Studies of memory: a reevaluation in mice of the effects of inhibitors on the rate of synthesis of cerebral proteins as related to amnesia

Fear generalization modulated by shock intensity and protein synthesis inhibitor

RATIONALE

Maladaptive fear responses, including sensitized threat reactions and overgeneralization, contribute to anxiety disorders such as generalized anxiety disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder. Although stress intensity influences the generation and extent of these maladaptive fears, the underlying mechanisms remain unclear.

OBJECTIVES

The present study examined whether varying footshock stress intensity and inhibition of protein synthesis have differential effect on fear sensitization and generalization in mice.

METHODS

Mice were subjected to a classic fear conditioning protocol involving five different levels of footshock intensities. Prior to fear acquisition, the protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximide (CHX) was administered intraperitoneally. Fear sensitization to white noise and fear generalization to tones with frequencies differing from the conditioned tone were assessed at either 2 or 4 days after fear acquisition.

RESULTS

The results showed that, although varying shock intensities (except the lowest) led to a similar pattern of increased freezing during auditory cues in fear acquisition, the extent of both fear sensitization and generalization increased with the intensity of the footshock in the following days. As shock intensities increased, there was a proportional rise in sensitized fear to white noise and generalized freezing to tones with frequencies progressively closer to the conditioned stimulus. Mildest shocks did not induce discriminative conditioned fear memory, whereas the most intense shocks led to pronounced fear generalization. Administration of CHX before fear acquisition did not affect sensitized fear but reduced generalization of freezing to tones dissimilar from the conditioned stimulus in the group exposed to the most intense shock.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that maladaptive fear responses elicited by varying stress intensities exhibit distinct characteristics. The effect of CHX to prevent overgeneralization without affecting discriminative fear memory points to potential therapeutic approaches for fear-related disorders, suggesting the possibility of mitigating overgeneralization while preserving necessary fear discrimination.

Assessment of cellular and molecular changes in the rat brain after gamma radiation and radioprotection by anisomycin

The objective of the study was to describe cellular and molecular markers of radioprotection by anisomycin, focusing on the changes in rat brain tissue. Two-month-old Wistar rats were exposed to a 60Co radiation source at a dose of 6 Gy, with or without radioprotection with anisomycin (150 mg/kg) administered subcutaneously 30 min before or 3 or 6 h after irradiation. Survivors were analyzed 30 days after treatment. Astroglial and microglial responses were investigated based on the expression of glial markers assessed with immunohistochemistry, and quantitative changes in brain biomolecules were investigated by Raman microspectroscopy. In addition, blood plasma levels of pro-inflammatory (interleukin 6 and tumor necrosis factor α) and anti-inflammatory (interleukin 10) cytokines were assessed. We found that application of anisomycin either before or after irradiation significantly decreased the expression of the microglial marker Iba-1. We also found an increased intensity of Raman spectral bands related to nucleic acids, as well as an increased level of cytokines when anisomycin was applied after irradiation. This suggests that the radioprotective effects of anisomycin are by decreasing Iba-1 expression and stabilizing genetic material by increasing the level of nucleic acids.

Temporal phases of long-term potentiation (LTP): myth or fact?

Long-term potentiation (LTP) remains the most widely accepted model for learning and memory. In accordance with this belief, the temporal differentiation of LTP into early and late phases is accepted as reflecting the differentiation of short-term and long-term memory. Moreover, during the past 30 years, protein synthesis inhibitors have been used to separate the early, protein synthesis-independent (E-LTP) phase and the late, protein synthesis-dependent (L-LTP) phase. However, the role of these proteins has not been formally identified. Additionally, several reports failed to show an effect of protein synthesis inhibitors on LTP. In this review, a detailed analysis of extensive behavioral and electrophysiological data reveals that the presumed correspondence of LTP temporal phases to memory phases is neither experimentally nor theoretically consistent. Moreover, an overview of the time courses of E-LTP in hippocampal slices reveals a wide variability ranging from <1 h to more than 5 h. The existence of all these conflictual findings should lead to a new vision of LTP. We believe that the E-LTP vs. L-LTP distinction, established with protein synthesis inhibitor studies, reflects a false dichotomy. We suggest that the duration of LTP and its dependency on protein synthesis are related to the availability of a set of proteins at synapses and not to the de novo synthesis of plasticity-related proteins. This availability is determined by protein turnover kinetics, which is regulated by previous and ongoing electrical activities and by energy store availability.

Cycloheximide impairs and enhances memory depending on dose and footshock intensity

This experiment examined the effects on memory of interactions of cycloheximide dose and training foot shock intensity. Mice received injections of cycloheximide (120 mg/kg, s.c.) or saline 30 min prior to inhibitory avoidance training with shock intensities of 100, 150, 250 or 300 μA (1 s duration). Memory was tested 48 h later. The saline control mice showed increasing memory latencies as a function of shock intensity. The ability of cycloheximide to impair memory increased as the training shock intensity increased. In a second experiment, mice were trained with a 200 μA (1 s duration) shock and received injections of saline or cycloheximide at one of several doses (30, 60 or 120 mg/kg). Under these training conditions, cycloheximide enhanced memory in an inverted-U dose-response manner. These findings are consistent with prior findings suggesting that protein synthesis inhibitors act on memory by altering modulators of memory formation as a secondary consequence of the inhibition of protein synthesis rather than by interfering with training-initiated synthesis of proteins required for memory formation.

The role of protein synthesis in memory consolidation: progress amid decades of debate

A major component of consolidation theory holds that protein synthesis is required to produce the synaptic modification needed for long-term memory storage. Protein synthesis inhibitors have played a pivotal role in the development of this theory. However, these commonly used drugs have unintended effects that have prompted some to reevaluate the role of protein synthesis in memory consolidation. Here we review the role of protein synthesis in memory formation as proposed by consolidation theory calling special attention to the controversy involving the non-specific effects of a group of protein synthesis inhibitors commonly used to study memory formation in vivo. We argue that molecular and genetic approaches that were subsequently applied to the problem of memory formation confirm the results of less selective pharmacological studies. Thus, to a certain extent, the debate over the role of protein synthesis in memory based on interpretational difficulties inherent to the use of protein synthesis inhibitors may be somewhat moot. We conclude by presenting avenues of research we believe will best provide answers to both long-standing and more recent questions facing field of learning and memory.

Cocaine-but not methamphetamine-associated memory requires de novo protein synthesis

Context-induced drug craving and continuous drug use manifest the critical roles of specific memory episodes associated with the drug use experiences. Drug-induced conditioned place preference (CPP) in C57BL/6J mouse model, in this regard, is an appropriate behavioral paradigm to study such drug use-associated memories. Requirement of protein synthesis in various forms of long-term memory formation and storage has been phylogenetically demonstrated. This study was undertaken to study the requirement of protein synthesis in the learning and memory aspect of the conditioned place preference induced by cocaine and methamphetamine, two abused drugs of choice in local area. Since pCREB has been documented as a candidate substrate for mediating the drug-induced neuroadaptation, the pCREB level in hippocampus, nucleus accumbens, and prefrontal cortex was examined for its potential participation in the formation of CPP caused by these psychostimulants. We found that cocaine (2.5 and 5.0 mg/kg/dose)-induced CPP was abolished by the pretreatment of anisomycin (50 mg/kg/dose), a protein synthesis inhibitor, whereas methamphetamine (0.5 or 1.0 mg/kg/dose)-induced CPP was not affected by the anisomycin pretreatment. Likewise, cocaine-induced CPP was mitigated by another protein synthesis inhibitor, cycloheximide (15 mg/kg/injection) pretreatment, whereas methamphetamine-induced CPP remained intact by such pretreatment. Moreover, anisomycin treatment 2h after each drug-place pairing disrupted the cocaine-induced CPP, whereas the same treatment did not affect methamphetamine-induced CPP. An increase of accumbal pCREB level was found to associate with the learning phase of cocaine, but not with the learning phase of methamphetamine. We further found that intraaccumbal CREB antisense oligodeoxynucleotide infusion diminished cocaine-induced CPP, whereas did not affect the methamphetamine-induced CPP. Taken together, these data suggest that protein synthesis and accumbal CREB phosphorylation are essential for the learning and consolidation of the cocaine-induced CPP, whereas methamphetamine-induced CPP may be unrelated to the synthesis of new proteins.

Post-translational protein modification as the substrate for long-lasting memory

Prevailing models of memory identify mRNA translation as necessary for long-lasting information storage. However, there are enough instances of memory storage in the virtual absence of protein synthesis to prompt consideration of alternative models. A comprehensive review of the protein synthesis literature leads us to conclude that the translational mechanism is exclusively a permissive, replenishment step. Therefore, we propose that post-translational modification (PTM) of proteins already at the synapse is the crucial instructive mechanism underlying long-lasting memory. A novel feature of this model is that non-random spontaneous (or endogenous) brain activity operates as a regulated positive-feedback rehearsal mechanism, updating network configurations by fine-tuning the PTM state of previously modified proteins. Synapses participating in memory storage are therefore supple, a feature required for networks to alter complexity and update continuously. In analogy with codons for amino acids, a long-lasting memory is represented by a 'degenerate code' - a set of pseudo-redundant networks that can ensure its longevity.

Onset of Amnesia Is Delayed with a Decrease in Inhibition of Protein Synthesis during Odor-taste Associative Learning in the Terrestrial Slug Limax valentianus

Slugs can retain odor-taste associative memory for several weeks, and this requires protein synthesis. We examined the dose-dependency of the onset time of amnesia caused by the protein synthesis inhibitor anisomycin, and showed that with reduced dose, the onset is shifted from 2 days to 3 days after conditioning; we could not shift the onset delay later than 3 days. Our results suggest that the mechanism underling memory retention is different in the period up to 3 days, versus the period later than 3 days. Our results also suggest that sustained inhibition of protein synthesis in the period from zero to 3 hr after conditioning is necessary to cause amnesia.

Color learning and memory in honey bees are not affected by protein synthesis inhibition

The role of protein synthesis was tested for memory formation after color learning in honey bees. Free flying bees were trained to a feeding place. Before the color conditioning started, foragers accustomed to flying to the feeding place received an injection of either cycloheximide in bee ringer or bee ringer alone into the brain. Afterward, the animals were trained appetitively to a specific colored target by three training trials. During the test situation, two targets with different colors and no reward were presented. The choice behavior toward the two targets was evaluated. The first test immediately followed the last trial, the second test 24 h later. A comparison between cycloheximide- and ringer-injected bees showed no significant difference in choice behavior in either test. Although the injection of cycloheximide causes the inhibition of protein synthesis (> 95%) for a period of 3 h, the memory for the learned color signal is not affected. These results corroborate those found for the olfactory conditioning of the proboscis extension reflex in bees (Wittstock, Kaatz, & Menzel, 1993, Menzel, Gaio, Gerberding, Nemrava, & Wittstock, 1993).

Effects of several amnesic drugs on the habituation of exploratory activity in mice as indexed by horizontal and vertical activities

1. The effects of several drugs on the habituation of exploratory activity in mice were investigated by using animal movement analyzing systems which could detect horizontal and vertical activities. 2. Habituation was regarded as the difference between exploratory activity measured first (session 1) and that measured second (session 2). 3. Scopolamine (1, 3 and/or 6 mg/kg), pirenzepine (20 and 40 micrograms) injected immediately after session 1, cycloheximide (30 mg/kg), diazepam (1, 2 and/or 4 mg/kg) and dizocilpine (0.05, 0.1 and/or 0.2 mg/kg), unlike butylscopolamine (1, 3 and 6 mg/kg) or haloperidol (0.2 and 0.4 mg/kg), significantly increased horizontal activity but not always vertical activity in session 2. 4. From the results obtained, it appears that the increase in horizontal activity in session 2 is more appropriate as an indicator of the impairments of memory processes than that in vertical activity.

Step-down-type passive avoidance- and escape-learning method. Suitability for experimental amnesia models

A method for evaluating passive avoidance- and escape-learning responses simultaneously has been developed for the study of learning and memory in mice. Prolongation of the step-down latency and shortening of the escape latency in the retention test depended on the strength of the voltage of the electric shocks delivered during the training test. Therefore, the step-down latency and escape latency may be good parameters of learning and memory performance. By cycloheximide treatment immediately after training, the step-down latency and escape latency were shortened and prolonged, respectively, in a dose-related manner, and the relationship between the step-down latency and escape latency was significant. Treatment with cycloheximide within 30 min after training caused significant amnesia, but not after more than 60 min. Furthermore, amnesic action of cycloheximide developed 24 hr after the treatment, but not within 4 hr. On the other hand, the step-down latency and/or the escape latency in the training test were changed by pretreatment with diethyldithiocarbamate and scopolamine. Therefore, the amnesic action of these drugs administered before the training should be investigated in detail. The present method, simultaneously estimating passive avoidance- and escape-learning responses, may be useful for the development of experimental amnesia models.

Neurochemical and behavioral effects of catecholamine and protein synthesis inhibitors in mice

A series of biochemical and behavioral experiments tested the hypothesis that anisomycin (ANI), a protein synthesis inhibitor, produced decrements in long-term memory by raising free tyrosine levels and by the accumulation of catecholamines (CAs) rather than by its primary effect on protein synthesis. We compared the effects of ANI and three catecholamine synthesis inhibitors (CAIs)--diethyldithiocarbamic acid, alpha-methyl-p-tyrosine, and tetrabenazine--on cerebral concentrations of tyrosine and CAs and on the rate of accumulation of CAs. ANI had a relatively small effect, whereas the CAIs resulted in large reductions. When ANI and a CAI were used in combination, effects on CA levels were determined mainly by the CAI. The amnestic effects of ANI and the CAIs were also compared across seven experimental paradigms. Pretraining administration of any of the four drugs could result in amnesia for passive avoidance training, but only when training was weak. With an increase in training strength, a series of three injections of ANI (one pre- and two post-training) caused amnesia, but a similar series of CAI injections did not. Substituting one CAI injection for the second of three successive ANI injections did not cause amnesia, but substituting cycloheximide, another protein synthesis inhibitor, resulted in amnesia. With an active avoidance test, ANI caused amnesia while AMPT did not; d-amphetamine blocked the amnestic effect of ANI but caused amnesia in AMPT injected mice. Whereas ANI lengthened the temporal gradient over which electroconvulsive shock produced amnesia, AMPT or DDC did not. DDC caused only transient amnesia for passive avoidance training, while the amnestic effect of ANI remained constant at 24-hr and 1-week retention tests. We conclude that ANI and CAIs have distinctly different abilities to produce amnesia. These experiments provide additional support for the hypothesis that protein synthesis is required for formation of long-term memory.

Investigation of the reported protective effect of cycloheximide on memory

Many findings support the hypothesis that formation of long-term memory requires synthesis of proteins in the nervous system close to the time of learning. This hypothesis has been challenged recently by reports that the protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximide (CYC) injected 2 hr prior to passive avoidance training in mice or rats attenuated the memory impairment induced by a usually amnestic dose of CYC administered 30 min pretraining. To investigate the reports of a "protective" effect of the prior injection, we attempted to replicate them and test their generality. For replication we administered either paired injections of CYC--120 mg/kg 2 hr prior to training and 30 mg/kg 30 min prior to training--or single injections of CYC (either 120 mg/kg or 30 mg/kg) 30 min pretraining and tested for retention of the passive avoidance habit either 1 or 7 days later. No attenuation of amnesia was observed at 1 day tests. Attenuation of amnesia following the double injection of CYC was observed at 7 day tests. When another protein synthesis inhibitor, anisomycin, was used in the same experimental design, there was no "protective" effect; two injections of anisomycin produced greater memory impairment for the passive avoidance habit than did the single low dose. Also, for active avoidance training, two successive injections of CYC caused significantly greater amnesia than did a single dose; this is the opposite of a "protective" effect. We suggest that the reported "protective" effect of CYC on memory is an as yet unexplained phenomenon that does not generalize to other antibiotic drugs and is specific to the passive avoidance task.

Effects of amino acid alterations caused by protein synthesis inhibitors on brain monoamine formation

Cerebral amino acid concentrations in mice were determined following in vivo treatment with cycloheximide and anisomycin. Synaptosomes from untreated mice were then exposed to concentrations of amino acids designed to simulate the conditions existing extraneuronally following in vivo drug treatment. The synthesis of [3H]norepinephrine, [3H]dopamine and [3H]5-hydroxytryptamine from their labelled amino acid precursors was determined, as well as the accumulation of the precursors by the synaptosomes. Although the synthesis of both [3H]dopamine and [3H]norepinephrine was decreased below expected values predicted from samples in which only tyrosine was altered to represent the concentrations following drug treatment, it was not decreased significantly below control levels. Synthesis of [3H]5-hydroxytryptamine was increased in the presence of amino acid mixtures simulating drug treatment. The results suggest that alteration of amino acid levels is not involved in the inhibition of brain monoamine synthesis caused by these protein synthesis inhibitors.

Effect of anisomycin on stimulation-induced changes in dendritic spines of the dentate granule cells

Tetanic stimulation of the entorhinal area induces significant enlargement of the average dendritic spine area and perimeter in the middle and distal thirds of the dentate molecular layer 4 and 90 min following stimulation. Four minutes after stimulation, the differences between the stimulated and control animals were 20% for the dendritic spine area and 9% for the perimeter in the middle third, and in the distal third 32 and 14%, respectively. Ninety minutes after stimulation the differences were 28 and 11% for the area and perimeter in the middle third, and 33 and 18% in the distal third, respectively. Anisomycin at a dose of 25 mg/kg had no significant effect on the average spine area or perimeter in the various thirds of the dentate molecular layer in the 19 and 105 min post-application intervals. This dose of anisomycin given 15 min prior to the stimulation suppresses the stimulation-induced spine changes in the 4 min interval. In the 90 min interval when the effect of anisomycin on protein synthesis is largely terminated, spine enlargement reappears, being 21% higher than the controls in the middle and distal thirds. The differential effect of anisomycin on dendritic spines in the two post-stimulation intervals is discussed in relation to the effect of anisomycin on protein synthesis. The present experiments thus demonstrate that the stimulation-induced spine enlargement in the dentate fascia can be suppressed by a protein synthesis blocking drug.