Subsets of retinal progenitors display temporally regulated and distinct biases in the fates of their progeny

A POU factor binding site upstream of the Chx10 homeobox gene is required for Chx10 expression in subsets of retinal progenitor cells and bipolar cells

Retinal progenitor cells (RPCs) undergo a series of changes over time that affect their competency to produce different cell types at different times in development. The transcriptional machinery that regulates these changes, as well as associated gene expression changes, have not been characterized. An analysis of the regulatory region of the retinal homeodomain transcription factor, Chx10, was carried out using in ovo electroporations in chick and transgenic mice. An RPC enhancer was defined that mediates reporter activity in subsets of RPCs and directs high-level expression in intermediate and late RPCs. Using bioinformatic and biochemical analysis, a key binding site in this enhancer was found and was shown to be bound by the POU domain factors, Brn-2 and Tst-1/SCIP, in retinal extracts. Analysis of the Brn-2 expression pattern shows that it is expressed in intermediate and late RPCs, but not early RPCs, and thus partially overlaps with expression of the reporter activated by the defined Chx10 enhancer. Biochemical analysis also revealed binding of both Chx10 and Brn-2 to an enhancer of the CNS progenitor cell marker, Nestin. Nestin expression in the retina is restricted to intermediate/late RPC subsets, and genetic evidence is presented that demonstrates that Chx10 represses Nestin expression in early RPCs. A bipolar cell enhancer for Chx10 also was defined, and a role for Brn-2 in expression of Chx10 in bipolar cells is predicted. These data identify Brn-2 as a new marker of subsets of RPCs and suggest a mechanism by which a combination of POU factors and Chx10 define RPC gene expression patterns, such as that of Nestin.

The search for the retinoblastoma cell of origin

The cellular effects of the genetic defects associated with tumorigenesis are context dependent. To better understand the reasons that different cell types require distinct combinations of mutations to form tumours, it is essential to identify and characterize a tumour's 'cell of origin'. Retinoblastoma, a rare childhood cancer of the retina that is caused by RB inactivation, is a good model in which to search for a tumour cell of origin, because retinal development is well understood and the initiating genetic lesion is well characterized. Identifying the cell of origin for this tumour would advance our understanding of how cellular context affects the requirement of specific mutations for cancer initiation and progression.

Foxn4 controls the genesis of amacrine and horizontal cells by retinal progenitors

During vertebrate retinogenesis, seven classes of cells are specified from multipotent progenitors. To date, the mechanisms underlying multipotent cell fate determination by retinal progenitors remain poorly understood. Here, we show that the Foxn4 winged helix/forkhead transcription factor is expressed in a subset of mitotic progenitors during mouse retinogenesis. Targeted disruption of Foxn4 largely eliminates amacrine neurons and completely abolishes horizontal cells, while overexpression of Foxn4 strongly promotes an amacrine cell fate. These results indicate that Foxn4 is both necessary and sufficient for commitment to the amacrine cell fate and is nonredundantly required for the genesis of horizontal cells. Furthermore, we provide evidence that Foxn4 controls the formation of amacrine and horizontal cells by activating the expression of the retinogenic factors Math3, NeuroD1, and Prox1. Our data suggest a model in which Foxn4 cooperates with other key retinogenic factors to mediate the multipotent differentiation of retinal progenitors.

Out-foxing fate; molecular switches create neuronal diversity in the retina

Progenitor cells in the mammalian retina generate at least 55 distinct kinds of neurons. Two reports in this issue of Neuron reveal two transcription factors (Foxn4 and Bhlhb4) that contribute to the development of this remarkable cellular diversity.

SPECIFICATION OF TEMPORAL IDENTITY IN THE DEVELOPING NERVOUS SYSTEM

The nervous system of higher organisms exhibits extraordinary cellular diversity owing to complex spatial and temporal patterning mechanisms. The role of spatial patterning in generating neuronal diversity is well known; here we discuss how neural progenitors change over time to contribute to cell diversity within the central nervous system (CNS). We focus on five model systems: the vertebrate retina, cortex, hindbrain, spinal cord, and Drosophila neuroblasts. For each, we address the following questions: Do multipotent progenitors generate different neuronal cell types in an invariant order? Do changes in progenitor-intrinsic factors or progenitor-extrinsic signals regulate temporal identity (i.e., the sequence of neuronal cell types produced)? What is the mechanism that regulates temporal identity transitions; i.e., what triggers the switch from one temporal identity to the next? By applying the same criteria to analyze each model system, we try to highlight common themes, point out unique attributes of each system, and identify directions for future research.

Genomic analysis of mouse retinal development

The vertebrate retina is comprised of seven major cell types that are generated in overlapping but well-defined intervals. To identify genes that might regulate retinal development, gene expression in the developing retina was profiled at multiple time points using serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE). The expression patterns of 1,051 genes that showed developmentally dynamic expression by SAGE were investigated using in situ hybridization. A molecular atlas of gene expression in the developing and mature retina was thereby constructed, along with a taxonomic classification of developmental gene expression patterns. Genes were identified that label both temporal and spatial subsets of mitotic progenitor cells. For each developing and mature major retinal cell type, genes selectively expressed in that cell type were identified. The gene expression profiles of retinal Müller glia and mitotic progenitor cells were found to be highly similar, suggesting that Müller glia might serve to produce multiple retinal cell types under the right conditions. In addition, multiple transcripts that were evolutionarily conserved that did not appear to encode open reading frames of more than 100 amino acids in length ("noncoding RNAs") were found to be dynamically and specifically expressed in developing and mature retinal cell types. Finally, many photoreceptor-enriched genes that mapped to chromosomal intervals containing retinal disease genes were identified. These data serve as a starting point for functional investigations of the roles of these genes in retinal development and physiology.

Alternative culture conditions for isolation and expansion of retinal progenitor cells

PURPOSE

To investigate different in vitro model systems for retinal progenitor cell (RPC) isolation and expansion.

METHODS

RPCs were isolated from embryonic day (E) 17 Long Evans rat retinas. Three different culture media: (1) modified serum free defined media (2) serum-containing media and (3) embryonic stem cell (ES)-conditioned media were used for RPC isolation and long term expansion. Expression of various cellular markers and cell morphologies were compared among the three culture systems at different passages by immunostaining and confocal microscopy.

RESULTS

All three culture systems could maintain RPCs as nestin-positive cells (78-87%) after long-term in vitro expansion. However, RPCs appeared to proliferate faster in the serum-free culture system. The ES-conditioned media provided the best RPC survival. Cells appeared smaller at early passages compared with later passages. This morphology change occurred at P9-P10 in the serum-free medium, and at P5-P6 in the other two culture systems.

CONCLUSIONS

The serum-free medium may be superior for preventing RPC differentiation during expansion.

The neurogenic competence of progenitors from the postnatal rat retina in vitro

The mammalian retina develops from stem or progenitor cells that are of neuroectodermal origin and derive from bilateral invaginations of the neuroepithelium, the optic vesicles. Shortly after birth, around 12 days postnatal in rats, the retina is fully developed in its cellular parts. Even though different cell types in the adult might be potential sources for retinal stem cells or progenitor cells, the retina is a non-neurogenic region and the diseased retina is devoid of any spontaneous regeneration. In an attempt to link late developmental processes to the adult situation, we analyzed the presence and the neurogenic potential of retinal progenitors during the postnatal period and compared it to adult ciliary body (CB) derived retinal progenitors and subventricular zone (SVZ) derived neural stem cells. Retinal progenitor properties were identified by the capacity to proliferate and by the expression of the progenitor markers Nestin, Flk-1, Chx10, Pax6 and the radial glia marker BLBP. The neurogenic potential was assayed by the expression of the neuronal markers doublecortin, betaIII Tubulin, Map2 and NSE, the glial makers A2B5, NG2, GalC and GFAP, and by incorporation of BrdU. The number of Flk-1 positive cells and concomitantly the number of newly born betaIII Tubulin-positive cells decreased within the first postnatal week in retinal progenitor cultures and no newly generated betaIII Tubulin, but GFAP positive cells were detected thereafter. In contrast to neural stem cells derived from the adult SVZ, postnatal and adult CB derived progenitors had a lower and a restricted proliferation potential and did not generate oligodendrocytes. The work demonstrates, however, that the existence of retinal progenitor cells is not restricted to embryonic development. In the sensory retina the differentiation potential of late retinal progenitors becomes restricted to the glial lineage, whereas neurogenic progenitor cells are still present in the CB. In addition, major differences in growth and differentiation potential of adult neural stem cells and postnatal and adult retinal progenitors are presented.

Roles of cell-extrinsic growth factors in vertebrate eye pattern formation and retinogenesis

Formation of the vertebrate visual system involves complex interplays of cell-extrinsic cues and cell-intrinsic determinants. Studies in several vertebrate species demonstrate that multiple classes of signaling molecules participate in pattern formation of the eye and neurogenesis of the retina. Certain signals, such as hedgehog, BMP, and FGF molecules, are repeatedly deployed at varying concentration thresholds and in different cellular contexts. Accumulating evidence reveals a striking conservation of molecular mechanisms regulating the neurogenic process between Drosophila and vertebrate retinas. The remaining challenge is to understand how these well-characterized signaling pathways are activated and integrated to impact eye morphogenesis and retinal progenitor cell fate determination.

Importance of intrinsic mechanisms in cell fate decisions in the developing rat retina

Cell diversification in the developing nervous system is thought to involve both cell-intrinsic mechanisms and extracellular signals, but their relative importance in particular cell fate decisions remains uncertain. In the mammalian retina, different cell types develop on a predictable schedule from multipotent retinal neuroepithelial cells (RNECs). A current view is that RNECs pass through a series of competence states, progressively changing their responsiveness to instructive extracellular cues, which also change over time. We show here, however, that embryonic day 16-17 (E16-17) rat RNECs develop similarly in serum-free clonal-density cultures and in serum-containing retinal explants--in the number of times they divide, the cell types they generate, and the order in which they generate these cell types. These surprising results suggest that extracellular signals may be less important than currently believed in determining when RNECs stop dividing and what cell types they generate when they withdraw from the cell cycle, at least from E16-17 onward.

Cell diversity in the retina: more than meets the eye

Over 10 years ago, Pax-6 was shown to play an evolutionarily conserved role in controlling eye formation from Drosophila to humans.1 Since then, the identification of an entire cascade of conserved eye determination genes has brought a new understanding to the developmental relationship between the insect compound eye and the vertebrate camera eye.2 Additional studies are now beginning to suggest that even late aspects of eye development, including cell type specification, also share common molecular machinery. In this commentary, I will discuss some of these findings, with a particular focus on the recent study by Dyer et al.3 describing a novel role for the Prox1 transcription factor in specifying horizontal cells in the mouse retina. As Prospero, the Drosophila homolog of Prox1, also participates in retinal cell specification, these data provide a forum for asking new questions concerning pathways that may regulate retinogenesis across evolution.

Transcriptional control of neuronal diversification in the retina

During embryonic development, the array of vastly different neuronal types that are incorporated into the functional architecture of the mature neuroretina derives from a common population of multipotent retinal progenitor cells (RPCs). Retinogenesis proceeds in a precise chronological order, with the seven principal cell classes generated in successive phases. Cell biological experiments established that this histogenetic order, at least in part, reflects intrinsic changes within the RPC pool. In recent years a number of molecules controlling various aspects of cell fate specification from RPCs have been identified. However, few attempts have been made to integrate previous concepts that emerged from cell biological studies and more recent results based on molecular genetic experiments. This review aims at providing an overview of recent advances in our understanding of the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying retinal neuronal diversification, with a particular focus on cell-intrinsic factors.

Isolation of a novel cDNA enriched in the undifferentiated chick retina and lens

By using a differential screening strategy, we have identified a previously uncharacterised gene that is preferentially expressed in chick retinal precursor cells as well as in the anterior epithelial cells of the lens at early stages of development. The EURL transcript has an open reading frame of 293 amino acids and a 3' untranslated region of >850 nucleotides. The only recognizable feature in the EURL (early undifferentiated retina and lens) amino acid sequence is a putative coiled-coil domain located at the C-terminus of the protein. The human EURL orthologue maps to chromosome 21q21. Northern blot analysis, in situ hybridization of tissue sections, and whole-mount hybridization indicate elevated levels of EURL mRNA in the embryonic dorsal retina from stage 14 (day 2) to stage 18 (day 3). At day 3.5, when >90% of the retinal cells are in the proliferative stage, EURL transcripts are found primarily in the peripheral dorsal retina, i.e., the most undifferentiated part of the dorsal retina. EURL transcripts are also detected in the lens at stage 18 and remain abundant in the proliferating epithelial cells of the lens until at least day 11. The distribution pattern of EURL in the developing retina and lens suggest a role before the events leading to cell determination and differentiation.

Characterization of Wnt signaling components and activation of the Wnt canonical pathway in the murine retina

The neuroepithelial layer of the developing eyecup contains multipotential precursor cells that give rise to all of the neurons and the one glial cell type present in the adult retina. Patterning within the retinal neuroepithelium is regulated by cell intrinsic as well as cell extrinsic mechanisms. Although the identity of some of the signaling molecules that regulate retinal development is known, the function of many others, especially members of the Wnt family, has yet to be characterized in the context of retinal development. We undertook a comprehensive in situ hybridization analysis to examine the expression of Wnt pathway components in the developing and adult mouse neural retina. Our findings confirm and extend previous expression studies in mice and other vertebrates, as we show that Wnt-3, -5a, -5b, and -7b are expressed in the neural retina and that there is a dynamic pattern of Wnt receptor (Mouse frizzled [Mfz]) and Wnt antagonist (Secreted-frizzled-related protein [Sfrp]) gene expression in the embryonic and perinatal neural retina. Moreover, we show that Wnt-13 is expressed in the pigment epithelium overlying the distal part of the eyecup and the ciliary margin and that Mfz-4, -6, and -7 are expressed in different regions within the ciliary margin. To determine where activation of canonical Wnt signaling is occurring in the retina, we examined reporter gene expression in TCF/Lef-LacZ mice and we demonstrate that the highest levels of beta-gal activity are found in the ciliary margin, adjacent to and within the Wnt-13 expression domain, implicating Wnt-13 signaling in the development of the ciliary margin and its derivatives.

Suppression of lens growth by alphaA-crystallin promoter-driven expression of diphtheria toxin results in disruption of retinal cell organization in zebrafish

In order to study lens-retina relationships during development, we cloned the zebrafish alphaA-crystallin cDNA and its promoter region. Using a 2.8-kb fragment of the zebrafish alphaA-crystallin promoter (z(alpha)Acry), we expressed the diphtheria toxin A fragment (DTA) in zebrafish embryos in a lens-specific manner. Injection of the z(alpha)Acry-DTA plasmid into eggs at the one-or two-cell stage resulted in the formation of small eyes, in which both lens and retina were reduced in size. In the DTA-expressing lenses, their fiber structure was disorganized, indicating that normal lens development had been abrogated. The neural retina also showed abnormal development, although this tissue did not express DTA. Lamination in the retina did not develop well, and molecular markers for the outer and inner plexiform layers were either abnormally expressed or absent. However, cell type-specific markers of ganglion and bipolar cells, as well as photoreceptors, were expressed in appropriate positions, indicating that initial differentiation of these retinal subpopulations occurred in the DTA-expressing embryos. Cell proliferation also proceeded normally in these embryos, although apoptosis was enhanced. These results suggest that the differentiated lens plays a critical role in the morphogenetic organization of retinal cells during eye development in zebrafish embryos.

Determination of retinal cell fates is affected in the absence of extraocular striated muscles

Neural retinas of genetically modified mouse embryos and fetuses entirely lacking extraocular striated muscles (designated as Myf5-/-:MyoD-/- or amyogenic) are used to study in vivo the role of extraocular muscle (i.e., fetal ocular movements) in the genesis of retinal cell diversity. Although retinal lamination and the total number of cells per retinal layer appeared unaffected in amyogenic fetuses, electron microscopy and histochemistry revealed the absence of cholinergic amacrine cell type. By contrast, the amounts of other amacrine cell subpopulations (calretinin-, tyrosine hydroxylase-, and parvalbumin-expressing) were increased, whereas the amounts of Islet1/2-expressing retinal ganglion cells were decreased. Surprisingly, it was not possible to detect any change in proliferation or cell death. Consistently, the number of progenitors for retinal ganglion cells (nestin-expressing precursors) were increased, whereas the amounts of precursors for amacrine cells (syntaxin- and VC1.1-expressing precursors) were decreased in the mutant retinas. The difference in requirements for extraocular muscle support in regulation of precise ratios of retinal neuronal cell types suggests an essential role of extrinsic cues in the determination of retinal cell fates. Taken together, it appears that patterning mechanisms intrinsic to the neural retina specify the basic organization of retinal spatial organization (e.g., retinal layers and total number of cells). However, extrinsic cues seem to change intrinsic properties (e.g., competence) of retinal progenitor cells and influence the ratios of the differentiated cell types (i.e., cell fate choice) they produce.

Cre-loxp fate-mapping of Pax6 enhancer active retinal and pancreatic progenitors

Pax6 plays important roles in the control of ocular and pancreatic development. We identified a 450 bp Pax6 enhancer that contains two interacting sequences: a 274 bp fragment sufficient for expression in retinal progenitors and an adjacent 156 bp fragment required for expression in pancreatic progenitors. Since this enhancer is only transiently expressed during embryogenesis, a Cre-loxP fate-mapping strategy was used to investigate the developmental potential of these progenitors. Surprisingly, the labeled retinal precursors predominantly gave rise to horizontal cells, indicating a cell lineage role in horizontal cell differentiation. In the pancreas, all enhancer-specific cells were restricted to endocrine and ductal cell lineages. This result lends support to a model whereby Pax6-expressing progenitors contribute to the adult pancreatic islets and ducts. The progenitor cell-specificity of this enhancer will be useful in studies that require either cell-specific expression or conditional gene inactivation in these cell populations.

Cellular localization of the vesicular inhibitory amino acid transporter in the mouse and human retina

Horizontal cells are classically thought to mediate lateral inhibition by gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA)-transporter mediated release. In the mammalian retina, however, GABA uptake and cloned GABA transporter were not detected in horizontal cells. Furthermore, the vesicular inhibitory amino acid transporter (VIAAT or VGAT) that loads GABA and glycine into synaptic vesicles was reported recently to be expressed in horizontal cells. To further assess synaptic transmission in mammalian horizontal cells, we examined the subcellular distribution of VIAAT in mouse and human retina by confocal microscopy with specific cell markers. VIAAT was observed in the mouse outer plexiform layer as punctate structures that localized in calbindin-positive horizontal cells. These structures were in close apposition with synaptophysin-, PSD-95-, dystrophin-, and bassoon-immunopositive photoreceptor terminals, suggesting that VIAAT is localized in horizontal cell tips at photoreceptor terminals. VIAAT-positive puncta were also in apposition to lectin-labeled cone terminals or dendrites of PKCalpha-immunopositive rod bipolar cells, indicating that VIAAT is expressed in horizontal cell tips at both rod and cone terminals. By contrast, only a very few puncta were observed in the human outer plexiform layer, whereas the inner plexiform layer remained labeled as in the mouse retina. When using adult human retinal cells in culture, horizontal cells identified by parvalbumin immunostaining were found to contain VIAAT, either at their terminals or throughout the entire cell similarly as in syntaxin-immunopositive cells. These differences between human retinal tissue and cultured cells were attributed to VIAAT degradation in postmortem retinal tissue. VIAAT localization in mouse and human horizontal cells further support the role of inhibitory transmitters in lateral inhibition at the photoreceptor terminals.

Mnb/Dyrk1A is transiently expressed and asymmetrically segregated in neural progenitor cells at the transition to neurogenic divisions

The Minibrain (Mnb) gene encodes a new family of protein kinases that is evolutionarily conserved from insects to humans. In Drosophila, Mnb is involved in postembryonic neurogenesis. In humans, MNB has been mapped within the Down's Syndrome (DS) critical region of chromosome 21 and is overexpressed in DS embryonic brain. In order to study a possible role of Mnb on the neurogenesis of vertebrate brain, we have cloned the chick Mnb orthologue and studied the spatiotemporal expression of Mnb in proliferative regions of the nervous system. In early embryos, Mnb is expressed before the onset of neurogenesis in the three general locations where neuronal precursors are originated: neuroepithelia of the neural tube, neural crest, and cranial placodes. Mnb is transiently expressed during a single cell cycle of neuroepithelial progenitor (NEP) cells. Mnb expression precedes and widely overlaps with the expression of Tis21, an antiproliferative gene that has been reported to be expressed in the onset of neurogenic divisions of NEP cells. Mnb transcription begins in mitosis, continues during G(1), and stops before S-phase. Very interestingly, we have found that Mnb mRNA is asymmetrically localized during the mitosis of these cells and inherited by one of the sibling cells after division. We propose that Mnb defines a transition step between proliferating and neurogenic divisions of NEP cells.

Pituitary adenylyl cyclase-activating polypeptide prevents induced cell death in retinal tissue through activation of cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase

Multiple neuroactive substances are secreted by neurons and/or glial cells and modulate the sensitivity to cell death. In the developing retina, it has been shown that increased intracellular levels of cAMP protect cells from degeneration. We tested the hypothesis that the neuroactive peptide pituitary adenylyl cyclase-activating polypeptide (PACAP) has neuroprotective effects upon the developing rat retina. PACAP38 prevented anisomycin-induced cell death in the neuroblastic layer (NBL) of retinal explants, and complete inhibition of induced cell death was obtained with 1 nm. A similar protective effect was observed with PACAP27 and with the specific PAC1 receptor agonist maxadilan but not with glucagon. Photoreceptor cell death induced by thapsigargin was also prevented by PACAP38. The neuroprotective effect of PACAP38 upon the NBL could be reverted by the competitive PACAP receptor antagonist PACAP6-38 and by the specific PAC1 receptor antagonist Maxd.4. Molecular and immunohistochemical analysis demonstrated PAC1 receptors, and treatment with PACAP38 induced phospho-cAMP-response element-binding protein immunoreactivity in the anisomycin-sensitive undifferentiated postmitotic cells within the NBL. PACAP38 produced an increase in cAMP but not inositol triphosphate, and treatment with the cAMP-dependent protein kinase inhibitor R(p)-cAMPS blocked the protective effect of PACAP38. The results indicate that activation of PAC1 receptors by PACAP38 modulates cell death in the developing retina through the intracellular cAMP/cAMP-dependent protein kinase pathway.

Retinal organization in the bcl-2-overexpressing transgenic mouse

Naturally occurring cell death is believed to play a major role during the development of the nervous system in the establishment of neuronal architecture. Here we study the effects of cell death inhibition by using a transgenic mouse in which the powerful antiapoptotic gene bcl-2 is expressed in neurons. The retina of this mouse reveals that the general neuronal plan has been maintained. However, bcl-2 overexpression leads to altered frequencies of the major cell types in the retina. Thus, it is possible to estimate cell-type-specific rates of apoptosis by observing the increases in numbers of cells in the bcl-2-overexpressing transgenic mouse.

The role of tangential dispersion in retinal mosaic formation

Individual types of retinal nerve cell are spaced across the retina in an orderly manner, ensuring a uniform sampling of the visual field. This regularity in cellular spacing has been commonly attributed to fate determination mechanisms operating around the time of cell birth, an hypothesis presuming that the position of a nerve cell is fixed within the plane of the retina from the time of its determination. At odds with this view, recent results from X-inactivation mosaic mice indicate that certain classes of retinal nerve cell, those known to form orderly mosaics in the adult retina, disperse tangentially during development. Furthermore, studies defining the spatial characteristics of developing and mature retinal mosaics suggest that cell-cell interactions around the time of morphological differentiation lead to mutual repulsion. Modelling studies in turn show that nothing more than a simple minimal spacing rule between neighboring cells of the same type is sufficient for the creation of the global patterning observed in biological retinal mosaics. For some cell types, the size of this "exclusion zone" surrounding individual cells is shown to be an intrinsic characteristic of each cell type, invariant across the retina, and accounting for the variation in mosaic regularity across changes in cell density. These results show how short-distance movements driven by intercellular interactions at the local level may mediate the emergence of the global patterning characteristic of retinal mosaics during development.

Retinal neuron activity of ETS domain-binding sites in a nicotinic acetylcholine receptor gene cluster enhancer

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAchRs) mediate amacrine to ganglion cell synaptic transmission in the developing mammalian retina. The clustered neuronal nAchRs subunit genes, alpha 3 and beta 4, are expressed in amacrine and ganglion cells where they are used to assemble functional receptor subtypes. The transcriptional mechanisms underlying expression of these subunits in retina are not yet known but may involve enhancers that are selectively active in retinal neurons. We previously identified a neuron-selective enhancer, beta 43', whose activity in neural cell lines is dependent on ETS domain-binding sites. To determine whether beta 43' is active in retinal neurons that express the alpha 3 and beta 4 genes, we investigated beta 43' activity in primary dissociated rat retinal cultures. We found that beta 43' is selectively active in retinal neurons compared with retinal non-neuronal cells. This activity was derived primarily from amacrine and ganglion neurons, which are the retinal neuron cell types that express the clustered genes. Moreover, beta 43' was selectively active in retinal neurons compared with cerebral cortical neurons suggesting that it is not a pan-neuronal enhancer. ETS factor-binding sites in the enhancer are required for its retinal neuron activity. These findings suggest that ETS factor interactions with beta 43' control retinal neuron expression of certain nAchR subtypes.

Generating neuronal diversity in the retina: one for nearly all

Visual perception of our environment essentially depends on the correct assembly of seven principal cell types into the functional architecture of the neuroretina. During retinogenesis these cell types derive from a common population of multipotent retinal progenitor cells (RPCs) residing in the inner layer of the optic cup. In contrast to other well studied regions of the developing CNS, retinal cell diversification is apparently not achieved by spatial prepatterning into distinct progenitor domains, but rather by the sequential production of cell types in a defined histogenetic order. Several lines of evidence suggest that this observation reflects substantial intrinsic changes in the retinogenic potential of RPCs. Recent advances, however, point at the existence of a common molecular framework underlying the retinogenic potential of RPCs throughout retinal neurogenesis.

Pax6 lights-up the way for eye development

Recent reports have exposed the temporal and spatial functions of the transcription factor Pax6 in the developing vertebrate eye. Pax6 is demonstrated to play essential roles in successive steps triggering lens differentiation while in the retina it functions to maintain multipotency and proliferation of retinal progenitor cells. These findings, together with the identification of Pax6 protein partners and downstream targets, pave the way for future work aimed to understand the molecular mechanism of eye development.

The perplexed and confused mutations affect distinct stages during the transition from proliferating to post-mitotic cells within the zebrafish retina

To identify and study genes essential for vertebrate retinal development, we are screening zebrafish embryos for mutations that disrupt retinal histogenesis. Key steps in retinogenesis include withdrawal from mitosis by multipotent neuroepithelial cells, specification to particular cell types, migration to the appropriate laminar positions, and molecular and morphological differentiation. In this study, we have identified two recessive mutations that affect the transition of proliferating neuroepithelial cells to postmitotic retinal cells. Both the perplexed and confused mutant phenotypes were initially detectable when the first retinal neuroepithelial cells began to leave the cell cycle. At this time, each mutant retina showed increased cell death and a lack of morphological differentiation. Cell death was found to be apoptotic in both perplexed and confused retinas based on TUNEL analysis and activation of caspase-3. TUNEL-phosphoRb-BrdU colocalization studies indicated that the perplexed mutation caused death in cells transitioning from a proliferative to postmitotic state. For the confused mutation, TUNEL-phosphoRb-BrdU analysis revealed that only a subset of postmitotic cells were induced to activate apoptosis. Mosaic analysis demonstrated that within the retina the perplexed mutation functions noncell-autonomously. Furthermore, whole lens or eye cup transplantations indicated that the retinal defect was intrinsic to the retina. Mosaic analysis with confused embryos showed this mutation acts cell-autonomously. From these studies, we conclude that the perplexed and confused genes are essential at distinct stages during the transition from proliferating to postmitotic cells within the zebrafish retina.

Expression pattern of a newt Notch homologue in regenerating newt retina

We isolated part of a newt Notch homologue, N-Notch, from regenerating newt retina. The spatio-temporal pattern of N-Notch expression was studied by in situ hybridization at different stages of newt retinal regeneration. Proliferating cells were confirmed by the injection of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU). In the early stage of regeneration, when the retina was one to two cells thick, all proliferating retinal progenitors expressed N-Notch. As the thickness of the retina increased with regeneration, N-Notch expression decreased in BrdU-positive cells on the vitreal side of the retina. Subsequently, presumptive retinal ganglion cells that were BrdU-negative cells appeared at the vitreal edge of the regenerating retina. These differentiating cells did not express N-Notch. Later, N-Notch expression decreased in the BrdU-positive cells on the scleral surface of the retina. Subsequently, presumptive photoreceptor cells that were BrdU-negative cells appeared in this region. These differentiating cells also did not express N-Notch. The proliferating retinal progenitors ceased expressing N-Notch and then stopped dividing during the differentiation of ganglion cells and photoreceptor cells. It was found that retinal regeneration involves the expression of an important developmental signaling molecule, Notch, in retinal progenitors and the expression of Notch ceased as cell differentiation proceeded during retinal regeneration.

Pax6 is required for the multipotent state of retinal progenitor cells

The molecular mechanisms mediating the retinogenic potential of multipotent retinal progenitor cells (RPCs) are poorly defined. Prior to initiating retinogenesis, RPCs express a limited set of transcription factors implicated in the evolutionary ancient genetic network that initiates eye development. We elucidated the function of one of these factors, Pax6, in the RPCs of the intact developing eye by conditional gene targeting. Upon Pax6 inactivation, the potential of RPCs becomes entirely restricted to only one of the cell fates normally available to RPCs, resulting in the exclusive generation of amacrine interneurons. Our findings demonstrate furthermore that Pax6 directly controls the transcriptional activation of retinogenic bHLH factors that bias subsets of RPCs toward the different retinal cell fates, thereby mediating the full retinogenic potential of RPCs.

An instructive function for Notch in promoting gliogenesis in the zebrafish retina

The Gal4-UAS technique has been used to misexpress a constitutively active Notch receptor variant (notch1a-intra) in the developing zebrafish retina. This is the first study to use this technique to misexpress genes and assess their function in neural development of the zebrafish. Expression of activated Notch1a either ubiquitously, driven by a heat-shock70 promoter, or in a spatially regulated manner, controlled by the deltaD promoter, causes a block in neuronal differentiation that affects all cell types. Developing cells take on either a glial fate or remain undifferentiated. A large number of cells eventually undergo apoptosis. These phenotypic effects of activated Notch1a are expressed cell autonomously. Cells within central regions of the retina adopt a glial fate if they express activated Notch1a in a time window that extends from 27 to 48 hours postfertilization. This period corresponds mainly to the time of origin of ganglion cells in the normal retina. Activation of notch1a at later stages results in defects in cell type specification that remain restricted to the ciliary marginal zone, whereas neuronal types are specified normally within the central region. These observations indicate that glial differentiation is initiated by Notch1a-intra expressing cells, which become postmitotic in the same time window. Our results strongly suggest that Notch1a instructs a certain cell population to enter gliogenesis, and keeps the remaining cells in an undifferentiated state. Some or all of these cells will eventually succumb to apoptosis.

Regulation of retinal ganglion cell production by Sonic hedgehog

Previous work has shown that production of retinal ganglion cells is in part regulated by inhibitory factors secreted by ganglion cell themselves; however, the identities of these molecules are not known. Recent studies have demonstrated that the signaling molecule Sonic hedgehog (Shh) secreted by differentiated retinal ganglion cells is required to promote the progression of ganglion cell differentiation wave front and to induce its own expression. We present evidence that Shh signals play a role to negatively regulate ganglion cell genesis behind the differentiation wave front. Higher levels of Shh expression are detected behind the wave front as ganglion cells accumulate, while the Patched 1 receptor of Shh is expressed in adjacent retinal progenitor cells. Retroviral-mediated overexpression of Shh results in reduced ganglion cell proportions in vivo and in vitro. Conversely, inhibiting endogenous Shh activity by anti-Shh antibodies leads to an increased production of ganglion cells. Shh signals modulate ganglion cell production within the normal period of ganglion cell genesis in vitro without significantly affecting cell proliferation or cell death. Moreover, Shh signaling affects progenitor cell specification towards the ganglion cell fate during or soon after their last mitotic cycle. Thus, Shh derived from differentiated ganglion cells serves as a negative regulator behind the differentiation wave front to control ganglion cell genesis from the competent progenitor pool. Based on these results and other recent findings, we propose that Shh signals secreted by early-differentiated retinal neurons play dual roles at distinct concentration thresholds to orchestrate the progression of retinal neurogenic wave and the emergence of new neurons.

Tissue biology of apoptosis. Ref-1 and cell differentiation in the developing retina

Programmed cell death by apoptosis plays a major role in neurogenesis. The sensitivity to apoptosis in developing nervous tissue is strongly dependent on cell interactions taking place within a highly structured environment, composed of various cell types at distinct stages of differentiation. In this article, we review evidence gathered both in vivo and in a histotypical retinal explant preparation in vitro that the bifunctional AP endonuclease/redox factor Ref-1 (HAP1, APE, APEX) may be an anti-apoptotic protein associated with cell differentiation in the developing retina.

Differential localization of SNARE complex proteins SNAP-25, syntaxin, and VAMP during development of the mammalian retina

SNARE complex proteins have critical functions during regulated vesicular release of neurotransmitter. In addition, they play critical roles during neurite outgrowth and synaptogenesis. Although it is clear that the function of any one SNARE complex protein during release of neurotransmitter is dependent on its association with other members of the complex, it is less certain whether their function during development and differentiation is dependent on interaction with one another. Previously, we have observed transient high levels of SNARE complex protein SNAP-25 in developing cholinergic amacrine cells (West Greenlee et al. [1998] J Comp Neurol 394:374-385). In addition, we detected, high levels of SNAP-25 in developing and mature photoreceptors. To better understand the functional significance of these high levels of SNAP-25 expression, we used immunocytochemistry to examine the developmental expression of the three members of the SNARE complex, SNAP-25, Syntaxin, and vesicle associated membrane protein (VAMP/also Synaptobrevin). Our results demonstrate that the high levels of SNAP-25 in cholinergic amacrine cells and photoreceptors are not accompanied by the same relatively high levels of other SNARE complex proteins. These results suggest that high levels of SNAP-25 in specific cell types may function independently of association with Syntaxin and VAMP. In this analysis, we characterized the changing patterns of immunoreactivity for the three SNARE complex proteins during the development and differentiation of the mammalian retina. We have compared the pattern of expression of the core SNARE complex proteins in the Brazilian opossum, Monodelphis domestica, and in the rat and found common patterns of expression between these diverse mammalian species. We observed temporal differences in the onset of immunoreactivity between these three proteins, and differences in their localization within synaptic layers in the developing and mature mammalian retina. This study is the first to characterize the changing expression patterns of the three SNARE complex proteins in the developing central nervous system. The differential distribution of SNAP-25, Syntaxin, and VAMP may indicate additional roles for these proteins during vesicle trafficking events, which are independent of their association with one another.

Vertebrate neural cell-fate determination: lessons from the retina

Postmitotic neurons are produced from a pool of cycling progenitors in an orderly fashion during development. Studies of cell-fate determination in the vertebrate retina have uncovered several fundamental principles by which this is achieved. Most notably, a model for vertebrate cell-fate determination has been proposed that combines findings on the relative roles of extrinsic and intrinsic regulators in controlling cell-fate choices. At the heart of the model is the proposal that progenitors pass through intrinsically determined competence states, during which they are capable of giving rise to a limited subset of cell types under the influence of extrinsic signals.

p57(Kip2) regulates progenitor cell proliferation and amacrine interneuron development in the mouse retina

A precise balance between proliferation and differentiation must be maintained during retinal development to obtain the correct proportion of each of the seven cell types found in the adult tissue. Cyclin kinase inhibitors can regulate cell cycle exit coincident with induction of differentiation programs during development. We have found that the p57(Kip2) cyclin kinase inhibitor is upregulated during G(1)/G(0) in a subset of retinal progenitor cells exiting the cell cycle between embryonic day 14.5 and 16.5 of mouse development. Retroviral mediated overexpression of p57(Kip2) in embryonic retinal progenitor cells led to premature cell cycle exit. Retinae from mice lacking p57(Kip2) exhibited inappropriate S-phase entry and apoptotic nuclei were found in the region where p57(Kip2) is normally expressed. Apoptosis precisely compensated for the inappropriate proliferation in the p57(Kip2)-deficient retinae to preserve the correct proportion of the major retinal cell types. Postnatally, p57(Kip2) was found to be expressed in a novel subpopulation of amacrine interneurons. At this stage, p57(Kip2)did not regulate proliferation. However, perhaps reflecting its role during this late stage of development, animals lacking p57(Kip2) showed an alteration in amacrine subpopulations. p57(Kip2) is the first gene to be implicated as a regulator of amacrine subtype/subpopulation development. Consequently, we propose that p57(Kip2) has two roles during retinal development, acting first as a cyclin kinase inhibitor in mitotic progenitor cells, and then playing a distinct role in neuronal differentiation.

Progressive restriction in fate potential by neural progenitors during cerebral cortical development

During early stages of cerebral cortical development, progenitor cells in the ventricular zone are multipotent, producing neurons of many layers over successive cell divisions. The laminar fate of their progeny depends on environmental cues to which the cells respond prior to mitosis. By the end of neurogenesis, however, progenitors are lineally committed to producing upper-layer neurons. Here we assess the laminar fate potential of progenitors at a middle stage of cortical development. The progenitors of layer 4 neurons were first transplanted into older brains in which layer 2/3 was being generated. The transplanted neurons adopted a laminar fate appropriate for the new environment (layer 2/3), revealing that layer 4 progenitors are multipotent. Mid-stage progenitors were then transplanted into a younger environment, in which layer 6 neurons were being generated. The transplanted neurons bypassed layer 6, revealing that layer 4 progenitors have a restricted fate potential and are incompetent to respond to environmental cues that trigger layer 6 production. Instead, the transplanted cells migrated to layer 4, the position typical of their origin, and also to layer 5, a position appropriate for neither the host nor the donor environment. Because layer 5 neurogenesis is complete by the stage that progenitors were removed for transplantation, restrictions in laminar fate potential must lag behind the final production of a cortical layer. These results suggest that a combination of intrinsic and environmental cues controls the competence of cortical progenitor cells to produce neurons of different layers.

The zebrafish young mutation acts non-cell-autonomously to uncouple differentiation from specification for all retinal cells

Embryos from mutagenized zebrafish were screened for disruptions in retinal lamination to identify factors involved in vertebrate retinal cell specification and differentiation. Two alleles of a recessive mutation, young, were isolated in which final differentiation and normal lamination of retinal cells were blocked. Early aspects of retinogenesis including the specification of cells along the inner optic cup as retinal tissue, polarity of the retinal neuroepithelium, and confinement of cell divisions to the apical pigmented epithelial boarder were normal in young mutants. BrdU incorporation experiments showed that the initiation and pattern of cell cycle withdrawal across the retina was comparable to wild-type siblings; however, this process took longer in the mutant. Analysis of early markers for cell type differentiation revealed that each of the major classes of retinal neurons, as well as non-neural Muller glial cells, are specified in young embryos. However, the retinal cells fail to elaborate morphological specializations, and analysis of late cell-type-specific markers suggests that the retinal cells were inhibited from fully differentiating. Other regions of the nervous system showed no obvious defects in young mutants. Mosaic analysis demonstrated that the young mutation acts non-cell-autonomously within the retina, as final morphological and molecular differentiation was rescued when genetically mutant cells were transplanted into wild-type hosts. Conversely, differentiation was prevented in wild-type cells when placed in young mutant retinas. Mosaic experiments also suggest that young functions at or near the cell surface and is not freely diffusible. We conclude that the young mutation disrupts the post-specification development of all retinal neurons and glia cells.

The anti-death league: associative control of apoptosis in developing retinal tissue

Apoptosis, the major form of programmed cell death (PCD), is executed through a proteolytic cascade that can be differentially engaged by various extracellular signals. Modulation of both the sensitivity to PCD and of the actual sequence of apoptotic events is, therefore, strongly dependent on cell interactions. This paper reviews the use of a retinal explant preparation as a model of the organized nervous tissue, to study the effects of neural messengers in the control of sensitivity to apoptosis. Studies of retinal explants showed that dopamine, glutamate and nitric oxide may have anti-apoptotic effects upon developing retinal cells. At least the effects of nitric oxide are clearly paracrine. In addition, preliminary evidence has been gathered of a role for gap junctional communication in the control of sensitivity of retinal cells to the induction of apoptosis. These findings underscore the importance of selective cell interactions in the control of PCD in the developing nervous system.

Development of the visual system of the chick. I. Cell differentiation and histogenesis

This review summarizes present knowledge on the embryonic development of the avian visual projections, based on the domestic chick as a model system. The reductionist goal to understand formation and function of complex neuroanatomical systems on a causal level requires a synthesis of classic developmental biology with recent advances on the molecular mechanisms of cell differentiation and histogenesis. It is the purpose of this article. We are discussing the processes underlying patterning of the anterior neural tube, when the retina and optic tectum are specified and their axial polarity is determined. Then the development of these structures is described from the molecular to the anatomical level. Following sections deal with the establishment of secondary visual connections, and the developmental interactions between compartments of the retinotectal system. Using this latter pathway, from the retina to the optic tectum, many investigations aimed at mechanisms of axonal pathfinding and connectivity have accumulated a vast body of research, which will be covered by a following review.

Specific expression of the LIM/homeodomain protein Lim-1 in horizontal cells during retinogenesis

The LIM/homeodomain transcription factor Lim-1 has been shown to play an essential role in early embryonic patterning during vertebrate development. Here we report the spatial and temporal expression patterns of Lim-1 during retinal development as detected by immunohistochemistry using a specific anti-Lim-1 antibody. By double-immunostaining, we have demonstrated for the first time that Lim-1 is exclusively expressed within the horizontal cell type in the adult retina. In the developing mouse retina, Lim-1 commences its expression in migratory horizontal cell precursors streaming toward the future horizontal cell layer in the ventricular zone. Moreover, its expression during retinogenesis is spatially and temporally coincident with that of the calcium-binding protein calbindin D-28k in horizontal cells. These data together suggest a possible role for Lim-1 in terminal differentiation and maintenance of horizontal cells, and that Lim-1 can serve as a specific molecular marker for the study of horizontal cell specification.

Evidence for an antiapoptotic role of dopamine in developing retinal tissue

Inhibition of protein synthesis leads to apoptosis in the undifferentiated neuroblastic layer of the retina of newborn rats. We have shown previously that an increase in the intracellular concentration of cyclic AMP prevented apoptosis induced in the retinal neuroblastic layer by inhibition of protein synthesis. In this study, we tested the effects of dopamine on retinal apoptosis and related these effects to the intracellular concentration of cyclic AMP. Both dopamine (100 microM) and the D1-like agonists SKF-38393, 6-chloro-7,8-dihydroxy-1-phenyl-2,3,4,5-tetrahydro-1H-3-benzazepine (6-Cl-PB), and (+/-)-2-amino-6,7-dihydroxy-1,2,3,4-tetrahydronaphthalene (100 microM) blocked apoptosis induced in the neuroblastic layer by the protein synthesis inhibitor anisomycin. The antiapoptotic effects of the D1-like agonists were not reversed by the D1-like antagonist SCH-23390 (5-100 microM). Both dopamine and D1-like agonists induced a five- to sevenfold increase in the intracellular concentration of cyclic AMP in the retina of newborn rats. The concentration of cyclic AMP induced by the D1-like agonists in the presence of 100 microM SCH-23390 was still at least two- to threefold as high as control values, showing that the activation of adenylyl cyclase by D1-like agonists was reversed only partially by the specific antagonist. The isoquinolinesulfonamide H-89 (20 microM), an inhibitor of cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase, partially prevented the antiapoptotic effect of 6-Cl-PB. The data show that an early effect of dopamine in the developing retina is the control of programmed cell death. The antiapoptotic effect of dopamine is mediated, at least in part, through an atypical D1-like receptor coupled to stimulation of adenylyl cyclase, followed by activation of cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase.

Misexpression of cNSCL1 disrupts retinal development

cNSCL1 is the chick homologue of mammalian NSCL1, a basic helix-loop-helix gene transiently expressed during neurogenesis. To gain insight into its function, we studied the involvement of cNSCL1 in retinal neurogenesis. In situ hybridization showed dynamic, cell-type-specific expression of cNSCL1, first in developing ganglion cells and later in glial cells. This is drastically different from the expression of neuroD in young photoreceptor cells and their precursors, demonstrating that the proposed neurogenin --> neuroD --> NSCL1 cascade might not apply to retinal neurogenesis in the chick. Small eyes were produced when cNSCL1 was misexpressed in the retinal neuroepithelium through viral transduction. Pulse-labeling with BrdU and [(3)H]thymidine revealed a significant decrease in cell proliferation activity with cNSCL1 misexpression. Massive cell death occurred, but only after cell proliferation activity had subsided, resulting in major distortions of retinal structure. Our data demonstrate the importance of regulated expression of cNSCL1 during retinal development.

POU domain factor Brn-3b is essential for retinal ganglion cell differentiation and survival but not for initial cell fate specification

While the mammalian retina is well understood at the anatomical and physiological levels, little is known about the mechanisms that give rise to the retina's highly ordered pattern or its diverse neuronal cell types. Previous investigations have shown that gene disruption of the POU-IV class transcription factor Brn-3b (Brn-3.2) resulted in the loss of most retinal ganglion cells in retinas of postnatal mice. Here, we used lacZ and human placental alkaline phosphatase genes knocked into the brn-3b locus to follow the fate of brn-3b-mutant cells in the developing retina. We found that Brn-3b was not required for the initial commitment of retinal ganglion cell fate or for the migration of ganglion cells to the ganglion cell layer. However, Brn-3b was essential for the normal differentiation of retinal ganglion cells; without it, the cells underwent enhanced apoptosis. Retinal ganglion cells lacking brn-3b extended processes at the appropriate time in development, but these processes were disorganized, resulting in a thinner optic nerve. Explanted retinas from brn-3b-null embryos also extended processes when cultured in vitro, but the processes were shorter and less bundled than in wild-type retinas. Ultrastructural and marker analyses showed that the processes of mutant ganglion cells had dendritic rather than axonal features, suggesting that mutant cells formed dendrites in place of axons. These results suggest that Brn-3b regulates the activity of genes whose products play essential roles in the formation of retinal ganglion cell axons.

Apoptosis in developing retinal tissue

The mechanisms of apoptosis are strongly dependent on cell-cell interactions typical of organized tissues. Experimental studies of apoptosis using a histotypical preparation of retinal explants are reported in the present article. We found that various characteristics of apoptosis are selectively associated with retinal cell death depending on cell type, stage of maturation, and means of induction of apoptosis. Among these were: (1) the requirements of protein synthesis; (2) the role of cAMP; (3) the expression of certain apoptosis-associated proteins; and (4) the sensitivity to excitotoxicity, modulation of protein phosphatases and calcium mobilization. Dividing cells undergo apoptosis in response to several inducers in specific phases of the cell cycle, and in distinct regions within their pathway of interkinetic nuclear migration. Recent post-mitotic cells are selectively sensitive to apoptosis induced by blockade of protein synthesis, while both proliferating and differentiated cells are more resistant. We also studied the association of several proteins, some of which play critical roles in the cell cycle, with both differentiation and apoptosis in the retinal tissue. Detection of cell cycle markers did not support the hypothesis that retinal cells re-enter the cell cycle on their pathway to apoptosis, although some proteins associated with cell proliferation re-appeared in degenerating cells. The transcription factors c-Jun, c-Fos and c-Myc were found associated with apoptosis in retinal cells, but their sub-cellular location in apoptotic bodies is not consistent with their canonical functions in the control of gene expression. The bifunctional redox factor/AP endonuclease Ref-1 and the transcription factor Max are associated with progressive cell differentiation, and both are down-regulated during cell death in the retina. The data suggest that Ref-1 and Max may normally function as negative modulators of retinal apoptosis. The results indicate that nuclear exclusion of transcription factors and other important control proteins is a hallmark of retinal apoptosis. Histotypical explants may be a choice preparation for the experimental analysis of the mechanisms of apoptosis, in the context both of cell-cell interactions and of the dynamic behavior of developing cells within the organized retinal tissue.

Cerebral cortical specification by early potential restriction of progenitor cells and later phenotype control of postmitotic neurons

Neurons expressing latexin, a carboxypeptidase A inhibitor, are restricted to lateral areas in the cerebral cortex of adult and early postnatal rats. To address the precise timing of cortical regional specification at the cellular level, we monitored latexin expression in developing cortical cells under specific conditions in vitro. Individual cortical cells were labeled with 5-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine in vivo, dissociated and exposed to a defined new environment in a monolayer or a reaggregated-cell culture system. While a substantial fraction of early progenitor cells derived from the lateral cerebral wall became latexin-expressing neurons in both systems, far fewer progenitors from dorsal cortex did so under the same environmental conditions, indicating early establishment of cortical regional specification at the progenitor cell level. Furthermore, it was shown that the probability for postmitotic cells within lateral cortex to become latexin-expressing neurons was influenced by temporally regulated regional environmental signals. These findings suggest that developing cortical cells are progressively specified for a regional molecular phenotype during both their proliferative and postmitotic periods.

Extrinsic and intrinsic factors control the genesis of amacrine and cone cells in the rat retina

The seven major classes of cells of the vertebrate neural retina are generated from a pool of multipotent progenitor cells. Recent studies suggest a model of retinal development in which both the progenitor cells and the environment change over time (Cepko, C. L., Austin, C. P., Yang, X., Alexiades, M. and Ezzeddine, D. (1996). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 93, 589–595). We have utilized a reaggregate culture system to test this model. A labeled population of progenitors from the embryonic rat retina were cultured with an excess of postnatal retinal cells and then assayed for their cell fate choices. We found that the postnatal environment had at least two signals that affected the embryonic cells' choice of fate; one signal inhibited the production of amacrine cells and a second affected the production of cone cells. No increase in cell types generated postnatally was observed. The source of the inhibitor of the amacrine cell fate appeared to be previously generated amacrine cells, suggesting that amacrine cell number is controlled by feedback inhibition. The progenitor cell lost its ability to be inhibited for production of an amacrine cell as it entered M phase of the cell cycle. We suggest that postmitotic cells influence progenitor cell fate decisions, but that they do so in a manner restricted by the intrinsic biases of progenitor cells.

The roles of intrinsic and extrinsic cues and bHLH genes in the determination of retinal cell fates

A fundamental issue concerning development of the vertebrate retina is the relative contributions of extrinsic and intrinsic cues to the determination of cell fate. Recent findings suggest that retinal progenitors go through a series of changes in intrinsic properties that control their competence to make different cell types and that extrinsic cues influence the ratios of the cell types that they produce. Recent studies of the role of the basic helix-loop-helix genes in retinal development have indicated that they can regulate competence and/or other aspects of cell fate determination.

Math5 encodes a murine basic helix-loop-helix transcription factor expressed during early stages of retinal neurogenesis

We have identified Math5, a mouse basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) gene that is closely related to Drosophila atonal and Xenopus Xath5 and is largely restricted to the developing eye. Math5 retinal expression precedes differentiation of the first neurons and persists within progenitor cells until after birth. To position Math5 in a hierarchy of retinal development, we compared Math5 and Hes1 expression in wild-type and Pax6-deficient (Sey) embryos. Math5 expression is downregulated in Sey/+ eyes and abolished in Sey/Sey eye rudiments, whereas the bHLH gene Hes1 is upregulated in a similar dose-dependent manner. These results link Pax6 to the process of retinal neurogenesis and provide the first molecular correlate for the dosage-sensitivity of the Pax6 phenotype. During retinogenesis, Math5 is expressed significantly before NeuroD, Ngn2 or Mash1. To test whether these bHLH genes influence the fates of distinct classes of retinal neurons, we ectopically expressed Math5 and Mash1 in Xenopus retinal progenitors. Unexpectedly, lipofection of either mouse gene into the frog retina caused an increase in differentiated bipolar cells. Directed expression of Math5, but not Xath5, in Xenopus blastomeres produced an expanded retinal phenotype. We propose that Math5 acts as a proneural gene, but has properties different from its most closely related vertebrate family member, Xath5.

Characterization of neurotrophin and Trk receptor functions in developing sensory ganglia: direct NT-3 activation of TrkB neurons in vivo

Spinal sensory ganglia have been shown to contain neuronal subpopulations with different functions and neurotrophin dependencies. Neurotrophins act, in large part, through Trk receptor tyrosine kinases: nerve growth factor (NGF) via TrkA, brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) and neurotrophin-4/5 (NT-4/5) via TrkB, and neurotrophin-3 (NT-3) via TrkC. In the present paper, we use antibodies to TrkA, TrkB, and TrkC to characterize their expression patterns and to determine which subpopulations of cells are lost in mice lacking individual neurotrophins or Trk receptors. Despite previous reports of Trk receptor mRNAs in neural crest cells, we detect Trk receptor proteins only in neurons and not in neural crest cells or neuronal precursors. Comparisons of neonatal mice deficient in NT-3 or its cognate receptor TrkC have shown that there is a much greater deficiency in spinal sensory neurons in the former, suggesting that NT-3 may activate receptors in addition to TrkC. Using the same antibodies, we show that, during the major period of neurogenesis, NT-3 is required to maintain neurons that express TrkB in addition to those that express TrkC but is not essential for neurons expressing TrkA. Results also indicate that survival of cells expressing both receptors can be maintained by activation of either one alone. NT-3 can thus activate more than one Trk receptor in vivo, which when coexpressed are functionally redundant.

Requirement for Brn-3b in early differentiation of postmitotic retinal ganglion cell precursors

The Brn-3 subfamily of POU domain transcription factors consists of Brn-3a, -3b, and -3c, which are important regulators for sensorineural development. Despite the expression of all three factors in retinal ganglion cells, earlier studies have shown that Brn-3b is the only one among the three Brn-3 genes that is essential for development of approximately 70% of ganglion cells in the murine retina. I report here that Brn-3b displays a spatiotemporal expression pattern characteristic of the dynamic profile of ganglion cell genesis during murine retinal development. Moreover, it is initially turned on in postmitotic ganglion cell precursors 2 days before the onset of Brn-3a and -3c expression in differentiated ganglion cells. During the entire period of retinal ganglion cell genesis, the postmitotic ganglion cell precursors that would normally become Brn-3b+ cells fail to properly differentiate in Brn-3b-/- mice, as evidenced by a twofold reduction in the optic nerve size and diminished expression of several ganglion cell markers. The undifferentiated ganglion cell precursors appear to be degenerated by apoptosis within the ganglion cell layer during the perinatal and early postnatal period. I propose that retinal ganglion cells develop following two separate differentiation pathways--Brn-3b dependent and Brn-3b independent. In the Brn-3b-dependent mechanism, Brn-3b may be required to initiate a particular differentiation program for a large set of postmitotic ganglion precursors to properly differentiate into the 70%, Brn-3b-dependent retinal ganglion cells.