Influence of process parameters on the heavy metal (Zn2+, Cu2+ and Cr3+) content of struvite obtained from synthetic swine wastewater

Bio-organic substitution in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L) cultivation: Optimum strategy to lower carbon footprint and boost net ecosystem economic benefit

The partial substitution of organic manure for chemical nitrogen fertilizers, known as organic substitution, is widely regarded as a cleaner and more sustainable production strategy. However, few studies have quantified greenhouse gas emissions, product income and net ecosystem economic benefit (NEEB) using a life cycle assessment (LCA) approach, particularly for typical tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) production. Here, we quantified the yield and quality of a typical tobacco production in Qujing, Yunnan, China, through field experiments and calculated its carbon footprint and NEEB using the LCA approach. Four organic substitution strategies were established with equal nitrogen inputs, including synthesized chemical fertilizer (SN), farmyard organic manure (NF), commercial organic manure (NC), and bio-organic (Trichoderma viride Pers.) manure (NT), each substituting 15% of synthesized nitrogen fertilizer. Compared to the SN strategy, the NT strategy significantly increased yield and income by 10.3% and 9.6%, respectively. In contrast, the NF strategy significantly reduced income, while the NC strategy showed no significant difference. Both the NC and NT strategies significantly reduced N2O cumulative emissions (by 15.9% and 8.0%, respectively), increased δSOC (by 38.4% and 15.0%, respectively), and decreased carbon footprint compared to the SN strategy. However, the NF strategy significantly increased the income-scaled carbon footprint, even though it also notably reduced N2O cumulative emissions (by 22.6%) and increased δSOC (by 7.9%). The NT strategy achieved a win-win scenario of low environmental risk and high economic returns of tobacco production with significantly increased NEEB (by 10.6%) compared to the SN strategy (37.60 × 103 CNY yr-1). This suggests that the bio-organic Trichoderma manure substituting 15% synthesized nitrogen fertilizer is the best organic substitution strategy for sustainable tobacco production.

Heavy metal sorption on struvite recovered from livestock wastewaters and release properties of granular forms

Phosphorus recovery from wastewater is receiving more attention due to its non-renewable property. As copper (Cu) and zinc (Zn) usually occur in livestock wastewater, this study focused on metal sorption in struvite from swine wastewater and the release properties of granular struvite in solution with varying pH conditions (2, 4, 7). The results demonstrated pH values presented a slightly decreasing trend with increasing Cu/Zn ratio, and Zn exhibited higher sorption performance on struvite crystals than that of Cu. Under the high content of metals in the wastewater, Cu/Zn ratios in the wastewater contributed to varying metal binding forms and mechanisms, resulting in the difference in the leaching properties of nutrients and metal. For the granular struvite manufactured with the adhesion of alginate, the P release percentage achieved 30.3-40.5% after 96 h in the wastewater of pH 2, whereas they were only 5.63-8.92% and 1.05-1.50% in the wastewater of pH 4 and 7, respectively. Acid wastewater contributed to the release of two metals, and the release amount of Zn was higher than that of Cu, which is associated with their sorption capacity in crystals. During the latter soil leaching test of adding granular struvite, the NH4+-N and PO43--P concentration in the effluent ranged from 0.34 to 1.26 and 0.62 to 2.56 mg/L after 96 h, respectively. However, the Cu and Zn could not be measured due to lower than the detection limit under varying treatments. Struvite might be accompanied by quicker metal leaching and slower nutrient leaching when surface sorption dominates in wastewater with lower metal concentrations.

Electrochemical route outperforms chemical struvite precipitation in mitigating heavy metal contamination

Electrochemically mediated struvite precipitation (EMSP) offers a robust, chemical-free process towards phosphate and ammonium reclamation from nutrients-rich wastewater, i.e., swine wastewater. However, given the coexistence of heavy metal, struvite recovered from wastewater may suffer from heavy metal contamination. Here, we systematically investigated the fate of Cu2+, as a representative heavy metal, in the EMSP process and compared it with the chemical struvite precipitation (CSP) system. The results showed that Cu2+ was 100% transferred from solution to solid phase as a mixture of copper and struvite under pHi 9.5 with 2-20 mg/L Cu2+ in the CSP system, and varying pH would affect struvite production. In the EMSP system, the formation of struvite was not affected by bulk pH, and struvite was much less polluted by co-removed Cu2+ (24.4%) at pHi 7.5, which means we recovered a cleaner and safer product. Specifically, struvite mainly accumulates on the front side of the cathode. In contrast, the fascinating thing is that Cu2+ is ultimately deposited primarily to the back side of the cathode in the form of copper (hydro)oxides due to the distinct thickness of the local high pH layer on the two sides of the cathode. In turn, struvite and Cu (hydro)oxides can be harvested separately from the front and back sides of the cathode, respectively, facilitating the subsequent recycling of heavy metals and struvite. The contrasting fate of Cu2+ in the two systems highlights the merits of EMSP over conventional CSP in mitigating heavy metal pollution on recovered products, promoting the development of EMSP technology towards a cleaner recovery of struvite from waste streams.

Co-precipitation of Cd with struvite during phosphorus recovery

During the struvite recovery process, Cd, a hazardous metal commonly found in waste streams, can be sequestered by struvite. This study investigated the influence of Cd2+ on the precipitation of struvite. Quantitative X-ray diffraction (QXRD) results showed that the purity of struvite decreased from 99.1% to 73.6% as Cd concentration increased from 1 to 500 μM. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) revealed a roughened surface of struvite, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis indicated that the peak area ratio of Cd-OH increased from 19.4% to 51.3%, while the area ratio of Cd-PO4 decreased from 86.6% to 48.7% as Cd concentrations increased from 10 to 500 μM. The findings suggested that Cd2+ disrupted the crystal growth of struvite, and mainly combined with -OH and -PO4 to form amorphous Cd-bearing compounds co-precipitated with struvite. Additionally, Mg-containing amorphous phases were formed by incorporating Mg2+ with -OH and -PO4 during struvite formation.

Phosphorus recovery from aqueous product of hydrothermal carbonization of cow manure

The work studies the recovery of nutrients (phosphorus and nitrogen) from the process water of acid-assisted hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) of cow manure. Three organic acids (formic acid, oxalic acid, and citric acid) and sulfuric acid were evaluated as additives in HTC. Using 0.3 M sulfuric acid, more than 99% of phosphorus and 15.6% of nitrogen from manure are extracted and dissolved during HTC at 170 °C with 10 min reaction time in a batch reactor. Nutrients (mainly phosphorus) were recovered through precipitation from process water by raising the ionic strength of the solution by addition of salts of magnesium and ammonia, and by raising the pH to 9.5. Subsequently, phosphorus-rich solids were recovered containing almost all (greater than 95%) of the dissolved phosphorus in the sulfuric and formic acid assisted runs. Morphology and qualitative chemical analysis of the precipitates were determined. It is shown by XRD that the precipitate formed from process water generated by HTC with oxalic acid is crystalline, although the diffraction pattern could not be matched with any expected substance.

Non-thermal plasma activated peroxide and percarbonate for tetracycline and oxytetracycline degradation: Synergistic performance, degradation pathways, and toxicity evaluation

Tetracycline (TC) and Oxytetracycline (OTC) are common antibiotics increasingly detected in the environment, posing a potential risk to human and aquatic lives. Although conventional methods such as adsorption and photocatalysis are used for the degradation of TC and OTC, they are inefficient in removal efficiency, energy yield, and toxic byproduct generation. Herein, a falling-film dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) reactor coupled with environmentally friendly oxidants (hydrogen peroxide (HPO), sodium percarbonate (SPC), and HPO + SPC) was applied, and the treatment efficiency of TC and OTC was investigated. Experimental results showed that moderate addition of the HPO and SPC exhibited a synergistic effect (SF > 2), significantly improving the antibiotic removal ratio, total organic removal ratio (TOC), and energy yield by more than 50%, 52%, and 180%, respectively. After 10 min of DBD treatment, the introduction of 0.2 mM SPC led to a 100% antibiotic removal ratio and a TOC removal of 53.4% and 61.2% for 200 mg/L TC and 200 mg/L OTC, respectively. Also, 1 mM HPO dosage led to 100% antibiotic removal ratios after 10 min of DBD treatment and a TOC removal of 62.4% and 71.9% for 200 mg/L TC and 200 mg/L OTC, respectively. However, the DBD + HPO + SPC treatment method had a detrimental effect on the performance of the DBD reactor. After 10 min of DBD plasma discharge, the removal ratios for TC and OTC were 80.8% and 84.1%, respectively, when 0.5 mM HPO +0.5 mM SPC was added. Moreover, principal component and hierarchical cluster analysis confirmed the differences between the treatment methods. Furthermore, the concentration of oxidant-induced in-situ generated ozone and hydrogen peroxide were quantitatively determined, and their indispensable roles during the degradation process were established via radical scavenger tests. Finally, the synergetic antibiotic degradation mechanisms and pathways were proposed, and the toxicities of the intermediate byproducts were evaluated.

Competitive adsorption of heavy metals between Ca-P and Mg-P products from wastewater during struvite crystallization

Wastewater usually contains high concentration of calcium (Ca), posing a competitive reaction with magnesium (Mg) on phosphorus (P) recovery during the struvite crystallization. The differences in the adsorption of heavy metals by Ca-P and Mg-P (struvite) generated are still unclear. Herein, we analyzed the residues of four kinds of common heavy metals (Cu, Zn, Cd, Pb) in Ca-P and Mg-P (struvite) under varying conditions (solution pH, N/P ratio, Mg/Ca ratio) in the swine wastewater and explored their possible competitive adsorption mechanisms. The experiments using synthetic wastewater and real wastewater have similar experimental patterns. However, under the same conditions, the metal (Pb) content of struvite recovered from the synthetic wastewater (16.58 mg/g) was higher than that of the real wastewater (11.02 mg/g), as predicted by the Box-Behnken Design of Response Surface Methodology (BBD-RSM). The results demonstrated that Cu was the least abundant in the precipitates compared to Zn, Cd, and Pb of almost all experimental groups with an N/P ratio greater than or equal to 10. The fact might be mainly attributed to the its stronger binding capacity of Cu ion with NH₃ and other ligands. Compared with struvite, the Ca-P product had a higher adsorption capacity for heavy metals and a lower P recovery rate. In addition, the higher solution pH and N/P ratio were favorable to obtain qualified struvite with lower heavy metal content. It can be applied to reduce the incorporation of heavy metals by modulating pH and N/P ratio through RSM, which is suitable for different Mg/Ca ratios. It is anticipated that the results obtained would offer support for the safe utility of struvite from wastewater containing Ca and heavy metals.

Interaction of divalent metals with struvite: sorption, reversibility, and implications for mineral recovery from wastes

Phosphorus (P) recovered from wastewater as struvite (MgNH₄PO₄·6H₂O) can meet high P demands in the agricultural sector by reuse as a P fertiliser. Heavy metals are prevalent in wastewaters and are common fertiliser contaminants, therefore struvite as a sorbent for metals requires evaluation. Struvite sorption experiments were conducted in model solutions with cadmium (Cd), cobalt (Co), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), and zinc (Zn) at 1-5 μM concentrations from pH 7-10. The struvite metal loading increased with dissolved metal concentration and pH, ranging from 2 to 493 mg kg^-1. Highest loadings were observed for 5 μM Pb, which exceeded the 120 mg kg^-1 European Union (EU) struvite fertiliser limit at all pH values. At 5 μM concentrations, Ni and Cd loadings exceeded EU limits of 100 mg kg^-1 at pH 10, and 60 mg kg^-1 at pH 8-10, respectively. In desorption experiments, 10-85% metal was released after resuspension in metal-free solutions, with a positive correlation between initial loading and amount desorbed. Distortions of the struvite phosphate band, by Fourier transformation infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, indicated lowered symmetry of phosphate vibrations with metal sorption. X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy (XAFS) analysis of pH 9 solids indicated tetrahedral coordination for Cu and Zn, octahedral coordination for Co and Ni, and Pb in 9-fold coordination. Precipitation of Pb-phosphate minerals was a primary mechanism for Pb sorption. The results provide insight into metal contaminant sorption with struvite in wastewaters, and the potential for metal desorption after recovery.

Co-precipitation of heavy metals with struvite from digested swine wastewater: Role of suspended solids

Struvite production can recover ammonia and phosphorous from digested wastewater as fertilizer. During struvite generation, most of the heavy metals was co-precipitated with ammonia and phosphorous into struvite. Understanding the precipitation behavior of heavy metals with suspended solids (SS) might provide the possible strategy for the control of co-precipitation. In this study, the distribution of heavy metals in SS and their role on the co-precipitation during struvite recovery from digested swine wastewater were investigated. The results showed that the concentration of heavy metal (including Mn, Zn, Cu, Ni, Cr, Pb and As) ranged from 0.05 to 17.05 mg/L in the digested swine wastewater. The distribution analysis showed that SS with particles > 50 μm harbored most of individual heavy metal (41.3-55.6%), followed by particles 0.45-50 μm (20.9-43.3%), and SS-removed filtrate (5.2-32.9%). During struvite generation, 56.9-80.3% of individual heavy metal was co-precipitated into struvite. The contributions of SS with particles > 50 μm, 0.45-50 μm, and SS-removed filtrate on the individual heavy metal co-precipitation were 40.9-64.3%, 25.3-48.3% and 1.9-22.9%, respectively. These finding provides potential way for controlling the co-precipitation of heavy metals in struvite.

Nutrient released characteristics of struvite-biochar fertilizer produced from concentrated sludge supernatant by fluidized bed reactor

With the exacerbating water eutrophication globally, it is important to recover nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) from sewage for recycle. In this study, coconut shell biochar and ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) were added into the designed fluidized bed reactor (FBR) to create struvite-biochar. N and P released from struvite-biochar and the recovery efficiency of N and P from concentrated sludge supernatant were analyzed. Results showed that the optimal operation condition for hydraulic retention time (HRT), pH, Mg/P molar ration, and addition amount EDTA were 90 min, 9.5, 1.2, and 0.2 g/L, respectively. The recovery efficiency of NH₄⁺-N and PO₄^3--P, and purity struvite for FBR were 34.41%-38.05%, 64.95-68.40%, and 84.15%, respectively. The recovery efficiency of NH₄⁺-N and PO₄^3--P were respectively increased by 7.23% and 5.36% when FBR with addition of 0.33 g/L coconut shell biochar, but purity struvite from struvite-biochar decreased by 45.70%. Contents of As, Cd, Pb, and Cr in struvite and struvite-biochar were all lower than Chinese Standard Limits of Fertilizer. Compared to commercial chemical fertilizer, such as superphosphate and urea, struvite-biochar and struvite have slowly released N and P. The amounts of released P, NO₃^--N and NH₄⁺-N from struvite-biochar were higher than struvite during the five leaching times. Compared with struvite, the total amounts of released P, NO₃^--N and NH₄⁺-N from struvite-biochar increased by 4.9%, 3.5% and 8.3%, respectively. Therefore, it is valuable to add biochar into FBR to recovery N and P from concentrated sludge supernatant and make struvite-biochar as a slow-release fertilizer.

Phosphorus recovery as K-struvite from a waste stream: A review of influencing factors, advantages, disadvantages and challenges

Currently, the depletion of natural resources and contamination of the surrounding environment demand a paradigm shift to resource recycling and reuse. In this regard, phosphorus (P) is a model nutrient that possesses the negative traits of depletion (will be exhausted in the next 100 years) and environmental degradation (causes eutrophication and climate change), and this has prompted the scientific community to search for options to solve P-related problems. To date, P recovery in the form of struvite from wastewater is one viable solution suggested by many scholars. Struvite can be recovered either in the form of NH₄-struvite (MgNH₄PO₄•6H₂O) or K-struvite (MgKPO₄•6H₂O). From struvite, K (MgKPO₄•6H₂O) and N (MgNH₄PO₄•6H₂O) are important nutrients for plant growth, but N is more abundant in the environment than K (the soil's most limited nutrient), which requires a systematic approach during P recovery. Although K-struvite recovery is a promising approach, information related to its crystallization is deficient. Here, we present the general concept of P recovery as struvite and details about K-struvite, such as the source of nutrients, factors (pH, molar ratio, supersaturation, temperature, and seeding), advantages (environmental, economic, and social), disadvantages (heavy metals, pathogenic organisms, and antibiotic resistance genes), and challenges (scale-up and acceptance). Overall, this study provides insights into state-of-the-art K-struvite recovery from wastewater as a potential slow-release fertilizer that can be used as a macronutrient (P-K-Mg) source for plants as commercial grade-fertilizers.

Oyster Shell Modified Tobacco Straw Biochar: Efficient Phosphate Adsorption at Wide Range of pH Values

In order to improve the phosphate adsorption capacity of Ca-loaded biochar at a wide range of pH values, Ca (oyster shell) was loaded as Ca(OH)2 on the tobacco stalk biochar (Ca-BC), which was prepared by high-temperature calcination, ultrasonic treatment, and stirring impregnation method. The phosphorus removal performance of Ca-BC adsorption was studied by batch adsorption experiments, and the mechanism of Ca-BC adsorption and phosphorus removal was investigated by SEM-EDS, FTIR, and XRD. The results showed that after high-temperature calcination, oyster shells became CaO, then converted into Ca(OH)2 in the process of stirring impregnation and had activated the pore expansion effect of biochar. According to the Langmuir model, the adsorption capacity of Ca-BC for phosphate was 88.64 mg P/g, and the adsorption process followed pseudo-second-order kinetics. The Ca(OH)2 on the surface of biochar under the initial pH acidic condition preferentially neutralizes with H+ acid-base in solution, so that Ca-BC chemically precipitates with phosphate under alkaline conditions, which increases the adsorption capacity by 3-15 times compared with other Ca-loaded biochar. Ca-BC phosphate removal rate of livestock wastewater (pig and cattle farms) is 91~95%, whereas pond and domestic wastewater can be quantitatively removed. This study provides an experimental basis for efficient phosphorus removal by Ca-modified biochar and suggesting possible applications in real wastewater.

Sustainable and efficient technologies for removal and recovery of toxic and valuable metals from wastewater: Recent progress, challenges, and future perspectives

Due to their numerous effects on human health and the natural environment, water contamination with heavy metals and metalloids, caused by their extensive use in various technologies and industrial applications, continues to be a huge ecological issue that needs to be urgently tackled. Additionally, within the circular economy management framework, the recovery and recycling of metals-based waste as high value-added products (VAPs) is of great interest, owing to their high cost and the continuous depletion of their reserves and natural sources. This paper reviews the state-of-the-art technologies developed for the removal and recovery of metal pollutants from wastewater by providing an in-depth understanding of their remediation mechanisms, while analyzing and critically discussing the recent key advances regarding these treatment methods, their practical implementation and integration, as well as evaluating their advantages and remaining limitations. Herein, various treatment techniques are covered, including adsorption, reduction/oxidation, ion exchange, membrane separation technologies, solvents extraction, chemical precipitation/co-precipitation, coagulation-flocculation, flotation, and bioremediation. A particular emphasis is placed on full recovery of the captured metal pollutants in various reusable forms as metal-based VAPs, mainly as solid precipitates, which is a powerful tool that offers substantial enhancement of the remediation processes' sustainability and cost-effectiveness. At the end, we have identified some prospective research directions for future work on this topic, while presenting some recommendations that can promote sustainability and economic feasibility of the existing treatment technologies.

Influence of cobalt chloride and ferric citrate on purple non-sulfur bacteria Rhodopseudomonas yavorovii

Heavy metals that enter the environment due to natural processes or industrial activities, when accumulated, have a negative impact on organisms, including microorganisms. Microorganisms have developed various adaptations to heavy metal compounds. The aim of our work was to investigate the influence of ferric citrate and cobalt (II) chloride on biomass accumulation, indicators of free radical damage and activity of enzymes of the antioxidant defense system of bacteria Rhodopseudomonas yavorovii IMV B-7620, that were isolated from the water of Yavorivske Lake (Ukraine, Lviv region), which was formed as a result of flooding of a sulfur quarry. We used cultural, photometric methods, and statistical processing of the results was performed using two-way ANOVA and factor analysis. It was found that ferric citrate at a concentration of 1–12 mM causes inhibition of the accumulation of biomass of bacteria Rh. yavorovii IMV B-7620 up to 44.7%, and cobalt (II) chloride at a concentration of 1–15 mM – up to 70.4%, compared with the control. The studied concentrations of ferric citrate and cobalt (II) chloride cause free radical damage to lipids and proteins of Rh. yavorovii IMV B-7620. As a result of two-way ANOVA we found that under the influence of ferric citrate statistically significant changes in biomass accumulation, lipid hydroperoxides and thiobarbiturate reactive species content, superoxide dismutase activity were predetermined by increasing the concentration of metal salts as well as increasing the duration of cultivation of bacteria, while the content of diene conjugates and catalase activity changed with increasing duration of cultivation. Under the influence of cobalt (II) chloride, statistically significant changes in all studied indicators were found both due to the increase in the concentration of metal salts and with increasing duration of bacterial cultivation. The studied parameters of Rh. yavorovii IMV B-7620 cells under the influence of ferric citrate and cobalt (II) chloride are combined into two factors, that explain 95.4% and 99.2% of the total data variance, respectively. Under the influence of ferric citrate, the first latent factor included diene conjugates, thiobarbiturate reactive species, carbonyl groups in proteins, which are closely linked by a direct bond and inversely related to the content of lipid hydroperoxides and catalase activity. The second latent factor included duration of cultivation of bacteria, biomass accumulation, and superoxide dismutase activity, which are inversely related to lipid hydroperoxide content and catalase activity. Under the influence of cobalt (II) chloride, the first latent factor included the content of lipid hydroperoxides, carbonyl groups in proteins, as well as catalase and superoxide dismutase activities, which are inversely related to bacterial biomass.

Effects of Application of Pig Manure on the Accumulation of Heavy Metals in Rice

Pig manure (PM) is often highly enriched in heavy metals, such as Cu and Zn, due to the wide use of feed additives. To study the potential risks of heavy metal accumulation in the soil and rice grains by the application of PM and other organic manure, a four-year field experiment was conducted in the suburb of Shanghai, southeast China. The contents of Cu, Zn, Pb, and Cd in the soils and rice plants by the treatments of PM and fungal culturing residues (FCR) show a trend of annual increase. Those in the soils and rice by the PM treatment are raised even more significantly. Cu and Zn contents in the soil and rice roots by the PM are significantly higher than those by the non-fertilizer control (CK) during the four years, and Pb and Cd also significantly higher than CK in the latter two years. Heavy metals taken up by the rice plants are mostly retained in the roots. Cu and Zn contents in the rice plants are in the decreasing order of roots > grains > stems > leaves, and Pb and Cd in the order of roots > stems > leaves > grains. Cu, Zn, Pb, and Cd contents in the soils by the PM treatment increase by 73%, 32%, 106%, and 127% on annual average, and those in the brown rice by 104%, 98%, 275%, and 199%, respectively. The contents of Cu, Zn, Pb, and Cd in the brown rice of the treatments are significantly correlated with those in the soils and rice roots (p < 0.05), suggesting the heavy metals accumulated in the rice grains come from the application of PM and FCR. Though the contents of heavy metals in the brown rice during the four experimental years are still within the safe levels, the risks of their accumulative increments, especially by long-term application of PM, can never be neglected.

Efficient reclaiming phosphate from aqueous solution using waste limestone modified sludge biochar: Mechanism and application as soil amendments

A novel limestone-modified biochar derived from sewage sludge was prepared to reclaim phosphorus (P) from aqueous solution, and the potential application of P-laden biochar as soil amendments was also investigated. The limestone-modified biochar demonstrated excellent performance on phosphate recovery from aqueous solution in a wide range of pH (2.0-11.0), with maximum adsorption capacity of the biochar (Limestone/sludge mass ratio of 3:1) up to 231.28 mg P/g, which was 10.7 times that of the original sludge biochar. The adsorption was well described by the pseudo second-order model and Langmuir isotherm model. According to the adsorption thermodynamic parameters, the phosphate adsorption was spontaneous (ΔG⁰ < 0) and endothermic (ΔH⁰ > 0) so that increasing the temperature was beneficial to adsorption. Characterization analysis by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), X-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscope-energy dispersive spectrometer (SEM-EDS) proved that electrostatic attraction, surface complexation and brushite (CaHPO₄^.2H₂O) precipitation were the dominant mechanism. The P-laden biochar exhibited an excellent ability to be reused as a new slow-release P fertilizer for soil. Pot experiment results showed that the treatment of P-laden LB 3:1 (P content of 22.8%) addition (1 wt%) significantly promoted Indian Lettuce germination (increasing by 14.4%), plant height (increasing by 18.6%), and dry biomass (53.0%) compared with the control, though it underperformed compared to commercial fertilizer.

A review on the incorporation and potential mechanism of heavy metals on the recovered struvite from wastewater

Phosphorus, as a non-renewable element, is flowing out too fast in the past decades. To sustain the development of this globally scarce resource, efficient measures were taken to recover more phosphorus in the struvite form from wastewater. However, heavy metals in the wastewater might produce an inhibitory effect on phosphorus recovery, and even worse, pollutants might be incorporated in/onto the crystals precipitated. Impurities on struvite will reduce the quality of struvite as a potential slow-release fertilizer and affect the safe application of struvite in agriculture. This review aims to identify the trends in the literature to present the residues of heavy metals in struvite. It summarizes the current status in the residues of main metal elements on crystals and its response to wastewater properties, composition, and oxidation state of metals. The adsorption process and potential adsorption mechanism of heavy metals during the struvite crystallization are deeply explored, which might determine the latter release rate of metals when applying into the soil. Possible solutions are further provided to minimize the amounts of heavy metals mainly through adjusting operational conditions or employing pretreatment methods. Finally, this review critically analyzes the limitation gap between theory and actual generalization and potential application of struvite products in the market, and corresponding perspectives in the future are given to safely utilize the phosphorus resource from wastewater in the form of struvite.

Impact of a super typhoon on heavy metal distribution, migration, availability in agricultural soils

Heavy metal contamination in agricultural soils is a worldwide concerned environmental issue. However, a short-term extreme hydrodynamic event (e.g., a super typhoon) may significantly affect the distribution, migration, and availability of heavy metals in agriculture soils on a large scale. The limited understanding of such an impact prevents effective environment survey, risk assessment, and remediation strategy for heavy metal contaminated soils. Here, we show a massive migration of heavy metals during a super typhoon (Lekima) based on the field investigation, simulated experiments, and isotopic fingerprinting. The contaminations of heavy metals (Cd, Zn, Cu, Ni, Cr and As) of agricultural soils at 209 sampling sites over 3.59 × 10⁵ km², were significantly relieved by 10.3-42.0 % after the typhoon, because of the primary contribution of runoff erosion over interflow according to the simulated soil erosions. However, the available fractions (as % of the total amount of each metal) were metal-dependent, with Cd, Zn, Cu, and Ni increased (5.3-26.4 %), and Cr and As decreased (0.9-3.5 %). In contrary, the Pb contamination was slightly aggravated by 8.7 % after the typhoon, and the Pb isotopic signatures indicate its input and migration via wet precipitation and surface runoff. The soil properties (e.g., pH and organic matter) showed limited impact on the migration of heavy metals during this typhoon. These results suggest that a natural short-term extreme hydrodynamic event can drive the massive migration of heavy metals in agricultural soils and their trade-off with other environmental medias, providing valuable information for multi-medias environmental risk assessment and cooperative remediation that can be significantly disturbed by such an event.

Application of co-pyrolysis biochar for the adsorption and immobilization of heavy metals in contaminated environmental substrates

Heavy metal pollution has been considered as a serious threat to the environment and human in the past decades due to its toxic and unbiodegradable properties. Recently, extensive studies have been carried out on the removal of heavy metals, and various adsorption materials have been successfully developed. Among, biochar is a promising option because of its advantages of various biomass sources, abundant microporous channels and surface functional groups, as well as its attractive economic feasibility. However, the application of pristine biochar is limited by its low adsorption capacity and nonregenerative property. Co-pyrolysis biochar, produced from the pyrolysis of biomass with the addition of another biomass or non-biomass precursor, is potential in overcoming the limitation of pristine biochar and achieving superior performance for heavy metal adsorption and immobilization. Therefore, this article summarizes the recent advances in development and applications of co-pyrolysis biochar for adsorption and immobilization of various heavy metals in contaminated environmental substrates. In details, the production, characteristics and advantages of co-pyrolysis biochar are initially presented. Subsequently, the adsorption behaviors and mechanisms of different heavy metals (including Hg, Zn, Pb, Cu, Cd, Cr, As, etc.) in flue gas and wastewater by co-pyrolysis biochar are reviewed, as well as factors influencing their adsorption capacities. Meanwhile, the immobilization of heavy metals in both biochar itself and contaminated soils by co-pyrolysis biochar is discussed. Finally, the limitations of current studies and future prospects are proposed. It aims at providing a guideline for the exploitation and application of cost-effective and environmental-friendly co-pyrolysis biochar in the decontamination of environmental substrates.

Nutrient recovery from the digestate obtained by rumen fluid enhanced anaerobic co-digestion of sewage sludge and cattail: Precipitation by MgCl2 and ion exchange using zeolite

The aim of this study was to recover nutrients (NPK and other) from the liquid fraction of digestate obtained by rumen fluid enhanced anaerobic co-digestion of sewage sludge and cattail (Typha latifolia grass). Firstly, anaerobic digestion (AD) studies were performed to examine the biogas potential of selected substrates. The liquid fraction of digestate was then used in nutrient recovery experiments. Four methods were applied to recover nutrients: i) conventional struvite precipitation by MgCl₂, ii) simultaneous precipitation and ion exchange by Na-zeolite, and iii) two-step recovery using precipitation, followed by ion exchange with powdered or iv) granulated Na-zeolite. The products of nutrient recovery were characterised using different chemical methods and the cress seed germination test was performed to evaluate their fertility potential. The results show that co-digestion of sewage sludge with cattail enhanced biogas production by almost 50 vol%. The addition of rumen fluid positively contributed to the degradation of lignocellulosic materials and to biogas production. In all of the recovery methods tested, phosphorus was successfully recovered with efficiency of more than 99 wt%. Nitrogen recovery was less efficient than phosphorus recovery, 85-92 wt%. Simultaneous precipitation and ion exchange lowered nitrogen recovery efficiency compared to classical struvite precipitation, while sequential precipitation and ion exchange resulted in improvement. The most efficient method was two-step recovery using granulated zeolite. The precipitates consisted of different Mg and K-phosphates in quite irregular shapes. The struvite and K-struvite were detected in low quantities. The precipitates contained more than 25 wt% of macronutrients (NPK), exhibited effective utilization of nutrients by plants, and showed good fertility potential. Precipitate mixed with powdered Na-zeolite promises to be interesting for further agricultural use, as zeolite offers several potential improvements for soil. Both zeolites exhibited good performance in the recovery of K⁺ ions.

Co-precipitation of Cu and Zn in precipitation of struvite

Struvite recovered from wastewater can be used as a slow-release fertilizer. Nevertheless, hazardous metals easily precipitated with struvite would increase the ecological risk for its agricultural use. In this study, the influence of individual and coexistence of Cu and Zn on the precipitation of struvite was investigated. The loading of Cu and/or Zn in precipitates increased with the increase of initial metal concentrations (0.1-100 mg/L). Quantitative X-ray diffraction (QXRD) analysis revealed that the increase of Cu and/or Zn level in reaction solution disturbed crystal growth of struvite and promoted the formation of amorphous phase(s). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) revealed the pit formation on struvite crystal surfaces, combined with X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) data, the results indicated a surface interaction for the formation of Cu-OH and Cu-NH₃ on struvite surface at Cu of 0.1-10 mg/L. With the increase of Cu to 25-100 mg/L, the precipitation of amorphous Cu phosphate(s) was confirmed by XPS and QXRD. At Zn of 0.1-10 mg/L, the enrichment of Zn-PO₄ and Zn-OH on struvite surface was observed, whereas, the precipitation of amorphous Zn hydroxide(s) was confirmed at Zn of 25-100 mg/L. At Cu and Zn co-existed solution, the decrease of Cu-PO₄ and increase of Zn-PO₄ suggested the competitive binding of PO₄ between Cu and Zn. In addition, the formation of amorphous Mg hydroxide(s) and phosphate(s) was detected regardless of the addition of Cu in solutions. The overall results revealed that the existence of Cu and Zn during struvite formation can greatly affect its content by formation of different metal-containing products.

New insights into interactions of organic substances in poultry slurry with struvite formation: An overestimated concern?

The high content of organic substances in strength agro-industrial wastewater has been documented to be among the major barriers hampering nutrient recovery efficiency of struvite precipitation. However, our results in this study show that the previously reported negative impacts of organic substances in high-strength agricultural wastewater on struvite precipitation might be overestimated. This study is the first to test the influence of three forms of organic substances from real high-strength wastewater that contains a complex of particulate, colloidal and soluble organic substances, on nutrient recovery efficiency and product quality through struvite precipitation at varying pH conditions. Our results demonstrated that the inhibition of organic substances on struvite formation only happens at the pH levels of <9.0 with recovery reduction of PO₄^3- (5-15%) and NH₄⁺ (6-13%). The inhibitory effect of the organic substances at the optimal pH range (9.5-10) reported from the literature review is only ≤5%. Moreover, the transformation in the contents of humic- and protein-like substances with an increment in pH was characterized and may contribute to mitigate the inhibition of nutrient recovery. Even though the particulate and colloidal organic substances slowed the precipitation reaction, they substantially increased the particle size (i.e., 70% and 40%, respectively) of the formed struvite. The presence of organic substances in all tested forms does not significantly influence the purity and crystalline structure of struvite which can still be used as a slow-releasing fertilizer. Regarding the relocation process of organic substances during struvite precipitation under varying pH conditions, understanding the interaction between organics and heavy metals which in turn affect the dynamics of heavy metals in solution and precipitates remains limited; thus, additional research is needed.

Struvite production from anaerobic digestate of piggery wastewater using ferronickel slag as a magnesium source

This study aimed to fully recover ammonia contained at a high concentration in anaerobic digestate of piggery wastewater (ADPW) by forming struvite. As magnesium and phosphorus sources, ferronickel slag (FNS) and K₂HPO₄ were used, respectively. By leaching 200 g L^-1 of FNS with 3.0 M H₂SO₄, 10,309 mg L^-1 of magnesium ions were extracted, and this acid-leachate of FNS (FNSL) also contained 5965 mg L^-1 of total iron. In order to simultaneously remove both high concentrations of organic matters in ADPW and iron in FNSL which were known to hinder struvite formation, the mixture of ADPW and FNSL was added with H₂O₂ at the H₂O₂/Fe molar ratio of 0.75 and pH 4.0. After Fenton reaction, removal efficiencies of COD and total iron reached 77.36% and 99.89%, respectively. Then COD and an iron-reduced mixture of ADPW and FNSL were added with K₂HPO₄ satisfying Mg:N:P molar ratio of 1.2:1:1.15 at pH 9.5 to produce struvite for 1 h. From 1 L of ADPW (2.21 g NH₃-N), 0.65 L of FNSL (4.65 g Mg²⁺), and 5.63 g of PO₄ ^3-P, 46.7 g of precipitates were obtained. Overall removal efficiencies of magnesium, NH₃-N, and phosphorus were 98.59%, 94.25%, and 99.97%, respectively. Obtained precipitates were analysed by using XRD, XRF, SEM-EDX and found to be struvite with impurities of potassium and metals. Additionally, the economic feasibility of FNS was assessed by estimating chemical costs of various magnesium sources.

Struvite Precipitation for Sustainable Recovery of Nitrogen and Phosphorus from Anaerobic Digestion Effluents of Swine Manure

In this study, we propose the application of struvite precipitation for the sustainable recovery of nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) from anaerobic digestion (AD) effluents derived from swine manure. The optimal conditions for four major factors that affect the recovery of N and P were derived by conducting batch experiments on AD effluents obtained from four AD facilities. The optimal conditions were a pH of 10.0, NH4-N:Mg:PO4-P molar ratio of 1:1.4:1, mixing intensity of 240 s−1, and mixing duration of 2 min. Under these optimal conditions, the removal efficiencies of NH4-N and PO4-P were approximately 74% and 83%, respectively, whereas those of Cu and Zn were approximately 74% and 79%, respectively. Herein, a model for swine manure treatment that incorporates AD, struvite precipitation, and biological treatment processes is proposed. We applied this model to 85 public biological treatment facilities in South Korea and recovered 4722 and 51 tons/yr of NH4-N and PO4-P, respectively. The economic analysis of the proposed model’s performance predicts a lack of profitability due to the high cost of chemicals; however, this analysis does not consider the resulting protection of the hydrological environment. Field-scale studies should be conducted in future to prove the effectiveness of the model.

Persulfate oxidation for alternative sludge treatment and nutrient recovery: An assessment of technical and economic feasibility

The introduce of tighter waste disposal regulations and increasing resource scarcity make the re-utilization of waste activated sludge a hot and crucial research topic. Compared with traditional sludge disposal technologies (e.g. landfill and incineration), advanced oxidation processes have been proven to be an environmentally friendly method for sludge stabilization and disintegration. However, the effectiveness of persulfate oxidation for sludge degradation, and the re-utilization of its embedded nutrients have been rarely reported. Therefore, this work is to investigate the technical and economic feasibility of using persulfate oxidation and struvite precipitation for sludge degradation and nutrient recovery. The results show that with the assistance of ultraviolet radiation, released phosphate and ammonia nitrogen from sludge could reach 233.4 and 265.6 mg/L. Besides, 92.8% phosphate and 32.6% ammonia-nitrogen could be recovered by struvite precipitation at a pH of 9.5, with an Mg: P molar ratio of 1.1:1. The economic analysis shows that the operational cost of the proposed process was 25% higher than traditional sludge disposal (267.5 $/ton), but its capital investment is much lower. Investigations on chemical dosage minimization, energy reclamation and process optimization are suggested to reduce the process's operating cost in the future.

Fungal community composition change and heavy metal accumulation in response to the long-term application of anaerobically digested slurry in a paddy soil

Anaerobically digested slurry (ADS) has been widely used as a liquid fertilizer in agroecosystems. However, there is scant information on the effects of successive ADS applications on heavy metals (HMs) accumulation and fungal community composition in paddy soils. In this study, we conducted a field experiment over 10 years to assess the changes in soil HMs and fungal community composition under the long-term application of ADS in a paddy field. The four treatments were (1) no fertilizer (CK); (2) mineral fertilizer and 270 kg N ha^-1 from urea (MF); (3) 270 kg N ha^-1 from ADS (ADS1); and (4) 540 kg N ha^-1 from ADS (ADS2). The results revealed that ADS application improved paddy soil fertility compared to that under the MF treatment by increasing soil organic C (SOC), total N (TN) and available potassium (AK). Long-term application of ADS significantly increased soil total and available Zn (TZn and AZn) concentrations as compared to those under the MF treatment. However, there were no significant differences in the total and available Cu concentrations or the total Pb concentration between the ADS and MF treatments. Sequence analysis showed that application of ADS increased the fungal richness indexes (Chao1 and ACE) compared to MF treatment. Principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) showed that the soil fungal community compositions were significantly separated by high levels of ADS application. Long-term application of ADS increased the relative abundance of classes Sordariomycetes, Dothideomycetes and Agaricomycetes by 20.8-29.0%, 107.3-141.4% and 289.5-387.5%, respectively, but decreased that of Pezizomycetes by 14.0-33.0% compared to that under the MF treatment. At the genus level, compared to those under the MF treatment, the relative abundances of Pyrenochaetopsis and Myrothecium were significantly increased by the application of ADS, but those of Mrakia and Tetracladium were significantly decreased. Redundancy analysis (RDA) revealed that SOC, AZn and AP were the three most important factors affecting the fungal community composition of the paddy soil. Our findings suggested that fungal community composition could be affected by changes in the chemical properties and heavy metal contents of paddy soil under high application of ADS in the long term.

Assessing the sustainability of phosphorus use in China: Flow patterns from 1980 to 2015

Phosphorus is vital for living creatures and will run out in the next few hundred years. The imbalanced phosphate rock distribution and inefficient consumption make phosphorus management of great importance. As China has an undeniable influence on global phosphorus production and consumption, understanding its changing historical patterns is critical for phosphorus resource management and water quality improvement. However, most existing research focus on anthropogenic phosphorus flows in the agricultural sector for a specific year, making the evaluation of such changes difficult. Therefore, substance flow analysis and principal component analysis for phosphorus flows between 1980 and 2015 were performed to understand phosphorus consumption structure change and the build-up of legacy phosphorus in China. The results show that although China's phosphorus utilization efficiency has decreased over time, it is still higher than in most other countries. The research also demonstrates the effectiveness of combining multiyear substance flow analysis and principal component analysis to improve the transparency of identifying underlying consumption structure change during resource management.

Effect of Ca:Mg ratio and high ammoniacal nitrogen on characteristics of struvite precipitated from waste activated sludge digester effluent

This study revealed the relationship between the presence of calcium impurities and ammoniacal nitrogen concentration upon crystallization of struvite. The research hypothesis was that the presence of both calcium and high concentrations of ammoniacal nitrogen (328-1000 mg/L) in waste activated sludge may influence the struvite quality and acid stability. Hence, we studied the impact of Ca:Mg ratio upon morphology, particle size, purity and dissolution of struvite, in the presence of varying levels of excess ammoniacal nitrogen. X-ray diffraction revealed that up to 31.4% amorphous material was made which was assigned to hydroxyapatite. Increasing the ammoniacal nitrogen concentration and elevation of the Mg:Ca ratio maximized the presence of struvite. Struvite particle size was also increased by ammoniacal nitrogen as was twinning of the crystals. Tests with dilute solutions of organic acid revealed the sensitivity of struvite dissolution to the physical characteristics of the struvite. Smaller particles (21.2 μm) dissolved at higher rates than larger particles (35.86 μm). However, struvite dissolved rapidly as the pH was further reduced irrespective of the physical characteristics. Therefore, addition of struvite to low pH soils was not viewed as beneficial in terms of controlled nutrient release. Overall, this study revealed that waste activated sludge effluent with high ammoniacal nitrogen was prospective for synthesis of high quality struvite material.

Removal of phosphate from aqueous solution by dolomite-modified biochar derived from urban dewatered sewage sludge

Excessive phosphorus emission is mainly responsible for eutrophication. Recently, the application of modified biochars for phosphorus removal from aqueous solution has set off a boom. In the present study, a novel modified biochar was developed, from urban sewage sludge by decorating dolomite according to the dried mass ratio of sludge to dolomite being 1:1. The experimental results showed that the adsorption process preferred lower pH, with the biochar under investigation exhibiting high phosphate removal efficiency of 96.8% at the adsorbent dosage of 2.6 g/L and the initial solution pH of 4.5. Moreover, for the tested biochar, the phosphate removal kinetics data at different temperatures were all well fitted by the pseudo-second-order model, thereby establishing the endothermic nature of the adsorption process. Furthermore, the phosphate removal data upon being well fitted by the Langmuir model showed the maximal removal capacity of 29.18 mg/g. Further, for determining the mechanism involved in the removal process, SEM, XRD, and FTIR analysis were carried out, which in turn revealed that the phosphate combines with the biochar via electrostatic attraction, thereby forming a new outer-sphere surface complex and inner-sphere surface complex in the acidic condition. Additionally, the calcium and magnesium precipitation of phosphate may contribute to the removal of phosphate in the adsorption process. The presence of SO₄^2-, HCO₃^-, and C₅H₇O₅COO^- could negatively affect the removal of phosphate, while CH₃COO^- had a positive effect on the adsorption of phosphate on the biochar. Thus, an economic assessment showed that the proposed adsorption process had a commercial attraction.

Phosphorus recovery through struvite crystallisation: Recent developments in the understanding of operational factors

Phosphorus is an essential element for life and is predicted to deplete within the next 100 years. Struvite crystallization is a potential phosphorus recovery technique to mitigate this problem by producing a slow release fertilizer. However, complex wastewater composition and a large number of process variables result in process uncertainties, making the process difficult to predict and control. This paper reviews the research progress on struvite crystallization fundamentals to address this challenge. The influence of manipulated variables (e.g. seed material, magnesium dosage and pH) and sources of variation on phosphorus removal efficiency (e.g. organics and heavy metal concentration) and product purity were investigated. Recently developed models to describe, control and optimize those variables were also discussed. This review helps to identify potential challenges in different wastewater streams and provide valuable information for future phosphorus recovery unit design. It therefore paves the way for commercialization of struvite crystallization in the future.

Phosphate Recovery from Swine Wastewater by a Struvite Precipitation Electrolyzer

Struvite precipitation electrolyzers are interesting environmental electrochemical reactors with potential applications for efficient phosphate recovery from wastewater, such as swine wastewater. In this paper, effects of phosphate concentration and pH on the struvite precipitation reaction rate were investigated. When phosphate concentration decreased from 100 to 20 mg/L, the precipitation reaction rate decreased from 396.65 mg/L·h to 70.46 mg/L·h, indicating that the reaction rate of struvite crystallization can be controlled by adjusting pH according to the change of phosphate concentration. Numerical simulation of different currents and flow rates on pH in the electrolyzer was developed and validated, and pH in the electrolyzer was dynamically measured along the distribution point of the flow field. We aimed to test the treatment effect of the electrolyzer on actual swine wastewater. When the flow rate was 20 L/h and constant voltage was 4 V, the electrolyzer was run continuously for 5 hours with the volume of 50 L. The phosphate recovery efficiency reached 99.51%, and the time-space yield of the struvite precipitation electrolyzer was 0.0219 kg/m2·h. The harvested struvite particles were identified by XRD and SEM-EDS, which presented orthorhombic structure and high purity. Economic analysis demonstrated that the proposed electrolyzer was cost-effective and technologically convenient.

Phosphorus recovery from freeze-microwave pretreated sludge supernatant by phosphate sedimentation

A novel pretreatment approach combined freeze with microwave was developed to promote the release of orthophosphate from excess sludge, and the phosphorus (P) was recovered from the produced supernatant by phosphate sedimentation. Batch tests examined the effects of freezing time, pH, and microwave time on the release of phosphate (PO₄^3--P) of the excess sludge during the freezing-microwave pretreatment. The release amount of PO₄^3--P reached 276 mg/L under the conditions of the freezing time of 23 h, microwave time of 5 min, and pH of 4. The optimal conditions for phosphate precipitation were pH of 9.5, the mole ratio of Mg/P of 1.8, and stirring speed of 200 rpm. The recovery efficiency of PO₄^3--P reached 97.42% after the reaction of 20 min and the precipitation of 50 min. The precipitated sediment mainly consisted of amorphous calcium phosphate and magnesium ammonium phosphate (MAP) which can be used as a substitute for phosphorus minerals.

Percarbonate promoted antibiotic decomposition in dielectric barrier discharge plasma

A coupling technique introducing sodium percarbonate (SPC) into a dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) plasma was investigated to enhance the degradation of antibiotic tetracycline (TC) in aqueous. The dominant effects of SPC addition amount and discharge voltage were evaluated firstly. The experiments indicated that the moderate SPC dosages in the DBD presented an obvious synergistic effect, improving the TC decomposition efficiency and kinetics. Elevating the voltage was conducive for the promotion of antibiotic abatement. After 5 min treatment, the removal reached 94.3% at the SPC of 52.0 μmol/L and voltage of 4.8 kV for 20 mg/L TC. Especially the defined synergy factors were greater than one since the SPC being added, and the energy yield was increased by 155%. Besides, the function mechanism was explained by the hydrogen peroxide and ozone quantitative determinations and radical scavenger test, and the results confirmed that the collaborative method could increase the generation of reactive species, and the produced hydroxyl and superoxide radicals both played the significant roles for the TC elimination. Furthermore, the decomposition and mineralization of the synergism were verified by UV-vis spectroscopy, TOC and COD analyses, and the degradation byproducts and transformation pathways were identified based on the analysis of HPLC-MS finally.

A new thermodynamic approach for struvite product quality prediction

Struvite precipitation has drawn much attention in the last decade as a green chemical process for phosphorus removal and recovery. Product purity affects the usefulness, and thus price, of the product when recovered struvite is sold as fertilizer. However, there is currently little research on struvite quality, as well as on models for accurately predicting. This paper presents an alternative approach to the traditional thermodynamic model where the solid with the largest positive saturation index precipitates first, depleting the concentrations of constituent ions before the next solid can precipitate. In the new thermodynamic approach, all solids with a positive saturation index precipitate simultaneously, and deplete the common pool of available ions in tandem. It was validated against experimental data, compared with the traditional thermodynamic models and a previously developed empirical model. The proposed new approach was more accurate than other models, except when both the ammonium nitrogen and magnesium concentrations were very low, a condition not likely to be encountered in industry. Therefore, this model is more suited for predicting the performance of struvite precipitation under varying wastewater conditions.