Genetic determinants of individual differences in avoidance learning: behavioral and endocrine characteristics

Selective breeding of rats for high (HAB) and low (LAB) anxiety-related behaviour: A unique model for comorbid depression and social dysfunctions

Animal models of selective breeding for extremes in emotionality are a strong experimental approach to model psychopathologies. They became indispensable in order to increase our understanding of neurobiological, genetic, epigenetic, hormonal, and environmental mechanisms contributing to anxiety disorders and their association with depressive symptoms or social deficits. In the present review, we extensively discuss Wistar rats selectively bred for high (HAB) and low (LAB) anxiety-related behaviour on the elevated plus-maze. After 30 years of breeding, we can confirm the prominent differences between HAB and LAB rats in trait anxiety, which are accompanied by consistent differences in depressive-like, social and cognitive behaviours. We can further confirm a single nucleotide polymorphism in the vasopressin promotor of HAB rats causative for neuropeptide overexpression, and show that low (or high) anxiety and fear levels are unlikely due to visual dysfunctions. Thus, HAB and LAB rats continue to exist as a reliable tool to study the multiple facets underlying the pathology of high trait anxiety and its comorbidity with depression-like behaviour and social dysfunctions.

Hatano rats selectively bred for high- and low-avoidance learning: an overview

This review compiles the results of a series of studies on Hatano high- and low-avoidance animals (HAA and LAA, respectively) established at the Hatano Research Institute, Food and Drug Safety Center, Japan. The HAA and LAA lines were selected and bred from Sprague Dawley rats for high and low avoidance learning, respectively, in a shuttlebox task since 1985. Although Hatano rats were selected only based on their behavioral traits in the active avoidance task, strain differences between the HAA and LAA lines were also observed in their stress responses and reproductive functions. However, the most noticeable finding of Hatano rats is a matched result in both active and passive avoidance tasks. The HAA and LAA lines are useful for next-generation toxicological studies, because the hereditary characters of behaviors or endocrine functions are well controlled.

The intrauterine environment affects learning ability of Tokai high avoider rat offspring derived using cryopreservation and embryo transfer-mediated reproduction

Embryo transfer (ET) to recipient female animals is a useful technique in biological and experimental animal studies. While cryopreservation of two-cell stage rat embryos and ET to recipient rats are currently well-defined, it is unknown whether these artificial reproductive techniques and maternal factors affect offspring phenotype, particularly higher brain functions. Therefore, we assessed the effects of cryopreservation, ET, and maternal care on learning behaviour of the offspring, using Tokai high avoider (THA) rats that have a high learning ability phenotype. We found that the high learning ability of THA rat offspring was not replicated following ET to surrogate Wistar rats with a low-avoidance phenotype. Additionally, the characteristic phenotype of offspring obtained through mating of ET-derived rats was similar to that of THA rats. A postnatal cross-fostering investigation with the offspring of Wistar and THA rats showed that maternal behaviour, including postnatal care and lactation traits, did not differ between the dams of low-avoidance Wistar rats and THA rats; therefore, learning behaviour was retained in both Wistar and THA rat offspring. We conclude that the offspring phenotype, although unchanged, has an imperceptible effect on the learning ability of ET-derived THA rats through the intrauterine environment of the recipient.

Responses conditioned to fear-relevant stimuli survive extinction of the expectancy of the UCS

Davey suggests that increased resistance to extinction of CRs conditioned to fear-relevant stimuli may be due to more persistent expectancies of the UCS following these stimuli. However, this viewpoint is contradicted by existing empirical evidence that fear-relevant CRs survive an extinction trials series producing extinction of expectancies whereas CRs conditioned to non-fear-relevant CSs do not.

Eggs in more than one basket: Mediating mechanisms between evolution and phobias

The evolutionary origin of phobias is strongly supported by behavioral genetics and monkey vicarious conditioning data. Prepared Pavlovian conditioning may be only one of the mechanisms mediating the evolutionarily determined outcome in phobias, avoidance. Davey's alternative biased expectancy hypothesis has merit in accounting for some aspects of laboratory data, but it is insufficient to explain the unconscious origin of phobic fear.

Preparedness, phobias, and the Panglossian paradigm

In his critique of preparedness theory, Davey does not address the limitations of adaptationism. The purpose of this commentary is to outline problems that arise when one assumes that mental illness (e.g., phobic disorder) must have had adaptive significance for it to have survived the vicissitudes of natural selection.

Natural selection and fear regulation mechanisms

Expectations can facilitate rapid fear conditioning and this may explain some phenomena that have been attributed to preparedness. However, preparedness remains the best explanation for some aspects of clinical phobias and the difficulty of creating fears of modern dangers. Rapid fear conditioning based on expectancy is not an alternative to an evolutionary explanation, but has, like preparedness, been shaped by natural selection.

Innateness versus expectation in human fears: Causal versus maintaining factors?

This commentary focuses upon two issues raised by Davey's target article: (1) whether there are certain core features of stimuli we learn to fear, rather than specific types of objects or situations, which implies some element of innateness; and (2) whether expectancy biases serve to maintain rather than generate anxiety.

Expectancy bias as sole or partial account of selective associations?

Davey reviews evidence purporting to distinguish between two accounts of selective associations – expectancy bias and evolved predispositions, although these hypotheses largely apply to different levels of causal analysis. Criticisms of primate studies in which subjects lack prior exposure to stimuli seem uncompelling. Expectancies may sometimes serve as proximal mediators in selective associations, but other factors, both proximate and ultimate, are clearly also involved.

The uneven distribution of fears and phobias: A nonassociative account

A review of data concerning the uneven distribution of phobias suggests that nonassociative, ethological models can account for most of tile important findings that cannot be attributed to expectancy biases. The origin of a variety of fears that appear in fixed developmental patterns across divergent cultures and species can best be explained by biological models.

Preparedness and phobias: Specific evolved associations or a generalized expectancy bias?

Most phobias are focussed on a small number of fear-inducing stimuli (e.g., snakes, spiders). A review of the evidence supporting biological and cognitive explanations of this uneven distribution of phobias suggests that the readiness with which such stimuli become associated with aversive outcomes arises from biases in the processing of information about threatening stimuli rather than from phylogenetically based associative predispositions or “biological preparedness.” This cognitive bias, consisting of a heightened expectation of aversive outcomes following fear-relevant stimuli, generates and maintains robust learned associations between them. Some of the features of such stimuli which determine this expectancy bias are estimates of how dangerous they are, the semiotic similarity between them and their aversive outcomes, and the degree of prior fear they elicit. Ontogenetic and cultural factors influence these features of fear-relevant stimuli and are hence important in determining expectancy bias. The available evidence does not exclude the possibility that both expectancy biases and specific evolved predispositions coexist, but the former can explain a number of important findings that the latter cannot.

A stochastic optimality theory of preparedness and plasticity

Many now consider “instinct” and “learning” opposite poles of a unidimensional continuum. An alternative model with two independently varying parameters predicts different selective pressures. Behavioral adaptation matches the organism's utilizations of stimuli and responses to their ecological validities: the mean validity over evolutionary time specifies the optimal initial potency of the prepared association; the variance specifies the optimal prepared plasticity.

Inter-individual differences in neurobiology as vulnerability factors for affective disorders: implications for psychopharmacology

Susceptibility to affective disorders is individually different, and determined both by genetic variance and life events that cause significant differences in the CNS structure and function between individual subjects. Therefore it is plausible that search for the inter-individual differences in endophenotypes that mediate the effects of causal factors, both genetic and environmental, will reveal the substrates for vulnerability, help to clarify pathogenetic mechanisms, and possibly aid in developing strategies to discover better, more personalized treatments. This review first examines comparatively a number of animal models of human affect and affect-related disorders that rely on persistent inter-individual differences, and then highlights some of the neurobiological findings in these models that are compatible with much of research in human behavioural and personality traits. Many behaviours occur in specific combinations in several models, but often remarkable dissociations are observed, providing a variety of constellations of traits. It is concluded that more systematic comparative experimentation on behaviour and neurobiology in different models is warranted to reveal possible "building blocks" of affect-related personality common in animals and humans. Looking into the perspectives in psychopharmacology the focus is placed on probable associations of inter-individual differences with brain structure and function, personality and coping strategies, and psychiatric vulnerability, highlighting some unexpected interactions between vulnerability endophenotypes, adverse life events, and behavioural traits. It is argued that further studies on inter-individual differences in affect and underlying neurobiology should include formal modeling of their epistatic, hierarchical and dynamic nature.

Responsiveness of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis to different novel environments is a consistent individual trait in adult male outbred rats

Susceptibility to some stress-induced pathologies may be strongly related to individual differences in the responsiveness of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis to stressors. However, there have been few attempts in rodents to study the reliability of the individual differences in the responsiveness of the HPA to stressors and the relationship to resting corticosterone levels. In the present work, we used a normal population of Sprague-Dawley rats, with a within-subject design. Our objectives were to study: (a) the reliability of the ACTH and corticosterone response to three different novel environments widely used in psychopharmacology and (b) the relationship between stress levels of HPA hormones and the daily pattern of corticosterone secretion (six samples over a 24-h-period). Animals were repeatedly sampled using tail-nick procedure. The novel environments were the elevated plus-maze, the hole-board and the circular corridor. Animals were sampled just after 15 min exposure to the tests and again at 15 and 30 min after the termination of exposure to them (post-tests). The hormonal levels just after the tests indicate that the hole-board seems to be more stressful than the circular corridor and the elevated plus-maze, the latter being characterized by the lowest defecation rate. Correlational analysis revealed that daily pattern of resting plasma corticosterone levels did not correlate to HPA responsiveness to the tests, suggesting no relationship between resting and stress levels of HPA hormones. In contrast, the present study demonstrates, for the first time, a good within-subject reliability of the ACTH and corticosterone responses to the three environments, suggesting that HPA responsiveness to these kind of stressors is a consistent individual trait in adult rats, despite differences in the physical characteristics of the novel environments.

Genetically-based behavioral traits influence the effects of Shuttle Box avoidance overtraining and extinction upon intertrial responding: a study with the Roman rat strains

In the present study, we evaluated the effects of extended exposure procedures to contextual fear cues as a way of reducing intertrial responses (ITRs), a characteristic stereotyped behavior displayed in 2-way Shuttle Box avoidance overtraining. We used rat strains psychogenetically selected for efficient (Roman high-avoidance; RHA) versus poor 2-way Shuttle Box performance (Roman low-avoidance; RLA), the former being fearless/impulsive relative to the latter. Additionally, Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats were compared with RHAs to have a measure of the ITRs exhibited by another, non-selected group of animals. The main findings were that after extended exposure RHAs diminished their ITRs without affecting avoidance performance, although they emitted a pattern of ITRs somewhat excessive as compared with SDs. We concluded that three factors could influence the expression of ITRs in RHA rats: (1) the repetitive and stereotyped responding induced by 2-way Shuttle Box overtraining; (2) contextual fear conditioning; and (3) a genetic background associated with high impulsiveness.

The influence of midazolam on active avoidance retrieval and acquisition rate in rats

The purpose of the present study was to examine the influence of midazolam on the retrieval and acquisition rate of two-way active avoidance in rats. In the schedule 2 x 100 trials, the effects of midazolam (0.5-5.0 mg/kg), benzodiazepine binding site antagonist flumazenil (2.5-10.0 mg/kg), specific antagonist of GABA(A) receptor, bicuculline (0.5-4.0 mg/kg), and the blocker of GABA(A) receptor containing Cl(-) channels, picrotoxin (1.0-5.0 mg/kg), on the second day retrieval of avoidance performance were investigated, as well as the influence of the used blockers of GABA(A) receptor function on midazolam effects. Furthermore, the effect of midazolam (1.0 mg/kg) on acquisition rate in the 5 x 50 schedule, as well as the effects of third day treatment changing in that paradigm, was examined. Throughout the study, drugs were given intraperitoneally, 30 min before testing. Midazolam at the dose of 1.0 mg/kg facilitated avoidance retrieval, whereas flumazenil and bicuculline did not significantly change behavior. Picrotoxin (5.0 mg/kg) diminished performance. All three kinds of blockers used abolished facilitatory action of midazolam, confirming GABAergic mediation of the effect of benzodiazepine. Midazolam (1.0 mg/kg) increased acquisition rate during five consecutive days relative to saline, but without significant effect on the first day acquisition. In the case of third day changing of treatments, the intersection of regression rate lines was detected. Results from active avoidance paradigm experimentally support the findings from human studies that in certain circumstances, benzodiazepines, potentiating GABAergic neurotransmission, could produce retrieval-enhancing effects in memory tasks.

Genetic animal models of anxiety

The focus of this review is on progress achieved in identifying specific genes conferring risk for anxiety disorders through the use of genetic animal models. We discuss gene-finding studies as well as those manipulating a candidate gene. Both human and animal studies thus far support the genetic complexity of anxiety. Clinical manifestations of these diseases are likely related to multiple genes. While different anxiety disorders and anxiety-related traits all appear to be genetically influenced, it has been difficult to ascertain genetic influences in common. Mouse studies have provisionally mapped several loci harboring genes that affect anxiety-related behavior. The growing array of mutant mice is providing valuable information about how genes and environment interact to affect anxious behavior via multiple neuropharmacological pathways. Classical genetic methods such as artificial selection of rodents for high or low anxiety are being employed. Expression array technologies have as yet not been employed, but can be expected to implicate novel candidates and neurobiological pathways.

Early-life handling stimulation and environmental enrichment: are some of their effects mediated by similar neural mechanisms?

Neonatal (early) handling (EH) and environmental enrichment (EE) of laboratory rodents have been the two most commonly used methods of providing supplementary environmental stimulation in order to study behavioral and neurobiological plasticity. A large body of research has been generated since the 1950s, unequivocally showing that both treatments induce profound and long-lasting behavioral and neural consequences while also inducing plastic brain effects and being "protective" against some age-related deficits. The present work is aimed at reviewing the main neurobehavioral effects of both manipulations, with the final purpose of comparing them and trying to find out to what extent the effects of both treatments may share (or not) possible neural mechanisms.

Molecular genetic approaches to investigate individual variations in behavioral and neuroendocrine stress responses

A large response range can be observed in both behavioral and neuroendocrine responses to environmental challenges. This variation can arise from central mechanisms such as those involved in the shaping of general response tendencies (temperaments) or involves only one or the other output system (behavioral vs. endocrine response). The participation of genetic factors in this variability is demonstrated by family and twin studies in humans, the comparison of inbred strains and selection experiments in animals. Those inbred strains diverging for specific traits of stress reactivity are invaluable tools for the study of the molecular bases of this genetic variability. Until recently, it was only possible to study biological differences between contrasting strains, such as neurotransmitter pathways in the brain or hormone receptor properties, in order to suggest structural differences in candidate genes. The increase of the power of molecular biology tools allows the systematic screening of significant genes for the search of molecular variants. More recently, it was possible to search for genes without any preliminary functional hypothesis (mRNA differential expression, nucleic acid arrays, QTL search). The approach known as quantitative trait loci (QTL) analysis is based on the association between polymorphic anonymous markers and the phenotypical value of the trait under study in a segregating population (such as F2 or backcross). It allows the location of chromosomal regions involved in trait variability and ultimately the identification of the mutated gene(s). Therefore, in a first step, those studies skip the 'black box' of intermediate mechanisms, but the knowledge of the gene(s) responsible for trait variability will point out to the pathway responsible for the phenotypical differences. Since variations in stress-related responses may be related to numerous pathological conditions such as behavioral and mood disorders, drug abuse, cardiovascular diseases or obesity, and production traits in farm animals, these studies can be expected to bring significant knowledge for new therapeutic approaches in humans and improved efficiency of selection in farm animals.

Harnessing the mouse to unravel the genetics of human disease

Complex traits, i.e. those with multiple genetic and environmental determinants, represent the greatest challenge for genetic analysis, largely due to the difficulty of isolating the effects of any one gene amid the noise of other genetic and environmental influences. Methods exist for detecting and mapping the Quantitative Trait Loci (QTLs) that influence complex traits. However, once mapped, gene identification commonly involves reduction of focus to single candidate genes or isolated chromosomal regions. To reach the next level in unraveling the genetics of human disease will require moving beyond the focus on one gene at a time, to explorations of pleiotropism, epistasis and environment-dependency of genetic effects. Genetic interactions and unique environmental features must be as carefully scrutinized as are single gene effects. No one genetic approach is likely to possess all the necessary features for comprehensive analysis of a complex disease. Rather, the entire arsenal of behavioral genomic and other approaches will be needed, such as random mutagenesis, QTL analyses, transgenic and knockout models, viral mediated gene transfer, pharmacological analyses, gene expression assays, antisense approaches and importantly, revitalization of classical genetic methods. In our view, classical breeding designs are currently underutilized, and will shorten the distance to the target of understanding the complex genetic and environmental interactions associated with disease. We assert that unique combinations of classical approaches with current behavioral and molecular genomic approaches will more rapidly advance the field.

A Mouse is Not Just a Mouse

In this paper we describe the existence and consequences of subspecific and individual variation in the genetic make-up of house mice. The purpose is to illustrate forms of variation that are often neglected in discussions about animal care and experimental design. Towards this end, different inbred mouse strains as well as genetically selected mouse lines are compared in relation to their ecological origin. Firstly, the behaviour of BALB/c, C57BL/6J and CBA mice is described in relation to different habitats. Furthermore, their aggression is compared, as measured by two paradigms. It appears that some inbred lines (eg BALB/c and C57BL/6J) clearly show behaviour that reflects the functional adaptation to the natural habitats in which their ancestors lived. Other strains (eg CBA) show a lack of such behavioural adaptation and their phenotypes appear to be very unstable over time. Secondly, two fundamentally different characters, both present in populations of wild house mice and under genetic control, are described: on the one hand, active copers are characterized by aggressive behaviour; on the other hand, passive copers are reluctant to attack. The active, aggressive animals (manipulators) are well adapted to an invariant environment like their own territory, whereas the passive, non-aggressive copers (adjustors) are well adapted to a changing environment, eg when roaming. We discuss to what extent these coping styles are present in laboratory strains of mice. The major conclusion with regard to both phenomena is that individual and subspecific variation may have significant implications for experimental design and the welfare of the experimental animals.

Effects of emotional reactivity on inhibitory avoidance in the elevated T-maze

The possibility of the presence of inter-individual emotional differences and the memory performance of rats was examined in the elevated T-maze. Two kinds of aversively motivated behaviors, inhibitory avoidance and escape learning, were measured. Based on the number of trials to achieve a learning criterion, rats were divided into two subgroups with either low or high avoidance reactivity (LAR or HAR, respectively). Retention test avoidance latencies showed that HAR animals had better avoidance memory (Mann-Whitney rank sum test, P = 0.0035). No such differences were found for the escape component of this test. These data suggest that individual emotional differences affect inhibitory avoidance performance, which may help to explain the dispersion of the data observed in other studies using this paradigm.

Inbred Roman high- and low-avoidance rats: differences in anxiety, novelty-seeking, and shuttlebox behaviors

In the present study, male inbred animals (from the 10th generation of an inbreeding program that has been carried out in parallel to that of the outbred Roman high- and low-avoidance rat lines), were compared for emotionality in different testing situations, exploratory behavior in the holeboard and two-way, active-avoidance acquisition. Compared to the inbred Roman high-avoidance (RHA-I/Verh) rats, inbred Roman low-avoidance (RLA-I-Verh) rats showed higher emotionality in the open field (reduced distance travelled and number of rearings, and increased self-grooming behavior), in the elevated plus-maze test (increased number of total and open-arm entries, reduced distance travelled in the open arms, and increased self-grooming behavior), and during the habituation period in the shuttle box (decreased number of crossings, increased self-grooming behavior and defecations). Results from the hyponeophagia test were not conclusive, probably due to the test-dependent hyperactivity shown by RHA-I/Verh rats. In the holeboard apparatus, RHA-I/Verh rats explored more than RLA-I/Verh rats, especially when novel objects were located beneath the holes. Finally, RHA-I/Verh animals rapidly acquired active, two-way (shuttlebox) avoidance, whereas RLA-I/Verh animals required four 50-trial sessions to achieve an assymptotic level of 30-40% avoidance. Thus, the behavioral patterns of the Roman inbred strains were very similar to those previously reported for the RHA/Verh outbred lines. Differences in locomotor activity, exploratory, and self-grooming behavior were actually greater between the inbred strains than between the outbred lines. Differences in defecation, however, although still significant, were not so pronounced as those noted previously at this laboratory with the outbred lines.

Endocrine and behavioral traits in low-avoidance Sprague-Dawley rats

In the present series of experiments, we have examined the endocrine profile of two stable colonies of Sprague-Dawley rats, here labeled Stock A, and Stock B, differing markedly in their ability to acquire a conditioned avoidance response. On separate occasions, the animals were subjected to five daily sessions (approximately 20 trials per 15 min session) of conditioned avoidance training, measurements of startle reactivity to an auditory stimulation and open-field spontaneous locomotor activity observations. The experiments were concluded by taking blood samples for later analysis of plasma glucose and plasma levels of the following hormones: insulin, gastrin, CCK, glucagon, somatostatin, oxytocin and corticosterone. The low-performing Stock B animals were characterized by [1] being more reactive to sensory stimulation: higher startle amplitude and shorter startle latency; [2] having higher plasma insulin and corticosterone levels, whereas plasma gastrin and oxytocin were significantly lowered and a strong tendency for a decrease also in plasma CCK. There were no differences in spontaneous locomotor activity between the two substrains. Taking total variability in avoidance performance into account, there was a statistically significant positive correlation between plasma oxytocin, as well as gastrin, levels and avoidance performance. The evidence obtained here, and in other laboratories, suggests that the Stock B animals display hormonal changes indicative of a submissive-defensive reaction pattern. Thus, the avoidance acquisition deficits displayed by the present Sprague-Dawley stocks A and B, are in all probability caused by emotional reactions when challenged with external stimuli requiring active responding.

Behavioural profiles of two Wistar rat lines selectively bred for high or low anxiety-related behaviour

Over the past years, two breeding lines, derived originally from outbred Wistar rats, have been established that differ markedly and consistently in their anxiety-related behaviour in the elevated plus-maze. At the age of ten weeks, rats were tested once on the elevated plus-maze and the males and females displaying the most anxious and the least anxious behaviour were sib-mated to start a new generation of the high anxiety-related behaviour (HAB) and the low anxiety-related behaviour (LAB) lines, respectively. The resulting difference in emotionality between these two lines was also evident in an open field test and correlated with differences in the forced swim test. In the open field, the HAB rats tended to be less active and explored the central zone of the open field much less than the LAB animals. In the forced swim test, HAB rats started floating earlier, spent significantly more time in this immobile posture and struggled less than LAB rats. However, in an olfactory-cued social discrimination task there was no difference between male and female animals from either line. The overall performance in these various behavioural tests suggests that selective breeding has resulted in rat lines not only differing markedly in their innate anxiety-related behaviour in the plus-maze, but also in other stress-related behavioural performances, suggesting a close link between the emotional evaluation of a novel and stressful situation and an individual's coping strategy.

Comparative study of behavioral development between high and low shuttlebox avoidance rats

Previously, we reported that high- and low-avoidance animals (HAA and LAA, respectively), selectively bred for different avoidance response rates in a shuttlebox avoidance test, showed additional behavioral differences in wheel cage activity and in water maze performance after weaning. In the present study, physical and behavioral development were examined in HAA and LAA during the preweaning period. As compared to HAA, LAA offspring showed lower body weight, delayed eye opening, poorer performance in pivoting and negative geotaxis, and increased open-field activity. A fostering study indicated that these differences observed in eye opening, pivoting, negative geotaxis, open-field activity, swimming speed, shuttlebox avoidance and wheel cage activity were independent of maternal care. Only the pup weight was strongly dependent on the maternal line. These results indicate that behavioral differences between HAA and LAA observed in the pre- and postweaning periods may be linked to the avoidance genotype, but the difference in pup weight may be caused by maternal care.

Dexamethasone suppression of the effects of cocaine on adrenocortical secretion in Lewis and Fischer rats

There is evidence to suggest that cocaine acts centrally to enhance adrenocortical secretory activity and this effect may be associated with the reinforcing properties of this drug. Lewis (LEW) and Fischer (F344) rats are inbred strains which differ in their responses to the reinforcing effects of cocaine. Previous findings from this laboratory have demonstrated differences in the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical (HPA) responses to cocaine between these strains. To determine whether strain differences in glucocorticoid responsiveness play a role in the differential effects of cocaine on plasma corticosterone (CS) secretion in these strains, experiments were designed to suppress the HPA response to cocaine in these two rat strains. HPA activity was attenuated by central administration of the glucocorticoid agonist dexamethasone (DEX) using osmotic minipumps. A constant infusion of artificial cerebrospinal fluid or DEX (50, 100 or 500 ng/h) was delivered into the lateral ventricle of LEW and F344 rats. Four days later, the rats were challenged with cocaine HCl (0, 20 and 40 mg/kg, i.p.), and the plasma CS response 15 min later was quantified. Cocaine-induced alterations in circulating plasma CS were reduced in a dose-related manner by centrally administered DEX in both strains. Significant strain differences in the effects of DEX on the plasma CS response to cocaine were observed, suggesting that LEW rats were more sensitive to DEX suppression of HPA activity than F344 rats. DEX also produced dose-related effects on body weight in both strains and decreased adrenal weight at the highest dose in F344 rats. Blood collected on the final day of the experiment demonstrated that central infusions of DEX decreased plasma ACTH concentrations in both strains compared to control rats. These studies indicate that central administration of DEX produces a feedback inhibition of cocaine-induced glucocorticoid release and that LEW rats are more sensitive to DEX suppression than F344 rats.

The effects of extended training and acute administration of an anxiolytic on avoidance learning and intertrial responding in the Syracuse strains of rats

Male and female animals of the SHA/Bru and SLA/Bru strains of rats were given extended two-way avoidance training in the shuttle box at the rate of 30 trials per day for 11 days. SLA/Bru animals increased their avoidance responses (AVRs) from approximately 10 to roughly 25%, whereas animals of the SHA/Bru strain remained unchanged at approximately 100% AVRs. SHA/Bru animals made a number of intertrial responses (ITRs) early in the experiment; these declined after about 3 days to the low level made by SLA/Bru animals. Chlordiazepoxide (CDP) had no effect on AVRs in animals of either strain, and had no effect on ITRs made by animals of the SHA/Bru strain, but increased ITRs, in a dose-dependent way, in animals of the SLA/Bru strain. These results are interpreted in terms of the well-established genetic difference in emotional reactivity between animals of the two strains and in terms of genetically determined differences in sensitivity to anxiolytic drugs such as CDP.

Behavioral stress response of genetically selected aggressive and nonaggressive wild house mice in the shock-probe/defensive burying test

Genetically selected aggressive and nonaggressive male wild house mice were tested in the shock-probe/defensive burying test: Five distinct behaviors (burying, immobility, rearing, grooming, and exploration) were recorded in two environmental situations: fresh and home cage sawdust. Nonaggressive animals, characterized by a Long Attack Latency (LAL), showed more immobility in both test situations than animals having Short Attack Latencies (SAL), whereas SAL males displayed more defensive burying than LAL ones when tested with fresh sawdust. Testing with home cage sawdust, however, resulted in the same duration of defensive burying in SAL and LAL. These results support earlier findings about the existence of two heritable, fundamentally different strategies to cope with aversive situations. Aggressive (SAL) animal react actively to environmental challenges, whereas nonaggressive animals react actively or passively, depending on the characteristics of the stressful environment. These mouse lines, selected for attack latency, i.e., aggression, may, therefore, be important tools to unravel the genetic architecture underlying the physiological and neuronal mechanisms of behavioral strategies towards stressful events.

Evaluating genetic models of cognitive evolution and behaviour

Cognitive evolution can be studied at several different levels, ranging from complex societies of interdependent persons to the DNA molecules coding for enzymes that synthesize neurotransmitter molecules. Genetic models of cognitive evolution can be fairly evaluated only if they involve one or two genetic loci, maybe three loci if a massive investment of resources is made. If a simple genetic model is seriously proposed, it ought to be tested by genetic linkage analysis so that future theorizing can be guided and constrained by facts. For more complex behavioural characteristics based on large numbers of genes and intricate interrelations with the environment, genetic analysis and genetic theories are not likely to yield conclusive results. Instead, studying individual differences in the brain and neural correlates of cognitive processes will likely provide more rapid progress toward a deeper understanding of evolution.

Genetic analysis of the relationships between behavioral and neuroendocrine traits in Roman High and Low Avoidance rat lines

In order to determine whether the coselection observed between the selection trait (active avoidance behavior) of the Roman High Avoidance (RHA) and Roman Low Avoidance (RLA) rat lines and their neuroendocrine characteristics were genetically determined, we analyzed, in nonsegregating (RHA, RLA, and F1) and segregating (F2 and the two backcrosses) crosses, the inheritance pattern and the phenotypic correlations among behavioral (shuttle-box behavior), physiological (body, adrenal, and thymus weights), and neuroendocrine (corticosterone and prolactin reactivity, catecholamine enzyme activities) variables. Physiological characteristics and enzyme activities have a crucial role in sex dissociation. Avoidance behavior and prolactin reactivity to novel environment remained associated in segregating crosses despite gene rearrangement. They represented the most important variables to differentiate the Roman lines, perhaps sharing a common regulatory mechanism under genetic control.

Defective habituation to nociceptive stimulation in alcohol-avoiding ANA rats

Brain opioidergic mechanisms participate in the regulation of motivational and ingestive behaviours. Since alcohol is believed to activate endogenous opioid systems and to produce opioid-mediated antinociception, the present experiments were performed to find out if alcohol-induced antinociception differs between the alcohol-preferring AA and alcohol-avoiding ANA rat lines. Alcohol doses relevant to the voluntary alcohol intake by the AA rats (0.5-1.0 g/kg, intraperitoneally) failed to alter tail-flick (TF) latency in a 55 degrees C water bath by either rat line. However, repeated measurement of TF latency, even without any alcohol treatment, prolonged tail-flick latencies in AA but not in ANA rats. Prolongation of TF latency was also seen in non-selected Wistar rats, indicating that the ANA rats respond abnormally in this test. The antinociceptive effects of swimming-induced stress (3 min at 15 degrees C) and those of cumulative morphine administration (0.5-16.0 mg/kg, subcutaneously) were similar in both rat lines. Using higher, motor-impairing alcohol doses with repeated baseline TF determinations, it was observed that a dose of 1.5 g/kg induced slight antinociception only in the AA rats, while 2.0 g/kg produced similar effects in both rat lines. It is thus concluded that the alcohol-preferring AA rats do not show any enhanced alcohol-induced antinociception at relevant alcohol doses. However, the alcohol-avoiding ANA rats appear to have a defective ability to habituate to repeated sensory stimuli, which could contribute to their alcohol avoidance by preventing the development of tolerance to aversive effects of alcohol.

Counterevidence from psychopharmacology, psychopathology, and psychobiology

Davey's discussion of phobias is criticized because of the lack of distinctions between the various classes of phobias. Psychopharmacological evidence indicates differing pathophysiologies. Clinical psychopharmacological distinctions are not congruent with either a strict phylogenetic preparedness model or with cognitive biases. Davey's critique of the laboratory bred animal studies seems far fetched. His hypothesis concerning the importance of historical significance is clearly ad hoc rather than based on comparative data.

Heredity × environment or developmental interactions?

This commentary acknowledges the importance of Davey's biocognitive approach to the uneven distribution of fears on the basis of its contribution to a human model for understanding fear. An integrated heredity-environment and developmental transactional approach based on field/system theory is recommended in place of the mechanistic heredity × environment interactionism that Davey uses to explain behavioral ontogeny.

Nonlinear experiential influences on the development of fear reactions

Failure to find an obvious or linear relationship between a developmental experiential factor and a developmental outcome often leads investigators to posit concepts such as “biological preparedness” and “evolved predispositions” that allude to hypothetical geneticmechanisms that may not exist. However, experiential nonlinearities alone may explain the development of certain instinctive behaviors, as shown by studies on alarm call responsivity in mallard ducklings.

Rule-governed and contingency-governed fears

Behavioral research suggests that rule-governed behavior should be less sensitive to environmental changes and thus more resistant to extinction (disconfirmation) than contingency-governed behavior. The opposite is implied in Davey's discussion of ontogenetic and phylogenetic contributions to fear development. The generality of the behavioral findings and their apparent inconsistency with the present article should be further explored with more sensitive research paradigms.

The generalized expectancy bias: An explanatory enigma

According to Davey, generalized expectancy biases cause fearrelevant behavior and may complement Seligman's biological preparedness model. Expectancy biases do not explain the preparedness phenomenon, because such cognitive (or covert behavioral) processes are themselves controlled by social and other environmentally based contingencies. Davey's own examination of the importance of cross-cultural factors can show the relationship between FR stimuli and behavior without needing cognitive agency to explain the behavioral phenomenon.

Enhanced processing of threatening stimuli: The case of face recognition

Because of their evolutionary importance, threat-detection mechanisms are likely to exist at a variety of levels. A recent study of face recognition suggests that novel stimuli receive enhanced processing when presented as fear-related. This suggests the existence of a complex, context-dependent threat-detection mechanism that can adaptively respond to spatiotemporally varying and unique environmental features.

Why are phobias irrational?

We endorse Davey's view that expectancy processes are intimately involved in fear reactions, but question his model on three grounds. First, the mechanism for generating expectancy bias to both ontogenetic and phylogenetic stimuli is not spelled out. Second, the selective association component is unnecessary. Third, the model fails to provide a clear explanation for the irrationality of phobic reactions.

Biologically primed acquisition of aversions and association of expected stimulus pairs: Two different forms of learning

The present commentary emphasizes that the acquisition of fear always involves complex changes in several quasi-independent response systems. Stimulus-specific electrodermal response differentiation as well as the bias to overestimate the belongingness of certain stimulus pairs mainly indicates cognitive processes of selective orienting and attention. Emotion, however, also involves the activation of subcortical motivational circuits. Why certain stimuli acquire rapid access to these basic motivational systems is not explained by the expectancy bias model.

Associative learning: Stimulus arrangement and response consistency

Studies on associative learning in normals and patients need appropriate dependent measures which are sensitive enough to reflect stimulus-specific responses and also consider the context in which the conditioning takes place. Patient's fear responses, once acquired, seem to be maintained by specific cognitive biases such as individual belief systems and a tendency to stay consistent with their previous judgments.

What is the critical evidence favoring expectancy bias theory, and where is it?

Davey has failed to clarify the critical evidence that could corroborate the expectancy bias hypothesis and refute preparedness theory. Such a clarification is necessary because each theory could potentially allow for multiple distal and proximal influences on selective associations. Expectancies are not the only proximal mediators. Our recent findings indicate that affective response matching may be an additional factor promoting such associations.

A comparison between house mouse lines selected for attack latency or nest-building: evidence for a genetic basis of alternative behavioral strategies

House mouse lines bidirectionally selected for either nest-building behavior or attack latency were tested for both attack latency and nest-building behavior under identical conditions. Male mice selected for high nest-building behavior had shorter attack latencies, i.e., were more aggressive, than those selected for low nest-building behavior and their randomly bred control lines. Conversely, male wild house mice selected for short attack latency showed more nest-building behavior than those selected for long attack latency when tested at 110 days of age. These findings imply a common genetic basis for control of aggression and nesting and support earlier proposals as to how animals may exhibit fundamentally different responses to environmental challenges, either reacting actively to aversive situations (aggressive and high-nesting animals: active copers) or adopting a passive strategy (nonaggressive and low-nesting animals: passive copers).

Evaluating activity and emotional reactivity in a hexagonal tunnel maze: correlational and factorial analysis from a study with the Roman/Verh rat lines

Two hundred forty 30-day-old Roman high- and low-avoidance (RHA/Verh and RLA/Verh) rats (divided equally by line and gender) which had received several peri- and/or postnatal treatments, forming two factorial [line x sex x treatment(s)] experimental designs, were tested in a hexagonal tunnel maze including a brightly illuminated central arena. The present study reports the results of correlational and factorial (principal-components) analyses performed on the data from those two experimental constituencies. The purpose of the study was to evaluate the validity of the hexagonal tunnel maze for testing emotionality, and therefore, the following measures were included in the analysis: entries into the central illuminated arena, total activity during testing, defecation during testing, and defecation during handling and weighing after testing. An overall pattern of negative correlations (or opposite loadings in the principal-components analyses) between defecation (especially during maze testing) and entries into the illuminated center and activity was found, thus giving support to the validity of entries into the illuminated center as being indicative of emotional reactivity.

Maturation of the behavioral and neuroendocrine differences between the Roman rat lines

The behavioral and/or neuroendocrine reactivity to psychological (open-field exposure) and physiological (CRF challenge) stimulations, as well as adrenal tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) and phenylethanolamine N-methyl transferase (PNMT) activities were measured, at different ages, in the Roman high avoidance (RHA) and Roman low avoidance (RLA) rat lines that have been genetically selected on the basis of their divergent active avoidance behavior. The highest locomotor activity in the open field, associated to blunted prolactin and renin reactivity to an emotional stress and lower specific TH and PNMT activities, characterized the RHA rats of all ages. HPA axis reactivity to psychological and/or physiological stimulations was identical in young animals (14 weeks old) of the two lines. Nevertheless, it displayed with age maturation processes, since the amplitude of postopen-field secretion peak for ACTH was larger in RLA rats from 20 weeks on, the response to CRF being not increased until 42 weeks. These maturation processes could result from genetically influenced changes related to environmental stimulations. Therefore, the Roman lines may be an excellent model to study the interactions between the genetic and developmental factors controlling the coupling between both behavioral and neuroendocrine functions.