathering accurate phenotypes in a commercial production setting. These characteristics make host traits related to GI nematode infection ideal candidates for genomics-based research. To initiate explanation of important allelic differences, economic trait loci (ETL) are being identified and mapped using a resource population of Angus cattle segregating for GI nematode resistance and susceptibility to the two most common nematode parasites of US cattle, Ostertagia ostertagi and Cooperia oncophora. The population is composed of five generations of half-sib progeny with complete phenotypic records produced from controlled infections. To detect the genomic locations of the three distinct phenotypic traits being expressed (innately immune, acquired immune, and immunologically non-responsive), genotypes have been generated for DNA markers (N=199) spaced at regular intervals (approximately 20cm intervals) throughout the entire genome (3000cm). Although initial ETL detection may be limited by half-sib family size, the unique structure of this population provides additional statistical power for refining map position of potential ETL. After allele frequency and contribution to phenotype are determined in this population, marker tests associated with ETL most beneficial for controlling parasite infection can be accurately used for selection. Comparative map and functional genomic information from humans and other species of biomedical importance will be utilized in further investigations to elucidate the genes underlying ETL.

Role of the bovine immune system and genome in resistance to gastrointestinal nematodes

Gastrointestinal nematode infections of cattle remain a constraint on the efficient raising of cattle on pasture throughout the world. Most of the common genera of parasites found in cattle stimulate an effective level of protective immunity in most animals within the herd after the animals have been on pasture for several months. In contrast, cattle remain susceptible to infection by Ostertagia for many months, and immunity that actually reduces the development of newly acquired larvae is usually not evident until the animals are more than 2 years old. This prolonged susceptibility to reinfection is a major reason that this parasite remains the most economically important GI nematode in temperate regions of the world. Although, animals remain susceptible to reinfection for a prolonged period of time, there are a number of manifestations of the immune response that result in an enhanced level of herd immunity. These include a delay in the development time of the parasites, an increase in the number of larvae that undergo an inhibition in development, morphological changes in the worms, stunting of newly acquired worms, and most importantly a reduction in the number of eggs produced by the female worms. The overall result of these manifestations of immunity is a reduction in parasite transmission within the cattle herd. The immune mechanisms responsible for these different types of functional immunity remain to be defined. In general, GI nematode infections in mammals elicit very strong Th2-like responses characterized by high levels of Interleukin 4 (IL4), high levels of IgG1 and IgE antibodies, and large numbers of mast cells. In cattle, the most extensively studied GI nematode, in regards to host immune responses, is Ostertagia ostertagi. In Ostertagia infections, antigens are presented to the host in the draining lymph nodes very soon after infection, and within the first 3-4 days of infection these cells have left the nodes, entered the peripheral circulation, and have homed to tissues immediately surrounding the parasite where they become established. The immune response seen in the abomasum is in many ways are similar to that seen other mammalian hosts, with high levels of expression of IL4 in the draining lymph nodes and in lymphocytes isolated from the mucosa. But unlike a number of other systems, lymphocyte populations taken from Ostertagia infected cattle seem to be up-regulated for a number of other cytokines, most notably Interferon (IFN, implying that in Ostertagia infections, the immune response elicit is not simply a stereotypic Th2 response. In addition, effector cell populations in the tissues surrounding the parasites, are not typical, inferring the Ostertagia has evolved means to suppress or evade protective immune mechanisms. Studies have also demonstrated that the number of nematode eggs/gram (EPG) in feces of pastured cattle is strongly influenced by host genetics and that the heritability of this trait is approximately 0.30. In addition, EPG values are not "normally" distributed and a small percentage of a herd is responsible for the majority of parasite transmission. This suggests that genetic management of a small percentage of the herd can considerably reduce overall parasite transmission. A selective breeding program has been initiated to identify the host genes controlling resistance/susceptibility to the parasites. The best indicator of the number of Cooperia infecting a host is the EPG value, while Ostertagia is best measured by serum pepsinogen levels, weight gain, and measures of anemia. Other phenotypic measures are either not significantly associated with parasite numbers or are very weakly correlated. In addition, calves can be separated into three types: (1) Type I which never demonstrates high EPG values, (2) Type II which shows rises in EPG values through the first 2 months on pasture which then fall and remain at levels associated with Type I calves, and (3) Type III calves which maintain high EPG levels. The approximate percentage of these calves is 25:50:25 respectively. Because these cattle are segregating for traits involved in resistance and susceptibility to GI nematodes, this resource population is being used to effectively detect the genomic locations of these Economic Trait Loci (ETL). For relational analysis between phenotype and genome location, over 80,000 genotypes have been generated by PCR amplification, and marker genotypes have been scored to produce inheritance data. The marker allele inheritance data is currently being statistically analyzed to detect patterns of co-segregation between allele haplotype and EPG phenotypes. Statistical power of this genome-wide scan has been strengthened by including genotypic data from the historic pedigree. In our herd, paternal half-sib families range from 5-13 progeny/sire, and extensive marker genotypes are available from ancestors of the population most of which are paternally descended from a single founding sire. Once ETL have been identified the next will be to refine ETL map resolution in attempt to discover the genes underlying disease phenotypes. Accurate identification of genes controlling resistance will offer the producer several alternatives for disease control. For a non-organic producer, the small percentage of susceptible animals can be targeted for drug administration. This approach would reduce both the cost of anthelmintics used and the odds for selection of drug resistant mutants, because the selective agent (drug) would not be applied over the entire parasite population. A second treatment option would be based on correcting a heritable immunologic condition. In this case, susceptible animals could be the targets for immunotherapy involving vaccines of immunomodulation. A final option would be genetic selection to remove susceptible animals from the herd. Producers with a high degree of risk for parasite-induced production losses, such as organic producers of producers in geographic areas with environmental conditions favorable to high rates of transmission would benefit the most from this strategy. In contrast, producers at low risk could take a more conservative approach and select against susceptibility when other factors were equal.

Immunisation of lambs with drug-abbreviated Haemonchus contortus infections: protection against homologous and heterologous challenge

Haemonchus contortus is known as a prolific parasite, producing high numbers of eggs. It could therefore be used as a cheap source of larvae for immunisation of lambs. The value of immunisation would be improved if the immunity produced gave protection against not only homologous but also heterologous infections. Because antibody cross-reactivity between Haemonchus and Ostertagia has been well established, we wanted to know whether drug-abbreviated infections of H. contortus would stimulate production of antibodies that would cross-react with Trichostrongylus colubriformis. The results obtained from these trials indicated that H. contortus drug-abbreviated infections produced significant immunity against not only Haemonchus but also O. circumcincta. Immunisation increased the level of immunoglobulin E (IgE) and IgE-specific antibodies against T. colubriformis, but the differences between experimental and control animals were not statistically significant. Significantly higher levels of IgG-specific antibodies against T. colubriformis were observed.

The immune response and the evaluation of acquired immunity against gastrointestinal nematodes in cattle: a review

The present review discusses the immune responses to gastrointestinal nematodes in cattle and the different immunological and parasitological parameters used to assess acquired immunity. Measuring acquired immunity to gastrointestinal nematodes in cattle (e.g. for the evaluation of candidate parasite vaccines) is hampered by the limited understanding of bovine immune responses against gastrointestinal parasites. In this paper the available data on protective immunity against gastrointestinal nematodes, and especially Ostertagia ostertagi, in cattle are compared with the current knowledge of protective immune responses against gastrointestinal nematodes in rodent models and small ruminants. In contrast to the immune response in mice, which is controlled by T helper 2 (Th2) lymphocytes and results in mast cell- or goblet cell-mediated expulsion of adult worms, bovine immune responses to O. ostertagi do not show a clear Th2 cytokine profile, nor do they result in rapid expulsion of the parasite. The first manifestation of immunity to O. ostertagi in calves is a reduction of worm fecundity, possibly regulated by the local IgA response. Worm numbers are only reduced after a prolonged period of host-parasite contact, and there are indications that O. ostertagi actively suppresses the host's immune response. Until the mechanisms of protective immunity against O. ostertagi are revealed, the use of immunological parameters to estimate acquired immunity in cattle is based on their correlation with parasitological parameters and on extrapolation from rodent and small ruminant models. Assessing the resistance of calves against a challenge infection by means of parasitological parameters is probably still the most accurate way to measure acquired immunity against gastrointestinal nematodes.

Can an increased intake of metabolizable protein affect the periparturient relaxation in immunity against teladorsagia circumcincta in sheep?

Within the overall hypothesis that the periparturient relaxation of immunity (PPRI) to gastrointestinal parasites has a nutritional basis, we studied whether an increased intake of metabolizable protein (MP) could affect the expression of immunity to Teladorsagia (Ostertagia) circumcincta of twin-bearing and -rearing Greyface ewes. Two sets of iso-energetic diets were formulated to provide either 85% (L-) or 130% (H-) of the MP requirements during the last 6 weeks of pregnancy (-P) and the first 6 weeks of lactation (-L). Thirty ewes were allocated to LP or HP. Six ewes of each group were slaughtered after lambing (S(0)); the remaining 24 ewes of each group were allocated to either LL or HL, thus creating four treatment combinations during lactation (LP/LL, LP/HL, HP/LL and HP/HL; n=12). Six ewes of each treatment combination were slaughtered at Week 3 (S(3)) or at Week 6 (S(6)) in lactation. The HP ewes were heavier at lambing, produced heavier lambs, had lower faecal egg counts (FECs), a lower concentration of plasma pepsinogen, a higher concentration of plasma albumin during late pregnancy and more abomasal globule leukocytes (GLs) but similar worm burdens at S(0) compared to the LP ewes. The LP/HL and HP/HL ewes had a higher calculated milk production than the LP/LL and HP/LL ewes. FECs increased for each treatment combination during the first 3 weeks of lactation. This increase concurred with fewer abomasal GLs at S(3) compared to S(0). The LP/HL and HP/HL ewes had a higher proportion of immature worms and more abomasal GLs than the LP/LL and HP/LL ewes at S(6). The FECs continued to increase during the second 3 weeks of lactation for the LP/LL ewes only, which concurred with an elevated plasma pepsinogen concentration and an absence of abomasal GLs at S(6). The plasma pepsinogen concentration decreased rapidly for the LP/HL ewes during lactation. We conclude that an increased intake of MP could enhance the expression of immunity to T. circumcincta of twin-bearing and -rearing Greyface ewes.

Identification of Ostertagia ostertagi specific cells in bovine abomasal lymph nodes

To investigate the contribution of different bovine cell subpopulations in the development of in vitro induced responses by Ostertagia ostertagi third larval antigen extract (L3), bovine abomasal lymph node cell suspensions were depleted of specific cell populations. The depleted cell suspensions were subsequently assayed for their proliferative responses to O. ostertagi L3 antigen extract. Proliferative responses to O. ostertagi L3 antigen extract were restricted to a CD2+ CD4- CD8- cell population and MHC II+ cells different from B-cells were of major importance. Depletion of CD4, CD8, CD4CD8, IgM or CD21 positive cells did not decrease proliferation to L3 antigen extract. Depletion of gammadelta T-cells, which also comprise a subpopulation of CD2+ CD4- CD8- cells, reduced proliferation to L3 antigen extract only in one animal. The results suggest that either gammadelta T-cells could be involved in the proliferation or that another as yet unidentified population is important for proliferation. The precise role of these populations during infection with O. ostertagi and the mechanism by which these cells may influence the host immune response are important issues that remain to be elucidated.

How lambs control infection with Ostertagia circumcincta

Two of the most important questions for immunologists studying nematode infections are what effect does the host response have on the parasite and which components of the host response are responsible for these effects. The number of nematodes and the mean length of adult female Ostertagia circumcincta was measured in over 500 6-7 month old lambs of the Scottish Blackface breed. Quantitative genetic analyses indicated that there was substantial genetic variation among lambs in faecal egg counts and in worm length but the analyses provided no evidence for genetic variation in worm numbers. Separate analyses have shown a strong relationship between decreased worm length and decreased worm fecundity. Therefore, genetic resistance in lambs appears to be due to control of worm growth and not to control of worm numbers. The only immune response that is consistently associated with reduced worm length is the IgA response to fourth-stage larvae. The association is remarkably strong. After allowing for the influence of worm number on worm length (density-dependence) essentially all of the variation among deliberately infected lambs in worm length can be accounted for, in a statistical sense, by variation in the strength and specificity of the local IgA response. Therefore, the IgA mediated suppression of worm growth and fecundity appears to be the major mechanism of resistance to O. circumcincta in lambs.

Cross-reactive antigens of Haemonchus contortus adult worms in Teladorsagia circumcincta infected goats

The adult Haemonchus contortus somatic antigens responsible for cross-reactivity have been analysed using serum samples from goat kids infected and reinfected with Teladorsagia circumcincta. Goat kids infected with T. circumcincta had similar serum ELISA values against somatic antigens of H. contortus as goats infected with H. contortus itself. Immunoblotting confirmed this extensive cross-reactivity particularly in the molecular weight range 105-29 kDa. However, peptides with high (195, 152 and 119 kDa) or low (23 kDa) molecular weight were only faintly recognized by heterologous sera.

Development of a protective immunity against Ostertagia leptospicularis in trickle-infected sheep and parallel changes of serum gastrin, pepsinogen and antibody levels

Nine lambs, approximately 9 months of age were allocated to three groups (A, B, C), with three animals in each. Sheep in Groups A and B were trickle-infected with doses of 1000 third-stage larvae (L3) of Ostertagia leptospicularis (five times per week) over periods of 7.5 and 10.5 weeks, respectively, and were subsequently treated with fenbendazole (7.5 mg/kg). Approximately 3 weeks after anthelmintic treatment, all sheep were challenged with a single dose of 100,000 L3, whereas sheep of Group C received the same dose as a primary infection. Sheep of Groups A and B were almost completely refractory against the challenge infection, as indicated by negative faecal egg counts and adult worm burdens. A relatively high infection level was present in the sheep of Group C. The results indicate that a comparatively short immunization period of 7.5 weeks is sufficient to protect lambs against subsequent larval challenge. During immunization, the pepsinogen-, gastrin- and IgA-responses were similar in the individual sheep. In contrast to parasite-specific IgG1 and IgG2 levels, IgA decreased rapidly after cessation of trickle infection and parallel anthelmintic treatment, and may therefore indicate current exposure to parasite antigen. After challenge, the majority of the immunized sheep exhibited immediate and short-term responses of pepsinogen, gastrin and IgA in the serum. The time course and the level of each of these responses were very similar in the individual sheep, suggesting that the release of pepsinogen, gastrin and IgA into the circulation was influenced by related mechanisms.

The recognition of molecules from fourth-stage larvae of Ostertagia circumcincta by IgA from infected sheep

The recognition of antigens from fourth-stage Ostertagia circumcincta by plasma IgA was studied in a group of 30, ten-month-old Scottish Blackface sheep which had been naturally, then deliberately infected. Western blotting revealed 49 bands that were recognized by antibody from one or more of the 30 sheep. There was a heterogeneous pattern of antigen recognition amongst the sheep. No individual recognized all the 49 bands and only one of the 49 bands was recognized by all sheep. Two antigens with approximate molecular weights 87,000 Da and 129,000 Da were significantly associated with a reduction in mean adult worm lengths. The observed variation in recognition of these two antigens on fourth-stage larval preparations accounted, in a statistical sense, for nearly 40% of the total variation in worm length. In addition to the variation in antibody mediated recognition of these two parasite molecules, three other components have been implicated in regulating worm length. They are a 37,000 Da band from adult worms, the amount of fourth-stage larval specific IgA in the abomasal mucosa and the density-dependent influence of adult worm burden. Together, these components and their interactions accounted for over 90% of the observed variation in worm length. These results indicate that the parasite-specific IgA response, or something extremely closely associated with it, is the major immunological mechanism controlling worm length.

Mechanisms underlying resistance to nematode infection

Lambs show considerable genetic variation in faecal egg count following natural, predominantly Ostertagia circumcinta infection. This genetic variation is acquired and not innate. Worm length is positively associated with worm fecundity. The genetic variation in faecal egg count is a consequence of genetic variation in worm length and hence worm fecundity, and not of genetic variation in worm burdens. In contrast to lambs, mature sheep may be able to regulate both fecundity and worm numbers. In lambs, three factors account for the majority of the variation in worm length: the strength of the local IgA response against fourth-stage larvae, the specificity of this response against four molecules in particular, and the density-dependent influence of worm number.

Characterization of protective immune responses in local lymphoid tissues after drug-attenuated infections with Ostertagia ostertagi in calves

In the present study, cell-surface markers and cytokine gene expression of lymphocytes from the local lymph nodes were studied 9 days after primary infection with Ostertagia ostertagi in previously naive calves or in calves previously immunized with multiple, chemically attenuated infections. Changes in lymphocyte populations were assessed by flow cytometry utilizing monoclonal antibodies specific for bovine cell-surface markers. Changes observed in the percentages of lymphoid populations after challenge were similar in animals immunized by either three or five drug-attenuated infections. In both immunized groups, the CD4+/CD8+ ratio was significantly higher than in naive animals after challenge infections. In addition, both immunized groups showed significantly lower levels of Ig-bearing cells upon experimental challenge when compared to animals with a primary experimental infection. No differences were observed in the number of gammadelta or interleukin 2 receptor (IL-2R) positive cells. The levels of mRNA for IL-4, IL-10, IL-15, IFN-gamma and TGF-beta1 were examined by competitive RT-PCR. After challenge, the levels of these cytokines were lower in animals immunized by five drug-attenuated infections, and in the case of IL-4 and TGF-beta1, these differences were statistically significant. These results indicate that animals exhibiting protection from reinfection with O. ostertagi do not show a shift to higher percentages of Ig+ cells characteristic of a primary infection. In addition, protected animals appear to show a decreased IL4 and TGF-beta1 response upon challenge when compared to non-immune animals.

Stochastic effects in a model of nematode infection in ruminants

We illustrate the importance of stochastic effects in population models of biological systems and demonstrate a number of analytic and simulation-based approaches that can usefully be applied to such models. In so doing, we compare the stochastic approach to the more usual deterministic one. The model studied represents the gastrointestinal infection of ruminants by nematodes when the hosts maintain a fixed density. The incorporation of a feedback mechanism, which accounts for the immune response of the infected animals, results in a highly nonlinear model; similar forms of nonlinearity are a feature of many plausible models in population biology. In the absence of an analytic solution to the full stochastic model we explore a number of approximations and compare them to simulations of the full stochastic process. We explore three modes of behaviour of the system. In the endemic regime the stochastic system fluctuates widely around the non-zero fixed points of the deterministic model. In the managed regime, where the system is subject to external periodic perturbation, stochastic effects are negligible. Finally, we find that in a regime in which the deterministic model predicts the long-term persistence of oscillations the stochastic model shows that extinction can occur. Of the approximation procedures we consider, the Normal approximation to the full stochastic process is the most generally applicable, and it is also the most accurate in the light of simulation results. Local linearization provides reasonably accurate prediction of the variance-covariance structure, and a transfer function approach allows calculation of the time-lagged auto- and cross-correlations in the endemic regime. Linearization of the stochastic updates themselves results in poor prediction of the population variances.

Pathogenicity and immunogenicity of different isolates of Teladorsagia circumcincta

The effects on liveweight gain and development of immunity were studied in lambs trickle infected for 8 weeks with either a benzimidazole-resistant isolate (Moredun ovine resistant isolate, MORI), a multiple benzimidazole + ivermectin-resistant isolate (Moredun caprine resistant isolate, MCRI) or an unselected susceptible isolate (Moredun ovine susceptible isolate, MOSI) of Teladorsagia circumcincta. Plasma pepsinogen concentrations of infected groups were significantly elevated compared to an uninfected control group (P < 0.001) by day 14. The liveweight gains varied markedly but there were no statistical differences between the infected and uninfected control groups at any point in time during the study. Lambs infected with the MORI had significantly lower faecal consistency scores than the other challenged groups on days 7 and 14 (P < 0.05) but from day 21 onwards, faecal consistencies were similar in all of the groups. There was a notable difference in the pre-patent periods of the different isolates with the MOSI producing positive faecal egg counts (FECs) by day 14 of the study. The FECs remained reasonably low once infections had reached patency and there were no further differences between the groups. Following administration of anthelmintic to remove residual worms from the trickle infection, no differences between the infected groups in terms of worm burden or mucosal mast cell numbers were evident as a consequence of a single challenge infection. The changes in genetic code associated with enhanced resistance against anthelmintics do not appear to have resulted in any fundamental alteration of the pathogenicity and immunogenicity of these three isolates of Teladorsagia.

Interpreting comparative experiments on parasite burdens in animals using randomization and canonical variates

Comparative experiments on parasite burdens present difficulties for modelling and interpretation: data tend to have highly skewed distributions, some standard methods of testing for effects have low power, and there is a need to make allowance for dependencies among the various measurements. Randomization testing and canonical variates analysis are advocated as a means of minimising these problems.

Quantification of cytokine gene expression in lamina propria lymphocytes of cattle following infection with Ostertagia ostertagi

Changes in cell surface markers and cytokine transcription were analyzed in lamina propria lymphocytes from control animals (noninfected calves) and calves after a single high but nonprotective primary infection with Ostertagia ostertagi. Flow cytometry of cells recovered from the lamina propria showed an increase in the percentages of IgM+, WC1+, and IL-2R+-bearing cells 10 days after infection; however, 2 mo after infection, cell staining was comparable to preinfection levels. Transcription levels of interleukins IL-2, IL-4, IL-10, and interferon (IFN)-gamma mRNA were measured using a competitive reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction. Results indicated elevated levels of IL-4 and IFN-gamma in the infected animals at 10 days and at 60 days after infection. Transcription of IL-10 also increased; however, this change was not observed until 60 days postinfection.

Immunity development against Ostertagia ostertagi and other gastrointestinal nematodes in cattle

The immunological response to gastrointestinal nematodes is complex and it will take time and financial support to dissect the different components of protective immunity in ruminants. The present review briefly summarises different aspects and manifestations of protective immunity in cattle against gastrointestinal nematodes, especially Ostertagia ostertagi, and the factors that may interact with the development of this immunity.

Effects of gastrointestinal nematode infection on the ruminant immune system

Gastrointestinal (GI) nematodes of ruminants evoke a wide variety of immune responses in their hosts. In terms of specific immune responses directed against parasite antigens, the resulting immune responses may vary from those that give strong protection from reinfection after a relatively light exposure (e.g. Oesophagostomum radiatum) to responses that are very weak and delayed in their onset (e.g. Ostertagia ostertagi). The nature of these protective immune responses has been covered in another section of the workshop and the purpose of this section will be to explore the nature of changes that occur in the immune system of infected animals and to discuss the effect of GI nematode infections upon the overall immunoresponsiveness of the host. The discussion will focus primarily on Ostertagia ostertagi because this parasite has received the most attention in published studies. The interaction of Ostertagia and the host immune system presents what appears to be an interesting contradiction. Protective immunity directed against the parasite is slow to arise and when compared to some of the other GI nematodes, is relatively weak. Although responses that reduce egg output in the feces or increase the number of larvae undergoing inhibition may occur after a relatively brief exposure (3-4 months), immune responses which reduce the number of parasites that can establish in the host are not evident until the animal's second year. Additionally, even older animals that have spent several seasons on infected pastures will have low numbers of Ostertagia in their abomasa, indicating that sterilizing immune responses against the parasite are uncommon. In spite of this apparent lack of specific protective immune responses, infections with Ostertagia induce profound changes in the host immune system. These changes include a tremendous expansion of both the number of lymphocytes in the local lymph nodes and the number of lymphoid cells in the mucosa of the abomasum. This expansion in cell numbers involves a shift away from a predominant classic T cell population (CD2 and CD3 positive), to a population where T cell percentages are decreased and B cells (immunoglobulin-bearing) and gamma-delta cells are increased. At the same time the expression of messenger RNAs for T cell cytokines (IL2, IL4, IL10 and gamma-interferon) is changed to that of increased expression of IL4 and IL10 and decreased expression of IL2 and perhaps of gamma-interferon. The reasons for these changes remain to be elucidated, but it is evident that the lack of protective immune responses is not the result of a poor exposure of the host to parasite products, or to the stomach being an immunoprivileged site. In fact, a superficial look at the responses elicited indicates that Ostertagia induces responses (the so-called TH2 mediated responses) that are widely considered to be the type of responses necessary for protection against GI nematodes. There are many factors that could lead to this apparent lack of immunity in the face of a strong stimulation of immune responses including: (1) the elicitation of suboptimal responses; (2) the failure of the abomasum to function as an efficient effector organ; (3) active evasion of the functional immune response by the parasite; and (4) that these classic responses are not protective in this particular ruminant-parasite system and that novel protective mechanisms may be required. The strong stimulation of the host gut immune system by Ostertagia and perhaps by other GI nematode infections, raises questions about the potential effects of such infections on the overall well-being of the host. A number of authors have indicated that Ostertagia infections may diminish the host's ability to mount subsequent immune responses to antigenic challenges such as vaccination against other infectious organisms. In addition, recent studies have indicated that infections with GI nematodes may result in increased circulatory levels of stress-related hormo

The genetic basis of resistance to Ostertagia circumcincta in lambs

The relationship between Ostertagia (Teladorsagia) circumcincta and sheep is one of the best understood host-parasite relationships in any species. The key components of resistance have been quantified, the extent of genetic control has been established for lambs, and methods now exist to breed lambs which will be both more resistant to worms and more productive than unselected lambs. A major gene for resistance has been identified within or around the major histocompatibility complex, and this gene appears to be the strongest yet identified for resistance to any parasite species. The most important mechanisms of resistance are local IgA responses which regulate worm fecundity and immediate hypersensitivity responses which regulate worm burdens. IgA responses develop before effective immediate hypersensitivity responses. Good simulation models now exist to predict, for example, outbreaks of disease and the response of sheep to selection. The challenge now is to use our improved understanding of the population biology to develop even better simulation models and to produce expert systems based on these models which can be used by veterinarians and others to determine optimal procedures for individual farms to control disease and reduce sub-clinical economic losses.

Cytokine profile induced by a primary infection with Ostertagia ostertagi in cattle

Changes that occur in the local draining lymph nodes including, changes in cell surface markers and cytokine gene expression were studied over the first 4 weeks of a primary, Ostertagia ostertagi infection of the abomasum. Cells recovered from the abomasal lymph nodes (ABLN) after infection showed a decrease in the percentage of CD3+ cells, and an increase in the percentage of IgM+ cells and cells bearing the TcR1 marker. These changes were coincident with an increase in the proportion of activated cells (II-2R). Analysis of mitogen-stimulated ABLN cells by RNase protection assay (RPA) showed a dramatic reduction in IL-2 and IFN-gamma transcription after infection. In addition, analysis of unstimulated ABLN cells by competitive RT-PCR showed a similar decrease in demonstrable levels of IL-2 mRNA, but IL-10, IL-4 and IFN-gamma mRNA levels were elevated.

Isolation and phenotypic characterization of abomasal mucosal lymphocytes in the course of a primary Ostertagia ostertagi infection in calves

Isolation and characterization of surface marker phenotypes of abomasal intraepithelial (IEL), lamina propria (LPL) and abomasal lymph node lymphocytes (ABLN) from uninfected calves were conducted, and the dynamics of change in these populations during the course of a primary Ostertagia ostertagi infection were defined. To obtain viable IEL and LPL from the abomasal mucosa of cattle, a modified isolation method was developed. The phenotypic characterization of abomasal lymphocytes was accomplished by indirect immunofluorescence staining. In uninfected animals, numbers of T cells exceeded the number of immunoglobulin-bearing cells in IEL, LPL and ABLN. The predominant T cell type in IEL and LPL was CD8+ cells, while the CD4+ T cell predominated in ABLN. Levels of activated cells and T cell receptor-1 gamma delta T cells were higher in IEL and LPL compared to ABLN. Within 3 weeks of infection, the number of lymphocytes recovered from the abomasal lamina propira and the mass of the ABLN was dramatically increased when compared to uninfected animals. Laser flow cytometric analysis demonstrated increased levels of immunoglobulin-bearing cells, gamma delta T cells, and activated T cells in IEL, LPL and ABLN in the infected animals. The greatest changes in LPL and ABLN took place during the first days of infection, and these changes were apparent throughout the 28 days covered by the experiment.

Induction and suppression of lymphocyte proliferation by antigen extracts of Ostertagia ostertagi

To obtain an insight into the responses of T-cells of cattle to Ostertagia ostertagi, the responses of peripheral blood and lymph node lymphocytes to O. ostertagi antigen extracts were determined in both exposed and naive calves. The lymphocyte responses induced by O. ostertagi antigen extracts of the third (L3) and fourth (L4) larval stages, as well as adult worms, were analysed. Although peripheral blood lymphocyte responses were very low or absent, abomasal lymph node lymphocytes of exposed animals showed a strong response to the L3 antigen extract. No such response was observed in naive calves or in mesenteric lymph node cells of exposed calves. L4 and adult worm antigen extracts suppressed the proliferative responses induced by the L3 antigen extract. Whether or not this suppressive effect plays a role in the slow rate at which protective immunity develops against O. ostertagi is under further investigation.

The influence of a Cooperia oncophora priming on a concurrent challenge with Ostertagia ostertagi and C. oncophora in calves

The development of immunity to Ostertagia ostertagi and Cooperia oncophora and interactions between these species were investigated in experimentally infected calves. Parasitological, serological and histological parameters were used for assessing immune responses. No conclusive evidence of an effect of C. oncophora on the course of an O. ostertagi infection in calves could be shown. Following a challenge with C. oncophora and O. ostertagi of C. oncophora primed calves, no significant reductions in establishment rate, faecal egg counts, worm length or the percentage of early fourth stage larvae could be demonstrated. Results also confirmed earlier work showing the very different degrees of immunity conferred following immunisation with either C. oncophora or O. ostertagi. While a protective immunity was generated in the case of C. oncophora, continuous infection of calves with 420000 L3 of O. ostertagi during almost 5 months induced immune reactions which affected growth and fecundity of the worms but not the establishment rate.

Heterogeneity in the recognition of Ostertagia circumcincta antigens by serum antibody from mature, infected sheep

The recognition of parasite molecules from third-stage and adult Ostertagia circumcincta by serum antibody was studied in a group of matched, mature Scottish Blackface sheep that had been naturally and then deliberately infected. A total of 20 molecules was recognized in somatic extracts from third-stage larvae and 31 molecules in somatic extracts from adult parasites. However, no sheep recognized all immunogenic molecules and no molecule was recognized by all sheep. There was no obvious relationship between recognition of any parasite antigen and polymorphism at class I loci or at the DRBI class II locus of the major histocompatibility complex in these outbred animals. Only 15 molecules from third-stage larvae were present at a frequency suitable for statistical analysis and recognition of three of these 15 molecules was associated with differences in worm burdens. Recognition of two of five molecules from adult parasites was associated with differences in worm length. These results indicate that variation in the recognition of specific, identifiable parasite molecules may be partly responsible for variation among sheep in resistance to O. circumcincta.

The death rate of Ostertagia circumcincta and Trichostrongylus colubriformis in lactating ewes: implications for anthelmintic resistance

Lactating adult Romney ewes were infected, 4 weeks post-lambing, with benzimidazole (bz) resistant strains of Ostertagia circumcincta and Trichostrongylus colubriformis. Commencing 4 weeks after the initial infection the ewes were subjected to challenge 3 times weekly with 5000 L3 of bz-susceptible strains of both parasite species. At weekly intervals over the following 6 weeks, groups of ewes were drenched with a bz anthelmintic (oxfendazole) to remove bz-susceptible parasites and slaughtered to determine adult worm burdens of the bz-resistant parasites. The O. circumcincta infection declined exponentially with a mean daily death rate of 10.6% day-1 and no worms were recovered after 4 weeks or more of challenge. The T. colubriformis infection did not decline significantly over the 6 weeks of continuous challenge, indicating that the death rate could not be distinguished from zero. The upper 95% confidence limit for the death rate of T. colubriformis was 4.9%. The implications of these death rates on selection for drug resistance following ewe drenching during the post-partum period are discussed with selection pressure likely to be greater for T. colubriformis than for O. circumcincta.

The presence of an early L4 population in relation to the acquired resistance of calves naturally infected with Ostertagia ostertagi

The aim of the present study was to determine if the presence of inhibited L4 Ostertagia ostertagi populations during the housing period influenced the level of acquired immunity in calves at the start of the second grazing season. Four groups (A-D) of first season grazing calves were turned out onto a heavily infected pasture for five months, while the fifth group (E) was kept as uninfected controls. At housing all group A calves were necropsied for worm counts. A mean total of 78915 Ostertagia worms were found, of which 85% were in the early L4 stage. The calves of group C were dewormed with ivermectin at housing, while groups B and D remained untreated. After the calves were housed, egg counts, pepsinogen and antibody levels all declined in groups B, C and D, but during the second half of the housing period pepsinogen and antibody levels increased again in groups B and D. The effect of housing on the resident worm population was evaluated by slaughtering all group B calves for worm counts at the end of the housing period. A mean burden of 57,950 Ostertagia was present, with 78% as early L4 larvae. The remaining three groups (C, D and E) were treated with oxfendazole and turned out on the same pasture as the previous year for a challenge period of four weeks. In the control calves (group E) the egg output rose steeply, while egg counts remained low in groups C and D. In addition the worm burdens of the previously infected groups C and D were significantly reduced (75-90%), and the percentage of inhibited L4 larvae was significantly increased compared to the control group E. No significant difference was observed between the calves that were treated at housing (group C) and the untreated animals of group D. It was concluded that the continued presence of an inhibited L4 population during housing was not essential for maintenance of immunity.

Immunisation of sheep by drug-abbreviated infections of Ostertagia circumcincta and Trichostrongylus colubriformis against field challenge of gastro-intestinal nematodes

A very high level of protection was achieved against homologous (up to 97%) and heterologous (up to 87%) infections in 12-month-old Romney sheep immunised with oxfendazole-abbreviated infections of Ostertagia circumcincta and Trichostrongylus colubriformis. No significant protection occurred following ivermectin-abbreviated infections. None of the immunised sheep showed an increase in antibody level against excretory-secretory antigen of T. colubriformis infective larvae. The immunisation procedures did not cause a decrease in wool production, or liveweight gains compared with non-immunised controls.