A comparison of three vaccines against respiratory syncytial virus in calves

Review on bovine respiratory syncytial virus and bovine parainfluenza - usual suspects in bovine respiratory disease - a narrative review

Bovine Respiratory Syncytial virus (BRSV) and Bovine Parainfluenza 3 virus (BPIV3) are closely related viruses involved in and both important pathogens within bovine respiratory disease (BRD), a major cause of morbidity with economic losses in cattle populations around the world. The two viruses share characteristics such as morphology and replication strategy with each other and with their counterparts in humans, HRSV and HPIV3. Therefore, BRSV and BPIV3 infections in cattle are considered useful animal models for HRSV and HPIV3 infections in humans.

The interaction between the viruses and the different branches of the host’s immune system is rather complex. Neutralizing antibodies seem to be a correlate of protection against severe disease, and cell-mediated immunity is thought to be essential for virus clearance following acute infection. On the other hand, the host’s immune response considerably contributes to the tissue damage in the upper respiratory tract.

BRSV and BPIV3 also have similar pathobiological and epidemiological features. Therefore, combination vaccines against both viruses are very common and a variety of traditional live attenuated and inactivated BRSV and BPIV3 vaccines are commercially available.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus in experimentally exposed and rechallenged calves; viral shedding related to clinical signs and the potential for transmission

Background

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) is an important respiratory pathogen worldwide, detrimentally affecting the economy and animal welfare. To prevent and control BRSV infection, further knowledge on virus shedding and transmission potential in individual animals is required. This study aimed to detect viral RNA and infective virions during BRSV infection to evaluate duration of the transmission period and correlation with clinical signs of disease. The outcome of BRSV re-exposure on calves, their housing environment and effect of introduction of sentinel calves was also investigated.

A live animal experiment including 10 calves was conducted over 61 days. Initially, two calves were inoculated with a non-passaged BRSV field isolate. Two days later, six naïve calves (EG: Exposed group) were introduced for commingling and four weeks later, another two naïve calves (SG: Sentinel group) were introduced. Seven weeks after commingling, EG animals were re-inoculated. Clinical examination was performed daily. Nasal swabs were collected regularly and analysed for viral RNA by RT-ddPCR, while virus isolation was performed in cell culture. BRSV serology was performed with ELISA.

Results

All the EG calves seroconverted and showed clinical signs of respiratory disease. Viral RNA was detected from days 1–27 after exposure, while the infective virus was isolated on day 6 and 13. On day 19, all animals were seropositive and virus could not be isolated. Total clinical score for respiratory signs corresponded well with the shedding of viral RNA. The SG animals, introduced 27 days after exposure, remained negative for BRSV RNA and stayed seronegative throughout the study. Inoculation of the EG calves seven weeks after primary infection did not lead to new shedding of viral RNA or clinical signs of disease.

Conclusion

Viral RNA was detected in nasal swabs from the calves up to four weeks after exposure. The detection and amount of viral RNA corresponded well with the degree of respiratory signs. The calves were shedding infective virions for a considerable shorter period, and naïve calves introduced after four weeks were not infected. Infected calves were protected from reinfection for at least seven weeks. This knowledge is useful to prevent spread of BRSV.

Brief History and Characterization of Enhanced Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease

In 1967, infants and toddlers immunized with a formalin-inactivated vaccine against respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) experienced an enhanced form of RSV disease characterized by high fever, bronchopneumonia, and wheezing when they became infected with wild-type virus in the community. Hospitalizations were frequent, and two immunized toddlers died upon infection with wild-type RSV. The enhanced disease was initially characterized as a "peribronchiolar monocytic infiltration with some excess in eosinophils." Decades of research defined enhanced RSV disease (ERD) as the result of immunization with antigens not processed in the cytoplasm, resulting in a nonprotective antibody response and CD4(+) T helper priming in the absence of cytotoxic T lymphocytes. This response to vaccination led to a pathogenic Th2 memory response with eosinophil and immune complex deposition in the lungs after RSV infection. In recent years, the field of RSV experienced significant changes. Numerous vaccine candidates with novel designs and formulations are approaching clinical trials, defying our previous understanding of favorable parameters for ERD. This review provides a succinct analysis of these parameters and explores criteria for assessing the risk of ERD in new vaccine candidates.

Bovine model of respiratory syncytial virus infection

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV), which is an important cause of respiratory disease in young calves, is genetically and antigenically closely related to human (H)RSV. The epidemiology and pathogenesis of infection with these viruses are similar. The viruses are host-specific and infection produces a spectrum of disease ranging from subclinical to severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia, with the peak incidence of severe disease in individuals less than 6 months of age. BRSV infection in calves reproduces many of the clinical signs associated with HRSV in infants, including fever, rhinorrhoea, coughing, harsh breath sounds and rapid breathing. Although BRSV vaccines have been commercially available for decades, there is a need for greater efficacy. The development of effective BRSV and HRSV vaccines face similar challenges, such as the need to vaccinate at an early age in the presence of maternal antibodies, the failure of natural infection to prevent reinfection, and a history of vaccine-augmented disease. Neutralising monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to the fusion (F) protein of HRSV, which can protect infants from severe HRSV disease, recognise the F protein of BRSV, and vice versa. Furthermore, bovine and human CD8(+) T-cells, which are known to be important in recovery from RSV infection, recognise similar proteins that are conserved between HRSV and BRSV. Therefore, not only can the bovine model of RSV be used to evaluate vaccine concepts, it can also be used as part of the preclinical assessment of certain HRSV candidate vaccines.

Complement-mediated virus infectivity neutralisation by HLA antibodies is associated with sterilising immunity to SIV challenge in the macaque model for HIV/AIDS

Sterilising immunity is a desired outcome for vaccination against human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and has been observed in the macaque model using inactivated simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV). This protection was attributed to antibodies specific for cell proteins including human leucocyte antigens (HLA) class I and II incorporated into virions during vaccine and challenge virus preparation. We show here, using HLA bead arrays, that vaccinated macaques protected from virus challenge had higher serum antibody reactivity compared with non-protected animals. Moreover, reactivity was shown to be directed against HLA framework determinants. Previous studies failed to correlate serum antibody mediated virus neutralisation with protection and were confounded by cytotoxic effects. Using a virus entry assay based on TZM-bl cells we now report that, in the presence of complement, serum antibody titres that neutralise virus infectivity were higher in protected animals. We propose that complement-augmented virus neutralisation is a key factor in inducing sterilising immunity and may be difficult to achieve with HIV/SIV Env-based vaccines. Understanding how to overcome the apparent block of inactivated SIV vaccines to elicit anti-envelope protein antibodies that effectively engage the complement system could enable novel anti-HIV antibody vaccines that induce potent, virolytic serological response to be developed.

A microcarrier-based cell culture process for the production of a bovine respiratory syncytial virus vaccine

Veterinary viral vaccines generally comprise either attenuated or chemically inactivated viruses which have been propagated on mammalian cell substrates or specific pathogen free (SPF) eggs. New generation vaccines include chemically inactivated virally-infected whole cell vaccines. The NM57 cell line is a bovine nasal turbinate persistently infected (non-lytic infection) with a strain of the respiratory syncytial virus (RSV). The potential of microcarrier technology for the cultivation in bioreactors of this anchorage dependent cell line for RSV vaccine production has been investigated. Both Cytodex 3 and Cultispher S microcarriers proved most suitable from a selection of microcarriers as growth substrates for this NM57 cell line. Maximum cell densities of 4.12×105 cells ml-1and 5.52×105 cells ml-1 respectively were obtained using Cytodex 3 (3 g l-1) and and Cultispher S (1 g l-1) in 5 l bioreactor cultures. The fact that cell growth was less sensitive to agitation rate when cultured on Cultispher S microcarriers, and that cells were efficiently harvested from this microcarrier by an enzymatic method, suggested Cultispher S is suitable for further evaluation at larger bioreactor scales (>5 l) than that described here.

A single vaccination with an inactivated bovine respiratory syncytial virus vaccine primes the cellular immune response in calves with maternal antibody

Background

The efficacy of a single dose of an inactivated bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) - Parainfluenaza type 3 (PI3) - Mannheimia haemolytica (Mh) combination vaccine, in calves positive for maternal antibodies, was established in a BRSV infection study.

Results

As expected the single vaccination did not have any effect on the decline of BRSV-specific neutralising or ELISA antibody. The cellular immune system was however primed by the vaccination. In the vaccinated group virus excretion with nasal discharge was reduced, less virus could be re-isolated from lung tissues and the lungs were less affected.

Conclusions

These results indicate that a single vaccination with an inactivated BRSV vaccine was able to break through the maternal immunity and induce partial protection in very young calves. It can be speculated that the level and duration of protection will improve after the second dose of vaccine is administered. A two-dose basic vaccination schedule is recommended under field conditions.

Host species-specific usage of the TLR4-LPS receptor complex

Recognition of LPS depends on the interaction of at least three molecules forming the LPS-receptor complex. The most important ones, CD14, MD2 and Toll-like receptor (TLR) 4 share a high degree of homology between species. In the present study, we investigated the importance of species-specific restriction on the recognition of LPS using stably transfected HEK293 cell lines expressing either human or bovine LPS-receptor complex components. Species-specific MD2 appeared to confer LPS recognition, whereas species-specific CD14 only appeared to play a minor role. In addition to the recognition of LPS, there is evidence that the fusion (F) protein of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), which is the most common viral respiratory pathogen during infancy world-wide, interacts with TLR4, and plays an important role in the initiation of the innate immune response. Our findings suggest that human and bovine RSV may activate human and bovine TLR4 receptors, respectively, in the presence of both MD2 and CD14. However, no clear role for the RSV F protein of either human or bovine RSV alone in stimulating TLR4-dependent NF-kappaB activation was observed.

Human and bovine respiratory syncytial virus vaccine research and development

Human (HRSV) and bovine (BRSV) respiratory syncytial viruses (RSV) are two closely related viruses, which are the most important causative agents of respiratory tract infections of young children and calves, respectively. BRSV vaccines have been available for nearly 2 decades. They probably have reduced the prevalence of RSV infection but their efficacy needs improvement. In contrast, despite decades of research, there is no currently licensed vaccine for the prevention of HRSV disease. Development of a HRSV vaccine for infants has been hindered by the lack of a relevant animal model that develops disease, the need to immunize immunologically immature young infants, the difficulty for live vaccines to find the right balance between attenuation and immunogenicity, and the risk of vaccine-associated disease. During the past 15 years, intensive research into a HRSV vaccine has yielded vaccine candidates, which have been evaluated in animal models and, for some of them, in clinical trials in humans. Recent formulations have focused on subunit vaccines with specific CD4+ Th-1 immune response-activating adjuvants and on genetically engineered live attenuated vaccines. It is likely that different HRSV vaccines and/or combinations of vaccines used sequentially will be needed for the various populations at risk. This review discusses the recent advances in RSV vaccine development.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus lacking the virokinin or with a mutation in furin cleavage site RA(R/K)R109 induces less pulmonary inflammation without impeding the induction of protective immunity in calves

The BRSV fusion (F) protein is cleaved at two furin consensus sequence sites, resulting in the generation of disulphide-linked F1 and F2 subunits and the release of an intervening peptide of 27 amino acids (pep27), which is converted into a biologically active tachykinin (virokinin). The role of the virokinin and the importance of one of the furin cleavage sites, FCS-2 [RA(R/K)R109], in the pathogenesis of BRSV infection and in the subsequent development of immunity was studied in gnotobiotic calves infected with a recombinant BRSV (rBRSV) lacking pep27 (rBRSVdelta p27) or with rBRSV108/109, which contains two amino acid substitutions in FCS-2 (RANN109). Although replication of the mutant viruses and the parental wild-type (WT) rBRSV in the lungs was similar, the extent of gross and microscopic lesions induced by the mutant viruses was less than that induced by WT rBRSV. Furthermore, the numbers of eosinophils in the lungs of calves infected with the mutant viruses were significantly less than that in calves infected with WT virus. These observations suggest a role for the virokinin in the pathogenesis of BRSV infection. Following mucosal immunization with rBRSVdelta p27, the levels of BRSV-specific serum antibodies were similar to those induced by WT virus. In contrast, the level of neutralizing antibodies induced by rBRSV108/109 was 10-fold lower than that induced by WT virus. Nevertheless, resistance to BRSV challenge induced by the mutant and WT viruses was similar, suggesting that neither pep27 nor FCS-2 plays a major role in the induction of protective immunity.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus ISCOMs--protection in the presence of maternal antibodies

The protection induced by immunostimulating complexes (ISCOMs) against bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) was evaluated and compared to that of a commercial inactivated vaccine (CV) in calves with BRSV-specific maternal antibodies. Following experimental challenge, controls (n = 4) and animals immunized with CV (n = 5) developed moderate to severe respiratory disease, whereas calves immunized with ISCOMs (n = 5) remained clinically healthy. BRSV was re-isolated from the nasopharynx of all controls and from all calves immunized with CV, but from none of the calves immunized with ISCOMs. BRSV-RNA was detected by real-time PCR from a single animal in this group. Significantly higher BRSV-specific nasal IgG, serum IgG1 and IgG2 titers were detected before and after challenge in animals immunized with ISCOMs versus CV. In conclusion, the ISCOMs overcame the suppressive effect of maternal antibodies in calves and induced strong clinical and virological protection against a BRSV challenge.

DNA vaccination against respiratory syncytial virus in young calves

A DNA vaccine encoding the fusion (F) gene (DNA-F) of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) induced significant protection against BRSV infection in young calves. However, serum antibody to RSV developed more slowly in animals vaccinated with DNA-F when compared with those previously infected with BRSV. Furthermore, protection against BRSV infection was not as great as that induced by prior BRSV infection. Although there was little difference in the level of protection induced in calves vaccinated with DNA-F by either the intramuscular (i.m.) or intradermal (i.d.) routes, only the i.m. route primed for a rapid BRSV-specific IgA response after BRSV challenge. These results indicate that a DNA vaccination may be effective against RSV infection even in very young infants and calves.

Protection against bovine respiratory syncytial virus challenge following a single dose of vaccine in young calves with maternal antibody

Twenty-one young calves with maternally derived antibody to bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) were divided into three groups of seven, each group balanced for BRSV antibody titre. The calves had no evidence of previous exposure to BRSV. The calves in one group were given a single dose of a monovalent modified live BRSV vaccine; the calves in the second group were given a single dose of an inactivated combined BRSV, parainfluenza virus type 3, Mannheimia haemolytica vaccine and the calves in the third group were left as unvaccinated controls. Three weeks after the single doses of vaccine, all the calves were challenged with BRSV. The clinical signs of disease were mild, and virus excretion was limited to two calves in the group given the inactivated vaccine, compared with six in the negative controls (P = 0.05) and five in the group given the live vaccine. The mean virus excretion titres after the challenge were not significantly different between the groups. There was little seroconversion before the challenge, but six of the seven calves in the group given the inactivated vaccine showed significant seroconversion within two weeks after the challenge, compared with only one calf in each of the other two groups (P = 0.015).

Evaluation of efficacy of an inactivated vaccine against bovine respiratory syncytial virus in calves with maternal antibodies

OBJECTIVE

To assess short- and long-term efficacy of an inactivated bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) vaccine administered i.m. to calves with maternally derived antibodies.

ANIMALS

28 two-week-old calves with neutralizing, maternally derived antibodies against BRSV.

PROCEDURE

For evaluation of short-term efficacy, 6 calves were vaccinated i.m. at 2 and 6 weeks of age and challenged intranasally and intratracheally along with a matched group of 4 unvaccinated control calves at 10 weeks of age. For evaluation of long-term efficacy, 2 groups of 6 calves each were vaccinated i.m. at 2, 6, and 18 weeks of age or 14 and 18 weeks of age; these calves were challenged intranasally and intratracheally along with 6 matched unvaccinated control calves at 43 weeks of age. Serum virus neutralizing antibody titer, clinical reactions, and virus shedding in nasal mucus and lung washings were assessed.

RESULTS

None of the vaccination regimens resulted in a significant increase in serum virus neutralizing antibody titer. As judged by virus shedding in nasal mucus and lung washings, vaccinated calves were protected against challenge, compared with unvaccinated control groups. Clinical signs attributable to challenge were coughing (short-term efficacy study) and tachypnea and dyspnea (long-term efficacy study). The severity and incidence of disease were significantly lower in the vaccinated groups, compared with that in the unvaccinated groups.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Through vaccination, it is possible to protect vulnerable calves with maternal antibodies against BRSV infection and reduce respiratory tract disease.

Role of alpha/beta interferons in the attenuation and immunogenicity of recombinant bovine respiratory syncytial viruses lacking NS proteins

Alpha/beta interferons (IFN-alpha/beta) are not only a powerful first line of defense against pathogens but also have potent immunomodulatory activities. Many viruses have developed mechanisms of subverting the IFN system to enhance their virulence. Previous studies have demonstrated that the nonstructural (NS) genes of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) counteract the antiviral effects of IFN-alpha/beta. Here we demonstrate that, in contrast to wild-type BRSVs, recombinant BRSVs (rBRSVs) lacking the NS proteins, and those lacking NS2 in particular, are strong inducers of IFN-alpha/beta in bovine nasal fibroblasts and bronchoalveolar macrophages. Furthermore, whereas the NS deletion mutants replicated to wild-type rBRSV levels in cells lacking a functional IFN-alpha/beta system, their replication was severely attenuated in IFN-competent cells and in young calves. These results suggest that the NS proteins block the induction of IFN-alpha/beta gene expression and thereby increase the virulence of BRSV. Despite their poor replication in the respiratory tract of young calves, prior infection with virus lacking either the NS1 or the NS2 protein induced serum antibodies and protection against challenge with virulent BRSV. The greater level of protection induced by the NS2, than by the NS1, deletion mutant, was associated with higher BRSV-specific antibody titers and greater priming of BRSV-specific, IFN-gamma-producing CD4(+) T cells. Since there were no detectable differences in the ability of these mutants to replicate in the bovine respiratory tract, the greater immunogenicity of the NS2 deletion mutant may be associated with the greater ability of this virus to induce IFN-alpha/beta.

Recognition of bovine respiratory syncytial virus proteins by bovine CD8+ T lymphocytes

CD8+ T lymphocytes play a major role in the clearance of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV), an important respiratory pathogen of young calves that shares many of the epidemiological and pathological features of human respiratory syncytial virus (HRSV) in infants. Recombinant vaccinia virus (rVV) and recombinant fowlpox virus (rFPV), expressing individual BRSV proteins, were used to demonstrate that the F, N and M2 proteins were the major antigens recognized by bovine CD8+ T cells in major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-defined cattle. BRSV protein recognition by CD8+ T cells was analysed using cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) assays or by the production of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) following restimulation with BRSV proteins. Strong recognition of the G protein by CD8+ T cells was observed in cattle that had been vaccinated with rVV expressing this protein and subsequently challenged with BRSV. Although there is variation in the number of expressed MHC genes in cattle with different class I haplotypes, this did not appear to influence BRSV protein recognition by CD8+ T cells. Knowledge of the antigenic specificity of BRSV-specific CD8+ T cells will facilitate the qualitative and quantitative analysis of BRSV-specific CD8+ T-cell memory in cattle and help to ensure that potential vaccines induce a qualitatively appropriate CD8+ T-cell response.

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) nonstructural (NS) proteins as host range determinants: a chimeric bovine RSV with NS genes from human RSV is attenuated in interferon-competent bovine cells

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) escapes from cellular responses to alpha/beta interferon (IFN-alpha/beta) by a concerted action of the two viral nonstructural proteins, NS1 and NS2. Here we show that the NS proteins of human RSV (HRSV) are also able to counteract IFN responses and that they have the capacity to protect replication of an unrelated rhabdovirus. Even combinations of BRSV and HRSV NS proteins showed a protective activity, suggesting common mechanisms and cellular targets of HRSV and BRSV NS proteins. Although able to cooperate, NS proteins from BRSV and HRSV showed differential protection capacity in cells from different hosts. A chimeric BRSV with HRSV NS genes (BRSV h1/2) was severely attenuated in bovine IFN competent MDBK and Klu cells, whereas it replicated like BRSV in IFN-incompetent Vero cells or in IFN-competent human HEp-2 cells. After challenge with exogenous IFN-alpha, BRSV h1/2 was better protected than wild-type BRSV in human HEp-2 cells. In contrast, in cells of bovine origin, BRSV h1/2 was much less resistant to exogenous IFN than wild-type BRSV. These data demonstrate that RSV NS1 and NS2 proteins are major determinants of host range. The differential IFN escape capacity of RSV NS proteins in cells from different hosts provides a basis for rational development of attenuated live RSV vaccines.

Identification of CD4+ T cell epitopes on the fusion (F) and attachment (G) proteins of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV)

To gain insight into the antigenic structure of the F and G proteins of BRSV, we have mapped CD4+ T cell epitopes on these proteins using synthetic peptides and lymphocytes from vaccinated, naturally infected or experimentally infected calves, in proliferation assays. Bovine CD4+ T cells recognised epitopes that were distributed predominantly within the F1 subunit of the F protein, some of which were adjacent to previously identified B cell epitopes. Bovine CD4+ T cell epitopes within the G protein were mainly located within the cytoplasmic tail. Several immunodominant bovine T cell epitopes within the F protein, that were recognised by calves with different haplotypes, are also recognised by human T cells. Thus, cattle and humans appear to recognise similar T cell epitopes on the F protein. Studies using antibodies to bovine MHC class II and BoLA DR-transfected CHO cells as antigen-presenting cells indicated that immunodominant regions of the F and G proteins contained both DR- and DQ-restricted epitopes. The finding that there was little recognition of the extracellular domain of the G protein by T cells has important implications for vaccine design based on the soluble form of this protein.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus nonstructural proteins NS1 and NS2 cooperatively antagonize alpha/beta interferon-induced antiviral response

The functions of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) nonstructural proteins NS1 and NS2 were studied by generation and analysis of recombinant BRSV carrying single and double gene deletions. Whereas in MDBK cells the lack of either or both NS genes resulted in a 5,000- to 10,000-fold reduction of virus titers, in Vero cells a moderate (10-fold) reduction was observed. Interestingly, cell culture supernatants from infected MDBK cells were able to restrain the growth of NS deletion mutants in Vero cells, suggesting the involvement of NS proteins in escape from cytokine-mediated host cell responses. The responsible factors in MDBK supernatants were identified as type I interferons by neutralization of the inhibitory effect with antibodies blocking the alpha interferon (IFN-alpha) receptor. Treatment of cells with recombinant universal IFN-alpha A/D or IFN-beta revealed severe inhibition of single and double deletion mutants, whereas growth of full-length BRSV was not greatly affected. Surprisingly, all NS deletion mutants were equally repressed, indicating an obligatory cooperation of NS1 and NS2 in antagonizing IFN-mediated antiviral mechanisms. To verify this finding, we generated recombinant rabies virus (rRV) expressing either NS1 or NS2 and determined their IFN sensitivity. In cells coinfected with NS1- and NS2-expressing rRVs, virus replication was resistant to doses of IFN which caused a 1,000-fold reduction of replication in cells infected with wild-type RV or with each of the NS-expressing rRVs alone. Thus, BRSV NS proteins have the potential to cooperatively protect an unrelated virus from IFN-alpha/beta mediated antiviral responses. Interestingly, BRSV NS proteins provided a more pronounced resistance to IFN in the bovine cell line MDBK than in cell lines of other origins, suggesting adaptation to host-specific antiviral responses. The findings described have a major impact on the design of live recombinant BRSV and HRSV vaccines.

High mortality rate associated with bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) infection in Belgian white blue calves previously vaccinated with an inactivated BRSV vaccine

In a group of 60 Belgian White Blue calves less than 8 months old still housed in barns, a bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) outbreak was revealed on the basis of a direct diagnosis (immunofluorescence and virus isolation) performed on the lungs of dead animals, and the kinetics of BRSV neutralizing antibodies. Clinical signs, macroscopical and microscopical pulmonary lesions were also compatible with a BRSV infection. This outbreak is peculiar because the 35 oldest calves (204 +/- 29 days old) had been vaccinated 3-4 months before with an inactivated BRSV vaccine and 30% of these animals had died of respiratory distress. While they experienced a mild respiratory symptomatology, no death was recorded among the 25 youngest calves (69 +/- 29 days old) which had been left unvaccinated. Another peculiarity was found at the histological level where a massive infiltration of eosinophils was demonstrated in the pulmonary tissues of the dead animals. Together these data parallel the dramatic story described 30 years ago in children previously vaccinated with a formalin-inactivated human RSV (HRSV) vaccine upon a natural HRSV challenge. This illustrates that an immunopathological phenomenon also takes place after BRSV vaccination in cattle.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV): a review

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) infection is the major cause of respiratory disease in calves during the first year of life. The study of the virus has been difficult because of its lability and very poor growth in cell culture. However, during the last decade, the introduction of new immunological and biotechnological techniques has facilitated a more extensive study of BRSV as illustrated by the increasing number of papers published. Despite this growing focus, many aspects of the pathogenesis, epidemiology, immunology etc. remain obscure. The course and outcome of the infection is very complex and unpredictable which makes the diagnosis and subsequent therapy very difficult. BRSV is closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus (HRSV) which is an important cause of respiratory disease in young children. In contrast to BRSV, the recent knowledge of HRSV is regularly extensively reviewed in several books and journals. The present paper contains an updated review on BRSV covering most aspects of the structure, molecular biology, pathogenesis, pathology, clinical features, epidemiology, diagnosis and immunology based on approximately 140 references from international research journals.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV): a review

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) infection is the major cause of respiratory disease in calves during the first year of life. The study of the virus has been difficult because of its lability and very poor growth in cell culture. However, during the last decade, the introduction of new immunological and biotechnological techniques has facilitated a more extensive study of BRSV as illustrated by the increasing number of papers published. Despite this growing focus, many aspects of the pathogenesis, epidemiology, immunology etc. remain obscure. The course and outcome of the infection is very complex and unpredictable which makes the diagnosis and subsequent therapy very difficult. BRSV is closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus (HRSV) which is an important cause of respiratory disease in young children. In contrast to BRSV, the recent knowledge of HRSV is regularly extensively reviewed in several books and journals. The present paper contains an updated review on BRSV covering most aspects of the structure, molecular biology, pathogenesis, pathology, clinical features, epidemiology, diagnosis and immunology based on approximately 140 references from international research journals.

Bovine interleukin-12 and modulation of IFNgamma production

The effects of IL-12 on the responses of cattle peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) to bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) antigen and ovalbumin (OVA) were tested, in vitro. IL-12 did not affect the proliferative responses of PBMC to these antigens but markedly accelerated and augmented the level of IFNgamma secreted. When tested on lymphoblasts rather than resting T-cells IL-12 also enhanced proliferation. In contrast IL-4 and, to greater extent, IL-10 inhibited the response. The effect of IL-12 on IFNgamma synthesis was confirmed at the level of IFNgamma. mRNA expression using Taqman PCR. CD4 and CD8 T-cell populations produced IFNgamma, however, CD4 T-cells comprised the largest contributors to the IFNgamma production. Gamma/delta T-cells did not contribute markedly. A comparison of the species cross-reactivity showed bovine IL-12 was also active in the human system. This study shows that antigen-driven responses in cattle can be significantly influenced by exogenous cytokines and suggests the IL-12/IL-10 balance is crucial for regulation of IFNgamma.

Vaccination with glutaraldehyde-fixed bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV)-infected cells stimulates a better immune response in lambs than vaccination with heat-inactivated cell-free BRSV

The lamb model was used to investigate the possible protective effects of vaccination with inactivated viral antigens against experimental infection with bovine respiratory syncytial virus. Two groups of eight lambs were vaccinated with either glutaraldehyde-inactivated cell-associated virus or heat-inactivated cell-free virus and subsequently challenged with live virus, along with a group of naive lambs. The virus was shed for significantly longer periods, and the virus titres in nasal secretions were significantly higher in the group of naive lambs than in the two groups of vaccinated lambs. The period of virus-shedding in nasal secretions and virus titres was significantly lower (p < 0.01) in the group of lambs immunized with the cell-associated preparation. The same antigen stimulated better cellular immune responses as measured by virus-specific cytotoxicity or by virus-specific lymphocyte proliferation. However, priming with inactivated vaccines had no significant effect on lymphocyte responses to phytohaemagglutinin, which was found to be significantly reduced (p < 0.01) following challenge with live virus.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus

Since the first report of BRSV in the 1970s, the understanding of this agent and its respective disease has increased dramatically. Current evidence supports a major role for this virus in bovine respiratory disease. Advances in diagnostics have increased the ability to demonstrate this virus in field outbreaks of respiratory disease. The clinical signs and pathologic features have been well described, and vaccines are available to aid in prevention and control. Still, many questions remain to be answered with respect to BRSV. It appears there may be antigenic subgroups of BRSV, but the epidemiologic significance and relevance to immunization of this remains unknown. The question of differences in virulence among isolates of this virus has yet to be addressed. From an epidemiologic standpoint, the means by which BRSV perpetuates in the cattle population has yet to be elucidated. Although progress has been made in understanding the pathogenesis and immune response to BRSV, the mechanism of disease production and immune protection is incomplete. Lastly, efficacy testing of existing vaccines need to continue, as well as the development of new vaccines and new approaches to vaccination.

Primary cytotoxic T-cell responses to bovine respiratory syncytial virus in calves

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is a major cause of respiratory disease in young calves. Recent studies in calves, in which different T-cell subsets were depleted, have shown that CD8+ T cells play a central role in recovery from RSV infection. The present study demonstrates that RSV-specific, major histocompatibility complex-restricted cytotoxic T cells appear in the peripheral blood of gnotobiotic calves 7-10 days after infection with bovine RSV and were also detected in the lungs 10 days after infection. The cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) recognized antigenically distinct strains of bovine RSV. There was no correlation between either the level of CTL activity in the lung or the development of CTL in the peripheral blood and the extent of pneumonic consolidation. The demonstration of CD8+ CTL in the lungs at a time when bovine RSV has been cleared confirms the importance of these cells in recovery from infection.

Replication of bovine respiratory syncytial virus in ovine peripheral blood lymphocytes and monocytes in vitro

Adherent and non-adherent mononuclear cells obtained from the peripheral blood of normal lambs supported the replication of bovine respiratory syncytial virus in vitro. Sequential treatment of monocytes with phorbol ester acetate (PMA) enhanced their ability to support viral replication. After exposure in vitro for 24 h, viral antigens were present in 47 +/- 4.5% of monocytes and 32 +/- 3% of lymphocytes. Treatment of monocytes with PMA resulted in the increase of the proportion of cells expressing viral antigen and in the titre of infectious virus.

Cell-mediated immune responses of lambs to challenge with bovine respiratory syncytial virus

The lamb is a good model to study the pathogenesis and immune responses to infections with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) as lambs experimentally infected with bovine or human RSV may develop overt clinical disease. In the present study the development of cellular cytotoxic responses was studied in splenic, pulmonary and peripheral blood mononuclear cells obtained from lambs after primary and secondary infection with bovine RSV. Infection with bovine RSV was followed by the appearance of cytotoxic cells in the peripheral blood, the spleen and lung lavage fluids. These effector cells lysed virus-infected targets in a self-restricted manner. Depletion techniques revealed that cytotoxic activity was largely due to OvCD8+ cells. When effector cells obtained from primed lambs were stimulated with inactivated bovine RSV or with virus-infected cells in vitro, virus-specific cytotoxicity was significantly increased.

Production of long-lived neutralizing antibodies to HIV-1 IIIB in mice with a vaccinia recombinant virus-infected cell vaccine expressing gp160

A formaldehyde-fixed cell vaccine in adjuvant (syngeneic cells infected with a vaccinia virus recombinant expressing gp160: vacc-gp160) stimulated only nonneutralizing antibody when used on its own in four strains of mice, but a similar nonfixed cell vaccine stimulated neutralizing antibodies up to a titer of 1/320 in C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice previously infected with live vacc-gp160. Synthesis of ELISA antibodies to rgp120 or rgp160 did not correspond closely to the synthesis of neutralizing antibodies and should not therefore be used to monitor the production of neutralizing antibody. The ELISA antibody response produced by boosting with the cell vaccine made with the vaccinia virus expressing gp160 under the control of a T7 promoter (vacc-gp160-PT7) was as high as that in mice given an approximately 10-fold higher dose of purified rgp160. The ELISA antibody response to the cell vaccine made with vacc-gp160-PT7 was better than that in which gp160 was expressed under the vaccinia early/late promoter (vacc-gp160-P7.5). Nearly all mice (92%; 11 of 12) primed by infection with vacc-gp160 produced comparable levels of neutralizing antibodies after a single boost with rgp160, vacc-gp160-PT7-infected cells, or vacc-gp160-P7.5-infected cells. Neutralization titers peaked at around day 22 after boost, and declined by day 29. A second boost with the same vacc-gp160-infected cells gave increased neutralizing titers in all (eight of eight) mice.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Dynamics of bovine respiratory syncytial virus infections: a longitudinal epidemiological study in dairy herds

To study the epidemiology of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) infections during the year, the incidences of primary infections and reinfections were monitored by titrating antibodies to bovine RSV (BRSV) in cattle above 2 months of age in 6 dairy herds in the Netherlands. From August 1990 until September 1991, 884 cattle were sampled at one-month intervals. A total of 155 cattle, most under two years of age, had a primary antibody response. Antibody rises were found in 259 cattle of all ages. The highest incidences of BRSV infections were found in one period either in autumn or winter. In other seasons, primary infections were rare, whereas reinfections were not uncommon. In 5 out of the 6 herds, two seronegative sentinel calves were introduced at the end of the winter and none developed specific antibodies before the next winter. The observations strongly suggest that, in spite of regular reinfections, BRSV circulates during spring or summer at a very low level or not at all. Persistent BRSV infection in a number of cows might be a means for the virus to survive during summer, but a steady rate of reinfection of seropositive cows throughout the year at a low level might also maintain a reservoir of infectious virus. This study adds to the knowledge of frequency and timings of primary infections and reinfections of BRSV and it might contribute to the study of these issues of human RSV.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus protects cotton rats against human respiratory syncytial virus infection

Human respiratory syncytial virus (HRSV) is the most frequent cause of severe respiratory infections in infancy. No vaccine against this virus has yet been protective, and antiviral drugs have been of limited utility. Using the cotton rat model of HRSV infection, we examined bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV), a cause of acute respiratory disease in young cattle, as a possible vaccine candidate to protect children against HRSV infection. Cotton rats were primed intranasally with graded doses of BRSV/375 or HRSV/Long or were left unprimed. Three weeks later, they were challenged intranasally with either BRSV/375, HRSV/Long (subgroup A), or HRSV/18537 (subgroup B). At intervals postchallenge, animals were sacrificed for virus titration and histologic evaluation. Serum neutralizing antibody titers were determined at the time of viral challenge. BRSV/375 replicated to low titers in nasal tissues and lungs. Priming with 10(5) PFU of BRSV/375 effected a 500- to 1,000-fold reduction in peak nasal HRSV titer and a greater than 1,000-fold reduction in peak pulmonary HRSV titer upon challenge with HRSV/Long or HRSV/18537. In contrast to priming with HRSV, priming with BRSV did not induce substantial levels of neutralizing antibody against HRSV and was associated with a delayed onset of clearance of HRSV upon challenge. Priming with BRSV/375 caused mild nasal and pulmonary pathology and did not cause exacerbation of disease upon challenge with HRSV/Long. Our findings suggest that BRSV may be a potential vaccine against HRSV and a useful tool for studying the mechanisms of immunity to HRSV.

Enhancement after feline immunodeficiency virus vaccination

Cats were vaccinated with one of the three preparations: purified feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) incorporated into immune stimulating complexes (ISCOMs), recombinant FIV p24 ISCOMs, or a fixed, inactivated cell vaccine in quil A. Cats inoculated with the FIV ISCOMs or the recombinant p24 ISCOMs developed high titres of antibodies against the core protein p24 but had no detectable antibodies against the env protein gp120 or virus neutralising antibodies. In contrast, all of the cats inoculated with the fixed, inactivated cell vaccine developed anti-env antibodies and four of five had detectable levels of neutralising antibody. However, none of the vaccinated cats were protected from infection after intraperitoneal challenge with 20 infectious units of FIV. Indeed there appeared to be enhancement of infection after vaccination as the vaccinated cats become viraemic sooner than the unvaccinated controls, and 100% of the vaccinated cats became viraemic compared with 78% of the controls. The mechanism responsible for this enhancement remains unknown.

Class-specific antibodies to bovine respiratory syncytial virus in experimentally infected lambs

Enzyme-linked immunoabsorbent assay (ELISA) was used to titrate virus-specific IgG, IgM and IgA levels in nasal secretions, lung lavage fluids and serum samples sequentially obtained from lambs experimentally infected with bovine respiratory syncytial virus (RSV). Virus-specific IgG and IgM responses were measured by the indirect double antibody sandwich ELISA using anti-bovine RSV monoclonal antibody, as capture antibody, and peroxidase-conjugated anti-sheep IgG and anti-sheep IgM. Virus-specific IgA antibodies were measured by antibody capture assay using anti-sheep IgA (alpha-chain specific) and anti-bovine RSV monoclonal antibodies. Bovine RSV-specific IgM and IgA antibodies were detected in the serum samples within 6 days post-inoculation (p.i.). Virus-specific IgC antibodies appeared in serum samples 4 days later. In nasal secretions, IgA antibodies appeared 7 days p.i. but IgM antibodies were not detected until 12-16 days p.i. In serum samples, IgM titres were predominant for the first 2 weeks p.i. IgC titres becoming predominant thereafter. In nasal secretions and lung lavage fluids, IgA titres were significantly higher than IgM or IgG titres up to 21 days p.i. (0.01).

Reinfection of lambs with bovine respiratory syncytial virus

Eight lambs which were experimentally infected with bovine respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) when they were six to eight weeks old were challenged with the same virus seven months later. After reinfection, lambs developed mild clinical disease and the virus was isolated from nasal swabs from three lambs and peripheral blood from two lambs. Reinfection resulted in changes in peripheral blood cell populations. There was an early increase in the number of CD8+ T lymphocytes and B (LCA p220+) lymphocytes but the proportions of CD4+ and CD4-CD8- T lymphocytes were significantly reduced. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells obtained from lambs reinfected with bovine RSV showed significantly higher responses to bovine RSV antigen in vitro than those obtained from control lambs but their responses to the mitogen phytohaemagglutinin were significantly lower than in control lambs. RSV-specific IgG, IgM and IgA levels of serum samples obtained 10 days after challenge were significantly higher than those of serum samples obtained before challenge.

Cytotoxic T cell responses in lambs experimentally infected with bovine respiratory syncytial virus

The role of cell-mediated immune response in the immunopathogenesis of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) infection is not well established. In the present study, cytotoxic T cell responses of BRSV-infected lambs were examined using the chromium release assay. Lambs experimentally infected with BRSV developed cytotoxic lymphocytes in the peripheral blood and the spleen, which lysed BRSV-infected but not uninfected cells. Peak cytotoxic activity occurred 10-14 days after infection. Pretreatment of mononuclear cells with anti-CD8 monoclonal antibodies and rabbit complement significantly reduced cytotoxic activity (P less than 0.05). It appears, therefore, that lambs experimentally infected with BRSV develop virus-specific, predominantly CD8+, cytotoxic lymphocytes in the peripheral blood and spleen.

Effects of recombinant human alpha A interferon in gnotobiotic calves challenged with respiratory syncytial virus

The effects of recombinant human alpha A interferon were studied in gnotobiotic calves challenged with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV). Gnotobiotic calves given doses of interferon by intramuscular injection over five days showed a marked, dose-related, rise in rectal temperature and depression of circulating leucocytes. Differential counts showed decreases in both lymphocytes and neutrophils. No significant pathological differences were found between treated and untreated calves, nor could any difference be demonstrated in the pattern of RSV infection.

Preliminary report: protection of cynomolgus macaques against simian immunodeficiency virus by fixed infected-cell vaccine

Cynomolgus macaques were vaccinated with inactivated simian immunodeficiency virus-infected cells and 'Quil-A' as adjuvant at 0, 4, 8, and 36 weeks or at 0, 4, 8, and 16 weeks. 2 weeks later these animals, together with a similar unvaccinated group, were challenged with 10 MID50 (50% monkey infectious doses) of a pool of SIVmac251 previously titrated in vivo. Virus was repeatedly isolated from unvaccinated animals on at least five separate occasions and proviral DNA was detected in circulating lymphocytes by polymerase chain reaction amplification. By contrast, virus and proviral DNA were not found in any of the vaccinated animals. However, the same vaccination regimen used after live virus challenge did not eliminate virus from previously infected macaques.

Immunity to human and bovine respiratory syncytial virus

Human and bovine respiratory syncytial viruses resemble each other closely. During annual winter outbreaks, they cause similar respiratory tract disease in infants and calves. The disease is most severe in children and calves between 1 and 3 months old, when maternal antibodies against the virus are usually present. Reinfections, which are common, are accompanied by progressively milder illnesses in children, but are symptomless in calves. Because maternal antibodies suppress serum and mucosal antibody responses of all isotypes, the development of a vaccine that is effective in young children and calves with high levels of maternal antibodies has been severely hampered. Although virus administered intranasally to young calves with maternal antibodies does not evoke antibody responses, it can prime these calves for a protective memory response upon reinfection. Protection appears to be associated with the capacity to mount a mucosal memory IgA response. There are several indications that one or more immunopathologic mechanisms contribute to the disease. An Arthus reaction (type III) may have a role in the pathogenesis, because activated complement may cause most of the pathologic lesions, including edema and emphysema in uninfected parts of the lung. Lungs from calves with severe or fatal disease have depositions of complement component C3 and a low histamine content. The most immunogenic and protective antigen of the virus is the fusion (F) glycoprotein, which evokes a strong antibody response and is a target for cytotoxic T cells. On the F protein, epitopes that induce neutralizing and non-neutralizing antibodies, both of which may enhance complement activation, were identified. Immunity to the F protein may have beneficial and harmful effects.

Detection of bovine respiratory syncytial virus using a heterologous antigen-capture enzyme immunoassay

Based on the marked antigenic similarities that exist between antigens of the human and bovine strains of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), an enzyme immunoassay (EIA) designed to detect human RSV was used to detect bovine RSV. The commercial test kit (RSV EIA) consists of a solid phase (beads) coated with a capture antiserum prepared against the Long strain of human RSV. The RSV EIA test was compared with the method of inoculation of cell cultures and fluorescent antibody (FA) staining of lung tissue for the detection of bovine RSV. Using a cell culture-propagated stock of strain 375 of bovine RSV, the threshold of sensitivity of the EIA test for the cattle strain of RSV was determined to be less than or equal to 10(2.3) CCID50/ml. In addition, RSV EIA detected the bovine RSV in nasal samples obtained from 3 experimentally inoculated cattle. The RSV EIA exhibited a sensitivity of greater than or equal to 80% during the period that shedding of infectious virus took place. All of the bovine RSV FA-positive lung samples (n = 37) were positive by the RSV EIA. Twenty-six of the remaining 214 bovine RSV FA-negative lung samples were positive by the RSV EIA. The RSV EIA was also used to test 137 nasal swabs obtained from cases of bovine respiratory disease. Of these, 38 tested positive by RSV EIA. All samples that tested positive by EIA were confirmed by blocking assays using hyperimmune serum anti-bovine RSV and a pool of monoclonal antibodies specific for that virus.

Detection of IgE antibodies to bovine respiratory syncytial virus

The role of IgE antibodies against respiratory syncytial virus has attracted attention for both human and bovine disease. To detect such antibodies, we have developed an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) specific for bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV). Firstly, antiserum strongly positive for BRSV-specific IgE was produced by immunizing a levamisole-treated calf with BRSV. The presence and specificity of BRSV-specific IgE in this animal was confirmed with the Praunitz-Kustner (PK) technique. Potential interference in an ELISA by other BRSV-specific immunoglobulin isotypes was eliminated by preferential precipitation of serum samples with 27.5% saturated ammonium sulfate. The correlation between the PK and the assay was greater than 93% and the ELISA was found to be more specific than the PK. Indeed, in a pilot experimental infection study, the serum levels of BRSV-specific IgE were found to correlate with the symptom expression following repetitive live virus aerosolization. This may prove to be a useful rapid test to study both herd immunity and the potential pathogenic influence of IgE.

Protection against respiratory infection with bovine virus diarrhoea virus by passively acquired antibody

Susceptibility to infection with bovine virus diarrhoea virus (BVDV) was compared for calves with varying amounts of specific antibody in their sera passively acquired from the ingestion of colostrum. Challenge consisted of intranasal exposure to a strain of BVDV isolated from an outbreak of respiratory disease. Resistance to infection, as judged by nasopharyngeal shedding of virus, was directly related to the titre of neutralizing antibodies in sera. Besides protecting against infection of the upper respiratory tract, passive antibody, which was mainly IgG1, also protected against viraemia and, to a lesser extent, leukopenia. In the presence of colostral antibody, neutralizing and IgG1 antibody responses were apparently inhibited, but a specific IgG2 response occurred.

Experimental polyvalent ISCOMs subunit vaccine induces antibodies that neutralize human and bovine respiratory syncytial virus

The purpose of the present study was to evaluate experimentally, in guinea-pigs, the immunogenicity of respiratory syncytial (RS) virus subunit vaccines. Immunostimulating complexes (ISCOMs), made from the surface proteins of both human (Long) and bovine (A-51908) RS strains adsorbed to the adjuvant Quil A, were assayed for their capacity to induce neutralizing antibodies, in comparison to experimental live virus vaccines. Serums from animals vaccinated with either the human or bovine RS subunit vaccines were equally efficient in neutralizing human or bovine RS virus. ISCOMs prepared with bovine RS virus proteins were significantly (p less than 0.05%) more efficient than their human counterpart, in inducing neutralizing antibodies, suggesting their greater potential as a subunit vaccine.