Cartilage morphogenesis: role of bone and cartilage morphogenetic proteins, homeobox genes and extracellular matrix

Therapeutic potential of growth differentiation factors in the treatment of degenerative disc diseases

Intervertebral disc (IVD) degeneration is a major contributing factor to chronic low back pain and disability, leading to imbalance between anabolic and catabolic processes, altered extracellular matrix composition, loss of tissue hydration, inflammation, and impaired mechanical functionality. Current treatments aim to manage symptoms rather than treat underlying pathology. Therefore, IVD degeneration is a target for regenerative medicine strategies. Research has focused on understanding the molecular process of degeneration and the identification of various factors that may have the ability to halt and even reverse the degenerative process. One such family of growth factors, the growth differentiation factor (GDF) family, have shown particular promise for disc regeneration in in vitro and in vivo models of IVD degeneration. This review outlines our current understanding of IVD degeneration, and in this context, aims to discuss recent advancements in the use of GDF family members as anabolic factors for disc regeneration. An increasing body of evidence indicates that GDF family members are central to IVD homeostatic processes and are able to upregulate healthy nucleus pulposus cell marker genes in degenerative cells, induce mesenchymal stem cells to differentiate into nucleus pulposus cells and even act as chemotactic signals mobilizing resident cell populations during disc injury repair. The understanding of GDF signaling and its interplay with inflammatory and catabolic processes may be critical for the future development of effective IVD regeneration therapies.

High LDL levels lead to increased synovial inflammation and accelerated ectopic bone formation during experimental osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

A relation between osteoarthritis (OA) and increased cholesterol levels is apparent. In the present study we investigate OA pathology in apolipoprotein E (ApoE)(-)(/-) mice with and without a cholesterol-rich diet, a model for high systemic low density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol levels independent of weight.

METHOD

Wild type (WT), Apoe(-)(/-), S100a9(-/-) and Apoe(-)(/-)S100a9(-/-) mice (C57BL/6 background) received a standard or cholesterol-rich diet. Experimental OA was induced by intra-articular injection of collagenase and animals were sacrificed at day 10 and day 36.

RESULTS

Although minimal differences in cartilage damage were found between the WT and ApoE(-)(/-) mice, increased synovial thickening was found in the latter. Thirty-six days after OA-induction, ApoE(-)(/-) mice on a standard diet showed increased ectopic bone formation, particularly at the medial collateral ligament, compared with OA in WT mice. Furthermore, a significant increase in synovial gene expression of both S100a8 and S100a9 and S100A8/S100A9 protein levels was found in ApoE(-)(/-) mice, suggesting an activated inflammatory status of synovial cells. In both ApoE(-)(/-) and WT mice, addition of a cholesterol-rich diet resulted in excessive bone formation in the medial collateral ligament at late-time-point OA. Interestingly, at the early time point, proteoglycan deposition was already significantly increased in ApoE(-)(/-) mice compared with WT mice. Mice deficient for both ApoE and S100a9 also showed increased ectopic bone formation, but not synovial activation, suggesting a role for S100-proteins in cholesterol-mediated synovial activation.

CONCLUSIONS

Increased cholesterol levels strongly elevate synovial activation and ectopic bone formation in early-stage collagenase-induced OA.

High yield isolation of BMP-2 from bone and in vivo activity of a combination of BMP-2/TGF-β1

A high-yield purification procedure for protein fractions derived from porcine bone matrix extracts is described, which has a high abundance of bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2). Naturally derived pBMP-2, ~5 μg per kilogram of porcine bone matrix, was isolated by using a 300 kDa membrane before chromatographic processing on heparin affinity media. The elution of pBMP-2 and transforming growth factor-β(1) (TGF-β(1)) revealed morphogen peaks that were unresolved on Prosep(®) medium, but resolved on hydroxyapatite medium. Antagonism was observed in animal studies when the two proteins were combined in specific doses. The TGF-β(1) fraction alone was not active in the rodent heterotopic in vivo bioassay, confirming previously obtained results.

Unveiling the bmp13 enigma: redundant morphogen or crucial regulator?

Bone morphogenetic proteins are a diverse group of morphogens with influences not only on bone tissue, as the nomenclature suggests, but on multiple tissues in the body and often at crucial and influential periods in development.

The purpose of this review is to identify and discuss current knowledge of one vertebrate BMP, Bone Morphogenetic Protein 13 (BMP13), from a variety of research fields, in order to clarify BMP13's functional contribution to developing and maintaining healthy tissues, and to identify potential future research directions for this intriguing morphogen. BMP13 is highly evolutionarily conserved (active domain >95%) across diverse species from Zebrafish to humans, suggesting a crucial function. In addition, mutations in BMP13 have recently been associated with Klippel-Feil Syndrome, causative of numerous skeletal and developmental defects including spinal disc fusion. The specific nature of BMP13's crucial function is, however, not yet known.

The literature for BMP13 is focused largely on its activity in the healing of tendon-like tissues, or in comparisons with other BMP family molecules for whom a clear function in embryo development or osteogenic differentiation has been identified. There is a paucity of detailed information regarding BMP13 protein activity, structure or protein processing. Whilst some activity in the stimulation of osteogenic or cartilaginous gene expression has been reported, and BMP13 expression is found in post natal cartilage and tendon tissues, there appears to be a redundancy of function in the BMP family, with several members capable of stimulating similar tissue responses. This review aims to summarise the known or potential role(s) for BMP13 in a variety of biological systems.

Scaffold stiffness influences cell behavior: opportunities for skeletal tissue engineering

Skeletal defects resulting from trauma, tumors, or abnormal development frequently require surgical treatment to restore normal tissue function. To overcome the limitations associated with conventional surgical treatments, several tissue engineering approaches have been developed. In particular, the use of scaffolds enriched with stem cells appears to be a very promising strategy. A crucial issue in this approach is how to control stem cell behavior. In this respect, the effects of growth factors, scaffold surface characteristics, and external ‘active’ loading conditions on stem cell behavior have been investigated. Recently, it has become clear that the stiffness of a scaffold is a highly potent regulator of stem cell differentiation. In addition, the stiffness of a scaffold affects cell migration, which is important for the infiltration of host tissue cells. This review summarizes current knowledge on the role of the scaffold stiffness in the regulation of cell behavior. Furthermore, we discuss how this knowledge can be incorporated in scaffold design which may provide new opportunities in the context of orthopedic tissue engineering.

Bone morphogenic protein and its application in trauma cases: a current concept update

BACKGROUND

Bone morphogenic proteins (BMP) have shown tremendous potential in bone formation at fracture sites and at non-union sites. Animal studies and limited human studies have proven their efficacy as an alternative or enhancer of autologus bone graft in bone regeneration. The action of BMP is mediated through receptor kinases and transcription factors called Smads that regulate the expression of target genes. In preclinical studies, it was observed that BMP is relatively devoid of adverse effects and carcinogenicity but further studies are needed to clarify the issue of ectopic bone formation before its extensive use in humans.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This review article intends to give brief information on biology and basic science of BMP and provide an overview on the current research data on clinical application of BMP in the treatment of fractures and difficult non-unions.

RESULTS

Various studies have shown that BMP holds promise in the management of delayed unions and recalcitrant non-unions. It has also been observed to initiate faster healing resulting in less pain and infection at the fracture site in open fractures. However the role of BMP in fresh fractures is debatable.

CONCLUSION

Judicious use of BMP in certain clinical scenarios may revolutionise management of non-unions and delayed unions. The major constraints for routine use of BMP are inadequate clinical trials in humans and the need to comprehensively assess the cost-effectiveness and budget impact of BMP.

Regional gene therapy for full-thickness articular cartilage lesions using naked DNA with a collagen matrix

A novel gene therapy approach for treating damaged cartilage is proposed that involves placing endotoxin-free cDNA containing the gene for bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) in type I collagen sponges and then transferring the naked plasmid DNA construct to the injury site. A full-thickness cartilaginous defect in rabbits implanted with plasmid containing a marker gene (beta-galactosidase) showed expressed protein as detected by immunostaining. At 1 week postimplantation, mesenchymal cells subjacent to the defect had incorporated the implanted naked plasmid DNA and, once transfected, served as local bioreactors, transiently producing the gene product. Plasmids containing the gene for BMP-2 implanted in collagen sponges in cartilage lesions stimulated hyalinelike articular cartilage repair at 12 weeks postimplantation, nearly equivalent in quality to that induced by collagen sponges with recombinant BMP-2 protein. Our approach circumvents the risks of inflammation and immunogenic response associated with the use of viral vectors. Naked plasmid DNA as a vehicle for transferring therapeutic genes has been shown to be effective in a therapeutic model within rabbit articular cartilage and appears to be safe and cost effective.

Developmental failure of phalanges in the absence of growth/differentiation factor 5

Growth/differentiation factor 5 (GDF5) is a member of the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) family, which has been implicated in several skeletogenic events including cartilage and bone formation. To study the role of GDF5, we analyzed digit development in brachypodism (bp) mice, which carry functional null mutations of the Gdf5 gene and exhibit a reduction in the length of digit bones and loss of the middle phalanges. In situ detection of apoptosis and whole-mount detection of cell death showed abnormal apoptosis in the developing phalanges of bp mice. In situ hybridization in bp mice showed overexpression of Gdf5 mRNA in the developing phalanges where apoptotic cells were increased. In addition, bp mice exhibited excessive apoptosis in the interdigital regions. The condensed mesenchymal cells were progressively decreased in the developing phalanges and failed to form cartilage models of the middle phalanges. These findings show that excessive apoptosis in the absence of GDF5 results in developmental failure of the phalanges. We conclude that GDF5 is essential for maintenance and growth of the developing phalanges.

Cartilage morphogenetic proteins: role in joint development, homoeostasis, and regeneration

BACKGROUND

Articular cartilage homoeostasis is critical for joint function. The steady state homoeostasis of articular cartilage is a balance between anabolic morphogens such as cartilage derived morphogenetic proteins (CDMPs) and bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) of the BMP family and catabolic cytokines such as interleukin (IL)1, IL17, and tumour necrosis factor alpha. Although bone and articular cartilage are adjacent tissues, there is a profound difference in their regeneration potential. Bone has the highest potential for regeneration. On the other hand, articular cartilage is recalcitrant to repair.

OBJECTIVE

To examine the hypothesis that the feeble innate regeneration ability of cartilage is due to the preponderance of catabolic cytokines such as IL1 and IL17.

RESULTS

During a systematic investigation of CDMPs and cytokines IL17B (chondroleukin) was found in bovine articular cartilage.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS

BMP-7 and IL17B are present in articular cartilage and synthesised in chondrocytes as shown by northern blots and real-time reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction. The coexistence of anabolic morphogens and catabolic cytokines in articular cartilage has important implications for cartilage homoeostasis and regeneration. The networks of signalling systems of morphogens and cytokines determine the net capacity for regenerative morphogenesis of articular cartilage. Finally, the feeble innate capacity for articular cartilage may be improved by targeted therapy by soluble receptors to block catabolic cytokines.

Analysis of the molecular cascade responsible for mesodermal limb chondrogenesis: Sox genes and BMP signaling

Here, we have studied how Sox genes and BMP signaling are functionally coupled during limb chondrogenesis. Using the experimental model of TGFbeta1-induced interdigital digits, we dissect the sequence of morphological and molecular events during in vivo chondrogenesis. Our results show that Sox8 and Sox9 are the most precocious markers of limb cartilage, and their induction is independent and precedes the activation of BMP signaling. Sox10 appears also to cooperate with Sox9 and Sox8 in the establishment of the digit cartilages. In addition, we show that experimental induction of Sox gene expression in the interdigital mesoderm is accompanied by loss of the apoptotic response to exogenous BMPs. L-Sox5 and Sox6 are respectively induced coincident and after the expression of Bmpr1b in the prechondrogenic aggregate, and their activation correlates with the induction of Type II Collagen and Aggrecan genes in the differentiating cartilages. The expression of Bmpr1b precedes the appearance of morphological changes in the prechondrogenic aggregate and establishes a landmark from which the maintenance of the expression of all Sox genes and the progress of cartilage differentiation becomes dependent on BMPs. Moreover, we show that Ventroptin precedes Noggin in the modulation of BMP activity in the developing cartilages. In summary, our findings suggest that Sox8, Sox9, and Sox10 have a cooperative function conferring chondrogenic competence to limb mesoderm in response to BMP signals. In turn, BMPs in concert with Sox9, Sox6, and L-Sox5 would be responsible for the execution and maintenance of the cartilage differentiation program.

AG-041R stimulates cartilage matrix synthesis without promoting terminal differentiation in rat articular chondrocytes

OBJECTIVE

AG-041R, a novel indolin-2-one derivative, has recently been demonstrated to induce systemic hyaline cartilage hyperplasia in rats. The aim of this study was to characterize its anabolic actions on chondrocytes.

DESIGN

Chondrocytes were isolated from knee joints of 5-week-old SD rats. Effects of AG-041R on cartilage matrix synthesis were examined by measuring [(35)S]sulfate incorporation into proteoglycans, Alcian blue staining, and Northern blotting of cartilage matrix genes. ALP activity, mineral deposition and the expression of markers for hypertrophic chondrocytes, were assessed for terminal differentiation of chondrocytes. Roles of endogenous TGF-beta/BMPs and MEK1/Erk signaling in the action of AG-041R were investigated using the neutralizing soluble receptors and the MEK1 inhibitor.

RESULTS

AG-041R accelerated proteoglycan synthesis assessed by both [(35)S]sulfate incorporation and Alcian blue stainable extracellular matrix accumulation. It also up-regulated the gene expression of type II collagen and aggrecan, as well as tenascin, a marker for articular cartilage. In contrast, AG-041R suppressed ALP activity, mineralization, and the gene expression of type X collagen and Cbfa1, indicating that AG-041R prevents chondrocyte terminal differentiation. AG-041R increased in BMP-2 mRNA, and the neutralizing soluble receptor for BMPs reversed the stimulatory effects of AG-041R on cartilage matrix synthesis. Moreover, AG-041R activated MEK1/Erk pathway, which was revealed to prevent chondrocyte terminal differentiation.

CONCLUSION

AG-041R stimulates cartilage matrix synthesis without promoting terminal differentiation in rat articular chondrocytes, which is mediated at least in part by endogenous BMPs and Erk. The data demonstrates that AG-041R has a potential to be a useful therapeutic agent for articular cartilage disorders.

The life cycle of chondrocytes in the developing skeleton

Cartilage serves multiple functions in the developing embryo and in postnatal life. Genetic mutations affecting cartilage development are relatively common and lead to skeletal malformations, dysfunction or increased susceptibility to disease or injury. Characterization of these mutations and investigation of the molecular pathways in which these genes function have contributed to an understanding of the mechanisms regulating skeletal patterning, chondrogenesis, endochondral ossification and joint formation. Extracellular growth and differentiation factors including bone morphogenetic proteins, fibroblast growth factors, parathyroid hormone-related peptide, extracellular matrix components, and members of the hedgehog and Wnt families provide important signals for the regulation of cell proliferation, differentiation and apoptosis. Transduction of these signals within the developing mesenchymal cells and chondrocytes results in changes in gene expression mediated by transcription factors including Smads, Msx2, Sox9, signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT), and core-binding factor alpha 1. Further investigation of the interactions of these signaling pathways will contribute to an understanding of cartilage growth and development, and will allow for the development of strategies for the early detection, prevention and treatment of diseases and disorders affecting the skeleton.

Chondrogenic activity of the heparan sulfate proteoglycan perlecan maps to the N-terminal domain I

C3H10T1/2 cells differentiate along a chondrogenic pathway when plated onto the extracellular matrix (ECM) protein perlecan (Pln). To identify the region(s) within the large Pln molecule that provides a differentiation signal, recombinant Pln-sequence-based polypeptides representing distinct structural domains were assayed for their ability to promote chondrogenesis in C3H10T1/2 cells. Five distinct domains, along with structural variations, were tested. The N-terminal domain I was tested in two forms (IA and IB) that contain only heparan sulfate (HS) chains or both HS and chondroitin sulfate (CS) chains, respectively. A mutant form of domain I lacking attachment sites for both HS and CS (Pln I(mut)) was tested also. Other constructs consecutively designated Pln domains II, III(A-C), IV(A,B), and V(A,B) were used to complete the structure-function analysis. Cells plated onto Pln IA or Pln IB but no other domain rapidly assembled into cellular aggregates of 40-120 microm on average. Aggregate formation was dependent on the presence of glycosaminoglycan (GAG) chains, because Pln I-based polypeptides lacking GAG chains either by enzymatic removal or mutation of HS/CS attachment sites were inactive. Aggregates formed on GAG-bearing Pln IA stained with Alcian Blue and were recognized by antibodies to collagen type II and aggrecan but were not recognized by an antibody to collagen type X, a marker of chondrocyte hypertrophy. Collectively, these studies indicate that the GAG-bearing domain I of Pln provides a sufficient signal to trigger C3H10T1/2 cells to enter a chondrogenic differentiation pathway. Thus, this matrix proteoglycan (PG) found at sites of cartilage formation in vivo is likely to enhance early stage differentiation induced by soluble chondrogenic factors.

Repair of a critical size defect in the rat mandible using allogenic type I collagen

Mandibular fractures, resulting from either trauma or reconstructive surgery, can be challenging craniofacial problems. The morbidity of failed fracture healing is significant and may require bone grafting. Donor site morbidity and finite amounts of autogenous bone are major drawbacks of autogenous bone grafting. Similarly, the use of allografts and xenografts may be associated with an increased risk of rejection, infection, and nonunion. To circumvent the limitations of bone grafting, research efforts have focused on formulating a suitable bone substitute. The purpose of our study was to evaluate the efficacy of type I collagen implants in repairing critical sized mandibular defects in rats. Twelve male Sprague-Dawley rats (200-300g) were divided equally into control and experimental groups. Full thickness, round, four millimeter in diameter defects were created in the ramus of the right mandible of all rats using an electrical burr at low speed. The defects were irrigated of all bone chips, and either filled with a precisely fitted disk of allogenic collagen type I gel (experimental animals) or left empty (control animals). Animals were killed 6 weeks after surgery and healing of the bone defects was assessed in a blinded fashion using radiologic and histologic analysis. Radiologic analysis of the control group revealed a clear circular right mandibular defect in all animals, whereas the collagen disk implant group revealed an indistinct to nonexistent right mandibular defect in all animals. Densitometric analysis revealed a significant difference between these groups (* P = 0.01). Similarly, gross analysis of control mandibles revealed a 4mm round, soft-tissue filled defect, while implanted defects demonstrated gross bone spanning the defect. Finally, histologic analysis of all control mandibles revealed clearly demarcated bony edges at the defect border with connective tissue spanning the defect. In contrast, histological analysis of all implanted mandibles revealed indistinct bony edges at the defect border with a thin layer of osteoblasts and viable bone spanning the defects. We have demonstrated the ability of type I collagen to promote healing of a membranous bony defect that would not otherwise heal at 6 weeks. The suitability of type I collagen as a carrier matrix provides ample opportunity for tissue-engineered approaches to further facilitate bony defect healing. Promoting bone formation through tissue engineering matrices offers great promise for skeletal healing and reconstruction.

Establishment and characterization of chondrocyte cell lines from the costal cartilage of SV40 large T antigen transgenic mice

Complete understanding of the physiology and pathology of the cartilage is essential to establish treatments for a variety of cartilage disorders and defects such as rheumatoid arthritis, congenital malformations, and tumors of cartilage. Although synthetic materials have been used in many cases, they possess inherent problems including wear of the materials and low mechanical strength. Autograft has been considered very effective to overcome these problems. However, the limitation of the transplant volume is a major problem in autograft to be overcome. The costal cartilage is the most serious candidate for donor site transplantation, since it is the largest permanent hyaline cartilage in the body. To investigate the possibility using the costal cartilage as a transplant source, we have established and characterized three mouse chondrocyte cell lines (MCC-2, MCC-5, and MCC-35) derived from the costal cartilage of 8-week-old male SV40 large T-antigen transgenic mice. At confluence, all the cell lines formed nodules that could be positively stained with alcian blue (pH 2.5). The size of nodules gradually increased during culturing time. After 2 and 6 weeks of culture, RT-PCR analysis demonstrated that all three cell lines expressed mRNA from the cartilage-specific genes for type II collagen, type XI collagen, aggrecan, and link protein. Furthermore, type X collagen expression was detected in MCC-5 and MCC-35 but not in MCC-2. Any phenotypic changes were not observed over 31 cell divisions. Immunocytochemistry showed further that MCC-2, MCC-5, and MCC-35 produced cartilage-specific proteins type II collagen and type XI collagen, while in addition MCC-5 and MCC-35 produced type X collagen. Treatment with 1alpha, 25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) inhibited cell proliferation and differentiation of the three cell lines in a dose-dependent manner. These phenotypic characteristics have been found consistent with chondrocyte cell lines established from cartilage tissues other than costal cartilage. In conclusion, costal cartilage shows phenotypic similarities to other cartilages, i.e., articular cartilage and embryonic limbs, suggesting that costal cartilage may be very useful as the donor transplantation site for the treatment of cartilage disorders. Furthermore, the cell lines established in this study are also beneficial in basic research of cartilage physiology and pathology.

Differential expression of multiple genes during articular chondrocyte redifferentiation

Articular chondrocytes undergo a rapid change in phenotype and gene expression, termed dedifferentiation, when isolated from cartilage tissue and cultured on tissue culture plastic. On the other hand, "redifferentiation" of articular chondrocytes in suspension culture is characterized by decreased cellular proliferation and the reinitiation of synthesis of hyaline articular cartilage extracellular matrix molecules. The molecular triggers for these events have yet to be defined. Subtracted cDNA libraries representing genes involved in the early events of adult human articular chondrocyte redifferentiation were generated from human articular chondrocytes that were first cultured in monolayer, and subsequently transferred to suspension culture at 10(6) cells/ml for redifferentiation. Differential regulation of genes involved in cellular organization, nuclear structure, cellular growth regulation, and extracellular matrix deposition and remodeling were observed within 48 hr of this transfer. Many of these genes had not been previously identified in the chondrocyte differentiation pathway and a number of the isolated cDNAs did not have homologies to sequences in the public data banks. Genes involved in IL-6 signal transduction including acute phase response factor (APRF), Mn superoxide dismutase, and IL-6 itself were up-regulated in suspension culture. Membrane glycoprotein gp130, a component of the IL-6 receptor, was down-regulated. Other genes involved in cell polarity, cell adherence, apoptosis, and possibly TGF-beta signaling were differentially regulated. The differential regulation of the cytokine connective tissue growth factor (CTGF) during the early stages of articular chondrocyte redifferentiation, decreasing within 48 hours of transfer to suspension culture, was particularly interesting given its reported role in the stimulation of cellular proliferation. CTGF was highly expressed in proliferative monolayer culture, and then greatly reduced by redifferentiation in standard high-density suspension culture. When articular chondrocytes were seeded in suspension at low-density (10(4) cells/ml), however, high levels of CTGF were observed along with increased levels of mature articular cartilage extracellular matrix protein RNAs, such as type II collagen and aggrecan. Although the role of CTGF in articular cartilage biology remains to be elucidated, the results described here demonstrate the potential utility of subtractive hybridization in understanding the process of articular chondrocyte redifferentiation.

Opposing effects of bone morphogenetic proteins on neuron production and survival in the olfactory receptor neuron lineage

In olfactory epithelium (OE) cultures, bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) can strongly inhibit neurogenesis. Here we provide evidence that BMPs also promote, and indeed are required, for OE neurogenesis. Addition of the BMP antagonist noggin inhibited neurogenesis in OE-stromal cell co-cultures. Bmp2, Bmp4 and Bmp7 were expressed by OE stroma, and low concentrations of BMP4 (below the threshold for inhibition of neurogenesis) stimulated neurogenesis; BMP7 did not exhibit a stimulatory effect at any concentration tested. Stromal cell conditioned medium also stimulated neurogenesis; part of this effect was due to the presence within it of a noggin-binding factor or factors. Studies of the pro-neurogenic effect of BMP4 indicated that it did not increase progenitor cell proliferation, but rather promoted survival of newly generated olfactory receptor neurons. These findings indicate that BMPs exert both positive and negative effects on neurogenesis, depending on ligand identity, ligand concentration and the particular cell in the lineage that is responding. In addition, they reveal the presence of a factor or factors, produced by OE stroma, that can synergize with BMP4 to stimulate OE neurogenesis.

Positionally-dependent chondrogenesis induced by BMP4 is co-regulated by Sox9 and Msx2

Cranial neural crest cells emigrate from the posterior midbrain and anterior hindbrain to populate the first branchial arch and eventually differentiate into multiple cell lineages in the maxilla and mandible during craniofacial morphogenesis. In the developing mouse mandibular process, the expression profiles of BMP4, Msx2, Sox9, and type II collagen demonstrate temporally and spatially restrictive localization patterns suggestive of their functions in the patterning and differentiation of cartilage. Under serumless culture conditions, beads soaked in BMP4 and implanted into embryonic day 10 (E10) mouse mandibular explants induced ectopic cartilage formation in the proximal position of the explant. However, BMP4-soaked beads implanted at the rostral position did not have an inductive effect. Ectopic chondrogenesis was associated with the up-regulation of Sox9 and Msx2 expression in the immediate vicinity of the BMP4 beads 24 hours after implantation. Control beads had no effect on cartilage induction or Msx2 and Sox9 expression. Sox9 was induced at all sites of BMP4 bead implantation. In contrast, Msx2 expression was induced more intensely at the rostral position when compared with the proximal position, and suggested that Msx2 expression was inhibitory to chondrogenesis. To test the hypothesis that over-expression of Msx2 inhibits chondrogenesis, we ectopically expressed Msx2 in the mandibular process organ culture system using adenovirus gene delivery strategy. Microinjection of the Msx2-adenovirus to the proximal position inhibited BMP4-induced chondrogenesis. Over-expression of Msx2 also resulted in the abrogation of endogenous cartilage and the down-regulation of type II collagen expression. Taken together, these results suggest that BMP4 induces chondrogenesis, the pattern of which is positively regulated by Sox9 and negatively by Msx2. Chondrogenesis only occurs at sites where Sox9 expression is high relative to that of Msx2. The combinatorial action of these transcription factors appear to establish a threshold for Sox9 function and thereby restricts the position of chondrogenesis.

Phenotypic stability of articular chondrocytes in vitro: the effects of culture models, bone morphogenetic protein 2, and serum supplementation

Numerous in vitro culture models have been developed for the investigation of chondrocyte and cartilage biology. In this study, we investigated the stability of the chondrocytic phenotype in monolayer, aggregate, pellet, and explant culture models and assessed the effects of recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein 2 (rhBMP-2) and serum supplementation on the phenotype in each model. Phenotypic effects were assessed by analyses of procollagen type II, aggrecan, (V + C)- fibronectin, and procollagen type I messenger RNA expression. In monolayer cultures, we noted a characteristic loss of procollagen type II and induction of procollagen type I expression. The aggregate and pellet culture models supported matrix protein gene expression profiles more reflective of in vivo levels. In explant cultures, expression of matrix protein genes was consistently depressed. Treatment with rhBMP-2 significantly increased the expression of procollagen type II and aggrecan in monolayer cultures; however, other models showed comparatively little response. Similarly, serum supplementation significantly down-regulated procollagen type II and aggrecan expression in monolayer cultures but had less effect on gene expression in the other models. Serum supplementation increased procollagen type I expression in monolayer and aggregate cultures. These results suggest that the influence of exogenous BMP-2 and serum on expression of chondrocyte-specific matrix protein genes is influenced by aspects of substrate attachments, cellular morphology, and/or cytoskeletal organization. Finally, the analyses of fibronectin expression suggest that V and C region alternative splicing in chondrocytes is linked to the establishment of a three-dimensional multicellular complex.

Initial evidence for the involvement of bone morphogenetic protein-2 early during periosteal chondrogenesis

The potential of periosteum to form cartilage makes periosteal transplantation a viable approach to repairing defects in articular cartilage, which has a limited potential for repair. However, cartilage repair, including that by periosteal chondrogenesis, is poorly understood. Consequently, a thorough understanding of its molecular mechanisms will help to achieve the quality of neocartilage required for its clinical application in damaged joints. An in vitro model was used to study the early molecular events of periosteal chondrogenesis. During the search for the expression of transforming growth factor-beta-related mRNAs in this model system, bone morphogenetic protein-2 mRNA expression was found to be upregulated 20-fold within the first 12 hours of culture. This stimulation was dependent on the explants being suspended in agarose and did not occur with explants cultured in liquid medium. The upregulation of bone morphogenetic protein-2 mRNA expression was also enhanced by exogenously added transforming growth factor-beta1 in the presence of fetal calf serum. The upregulation, however, was not transient; rather, it persisted over a prolonged period in both transforming growth factor-beta1-treated and untreated explants. Further data indicate that this stimulation of bone morphogenetic protein-2 mRNA expression was regulated at the transcriptional level and that no new protein synthesis was required for this. Bone morphogenetic protein-2 is known to influence developmental chondrogenesis; therefore, these observations direct our attention toward an important potential role of it as a regulator of the early events in cartilage repair. Furthermore, because periosteum produces fracture (cartilage) callus, these findings may be important in defining the molecular mechanisms of fracture healing.

Type IIA procollagen containing the cysteine-rich amino propeptide is deposited in the extracellular matrix of prechondrogenic tissue and binds to TGF-beta1 and BMP-2

Type II procollagen is expressed as two splice forms. One form, type IIB, is synthesized by chondrocytes and is the major extracellular matrix component of cartilage. The other form, type IIA, contains an additional 69 amino acid cysteine-rich domain in the NH2-propeptide and is synthesized by chondrogenic mesenchyme and perichondrium. We have hypothesized that the additional protein domain of type IIA procollagen plays a role in chondrogenesis. The present study was designed to determine the localization of the type IIA NH2-propeptide and its function during chondrogenesis. Immunofluorescence histochemistry using antibodies to three domains of the type IIA procollagen molecule was used to localize the NH2-propeptide, fibrillar domain, and COOH-propeptides of the type IIA procollagen molecule during chondrogenesis in a developing human long bone (stage XXI). Before chondrogenesis, type IIA procollagen was synthesized by chondroprogenitor cells and deposited in the extracellular matrix. Immunoelectron microscopy revealed type IIA procollagen fibrils labeled with antibodies to NH2-propeptide at approximately 70 nm interval suggesting that the NH2-propeptide remains attached to the collagen molecule in the extracellular matrix. As differentiation proceeds, the cells switch synthesis from type IIA to IIB procollagen, and the newly synthesized type IIB collagen displaces the type IIA procollagen into the interterritorial matrix. To initiate studies on the function of type IIA procollagen, binding was tested between recombinant NH2-propeptide and various growth factors known to be involved in chondrogenesis. A solid phase binding assay showed no reaction with bFGF or IGF-1, however, binding was observed with TGF-beta1 and BMP-2, both known to induce endochondral bone formation. BMP-2, but not IGF-1, coimmunoprecipitated with type IIA NH2-propeptide. Recombinant type IIA NH2-propeptide and type IIA procollagen from media coimmunoprecipitated with BMP-2 while recombinant type IIB NH2-propeptide and all other forms of type II procollagens and mature collagen did not react with BMP-2. Taken together, these results suggest that the NH2-propeptide of type IIA procollagen could function in the extracellular matrix distribution of bone morphogenetic proteins in chondrogenic tissue.

Expression and function of Gdf-5 during digit skeletogenesis in the embryonic chick leg bud

Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) constitute a large family of secreted signals involved in the formation of the skeleton but the specific function of each member of this family remains elusive. GDF-5 is a member of the BMP family which has been implicated in several skeletogenic events including the induction and growth of the appendicular cartilages, the determination of joint forming regions, and the establishment of tendons. Here, we have studied the function of GDF-5 in digit skeletogenesis by analyzing the effects of its local administration in the developing autopod of embryonic chick and the regulation of its pattern of gene expression by other signals involved in digit morphogenesis. As reported in the mouse, the gdf-5 gene exhibits a precise distribution in the joint-forming regions of the developing chicken digital rays. GDF-5 beads implanted at the tip of the digits promote intense cartilage growth and fail to induce morphological or molecular signs of joint formation. Furthermore, GDF-5 beads implanted in the interdigits inhibit the formation of joints in the adjacent digits. These data suggest that the role of GDF-5 in joint formation is the control of growth and differentiation of the cartilage of the epiphyseal regions of the phalanges rather than accounting for the differentiation of the sinovial joint tissues. The interdigital mesoderm in spite of its potential to form ectopic digits with their tendinous apparatus failed to form either ectopic cartilages or ectopic tendons after the implantation of GDF-5 beads in the stages preceding cell death. At difference with other BMPs, GDF-5 exhibited only a weak cell death promoting effect. The BMP antagonist Noggin binds to GDF-5 and is able to inhibit all the observed effects of this growth factor in vivo. Potential interactions of GDF-5 with other signals involved in digits morphogenesis were also explored. BMP-7 regulates negatively the expression of gdf-5 gene in the joint forming regions and local treatment with Noggin induces the ectopic expression of gdf-5 in the interdigital mesoderm. Retroviral-induced misexpression of Indian or Sonic Hedgehog genes in the developing digits leads to the formation of digits without joints in which gdf-5 expression occurs throughout the entire perichondrial surface. In conclusion, this study indicates that GDF-5 is a signal regulated by other BMPs which controls the growth and differentiation of the epiphyses of the digital cartilages acting in close relationship with Hedgehog signaling.

Cloning and characterization of a novel member of the transforming growth factor-beta/bone morphogenetic protein family

Members of the transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) superfamily of growth and differentiation factors have been identified in a wide variety of organisms, ranging from invertebrates to mammals. Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) constitute a subgroup of proteins belonging to the TGF-beta superfamily. BMPs were initially identified by their ability to induce endochondral bone formation at ectopic sites, suggesting a critical role for this family in development and regeneration of the skeleton. They are also expressed at a variety of nonskeletal sites during development, suggesting possible extraskeletal roles for these proteins. We cloned a novel member of the BMP family that is expressed at high levels in the placenta and the prostate and that we have designated as prostate-derived factor (PDF). Based on cDNA sequence analysis, the predicted PDF protein contains two cysteines in addition to the seven conserved cysteines that are the hallmark of the members of the TGF-beta superfamily. In addition, Northern blot hybridization to poly(A)+ RNA showed low levels of expression in the kidney and pancreas. We further characterized the expression of this member of the BMP family by in situ hybridization and immunohistochemistry. These results show high expression in the terminal villae of the placenta. The expression of the protein as visualized by immunohistochemistry shows an expression pattern identical to that of the message in the terminal villae of the placenta. In day 18 rat embryos, protein expression was also seen in the skin and in the cartilaginous tissue of developing skeleton. Orchidectomy and dihydrotestosterone treatment of rats revealed that PDF expression is regulated by androgens in the prostate. In addition, subcutaneous implantation of recombinant PDF induced cartilage formation and the early stages of endochondral bone formation. These data indicate that PDF has a functional relationship to the BMPs.

Expression of a stable articular cartilage phenotype without evidence of hypertrophy by adult human articular chondrocytes in vitro

Chondrocytes that were isolated from adult human articular cartilage changed phenotype during monolayer tissue culture, as characterized by a fibroblastic morphology and cellular proliferation. Increased proliferation was accompanied by downregulation of the cartilage-specific extracellular matrix proteoglycan, aggrecan, by cessation of type-II collagen expression, and by upregulation of type-I collagen and versican. This phenomenon observed in monolayer was reversible after the transfer of cells to a suspension culture system. The transfer of chondrocytes to suspension culture in alginate beads resulted in the rapid upregulation of aggrecan and type-II collagen and the downregulation of expression of versican and type-I collagen. Type-X collagen and osteopontin, markers of chondrocyte hypertrophy and commitment to endochondral ossification, were not expressed by adult articular chondrocytes cultured in alginate, even after 5 months. In contrast, type-X collagen was expressed within 2 weeks in a population of cells derived from a fetal growth plate. The inability of adult articular chondrocytes to express markers of chondrocyte hypertrophy has underscored the fundamental distinction between the differentiation pathways that lead to articular cartilage or to bone. Adult articular chondrocytes expressed only hyaline articular cartilage markers without evidence of hypertrophy.

Osteogenic protein-1 up-regulation of the collagen X promoter activity is mediated by a MEF-2-like sequence and requires an adjacent AP-1 sequence

Bone morphogenetic proteins induce chondrogenesis and osteogenesis in vivo. To investigate molecular mechanisms involved in chondrocyte induction, we examined the effect of osteogenic protein (OP)-1/bone morphogenetic protein-7 on the collagen X promoter. In rat calvaria-derived chondrogenic C5.18 cells, OP-1 up-regulates collagen X mRNA levels and its promoter activity in a cell type- specific manner. Deletion analysis localizes the OP-1 response region to 33 bp (-310/-278), which confers OP-1 responsiveness to both the minimal homologous and heterologous Rous sarcoma virus promoter. Transforming growth factor-beta2 or activin, which up-regulates the expression of a transforming growth factor-beta-inducible p3TP-Lux construct, has little effect on collagen X mRNA and on this 33-bp region. Mutational analysis shows that both an AP-1 like sequence (-294/-285, TGAATCATCA) and an A/T-rich myocyte enhancer factor (MEF)-2 like sequence (-310/-298, TTAAAAATAAAAA) in the 33-bp region are necessary for the OP-1 effect. Gel shift assays show interaction of distinct nuclear proteins from C5.18 cells with the AP-1-like and the MEF-2-like sequences. OP-1 rapidly induces nuclear protein interaction with the MEF-2-like sequence but not with the AP-1 like sequence. MEF-2-like binding activity induced by OP-1 is distinct from the MEF-2 family proteins present in C2C12 myoblasts, in which OP-1 does not induce collagen X mRNA or up-regulate its promoter activity. In conclusion, we identified a specific response region for OP-1 in the mouse collagen X promoter. Mutational and gel shift analyses suggest that OP-1 induces nuclear protein interaction with an A/T-rich MEF-2 like sequence, distinct from the MEF-2 present in myoblasts, and up-regulates collagen X promoter activity, which also requires an AP-1 like sequence.

The functional matrix hypothesis revisited. 4. The epigenetic antithesis and the resolving synthesis

In two interrelated articles, the current revision of the functional matrix hypothesis extends to a reconsideration of the relative roles of genomic and of epigenetic processes and mechanisms in the regulation (control, causation) of craniofacial growth and development. The dialectical method was chosen to analyze this matter, because it explicitly provides for the fuller presentation of a genomic thesis, an epigenetic antithesis, and a resolving synthesis. The later two are presented here, where the synthesis suggests that both genomic and epigenetic factors are necessary causes, that neither alone is also a sufficient cause, and that only the two, interacting together, furnish both the necessary and sufficient cause(s) of ontogenesis. This article also provides a comprehensive bibliography that introduces the several new, and still evolving, disciplines that may provide alternative viewpoints capable of resolving this continuing controversy; repetition of the present theoretical bases for the arguments on both sides of these questions seems nonproductive. In their place, it is suggested that the group of disciplines, broadly termed Complexity, would most likely amply repay deeper consideration and application in the study of ontogenesis.

Bone morphogenetic protein 2 stimulates articular cartilage proteoglycan synthesis in vivo but does not counteract interleukin-1alpha effects on proteoglycan synthesis and content

OBJECTIVE

To study the effect of bone morphogenetic protein 2 (BMP-2) on articular cartilage proteoglycan (PG) synthesis in vivo and to investigate whether BMP-2 is able to counteract the effects of interleukin-1 (IL-1) on articular cartilage PG synthesis and content.

METHODS

BMP-2 alone or in combination with IL-1alpha was injected into murine knee joints. PG synthesis was measured by 35S-sulfate incorporation using an ex vivo method or autoradiography. Cartilage PG content was analyzed by measuring Safranin O staining intensity on histologic sections.

RESULTS

BMP-2 appeared to be a potent stimulator of articular cartilage PG synthesis in vivo. However, BMP-2 was not able to counteract the deleterious effects of IL-1alpha on articular cartilage PG synthesis and content. In addition, intraarticular injections of BMP-2 induced chondrophytes.

CONCLUSION

Although BMP-2 is a very potent stimulator of cartilage PG synthesis in vivo, the therapeutic applications of BMP-2 are limited due to the inability of BMP-2 to counteract the effects of IL-1 and the induction of chondrophytes.