Specific recognition of thymic self-peptides induces the positive selection of cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Innovations Toward Immunopeptidomics

Over the past 30 years, immunopeptidomics has grown alongside improvements in mass spectrometry technology, genomics, transcriptomics, T cell receptor sequencing, and immunological assays to identify and characterize the targets of activated T cells. Together, multiple research groups with expertise in immunology, biochemistry, chemistry, and peptide mass spectrometry have come together to enable the isolation and sequence identification of endogenous major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-bound peptides. The idea to apply highly sensitive mass spectrometry techniques to study the landscape of peptide antigens presented by cell surface MHCs was innovative and continues to be successfully used and improved upon to deepen our understanding of how peptide antigens are processed and presented to T cells. Multiple research groups were involved in this bringing immunopeptidomics to the forefront of translational research, and we will highlight the contributions of one of the earliest developers, Professor Donald F. Hunt, and his research group at the University of Virginia. The Hunt laboratory applied cutting edge mass spectroscopy-based immunopeptidomics to study cancer, autoimmunity, transplant rejection, and infectious diseases. Across these diverse research areas, the Hunt laboratory and collaborators would characterize previously unknown MHC peptide-binding motifs and identify immunologically active antigens using ultra sensitive mass spectrometry techniques. Amazingly, many of the MHC-bound peptide antigens discovered in collaborations with the Hunt laboratory were sequenced by mass spectrometry before the completion of the human genome using manual de novo sequencing. In this perspective article, we will chronicle the work of the Hunt laboratory and their many collaborators that would be a major part of the foundation for mass spectrometry-based immunopeptidomics and its application to immunology research.

The early proximal αβ TCR signalosome specifies thymic selection outcome through a quantitative protein interaction network

During αβ T cell development, T cell antigen receptor (TCR) engagement transduces biochemical signals through a protein-protein interaction (PPI) network that dictates dichotomous cell fate decisions. It remains unclear how signal specificity is communicated, instructing either positive selection to advance cell differentiation or death by negative selection. Early signal discrimination might occur by PPI signatures differing qualitatively (customized, unique PPI combinations for each signal), quantitatively (graded amounts of a single PPI series), or kinetically (speed of PPI pathway progression). Using a novel PPI network analysis, we found that early TCR-proximal signals distinguishing positive from negative selection appeared to be primarily quantitative in nature. Furthermore, the signal intensity of this PPI network was used to find an antigen dose that caused a classic negative selection ligand to induce positive selection of conventional αβ T cells, suggesting that the quantity of TCR triggering was sufficient to program selection outcome. Because previous work had suggested that positive selection might involve a qualitatively unique signal through CD3δ, we reexamined the block in positive selection observed in CD3δ⁰ mice. We found that CD3δ⁰ thymocytes were inhibited but capable of signaling positive selection, generating low numbers of MHC-dependent αβ T cells that expressed diverse TCR repertoires and participated in immune responses against infection. We conclude that the major role for CD3δ in positive selection is to quantitatively boost the signal for maximal generation of αβ T cells. Together, these data indicate that a quantitative network signaling mechanism through the early proximal TCR signalosome determines thymic selection outcome.

A modified HLA-A*0201-restricted CTL epitope from human oncoprotein (hPEBP4) induces more efficient antitumor responses

We previously identified human phosphatidylethanolamine-binding protein 4 (hPEBP4) as an antiapoptotic protein with increased expression levels in breast, ovarian and prostate cancer cells, but low expression levels in normal tissues, which makes hPEBP4 an attractive target for immunotherapy. Here, we developed hPEBP4-derived immunogenic peptides for inducing antigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) targeting breast cancer. A panel of hPEBP4-derived peptides predicted by peptide-MHC-binding algorithms was evaluated to characterize their HLA-A2.1 affinity and immunogenicity. We identified a novel immunogenic peptide, P40-48 (TLFCQGLEV), that was capable of eliciting specific CTL responses in HLA-A2.1/K^b transgenic mice, as well as in peripheral blood lymphocytes from breast cancer patients. Furthermore, amino-acid substitutions in the P40-48 sequence improved its immunogenicity against hPEBP4, a self-antigen, thus circumventing tolerance. We designed peptide analogs by preferred auxiliary HLA-A*0201 anchor residue replacement, which induced CTLs that were crossreactive to the native peptide. Several analogs were able to stably bind to HLA-A*0201 and elicit specific CTL responses better than the native sequence. Importantly, adoptive transfer of CTLs induced by vaccination with two analogs more effectively inhibited tumor growth than the native peptide. These data indicate that peptide analogs with high immunogenicity represent promising candidates for peptide-mediated therapeutic cancer vaccines.

Generation of Peptides That Promote Positive Selection in the Thymus

To establish an immunocompetent TCR repertoire that is useful yet harmless to the body, a de novo thymocyte repertoire generated through the rearrangement of genes that encode TCR is shaped in the thymus through positive and negative selection. The affinity between TCRs and self-peptides associated with MHC molecules determines the fate of developing thymocytes. Low-affinity TCR engagement with self-peptide-MHC complexes mediates positive selection, a process that primarily occurs in the thymic cortex. Massive efforts exerted by many laboratories have led to the characterization of peptides that can induce positive selection. Moreover, it is now evident that protein degradation machineries unique to cortical thymic epithelial cells play a crucial role in the production of MHC-associated self-peptides for inducing positive selection. This review summarizes current knowledge on positive selection-inducing self-peptides and Ag processing machineries in cortical thymic epithelial cells. Recent studies on the role of positive selection in the functional tuning of T cells are also discussed.

The ability to rearrange dual TCRs enhances positive selection, leading to increased Allo- and Autoreactive T cell repertoires

Thymic selection is designed to ensure TCR reactivity to foreign Ags presented by self-MHC while minimizing reactivity to self-Ags. We hypothesized that the repertoire of T cells with unwanted specificities such as alloreactivity or autoreactivity are a consequence of simultaneous rearrangement of both TCRα loci. We hypothesized that this process helps maximize production of thymocytes capable of successfully completing thymic selection, but results in secondary TCRs that escape stringent selection. In T cells expressing two TCRs, one TCR can mediate positive selection and mask secondary TCR from negative selection. Examination of mice heterozygous for TRAC (TCRα(+/-)), capable of only one functional TCRα rearrangement, demonstrated a defect in generating mature T cells attributable to decreased positive selection. Elimination of secondary TCRs did not broadly alter the peripheral T cell compartment, though deep sequencing of TCRα repertoires of dual TCR T cells and TCRα(+/-) T cells demonstrated unique TCRs in the presence of secondary rearrangements. The functional impact of secondary TCRs on the naive peripheral repertoire was evidenced by reduced frequencies of T cells responding to autoantigen and alloantigen peptide-MHC tetramers in TCRα(+/-) mice. T cell populations with secondary TCRs had significantly increased ability to respond to altered peptide ligands related to their allogeneic ligand as compared with TCRα(+/-) cells, suggesting increased breadth in peptide recognition may be a mechanism for their reactivity. Our results imply that the role of secondary TCRs in forming the T cell repertoire is perhaps more significant than what has been assumed.

Effect of CDR3 sequences and distal V gene residues in regulating TCR-MHC contacts and ligand specificity

The mature T cell repertoire has the ability to orchestrate immunity to a wide range of potential pathogen challenges. This ability stems from thymic development producing individual T cell clonotypes that express TCRs with unique patterns of Ag reactivity. The Ag specificity of TCRs is created from the combinatorial pairing of one of a set of germline encoded TCR Vα and Vβ gene segments with randomly created CDR3 sequences. How the amalgamation of germline encoded and randomly created TCR sequences results in Ag receptors with unique patterns of ligand specificity is not fully understood. Using cellular, biophysical, and structural analyses, we show that CDR3α residues can modulate the geometry in which TCRs bind peptide-MHC (pMHC), governing whether and how germline encoded TCR Vα and Vβ residues interact with MHC. In addition, a CDR1α residue that is positioned distal to the TCR-pMHC binding interface is shown to contribute to the peptide specificity of T cells. These findings demonstrate that the specificity of individual T cell clonotypes arises not only from TCR residues that create direct contacts with the pMHC, but also from a collection of indirect effects that modulate how TCR residues are used to bind pMHC.

Use of proteomics to define targets of T-cell immunity

The mammalian immune system has evolved to display peptides derived from microbial antigens to immune effector cells. Liberated from the intact antigens through distinct proteolytic mechanisms, these peptides are subsequently transported to the cell surface while bound to chaperone-like receptors known as major histocompatibility complex molecules. These complexes are then scrutinized by T-cells that express receptors with specificity for specific major histocompatibility complex-peptide complexes. In normal uninfected cells, this process of antigen processing and presentation occurs continuously, with the resultant array of self-antigen-derived peptides displayed on the surface of these cells. Changes in this cellular peptide array alert the immune system to changes in the intracellular environment that may be associated with infection, oncogenesis or other abnormal cellular processes, resulting in a cascade of events that result in the elimination of the abnormal cell. Since peptides play such an essential role in informing the immune system of infection with viral or microbial pathogens and the transformation of cells in malignancy, the tools of proteomics, in particular mass spectrometry, are ideally suited to study these immune responses at a molecular level. Recent advances in studies of immune responses that have utilized mass spectrometry and associated technologies are reviewed. The authors gaze into the future and look at current challenges and where proteomics will impact in immunology over the next 5 years.

T-cell receptor affinity in thymic development

Understanding the thymic processes that support the generation of functionally competent and self-tolerant lymphocytes requires dissection of the T-cell receptor (TCR) response to ligands of different affinities. In spatially segregated regions of the thymus, with unique expression of proteases and cytokines, TCR affinity guides a number of cell fate decisions. Yet affinity alone does not explain the selection paradox. Increasing evidence suggests that the 'altered peptide' model of the 1980s together with the affinity model might best explain how the thymus supports conventional and regulatory T-cell development. Development of new tools to study the strength of TCR signals perceived by T cells, novel regulatory T-cell transgenic mice, and tetramer enrichment strategies have provided an insight into the nature of TCR signals perceived during thymocyte development. These topics are discussed and support for the prevailing hypotheses is presented.

How the TCR balances sensitivity and specificity for the recognition of self and pathogens

The T cell repertoire is generated during thymic development in preparation for the response to antigens from pathogens. The T cell repertoire is shaped by positive selection, which requires recognition by the T cell antigen receptor (TCR) of complexes of self peptide and major histocompatibility complex proteins (self-pMHC) with low affinity, and negative selection, which eliminates T cells with TCRs that recognize self-pMHC with high affinity. This generates a repertoire with low affinity for self-pMHC but high affinity for foreign antigens. The TCR must successfully engage both of these ligands for development, homeostasis and immune responses. This review discusses mechanisms underlying the interaction of the TCR with peptide-major histocompatibility complex ligands of varying affinity and highlights signaling mechanisms that enable the TCR to generate different responses to very distinct ligands.

Impact of TCR reactivity and HLA phenotype on naive CD8 T cell frequency in humans

The impact of MHC phenotype on the shaping of the peripheral naive T cell repertoire in humans remains unknown. To address this, we compared the frequency and antigenic avidity of naive T cells specific for immunodominant self-, viral, and tumor Ags presented by a human MHC class I allele (HLA-A*02, referred to as A2) in individuals expressing or not this allele. Naive T cell frequencies varied from one Ag specificity to another but were restrained for a given specificity. Although A2-restricted T cells showed similar repertoire features and antigenic avidities in A2+ and A2- donors, A2 expression had either a positive, neutral, or negative impact on the frequency of A2-restricted naive CD8 T cells, depending on their fine specificity. We also identified in all donors CD4 T cells specific for A2/peptide complexes, whose frequencies were not affected by MHC class I expression, but nevertheless correlated with those of their naive CD8 T cell counterparts. Therefore, both selection by self-MHC and inherent TCR reactivity regulate the frequency of human naive T cell precursors. Moreover this study also suggests that T cell repertoire shaping by a given self-MHC allele is dispensable for generation of immunodominant T cell responses restricted by this particular allele.

A single peptide-MHC complex positively selects a diverse and specific CD8 T cell repertoire

Pathogen recognition by T cells is dependent on their exquisite specificity for self-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules presenting a bound peptide. Although this specificity results from positive and negative selection of developing T cells in the thymus, the relative contribution of these two processes remains controversial. To address the relation between the selecting peptide-MHC complex and the specificity of mature T cells, we generated transgenic mice that express a single peptide-MHC class I complex. We demonstrate that positive selection of CD8 T cells in these mice results in an MHC-specific repertoire. Although selection on a single complex is peptide promiscuous, mature T cells are highly peptide specific. Thus, positive selection imparts MHC and peptide specificity on the peripheral CD8 T cell repertoire.

Learning to be tolerant: how T cells keep out of trouble

A pool of immature T cells with a seemingly unrestricted repertoire of antigen specificities is generated life-long in the thymus. Amongst these cells are, however, thymocytes that express a strongly self-reactive antigen receptor and hence hold the potential to trigger autoimmunity. To prevent such an outcome, the thymus employs several independent but functionally related strategies that act in parallel to enforce self-tolerance. The deletion of strongly self-reactive thymocytes and the generation of regulatory T cells constitute the two most efficient mechanisms to induce and maintain immunological tolerance. Thymic epithelial cells of the medulla express for this purpose tissue-restricted self-antigens. This review will focus on the cellular and molecular mechanisms operative in the thymus to shape a repertoire of mature T cells tolerant to self-antigens.

Thymoproteasome: probable role in generating positively selecting peptides

The proteasome is the protein destroying machinery conserved in all eukaryotes and plays essential roles in various cellular processes. Apart from the conserved 'standard' proteasome, a special type of proteasome called 'immunoproteasome' exists in vertebrates for better presentation of antigenic peptides on MHC class I molecules. Recently, another vertebrate-specific proteasome was discovered in the thymus. This 'thymoproteasome' has a novel catalytic subunit 'beta5t' with unusual enzymatic activity and is expressed exclusively in cortical thymic epithelial cells (cTECs), which catalyze positive selection of developing thymocytes. beta5t-deficient mice exhibit severe impairment in CD8(+) T cell development. These findings suggest that cTECs are quite unique cells capable of presenting a unique set of self-peptides that are not seen in other cells and are required for positive selection of CD8(+) T cells.

Studying T-cell repertoire selection using fetal thymus organ culture

T lymphocytes express receptors (T-cell receptor) that are not only specific for antigenic peptide but also molecules encoded by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) that present peptide on the surface of cells (MHC-restricted antigen recognition). However, the vast majority of T cells are tolerant to their own MHC molecules and do not give rise to autoimmune disease. This MHC-restricted, but tolerant, repertoire of T cells is determined by selection triggered by the appropriate recognition of peptide/MHC on thymic stromal cell by immature thymocytes. We have developed a fetal thymus organ culture (FTOC) system based on transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP) 1-deficient mice to examine the role of peptide/MHC in triggering the differentiation of T cells restricted to class I MHC (positive selection). We also describe an FTOC system to study central T-cell tolerance, which occurs through clonal deletion in the thymus (negative selection).

TCR-alpha CDR3 loop audition regulates positive selection

How positive selection molds the T cell repertoire has been difficult to examine. In this study, we use TCR-beta-transgenic mice in which MHC shapes TCR-alpha use. Differential AV segment use is directly related to the constraints placed on the composition of the CDR3 loops. Where these constraints are low, efficient selection of alphabeta pairs follows. This mode of selection preferentially uses favored AV-AJ rearrangements and promotes diversity. Increased constraint on the alpha CDR3 loops leads to inefficient selection associated with uncommon recombination events and limited diversity. Further, the two modes of selection favor alternate sets of AJ segments. We discuss the relevance of these findings to the imprint of self-MHC restriction and peripheral T cell activation.

Plasticity in the positive selection of T cells: affinity of the selecting antigen and IL-7 affect T cell responsiveness

The current study examines how responsiveness of T cells is affected by the avidity of the peptide/MHC engaged during positive selection of their thymocyte precursors. We used a thymus reaggregate culture system in which CD4(+)CD8(+) thymocytes from AND TCR transgenic mice were induced to undergo positive selection by pigeon cytochrome c (PCC) peptide or its analogs presented by I-E(k) class II MHC on a thymic epithelial cell line. When low-affinity peptide analogs drove positive selection, up to 100 microM was needed to produce >50% CD4(+) T cells, and these cells were highly responsive to PCC. In contrast, <0.2 microM high-affinity peptides was required to achieve similar selection efficiency, but the resultant cells failed to respond to PCC. However, these cells were not dead based on dye exclusion and capacity to respond to phorbal ester and to agonist if IL-2 was also present, supporting the view that non-responsiveness of cells selected on high-affinity peptides is a form of central T cell tolerance distinct from deletion. Cells selected on intermediate-affinity peptides showed variable responsiveness which was suppressed 5- to 10-fold by addition during reaggregate culture of antibody to the IL-7R. Similarly, supplementary IL-7 in the reaggregate culture produced CD4(+) T cells that were promiscuously responsive. Overall, this study demonstrates that the responsiveness of T cells is not rigidly controlled and that the presence of IL-7 during T cell development has the potential to negate central T cell tolerance and produce autoreactive T cells.

Heteroclitic CD33 peptide with enhanced anti-acute myeloid leukemic immunogenicity

The goal of these studies was to engineer a synthetic CD33 peptide with enhanced immunogenicity for the induction of acute myeloid leukemia (AML)-specific CTLs. Eight modified CD33 peptides YLISGDSPV, YIGSGDSPV, YIIIGDSPV, YIILGDSPV, YIISGISPV, YIISGDLPV, YIISGDSWV and YIISGDSPL were designed for increased HLA-A2.1 or T cell receptor affinity and compared with the native CD33(65-73) peptide, AIISGDSPV, for enhanced immunogenicity. The YLISGDSPV peptide was found to be the most immunogenic epitope producing highly cytolytic CTLs against AML target cells. The CTLs generated withYLISGDSPV peptide showed CD33 peptide-specificity through targeting of both native (AIISGDSPV) and modified (YLISGDSPV) peptide presenting EBV-BLCL. The CTL cultures displayed a distinct phenotype consisting of a high percentage of activated memory (CD69(+)/CD45RO(+))-CD8(+)and a low percentage of naive (CD45RA(+)/CCR7(+))-CD8(+)cells. In addition, T-cell clones specific to the YLISGDSPV peptide were isolated and characterized to target AML cells. The clones exhibited both HLA-A2.1-restricted and AML cell-specific cytotoxicity that was mediated through a granule-dependent pathway. More importantly, the CTL clones did not lyse or inhibit the proliferation of normal CD34(+) progenitor cells. In conclusion, we report on the identification of a highly immunogenic heteroclitic YLISGDSPV CD33 epitope that is a promising candidate for immunotherapy targeting AML.

Duration of Alloantigen Presentation and Avidity of T Cell Antigen Recognition Correlate with Immunodominance of CTL Response to Minor Histocompatibility Antigens

CD8 T lymphocytes (CTL) responsive to immunodominant minor histocompatibility (minor H) Ags are thought to play a disproportionate role in allograft rejection in MHC-identical solid and bone marrow transplant settings. Although many studies have addressed the mechanisms underlying immunodominance in models of infectious diseases, cancer immunotherapy, and allograft immunity, key issues regarding the molecular basis of immunodominance remain poorly understood. In this study, we exploit the minor H Ag system to understand the relationship of the various biochemical parameters of Ag presentation and recognition to immunodominance. We show that the duration of individual minor H Ag presentation and the avidity of T cell Ag recognition influence the magnitude and, hence, the immunodominance of the CTL response to minor H Ags. These properties of CTL Ag presentation and recognition that contribute to immunodominance have implications not only for tissue transplantation, but also for autoimmunity and tumor vaccine design.

Immunoproteomics: Mass spectrometry-based methods to study the targets of the immune response

The mammalian immune system has evolved to display fragments of protein antigens derived from microbial pathogens to immune effector cells. These fragments are typically peptides liberated from the intact antigens through distinct proteolytic mechanisms that are subsequently transported to the cell surface bound to chaperone-like receptors known as major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. These complexes are then scrutinized by effector T cells that express clonally distributed T cell receptors with specificity for specific MHC-peptide complexes. In normal uninfected cells, this process of antigen processing and presentation occurs continuously, with the resultant array of self-antigen-derived peptides displayed on the surface of these cells. Changes in this peptide landscape of cells act to alert immune effector cells to changes in the intracellular environment that may be associated with infection, malignant transformation, or other abnormal cellular processes, resulting in a cascade of events that result in their elimination. Because peptides play such a crucial role in informing the immune system of infection with viral or microbial pathogens and the transformation of cells in malignancy, the tools of proteomics, in particular mass spectrometry, are ideally suited to study these immune responses at a molecular level. Here we review recent advances in the studies of immune responses that have utilized mass spectrometry and associated technologies, with specific examples from collaboration between our laboratories.

Positive and negative selection of T cells

A functional immune system requires the selection of T lymphocytes expressing receptors that are major histocompatibility complex restricted but tolerant to self-antigens. This selection occurs predominantly in the thymus, where lymphocyte precursors first assemble a surface receptor. In this review we summarize the current state of the field regarding the natural ligands and molecular factors required for positive and negative selection and discuss a model for how these disparate outcomes can be signaled via the same receptor. We also discuss emerging data on the selection of regulatory T cells. Such cells require a high-affinity interaction with self-antigens, yet differentiate into regulatory cells instead of being eliminated.

Self-peptides with intermediate capacity to bind and stabilize MHC class I molecules may be immunogenic

Thirty self-peptides were selected on the basis of their predicted binding to H-2b molecules. The binding of peptides was ascertained experimentally by biochemical (KD measurements) and cellular [major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I) stabilization] assays. A weak, but significant, correlation between KD measurements and MHC-I stabilization was observed. Mice (n = 99) were immunized with individual peptides. Twenty-eight peptides were found to induce peptide-specific cytotoxic activity, and a total of 84 mice developed significant cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses after immunization. Only one of the 21 mice immunized with high-affinity peptides developed a peptide-specific CTL response of 29 lytic units per 106 splenocytes, whereas 11 of the 42 mice immunized with intermediate-affinity peptides developed peptide-specific CTL responses at this level (P < 0.05). These observations suggest the absence of tolerance towards most MHC-I-restricted self-peptides and that strong antiself immunity can be generated preferentially towards self-peptides with an intermediate affinity for MHC-I. These data should be considered in the design of tumour vaccines based on MHC-I-binding self-peptides.

Recognition of a specific self-peptide: self-MHC class II complex is critical for positive selection of thymocytes expressing the D10 TCR

We examined the specificity of positive and negative selection by using transgenic mice carrying a variant of the D10 TCR. We demonstrate that a point mutation at position 51 within the CDR2alpha segment significantly reduces the avidity of this TCR for its cognate ligand, but does not impact recognition of nonself MHC class II molecules. Although structural studies have suggested that this TCR site interacts with the MHC class II beta-chain, the avidity of this TCR for its ligand and the function of the T cell can be reconstituted by a point mutation in the bound antigenic peptide. These data demonstrate that the bound peptide can indirectly alter TCR interactions by influencing MHC structure. Remarkably, reducing the avidity of this TCR for a specific antigenic peptide-MHC ligand has a dramatic impact on thymic selection. Positive selection of thymocytes expressing this TCR is nearly completely blocked, whereas negative selection on allogenic MHC class II molecules remains intact. Therefore, the recognition of self that promotes positive selection of the D10 TCR is highly peptide-specific.

Genomics-based identification of self-ligands with T cell receptor-specific biological activity

Self-peptide/major histocompatibility complex (MHC) complexes profoundly influence the biology of T lymphocytes. They promote the selection of the T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire in the thymus, maintain the homeostasis of peripheral T cells prior to encounter with antigen, and modify the responsiveness of T cells to foreign antigens. In addition, they can serve as antigens for autoaggressive T cells that induce autoimmune diseases. The complete sequencing of the genomes of human, mouse, and many pathogenic organisms now provides us with a comprehensive list of all possible proteins that may be the source of foreign antigenic and self-peptides. A computational approach using profile-based similarity searches on potential self-MHC-binding peptides can be used to efficiently predict self-peptides with biological activities. The common feature of the identified peptides is similarity to antigen. Thus, self-peptides may form 'hazy' images of the universe of antigens that are used as templates to create and maintain the TCR repertoire.

Rare, structurally homologous self-peptides promote thymocyte positive selection

Although it is clear that positive selection of T cells involves recognition of specific self-peptide/MHC complexes, the nature of these self-ligands and their relationship to the cognate antigen are controversial. Here we used two complementary strategies to identify naturally occurring self-peptides able to induce positive selection of T cells bearing a specific T cell receptor, OT-I. Both the bioassay- and bioinformatics-based strategies identified the same self-peptides, derived from F-actin capping protein and beta-catenin. These peptides displayed charge conservation at two key TCR contact residues. The biological activity of 43 other self-peptides and of complex peptide libraries directly correlated to the extent of conservation at TCR contact residues. These results demonstrate that selecting self-peptides are rare and can be identified by homology-based search strategies.

Cutting edge: positive selection induced by a self-peptide with TCR antagonist activity

Antagonist-like engagement of the TCR has been proposed to induce T cell selection in the thymus. However, no natural TCR ligand with TCR antagonist activity is presently known. Using a combination of bioinformatics and functional testing we identified the first self-peptide that can both deliver antagonist-like signals and promote T cell selection in the thymus. The peptide is presented by appropriate MHC class I molecules in vivo. Thus, endogenous antagonist peptides exist and may be involved in TCR repertoire selection.

A naturally processed mitochondrial self-peptide in complex with thymic MHC molecules functions as a selecting ligand for a viral-specific T cell receptor

Peptide fragments of self-proteins bound to major histocompatibility complex molecules within the thymus are important for positively selecting T cell receptor (TCR)-bearing CD4(+)CD8(+) double positive (DP) thymocytes for further maturation. The relationship between naturally processed thymic self-peptides and TCR-specific cognate peptides is unknown. Here we employ HPLC purification of peptides released from H-2K(b) molecules of the C57BL/6 thymus in conjunction with mass spectrometry (MS) and functional profiling to identify a naturally processed K(b)-bound peptide positively selecting the N15 TCR specific for the vesicular stomatitis virus octapeptide (VSV8) bound to K(b). The selecting peptide was identified in 1 of 80 HPLC fractions and shown by tandem MS (MS/MS) sequencing to correspond to residues 68-75 of the MLRQ subunit of the widely expressed mitochondrial NADH ubiquinone oxidoreductase (NUbO(68-75)). Of note, the peptide differs at six of its eight residues from the cognate peptide VSV8 and functions as a weak agonist for mature CD8 single positive (SP) N15 T cells, with activity 10,000-fold less than VSV8. In N15 transgenic (tg) recombinase activating gene 2(-/)- transporter associated with antigen processing 1(-/)- fetal thymic organ culture, NUbO(68-75) induces phenotypic and functional differentiation of N15 TCR bearing CD8 SP thymocytes. Failure of NUbO(68-75) to support differentiation of a second K(b)-restricted TCR indicates that its inductive effects are not general.

Evidence of the extrathymic development of tyrosinase-related protein-2-recognizing CD8+ T cells with low avidity

The majority of the human tumour-associated antigens characterized to date are derived from non-mutated self-proteins. However, nothing is known about the development of autoreactive and tumour-associated antigen-recognizing T cells. Tyrosinase-related protein (TRP)-2 is a non-mutated melanocyte differentiation antigen and TRP-2-recognizing CD8+ T cells are known to show responses to melanoma both in humans and mice. In addition, TRP-2-reactive T cells with low avidity have been suggested to be readily induced from the spleen cells of naïve mice. On the other hand, recent reports suggest that self antigen-reactive CD8+ T cells can be positively selected in the periphery. In this study, we tested the possibility that TRP-2-reactive CD8+ T cells in naïve mice could develop via the extrathymic pathway. As a consequence, TRP-2-reactive CD8+ T cell precursors in naïve C57BL/6 mice were suggested to express both interleukin-2 (IL-2) receptor beta chain (IL-2Rbeta) and CD44 molecules, in a manner similar to that of extrathymically developed T cells. Furthermore, IL-2Rbeta+ CD44+ CD8+ T cells were detected in the adult thymectomized and bone marrow-reconstituted mice, and functional TRP-2-reactive T cells were generated from their spleen cells. Overall, these results suggest that low avidity CD8+ T cells recognizing TRP-2 can be developed extrathymically.

Positive selection of CD4(+) T cells is induced in vivo by agonist and inhibited by antagonist peptides

The nature of peptides that positively select T cells in the thymus remains poorly defined. Here we report an in vivo model to study the mechanisms of positive selection of CD4(+) T cells. We have restored positive selection of TCR transgenic CD4(+) thymocytes, arrested at the CD4(+)CD8(+) stage, due to the lack of the endogenously selecting peptide(s), in mice deficient for H2-M and invariant chain. A single injection of soluble agonist peptide(s) initiated positive selection of CD4(+) transgenic T cells that lasted for up to 14 days. Positively selected CD4(+) T cells repopulated peripheral lymphoid organs and could respond to the antigenic peptide. Furthermore, coinjection of the antagonist peptide significantly inhibited agonist-driven positive selection. Hence, contrary to the prevailing view, positive selection of CD4(+) thymocytes can be induced in vivo by agonist peptides and may be a result of accumulation of signals from TCR engaged by different peptides bound to major histocompatibility complex class II molecules. We have also identified a candidate natural agonist peptide that induces positive selection of CD4(+) TCR transgenic thymocytes.

Structural and functional identification of major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted self-peptides as naturally occurring molecular mimics of viral antigens. Possible role in CD8+ T cell-mediated, virus-induced autoimmune disease

Structural similarity (molecular mimicry) between viral epitopes and self-peptides can lead to the induction of autoaggressive CD4(+) as well as CD8(+) T cell responses. Based on the flexibility of T cell receptor/antigen/major histocompatibility complex recognition, it has been proposed that a self-peptide could replace a viral epitope for T cell recognition and therefore participate in pathophysiological processes in which T cells are involved. To address this issue, we used, as a molecular model of viral antigen, the H-2D(b)-restricted immunodominant epitope nucleoprotein (NP)-(396-404) (FQPQNGQFI) of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV). We identified peptide sequences from murine self-proteins that share structural and functional homology with LCMV NP-(396-404) and that bound to H-2D(b) with high affinity. One of these self-peptides, derived from tumor necrosis factor receptor I (FGPSNWHFM, amino acids 302-310), maintained LCMV-specific CD8(+) T cells in an active state as observed both in vitro in cytotoxic assays and in vivo in a model of virus-induced autoimmune diabetes, the rat insulin promoter-LCMV NP transgenic mouse. The natural occurrence and molecular concentration at the surface of H-2(b) spleen cells of tumor necrosis factor receptor I-(302-310) were determined by on-line micro-high pressure liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry and supported its biological relevance.

Alpha beta TCRs differ in the degree of their specificity for the positively selecting MHC/peptide ligand

We have tested the peptide specificity of positive selection using three transgenic alphabetaTCRs, originally selected on class II MHC (A(b)) covalently bound with one peptide Ealpha (52-68) (Ep). The transgenic TCR specific for the cytochrome c-derived (43-58) peptide was selected on A(b) bound with different arrays of endogenous peptides or the analogue of Ep covalently bound to A(b), but not on the original A(b)Ep complex. In contrast, transgenic TCRs specific for two different analogues of the Ep peptide and A(b) did not mature as CD4(+) T cells in various thymic environments, including the A(b)EpIi(-) mice. These results show that TCRs can be promiscuous or specific for the selecting MHC/peptide complex, and suggest that in mice described in this study transgenic expression of the TCR changes the original requirements for the positively selecting MHC/peptide complex. Future studies will determine whether the latter phenomenon is general or specific for this system.

Diversity of T cell repertoire shaped by a single peptide ligand is critically affected by its amino acid residue at a T cell receptor contact

T cell differentiation in the thymus is driven by positive selection through the interaction of alphabeta T cell receptors (TCRs) with self-peptides bound to self-major histocompatibility complex molecules, yet the influence of the peptide sequence on this process remains unknown. To address this issue, we have compared CD4(+) T cell differentiation between two sets of mouse lines in which MHC class II I-A(b) molecules are occupied with either Ealpha chain-derived peptide ((p)Ealpha) or its variant, (p)60K, with one amino acid substitution from leucine to lysine at P5 residue of TCR contacts. Here, we show that despite the comparable expression of I-A(b)-peptide complex in the thymus, this substitution from leucine to lysine affects efficiency of positive selection, resulting in extremely small numbers of CD4(+) T cells to be selected to mature on I-A(b)-(p)60K complex. Furthermore, we show that, although I-A(b)-(p)Ealpha complex selects diverse T cells, T cell repertoire shaped by I-A(b)-(p)60K complex is markedly constrained. Our findings thus suggest that positive selection is both specific and degenerate, depending on the amino acid residues at TCR contacts of the selecting self-peptides.

V beta T cell repertoire of CD8+ splenocytes selected on nonpolymorphic MHC class I molecules

In this work, we have studied the role of the MHC class Ib molecules in the selection and maintenance of CD8(+) T splenocytes. We have compared the CD8(+) T cell repertoires of wild-type, H-2K-deficient, H-2D-deficient, or double knockout C57BL/6 mice. We show that the different CD8(+) repertoires, selected either by class Ia and class Ib or by class Ib molecules only, use the various V alpha (AV) and V beta (BV) rearrangements in the same proportion and without biases in the CDR3 size distribution. Furthermore, we have estimated the size of the BV repertoire in the four different strains of mice. Interestingly, we have found that the BV repertoire size is proportional to the overall number of CD8(+) splenocytes. This observation implies that BV diversity is positively correlated with the number of CD8(+) cells, even when the number of CD8(+) splenocytes is dramatically reduced (90% in the double knockout mice).

On the self-referential nature of naive MHC class II-restricted T cells

The use of mutant mice expressing a normal MHC class II molecule surface level but a severely restricted self-peptide diversity (H-2Malpha(-/-)) previously revealed that T cells carrying the Ealpha(52-68)-I-A(b) complex-specific 1H3.1 TCR rely on self-peptide(s) recognition for both their peripheral persistence in irradiated hosts and their intrathymic positive selection. Here, we identify Ealpha(52-68) structurally related self-peptide(s) as a major contributor to in vivo positive selection of 1H3.1 TCR-transgenic thymocytes in I-A(b+)/I-Ealpha(-) mice. This is demonstrated by the drastic and specific reduction of the TCR high thymocyte population in 1H3.1 TCR-transgenic (Tg) mice treated with the Ealpha(52-68)-I-A(b) complex-specific Y-Ae mAb. Self-peptide(s) recognition is also driving the maturation of T cells carrying a distinct MHC class II-restricted specificity (the Ealpha(6) alphass TCR), since positive selection was also deficient in Ealpha(6) TCR Tg H-2Malpha(-/-) thymi. Such a requirement for recognition of self-determinants was mirrored in the periphery; Ealpha(6) TCR Tg naive T cells showed an impaired persistence in both H-2Malpha(-/-) and I-A(b)ss(-/-) irradiated hosts, whereas they persisted and slowly cycled in wild-type recipients. This moderate self-peptide(s)-dependent proliferation was associated with a surface phenotype intermediate between those of naive and activated/memory T cells; CD44 expression was up-regulated, but surface expression of other markers such as CD62L remained unaltered. Collectively, these observations indicate that maturation and maintenance of naive MHC class II-restricted T cells are self-oriented processes.

A physiological ligand of positive selection is recognized as a weak agonist

Positive selection is a process that ensures that peripheral T cells express TCR that are self-MHC restricted. This process occurs in the thymus and requires both self-MHC and self-peptides. We have recently established a TCR transgenic (TCR(trans)(+)) mouse model using the C10.4 TCR restricted to the MHC class Ib molecule, H2-M3. Having defined H2-M3 as the positively selecting MHC molecule, the severely limited number of H2-M3 binding peptides allowed us to characterize a mitochondrial NADH dehydrogenase subunit 1-derived 9-mer peptide as the physiological ligand of positive selection. Here, we demonstrate that the NADH dehydrogenase subunit 1 self-peptide is seen by mature C10.4 TCR(trans)(+) T cells as a weak agonist and induces positive selection at a defined concentration range. We also found that the full-length cognate peptide, a strong agonist for mature C10.4 TCR(trans)(+) T cells, initiated positive selection, albeit at significantly lower concentrations. At increased peptide concentrations, and thus increased epitope densities, either peptide only induced the development of partially functional T cells. We conclude that successful positive selection only proceeded at a defined, yet fairly narrow window of avidity.

Affinity of thymic self-peptides for the TCR determines the selection of CD8(+) T lymphocytes in the thymus

Experiments with synthetic antigen peptides have suggested that a critical parameter that determines the developmental fate of an immature thymocyte is the affinity of interaction between TCR and self-peptide/MHC expressed on thymic stromal cells. To test the physiological relevance of this model for thymocyte development, we determined the affinity of the anti-HY TCR (B6.2.16) expressed on CD8(+) cells for thymic self-peptide/H-2D(b) tetramers, then examined the ability of these self-peptides to determine the outcome of B6.2.16 CD8 cell selection in the thymus. The B6.2.16 TCR bound the male HY self-antigen with high affinity. Thymic self-peptides, which are highly abundant on the surface of thymic epithelial cells, bound the B6.2.16 TCR with low affinity. The ability of self-peptides to trigger positive or negative selection of B6.2.16 CD8 cells in cultured fetal thymi was determined by the relative affinity of self-peptide/H-2D(b) for the B6.2.16 TCR. High-affinity binding of the HY self-peptide resulted in B6.2.16 TCR complex zeta chain phosphorylation and the negative selection of B6.2.16 CD8 cells. Low-affinity binding of thymic self-peptides to B6.2.16 TCR resulted in the positive selection of B6.2.16 CD8 cells. Differences between the binding affinities of self-peptides to B6.2.16 TCR accounted for the self-peptide specificity of B6.2.16 CD8 cell positive selection. We conclude that the relative affinity of TCR for thymic self-peptide/class I MHC is a critical parameter in determining fate of CD8(+) cells during thymic selection.

Positive selection is limited by available peptide-dependent MHC conformations

Recent data suggest that the diversity of self peptides presented in the thymus during development contributes to positive selection of a diverse T cell repertoire. We sought to determine whether a previously defined "hole in the immunological repertoire" could be explained by the absence of an appropriate selecting self peptide. The repertoire defect in question is the inability of bm8 mice to make an H-2K-restricted response to OVA. Like other OVA-specific, H-2K-restricted receptors, OT-I-transgenic T cells are not positively selected in bm8 mice. Using criteria we had previously established for identifying positive selection ligands, we found peptides that could restore positive selection of OT-I thymocytes in bm8 mice. Thus, the T cell repertoire can be limited by a requirement for specific self peptides during development. Data with MHC-specific Abs suggested that peptides might be able to force MHC residues to adopt different conformations in Kb vs Kbm8. This shows that peptides can potentially contribute to ligand diversity both directly (via variability in the solvent-exposed side chains) and indirectly (through their effect on the MHC conformation). Our data support a model where self peptide diversity allows selection of T cells specific for a broad range of MHC conformations.

MEK activity regulates negative selection of immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes

CD4+CD8+ thymocytes are either positively selected and subsequently mature to CD4 single positive (SP) or CD8 SP T cells, or they die by apoptosis due to neglect or negative selection. This clonal selection is essential for establishing a functional self-restricted T cell repertoire. Intracellular signals through the three known mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase pathways have been shown to selectively guide positive or negative selection. Whereas the c-Jun N-terminal kinase and p38 MAP kinase regulate negative selection of thymocytes, the extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) pathway is required for positive selection and T cell lineage commitment. In this paper, we show that the MAP/ERK kinase (MEK)-ERK pathway is also involved in negative selection. Thymocytes from newborn TCR transgenic mice were cultured with TCR/CD3epsilon-specific Abs or TCR-specific agonist peptides to induce negative selection. In the presence of the MEK-specific pharmacological inhibitors PD98059 or UO126, cell recovery was enhanced and deletion of DP thymocytes was drastically reduced. Furthermore, development of CD4 SP T cells was blocked, but differentiation of mature CD8 SP T cells proceeded in the presence of agonist peptides when MEK activity was blocked. Thus, our data indicate that the outcome between positively and negatively selecting signals is critically dependent on MEK activity.

The selection of M3-restricted T cells is dependent on M3 expression and presentation of N-formylated peptides in the thymus

The major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class Ib molecule H2-M3 binds N-formylated peptides from mitochondria and bacteria. To explore the role of M3 expression and peptide supply in positive and negative selection, we generated transgenic mice expressing an M3-restricted TCR-alpha/beta from a CD8(+) T cell hybridoma (D7) specific for a listerial peptide (LemA). Development of M3-restricted transgenic T cells is impaired in both beta2-microglobulin-deficient and transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP)-deficient mice, but is not diminished by changes in the H-2 haplotype. Maturation of M3/LemA-specific CD8(+) single positive cells in fetal thymic organ culture was sensitive to M3 expression levels as determined by antibody blocking and use of the castaneus mutant allele of M3. Positive selection was rescued in TAP(-/-) lobes by nonagonist mitochondrial and bacterial peptides, whereas LemA and a partial agonist variant caused negative selection. Thus, M3-restricted CD8(+) T cells are positively and negatively selected by M3, with no contribution from the more abundant class Ia molecules. These results demonstrate that class Ib molecules can function in thymic education like class Ia molecules, despite limited ligand diversity and low levels of expression.

Tolerance to Maternal Immunoglobulins: Resilience of the Specific T Cell Repertoire in Spite of Long-Lasting Perturbations

T cell tolerance is established and maintained through various mechanisms, the critical component being the persistence of the specific Ag. However, at the molecular level, the nature of the recovering TCR repertoire following breakdown of tolerance is unknown. We address this important question by following κ light chain constant region (Cκ)-specific CD4+ T cells of κ light chain knock-out (κ−/−) mice born to κ+/− mothers. These cells, which were in contact with maternal κ+ Igs from early ontogeny until weaning, were strongly tolerized. Tolerance was reversible and waned with the disappearance of peptide Cκ134–148 presentation in lymphoid organs, including the thymus. Whereas three specific Vβ-Jβ rearrangements emerged in the peptide Cκ134–148-specific CD4+ T cell response of all regular κ−/− mice, soon after breakdown of tolerance only one of these rearrangements was detected. The two others displayed a significant delay in reappearance and were still rare at 26 wk of age, while the control proliferative response had already recovered 3 mo earlier. At 52 wk of age, a complete recovery of the three canonical Vβ-Jβ rearrangements was observed. Thus, although profoundly perturbed for several months, the T cell repertoire returns to equilibrium, highlighting the resilient nature of this system.

A clonal view of alphabeta T cell responses

Quantitative analyses of antigen (Ag)-specific alphabeta T cell populations have provided a large body of information on the natural course of T cell immune responses. New tools are now available to determine the clonal composition of Ag-specific pools in individual responders, an approach which offers direct insights into the generation of T cell immune responses and establishment of protective immunity. The present review discusses the parameters that determine the composition of Ag-specific T cell responses. Emphasis is placed on the role of the naive alphabeta T cell repertoire and on the dynamics of individual Ag-specific T cell clones during the successive phases of an immune response.

Selecting and maintaining a diverse T-cell repertoire

To provide a T-cell population that will respond promptly to foreign antigen, the immune system looks inward, using the variety of self-antigens to select and maintain a diverse repertoire of receptors. A protective immune system must include a T-lymphocyte population that is poised to respond to foreign antigenic peptides presented by self-major histocompatibility complex molecules. As the organism cannot predict the precise pathogen-derived antigens that will be encountered, the system uses the diverse array of self-peptides bound to self-major histocompatibility complex molecules, not only to select a receptor repertoire in the thymus, but also to keep naïve T cells alive and 'ready for action' in the periphery.

Neurofilament is an autoantigenic determinant in myasthenia gravis

Intratumorous expression of a 153-kd protein (p153), which contains an acetylcholine receptor-like epitope, is the only tumor marker described to date that significantly associates with thymoma in paraneoplastic myasthenia gravis (MG). Here, we report that p153 is identical to the midsize neurofilament, as verified by immunohistochemistry, immunofluorescence, and western blot analysis. Furthermore, the acetylcholine receptor-like epitope of the midsize neurofilament (NF-M) was identified by peptide epitope mapping. We also show, using T-cell proliferation assays, a significantly increased response of intratumorous T cells to a recombinant midsize neurofilament fragment in thymoma patients with MG compared with MG patients with thymic follicular hyperplasia or thymoma patients without MG. The T cells of thymic follicular hyperplasia and thymoma patients without MG seem to be unresponsive to NF-M. In contrast, we found increased T-cell responses to recombinant acetylcholine receptor fragments in MG patients in general compared with non-MG patients. Increased T-cell responses to NF-M in patients with paraneoplastic MG might be the result of an abnormal positive selection of immature T cells within thymomas, caused by the expression of NF-M in neoplastic thymic epithelial cells. Our results offer further evidence that NF-M expression in thymomas is an autoantigenic determinant in MG.

Positive selection of an H2-M3 restricted T cell receptor

Thymocytes are positively selected for alphabeta T cell antigen receptors (TCR) that recognize antigen in conjunction with self-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. MHC bound peptides participate in positive selection; however, their role has remained controversial. A TCR transgenic mouse was established using a TCR restricted to the MHC class Ib molecule, H2-M3. Having defined H2-M3 as the positively selecting MHC molecule, the severely limited number of H2-M3 binding peptides allowed us to characterize an NADH dehydrogenase subunit 1 (ND1)-derived peptide as the physiological ligand of positive selection. This peptide bears no apparent sequence homology to the cognate peptide, is expressed ubiquitously, and yet does not interfere with peripheral T cells. Our studies also suggest that positive selection becomes promiscuous at high epitope densities.

Immunological self/nonself discrimination: integration of self vs nonself during cognate T cell interactions with antigen-presenting cells

The hypothesis is presented that immunological integration of nonefficacious vs efficacious T cell antigen receptor (TCR) signals are foundational for self/nonself discrimination and that multiple integrative mechanisms are intrinsic to the molecular to molar organization of an adaptive immune response. These integrative mechanisms are proposed to adaptively regulate expression of costimulatory signals, such that foreign proteins are associated with the expression of costimulatory signals, whereas self-proteins are associated with the lack of costimulatory signaling. Overall, this model offers several unique contributions to the study of immunology. First, this model postulates that cognate TCR/major histocompatibility complex (MHC) interactions are sufficient to adaptively mediate immunological self/nonself discrimination. This model thereby offers a unique alternative to models that largely rely on innate immunity to prime immune discrimination. Second, the integrative model argues that the immune system can simultaneously reinforce self-tolerance and promote immunity to foreign organisms at the same time and in the same location. Many alternative models presume that pathogenic self-reactive T cells do not exist at the outset of an immune response against foreign agents. Third, the integrative model uniquely predicts relationships between immunodeficiency and autoimmune pathogenesis. Fourth, this model illustrates the regulatory advantages of cognate antigen presenting cell (APC) systems (i.e., T cell or B cell APC) compared to nonspecific APC. Cognate APC systems together with the respective clonotypic responders may comprise a fundamental "network" of lymphoid cells. Such networks would have clone-specific regulatory capabilities and may be central for immunological self/nonself discrimination. Fifth, this model provides an explanation for "infectious" tolerance without creating specialized subsets of "suppressor" or "regulatory" T cells. Each mature T cell retains the potential to reinforce tolerance or mediate immunity, depending on the specific antigenic cues present in the immediate environment.

Selection of the T cell repertoire

Advances in gene technology have allowed the manipulation of molecular interactions that shape the T cell repertoire. Although recognized as fundamental aspects of T lymphocyte development, only recently have the mechanisms governing positive and negative selection been examined at a molecular level. Positive selection refers to the active process of rescuing MHC-restricted thymocytes from programmed cell death. Negative selection refers to the deletion or inactivation of potentially autoreactive thymocytes. This review focuses on interactions during thymocyte maturation that define the T cell repertoire, with an emphasis placed on current literature within this field.