Methane Production and Conductive Materials: A Critical Review

Carbon-based conductive materials accelerated methane production in anaerobic digestion of waste fat, oil and grease

Little is known about the effect of carbon-based conductive material (CM) addition on the anaerobic co-digestion of fat, oil and grease (FOG) and waste activated sludge (WAS). In this study, three types of carbon-based CMs (nano-graphite (NG), granular activated carbon (GAC), and carbon cloth (CC)) and nine dosages were evaluated for their influences on co-digestion performance. The best dosage was achieved at 0.2 g/L NG, 10 g/L GAC, and 1 cm × 5 cm CC with 13-22% incremental methane production, 25-55% increased VS removal and 28-32% enhanced COD conversion efficiency compared to the control. The highest total amount of bacteria/archaea was found in CC (1 cm × 5 cm), followed by GAC at 10 g/L and NG at 0.2 g/L, which were all higher than those of the control. Microbial community analysis revealed that direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET)-mediated syntrophic acetate oxidation (SAO) enabling faster acetate conversion might be responsible for the enhancement of methane production.

Insight into the performance and microbial community profiles of magnetite-amended anaerobic digestion: Varying promotion effects at increased loads

In current study, the enhancement effect of magnetite on anaerobic digestion was evaluated at increased organic loading rate (OLR) from 1.6 to 25.6 kg COD·m^-3·d^-1. The supplement of magnetite enhanced the methane yield by 7-483% accompanied with faster VFAs conversion. Microbial analysis suggested the varied enhancing effect achieved at different OLRs was attributed to different syntrophic interactions triggered by magnetite. More specially, an electroactive syntropy was established between Trichococcus with Methanobacterium at OLR lower than 6.4 kg COD·m^-3·d^-1, while with the OLR increase, more acid fermentative bacteria (Propionimicrobium, Syner-01) were enriched and further enhanced methanogenesis in a syntrophic way with Methanosaeta. Overall, the incorporation of magnetite was a promising approach to achieve efficient anaerobic digestion, OLR was also critical factor affecting the methanogenesis and should be carefully regulated in future application.

Metagenomic analysis reveals nonylphenol-shaped acidification and methanogenesis during sludge anaerobic digestion

Nonylphenol (NP) is widely known for its estrogenic activity on organisms, but its influence on biochemical processes executed by complex microbiota is still unclear. The dose-specific effects of NP on sludge anaerobic digestion by shaping acidification and methanogenesis were reported. Both low (50 mg/kg) and high (1000 mg/kg) NP doses were beneficial to acidification and aceticlastic methanogenesis (AM), and high NP dose further stimulated hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis (HM). Stable isotope probing analysis indicated that the predominant methanogenic pathway was shifted from AM to a combination of AM and HM as NP dose increased. Acidogenic and methanogenic consortia were accumulated and restructured by NP in favor of acidification and substrate-based methanogenesis. Acidification-related genes for bioconversion of substrates into acetate (glycolysis, stickland reaction and pyruvate metabolism), acetate transportation and microbial robust performance were enriched with both low and high NP doses. Methanogenesis-related genes encoding acetyl-CoA dehydrogenase/synthetase (CODH/ACS) in aceticlastic pathway and transporters for coenzyme synthesis were enhanced by both NP doses. Besides, high NP dose promoted a majority of genes in CO₂-reduction pathway and key material transporters for coenzyme F420 and heterodisulfide reductase synthesis. This study shed light on complex microbial processes rather than certain organisms affected by NP with dose-specific pattern at genetic level and had implications in resource utilization of sludge containing refractory organics.

New Frontiers in 3D Structural Sensing Robots

Advanced robotics is the result of various contributions from complex fields of science and engineering and has tremendous value in human society. Sensing robots are highly desirable in practical settings such as healthcare and manufacturing sectors through sensing activities from human-robot interaction. However, there are still ongoing research and technical challenges in the development of ideal sensing robot systems. The sensing robot should synergically merge sensors and robotics. Geometrical difficulty in the sensor positioning caused by the structural complexity of sensing robots and their corresponding processing have been the main challenges in the production of sensing robots. 3D electronics integrated into 3D objects prepared by the 3D printing process can be the potential solution for designing realistic sensing robot systems. 3D printing provides the advantage to manufacture complex 3D structures in electronics in a single setup, allowing the ease of design flexibility, and customized functions. Therefore, the platform of 3D sensing systems is investigated and their expansion into sensing robots is studied further. The progress toward sensing robots from 3D electronics integrated into 3D objects and the advanced material strategies, used to overcome the challenges, are discussed.

Coupling granular activated carbon and exogenous hydrogen to enhance anaerobic digestion of phenol via predominant syntrophic acetate oxidation and hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis pathway

Anaerobic digestion is a promising biological method for treating phenol-containing wastewater. However, the low methane yield of phenol due to the biological toxicity limits its potential application. This study presents a novel method to enhance the conversion rate of phenol to methane by coupling of granular activated carbon and exogenous hydrogen (GAC/H₂). The cumulative methane production in the GAC/H₂, H₂, GAC, and control groups were 408.2 ± 16.2, 336.5 ± 5.7, 287.2 ± 26. 2, and 258.1 ± 8.6 mL‬ CH₄/g COD, respectively. Compared with the control group, the hydrogenotrophic methanogenic activity and electron transfer activity of GAC/H₂ group were increased by 403.9 and 367.4%, respectively. The results of the 16SrRNA analysis indicated GAC enhanced the relative abundances of Syntrophus and Syntrophorhabdus, and hydrogen promoted the relative abundances of Cryptanaerobacter, Aminicenantes, and Methanobacterium. Therefore, the coupling of GAC and exogenous hydrogen promoted a dominate SAO-HM pathway to convert phenol to methane.

Advances towards understanding long chain fatty acids-induced inhibition and overcoming strategies for efficient anaerobic digestion process

The inhibition of the anaerobic digestion (AD) process, caused by long chain fatty acids (LCFAs), has been considered as an important issue in the wastewater treatment sector. Proper understanding of mechanisms behind the inhibition is a must for further improvements of the AD process in the presence of LCFAs. Through analyzing recent literature, this review extensively describes the mechanism of LCFAs degradation, during AD. Further, a particular focus was directed to the key parameters which could affect such process. Besides, this review highlights the recent research efforts in mitigating LCFAs-caused inhibition, through the addition of commonly used additives such as cations and natural adsorbents. Specifically, additives such as bentonite, cation-based adsorbents, as well as zeolite and other natural adsorbents for alleviating the LCFAs-induced inhibition are discussed in detail. Further, panoramic evaluations for characteristics, various mechanisms of reaction, merits, limits, recommended doses, and preferred conditions for each of the different additives are provided. Moreover, the potential for increasing the methane production via pretreatment using those additives are discussed. Finally, we provide future horizons for the alternative materials that can be utilized, more efficiently, for both mitigating LCFAs-based inhibition and boosting methane potential in the subsequent digestion of LCFA-related wastes.

Deep insights into the network of acetate metabolism in anaerobic digestion: focusing on syntrophic acetate oxidation and homoacetogenesis

Acetate is a pivotal intermediate product during anaerobic decomposition of organic matter. Its generation and consumption network is quite complex, which almost covers the most steps in anaerobic digestion (AD) process. Besides acidogenesis, acetogenesis and methanogenesis, syntrophic acetate oxidation (SAO) replaced acetoclastic methanogenesis to release the inhibition of AD at some special conditions, and the importance of considering homoacetogenesis had also been proved when analysing anaerobic fermentations. Syntrophic acetate-oxidizing bacteria (SAOB), with function of SAO, can survive under high temperature and ammonia/ volatile fatty acids (VFAs) concentrations, while, homoacetogens, performed homoacetogenesis, are more active under acidic, alkaline and low temperature (10°C-20°C) conditions, This review summarized the roles of SAO and homoacetogenesis in AD process, which contains the biochemical reactions, metabolism pathways, physiological characteristics and energy conservation of functional bacteria. The specific roles of these two processes in the subprocess of AD (i.e., acidogenesis, acetogenesis and methanogenesis) were also analyzed in detail. A two phases anaerobic digester is proposed for protein-rich waste(water) treatment by enhancing the functions of homoacetogens and SAOB compared to the traditional two-phases anaerobic digesters, in which the first phase is fermentation phase including acidogens and homoacetogens for acetate production, and second phase is a mixed culture coupling syntrophic fatty acids bacteria, SAOB and hydrogenotrophic methanogens for methane production. This review provides a new insight into the network on production and consumption of acetate in AD process.

Microbes trading electricity in consortia of environmental and biotechnological significance

Favorable interspecies associations prevail in natural microbial assemblages. Some of these favorable associations are co-metabolic dependent partnerships in which extracellular electrons are exchanged between species. For such electron exchange to occur, the cells must exhibit electroactive interfaces and get involved in direct cell-to-cell contact (Direct Interspecies Electron Transfer/DIET) or use available conductive mineral grains from their environment (Conductive-particle-mediated Interspecies Electron Transfer/CIET). This review will highlight recent discoveries and knowledge gaps regarding DIET and CIET interspecies associations in artificial co-cultures and consortia from natural and man-made environments and emphasize approaches to validate DIET and CIET. Additionally, we acknowledge the initiation of a movement towards applying electric syntrophies in biotechnology, bioremediation and geoengineering for natural attenuation of toxic compounds. Next, we have highlighted the urgent research needs that must be met to develop such technologies.

Graphite accelerate dissimilatory iron reduction and vivianite crystal enlargement

Biomineralized vivianite induced by dissimilatory iron reduction bacteria (DIRB) has received increasing attention because it alleviates phosphorus crisis and phosphorus pollution simultaneously. However, the relatively small crystal size and low Fe(III) reduction rate restrict the separation and recovery of vivianite. In this study, graphite was selected as additive to enhance vivianite biomineralization with soluble ferric citrate and insoluble hematite as two representative electron acceptors. As soluble ferric citrate provided abundant accessible electron acceptors, relatively inconspicuous increase (lower than 7%) was observed for graphite on vivianite formation while inoculated with raw sewage or DIRB. In contrast, graphite considerably increased vivianite formation efficiency by 23% in insoluble hematite inoculated with raw sewage. The graphite promotion on vivianite formation in hematite batch was magnified to 70% by DIRB. Dosing hematite inhibited the supply of electron acceptors, while conductive graphite promoted the electrical connection between minerals and DIRB, thus improved the Fe(III) reduction rate and efficiency. In addition, secondary minerals in hematite exhibited a larger aspect ratio and tended to aggregate on graphite. Graphite enlarged the vivianite size in hematite from 10 µm to 90 µm due to aggregation. Enhancing dissimilatory iron reduction (DIR) rate of iron oxides and enlarging crystal size provide new insights for vivianite formation and separation during wastewater treatment.

Recent advances in methanogenesis through direct interspecies electron transfer via conductive materials: A molecular microbiological perspective

Conductive materials can serve as biocatalysts during direct interspecies electron transfer for methanogenesis in anaerobic reactors. However, the mechanism promoting direct interspecies electron transfer in anaerobic reactors, particularly under environments in which diverse substrates and microorganisms coexist, remains to be elucidated from a scientific or an engineering point of view. Currently, many molecular microbiological approaches are employed to understand the fundamentals of this phenomenon. Here, the direct interspecies electron transfer mechanisms and relevant microorganisms identified to date using molecular microbiological methods were critically reviewed. Moreover, molecular microbiological methods for direct interspecies electron transfer used in previous studies and important findings thus revealed were analyzed. This review will help us better understand the phenomena of direct interspecies electron transfer using conductive materials and offer a framework for future molecular microbiological studies.

Prediction of the Long-Term Effect of Iron on Methane Yield in an Anaerobic Membrane Bioreactor Using Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis

A method for predicting the long-term effects of ferric on methane production was developed in an anaerobic membrane bioreactor treating food processing wastewater to provide management tools for maximizing methane recovery using ferric based on a batch test. The results demonstrated the accuracy of the predictions for both batch and long-term continuous operations using a Bayesian network meta-analysis based on the Gompertz model. The prediction bias of methane production for batch and continuous operations was minimized, from 11~19% to less than 0.5%. A biochemical methane potential-based Bayesian network meta-analysis suggested a maximum 2.55% ± 0.42% enhancement for Fe2.25. An anaerobic membrane bioreactor improved the methane yield by 2.27% and loading rate by 4.57% for Fe2.25, operating in the sequenced batch mode. The method allowed for a predictable methane yield enhancement based on the biochemical methane potential. Ferric enhanced the biochemical methane potential in batch tests and the methane yield in a continuously operated reactor by a maximum of 8.20% and 7.61% for Fe2.25, respectively. Copper demonstrated a higher methane (18.91%) and sludge yield (17.22%) in batch but faded in the continuous operation (0.32% of methane yield). The enhancement was primarily due to changing the kinetic patterns for the last period, i.e., increasing the second methane production peak (k₇₁), bringing forward the second peak (λ₇, λ₈), and prolonging the second period (k₆₂). The dual exponential function demonstrated a better fit in the last three stages (after the first peak), which implied that syntrophic methanogenesis with a ferric shuttle played a primary role in the last three methane production periods, in which long-term effects were sustained, as the Bayesian network meta-analysis predicted.

A high-rate anaerobic biofilm reactor for biomethane recovery from source-separated blackwater at ambient temperature

Anaerobic bioreactors for source-separated blackwater are mostly operated at low organic loading rates (OLRs) due to low biodegradability and the potential of ammonia inhibition. In this study, an anaerobic biofilm reactor having conductive carbon fibers as the media was investigated for the high-rate treatment of blackwater collected from vacuum toilets. The bioreactor was operated at different OLRs ranged from 0.77 to 3.01 g COD/L-d in four stages for a total operating period of ~ 250 days. With the increase of OLRs, the specific methane production rate increased from 105.3 to 304.6 ml/L-d with high methane content in biogas (75.5%-83%). The maximum methane yield was achieved at hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 15 days. Highest organics and suspended solids removal (80%-83%) were achieved at 20-days HRT, while increased OLRs resulted in diminished removal efficiencies. The state variables, including pH, total ammonia nitrogen, short-chain volatile fatty acids, and soluble chemical oxygen demand, indicated the system had a great capability to withstand the high OLRs. Microbial community analysis revealed that the high performance might be attributed to direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) facilitated by potentially electroactive bacteria (e.g., Syntrophomonas, Clostridium) and electrotrophic archaea (e.g., Methanosaeta and Methanosarcina species) enriched on the carbon fibers. PRACTITIONER POINTS: An anaerobic biofilm reactor was investigated for biomethane recovery from source-separated blackwater. Conductive carbon fibers were utilized as the media to stimulate enrichment of potentially electroactive methanogenic communities. The bioreactor was operated at ambient temperature for over 250 days. High methane production rate and high-quality biogas were achieved at OLRs ranged from 0.77 to 3.01 g COD/L-d. Microbial community analysis suggested direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) between specific electroactive bacteria and electrotrophic archaea.

Insight into sludge anaerobic digestion with granular activated carbon addition: Methanogenic acceleration and methane reduction relief

In this study, the multiple effects of granular activated carbon (GAC) on sludge anaerobic digestion at ambient (16-24 °C), mesophilic (35 °C) and thermophilic (55 °C) temperature were investigated. After GAC addition, although the methane yields of raw sludge were reduced by 6.5%-36.9%, the lag phases of methanogenesis were shortened by 19.3%-30.6% and the reductions of methane yields were declined to only 5.9%-8.1% simultaneously for pretreated sludge. The inhibitory substances like phenols that generated by thermal pretreatment were reduced after GAC addition, which were demonstrated to be responsible for the methanogenic acceleration. Meanwhile, the methane reduction due to the non-selective adsorption by GAC could be mitigated by pretreatment and elevated temperature. Thus, a strategy coupling thermal pretreatment with detoxification by GAC was proposed to improve the methane production rate and avoid the negative effects during sludge anaerobic digestion with GAC addition.

Biochar facilitates rapid restoration of methanogenesis by enhancing direct interspecies electron transfer after high organic loading shock

This study evaluated the effectiveness of biochar addition against high organic loading shock (OLS) of 80 kg COD/m³/d in up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) reactors (R1 with biochar; R2 without biochar). After OLS of 24 h, R2 suffered the irreversible acidification (pH of 5.42 ± 0.07) with low biogas production of 0.08 ± 0.01 m³/kg COD/d. In contrast, the biogas production in R1 restored rapidly to 0.33 ± 0.04 m³/kg COD/d, and effluent pH in R1 returned to 7.01 ± 0.22. With addition of biochar, potential direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) partners, including volatile fatty acids (VFAs)-oxidizing bacteria (Bacteroidetes, Smithella, Desulfovibrio, Geobacter) and methanogens (Methanosaeta, Methanosarcina) were enriched in R1, which were conductive to maintain the balance of acidogenesis and methanogenesis. Moreover, the retention of Methanosaeta and Methanosarcina coupled with biochar maintained the structural stability of granular sludge in R1 under the pressure of OLS and VFAs, which guaranteed the stability of anaerobic system.

Activation of the methane C–H bond by Al- and Ga-doped graphenes: a DFT investigation

The potential of Al- and Ge-embedded graphene to activate the C–H bond of CH4 in the presence of a N2O molecule was studied using DFT calculations.

An underappreciated DIET for anaerobic petroleum hydrocarbon-degrading microbial communities

Direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) via electrically conductive minerals can play a role in the anaerobic oxidation of petroleum hydrocarbons in contaminated sites and can be exploited for the development of new, more effective bioremediation approaches.

Co-Digestion of Grape Marc and Cheese Whey at High Total Solids Holds Potential for Sustained Bioenergy Generation

At the end of fermentation, wine contains approximately 20% (w/v) of solid material, known as grape marc (GM), produced at a yield of 2 t/ha. Cheese manufacture produces cheese whey (CW), which is over 80% of the processed milk, per unit volume. Both waste types represent an important fraction of the organic waste being disposed of by the wine and dairy industries. The objective of this study was to investigate the bioenergy potential through anaerobic codigestion of these waste streams. The best bioenergy profile was obtained from the digestion setups of mixing ratio 3/1 GM/CW (wet weight/wet weight). At this ratio, the inhibitory salinity of CW was sufficiently diluted, resulting in 23.73% conversion of the organic material to methane. On average, 64 days of steady bioenergy productivity was achieved, reaching a maximum of 85 ± 0.4% CH₄ purity with a maximum cumulative methane yield of 24.4 ± 0.11 L CH₄ kg⁻¹ VS. During the fermentation there was 18.63% CODt removal, 21.18% reduction of conductivity whilst salinity rose by 36.19%. It can be concluded that wine and dairy industries could utilise these waste streams for enhanced treatment and energy recovery, thereby developing a circular economy.

Inhibition mitigation of methanogenesis processes by conductive materials: A critical review

Methanogenesis can be promoted by the addition of conductive materials. Although stimulating effects of conductive materials on methane (CH₄) production has been extensively reported, the crucial roles on recovering methanogenic activities under inhibitory conditions have not been systematically discussed. This critical review presents the current findings on the effects of conductive materials in methanogenic systems under volatile fatty acids (VFAs), ammonia, sulfate, and nano-cytotoxicity stressed conditions. Conductive materials induce fast VFAs degradation, avoiding VFAs accumulation during anaerobic digestion. Under high ammonia concentrations, conductive materials may ensure sufficient energy conservation for methanogens to maintain intracellular pH and proton balance. When encountering the competition of sulfate-reducing bacteria, conductive materials can benefit electron competitive capability of methanogens, recovering CH₄ production activity. Conductive nanomaterials stimulate the excretion of extracellular polymeric substances, which can prevent cells from nano-cytotoxicity. Future perspectives about unraveling mitigation mechanisms induced by conductive materials in methanogenesis processes are further discussed.

Methanobacterium Capable of Direct Interspecies Electron Transfer

Direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) from bacteria to methanogens is a revolutionary concept for syntrophic metabolism in methanogenic soils/sediments and anaerobic digestion. Previous studies have indicated that the potential for DIET is limited to methanogens in the Methanosarcinales, leading to the assumption that an abundance of other types of methanogens, such as Methanobacterium species, indicates a lack of DIET. We report here on a strain of Methanobacterium, designated strain YSL, that grows via DIET in defined cocultures with Geobacter metallireducens. The cocultures formed aggregates, in which cells of strain YSL and G. metallireducens were uniformly dispersed throughout. This close association of the two species is the likely explanation for the ability of a strain of G. metallireducens that could not express electrically conductive pili to grow in coculture with strain YSL. Granular activated carbon promoted the initial formation of the DIET-based cocultures. The discovery of DIET in Methanobacterium, the genus of methanogens that has been the exemplar for interspecies electron transfer via H₂, suggests that the capacity for DIET is much more broadly distributed among methanogens than previously considered. More innovative approaches to microbial isolation and characterization are needed in order to better understand how methanogenic communities function.

Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes Enhance Methanogenesis from Diverse Organic Compounds in Anaerobic Sludge and River Sediments

Conductive nanomaterials affect anaerobic digestion (AD) processes usually by improving methane production. Nevertheless, their effect on anaerobic communities, and particularly on specific trophic groups such as syntrophic bacteria or methanogens, is not extensively reported. In this work, we evaluate the effect of multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNT) on the activity of two different anaerobic microbial communities: an anaerobic sludge and a river sediment. Methane production by anaerobic sludge was assessed in the presence of different MWCNT concentrations, with direct methanogenic substrates (acetate, hydrogen) and with typical syntrophic substrates (ethanol, butyrate). MWCNT accelerated the initial specific methane production rate (SMPR) from all compounds, with a more pronounced effect on the assays with acetate and butyrate, i.e., 2.1 and 2.6 times, respectively. In the incubations with hydrogen and ethanol, SMPR increased 1.1 and 1.2 times. Experiments with the river sediment were performed in the presence of MWCNT and MWCNT impregnated with 2% iron (MWCNT-Fe). Cumulative methane production was 10.2 and 4.5 times higher in the assays with MWCNT-Fe and MWCNT, respectively, than in the assays without MWCNT. This shows the high potential of MWCNT toward bioenergy production, in waste/wastewater treatment or ex situ bioremediation in anaerobic digesters.

Effects of foam nickel supplementation on anaerobic digestion: Direct interspecies electron transfer

Stimulating direct interspecies electron transfer with conductive materials is a promising strategy to overcome the limitation of electron transfer efficiency in syntrophic methanogenesis of industrial wastewater. This paper assessed the impact of conductive foam nickel (FN) supplementation on syntrophic methanogenesis and found that addition of 2.45 g/L FN in anaerobic digestion increased the maximum methane production rate by 27.4 % (on day 3) while decreasing the peak production time by 33 % as compared to the control with no FN. Cumulative methane production from day 2 to 6 was 14.5 % higher with addition of 2.45 g/L FN than in the control. Levels of FN in excess of 2.45 g/L did not show benefits. Cyclic voltammetry results indicated that the biofilm formed on the FN could generate electrons. The dominant bacterial genera in suspended sludge were Dechlorobacter and Rikenellaceae DMER64, whereas that in the FN biofilm was Clostridium sensu stricto 11. The dominant archaea Methanosaeta in the FN biofilm was enriched by 14.1 % as compared to the control.

Enhanced anaerobic digestion of primary sludge with additives: Performance and mechanisms

Anaerobic digestion of primary sludge with different additives, namely nano magnetite, graphite powder, activated carbon powder and NiCl₂/CoCl_2, were evaluated by biomethane potential tests, kinetics modelling and microbial community analysis. Specific methane yields increased from 136 mL/g VS for primary sludge to 146 mL/g VS, 151 mL/g VS, and 152 mL/g VS for the addition of nano magnetite, graphite powder, and activated carbon powder at optimal dosages, respectively. The first order hydrolysis constant k_h increased from 0.488 d^-1 to 0.526 d^-1, 0.622 d^-1, and 0.724 d^-1, respectively. Microbial community analysis revealed that the abundance of key bacterial and archaeal populations was positively correlated with hydrolysis and methane production. The enhanced methane production with activated carbon powder was due to shifting methane formation pathway from acetoclastic to hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis. In contrast, nano magnetite and graphite powder additives enhanced the direct interspecies electron transfer evidenced by increased abundance of Methanosaeta and Methanolinea.

A slurry electrode integrated with membrane electrolysis for high-performance acetate production in microbial electrosynthesis

Microbial electrosynthesis (MES) technology employs electrotrophic microbes as biocatalysts to produce chemicals from CO₂. The application of a slurry electrode can enlarge the surface area to volume ratio, and membrane electrolysis (ME) for on-line extraction can solve the problem of product inhibition. This study constructed a novel dual-chamber ME-MES integrated system equipped with a slurry electrode, and the effect of concentration of powder-activated carbon (AC) in the catholyte on chemical production was also evaluated. The integrated system amended with 5 g L^-1 AC produced up to 13.4 g L^-1 acetate, showing a 179% increase compared with the control group without AC (4.8 g L^-1). However, further increasing the AC concentration to 10 and 20 g L^-1 resulted in decreased acetate production. A high concentration of AC showed higher antimicrobial activity to methanogens, as compared to acetogens. Amending AC exacerbated the process of electroosmosis. Also, amending AC with 0 to 10 g L^-1 decreased the electrochemical losses via both the membrane and electrolyte. The chemical production using H₂ or the electrode as electron donors showed a similar trend when amending AC. The present study provided important information for guiding future research to construct an efficient configuration of an MES bioreactor.

Role of magnetite in methanogenic degradation of different substances

For better understanding the role of magnetite in methanation of different substrates, two up-flow anaerobic sludge bed reactors (RM with magnetite; RS with silica) were built using acetate (stage I), propionate + butyrate (stage II), and sucrose (stage III) as the substrates, respectively. RM reactor showed better COD removal efficiency and adaptability to different substrate impacts. More extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) were produced for anaerobic sludge granulation, and the sludge in RM had better intensity, hydrophobicity and electroactivity compared with those in RS. Interestingly, magnetite had different promoting effects on methanogenic degradation of different substrates, and magnetite facilitated different syntrophic partners, like Desulfovibrio, Smithella, unidentified Clostridiates and Methanosaeta in different stages. The strengthening factor of biogas production from sucrose was the highest (1.23 ± 0.03), and analysis of key enzyme activities indicated that the potential magnetite-induced direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) improved the process between the glycolysis, oxidation of pyruvate and CO₂-dependent methanogenesis.

Methane production in a bioelectrochemistry integrated anaerobic reactor with layered nickel foam electrodes

Towards the regulation and enhancement of inter-species electron transfer in sludge anaerobic digestion system, microbial electrolysis technology has become one of the effective ways to accelerate both fermentation and methanogenesis. In this study, the reactor performances and microbial activities related to biocathode formation are evaluated when the role of biocathode is regulated by series of layered cathodes. The results show the abundance of the cathodic methanogens decreased when enlarges the cathode area due to the lower current density. The biocathode evolution is directly related to the spatial methane distribution, which can further determine 25% increase of methane production rate compared to control without biocathode. Ultimately, the maximum methane production yield of 145.79 mL·d^-1 is achieved by the optimal cathode area with a current density of 5.3 mA/cm³. The spatially methanogens distribution in suspended sludge and electrodes regulated by the layered cathodes is regarded to be the key to increase methanogenesis.

A review on facilitating bio-wastes degradation and energy recovery efficiencies in anaerobic digestion systems with biochar amendment

In this review, progress in the potential mechanisms of biochar amendment for AD performance promotion was summarized. As adsorbents, biochar was beneficial for alleviating microbial toxicity, accelerating refractory substances degradation, and upgrading biogas quality. The buffering capacity of biochar balanced pH decreasing caused by volatile fatty acids accumulation. Moreover, biochar regulated microbial metabolism by boosting activities, mediating electron transfer between syntrophic partners, and enriching functional microbes. Recent studies also suggested biochar as potential useful additives for membrane fouling alleviation in anaerobic membrane bioreactors (AnMBR). By analyzing the reported performances based on different operation models or substrate types, debatable issues and associated research gaps of understanding the real role of biochar in AD were critically discussed. Accordingly, Future perspectives of developing biochar-amended AD technology for real-world applications were elucidated. Lastly, with biochar-amended AD as a core process, a novel integrated scheme was proposed towards high-efficient energy-resource recovery from various bio-wastes.

Methanogenic pathway and microbial succession during start-up and stabilization of thermophilic food waste anaerobic digestion with biochar

One of the major obstacles for thermophilic anaerobic digestion is the process instability during start-up. This study proposed the use of a cost-effective additive, biochar, to accelerate and stabilize the start-up of thermophilic semi-continuous food waste anaerobic digestion. The results showed that the reactors with biochar addition resulted in up to 18% higher methane yield as compared to the control reactors (without biochar). The key microbial networks were elucidated through thermochemical and microbial analysis. Particularly, the addition of biochar promoted the growth of electroactive Clostridia and other electroactive bacteria, while the absence of biochar promoted the growth of homoacetogenic Clostridia and syntrophic acetate oxidizing bacteria. It was revealed that biochar promoted direct interspecies electron transfer between the microbes and was responsible for the faster degradation of volatile fatty acids. Furthermore, reactors with biochar also enhanced the thermodynamically favourable acetoclastic methanogenic pathway due to the higher abundance of Methanosarcina.

Powdered activated carbon facilitates methane productivity of anaerobic co-digestion via acidification alleviating: Microbial and metabolic insights

Low methanogenic efficiency caused by excess acidification is a challenge during anaerobic digestion. This study indicated that both granular activated carbon (GAC) and powdered activated carbon (PAC) promoted the start-up of methanogenesis and methane output in anaerobic co-digestion of food waste and fruit-vegetable waste. Moreover, PAC performed better than GAC. Specifically, the highest cumulative methane yield and shortest lag phase were observed in 5 g/L PAC and 10 g/L PAC group, 22.0% higher and 62.5% shorter than that without activated carbon supplementation, respectively. PAC facilitated the methane productivity by effectively accelerating volatile fatty acids (VFAs) consumption and thereby alleviating acidification. Syntrophic VFAs oxidizing bacteria (Gelria and Syntrophomonas) and direct interspecies electron transfer related microorganisms (Geobacter and Methanosarcina) were remarkably enriched by PAC. Furthermore, metagenomic analysis showed that both PAC and GAC might facilitate the electron transfer between microbes by acting as the electrical bridge and enhance both hydrogenotrophic and aceticlastic pathways.

Methanogenesis inhibitors used in bio-electrochemical systems: A review revealing reality to decide future direction and applications

Microbial fuel cell (MFC) is a robust technology capable of treating real wastewaters by utilizing mixed anaerobic microbiota as inoculum for producing electricity from oxidation of the biodegradable matters. However, these mixed microbiota comprises of both electroactive microorganisms (EAM) and substrate/electron scavenging microorganisms such as methanogens. Hence, in order to maximize bioelectricity from MFC, different physio-chemical techniques have been applied in past investigations to suppress activity of methanogens. Interestingly, recent investigations exhibit that methanogens can produce electricity in MFC and possess the cellular machinery like cytochrome c and Type IV pili to perform extracellular electron transfer (EET) in the presence of suitable electron acceptors. Hence, in this review, in-depth analysis of versatile behaviour of methanogens in both MFC and natural anaerobic conditions with different inhibition techniques is explored. This review also discusses the future research directions based on the latest scientific evidence on role of methanogens for EET in MFC.

Eco-compatible biochar mitigates volatile fatty acids stress in high load thermophilic solid-state anaerobic reactors treating agricultural waste

A high concentration of accumulated volatile fatty acids (VFAs) is one of the most important factors resulting in reactor failure during solid-state anaerobic digestion. In this study, the feedstock-to-inoculum (F/I) ratio (0.5, 2, 3, 4 and 6) and the recovery method after failure (biochar addition or inoculum addition) were investigated in batch solid-state anaerobic digestion fed with rice straw and pig urine. An F/I ratio of 3 was the threshold for stable operation, while the reactors failed at F/I ratios of 4 and 6 because of high accumulated VFAs concentrations (above 30 g HAc/kg). Biochar addition (10% or 20% (wet weight) of the mixture) was as effective as inoculum addition (by adjusting the F/I ratio to 2 or 3) in promoting VFAs degradation in failed reactors within a short period (<1 day). The buffering capacity of biochar was important in promoting VFAs degradation.

Three-dimensional carbon-based anodes promoted the accumulation of exoelectrogens in bioelectrochemical systems

To achieve deep understandings on the effects of structure and surface properties of anode material on the performance of bioelectrochemical systems, the present research investigated the bacterial community structures of biofilms attached to different three-dimensional anodes including carbon felt and materials derived from pomelo peel, kenaf stem, and cardboard with 454 pyrosequencing analysis based on the bacterial 16S rRNA gene. The results showed that bacterial community structures, especially the relative abundance of exoelectrogens, were significantly related to the types of adopted three-dimensional anode materials. Proteobacteria was the shared predominant phylum, accounting for 55.4%, 52.1%, 66.7%, and 56.1% for carbon felt, cardboard, pomelo peel, and kenaf stem carbon, respectively. The most abundant OTU was phylogenetically related to the well-known exoelectrogen of Geobacter, with a relative abundance of 16.3%, 19.0%, 36.3%, and 28.6% in carbon felt, cardboard, pomelo peel, and kenaf stem, respectively. Moreover, another exoelectrogen of Pseudomonas sp. accounted for 4.9% in kenaf stem and 3.9% in carbonboard, respectively. The results implied the macrostructure and properties of different anode materials might result in different niches such as hydrodynamics and substrate transport dynamics, leading to different bacterial structure, especially different relative abundance of exoelectrogens, which consequently affected the performance of bioelectrochemical systems. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Bioelectrochemical systems (BESs) represent a novel biotechnology platform to simultaneously treat wastewaters and produce electrical power. Three-dimensional materials derived from nature plant as anode to promote electricity output from BESs and reduce the construct cost of BESs. Macrostructure of the three-dimensional anode material affected phylotype richness and phylogenetic diversity of microorganisms in anodic biofilm of BESs. Geobacter as well-known exoelectrogen was the most abundant in biofilm attached to three-dimensional anode.

Coupled effects of ferroferric oxide supplement and ethanol co-metabolism on the methanogenic oxidation of propionate

Direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) is a new electron-transfer strategy for enhanced propionate degradation. Ethanol can enrich the DIET species of Geobacter and conductive ferroferric oxide (Fe₃O₄) can promote DIET. Therefore, coupled effects of ethanol and Fe₃O₄ on propionate degradation were investigated. The maximum CH₄ production rate was increased by 81.4% by adding Fe₃O₄ when simultaneously fed with ethanol and propionate, while the improvement could not be observed without ethanol. The sludge conductivity and the electron transfer system activity by adding Fe₃O₄ were increased by 2.66 and 2.73 times, respectively. Besides, the relative abundance of functional microbes such as Geobacter, Syntrophobacter, Smithella, and Methanosaeta, and their functional genes were increased by the supplement of Fe₃O₄. The improvement of propionate degradation by adding Fe₃O₄ was largely attributed to the co-existence of ethanol degradation. The DIET between Geobacter and Methanosaeta might provide more energies or rapidly consume the oxidation products to promote the propionate degradation.

Stimulation of methane production from benzoate with addition of carbon materials

Huge amounts of wastewater that contain aromatic compounds such as benzene and phenols are discharged worldwide. Benzoate is a typical intermediate in the anaerobic transformation of those aromatic compounds. In this study, electrically conductive carbon-based materials of granulated activated carbon (GAC), multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MwCNTs), and graphite were evaluated for the ability to promote the benzoate degradation. The results showed that 82-93% of the electrons were recovered in CH₄ production from benzoate. The carbon materials stimulated benzoate degradation in the sequence of GAC (5 g/L) > MwCNTs (1 g/L) ~ Graphite (0.1 g/L) > Control. Acetate was the only detected intermediate in the process of benzoate degradation. Taxonomic analyses revealed that benzoate was degraded by Syntrophus to acetate and H₂, which were subsequently converted to methane by Methanosarcina (both acetoclastic methanogens and hydrogenotrophic methanogens) and Methanoculleus (hydrogenotrophic methanogens), and direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) of Desulfovibrio and Methanosarcina. Thus, these results suggest a method to effectively enhance the removal of aromatic compounds and methane recovery.

Enhancement of syntrophic acetate oxidation pathway via single walled carbon nanotubes addition under high acetate concentration and thermophilic condition

The effect of single walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNT) on methane production under high acetate concentration and thermophilic condition was evaluated. An isotope labeling experiment verified that >85% of methane was generated from syntrophic acetate oxidation (SAO) at 50, 100 and 150 mM acetate and almost 100% at 200 mM. SWCNT addition had little effect on the methanogenesis pathway, whereas it accelerated methane production via decreasing lag phase times and increasing maximum methane production rates. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) results revealed the electrical resistivity of sludge in groups of SWCNT was distinctly smaller than CK groups, indicating higher sludge conductivity was achieved. Further, the results of communities described that Coprothermobacter and Thermacetogenium played the most important role in SAO under all conditions. Meanwhile, the enriched Thermacetogenium and direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) pathway in SAO consortia contributed to the acceleration of methane production via SWCNT addition.

Redox-based electron exchange capacity of biowaste-derived biochar accelerates syntrophic phenol oxidation for methanogenesis via direct interspecies electron transfer

In this study, six different types of biochar (based on two feedstocks and three pyrolytic temperatures) were prepared as individual additives for both syntrophic phenol degradation and methanogenesis promotion. The results showed that for phenol degradation, the addition of biochar (15 g/L) shortened the methanogenic lag time from 15.0 days to 1.1-3.2 days and accelerated the maximum CH₄ production rate from 4.0 mL/d to 10.4-13.9 mL/d. Microbial community analysis revealed that the electro-active Geobacter was enriched (from 3.8-7.7% to 11.1-23.1%), depending on the type of biochar that was added. This indicates a potential shift of syntrophic phenol metabolism from a thermodynamically unfavorable pathway with H₂ as the interspecies electron transfer mediator to direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET). Integrated analysis of methanogenesis dynamics and the electrochemical properties of biochar showed that compared with electrical conductivity, the electron exchange capacity of biochar was more likely to dominate the DIET process, which was due to the presence of redox-active organic functional groups in biochar. The removal of biochar from the anaerobic system generally prolonged the lag time, revealing the importance of adsorption capacity of biochar to mitigate bio-toxicity of phenol to microbial activity.

Dark fermentation production of volatile fatty acids from glucose with biochar amended biological consortium

Effects of adding biochars on dark fermentation production of volatile fatty acids (VFAs) from glucose were investigated. Nine biochars were synthesized and applied, together with an activated carbon, as the testing amendment to enhance preferable fermentation. Biochars were porous materials with internal pores and excess surface functional groups, which would lead to enrichment of acetate over butyrate in the VFA production. Biochar coconut and biochar longan shell showed excess functional groups and high bulk internal crystallinity, presented 109.6% and 71.8% enrichments of acetate production, respectively. The syntrophic growth of fermentative bacteria and homoacetogens on biochar surfaces via direct interspecies electron transfer mechanism was assumed to interpret the noted enhanced acetate production. The excess functional groups on biochar surface to facilitate biofilm development and the high crystallinity of biochar bulk to ease electron transfer favored the production of acetate.

Enhanced Anaerobic Digestion by Stimulating DIET Reaction

Since the observation of direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) in anaerobic mixed cultures in 2010s, the topic “DIET-stimulation” has been the main route to enhance the performance of anaerobic digestion (AD) under harsh conditions, such as high organic loading rate (OLR) and the toxicants’ presence. In this review article, we tried to answer three main questions: (i) What are the merits and strategies for DIET stimulation? (ii) What are the consequences of stimulation? (iii) What is the mechanism of action behind the impact of this stimulation? Therefore, we introduced DIET history and recent relevant findings with a focus on the theoretical advantages. Then, we reviewed the most recent articles by categorizing how DIET reaction was stimulated by adding conductive material (CM) and/or applying external voltage (EV). The emphasis was made on the enhanced performance (yield and/or production rate), CM type, applied EV, and mechanism of action for each stimulation strategy. In addition, we explained DIET-caused changes in microbial community structure. Finally, future perspectives and practical limitations/chances were explored in detail. We expect this review article will provide a better understanding for DIET pathway in AD and encourage further research development in a right direction.

Comparative facilitation of activated carbon and goethite on methanogenesis from volatile fatty acids

To provide insight into direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) via carbon-based materials and ferric oxides, the effects of three conductive materials (i.e. activated carbon (AC), iron modified activated carbon (FEAC) and goethite (FEOOH)), on methanogenesis from volatile fatty acids (VFAs) were evaluated. Under the acid stress (~4 g/L VFAs), the maximum methane yield of 266 mL/g-chemical oxygen demand (COD) was found in the FEOOH supplemented reactor, which was 48% higher than that of AC reactor. The reasons for the enhanced activity of the electron transport chain and extracellular electron transfer ability by FEOOH include: 1) the activation on iron-containing enzymes that involved in methanogenesis and acidogenesis; 2) selective enrichment on functional microorganism. The higher electron donating capacities (EDC) value of FEOOH may be a triggering factor on the growth of Syntrophomonadaceae, which perform DIET with methanogens (Methanosaeta and Methanosarcina) for the syntrophic degradation of VFAs.

Adding carbon-based materials on anaerobic digestion performance: A mini-review

The anaerobic digestion is the adopted to remediate the pollutant and extract the bioenergy from the waste during the treatment. Effects of adding carbon-based materials on enhancement of digestion performance are studied in literature. This paper provided a mini review on the current research efforts on the traditional view on the cytotoxicity of carbon-based materials to the aquatic microorganisms and the novel "adding carbon-based material strategy" for improving the anaerobic digestion performances. The further research needs for comprehending the interactions between the added carbon materials, the substrates and the microorganisms and the impacts of adopting these additives on full-scale operations were highlighted.

Effects of graphene oxide and reduced graphene oxide on acetoclastic, hydrogenotrophic and methylotrophic methanogenesis

This study describes the effects of graphene oxide (GO) and reduced graphene oxide (rGO) on the acetoclastic, hydrogenotrophic and methylotrophic pathways of methanogenesis by an anaerobic consortium. The results showed that GO negatively affected the hydrogenotrophic and acetoclastic pathways at a concentration of 300 mg/L, causing a decrease of ~ 38% on the maximum specific methanogenic activity (MMA) with respect to the controls lacking GO. However, the presence of rGO (300 mg/L) promoted an improvement of the MMA (> 45%) achieved with all substrates, except for the hydrogenotrophic pathway, which was relatively insensitive to rGO. The presence of either rGO or GO enhanced the methylotrophic pathway and resulted in an increase of the MMA of up to 55%. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis revealed that GO underwent microbial reduction during the incubation period. Electrons derived from substrates oxidation were deviated from methanogenesis towards the reduction of GO, which may explain the MMA decreased observed in the presence of GO. Furthermore, XPS evidence indicated that the extent of GO reduction depended on the metabolic pathway triggered by a given substrate.

Effects of dissimilatory iron reduction on acetate production from the anaerobic fermentation of waste activated sludge under alkaline conditions

Anaerobic digestion of waste activated sludge (WAS) to produce acetate has recently attracted growing interest, while the slow hydrolytic acidification of sludge and the consumption of acetate by methanogens both decrease the yield of acetate. In this study, Fe₃O₄ was added to a WAS anaerobic digester under alkaline conditions (pH = 10). The concentration of short-chain fatty acids (SCFA) during WAS anaerobic fermentation was found to be affected positively by Fe₃O₄. The maximal SCFA production of the Fe₃O₄-added digester was 3619.4 mg/L, while the maximal SCFA production in the control was 2899.7 mg/L. The increase of SCFA with Fe₃O₄ was mainly resulted from the increase in acetate accumulation (accounting for 90%), because Fe₃O₄ stimulated dissimilatory iron reduction (DIR) that participated in the decomposition of complex organics and the transformation of pronionate and butyrate into acetate. Further investigation showed that each step of hydrolytic-acidification process was promoted except the homoacetogenesis. The activity of enzymes and abundance of microbes relevant to hydrolysis and acidification were in agreement with the above results.

Conductive materials in anaerobic digestion: From mechanism to application

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is an effective strategy combined advantages of maintaining the global carbon flux and efficient energy conversion. Various conductive materials (CMs) have been applied in anaerobic digesters to improve the performance of anaerobic fermentation and methanogenesis, including carbon-based CMs and metal-based CMs. Generally, CMs facilitated the AD thermodynamically and kinetically because they triggered more efficient syntrophic metabolism to increase electron capture capability and accelerate reaction rate as well as enhance the performance of AD stages (hydrolysis-acidification, methanogenesis). Besides, adding CMs into anaerobic digester is benefit to dealing with the deteriorating AD, which induced from temperature variation, acidified working condition, higher H₂ partial pressure, etc. However, few CMs exhibited inhibition on AD, including ferrihydrite, magnesium oxide, silver nanoparticles and carbon black. Inhibition comes from a series of complex factors, such as substrate competition, direct inhibition from Fe(III), Fe(III) reduction of methanogens, toxic effects to microorganisms and mass transfer limitation.

RNA-based spatial community analysis revealed intra-reactor variation and expanded collection of direct interspecies electron transfer microorganisms in anaerobic digestion

Granular activated carbon (GAC) has been shown to mediate direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) in anaerobic digestion. Adding GAC to up-flow anaerobic sludge bed reactor increased the total biomass slightly from 20.0 to 26.6 gVSS/reactor, and maximum organic removal capacity remarkably from 285 to 1660 mgCOD/L/d. Since GAC occupied 7% of reactor volume (denser than suspended sludge, settled to the reactor bottom), we used a spatial sampling strategy (sludge bed top/mid/bottom layers, and tightly attached GAC-biofilm) and DNA- and RNA-based community analyses. RNA-based analysis demonstrated significant community differences between the non-GAC and GAC-amended reactors (p < 0.05) based on ANOSIM statistical analysis. In comparison, DNA-based analysis showed little community difference between these reactors (p > 0.05). RNA-based analysis revealed active enrichments in GAC-biofilm, including bacteria Geobacter, Syntrophus, Desulfovibrio and Blvii28, and archaea Methanosaeta and Methanospirillum. These are potential electro-active syntrophic microorganisms related with DIET, which expand the previously defined list of DIET microorganisms.

Redox-active biochar facilitates potential electron tranfer between syntrophic partners to enhance anaerobic digestion under high organic loading rate

Sawdust-based biochar prepared (SDBC) at three pyrolytic temperatures were compared as additives to mesophilic anaerobic digestion (AD). SDBC prepared at 500 °C performed better in enhancing CH₄ production than other SDBCs. Analyzing the crucial electro-chemical characteristics of the SDBCs revealed that the excellent electron transfer capacity of SDBC was significant to stimulate methanogenesis promotion. A long-term semi-continuous operation further confirmed that adding SDBC to AD system increased the maximum organic loading rate (OLR) from 6.8 g VS/L/d to 16.2 g VS/L/d, which attributed to the extremely low volatile fatty acids (VFA) accumulation. Microbial community succession analysis found that SDBC addition altered both bacterial and archaea structure greatly. More importantly, the syntrophic and electro-active partners of Petrimonas and Methanosarcina synergistically enriched under high OLR condition were responsible for the high-efficient VFA degradation, which suggested that SDBC likely acted as redox-active mediator to facilitate direct interspecies electron transfer between the syntrophic partners for high-efficient syntrophic methanogenesis process.

Syntrophus conductive pili demonstrate that common hydrogen-donating syntrophs can have a direct electron transfer option

Syntrophic interspecies electron exchange is essential for the stable functioning of diverse anaerobic microbial communities. Hydrogen/formate interspecies electron transfer (HFIT), in which H₂ and/or formate function as diffusible electron carriers, has been considered to be the primary mechanism for electron transfer because most common syntrophs were thought to lack biochemical components, such as electrically conductive pili (e-pili), necessary for direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET). Here we report that Syntrophus aciditrophicus, one of the most intensively studied microbial models for HFIT, produces e-pili and can grow via DIET. Heterologous expression of the putative S. aciditrophicus type IV pilin gene in Geobacter sulfurreducens yielded conductive pili of the same diameter (4 nm) and conductance of the native S. aciditrophicus pili and enabled long-range electron transport in G. sulfurreducens. S. aciditrophicus lacked abundant c-type cytochromes often associated with DIET. Pilin genes likely to yield e-pili were found in other genera of hydrogen/formate-producing syntrophs. The finding that DIET is a likely option for diverse syntrophs that are abundant in many anaerobic environments necessitates a reexamination of the paradigm that HFIT is the predominant mechanism for syntrophic electron exchange within anaerobic microbial communities of biogeochemical and practical significance.