Genetic selection of peptide inhibitors of biological pathways

Controlling small guanine-nucleotide-exchange factor function through cytoplasmic RNA intramers

ADP-ribosylation factor (ARF) GTPases and their regulatory proteins have been implicated in the control of diverse biological functions. Two main classes of positive regulatory elements for ARF have been discovered so far: the large Sec7/Gea and the small cytohesin/ARNO families, respectively. These proteins harbor guanine-nucleotide-exchange factor (GEF) activity exerted by the common Sec7 domain. The availability of a specific inhibitor, the fungal metabolite brefeldin A, has enabled documentation of the involvement of the large GEFs in vesicle transport. However, because of the lack of such tools, the biological roles of the small GEFs have remained controversial. Here, we have selected a series of RNA aptamers that specifically recognize the Sec7 domain of cytohesin 1. Some aptamers inhibit guanine-nucleotide exchange on ARF1, thereby preventing ARF activation in vitro. Among them, aptamer M69 exhibited unexpected specificity for the small GEFs, because it does not interact with or inhibit the GEF activity of the related Gea2-Sec7 domain, a member of the class of large GEFs. The inhibitory effect demonstrated in vitro clearly is observed as well in vivo, based on the finding that M69 produces similar results as a dominant-negative, GEF-deficient mutant of cytohesin 1: when expressed in the cytoplasm of T-cells, M69 reduces stimulated adhesion to intercellular adhesion molecule-1 and results in a dramatic reorganization of F-actin distribution. These highly specific cellular effects suggest that the ARF-GEF activity of cytohesin 1 plays an important role in cytoskeletal remodeling events of lymphoid cells.

Peptide inhibitors expressed in vivo

Peptide inhibitors isolated from libraries either through genetic screens or binding assays have gained visibility in the past year - especially with the publication of four studies in model systems (two in yeast, two in Escherichia coli). These and other studies demonstrate that forward and reverse genetic experiments with peptides can be extremely efficient in validating candidate drug targets and in defining elements of biochemical pathways.

Use of protein-interaction maps to formulate biological questions

Protein-interaction mapping approaches generate functional information for large numbers of genes that are predicted from complete genome sequences. This information, released as databases available on the Internet, is likely to transform the way biologists formulate and then address their questions of interest.

A minimal peptide scaffold for beta-turn display: optimizing a strand position in disulfide-cyclized beta-hairpins

Phage display of peptide libraries has become a powerful tool for the evolution of novel ligands that bind virtually any protein target. However, the rules governing conformational preferences in natural peptides are poorly understood, and consequently, structure-activity relationships in these molecules can be difficult to define. In an effort to simplify this process, we have investigated the structural stability of 10-residue, disulfide-constrained beta-hairpins and assessed their suitability as scaffolds for beta-turn display. Using disulfide formation as a probe, relative free energies of folding were measured for 19 peptides that differ at a one strand position. A tryptophan substitution promotes folding to a remarkable degree. NMR analysis confirms that the measured energies correlate well with the degree of beta-hairpin structure in the disulfide-cyclized peptides. Reexamination of a subset of the strand substitutions in peptides with different turn sequences reveals linear free energy relationships, indicating that turns and strand-strand interactions make independent, additive contributions to hairpin stability. Significantly, the tryptophan strand substitution is highly stabilizing with all turns tested, and peptides that display model turns or the less stable C'-C' ' turn of CD4 on this tryptophan "stem" are highly structured beta-hairpins in water. Thus, we have developed a small, structured beta-turn scaffold, containing only natural L-amino acids, that may be used to display peptide libraries of limited conformational diversity on phage.

Dominant effector genetics in mammalian cells

We have expressed libraries of peptides in mammalian cells to select for trans-dominant effects on intracellular signaling systems. As an example-and to reveal pharmacologically relevant points in pathways that lead to Taxol resistance-we selected for peptide motifs that confer resistance to Taxol-induced cell death. Of several peptides selected, one, termed RGP8.5, was linked to upregulation of expression of the gene ABCB1 (also known as MDR1, for multiple drug resistance) in HeLa cells. Our data indicate that trans-dominant effector peptides can point to potential mechanisms by which signaling systems operate. Such tools may be useful in functional genomic analysis of signaling pathways in mammalian disease processes.

Targeted modification and transportation of cellular proteins

Peptide aptamers are proteins selected from combinatorial libraries that display conformationally constrained variable regions. Peptide aptamers can disrupt specific protein interactions and thus represent a useful method for manipulating protein function in vivo. Here, we describe aptamer derivatives that extend the range of functional manipulations. We isolated an aptamer with increased affinity for its Cdk2 target by mutagenizing an existing aptamer and identifying tighter binding mutants with calibrated two-hybrid reporter genes. We used this and other anti-Cdk2 aptamers as recognition domains in chimeric proteins that contained other functional moieties. Aptamers fused to the catalytic domain of a ubiquitin ligase specifically decorated LexA-Cdk2 with ubiquitin moieties in vivo. Aptamers against Cdk2 and another protein, Ste5, that carried a nuclear localization sequence transported their targets into the nucleus. These experiments indicate that fusion proteins containing aptameric recognition moieties will be useful for specific modification of protein function in vivo.

Pheromone response, mating and cell biology

Saccharomyces cerevisiae responds to mating pheromones by activating a receptor-G-protein-coupled mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) cascade that is also used by other signaling pathways. The activation of the MAPK cascade may involve conformational changes through prebound receptor and heterotrimeric G-protein. G beta may then recruit Cdc42-bound MAPKKKK Ste20 to MAPKKK Ste11 through direct interactions with Ste20 and the Ste5 scaffold. Ste20 activates Ste11 by derepressing an autoinhibitory domain. An underlying nuclear shuttling machinery may be required for proper recruitment of Ste5 to G beta. Subsequent polarized growth is mediated by a similar mechanism involving Far1, which binds G beta in addition to Cdc24 and Bem1. Far1 and Cdc24 also undergo nuclear shuttling and the nuclear pool of Far1 may temporally regulate access of Cdc24 to the cell cortex.

Applications of display technology in protein analysis

Display technology refers to a collection of methods for creating libraries of modularly coded biomolecules that can be screened for desired properties. It has become a routine tool for enriching molecular diversity and producing novel types of proteins. The combination of an ever-increasing variety of libraries of modularly coded protein complexxes with the development of innovative approaches to select a wide array of desired properties has facilitated large-scale analyses of protein-protein/protein-substrate interactions, rapid isolation of antibodies (or antibody mimetics) without immunization, and function-based protein analysis. Several practical and theoretical challenges remain to be addressed before display technology can be readily applied to proteomic studies.

Applied genomics: integration of the technology within pharmaceutical research and development

Multiple novel technologies have recently been developed to improve the analysis of genetic sequences, to rapidly assess RNA or protein levels in relevant tissues, and to validate function of potential new drug targets. The challenge facing pharmaceutical research is one of effective integration of these new technologies in ways that can maximally affect the discovery and development pipeline. Although database mining and transcriptional profiling clearly have increased the number of putative targets, the current focus is to assign function to new gene targets in a high-throughput manner. This requires a restructuring of the classical linear progression from gene identification, functional elucidation, target validation and screen development. New approaches are called for that can make this process non-linear and high-throughput.

A role for cyclin J in the rapid nuclear division cycles of early Drosophila embryogenesis

The nuclear division cycles of early Drosophila embryogenesis have a number of unique features that distinguish them from later cell cycles. These features include the lack of some checkpoints that operate in later cell cycles, the absence of gap phases, and very rapid DNA synthesis phases. The molecular mechanisms that control these rapid nuclear division cycles are poorly understood. Here we describe analysis of cyclin J, a previously uncharacterized cyclin which has an RNA expression pattern that suggests a possible role in early embryogenesis. We show that the cyclin J protein is present in early embryos where it forms active kinase complexes with cyclin-dependent kinase (Cdk) 2. To determine whether cyclin J plays a role in controlling the early nuclear cycles we isolated peptide aptamers that specifically bind to cyclin J and inhibit its ability to activate Cdks. We injected the inhibitory aptamers into syncytial Drosophila embryos and demonstrated that they caused defects in chromosome segregation and progression through mitosis. We obtained similar results by injecting cyclin J antibodies into embryos. Our results suggest that a cyclin J-associated kinase activity is required for the early embryonic division cycles.

Genetic systems for analyzing protein-protein interactions in bacteria

Analysis of protein-protein interactions has been revolutionized by the yeast two-hybrid system introduced by Fields and coworkers. In recent years, similar genetic assays have been developed in bacteria. We describe here several of these systems and highlight some potential applications of these technologies.

Chemical genetics: ligand-based discovery of gene function

Chemical genetics is the study of gene-product function in a cellular or organismal context using exogenous ligands. In this approach, small molecules that bind directly to proteins are used to alter protein function, enabling a kinetic analysis of the in vivo consequences of these changes. Recent advances have strongly enhanced the power of exogenous ligands such that they can resemble genetic mutations in terms of their general applicability and target specificity. The growing sophistication of this approach raises the possibility of its application to any biological process.

Gene expression analysis as an aid to the identification of drug targets

Many drug targets are components of complex signalling pathways, and in order to understand the true biological consequences of modulating these targets it is necessary to understand the biology of the system in great detail. Genomics research can contribute some of the tools to achieve this, for example through the use of cDNA microarrays. Since activation of signalling pathways leads to mRNA expression, microarray technology can be used to provide a detailed quantitative assessment of the consequences of this activation, often providing a completely new biological perspective on well established cellular systems. This review will discuss some of the results obtained using mRNA profiling of yeast and mammalian cells to analyse signalling pathways of relevance to inflammation and cancer, and will point towards the future applications of this exciting approach to drug target evaluation.

A CDC6 protein-binding peptide selected using a bacterial two-hybrid-like system is a cell cycle inhibitor

Peptides or small molecules able to modulate protein-protein interactions hold promise as tools with which to probe and manipulate biological pathways. An important issue in this nascent field is to evaluate different methods with which to search libraries for molecules that modulate the function of specific target proteins. One strategy is to screen libraries for molecules that bind specifically to a protein known to be critical in the pathway of interest, with the expectation that the molecules isolated will recognize regions of the target protein important for its function and thereby exhibit biological activity. Here, a peptide library was screened using a two-hybrid-like system for molecules able to bind human CDC6 protein (CDC6p), required for the initiation of DNA replication in eukaryotic cells. From a collection of over a million peptides, a single species that exhibited good affinity and specificity for binding CDC6p was obtained. When expressed in human cells, the peptide inhibited cell cycle progression and exhibited other properties expected of a CDC6p inhibitor. This approach, which does not require detailed knowledge of the mechanism of action of a protein target, may be generally useful for isolating peptides capable of manipulating biological pathways.

Convergent evolution with combinatorial peptides

Once the sequence of a genome is in hand, understanding the function of its encoded proteins becomes a task of paramount importance. Much like the biochemists who first outlined different biochemical pathways, many genomic scientists are engaged in determining which proteins interact with which proteins, thereby establishing a protein interaction network. While these interactions have evolved in regard to their specificity, affinity and cellular function over billions of years, it is possible in the laboratory to isolate peptides from combinatorial libraries that bind to the same proteins with similar specificity, affinity and primary structures, which resemble those of the natural interacting proteins. We have termed this phenomenon 'convergent evolution'. In this review, we highlight various examples of convergent evolution that have been uncovered in experiments dissecting protein-protein interactions with combinatorial peptides. Thus, a fruitful approach for mapping protein-protein interactions is to isolate peptide ligands to a target protein and identify candidate interacting proteins in a sequenced genome by computer analysis.

Domain repertoires as a tool to derive protein recognition rules

Several approaches, some of which are described in this issue, have been proposed to assemble a complete protein interaction map. These are often based on high throughput methods that explore the ability of each gene product to bind any other element of the proteome of the organism. Here we propose that a large number of interactions can be inferred by revealing the rules underlying recognition specificity of a small number (a few hundreds) of families of protein recognition modules. This can be achieved through the construction and characterization of domain repertoires. A domain repertoire is assembled in a combinatorial fashion by allowing each amino acid position in the binding site of a given protein recognition domain to vary to include all the residues allowed at that position in the domain family. The repertoire is then searched by phage display techniques with any target of interest and from the primary structure of the binding site of the selected domains one derives rules that are used to infer the formation of complexes between natural proteins in the cell.

Genetic selection for dissociative inhibitors of designated protein-protein interactions

Many biological processes rely on protein-protein interactions. These processes include signal transduction, cell cycle regulation, gene regulation, and viral assembly and replication. Moreover, many proteins and enzymes manifest their function as oligomers. We describe here an efficient means to sift through large combinatorial libraries and identify molecules that block the interaction of target proteins in vivo. The power of this approach is demonstrated by the identification of nine-residue peptides from a combinatorial library that inhibit the intracellular dimerization of HIV-1 protease. Fewer than 1 in 106 peptides do so. In vitro biochemical analyses of one such peptide demonstrate that it acts by dissociating HIV-1 protease into monomers, which are inactive catalysts. Inhibition is enhanced further by dimerizing the peptide. This approach enables the facile identification of new molecules that control cellular processes.

Engineered protein scaffolds for molecular recognition

The use of so-called protein scaffolds has recently attracted considerable attention in biochemistry in the context of generating novel types of ligand receptors for various applications in research and medicine. This development started with the notion that immunoglobulins owe their function to the composition of a conserved framework region and a spatially well-defined antigen-binding site made of peptide segments that are hypervariable both in sequence and in conformation. After the application of antibody engineering methods along with library techniques had resulted in first successes in the selection of functional antibody fragments, several laboratories began to exploit other types of protein architectures for the construction of practically useful binding proteins. Properties like small size of the receptor protein, stability and ease of production were the focus of this work. Hence, among others, single domains of antibodies or of the immunoglobulin superfamily, protease inhibitors, helix-bundle proteins, disulphide-knotted peptides and lipocalins were investigated. Recently, the scaffold concept has even been adopted for the construction of enzymes. However, it appears that not all kinds of polypeptide fold which may appear attractive for the engineering of loop regions at a first glance will indeed permit the construction of independent ligand-binding sites with high affinities and specificities. This review will therefore concentrate on the critical description of the structural properties of experimentally tested protein scaffolds and of the novel functions that have been achieved on their basis, rather than on the methodology of how to best select a particular mutant with a certain activity. An overview will be provided about the current approaches, and some emerging trends will be identified. (c) 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Abbreviations used: ABD albumin-binding domain of protein G APPI Alzheimer's amyloid beta-protein precursor inhibitor BBP bilin-binding protein BPTI bovine (or basic) pancreatic trypsin inhibitor BSA bovine serum albumin CBD cellulose-binding domain of cellobiohydrolase I CD circular dichroism Cdk2 human cyclin-dependent kinase 2 CDR complementarity-determining region CTLA-4 human cytotoxic T-lymphocyte associated protein-4 FN3 fibronectin type III domain GSH glutathione GST glutathione S-transferase hIL-6 human interleukin-6 HSA human serum albumin IC(50) half-maximal inhibitory concentration Ig immunoglobulin IMAC immobilized metal affinity chromatography K(D) equilibrium constant of dissociation K(i) equilibrium dissociation constant of enzyme inhibitor LACI-D1 human lipoprotein-associated coagulation inhibitor pIII gene III minor coat protein from filamentous bacteriophage f1 PCR polymerase-chain reaction PDB Protein Data Bank PSTI human pancreatic secretory trypsin inhibitor RBP retinol-binding protein SPR surface plasmon resonance TrxA E. coli thioredoxin

Induction of apoptosis in human papillomaviruspositive cancer cells by peptide aptamers targeting the viral E6 oncoprotein

Certain types of human papillomaviruses (HPVs) are closely linked to the development of human cancers. Herein, it is shown that intracellular targeting of the HPV16 E6 oncoprotein by E6-binding peptide aptamers resulted in the apoptotic elimination of HPV16-positive cancer cells, whereas HPV-negative cells were not affected. These results provide direct experimental evidence that the HPV E6 oncoprotein has antiapoptotic activity in HPV-positive tumor cells that is required for their survival. The E6-targeting molecules identified herein have implications for the development of therapeutic strategies for the treatment of HPV-associated dysplasias and cancers.

Phosphorylation of the MEKK Ste11p by the PAK-like kinase Ste20p is required for MAP kinase signaling in vivo

BACKGROUND

Many signals are transduced from the cell surface to the nucleus through mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase cascades. Activation of MAP kinase requires phosphorylation by MEK, which in turn is controlled by Raf, Mos or a group of structurally related kinases termed MEKKs. It is not understood how MEKKs are regulated by extracellular signals. In yeast, the MEKK Ste11p functions in multiple MAP kinase cascades activated in response to pheromones, high osmolarity and nutrient starvation. Genetic evidence suggests that the p21-activated protein kinase (PAK) Ste20p functions upstream of Ste11p, and Ste20p has been shown to phosphorylate Ste11p in vitro.

RESULTS

Ste20p phosphorylated Ste11p on Ser302 and/or Ser306 and Thr307 in yeast, residues that are conserved in MEKKs of other organisms. Mutating these sites to non-phosphorylatable residues abolished Ste11p function, whereas changing them to aspartic acid to mimic the phosphorylated form constitutively activated Ste11p in vivo in a Ste20p-independent manner. The amino-terminal regulatory domain of Ste11p interacted with its catalytic domain, and overexpression of a small amino-terminal fragment of Ste11p was able to inhibit signaling in response to pheromones. Mutational analysis suggested that this interaction was regulated by phosphorylation and dependent on Thr596, which is located in the substrate cleft of the catalytic domain.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that, in response to multiple extracellular signals, phosphorylation of Ste11p by Ste20p removes an amino-terminal inhibitory domain, leading to activation of the Ste11 protein kinase. This mechanism may serve as a paradigm for the activation of mammalian MEKKs.

The continued evolution of two-hybrid screening approaches in yeast: how to outwit different preys with different baits

The original two-hybrid system, an experimental approach designed to detect protein interactions, exploited the modular nature of many transcription factors. It has provided the intellectual and technical seed for the evolution of an array of innovative approaches, the application of which broadens the scope of experimentally feasible questions to include the interaction of proteins with diverse binding partners. The available array of modified and alternative approaches facilitates the analysis of complex cellular machinery and signaling networks that rely on multiple protein interactions. Such advances have facilitated the functional analysis of proteins on the genome level, a feat considered untenable a decade ago.

Reversible transdominant inhibition of a metabolic pathway. In vivo evidence of interaction between two sequential tricarboxylic acid cycle enzymes in yeast

The enzymes of the Krebs tricarboxylic acid cycle in mitochondria are proposed to form a supramolecular complex, in which there is channeling of intermediates between enzyme active sites. While interactions have been demonstrated in vitro between most of the sequential tricarboxylic acid cycle enzymes, no direct evidence has been obtained in vivo for such interactions. We have isolated, in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae gene encoding the tricarboxylic acid cycle enzyme citrate synthase Cit1p, an "assembly mutation," i.e. a mutation that causes a tricarboxylic acid cycle deficiency without affecting the citrate synthase activity. We have shown that a 15-amino acid peptide from wild type Cit1p encompassing the mutation point inhibits the tricarboxylic acid cycle in a dominant manner, and that the inhibitory phenotype is overcome by a co-overexpression of Mdh1p, the mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase. These data provide the first direct in vivo evidence of interaction between two sequential tricarboxylic acid cycle enzymes, Cit1p and Mdh1p, and indicate that the characterization of assembly mutations by the reversible transdominant inhibition method may be a powerful way to study multienzyme complexes in their physiological context.

The spindle checkpoint: two transitions, two pathways

The spindle checkpoint is an evolutionarily conserved mitotic regulatory mechanism that ensures that anaphase is not attempted until chromosomes are properly aligned on the spindle. Two different cell-cycle transitions must be inhibited by the spindle checkpoint to arrest cells at metaphase and prevent mitotic exit. The checkpoint proteins interact in ways that are more complex than was originally envisioned. This review summarizes the evidence for two pathways of spindle-checkpoint regulation in budding yeast. We describe how the proteins are involved in these pathways and discuss the ways in which the spindle checkpoint inhibits the cell-cycle machinery.

Chemical ligands, genomics and drug discovery

The sequencing of the human genome and numerous pathogen genomes has resulted in an explosion of potential drug targets. These targets represent both an unprecedented opportunity and a technological challenge for the pharmaceutical industry. A new strategy is required to initiate small-molecule drug discovery with sets of incompletely characterized, disease-associated proteins. One such strategy is the early application of combinatorial chemistry and other technologies to the discovery of bioactive small-molecule ligands that act on candidate drug targets. Therapeutically active ligands serve to concurrently validate a target and provide lead structures for downstream drug development, thereby accelerating the drug discovery process.

Isolation of peptide aptamers that inhibit intracellular processes

We have developed a method for isolation of random peptides that inhibit intracellular processes in bacteria. A library of random peptides expressed as fusions to Escherichia coli thioredoxin (aptamers) were expressed under the tight control of the arabinose-inducible P(BAD) promoter. A selection was applied to the library to isolate aptamers that interfered with the activity of thymidylate synthase (ThyA) in vivo. Expression of an aptamer isolated by this method resulted in a ThyA(-) phenotype that was suppressed by simultaneous overexpression of ThyA. Two-hybrid analysis showed that this aptamer is likely to interact with ThyA in vivo. The library also was screened for aptamers that inhibited growth of bacteria expressing them, and five such aptamers were characterized. Four aptamers were bacteriostatic when expressed, whereas one showed a bactericidal effect. Introduction of translational stop codons into various aptamers blocked their activity, suggesting that their biological effects were likely to be due to protein aptamer rather than RNA. Combinatorial aptamers provide a new genetic and biochemical tool for identifying targets for antibacterial drug development.

Complexity in the spindle checkpoint

Cell viability requires accurate chromosome segregation at mitosis. The spindle checkpoint ensures that anaphase is not attempted until the sister chromatids of each chromosome are attached to spindle microtubules from opposite poles. The checkpoint mechanism involves a signal transduction cascade that is more complex than was originally envisioned.

Combinatorial protein reagents to manipulate protein function

The design and use of combinatorial protein libraries has become a fast moving field in molecular biology. Different experimental systems supporting various selection schemes are now available. The latest breakthroughs include evolutionary experiments to improve existing binding surfaces, selections of homodimerizing peptides, the use of peptide aptamers to disrupt protein interactions inside living cells, and functional selections of aptamers to probe regulatory networks.

Oligonucleotide-conjugated beads for transdominant genetic experiments

Transdominant genetics using expression libraries can identify proteins and peptides that affect cell division. In conjunction with these libraries, oligo-nucleotide-conjugated beads and flow cytometry were used to test a strategy that potentially expands the range of such genetic studies. The experimental approach involved creation of tagged expression libraries, introduction of these libraries into cells, growth of the cultured cells for several generations and recovery on oligonucleotide-conjugated beads of sequences that encode growth-modulatory proteins or peptides. Experiments in Saccharomyces cerevisiae demonstrating the feasibility of the strategy are presented.

Production of cyclic peptides and proteins in vivo

Combinatorial libraries of synthetic and natural products are an important source of molecular information for the interrogation of biological targets. Methods for the intracellular production of libraries of small, stable molecules would be a valuable addition to existing library technologies by combining the discovery potential inherent in small molecules with the large library sizes that can be realized by intracellular methods. We have explored the use of split inteins (internal proteins) for the intracellular catalysis of peptide backbone cyclization as a method for generating proteins and small peptides that are stabilized against cellular catabolism. The DnaE split intein from Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 was used to cyclize the Escherichia coli enzyme dihydrofolate reductase and to produce the cyclic, eight-amino acid tyrosinase inhibitor pseudostellarin F in bacteria. Cyclic dihydrofolate reductase displayed improved in vitro thermostability, and pseudostellarin F production was readily apparent in vivo through its inhibition of melanin production catalyzed by recombinant Streptomyces antibioticus tyrosinase. The ability to generate and screen for backbone cyclic products in vivo is an important milestone toward the goal of generating intracellular cyclic peptide and protein libraries.