Oil sands process-affected water impairs feeding by Daphnia magna

Impacts of UV light on the effects of either conventional or nano-enabled azoxystrobin on Daphnia magna

Agri-chemicals such as fungicides are applied in natural settings and hence are exposed to the environment's ultraviolet (UV) light. Recently, many fungicides in commerce are being modified as nano-enabled formulations to increase agricultural productivity and reduce potential off-target effects. The present study investigated the impacts of sunlight-grade UV emission on the effects of either conventional or nano-enabled azoxystrobin (Az or nAz, respectively), a commonly applied agricultural fungicide, on Daphnia magna. Daphnids were exposed to increasing concentrations of Az or nAz under either full-spectrum (Vis) or full-spectrum Vis+UV (Vis+UV) lighting regimes to evaluate LC50s. Az LC50 was calculated at 268.8 and 234.2 μg/L in Vis or Vis+UV, respectively, while LC50 for nAz was 485.6 and 431.0 μg/L under Vis or Vis+UV light, respectively. Daphnids were exposed to 10% LC50 of either Az or nAz under Vis or Vis+UV lighting regime for 48 h or 21 d (acute and chronic, respectively). By 48 h, both Az and nAz reduced O2 consumption and increased TBARS. Heart rate was increased in Az-exposed daphnids but not in nAz groups. Neither of the two chemicals impacted thoracic limb activity. In 21 d exposures, Az significantly reduced biomass production and fecundity, but nAz groups were not significantly different from controls. The results of the present study demonstrate that conventional Az is more toxic to D. magna at lethal and sub-lethal levels in acute and chronic exposures, and sunlight strength UV can potentiate both acute and chronic effects of Az and nAz on D. magna.

Daphnia magna digestive activity is differentially altered when exposed to equally turbid waters caused by either suspended sediment or suspended microplastics

Turbidity can be a result of suspended natural particles, such as sediment, or anthropogenic particles such as microplastics. This study assessed whether Daphnia magna, a pelagic filter feeder known to ingest suspended particles, have an altered response to equally turbid environments caused by the presence of either suspended bentonite or suspended polyethylene microplastics. Compared to controls, daphnids exposed to suspended bentonite maintained their feeding efficiency and increased their digestive activity, as measured by mandibular movement, peristalsis, and expulsion, to pass bentonite through the digestive tract. The same effects were not seen in microplastic-exposed individuals, in which feeding efficiency was decreased and only peristaltic movement was increased but without a coordinated increase in expulsion, suggesting that microplastics do not have the same ability as bentonite to pass through the digestive tract. This study highlights the need to discern the identities of particulates contributing to turbid environments as different particles, even of the same size, can have different effects on filter feeders, which inherently ingest suspended particles.

Toxic Effects of Methylene Blue on the Growth, Reproduction and Physiology of Daphnia magna

Methylene blue (MB) is a disinfectant used in aquaculture to prevent and treat fish diseases. However, the release of MB can pose a risk to the receiving water bodies. Zooplankton are the most sensitive organisms among aquatic life. Hence, this study examined the acute and chronic toxic effects of MB on zooplankton using Daphnia magna (D. magna) as a test organism to provide basic data for risk assessment. The results show that 48 h-EC₅₀ and 24 h-LC₅₀ were 61.5 ± 2.3 and 149.0 ± 2.2 μg/L, respectively. Chronic exposure to MB affected the heart rate, beat frequency of the thoracic limbs, and reproductive ability of D. magna at environmental concentrations higher than 4.7 μg/L. The cumulative molts, time to production of the first brood, and total number of living offspring were affected at different MB concentrations, while "abortions" were observed in high-exposure groups. The activity of superoxide dismutase was increased, while glutathione S-transferase activity was stimulated at low concentrations and inhibited at high concentrations. In addition, the malondialdehyde content increased with increasing concentrations of MB. Our findings demonstrate the impact of MB on the reproduction and growth of freshwater species, as well as their physiological responses. These results have implications for establishing guidelines on the use of MB in aquaculture and setting discharge standards.

Chronic toxicity of diclofenac, carbamazepine and their mixture to Daphnia magna: a comparative two-generational study

The chronic toxicity of diclofenac (DCF) and carbamazepine (CBZ) as separate substances and in conjunction with their mixture on Daphnia magna was assessed in the parental (F0) and first filial (F1) generations. The second (F1-B2) and fifth (F1-B5) broods of F1 offspring were investigated and compared. Both drugs and their mixture were exposed to each generation of Daphnia magna for 21 days with life history, behavioural and gene expressions as measured endpoints. After the parental exposure, offspring from these two broods were transferred to a clean medium for a 21-day recovery. Exposure to diclofenac, carbamazepine and their mixture significantly inhibited growth, reproduction, swimming activities, heart rate, thoracic limb activities, reproductive and antioxidant-related genes in the parental as well as the first filial generations. These effects were relatively greater in the F1 generation. This indicates that Daphnia magna's sensitivity improved while its fitness declined over the two generations, which is an indicator of greater energy requirements for maintenance. Besides, the significant inhibition in the antioxidant-related genes implies that oxidative stress occurred in Daphnia magna under the exposure to these drugs. The significant reduction in the reproductive output, moulting frequency and cyp314 gene expression as a result of exposure to CBZ simultaneously obtained herein may indicate that this drug could act as an endocrine disruptor. Most of these significant effects were not recoverable after the 21-day recovery period. The findings reported herein highlight the necessity to include maternal effects in environmental risk assessment processes, considering that pollutant effects are underestimated during single-generational exposure.

Physiological and metabolic alterations induced by commercial neonicotinoid formulations in Daphnia magna

Neonicotinoid insecticides are widely used agents in agriculture to control a broad range of insect pests. Although use of neonicotinoid pesticides has resulted in the widespread contamination of surface waters, sublethal toxicity data of these products in relation to non-target aquatic biota are still poor. Therefore, the objective of this study was to assess the effects of two neonicotinoid pesticides with widespread use on the basic physiological functions: the thoracic limb activity and heart rate of Daphnia magna, and to screen for their potential to affect the cytochrome P450 monooxygenase system (ECOD activity) of daphnids. The considered pesticides were the acetamiprid- and thiacloprid based products Mospilan 20 SG and Calypso 480 SC, respectively. The dose-dependent variation in the three biological endpoints considered were assessed following 24 h exposures. The two neonicotinoid formulations elicited significant depression on the thoracic limb activity and heart rate of daphnids at doses close to the immobility thresholds of formulations (48h-EC₅₀: Mospilan 20 SG = 190 mg L^-1; Calypso 480 SC = 120 mg L^-1), an effect mainly attributable to the overall drop in the general health status of the organisms. The alterations in the physiological traits were significant at exposures to 190 mg L^-1 for Mospilan 20 SG and 48 mg L^-1 for Calypso 480 SC. The dose related variation in the ECOD activity of daphnids exposed to the selected neonicotinoid formulations followed a biphasic pattern, with starting effective doses for Mospilan 20 SG of 6.3 mg L^-1 (=1/20 of 48h-EC₅₀ for Daphnia neonates), and for Calypso 480 SC of 0.034 mg L^-1 (=1/4000 of 48h-EC₅₀). Maximal ECOD activity (2.2 fold increase vs. controls) was induced by Mospilan 20 SG in daphnids exposed to 114 mg L^-1 product (=48 h-EC₂₀), and by Calypso 480 SC (1.8 fold increase) at 5.2 mg L^-1 dose (=1/20 of 48 h-EC₅₀). Our results outlined significant alterations in the physiological traits and ECOD activity in exposed daphnids at concentrations below the immobility thresholds (48 h-EC₅₀) of the products used as benchmarks to rate their toxicity risks to aquatic biota. Therefore, we think our findings might deserve consideration in the environmental risk evaluation of these products.

Bioavailability of citalopram to Daphnia magna in the presence of suspended sediments with various properties

The influence of suspended sediment (SPS) properties on the biological effects of antidepressant citalopram (CIT) was investigated in our study. For CIT exposure alone, the feeding behavior, energy available, glutathione-S-transferase (GST) activity of D. magna were vitally induced at 10 μg/L. In the presence of SPS, significant dose-dependent reduction in the ingestion and filtration rates were observed with the increase of SPS concentration, while SPS organic content (f_oc) of 1% exhibited the most serious aggravation. The protein was the main contributor to detoxification and cellular protection under the stress of CIT and SPS. Obvious disturbance effects on the malonaldehyde content, catalase and GST activities were observed for SPS of 0.1 g/L, 60-90 μm and f_oc of 2%. Overall, the important role of SPS properties on the biological effects of CIT should be taken into consideration for the accurate risk assessment of pollutants.

Ecological criteria for assessing the content of petroleum hydrocarbons in the main soils of coniferous-deciduous forests and forest steppe

The effect of pollution of Albicluvisols/Retisols, Calcaric Leptosols, Luvic Phaeozems, Greyzamic Phaeozems and Folic Fluvisols with oil (Solovatovsky oil field, Perm region) added in amounts of 1, 2, 3 and 5 g oil/kg of soil on the organisms was studied in a model laboratory experiment. Oil addition showed phytotoxic effects on root length in Triticum aestivum L., Lepidium sativum L., Picea obovata Ledeb. and Pinus sylvestris L. in all soils. However, oil contamination of Calcaric Leptosols and Greyzamic Phaeozems led to growth stimulation in Picea obovata seedlings. A remarkable shift in the diversity and number of colony-forming units of heterotrophic and oil-oxidizing bacteria was detected in all soil types. The maximum decrease in biodiversity (45%) was noted for heterotrophic bacteria in Luvic Phaeozems. Aqueous extracts from all oil-contaminated soils had a toxic effect on Chlorella vulgaris Beijer, causing an increase in biomass by more than 30%, but did not show acute toxicity on Daphnia magna Straus. Oil addition in the range of 1-3 g oil/kg soil posed no environmental risk to human health. However, oil addition at 5 g oil/kg of soil led to an increase in the level of carcinogenic risk to children to the threshold values of acceptable risk and ranged from 0.95 × 10^-4 for Greyzamic Phaeozems and Folic Fluvisols to 1.098 × 10^-4 for Luvic Phaeozems. Our results suggest that the reaction of test organisms to oil pollution depends on the soil type, and their complex application makes it possible to identify the most sensitive factor and assess the dangerous level of pollution.

Sublethal effects of DBE-DBCH diastereomers on physiology, behavior, and gene expression of Daphnia magna

1,2-dibromo-4-(1,2-dibromoethyl)-cyclohexane (DBE-DBCH) is a brominated flame retardant used in commercial and industrial applications. The use of DBE-DBCH containing products has resulted in an increased release into the environment. However, limited information is available on the long-term effects of DBE-DBCH and its effects in aquatic invertebrates. Thus, the present study was aimed at determining how DBE-DBCH diastereomers (αβ and γδ) affects aquatic invertebrates using Daphnia magna as a model organism. Survival, reproduction, feeding, swimming behavior and toxicogenomic responses to environmental relevant concentrations of DBE-DBCH were analyzed. Chronic exposure to DBE-DBCH resulted in decreased lifespan, and reduced fecundity. Expression of genes involved in reproductive processes, vtg1 and jhe, were also inhibited. DBE-DBCH also induced hypoxia by inhibiting the transcription of genes involved in heme biosynthesis and oxygen transport. Furthermore, DBE-DBCH also inhibited feeding resulting in emptiness of the alimentary canal. Increased expression of the stress response biomarkers was observed following DBE-DBCH exposure. In addition, DBE-DBCH diastereomers also altered the swimming behavior of Daphnia magna. The present study demonstrates that DBE-DBCH cause multiple deleterious effects on Daphnia magna, including effects on reproduction and hormonal systems. These endocrine disrupting effects are in agreement with effects observed on vertebrates. Furthermore, as is the case in vertebrates, DBE-DBCH γδ exerted stronger effects than DBE-DBCH αβ on Daphnia magna. This indicate that DBE-DBCH γδ has properties making it more toxic to all so far studied animals than DBE-DBCH αβ.

Influence of suspended sediment on the bioavailability of benzophenone-3: Focus on accumulation and multi-biological effects in Daphnia magna

The UV-filter benzophenone-3 (BP3) tends to associate with suspended sediment (SPS) due to hydrophobicity, which could alter its toxicological effects on non-target aquatic organisms. In this study, the freshwater cladoceran Daphnia magna (D. magna) was selected as a model organism to investigate the impacts of the source and composition of SPS on the accumulation and multiple toxicological effects (from the molecular level to individual level) of BP3. Among the three components of SPS, amorphous organic carbon (AOC) and minerals promoted the body burden of BP3, while black carbon (BC) inhibited the bioaccumulation. The inhibition effects of BP3 on swimming and feeding behaviors of D. magna were also enhanced due to the presence of AOC and BC. Compared with BP3 exposure alone, higher oxidative stress and neurotoxicity were observed in the presence of SPS containing AOC, BC and minerals, corresponding to that superoxide dismutase, catalase and glutathione-S-transferase activities were further induced, and acetylcholinesterase activity was inhibited. Furthermore, BP3 induced mRNA expression levels of the endocrine system (ecdysone receptor, cytochrome P450 CYP314) and metabolic system (toxicant nuclear receptor HR96, P-glycoprotein), and the presence of SPS containing AOC, BC and minerals exhibited an enhanced effect. Combined with all endpoints, evident relationship was observed between the bioaccumulation level and the response of individual behavior and molecular biomarkers. The results demonstrated that the effects of SPS compositions on bioaccumulation and toxicological effects of organic UV-filters should be considered in aquatic environments.

Physiological endpoints in daphnid acute toxicity tests

Daphnids are freshwater crustaceans used in toxicity tests. Although lethality and immobilisation are the most commonly used endpoints in those tests, more sensitive parameters are required for determination of sublethal acute effects of toxicants. The use of various physiological endpoints in daphnids is considered as a low-cost and simple alternative that meets the 3R's rule (Replacement, Reduction, Refinement) criteria. However, currently there is no review-based evaluation of their applicability in toxicity testing. This paper presents the results on the most commonly determined physiological parameters of Daphnia in ecotoxicological studies and human drug testing, such as feeding activity, thoracic limb movement, heart rate, cardiac area, respiratory activity, compound eye, mandible movements and post-abdominal claw contractions. Furthermore, their applicability as promising endpoints in the assessment of water quality or drug testing is discussed.

The effects of diltiazem on growth, reproduction, energy reserves, and calcium-dependent physiology in Daphnia magna

With the growth of both the pharmaceutical industry and the human population and longevity, more drugs are used and processed each day. Inevitably, these pharmaceuticals enter wastewater through human excretion and improper disposal of leftovers. One such medication, diltiazem, a calcium channel blocker, is of importance due to its widespread consumption, and prevalence in aquatic environments. To study the sub-lethal effects of diltiazem on aquatic animals, we investigated its impacts no feeding behaviour, heart rate, respiration, growth, and reproduction of a bioindicator species, Daphnia magna. When exposed to environmentally relevant concentrations, D. magna increased their heart rate by 12% and oxygen consumption by 48%. However, exposure did not have any effects on thoracic limb movement frequency or peristalsis (i.e. feeding behaviour). Individuals exposed to diltiazem for a longer duration (16 days) showed a 44% decrease in lipid reserves and produced between 17 and 28% fewer neonates which were 10-12% larger. Our study demonstrated that exposure to diltiazem creates an energy imbalance in D. magna which could, in the long run, influence their populations.

Two PBDEs exposure inducing feeding depression and disorder of digestive and antioxidative system of Daphnia magna

2,2',4,4'-tetrabrominated diphenyl ether (BDE-47) and 2,2',4,4',5-pentabromodiphenyl ether (BDE-99) are two typical polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs), and studies have proven that these PBDs can disrupt the behaviors and physical function of aquatic organisms. However, little is known about the compositional impacts of BDE-47/BDE-99 compound pollution on the feeding behavior of Daphnia magna. In this study, a response surface methodology (RSM) was introduced into the combined toxicity assessment of BDE-47 and BDE-99 on the feeding depression of D. magna. Low concentrations of BDE-47 (9.2 μg/L) and BDE-99 (5.4 μg/L) had no effect on the feeding behavior of D. magna; nevertheless, the feeding depression was strengthened, and a concentration-dependent effect was observed with increasing concentrations of BDE-47 and BDE-99. The results of RSM indicated that the mixture of BDE-47 and BDE-99 can enhance their toxicity on the feeding behavior of D. magna. Moreover, real-time PCR (qPCR) analysis showed that the down-regulation of α-amylase (AMS) appeared in most of the exposed D. magna. However, there were significant different in the gene expression of trypsin, superoxide dismutase (SOD) and catalase (CAT) between the exposure and control groups. The change in the enzyme activity of AMS, trypsin, SOD and CAT implied that BDE-47 and BDE-99 cause damage to the digestive and antioxidative systems of D. magna. Correlation analysis indicated that a significant positive correlation existed between the gene expression and enzyme activity of SOD and CAT. Our results contribute to the understanding of toxicity caused by BDE-47/BDE-99 compound pollution in D. magna and help to improve traditional toxicity assessment methods for aquatic environments.

Food up-take and reproduction performance of Daphnia magna under the exposure of Bisphenols

Because the application of Bisphenol A (BPA) was restricted, many substitutes, such as Bisphenol F (BPF) and Bisphenol S (BPS), were developed as BPA substitutes. Therefore, environmental impacts of BPA and its substitutes on aquatic organisms should be concerned, especially their combined toxicity. In this study, the impacts of BPA, BPF, BPS and their mixture on the feeding behavior, reproduction and physiological function of daphnids were synthetically evaluated, involving the duration and mode of exposure. In short-term exposure tests, feeding rates of D. magna decreased after exposure to BPA, BPF, BPS and their mixture, while the inhibition reversed into stimulation in the recovery period. It may benefit from overcompensation of D. magna. In long-term exposure tests, the inhibition effect on the reproduction and growth of the exposed D. magna was difficult to recover, and only some experimental groups have a certain recovery. In conclusion, environmental risk of BPA, BPF, BPS and their mixture on the behavior of D. magna increased with prolonged exposure time. Moreover, relative activities of trypsin, amylase (AMS), acetylcholinesterase (AChE), carbonic anhydrase (CA), glutathione peroxidase (GPx) and super oxidase dimutase (SOD) of the exposed daphnids decreased in most treatment groups, indicating the disorder of digestive, nervous and antioxidative system of D. magna. Interestingly, inhibition of enzymes activities decreased with the increase of the exposure time, which implied the tolerance may be occurred.

Influence of suspended sediment characteristics on the bioaccumulation and biological effects of citalopram in Daphnia magna

The influence of suspended sediment (SPS) characteristics on the bioavailability of the antidepressant citalopram (CIT) was investigated in the cladoceran Daphnia magna. The bioaccumulation, swimming behaviours, psychological indices, and oxidative stress were examined. The CIT bioaccumulation were altered in the presence of SPS, such that the body burden of CIT decreased as the concentration of SPS increased and as the organic carbon content of SPS (f_oc) increased; moreover, the body burden of CIT increased as SPS particle size increased. All the biomarker activities of D. magna were markedly induced at a CIT exposure concentration of 10 μg/L. However, the biological effects of CIT did not depend on the body burden of CIT as SPS concentration increased, while the swimming activities and oxidative stress were significantly enhanced by SPS concentration at 1 g/L. The influences of SPS particle size and f_oc on the activities of swimming and physiological indicators were mainly associated with the CIT bioaccumulation, while f_oc in SPS was more substantial than particle size. In addition, the antioxidant activities decreased as f_oc increased and were significantly strengthened at particle sizes of 30-60 μm. The impacts of different SPS characteristics on the adsorption and desorption capacity of CIT and the ingestion habits of D. magna were the main reasons for the variations in CIT body burden and biological effects. According to the results obtained in this study, the SPS characteristics should be considered in the risk assessment of contaminants in natural aquatic environments.

Effects of Seasonal Changes on the Toxic Impacts of Oil Sands Process-Affected Water on Daphnia magna

Oil sands process-affected water (OSPW), which can be potentially toxic to aquatic biota, is a major by-product of bitumen mining in northern Alberta. The effects of environmental factors on the toxicity of OSPW are understudied. In the present study, the impacts of seasonal changes in water quality on the toxic effects of OSPW (1 and 10%) on Daphnia magna was examined. Animals were chronically exposed to OSPW under conditions that represented water quality of a cold or warm seasonal condition. At each seasonal scenario survival, growth (length and mass) and reproduction of exposed D. magna were investigated. Survival and length of D. magna were only affected by OSPW in the cold-season treatment. Exposure to OSPW reduced the mass of D. magna in both cold and warm season scenarios. Daphnia magna in the cold-season treatment did not reproduce or produce eggs during the course of the experiment. The results of the present study suggest that seasonal changes in water quality may alter the toxicity of OSPW on D. magna.

Effects of gemfibrozil on the growth, reproduction, and energy stores of Daphnia magna in the presence of varying food concentrations

Gemfibrozil, a common lipid regulator, enters aquatic environments through treated municipal wastewater effluent that fails to remove it completely from effluent streams. When exposed to gemfibrozil concentrations of 50, 500, 5,000, and 50,000 ng L^-1, Daphnia magna showed increased lipid reserves by 14-21% (significant at 500 ng L^-1), increased length by 9-13% (significant at 50 ng L^-1), increased mass by 6-13% (significant at 50 ng L^-1) and increased neonate production by 57-74% (significant at 50 ng L^-1). Gemfibrozil-exposed Daphnia held under conditions where food availability was low, grew and reproduced as well as those in the control. Taken together, these results suggest that gemfibrozil exposure within environmentally relevant concentration ranges is not toxic to Daphnia magna but has the potential to be beneficial to the species under these conditions.

Effects of oil sands process-affected water on the respiratory and circulatory system of Daphnia magna Straus, 1820

Millions of cubic meters of oil sands process-affected water (OSPW), the major by-product of oil sand surface mining, is currently stored in tailings ponds. The present study investigated the effects of OSPW on the respiratory and circulatory system of Daphnia magna Straus 1820. The effect of OSPW on the activity (i.e. total movement and active time) of D. magna was also studied, as it has been shown to interact with the respiratory and circulatory system. Daphniids were exposed to both 1 and 10% OSPW for acute (1-day) and chronic (10-day) exposure periods. At the end of the exposures, daphniid oxygen (O₂) consumption, heart rate, hemoglobin (Hb) content and activity were investigated. In response to chronic exposure to 10% OSPW, O₂ consumption of D. magna increased, while the hemoglobin content and activity were reduced in both 1 and 10% OSPW. None of the OSPW treatments changed the heart rate of the test organisms. The results of the present study suggest that in response to increasing metabolic rate caused by OSPW exposure, D. magna conserve their energy by reducing their activity and probably by recycling macromolecules (i.e. hemoglobin).

Investigating the chronic effects of oil sands process-affected water on growth and fitness of Daphnia magna Straus 1820

The increasing amount of stored oil sands process-affected water (OSPW), a primary by-product of oil sands mining, is an environmental concern. In the present study, we investigated the chronic effects of OSPW on growth, reproduction, and macronutrient content in Daphnia magna. To do so, we exposed D. magna to 1 and 10% OSPW (a mixture of three OSPW samples provided by major oil sands mining operators in northern Alberta) for ten days. We measured the number of the neonates produced daily in each group throughout the exposure. At the end of the exposure, we measured the mass and length of the exposed daphniids and neonates. We also measured the carbohydrate, lipid, and protein content of exposed daphniids. In the 10% OSPW group, we observed a significant reduction in all of the measured endpoints except for body length and carbohydrate and protein content of exposed daphniids. In the 1% OSPW group, on the other hand, we found a reduction only in lipid content of exposed daphniids as compared to the control group. The results of the present study demonstrated that chronic exposure to 10% OSPW affects growth and fitness of D. magna, probably due to a reduction in energy intake that causes daphniids to deplete their energy reserves.

Interactive toxicity of Ni, Zn, Cu, and Cd on Daphnia magna at lethal and sub-lethal concentrations

The toxicity of metal mixtures is currently of particular interest among aquatic toxicologists. To provide insight into whether the interaction of multiple metals is similar at different biological levels, the survival and feeding behavior of Daphnia magna were studied following exposure to four metals (Cd, Cu, Ni, Zn) and their binary and quaternary combinations. In terms of survival, Zn-Cu and Cu-Cd mixtures produced more-than-additive mortality, while Ni-Cd mixtures resulted in less-than-additive mortality. Regarding behavior, Zn-Cu and Zn-Cd mixtures produced a more-than-additive reduction in feeding rate. Four (i.e. Zn-Cu, Cu-Cd, Ni-Cd, and Zn-Cd) out of six binary mixtures in the present study interacted differently at the survival and behavioral levels, strengthening the emphasis on carefully selecting the toxicological endpoint when addressing metal mixture toxicity. The results of the present study demonstrated that metals are toxic to feeding behavior of D. magna at much lower concentrations (i.e. 27-63 times lower) compared to survival, suggesting that applying sub-lethal endpoints are required for producing protective regulations.