Influence of stressor predictability and behavioral control on lymphocyte reactivity, antibody responses and neuroendocrine activation in rats

Early experience unpredictability in child development as a model for understanding the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic: A translational neuroscience perspective

Extensive evidence links adverse experiences during childhood to a wide range of negative consequences in biological, socioemotional, and cognitive development. Unpredictability is a core element underlying most forms of early adversity; it has been a focus of developmental research for many years and has been receiving increasing attention recently. In this article, we propose a conceptual model to describe how unpredictable and adverse early experiences affect children's neurobiological, behavioral, and psychological development in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. We first highlight the critical role of unpredictability in child development by reviewing existing conceptual models of early adversity as they relate to subsequent development across the lifespan. Then, we employ a translational neuroscience framework to summarize the current animal- and human-based evidence on the neurobiological alterations induced by early experience unpredictability. We further argue that the COVID-19 pandemic serves as a global "natural experiment" that provides rare insight to the investigation of the negative developmental consequences of widespread, clustered, and unpredictable adverse events among children. We discuss how the pandemic helps advance the science of unpredictable early adverse experiences. As unpredictability research continues to grow, we highlight several directions for future studies and implications for policymaking and intervention practices.

Early life stress and neural development: Implications for understanding the developmental effects of COVID-19

Chronic and/or extreme stress in childhood, often referred to as early life stress, is associated with a wide range of long-term effects on development. Given this, the COVID-19 pandemic has led to concern about how stress due to the pandemic will affect children's development and mental health. Although early life stress has been linked to altered functioning of a number of neural and biological systems, there is a wide range of variability in children's outcomes. The mechanisms that influence these individual differences are still not well understood. In the past, studies of stress in childhood focused on the type of events that children encountered in their lives. We conducted a review of the literature to formulate a new perspective on the effects of early life stress on development. This new, topological model, may increase understanding of the potential effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on children's development. This model is oriented on children's perceptions of their environment and their social relationships, rather than specific events. These factors influence central and peripheral nervous system development, changing how children interpret, adapt, and respond to potentially stressful events, with implications for children's mental and physical health outcomes.

Rethinking Concepts and Categories for Understanding the Neurodevelopmental Effects of Childhood Adversity

Discovering the processes through which early adverse experiences affect children's nervous-system development, health, and behavior is critically important for developing effective interventions. However, advances in our understanding of these processes have been constrained by conceptualizations that rely on categories of adversity that are overlapping, have vague boundaries, and lack consistent biological evidence. Here, we discuss central problems in understanding the link between early-life adversity and children's brain development. We conclude by suggesting alternative formulations that hold promise for advancing knowledge about the neurobiological mechanisms through which adversity affects human development.

Early life stress and development: potential mechanisms for adverse outcomes

BACKGROUND

Chronic and/or extreme stress in early life, often referred to as early adversity, childhood trauma, or early life stress, has been associated with a wide range of adverse effects on development. However, while early life stress has been linked to negative effects on a number of neural systems, the specific mechanisms through which early life stress influences development and individual differences in children's outcomes are still not well understood.

MAIN TEXT

The current paper reviews the existing literature on the neurobiological effects of early life stress and their ties to children's psychological and behavioral development.

CONCLUSIONS

Early life stress has persistent and pervasive effects on prefrontal-hypothalamic-amygdala and dopaminergic circuits that are at least partially mediated by alterations in hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis function. However, to date, this research has primarily utilized methods of assessment that focus solely on children's event exposures. Incorporating assessment of factors that influence children's interpretation of stressors, along with stressful events, has the potential to provide further insight into the mechanisms contributing to individual differences in neurodevelopmental effects of early life stress. This can aid in further elucidating specific mechanisms through which these neurobiological changes influence development and contribute to risk for psychopathology and health disorders.

Cognitive appraisal in fish: stressor predictability modulates the physiological and neurobehavioural stress response in sea bass

The role of cognitive factors in triggering the stress response is well established in humans and mammals (aka cognitive appraisal theory) but very seldom studied in other vertebrate taxa. Predictability is a key factor of the cognitive evaluation of stimuli. In this study, we tested the effects of stressor predictability on behavioral, physiological and neuromolecular responses in the European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax). Groups of four fish were exposed to a predictable (signalled) or unpredictable (unsignalled) stressor. Stressor predictability elicited a lower behavioural response and reduced cortisol levels. Using the expression of immediate early genes (c-fos, egr-1, bdnf and npas4) as markers of neuronal activity, we monitored the activity of three sea bass brain regions known to be implicated in stressor appraisal: the dorsomedian telencephalon, Dm (putative homologue of the pallial amygdala); and the dorsal (Dld) and ventral (Dlv) subareas of the dorsolateral telencephalon (putative homologue of the hippocampus). The activity of both the Dm and Dlv significantly responded to stressor predictability, suggesting an evolutionarily conserved role of these two brain regions in information processing related to stressor appraisal. These results indicate that stressor predictability plays a key role in the activation of the stress response in a teleost fish, hence highlighting the role of cognitive processes in fish stress.

Controllability affects endocrine response of adolescent male rats to stress as well as impulsivity and behavioral flexibility during adulthood

Exposure to stress during adolescence exerts a long-term impact on behavior and might contribute to the development of several neuropsychiatric disorders. In adults, control over stress has been found to protect from the negative consequences of stress, but the influence of controllability at early ages has not been extensively studied. Here, we evaluated in a rodent model the effects of repeated exposure in adolescent male rats to controllable versus uncontrollable foot-shock stress (CST or UST, respectively). Rats were assigned to three groups: non-stress (stress-naïve), CST (exposed to 8 sessions of a two-way shuttle active avoidance task over a period of 22 days) and UST (receiving the same amount of shocks as CST, regardless of their actual behavior). During adulthood, different cohorts were tested in several tasks evaluating inhibitory control and cognitive flexibility: 5-choice serial reaction time, delay-discounting, gambling test and probabilistic reversal learning. Results showed that the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal response to the first shock session was similar in CST and UST animals, but the response to the 8^th session was lower in CST animals. In adulthood, the UST animals presented impaired motor (but not cognitive) impulsivity and more perseverative behavior. The behavioral effects of UST were associated with increased number of D2 dopamine receptors in dorsomedial striatum, but not in other striatal regions. In summary, UST exposure during adolescence induced long-term impairments in impulsivity and compulsivity, whereas CST had only minor effects. These data support a critical role of stress uncontrollability on the long-lasting consequences of stress, as a risk factor for mental illnesses.

Behavior and physiology of two different sow breeds in a farrowing environment during late 35-day lactation

To improve the overall welfare levels of sows and to reduce stress levels at late 35-day lactation, we selected targeted behavioral indicators that might be associated with stress. Therefore, we monitored and evaluated the adaptive capability of two different breeds of sows to the farrowing environment. In this study, Damin sows (Large White × Min pig sows, n = 20) and Large White sows (n = 20) were farrowed in individual pens. Saliva was collected and tested for cortisol density at –15 min, and then at +15, 30, 60, 90, 120, 180 and 240 min after an adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) stimulation test conducted at 20, 27 and 34 d post-partum. The postures, including ventral and lateral recumbency to other postures, defecating, urinating, sham-chewing and bar-biting behavior, were observed by video from 07:00 to 09:00 and from 13:00 to 15:00 on the 7th day of each week from the 3rd to the 5th week post-parturition. In addition, the concentrations of salivary interleukin (IL)-6, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α and secretory immunoglobulin (SIgA) were assayed after the observed behaviors. The results showed no significant difference between Damin sows and Large White sows in terms of behaviors at the 3rd week. Additionally, there were no significant differences between Damin and Large White sows in terms of the behaviors of ventral recumbency and bar-biting with the exception of lateral recumbency to other postures, sham-chewing, defecation and urination in the fifth week. Meanwhlie, there was significant difference between two breeds in term of ventral recumbency at the 4th week. The result of the ACTH test showed a significant difference between the Damin and Large White sows by the 27th and 34th days postpartum (P<0.01). In addition, the serological concentrations of IL-6 and TNF-α were not significantly different between the two breeds at the 3rd week postpartum. However, these indicators were significantly different at the 5th week postpartum (P = 0.000, and P = 0.003, respectively). The SIgA concentrations in saliva were significantly different between breeds at the 3rd week postpartum (P<0.01). In conclusion, both breeds of sows maybe in a state of stress after the 4th week postpartum. However, the Damin sows may be better than the Large White sows in terms of adapting to this farrowing environment.

Predictable chronic mild stress in adolescence increases resilience in adulthood

Stress in adolescence has been widely demonstrated to have a lasting impact in humans and animal models. Developmental risk and protective factors play an important role in the responses to stress in adulthood. Mild-to-moderate stress in adolescence may resist the negative impacts of adverse events in adulthood. However, little research on resilience has been conducted. In this study, we used a predictable chronic mild stress (PCMS) procedure (5 min of daily restraint stress for 28 days) in adolescent rats (postnatal days (PNDs) 28-55) to test the resilience effect of PCMS on depressive-like behavior in the sucrose preference test and forced swim test and anxiety-like behavior in the novelty-suppressed feeding test and elevated plus maze in adulthood. We also investigated the role of mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) signaling in the brain during the PCMS procedure in adolescence. Moreover, we investigated the effect of PCMS in adolescence on subsequent responses to chronic unpredictable stress (CUS; PNDs 63-83) in adulthood. The results demonstrated that PCMS during adolescence produced antidepressant- and anxiolytic-like effects and increased mTOR signaling activity in the prefrontal cortex in early adulthood. Either systemic administration or intra-PFC infusion of the mTOR inhibitor rapamycin completely blocked the behavioral effects produced by PCMS in adolescence. PCMS during adolescence resisted depressive- and anxiety-like behavior caused by CUS in adulthood. These findings indicate that PCMS in adolescence can contribute to resilience against depression and anxiety caused by stress in adulthood.

An unexpected increase in restraint duration alters the expression of stress response habituation

While habituation develops to a repeated psychological stressor, manipulating certain parameters of the stress challenge experience may lead to dishabituation of the stress response. In this experiment, we investigated whether the behavioral, endocrine, and neural responses (c-fos mRNA immediate early gene expression) to a psychological stressor (restraint) differ when the duration of the stressor given on the test day violates expectations based on prior stress experience. Rats experienced 10 min of daily restraint on Days 1-4 followed by a challenge with either the same duration (10 min) or a longer duration (30 min) of restraint on Day 5. Rats' behavior was video recorded during the Day 5 restraint episode, and trunk blood and brain tissue were collected 30 min following restraint onset. Struggling behavior was manually scored as active attempts to escape the restraint device. Rats who experienced the same duration of repeated restraint showed a significant decrease of plasma corticosterone (CORT) compared to the 10 min acute restraint group (habituation). In addition, these rats showed decreased active struggling over repeated restraint trials. Conversely, the rats showed an increased CORT response (dishabituation) when they experienced a longer duration of restraint on Day 5 than they had previously. These rats showed a habituated behavioral response during the first 10 min of restraint, however struggling behavior increased once the duration of restraint exceeded the expected duration (with a peak at 12 min). This peak in struggling behavior did not occur during 30 min acute restraint, indicating that the effect was related to the memory of previous restraint experience and not due to a longer duration of restraint. In contrast, these animals showed habituated c-fos mRNA expression in the paraventricular nucleus (PVN), lateral septum (LS), and medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) in response to the increased stressor duration. Thus, there was a dissociation between c-fos mRNA expression in key stress responsive brain regions and the behavioral and endocrine response to increased stressor duration. This dissociation may have been due to a greater lag time for c-fos mRNA responses to reflect the impact of a dishabituation response. In conclusion, habituation of the endocrine and behavioral stress response occurred when the duration of the stressor matches the previous experience, while dishabituation of the stress response was triggered (with remarkable temporal precision) by an unexpected increase in stress duration.

Active behavioral coping alters the behavioral but not the endocrine response to stress

Exposure to traumatic stressors typically causes lasting changes in emotionality and behavior. However, coping strategies have been shown to prevent and alleviate many stress consequences and the biological mechanisms that underlie coping are of great interest. Whereas the laboratory stressor inescapable tail-shock induces anxiety-like behaviors, here we demonstrate that permitting a rat to chew on a wooden dowel during administration of tail-shock prevented the development of anxiety like behaviors in the open field and juvenile social exploration tests. Uncontrollable stressors increase corticosterone and decrease thyroid hormone, and we hypothesized that coping would blunt these changes. While tail-shock did produce these effects, active coping did not alter hormone levels. The dissociation between behavioral resilience and circulating hormones is discussed with regard to the utility of these molecules as biomarkers for psychiatric disease.

What can we know from pituitary-adrenal hormones about the nature and consequences of exposure to emotional stressors?

Exposure to stress induces profound physiological and behavioral changes in the organisms and some of these changes may be important regarding stress-induced pathologies and animal models of psychiatric diseases. Consequences of stress are dependent on the duration of exposure to stressors (acute, chronic), but also of certain characteristics such as intensity, controllability, and predictability. If some biological variables were able to reflect these characteristics, they could be used to predict negative consequences of stress. Among the myriad of physiological changes caused by stress, only a restricted number of variables appears to reflect the intensity of the situation, mainly plasma levels of ACTH and adrenaline. Peripheral hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) hormones (ACTH and corticosterone) are also able to reflect fear conditioning. In contrast, the activation of the HPA axis is not consistently related to anxiety as evaluated by classical tests such as the elevated plus-maze. Similarly, there is no consistent evidence about the sensitivity of the HPA axis to psychological variables such as controllability and predictability, despite the fact that: (a) lack of control over aversive stimuli can induce behavioral alterations not seen in animals which exert control, and (b) animals showed clear preference for predictable versus unpredictable stressful situations. New studies are needed to re-evaluate the relationship between the HPA axis and psychological stress characteristics using ACTH instead of corticosterone and taking advantages of our current knowledge about the regulation of this important stress system.

Coping in an intermittent swim stress paradigm compromises natural killer cell activity in rats

The effects of intermittent swim stress and stressor controllability on natural killer cell activity (NKCA) was examined. Significant decreases in splenic NKCA were observed immediately post-stress, but only when the stress was controllable. Although decreased NKCA was also observed in yoked rats subjected to the same stressor, it failed to attain statistical significance. Previous results suggest these effects are not due to corticosterone. The results suggest a cost of coping on the acute, in vitro immune measure of NKCA.

Effects of anxiety on TNF-alpha levels during psychological stress

OBJECTIVES

Psychological stress can influence the immune system, which may result in stress-related illnesses. In this study, we investigated the effect of psychological stress and the coping skill on plasma cytokine levels.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred eighty-three students, at different stages of an academic year, participated in this study. Plasma tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha), interleukin (IL)-2 soluble receptor alpha, and IL-4 were measured and examined in relation to the measures of anxiety [State Anxiety Inventory (SAI)] and Bell Adjustment Inventory (BAI) score.

RESULTS

SAI scores were significantly higher in both midterm students (MTS) and examination-taking students (ETS), compared with the freshly admitted students (FAS). In addition, TNF-alpha levels were significantly different between the high- and the low-anxiety groups of ETS but not in MTS or FAS. The correlation between SAI scores and the BAI emotional scores was highest in the ETS group.

CONCLUSIONS

TNF-alpha level was significantly lower in the ETS group with high anxiety scores, and it is situation specific.

Social defeat increases food intake, body mass, and adiposity in Syrian hamsters

Overeating and increases in body and fat mass are the most common responses to day-to-day stress in humans, whereas stressed laboratory rats and mice respond oppositely. Group housing of Syrian hamsters increases body mass, adiposity, and food intake, perhaps due to social confrontation-induced stress. In experiment 1 we asked, Does repeated social defeat increase food intake, body mass, and white adipose tissue (WAT) mass in Syrian hamsters? Male hamsters subjected to the resident-intruder social interaction model and defeated intermittently 15 times over 34 days for 7-min sessions significantly increased their food intake, body mass, and most WAT masses compared with nondefeated controls. Defeat significantly increased terminal adrenal norepinephrine, but not epinephrine, content. In experiment 2 we asked, Are 15 intermittent resident-intruder interactions necessary to increase body mass and food intake? Body mass and food intake of subordinate hamsters defeated only once were similar to those of nondefeated controls, but four or eight defeats similarly and significantly increased these responses. In experiment 3 we asked, Do intermittent defeats increase adiposity and food intake more than consecutive defeats? Four intermittent or consecutive defeats similarly and significantly increased food intake and body mass compared with nondefeated controls, but only intermittent defeats significantly increased all WAT masses. Consecutive defeats significantly increased mesenteric and inguinal WAT masses. Plasma leptin, but not insulin, concentrations were similarly and significantly increased compared with nondefeated controls. Collectively, social defeat, a natural stressor, significantly increased food intake, body mass, and adiposity in Syrian hamsters and may prove useful in determining mechanisms underlying human stress-induced obesity.

Impact of water temperature and stressor controllability on swim stress-induced changes in body temperature, serum corticosterone, and immobility in rats

The present study compared the effects of three different water temperatures (20, 25, and 30 degrees C) and stressor controllability on several physiological and behavioral endpoints in an intermittent swim stress paradigm. The escape latency of rats in the 20 and 25 degrees C water was less than that observed for the 30 degrees C group. Both escape and yoked groups at 20 and 25 degrees C exhibited moderate to severe hypothermia following the swim stress session that returned to prestress levels 30-40 min post-stress. At 30 degrees C core body temperature (Tb) only decreased by 1 degree C for either swim group. Following swim, serum corticosterone (CORT) levels were significantly elevated in both escape and yoked groups in comparison to confined and home cage controls. The confined control group showed a significant elevation that was approximately halfway between the home cage control and the swim stress groups. At 30 degrees C, there was still a significant elevation of serum CORT in both swim groups in comparison to confined and home cage controls. Therefore, 30 degrees C appears to be the optimal water temperature to evaluate stress controllability effects in the current paradigm. In a final experiment, swim stressor controllability effects were examined in a 5 min forced swim test (FST) 24 h following the initial stress exposure. Rats exposed to yoked-inescapable swim stress at 30 degrees C exhibited more immobility than their escapable swim stress and confined counterparts, while the escape and confined controls did not differ. These results demonstrate that the behavioral deficits observed in the FST are attributable to the stress of inescapable swim and not swim stress per se.

O desamparo aprendido revisitado: estudos com animais

O desamparo aprendido tem sido definido como a dificuldade de aprendizagem apresentada por indivíduos que tiveram experiência prévia com estímulos aversivos incontroláveis. O objetivo deste trabalho é fazer uma revisão crítica dos estudos sobre o desamparo aprendido, com animais. Nessa análise, são considerados aspectos conceituais e metodológicos dos estudos em questão e as interpretações teóricas sobre esse efeito comportamental. Aborda-se a evolução histórica desses estudos, bem como alguns aspectos controversos das publicações que se acumularam ao longo de quatro décadas de pesquisa. A associação do desamparo aprendido com a depressão clínica é analisada criticamente, destacando-se a necessidade de maior rigor metodológico e conceitual nos estudos da área.

Stress, depression, and anhedonia: caveats concerning animal models

Numerous animal models of depression have been advanced, each having multiple attributes and some limitations. This review provides caveats concerning etiologically valid animal models of depression, focusing on characteristics of the depressive subtype being examined (e.g. typical vs atypical major depression, dysthymia, melancholia), and factors that contribute to the interindividual behavioral variability frequently evident in stressor-related behavioral paradigms. These include the stressor type (processive vs systemic stressors), and characteristics of the stressor (controllability, predictability, ambiguity, chronicity, intermittence), as well as organismic variables (genetic, age, sex), experiential variables (stressor history, early life events) and psychosocial and personality factors that moderate stressor reactivity. Finally, a model of depression is reviewed that evaluates the effects of stressors on hedonic processes, reflected by responding for rewarding brain stimulation. Anhedonia is a fundamental feature of depression, and assessment of stressor-related reductions in the rewarding value of brain stimulation, especially when coupled with other potential symptoms of depression, provides considerable face, construct and predictive validity. Stressful events markedly impact rewarding brain stimulation, and this effect varies across strains of mice differentially reactive to stressors, is modifiable by antidepressant treatments, and allows for analyses of the contribution of different brain regions to anhedonic processes. The paradigm is sensitive to several factors known to acts as moderators of stress responses, but analyses remain to be conducted with regard to several such variables.

Behavioral and physiological characterization of male mice under chronic psychosocial stress

Social stress is a major factor in the etiology of several psychopathologies, with individuals greatly differing in vulnerability. The development of appropriate animal models of social stress is, thus, a major challenge of modern bio-medical research. Adult male mice were subjected to a new model of chronic psychosocial stress in which resident/intruder dyads live chronically in sensory contact and physically interact on a daily basis. Four behavioral categories were identified: Resident Dominants (RD), Resident Subordinates (RS), Intruder Dominants (InD), Intruder Subordinates (InS). Here we investigated: behavior during aggressive interactions; gross physiological components of mice metabolism; organ physiology; response to dexamethasone suppression test (DST). RD and InD mice showed persistently high levels of aggression. All four categories of mice showed robust lack of suppression of corticosterone level when challenged with the DST. Although food intake was not altered under chronic stress, body weight decreased in RD and InD mice while increased in InS and, even more so, in RS mice, suggesting an alteration of their metabolic functions. In conclusion, social status and territory ownership were factors determining individual vulnerability to stress exposure. Our model could, thus, be regarded as a valid model to investigate the biological basis of the individual differences in the response to stressful events.

The effects of a switch-off response accompanied by hypothalamically induced restlessness on immunoendocrinological changes in cats

Electrical stimulation of the anterior hypothalamus in cats elicits a behavior called restlessness. When a switch is available for the cats to shut off the electrical stimulation, the cats learn to turn off the stimulation (switch-off response; SOR). In this study, we examined the relationship between the SOR and immunoendocrinological alterations. First of all, an escapable stimulation, in which cats could turn off the stimulation, was applied (escapable condition; EC). One month later, inescapable stimulation was delivered under the same conditions except for the fact that the cats could not turn off the stimulation (inescapable condition; IC). A behavioral analysis revealed that unstable patterns of behavior and a reduction in motor activity were observed in IC compared with those in EC. Furthermore, no significant changes in peripheral leukocytes were observed, while plasma epinephrine and cortisol transiently increased after the series of stimulations, but immediately decreased after the end of the stimulation in EC. On the other hand, there was a greater and prolonged increase in the number of peripheral granulocytes and the plasma levels of epinephrine and cortisol from 1 to 2 h after the stimulation until the end of the experiment in IC. Regarding the number of peripheral lymphocytes, CD4+ or CD8+ lymphocytes and the CD4+ to CD8+ ratio, no significant differences were found between EC and IC. These results suggest that the inability to escape from the aversive stimulation caused a decrease in movement and a prolonged alteration of the immune and endocrine systems, as is often observed in learned helplessness.

Stress applied during primary immunization affects the secondary humoral immune response in the rat: involvement of opioid peptides

The effect of unpredictable, inescapable and uncontrollable electric tail shocks (ES) on the humoral immune response to bovine serum albumin (BSA) was investigated in the rat. Contributions of the procedures that accompany shock delivery, such as witnessing the ES procedure (stress witnessing, SW) and exposure to the apparatus for shock delivery (apparatus control, AC) to the changes in specific immunity induced by ES were also tested. All procedures were applied during primary and/or secondary immunization. It was demonstrated that exposure to ES during primary immunization with BSA significantly suppressed specific anti-BSA antibody production after secondary and tertiary immunization with the same antigen. Exposure to the SW procedure during primary immunization with BSA enhanced the specific antibody level after secondary immunization, while exposure to the apparatus alone did not influence the development of either the primary or secondary humoral immune response to BSA. Both ES-induced suppression and SW-induced potentiation of the humoral immune response were partially inhibited by prior treatment with the opioid receptor antagonist naloxone. Additionally, treatments with the opioid peptides methionine- and leucine-enkephalin decreased anti-BSA antibody level, mimicking to some extent the effects of ES. It is suggested that ES and endogenous opioid peptides had long-term effects on humoral immunity through mechanisms involving immunologic memory.

Mechanisms of stress-induced modulation of immunity

The purpose of this chapter is to discuss the wealth of animal studies of stress-induced modulation of immunity, and to relate our understanding of stress and immunity to clinical populations, particularly cancer patients.

Predictable stress promotes place preference and low mesoaccumbens dopamine response

Aversive stimuli that are signaled, and therefore predictable, are preferred to unsignaled ones and promote less severe stress-related disturbances. Since stressful events are known to activate mesoaccumbens dopamine (DA) transmission, in the present experiments, we evaluated possible differences in mesoaccumbens DA response to predictable and unpredictable footshocks. Mice of the inbred strain DBA/2 were trained for conditioned place preference (CPP) in shuttle boxes. The procedure promoted significant preference for the compartment previously paired with predictable shocks (PR) to that paired with unpredictable shocks (NP). Mesoaccumbens levels of DA and its metabolites were therefore evaluated either after the first or the last (third) training session. A significant increase of 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetic acid (DOPAC) and homovanillic acid (HVA) levels were observed in animals exposed for the first time to the apparatus without shock delivery (SHAM) or to the PR and NP conditions compared with unhandled mice. There was no difference between PR and NP values, and DOPAC and HVA levels in both groups differed from those observable in the SHAM-exposed group. However, trained mice exposed to NP showed a significant elevation of DOPAC and HVA levels in comparison with those exposed to PR. These results show that information about predictability of aversive stimuli reduces central stress responses and suggest a possible relationship between reduced stressfulness and preference for predictable aversive experiences.

On learned helplessness

"Learned helplessness" and its Pavlovian analog, learned irrelevance, are phenomena thought integral to understanding depression, PTSD, psychosomatic vulnerability, and a variety of diseases and immune disorders. The origin and development of research on learned helplessness is briefly overviewed with attention to the reasons for the controversy that surrounds the study of learned helplessness and derived physiological, psychological, and behavioral phenomena. The need to remedy past focus on American research and English language journals in this area is noted. The heuristic value as well as the wide ranging empirical value of the research domain is lauded. The meretricious emerging social and legal barriers to this research are noted to be unrealistic and unfortunate.

Behavioral analysis of stress controllability effects in a new swim stress paradigm

Previous animal stress studies have illustrated the marked impact of coping on subsequent behavior and physiology by using shock as the stressor. The current study evaluates the generality of shock stress controllability effects in a new swim stress paradigm on several dependent measures: behavioral despair, analgesia, shuttlebox escape, and alcohol reactivity. In this new paradigm, rats in the escape group are able to learn the behavioral response as evidenced by significant reduction in the acquisition of a lever press response. Both escape and yoked subjects showed "behavioral despair" in comparison to both restrained and home cage controls when tested 24 h later. In the standard shuttlebox escape task 24-h post-stress, no group differences emerged, although a trend for poorer performance in the yoked subjects was evident. No group differences were observed in pain sensitivity after the first or second forced swim exposure. Finally, stress controllability effects were observed in behavioral reactivity to alcohol 2-h post-stress as measured by rotarod performance. This effect is opposite to the previous observations with the tailshock stress controllability paradigm. These results suggest that (1) there are certain similarities, but some fundamental differences between the behavioral endpoints measured following intermittent swim stress in comparison to the well-established effects of the intermittent tailshock stress model and (2) the qualitative nature of a stressor may markedly influence the behavioral and physiological consequences of stress and coping.

Stress, depression and the activation of the immune system

Both stress and depression have been associated with impaired immune function and increased susceptibility of the patient to infectious diseases and cancer. While it was initially thought that the hypercorticosolaemia caused a suppression of immune function, it is now apparent that adaptive changes result from chronic stress and depression that lead to a hypoactivity of the glucocorticoid receptors on immune cells and in limbic regions of the brain. Thus depression is now thought to be associated with activation of some aspects of cellular immunity resulting in the hypersecretion of proinflammatory cytokines and the hyperactivity of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis. There is also experimental evidence to show that such immune activation induces "stress-like" behavioural and neurochemical changes in rodents which supports the hypothesis that the hypersecretion of proinflammatory cytokines are involved in the pathology of depression. This review attempts to show how the immune, endocrine and neurotransmitter systems are integrated and how the result of such integration may be causally involved in the aetiology of depression.

Immune responses to experimental stress: effects of mental effort and uncontrollability

OBJECTIVE

Two important determinants of physiological stress responses have been identified, uncontrollability of the stressor and amount of effort involved in coping with the stressor. In the present experiment, we tried to identify the specific contributions of effort and uncontrollability to immune system responses to stress.

METHODS

In a 2 x 2 design, effort and uncontrollability were manipulated independently of each other. Subjects participated in one of four experimental conditions, and their endocrine, immune, and sympathetic nervous system responses to the task were assessed.

RESULTS

Effort had a stimulating effect on enumerative immunological parameters (CD8 and CD16+ cells) and on natural killer cell activity. The effect occurred immediately after the stressor and was transient. Regression models indicated that this effort effect may have been mediated by activation of the sympathetic nervous system. Uncontrollability influenced in vitro production of the cytokine interleukin-6, leading to decreased production 15 and 30 minutes after the stressor. Uncontrollability also led to an increased level of cortisol, but no evidence was found that the decrease in cytokine production was mediated by cortisol release.

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that two major stressor characteristics, effort and uncontrollability, may have differential effects on the immune system.

Differences in NK cell function in mice bred for high and low aggression: genetic linkage between complex behavioral and immunological traits?

In previous studies, we found differences in cellular immune responsiveness in Institute for Cancer Research (ICR) mice selectively bred for high and low levels of aggression. Compared to the high aggressive line, the low aggressive line had low levels of natural killer (NK) and T cell activity and increased susceptibility to tumor development. To dissect further this novel association, experiments were designed to test two competing hypotheses. The first hypothesis was that the phenotypic expression of the line differences in NK cell activity are dependent on and regulated by the expression of high and low levels aggressive behavior in the lines. The alternative hypothesis was that the differences in immune status are independent of the expression of aggression by the lines, suggesting linkage between a subset of genes involved in determining these complex behavioral and immunological traits or pleiotropic gene effects on both traits. In Experiment 1, three conditions of postweaning social experience (mice singly housed, group housed within line, or group housed between lines) were tested in males to determine whether experiential conditions which modify the expression of aggression would in turn modify the line differences in NK cell activity. This experiment revealed that the difference in NK cell activity between high aggressive and low aggressive male mice was attributable to line only. The different postweaning social conditions examined had no effect on modifying the differences in NK activity, and social dominance hierarchy did not correlate with levels of NK cell activity. Whereas males of the high and low lines exhibit differences in aggressive behaviors across most contexts, females do not exhibit such differences except in response to an intruder during the postpartum period. Therefore, in Experiment 2 we compared the NK cell activity of nulliparous females of the high and low aggressive lines. Under these conditions, females of the low aggressive line had low levels of NK activity compared to high aggressive females (differences comparable to those seen between males of the high and low lines). Taken together, these experiments lend support to the hypothesis that this association may be due to a genetic linkage between subsets of genes involved in determining these complex behavioral and immunological traits, or may possibly represent a fortuitous association which occurred during the selective breeding.

Effects of chronic mild stress (CMS) and imipramine administration, on spleen mononuclear cell proliferative response, serum corticosterone level and brain norepinephrine content in male mice

There is increasing evidence that stress and emotional reactions produce changes in various immune processes. These changes may be due to alterations of the stress responses endocrine and for autonomic mediating mechanisms. In order to study such effects, the impact of chronic mild stress (CMS) application, and of subsequent imipramine administration were studied on the spleen mononuclear cell proliferative response period. OFI strain male mice were subjected to 4 or 7 weeks of CMS. The effects of these treatments on serum corticosterone levels and hypothalamic and hippocampal norepinephrine (NE) contents were also assessed. Subjects submitted to CMS had a higher spleen mononuclear cell proliferative response after either treatment duration. Imipramine treatment diminished this response enhancement in CMS exposed animals, but did not alter the proliferative responses of control subjects. Serum corticosterone levels, as well as hypothalamic and hippocampal nonrepinephrine contents did not significantly vary between groups. Taken together, these results suggest that CMSs effects on immune reactivity are not related to serum glucocorticoids or NE changes in these locations associated with the hypothalamic-pituitary- adrenocortical (HPA) axis.

Effects of mild stress on the immune response against pseudorabies virus in mice

Stress is a recognised problem in intensive pig husbandry, which might lead to changes in immune reactivity. To study the effect of stress on the development of an anti-viral immune response, we used a murine model in which mice were immunized with an attenuated strain of pseudorabies virus (PRV). The effect of two stress treatments, both relevant to intensive pig husbandry, on the development of the specific immune response against PRV was investigated. The stress treatments consisted of restraint, social isolation, and transport and they differed in predictability. The specific immune response against PRV, which developed in the draining lymph nodes, was measured by a lymphocyte proliferation assay and cytokine production assays. Our results showed that the unpredictable stress treatment had no effect on the development of the immune response against PRV in mice, whereas the predictable stress treatment actually hastened the immune response.

Experimental stress and immunological reactivity: a closer look at perceived uncontrollability

OBJECTIVE

Although stressor uncontrollability has been shown to suppress immune responses in animals and for human subjects, the results have been inconsistent. We reanalyzed results of our previous study regarding stress-related immune deviation in man, to establish whether perceived uncontrollability of an acute stressor acts as a co-determinant in the observed changes in immunological parameters.

METHOD

Three types of cognitive reactions to an acute interpersonal stressor were assessed: "motivation," "uncontrollability," and "guiltiness." Stress-induced changes in the number of several types of immune cells in peripheral blood and proliferative responses of lymphocytes to antigens and mitogens were assessed.

RESULTS

In comparison with control subjects and with subjects perceiving high control over the experimental stress situation, the subject perceiving low control showed a stressor-induced decrease in the number of T helper cells. Reversely, subjects perceiving high control showed an increase in the number of B cells as opposed to the other two groups. The effects of perceived uncontrollability could not be accounted for by mood changes, but they were related to previously experienced life stress.

CONCLUSIONS

Perceived uncontrollability of an acute stressor can have immuno-modulating effects over and above those of the stressor per se.

The effect of depression in an animal model on 5'-ectonucleotidase, antibody production, and tissue ascorbate stores

The learned helplessness model of depression in rats was tested. It was hypothesized that 5'-ectonucleotidase (NT), ascorbate, and antibody to sheeps' red blood cells (SRBC) are significantly reduced in rats who experienced uncontrollable shock, compared with rats who did not receive shock or could control it. During a learned-helplessness manipulation, antibody response to SRBC and NT values were unaffected. However, tissue ascorbate stores fell significantly, by 20-30%. The lack of effects on antibody responses and NT are discussed n terms of the acute nature of the stressor used in this model, as opposed to the more chronic stressors that have occurred in the human model.

The immunomodulator OM-89 induces ACTH and glucocorticoid secretion in rats through an IL-1 dependent pathway

The immunomodulator OM-89 (bacterial extract from E. coli), known to act on the immune system by modulating both humoral and cellular responses, significantly increases ACTH and glucocorticoids secretion in normal Wistar rats. A comparative administration of IL-1 displays a similar pattern of release. Moreover, OM-89-induced responses are blocked by IL-1ra, the soluble receptor antagonist of IL-1. The effect of OM-89 can thus be explained, at least in part, via IL-1 which directly enhances the secretion of both stress hormones. Finally, a comparative experiment between control and stressed rats (by immobilization) shows that the responses to OM-89 measured in this study (ACTH and corticosterone secretion) are stress-modulated.

Stress and immunity after traumatic injury: the mind-body link

Traumatic injury poses a significant psychologic and physiologic threat, challenging a victim's perceptions of control over their environment and life outcomes. The multiple stressors presented by traumatic injury diminishes the patient's perceptions of control, resulting in a subjective stress response. Increased stress response after traumatic injury has been associated with altered immune function and decreased immunity. This paper reviews the current literature on stress and immunity after traumatic injury, focusing on the immune changes induced by excessive serum cortisol. It then presents evidence suggesting that the trauma patient's subjective stress response and diminished perceptions of control may act as factors in the immune changes occurring after injury. Recent studies supporting this hypothesis are reviewed, and recommendations for interventions, nursing practice, and research are discussed.

Stress versus depression

1. Exhaustive evidence is quoted showing that uncontrollable (uncoping) stress provoked in experimental mammals leads to depletion of central noradrenergic activity+ adrenomedullary-cortical gland hyperactivity. These physiological disorders cause the typical neuroendocrine peripheral profile: a) raised catecholamines (CA) in plasma [noradrenaline (NA)+adrenaline (Ad)+dopamine (DA), b) reduced NA/Ad ratio in plasma and c) raised plasma cortisol. 2. Exhaustive evidence is quoted which indicates that severely ill humans show peripheral neuroendocrine profile similar to that found in mammals submitted to uncontrollable stress situation. Further, the NA/Ad ratio does not increase but decreases during orthostasis and exercise stress challenges, as well as oral glucose stress (tolerance) test. 3. Exhaustive evidence is quoted which indicates that endogenous depressed subjects show a neuroendocrine profile opposite to that observed in stressed mammals and severely ill humans. This profile consists of central NA (neural sympathetic) hyperactivity+ adrenomedullary glands hyporresponsivity. These disorders are reflected in a three to ten fold increase of the NA/Ad ratio in plasma. 4. Exhaustive evidence is also quoted showing that dysthymic depressed patients show low plasma catecholamines+low NA/Ad plasma ratio (< 2) during supine-resting condition, it is normalized at orthostasis and exercise periods. 5. It is quoted evidence showing that whereas platelet serotonin is increased in dysthymics, the same is reduced in both endogenous depressed and stressed mammals as well as severely ill humans. 6. It is quoted evidence showing that free serotonin in plasma is greatly raised in uncoping stressed mammals and severely ill humans. The same parameter is normal or slightly increased in dysthymic and endogenous depressed humans. These findings are consistent with the increased platelet aggregability observed in "uncontrollable" stressed mammals and in severely ill, but not depressed patients. 7. It is also quoted evidence showing that whereas parasympathetic activity is absent in uncontrollable stressed mammals and severely ill humans, the same is increased in both types of depressed humans. 8. According to the above, the authors postulate the existence of 3 distinct central+ peripheral neuroendocrine profiles for endogenous depression, dysthymic depression and maladaptation to stress syndrome. These different profiles should lead researchers to attempt different therapeutical approach. 9. In view of the fact that the authors found much clinical overlap among the three syndromes (endogenous depression, dysthymic depression and severely ill patients), they believe that a differential diagnosis should be based on neurochemical, neuroendocrine, physiologic, metabolic and neuropharmacological grounds. 10. The experimentally induced uncontrollable stress (behavioral despair) syndrome in mammals should not be used as a valid model of human depressive syndrome.

Effect of environmental enrichment and housing density on immune system reactivity to acute exercise stress

Positive stress has been described in the literature but not well characterized experimentally. This experiment was designed to test the hypothesis that environmental enrichment and housing density in C57BL/6 female mice modulate immune responses to acute exercise stress. A 2 x 2 x 2 factorial design was used where enrichment (enrich), nonenriched (nonenrich), group housed (group), individually housed (ind), and stress (stress) or no stress (nonstress) acted as the independent variables. Enrichment involved a 7-week exposure to in-cage running wheels and a variety of cage objects. Ninety minutes after treadmill exercise stress at 25 m/min, 4 degrees slope, for 30 min (or no exercise stress) mice were sacrificed, and splenocyte blastogenesis to the T-cell mitogen concanavalin A (Con A), splenic T-cell subset enumeration, and percent live/dead splenic cells by flow cytometry were evaluated. Results showed significant interaction effects for mitogen responses, percent Ly2+ subset, and percent live/dead splenocyte responses. Proliferation to Con A was higher in nonenrich group-housed animals than other groups. Percent live/dead cell analysis revealed a significant housing x stress interaction with fewer percent live and higher percent metabolically stressed splenocytes obtained from ind-stressed mice than other groups. These data suggest that enrichment and housing density are important factors influencing immune responses in the basal state, and in response to exercise stress.

Plaque-forming cell responses and antibody titers following injection of sheep red blood cells in nonstressed, acute, and/or chronically stressed handled and nonhandled animals

Given the bidirectional nature of the communication between the immune and hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) systems, we examined whether animals that exhibit differences in HPA responses to stress would also exhibit differences in their plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses to sheep red blood cells (SRBC). Neonatally handled (H) animals exhibit lower HPA responses to a number of acute stressors in adulthood compared to nonhandled (NH) animals. Furthermore, these differences also emerge as a function of chronic, intermittent cold stress. We hypothesized that H and NH animals may exhibit differences in the PFC response to SRBC under conditions of acute and/or chronic stress (H CHR and NH CHR). Exposure to acute (4 hr) cold decreased PFC responses in both H and NH animals compared to nonstressed H and NH animals. The decrease in PFC response produced by chronic, intermittent cold stress was similar in H and NH animals and was not different from that found in acutely stressed animals. In H CHR animals reexposed to cold stress, the PFC response was not different from acutely stressed or chronically stressed H and NH animals. In contrast, the PFC response in NH CHR animals reexposed to cold stress was lower than all other groups studied. Thus, neonatal handling prevented prior chronic stress-induced suppression of the PFC response to a subsequent stress. These data suggest that there may be subpopulations of individuals in whom prior chronic stress does not exacerbate the immune suppression produced by acute stress. However, those chronically stressed individuals in whom immune suppression does occur may be more vulnerable to infection and disease.

A role for CRH and the sympathetic nervous system in stress-induced immunosuppression

Central CRH coordination of the behavioral and physiologic sequelae of stress has been well established, and so it is parsimonious to suggest that CRH might also coordinate the immunologic sequelae. The studies presented here lend support to this suggestion. CRH administration into the brain was shown to modulate aspects of both cellular and humoral immune function, and the inhibition of CRH release in the brain following stress inhibited stress-associated immunosuppression. The effects of CRH appear to be mediated by the sympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system, as chemical sympathectomy and pharmacological blockade of beta-adrenergic receptors both reversed the effects of CRH on immune function. In contrast, removal of the adrenal glands did not alter the immunologic effects of CRH. These links among CRH in the brain, sympathetic activation, and immune function suggest the possibility that immune function may be altered in other conditions characterized by elevated sympathetic tone, such as depression and aging, and that these alterations may be attributed to CRH dysregulation in the brain. These studies shed light on the intricate relationship between the brain and the immune system, and also illuminate its complexity. The differential regulation of CRH in the brain and the periphery is one example of the latter. These findings also set the stage for potential clinical intervention with CRH antagonists, for example, to treat compromised immune function associated with chronic stress, depression, or aging.

Social rank and disease susceptibility in pigs

Two experiments were carried out to investigate the inter-individual variation in immune reactivity and disease susceptibility of group housed pigs of different social status. The social status of the individual pig was determined by the outcome of social ranking fights and food competition tests. On Day 75 after the start of both experiments, all pigs were challenged with 0.5 ml of an Aujeszky disease virus (ADV) in each nostril. Data combined from both experiments showed that mortality and/or morbidity after the ADV challenge was highest among subordinates. In both experiments, a lymphocyte proliferation assay, using purified ADV as an antigenic stimulus, showed that dominant pigs had significantly higher counts per minute than subdominant and subordinate pigs. Kendall's partial correlations showed that morbidity had been associated with high values in haematological and clinicochemical blood parameters and not with social status of the individual pig. In each experiment, maternal derived antibodies against the ADV and the antibody level after the ADV challenge hardly differed between pigs of different social status. Major histocompatibility complex typing of class I and II by iso-electro focusing of all pigs in Experiment 2 showed that not all haplotypes were distributed equally among dominant, subdominant and subordinate pigs. The present work shows that there are large individual differences in immune reactivity and disease susceptibility which appear to be related to the social status of the individual pig in a stable social structure.

The protective effects of stress control may be mediated by increased brain levels of benzodiazepine receptor agonists

Control over stress protects against many of the deleterious effects of stress exposure, but the endogenous mediators responsible for these prophylactic effects have remained elusive. Using behavioral pharmacology, in vitro radioligand binding and neurochemical analyses, we demonstrate that exposure to escapable stress results in brain and behavior changes reminiscent of benzodiazepine administration. The stress control group shows significant protection against picrotoxinin-induced seizures, reductions in [35S]t-butylbicyclophosphorothionate (TBPS) binding and a 3-fold increase of benzodiazepine-like substances in brain in comparison to both yoked-inescapable shock and non-shock controls. These observations suggest that coping behavior leads to the release of endogenous benzodiazepine-like compounds in brain which protect the organism from stress pathology.

Effect of climatic stress on the immunological reactivity of weaned pigs

Weaned pigs exposed daily to either unpredictable draught (experiment 1) or intermittent unpredictable draught (experiment 2) showed different lymphocyte blastogenic responses after mitogenic stimulation with phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) and concanavalin A (ConA). In both experiments PHA skin test responses were lower for draught exposed pigs than for control pigs and leucocyte numbers or profiles were altered compared to those of control pigs. Superoxide production and chemiluminescence of porcine granulocytes were similar for draught exposed and control animals. Furthermore, serum globulin content did not differ significantly between pigs in the experimental and control room. The strong increase in serum gamma-globulin after the Aujeszky Disease Virus (ADV)-challenge was the same for draught exposed and control pigs. The same held for the lymphocyte blastogenic response with ADV protein as antigenic stimulus. The present study shows the effects of climatic stress on immunological reactivity, which may reflect a homeostatic disturbance of the pig's immune system elicited by exposure to unpredictable draught.

Stress-induced modulation of the immune response in the developing rat pup

Although substantial evidence has linked stressful events to immune changes in adult animals, little is known regarding the impact of stress on immune function during ontogeny. In the present study, 8-, 16-, and 20-day old rat pups were isolated from their mothers and littermates for 24 h; splenocyte responses to the mitogen Con A were assessed 72 h following reunion. A suppression of the mitogen response was obtained for 16- and 20-day old pups, but no effect was found in the 8-day-old animals, possibly due to the small sample size. These data offer a viable model from which to study further changes in immune responsiveness during ontogeny.

Role of dopaminergic mechanisms in the regulation of stress responses in experimental animals

The effects of some dopaminergic agents were evaluated on stress responses in normal and immunized experimental animals. Restraint stress (RS) consistently induced gastric mucosal lesions and elevated plasma corticosterone in rats. Pretreatment with alpha-methyltyrosine (alpha-MT), haloperidol, or sulpiride aggravated both responses, whereas bromocriptine attenuated them. In rats immunized with sheep red blood cells (SRBCs), RS prevented the booster-induced rise in anti-SRBC antibody titre. This response was further suppressed by alpha-MT, haloperidol, or sulpiride pretreatment, whereas bromocriptine potentiated the humoral immune response. In mice immunized with SRBCs, antigen challenge-induced increase in footpad thickness was inhibited by RS. Similar inhibitions in this response were also seen after alpha-MT or haloperidol treatment. The results are discussed in light of complex dopaminergic mechanisms in the regulation of visceral, endocrinological, and immune responses during stress.