Gas-phase concentration, purification, and identification of whole proteins from complex mixtures

Single-Frequency Ion Parking in a Digital 3D Quadrupole Ion Trap

Single-frequency ion parking, a useful technique in electrospray mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), involves gas-phase charge-reduction ion/ion reactions in an electrodynamic ion trap in conjunction with the application of a supplementary oscillatory voltage to selectively inhibit the reaction rate of an ion of interest. The ion parking process provides a means for limiting the extent of charge reduction in a controlled fashion and allows for ions distributed over a range of charge states to be concentrated into fewer charge states (a single charge state under optimal conditions). As charge reduction inherently leads to an increase in the mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio of the ions, it is important that the means for storing and analyzing ions be able to accommodate ions of high m/z ratios. The so-called 'digital ion trap' (DIT), which uses a digital waveform as the trapping RF, has been demonstrated to be well-suited for the analysis of high m/z ions by taking advantage of its ability to manipulate the waveform frequency. In this study, the feasibility of ion parking in a 3D quadrupole ion trap operated as a DIT using a slow-amplitude single-frequency sine-wave for selective inhibition of an ion/ion reaction is demonstrated. A recently described model that describes ion parking has been adjusted for the DIT case and is used to interpret experimental data for proteins ranging in mass from 8600 Da to 467,000 Da.

Ion parking in native mass spectrometry

A forced, damped harmonic oscillator model for gas-phase ion parking using single-frequency resonance excitation is described and applied to high-mass ions of relevance to native mass spectrometry. Experimental data are provided to illustrate key findings revealed by the modelling. These include: (i) ion secular frequency spacings between adjacent charge states of a given protein are essentially constant and decrease with the mass of the protein (ii) the mechanism for ion parking of high mass ions is the separation of the ion clouds of the oppositely-charged ions with much less influence from an increase in the relative ion velocity due to resonance excitation, (iii) the size of the parked ion cloud ultimately limits ion parking at high m/z ratio, and (iv) the extent of ion parking of off-target ions is highly sensitive to the bath gas pressure in the ion trap. The model is applied to ions of 17 kDa, 467 kDa, and 2 MDa while experimental data are also provided for ions of horse skeletal muscle myoglobin (≈17 kDa) and β-galactosidase (≈467 kDa). The model predicts and data show that it is possible to effect ion parking on a 17 kDa protein to the 1+ charge state under trapping conditions that are readily accessible with commercially available ion traps. It is also possible to park β-galactosidase efficiently to a roughly equivalent m/z ratio (i.e., the 26+ charge state) under the same trapping conditions. However, as charge states decrease, analyte ion cloud sizes become too large to allow for efficient ion trapping. The model allows for a semi-quantitative prediction of ion trapping performance as a function of ion trapping, resonance excitation, and pressure conditions.

Selective Schiff base formation via gas-phase ion/ion reactions to enable differentiation of isobaric lipids in imaging mass spectrometry

The separation and identification of lipids in complex mixtures are critical to deciphering their cellular functions. Failure to resolve isobaric compounds (e.g., via high mass resolution or tandem mass spectrometry) can result in incorrect identifications in mass spectrometry experiments. In imaging mass spectrometry, unresolved peaks can also result in composite images of multiple compounds, giving inaccurate depictions of molecular distributions. Gas-phase ion/ion reactions can be used to selectively react with specific chemical functional groups on a target analyte, thereby extracting it from a complex mixture and shifting its m/z value to an unobstructed region of the mass range. Herein, we use selective Schiff base formation via a novel charge inversion ion/ion reaction to purify phosphatidylserines from other isobaric (i.e., same nominal mass) lipids and reveal their singular distributions in imaging mass spectrometry. The selective Schiff base formation between singly deprotonated phosphatidylserine (PS) lipid anions and doubly charged N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-N,N'-bis(6-oxohexyl)hexane-1,6-diaminium (TMODA) cations is performed using a modified commercial dual source hybrid Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometer. This process is demonstrated using the isobaric lipids [PS 40:6 - H]- (m/z 834.528) and [SHexCer d38:1 - H]- (m/z 834.576), which produces [PS 40:6 + TMODA - H - H2O]+ (m/z 1186.879), and [SHexCer d38:1 + TMODA - H]+ (m/z 1204.938) product ions following the gas-phase charge inversion reaction. These product ions differ by roughly 18 Da in mass and are easily separated by low mass resolution analysis, while the isobaric precursor ions require roughly 45,000 mass resolving power (full-width at half maximum) to separate. Imaging mass spectrometry using targeted gas-phase ion/ion reactions shows distinct spatial distributions for the separated lipid product ions relative to the composite images of the unseparated precursor ions.

Formation of Fibrils by the Periplasmic Molecular Chaperone HdeB from Escherichia coli

The molecular chaperones HdeA and HdeB of the Escherichia coli (E. coli) periplasm protect client proteins from acid denaturation through a unique mechanism that utilizes their acid denatured states to bind clients. We previously demonstrated that the active, acid-denatured form of HdeA is also prone to forming inactive, amyloid fibril-like aggregates in a pH-dependent, reversible manner. In this study, we report that HdeB also displays a similar tendency to form fibrils at low pH. HdeB fibrils were observed at pH < 3 in the presence of NaCl. Similar to HdeA, HdeB fibrils could be resolubilized by a simple shift to neutral pH. In the case of HdeB, however, we found that after extended incubation at low pH, HdeB fibrils were converted into a form that could not resolubilize at pH 7. Fresh fibrils seeded from these “transformed” fibrils were also incapable of resolubilizing at pH 7, suggesting that the transition from reversible to irreversible fibrils involved a specific conformational change that was transmissible through fibril seeds. Analyses of fibril secondary structure indicated that HdeB fibrils retained significant alpha helical content regardless of the conditions under which fibrils were formed. Fibrils that were formed from HdeB that had been treated to remove its intrinsic disulfide bond also were incapable of resolubilizing at pH 7, suggesting that certain residual structures that are retained in acid-denatured HdeB are important for this protein to recover its soluble state from the fibril form.

Adaptation and Operation of a Quadrupole/Time-of-Flight Tandem Mass Spectrometer for High Mass Ion/Ion Reaction Studies

A commercial quadrupole/time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometer has been modified and evaluated for its performance in conducting ion/ion reaction studies involving high mass (>100 kDa) ions. Modifications include enabling the application of dipolar AC waveforms to opposing rods in three quadrupole arrays in the ion path. This modification allows for resonance excitation of ions to effect ion activation, selective ion isolation, and ion parking. The other set of opposing rods in each array is enabled for the application of dipolar DC voltages for the purpose of broad-band (non-selective) ion heating. The plates between each quadrupole array are enabled for the application of either DC or AC (or both) voltages. The use of AC voltages allows for the simultaneous storage of ions of opposite polarity, thereby enabling mutual storage ion/ion reactions. Ions derived from nano-electrospray ionization of GroEL and β-galactosidase under native conditions were used to evaluate limits of instrument performance, in terms of m/z range, ion isolation, and ion storage. After adjustment of the pulser frequency, ions as high in m/z as 400,000 were detected. Significant losses in efficiency were noted above m/z 250,000 that is likely due to roll-over in the ion detector efficiency and possibly also due to limitations in ion transfer efficiency from the collision quadrupole to the pulser region of the mass analyzer. No measurable decrease in the apparent mass resolving power was noted upon charge state reduction of the model ions. Resonance ejection techniques that employ the dipolar AC capabilities of the quadrupoles allow for ion isolation at m/z values much greater than the RF/DC limitation of Q1 of m/z = 2100. For example, at the highest low-mass cutoff achievable in the collision quadrupole (m/z = 500), it is possible to isolate ions of m/z as high as 62,000. This is limited by the lowest dipolar AC frequency (5 kHz) that can be applied. A simple model is included to provide for an estimate of the ion cloud radius based on ion m/z, ion z, and ion trap operating conditions. The model predicts that singly charged ions of 1 MDa and thermal energy can be contained in the ion trap at the maximum low-mass cutoff, although such an ion would not be detected efficiently. Doubly charged GroEL ions were observed experimentally. Collectively, the performance characteristics at high m/z, the functionality provided by the standard instrument capabilities, the modifications described above, and highly flexible instrument control software provide for a highly versatile platform for the study of high mass ion/ion reactions.

Thermal Analysis of a Mixture of Ribosomal Proteins by vT-ESI-MS: Toward a Parallel Approach for Characterizing the Stabilitome

The thermal stabilities of endogenous, intact proteins and protein assemblies in complex mixtures were characterized in parallel by means of variable-temperature electrospray ionization coupled to mass spectrometry (vT-ESI-MS). The method is demonstrated by directly measuring the melting transitions of seven proteins from a mixture of proteins derived from ribosomes. A proof-of-concept measurement of a fraction of an Escherichia coli lysate is provided to extend this approach to characterize the thermal stability of a proteome. As the solution temperature is increased, proteins and protein complexes undergo structural and organizational transitions; for each species, the folded ↔ unfolded and assembled ↔ disassembled populations are monitored based on changes in vT-ESI-MS charge state distributions and masses. The robustness of the approach illustrates a step toward the proteome-wide characterization of thermal stabilities and structural transitions-the stabilitome.

Using 10,000 Fragment Ions to Inform Scoring in Native Top-down Proteomics

Protein fragmentation is a critical component of top-down proteomics, enabling gene-specific protein identification and full proteoform characterization. The factors that influence protein fragmentation include precursor charge, structure, and primary sequence, which have been explored extensively for collision-induced dissociation (CID). Recently, noticeable differences in CID-based fragmentation were reported for native versus denatured proteins, motivating the need for scoring metrics that are tailored specifically to native top-down mass spectrometry (nTDMS). To this end, position and intensity were tracked for 10,252 fragment ions produced by higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD) of 159 native monomers and 70 complexes. We used published structural data to explore the relationship between fragmentation and protein topology and revealed that fragmentation events occur at a large range of relative residue solvent accessibility. Additionally, our analysis found that fragment ions at sites with an N-terminal aspartic acid or a C-terminal proline make up on average 40 and 27%, respectively, of the total matched fragment ion intensity in nTDMS. Percent intensity contributed by each amino acid was determined and converted into weights to (1) update the previously published C-score and (2) construct a native Fragmentation Propensity Score. Both scoring systems showed an improvement in protein identification or characterization in comparison to traditional methods and overall increased confidence in results with fewer matched fragment ions but with high probability nTDMS fragmentation patterns. Given the rise of nTDMS as a tool for structural mass spectrometry, we forward these scoring metrics as new methods to enhance analysis of nTDMS data.

Valet Parking for Protein Ion Charge State Concentration: Ion/Molecule Reactions in Linear Ion Traps

There are several analytical applications in which it is desirable to concentrate analyte ions generated over a range of charge states into a single charge state. This has been demonstrated in the gas phase via ion/ion reactions in conjunction with a technique termed ion parking, which can be implemented in electrodynamic ion traps. Ion parking depends upon the selective inhibition of the reaction of a selected charge state or charge states. In this work, we demonstrate a similar charge state concentration effect using ion/molecule reactions rather than ion/ion reactions. The rates of ion/molecule reactions cannot be affected in the manner used in conventional ion parking. Rather, to inhibit the progression of ion/molecule proton transfer reactions, the product ions must be removed from the reaction cell as they are formed and transferred to an ion trap where no reactions occur. This is accomplished here with mass-selective axial ejection (MSAE) from one linear ion trap to another. The application of MSAE to inhibit ion/molecule reactions is referred to as "valet parking" as it entails the transport of the ions of interest to a remote location for storage. Valet parking is demonstrated using model proteins to concentrate ion signal dispersed over multiple charge states into largely one charge state. Additionally, it has been applied to a simple two-protein mixture of cytochrome c and myoglobin.

Maximizing Selective Cleavages at Aspartic Acid and Proline Residues for the Identification of Intact Proteins

A new approach for the identification of intact proteins has been developed that relies on the generation of relatively few abundant products from specific cleavage sites. This strategy is intended to complement standard approaches that seek to generate many fragments relatively non-selectively. Specifically, this strategy seeks to maximize selective cleavage at aspartic acid and proline residues via collisional activation of precursor ions formed via electrospray ionization (ESI) under denaturing conditions. A statistical analysis of the SWISS-PROT database was used to predict the number of arginine residues for a given intact protein mass and predict a m/z range where the protein carries a similar charge to the number of arginine residues thereby enhancing cleavage at aspartic acid residues by limiting proton mobility. Cleavage at aspartic acid residues is predicted to be most favorable in the m/z range of 1500-2500, a range higher than that normally generated by ESI at low pH. Gas-phase proton transfer ion/ion reactions are therefore used for precursor ion concentration from relatively high charge states followed by ion isolation and subsequent generation of precursor ions within the optimal m/z range via a second proton transfer reaction step. It is shown that the majority of product ion abundance is concentrated into cleavages C-terminal to aspartic acid residues and N-terminal to proline residues for ions generated by this process. Implementation of a scoring system that weights both ion fragment type and ion fragment area demonstrated identification of standard proteins, ranging in mass from 8.5 to 29.0 kDa. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Top-Down LESA Mass Spectrometry Protein Analysis of Gram-Positive and Gram-Negative Bacteria

We have previously shown that liquid extraction surface analysis (LESA) mass spectrometry (MS) is a technique suitable for the top-down analysis of proteins directly from intact colonies of the Gram-negative bacterium Escherichia coli K-12. Here we extend the application of LESA MS to Gram-negative Pseudomonas aeruginosa PS1054 and Gram-positive Staphylococcus aureus MSSA476, as well as two strains of E. coli (K-12 and BL21 mCherry) and an unknown species of Staphylococcus. Moreover, we demonstrate the discrimination between three species of Gram-positive Streptococcus (Streptococcus pneumoniae D39, and the viridans group Streptococcus oralis ATCC 35037 and Streptococcus gordonii ATCC35105), a recognized challenge for matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight MS. A range of the proteins detected were selected for top-down LESA MS/MS. Thirty-nine proteins were identified by top-down LESA MS/MS, including 16 proteins that have not previously been observed by any other technique. The potential of LESA MS for classification and characterization of novel species is illustrated by the de novo sequencing of a new protein from the unknown species of Staphylococcus. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

The Generation of Dehydroalanine Residues in Protonated Polypeptides: Ion/Ion Reactions for Introducing Selective Cleavages

We examine a gas-phase approach for converting a subset of amino acid residues in polypeptide cations to dehydroalanine (Dha). Subsequent activation of the modified polypeptide ions gives rise to specific cleavage N-terminal to the Dha residue. This process allows for the incorporation of selective cleavages in the structural characterization of polypeptide ions. An ion/ion reaction within the mass spectrometer between a multiply protonated polypeptide and the sulfate radical anion introduces a radical site into the multiply protonated polypeptide reactant. Subsequent collisional activation of the polypeptide radical cation gives rise to radical side chain loss from one of several particular amino acid side chains (e.g., leucine, asparagine, lysine, glutamine, and glutamic acid) to yield a Dha residue. The Dha residues facilitate preferential backbone cleavages to produce signature c- and z-ions, demonstrated with cations derived from melittin, mechano growth factor (MGF), and ubiquitin. The efficiencies for radical side chain loss and for subsequent generation of specific c- and z-ions have been examined as functions of precursor ion charge state and activation conditions using cations of ubiquitin as a model for a small protein. It is noted that these efficiencies are not strongly dependent on ion trap collisional activation conditions but are sensitive to precursor ion charge state. Moderate to low charge states show the greatest overall yields for the specific Dha cleavages, whereas small molecule losses (e.g., water/ammonia) dominate at the lowest charge states and proton catalyzed amide bond cleavages that give rise to b- and y-ions tend to dominate at high charge states. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

A Comprehensive Guide for Performing Sample Preparation and Top-Down Protein Analysis

Methodologies for the global analysis of proteins in a sample, or proteome analysis, have been available since 1975 when Patrick O′Farrell published the first paper describing two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2D-PAGE). This technique allowed the resolution of single protein isoforms, or proteoforms, into single ‘spots’ in a polyacrylamide gel, allowing the quantitation of changes in a proteoform′s abundance to ascertain changes in an organism′s phenotype when conditions change. In pursuit of the comprehensive profiling of the proteome, significant advances in technology have made the identification and quantitation of intact proteoforms from complex mixtures of proteins more routine, allowing analysis of the proteome from the ‘Top-Down’. However, the number of proteoforms detected by Top-Down methodologies such as 2D-PAGE or mass spectrometry has not significantly increased since O’Farrell’s paper when compared to Bottom-Up, peptide-centric techniques. This article explores and explains the numerous methodologies and technologies available to analyse the proteome from the Top-Down with a strong emphasis on the necessity to analyse intact proteoforms as a better indicator of changes in biology and phenotype. We arrive at the conclusion that the complete and comprehensive profiling of an organism′s proteome is still, at present, beyond our reach but the continuing evolution of protein fractionation techniques and mass spectrometry brings comprehensive Top-Down proteome profiling closer.

A broader view on ion heating in traveling-wave devices using fragmentation of CsI clusters and extent of H˙ migration as molecular thermometers

Traveling-wave-dependent ion ‘heating’ is observed during mass spectrometry experiments under both ion mobility and electron transfer dissociation conditions and investigated using novel molecular ‘thermometers’.

Ultraviolet Photodissociation of Native Proteins Following Proton Transfer Reactions in the Gas Phase

The growing use of mass spectrometry in the field of structural biology has catalyzed the development of many new strategies to examine intact proteins in the gas phase. Native mass spectrometry methods have further accelerated the need for methods that can manipulate proteins and protein complexes while minimizing disruption of noncovalent interactions critical for stabilizing conformations. Proton-transfer reactions (PTR) in the gas phase offer the ability to effectively modulate the charge states of proteins, allowing decongestion of mass spectra through separation of overlapping species. PTR was combined with ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) to probe the degree of structural changes that occur upon charge reduction reactions in the gas phase. For protein complexes myoglobin·heme (17.6 kDa) and dihydrofolate reductase·methotrexate (19.4 kDa), minor changes were found in the fragmentation patterns aside from some enhancement of fragmentation near the N- and C-terminal regions consistent with slight fraying. After finding little perturbation was caused by charge reduction using PTR, homodimeric superoxide dismutase/CuZn (31.4 kDa) was subjected to PTR in order to separate overlapping monomer and dimer species of the protein that were observed at identical m/z values.

Structures of Fluoranthene Reagent Anions Used in Electron Transfer Dissociation and Proton Transfer Reaction Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Ion/ion reactions have in recent years seen widespread use in ion activation methods such as electron transfer dissociation (ETD) tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) as well as in charge manipulation of highly charged peptides/proteins and their fragments by proton transfer reaction (PTR). These techniques have, in combination, enabled top-down proteomics on limited-resolution benchtop mass spectrometry platforms such as quadrupole ion traps. Anions generated by chemical ionization of fluoranthene are often used for both ETD and PTR reactions; the radical anion of fluoranthene (m/z 202) for ETD and the closed-shell anion resulting from H atom attachment to the radical anion (m/z 203) for PTR. Here we use infrared ion spectroscopy in combination with density functional theory calculations to identify the structures of these reagent anions. We establish that the m/z 203 PTR reagent anion possesses a structure that deviates from what has been suggested previously and provides some insight into the reaction mechanism involved in PTR.

Activated Ion Electron Transfer Dissociation for Improved Fragmentation of Intact Proteins

Here we report the first implementation of activated ion electron transfer dissociation (AI-ETD) for top down protein characterization, showing that AI-ETD definitively extends the m/z range over which ETD can be effective for fragmentation of intact proteins. AI-ETD, which leverages infrared photon bombardment concurrent to the ETD reaction to mitigate nondissociative electron transfer, was performed using a novel multipurpose dissociation cell that can perform both beam-type collisional dissociation and ion-ion reactions on an ion trap-Orbitrap hybrid mass spectrometer. AI-ETD increased the number of c- and z-type product ions for all charge states over ETD alone, boosting product ion yield by nearly 4-fold for low charge density precursors. AI-ETD also outperformed HCD, generating more matching fragments for all proteins at all charge states investigated. In addition to generating more unique fragment ions, AI-ETD provided greater protein sequence coverage compared to both HCD and ETD. In all, the effectiveness of AI-ETD across the entirety of the m/z spectrum demonstrates its efficacy for robust fragmentation of intact proteins.

Gas-phase ion/ion reactions of peptides and proteins: acid/base, redox, and covalent chemistries

Gas-phase ion/ion reactions are emerging as useful and flexible means for the manipulation and characterization of peptide and protein biopolymers. Acid/base-like chemical reactions (i.e., proton transfer reactions) and reduction/oxidation (redox) reactions (i.e., electron transfer reactions) represent relatively mature classes of gas-phase chemical reactions. Even so, especially in regards to redox chemistry, the widespread utility of these two types of chemistries is undergoing rapid growth and development. Additionally, a relatively new class of gas-phase ion/ion transformations is emerging which involves the selective formation of functional-group-specific covalent bonds. This feature details our current work and perspective on the developments and current capabilities of these three areas of ion/ion chemistry with an eye towards possible future directions of the field.

Selective deletion of the internal lysine residue from the peptide sequence by collisional activation

The gas-phase peptide ion fragmentation chemistry is always the center of attraction in proteomics to analyze the amino acid sequence of peptides and proteins. In this work, we describe the formation of an anomalous fragment ion, which corresponds to the selective deletion of the internal lysine residue from a series of lysine containing peptides upon collisional activation in the ion trap. We detected several water-loss fragment ions and the maximum number of water molecules lost from a particular fragment ion was equal to the number of lysine residues in that fragment. As a consequence of this water-loss phenomenon, internal lysine residues were found to be deleted from the peptide ion. The N,N-dimethylation of all the amine functional groups of the peptide stopped the internal lysine deletion reaction, but selective N-terminal α-amino acetylation had no effect on this process indicating involvement of the side chains of the lysine residues. The detailed mechanism of the lysine deletion was investigated by multistage CID of the modified and unmodified peptides, by isotope labeling and by energy resolved CID studies. The results suggest that the lysine deletion might occur through a unimolecular multistep mechanism involving a seven-membered cyclic imine intermediate formed by the loss of water from a lysine residue in the protonated peptide. This intermediate subsequently undergoes degradation reaction to deplete the interior imine ring from the peptide backbone leading to the deletion of an internal lysine residue.

Automated gas-phase purification for accurate, multiplexed quantification on a stand-alone ion-trap mass spectrometer

Isobaric tagging enables the acquisition of highly multiplexed proteome quantification, but it is hindered by the pervasive problem of precursor interference. The elimination of coisolated contaminants prior to reporter tag generation can be achieved through the use of gas-phase purification via proton transfer ion/ion reactions (QuantMode); however, the original QuantMode technique was implemented on the high-resolution linear ion-trap-Orbitrap hybrid mass spectrometer enabled with electron transfer dissociation (ETD). Here we extend this technology to stand-alone linear ion-trap systems (trapQuantMode, trapQM). Facilitated by the use of inlet beam-type activation (i.e., trapHCD) for production and observation of the low mass-to-charge reporter region, this scan sequence comprises three separate events to maximize peptide identifications, minimize duty cycle requirements, and increase quantitative accuracy, precision, and dynamic range. Significant improvements in quantitative accuracy were attained over standard methods when using trapQM to analyze an interference model system comprising tryptic peptides of yeast that we contaminated with human peptides. Finally, we demonstrate practical benefits of this method by analysis of the proteomic changes that occur during mouse skeletal muscle myoblast differentiation. While the reduced duty cycle of trapQM led to the identification of fewer proteins than conventional operation (4050 vs 2964), trapQM identified more significant differences (>1.5 fold, 1362 vs 1132, respectively; p < 0.05) between the proteomes of undifferentiated myoblasts and differentiated myotubes and nearly 10-fold more differences with changes greater than 5-fold (96 vs 12). We further show that our trapQM dataset is superior for identifying changes in protein abundance that are consistent with the metabolic and structural changes known to accompany myotube formation.

Comprehensive analysis of protein modifications by top-down mass spectrometry

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics is playing an increasingly important role in cardiovascular research. Proteomics includes identification and quantification of proteins and the characterization of protein modifications, such as posttranslational modifications and sequence variants. The conventional bottom-up approach, involving proteolytic digestion of proteins into small peptides before MS analysis, is routinely used for protein identification and quantification with high throughput and automation. Nevertheless, it has limitations in the analysis of protein modifications, mainly because of the partial sequence coverage and loss of connections among modifications on disparate portions of a protein. An alternative approach, top-down MS, has emerged as a powerful tool for the analysis of protein modifications. The top-down approach analyzes whole proteins directly, providing a "bird's-eye" view of all existing modifications. Subsequently, each modified protein form can be isolated and fragmented in the mass spectrometer to locate the modification site. The incorporation of the nonergodic dissociation methods, such as electron-capture dissociation (ECD), greatly enhances the top-down capabilities. ECD is especially useful for mapping labile posttranslational modifications that are well preserved during the ECD fragmentation process. Top-down MS with ECD has been successfully applied to cardiovascular research, with the unique advantages in unraveling the molecular complexity, quantifying modified protein forms, complete mapping of modifications with full-sequence coverage, discovering unexpected modifications, identifying and quantifying positional isomers, and determining the order of multiple modifications. Nevertheless, top-down MS still needs to overcome some technical challenges to realize its full potential. Herein, we reviewed the advantages and challenges of the top-down method, with a focus on its application in cardiovascular research.

Solution versus gas-phase modification of peptide cations with NHS-ester reagents

A comparison between solution and gas phase modification of primary amine sites in model peptide cations with N-hydroxysuccinimide (NHS) ester reagents is presented. In all peptides, the site of modification in solution was directed to the N-terminus by conducting reactions at pH=5, whereas for the same peptides, a lysine residue was preferentially modified in the gas phase. The difference in pKa values of the N-terminus and ε-amino group of the lysine allows for a degree of control over sites of protonation of the peptides in aqueous solution. With removal of the dielectric and multiple charging of the peptide ions in the gas phase, the accommodation of excess charge can affect the preferred sites of reaction. Interaction of the lone pair of the primary nitrogen with a proton reduces its nucleophilicity and, as a result, its reactivity towards NHS-esters. While no evidence for reaction of the N-terminus with sulfo-NHS-acetate was noted in the model peptide cations, a charge inversion experiment using bis[sulfosuccinimidyl] suberate, a cross-linking reagent with two sulfo-NHS-ester functionalities, showed modification of the N-terminus. Hence, an unprotonated N-terminus can serve as a nucleophile to displace NHS, which suggests that its lack of reactivity with the peptide cations is likely due to the participation of the N-terminus in solvating excess charge.

Gas-phase purification enables accurate, multiplexed proteome quantification with isobaric tagging

We describe a mass spectrometry method, QuantMode, which improves accuracy of isobaric tag-based quantification by alleviating the pervasive problem of precursor interference, simultaneous isolation and fragmentation of impurities, through gas-phase purification. QuantMode analysis of a yeast sample 'contaminated' with interfering human peptides showed substantially improved quantitative accuracy compared to a standard scan, with a small loss of spectral identifications. This technique enables large-scale, multiplexed quantitative proteomics using isobaric tagging.

Intra- and inter-molecular cross-linking of peptide ions in the gas phase: reagents and conditions

Intra-molecular and inter-molecular cross-linking of protonated polypeptide ions in the gas phase via ion/ion reactions have been demonstrated using N-hydroxysulfosuccinimide (sulfo-NHS)- based reagent anions. The initial step in the ion/ion reaction involves the formation of a long-lived complex between the peptide and reagent, which is a prerequisite for the covalent bioconjugation chemistry. The sulfonate groups on the NHS rings of the homo-bifunctional cross-linking reagents have high affinity for the protonated sites in the peptide and, therefore, facilitate the long-lived complex formation. In addition to the formation of a long-lived chemical complex, intra-molecular cross-linking also requires two unprotonated primary amine sites within a molecule where the covalent modification takes place. Alternatively, inter-molecular cross-linking demands the availability of one neutral primary amine site in each of the two peptides that are being cross-linked. Nucleophilic displacement of two sulfo-NHS groups by the amine functionalities in the peptide is a signature of the covalent cross-linking chemistry in the gas phase. Upon removal of the two sulfo-NHS groups, two amide bonds are formed between an unprotonated, primary amine group of a lysine side chain in the peptide and the carboxyl group in the reagent.

Top-down protein characterization facilitated by ion/ion reactions on a quadrupole/time of flight platform

In comparison to bottom-up proteomics approaches, whereby peptides derived from proteolytic digestion are analyzed, top-down approaches, involving direct analysis of intact proteins, provide higher specificity for protein identification and are better-suited for the characterization of sequence variants. However, top-down protein characterization usually requires more sophisticated instrumentation and methodologies to deal with the more complex tandem mass spectra derived from dissociation of high mass multiply charged intact proteins. Gas-phase ion/ion reactions are universally applicable and have proved to be useful in mixture analysis and top-down biomolecule characterization. The coupling of the ion/ion proton transfer reaction in the context of MS/MS has been demonstrated to expand informing power in top-down protein characterization, particularly with platforms that employ electrodynamic ion trap and TOF mass analysis. In addition, probing protein primary structure using ion/ion electron transfer dissociation usually provides extensive structurally informative fragmentation and also allows for the localization of labile PTMs. Here, the performance of the widely used quadrupole/TOF platform, equipped with ion/ion reaction functionality, for top-down protein characterization is summarized, and various methodologies employing ion/ion reactions are reviewed.

Covalent modification of gaseous peptide ions with N-hydroxysuccinimide ester reagent ions

Covalent modification of primary amine groups in multiply protonated or deprotonated polypeptides in the gas phase via ion/ion reactions is demonstrated using N-hydroxysuccinimide (NHS) esters as the modifying reagents. During the ion/ion reaction, the peptide analyte ions and the NHS or sulfo-NHS based reagent form a long-lived complex, which is a prerequisite for the covalent modification chemistry to occur. Ion activation of the peptide-reagent complex results in a neutral NHS or sulfo-NHS molecule loss, which is a characteristic signature of covalent modification. As the NHS or sulfo-NHS group leaves, an amide bond is formed between a free, unprotonated, primary amine group of a lysine side chain in the peptide and the carboxyl group in the reagent. Subsequent activation of the NHS or sulfo-NHS loss product ions results in sequence informative fragment ions containing the modification. The N-terminus primary amine group does not make a significant contribution to the modification process; this behavior has also been observed in solution phase reactions. The ability to covalently modify primary amine groups in the gas phase with N-hydroxysuccinimide reagents opens up the possibility of attaching a wide range of chemical groups to gaseous peptides and proteins and also for selectively modifying other analytes containing free primary amine groups.

Targeted ion parking for the quantitation of biotherapeutic proteins: concepts and preliminary data

Targeted ion parking (or TIPing) is the first quantitative application of ion/ion reactions for mass spectrometry. In TIPing, intact biotherapeutic proteins are electrosprayed as intact molecules (no digestion) and, as expected, many multiply protonated species are produced (e.g., (M + 7H)(7+), (M + 8H)(8+), etc.). Several of these multiply charged species are selectively isolated using a quadrupole mass analyzer and then contained in a linear ion trap. The protein ions are then subjected to a proton-transfer reaction with a reagent anion. The ions undergo sequential charge reduction (e.g., to (M + 6H)(6+)) during a defined reaction period. Applying a low-amplitude waveform to the trap during this reaction time stops the ion/ion reaction at a chosen (and predicted) charge state for the protein. This funnels the analyte ions into a single channel with relatively high efficiency (>50% of reactant ion signal is converted into product ion signal) that can be used for quantitation. In TIPing, the target protein's molecular weight and charge state distribution are the only prerequisite knowledge required. This information can be acquired experimentally or can be easily predicted based upon amino acid sequences. Preliminary data for a biotherapeutic protein, a domain antibody, were collected using TIPing coupled online with liquid chromatography (LC-TIPing). The LC-TIPing data demonstrate a linear response for samples from 10-1000 ng/mL extracted from a complex plasma sample, demonstrating the analytical potential for TIPing.

Enhanced protein detection using a trapping mode on a hybrid quadrupole linear ion trap (Q-Trap)

A novel method to improve the detection of protein ions using a linear ion trap mass spectrometer is presented. A scan function combining charge separation with segmented transmission of multiply charged ions was developed to enhance the sensitivity and resolution of the linear ion trap for the nanoLC-MS analysis of intact proteins. The analytical benefits of the present method are particularly apparent in protein analyses, where the increased proportion of multiply charged ions can exacerbate space-charge effects and compromise the dynamic range of the linear ion trap instrument. The enhanced ion storage and charge separation capabilities of our targeted and enhanced multiply charged scan mode provided a 4-fold increase in signal-to-noise and 5-fold increase in resolution, thus enabling the detection of closely related protein isoforms. The application of this method is demonstrated for low femtomole detection of protein standards and nuclear extracts enriched in histone proteins. The enhanced resolution of this scan mode also enabled us to monitor subtle changes in the methylation of a subpopulation of histone H3 that occurs in chicken DT40 cells lacking specific methyltransferase activity. The extent of the fold change and PTM site localization was performed using predictive software tools and targeted multiple reaction monitoring analysis of histone peptides. Monomethylation of Lys 79 in histone H3 (H3K79me1) was down regulated by 240-fold in methyltransferase deficient cells.

Top-down protein fragmentation by infrared multiphoton dissociation in a dual pressure linear ion trap

Infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) was implemented in a novel dual pressure linear ion trap for rapid top-down proteomics. The high pressure cell provided improved trapping and isolation efficiencies while the isotopic profiles of 10+ charged ions could be resolved by mass analysis in the low pressure cell that enabled effective top down protein identification. Striking differences between IRMPD in the low pressure cell and CID in the high pressure cell were observed for proteins ranging from 8.6 to 29 kDa. Because of secondary dissociation, IRMPD yielded product ions in significantly lower charge states as compared to CID, thus facilitating more accurate mass identification and streamlining product ion assignment. This outcome was especially useful for database searching of larger proteins (approximately 29 kDa) as IRMPD substantially improved protein identification and scoring confidence. Also, IRMPD showed an increased selectivity toward backbone cleavages N-terminal to proline and C-terminal to acidic residues (especially for the lowest charge states), which could be useful for a priori spectral predictions and enhanced database searching for protein identification.

Ion/ion reactions: new chemistry for analytical MS

Gas-phase ion/ion reactions are emerging as flexible means for probing and manipulating analyte ions with particular utility in bioanalysis.

Gas-phase chemistry of multiply charged bioions in analytical mass spectrometry

Ion chemistry has long played an important role in molecular mass spectrometry (MS), as it is central to the use of MS as a structural characterization tool. With the advent of ionization methods capable of producing gaseous ions from large biomolecules, the chemistry of gaseous bioions has become a highly active area of research. Gas-phase biomolecule-ion reactions are usually driven by interactions with neutral molecules, photons, electrons, ions, or surfaces. Ion dissociation or transformation into different ion types can be achieved. The types of reaction products observed depend on the characteristics of the ions, the transformation methods, and the time frame of observation. This review focuses on the gas-phase chemistries of ions derived from the electrospray ionization of peptides, proteins, and oligonucleotides, with particular emphasis on their utility in bioanalysis. Various ion-transformation strategies, which further facilitate structural interrogation by converting ions from one type to another, are also summarized.

Sources of Urinary Proteins and their Analysis by Urinary Proteomics for the Detection of Biomarkers of Disease

Renal disorders account for a substantial fraction of the budget for health care in many countries. Proteinuria is a frequent manifestation in afflicted patients, but the origin of the proteins varies based on the nature of the disorder. The emerging field of urinary proteomics has the potential to replace kidney biopsy as the diagnostic procedure of choice for patients with some glomerular forms of renal disease. To fully realize this potential, it is vital to understand the basis for the urinary excretion of protein in physiological and pathological conditions. In this review, we discuss the structure of the nephron, the functional unit of the kidney, and the process by which proteins/peptides enter the urine. We discuss several aspects of proteinuria that impact the proteomic analysis of urine of patients with renal diseases.

Top-down protein identification/characterization of a priori unknown proteins via ion trap collision-induced dissociation and ion/ion reactions in a quadrupole/time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometer

The identification and characterization of a priori unknown proteins from an Escherichia coli (E. coli) soluble protein lysate using ion trap collision-induced dissociation of intact protein ions followed by ion/ion reactions in a quadrupole/time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometer is illustrated. The procedure involved the submission of uninterpreted product ion spectra to a peak-picking program and then to ProSightPTM for searching against an E. coli database. Examples are provided for the identification and characterization of both modified and unmodified unknown proteins with masses up to approximately 28 kDa. The availability of protein intact mass along with sequence information makes possible the characterization of proteins with post-translational modifications, such as disulfide linkages, as well as protein isoforms whose sequences are absent from a database, provided that a related form of the gene product is present in the database. This work demonstrates that the quadrupole/time-of-flight platform, in conjunction with ion-ion proton transfer reactions, can be adapted to obtain primary structure information from entire protein ions, rather than simply N- or C-terminal information from low mass-to-charge products, for proteins as large as several tens of kilodaltons.

Simultaneous transmission mode collision-induced dissociation and ion/ion reactions for top-down protein identification/characterization using a quadrupole/time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometer

Simultaneous transmission mode collision-induced dissociation (CID) and ion/ion proton transfer reactions have been implemented on a quadrupole/time-of-flight (TOF) tandem mass spectrometer. Reagent anions were trapped in a pressurized quadrupole collision cell by applying appropriate dc voltages while multiply protonated protein precursor ions were injected into the collision cell at energies sufficient to give rise to CID. Intact precursor ions as well as fragment ions underwent ion/ion proton transfer reactions during their passage through the collision cell and on to an orthogonal acceleration TOF mass analyzer. The resulting product ion spectrum was then submitted to deconvolution to yield a "zero-charge" spectrum, which was then matched against in silico produced spectra derived from a protein database. Dramatic improvements in the scores associated with correct matches were obtained relative to CID data without the benefit of ion/ion reactions for proteins as large as carbonic anhydrase (29 kDa). The parameters that most affect the extent of ion/ion proton transfer during transmission through the instrument include the number of anions stored in the collision cell, the amplitude of the radio frequency trapping voltage, the voltage of the LINAC potential associated with the collision cell, and the collision gas pressure. This work demonstrates that it is possible to effect whole protein tandem mass spectrometry with simultaneous CID, ion/ion reactions, and mass analysis for high duty cycle top-down protein characterization.

Characterization of recombinant protein mutants by top-down sequencing using quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Top-down sequencing using quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry is used as a direct way of locating the mutated sites of recombinant proteins and posttranslational modification in a protein. Several mutants of barstar, expressed in E.coli, were confirmed by analyzing the fragmentation pattern of mutants. A contaminant protein, that appeared while purifying mutants of barstar, was identified as acyl carrier protein from E.coli with a posttranslational modification on serine residue, indicating that the protein was biologically active. A mutant of ribosomal protein S6 has been characterized with neutral loss of ammonia at the N-terminal region of the protein. The power of the "top-down" approach in characterizing the mutants of recombinant proteins has been demonstrated.

Peptide and protein ion/ion reactions in electrodynamic ion traps: tools and methods

Gas-phase reactions of oppositely charged ions can play important roles in the analysis of peptides and proteins. Electrospray ionization (ESI) can yield multiply charged versions of gaseous peptide and protein ions that can react with oppositely charged ions via several distinct mechanisms. Reagent ions that react via proton transfer can be used to facilitate protein mixture analysis and the mass assignment of product ions in a tandem mass spectrometry experiment. Proton transfer reactions can also be used to concentrate protein ion signals into one or two charge states and can be used to charge state purify a precursor ion population for subsequent dissociation. Electron transfer reactions have been shown to lead to fragmentation of gaseous protonated peptides and proteins. The extent of sequence information available from an electron transfer reaction is often greater than that obtained via conventional collision-induced dissociation. Electron transfer dissociation is particularly useful in probing the structures of polypeptides with labile posttranslational modifications. We summarize here the tools and general methods for conducting ion/ion reaction studies with emphasis on electrodynamic ion traps as the reaction vessels.

Ion-Ion Reactions with Fixed-Charge Modified Proteins to Produce Ions in a Single, Very High Charge State

Electrospray ionization (ESI) of denatured proteins produces a mass spectrum with a broad distribution of multiply charged ions. Attaching fixed positive charges, specifically quaternary ammonium groups, to proteins at their carboxylic acid groups generates substantially higher charge states compared to the corresponding unmodified proteins in positive-mode ESI. Ion-ion reactions of these modified proteins with reagent anions leads to charge reduction by proton transfer. These proton transfer reactions cannot remove charge from the quaternary ammonium groups, which do not have a proton to transfer to the anion. Thus, one might expect charge reduction to stop at a single charge state equal to the number of fixed charges on the modified protein. However, ion-ion reactions yield charge states lower than this number of fixed charges due to anion attachment (adduction) to the proteins. Charge reduction via ion-molecule reactions involving gas-phase bases also give adducts on the modified protein ions in low charge states. Such adducts are avoided by keeping the ions in charge states well above the number of fixed charges. In the present work protein ions were selectively "parked" within an ion trap mass spectrometer in a high charge state by mild radiofrequency excitation that dramatically slows their ion-ion reaction rate-a technique termed "ion parking". The combination of ion parking with the fixed-charge modified proteins permits generation of a large population of ions in a single, very high charge state.

Using ProSight PTM and related tools for targeted protein identification and characterization with high mass accuracy tandem MS data

ProSight PTM v2.0, neuroProSight, and the Sequence Gazer allow the identification and characterization of proteins from high mass accuracy tandem mass spectrometric data of intact proteins and large peptides. Input data consists of one or more neutral precursor ion masses and a set of neutral b/y or c/z(.) fragment ions masses. This data is compared against "shotgun annotated" proteome databases or known protein sequences. With these tools it is possible to not only identify unknown proteins, but to determine the location of post-translational modifications (PTM) with 100% sequence coverage. Collectively, the tools create a search environment that allows five different search modes, including absolute mass and sequence tag searching, which are conveniently employed via a graphical user interface. Data management and chemical noise reduction tools are also available. These tools provide a complete environment for the identification and characterization of proteins from high resolution tandem mass spectrometry of intact proteins and large peptides.

"Proteotyping": population proteomics of human leukocytes using top down mass spectrometry

Characterizing combinations of coding polymorphisms (cSNPs), alternative splicing and post-translational modifications (PTMs) on a single protein by standard peptide-based proteomics is challenging owing to <100% sequence coverage and the uncoupling effect of proteolysis on such variations >10-20 residues apart. Because top down MS measures the whole protein, combinations of all the variations affecting primary sequence can be detected as they occur in combination. The protein form generated by all types of variation is here termed the "proteotype", akin to a haplotype at the DNA level. Analysis of proteins from human primary leukocytes harvested from leukoreduction filters using a dual on-line/off-line top down MS strategy produced >600 unique intact masses, 133 of which were identified from 67 unique genes. Utilizing a two-dimensional platform, termed multidimensional protein characterization by automated top down (MudCAT), 108 of the above protein forms were subsequently identified in the absence of MS/MS in 4 days. Additionally, MudCAT enables the quantitation of allele ratios for heterozygotes and PTM occupancies for phosphorylated species. The diversity of the human proteome is embodied in the fact that 32 of the identified proteins harbored cSNPs, PTMs, or were detected as proteolysis products. Among the information were three partially phosphorylated proteins and three proteins heterozygous at known cSNP loci, with evidence for non-1:1 expression ratios obtained for different alleles.

Evolution of instrumentation for the study of gas-phase ion/ion chemistry via mass spectrometry

The scope of gas-phase ion/ion chemistry accessible to mass spectrometry is largely defined by the available tools. Due to the development of novel instrumentation, a wide range of reaction phenomenologies has been noted, many of which have been studied extensively and exploited for analytical applications. This perspective presents the development of mass spectrometry-based instrumentation for the study of the gas-phase ion/ion chemistry in which at least one of the reactants is multiply charged. The instrument evolution is presented within the context of three essential elements required for any ion/ion reaction study: the ionization source(s), the reaction vessel or environment, and the mass analyzer. Ionization source arrangements have included source combinations that allow for reactions between multiply charged ions of one polarity and singly charged ions of opposite polarity, arrangements that enable the study of reactions of multiply charged ions of opposite polarity and, most recently, arrangements that allow for ion formation from more than two ion sources. Gas-phase ion/ion reaction studies have been performed at near atmospheric pressure in flow reactor designs and within electrodynamic ion traps operated in the mTorr range. With ion trap as a reaction vessel, ionization and reaction processes can be independently optimized and ion/ion reactions can be implemented within the context of MSn experiments. Spatial separation of the reaction vessel from the mass analyzer allows for the use of any form of mass analysis in conjunction with ion/ion reactions. Time-of-flight mass analysis, for example, has provided significant improvements in mass analysis figures of merit relative to mass filters and ion traps.

Protein identification via ion-trap collision-induced dissociation and examination of low-mass product ions

A whole-protein tandem mass spectrometry approach for protein identification based on precursor ion charge state concentration via ion/ion reactions, ion-trap collisional activation, ion/ion proton-transfer reactions involving the product ions, and mass analysis over a narrow m/z range (up to m/z 2000) is described and evaluated. The experiments were carried out with a commercially available electrospray ion-trap instrument that has been modified to allow for ion/ion reactions. Reaction conditions and the approach to searching protein databases were developed with the assumption that the resolving power of the mass analyzer is insufficient to distinguish charge states on the basis of the isotope spacings. Ions derived from several charge states of cytochrome c, myoglobin, ribonuclease A, and ubiquitin were used to evaluate the approach for protein identification and to develop a two-step procedure to database searching to optimize specificity. The approach developed with the model proteins was then applied to whole cell lysate fractions of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The results are illustrated with examples of assignments made for three a priori unknown proteins, each selected randomly from a lysate fraction. Two of the three proteins were assigned to species present in the database, whereas one did not match well any database entry. The combination of the mass measurement and the product ion masses suggested the possibility for the oxidation of two methionine residues of a protein in the database. The examples show that this limited whole-protein characterization approach can provide insights that might otherwise be lacking with approaches based on complete enzymatic digestion.

Decoding protein modifications using top-down mass spectrometry

Top-down mass spectrometry is an emerging technology which strives to preserve the post-translationally modified forms of proteins present in vivo by measuring them intact, rather than measuring peptides produced from them by proteolysis. The top-down technology is beginning to capture the interest of biologists and mass spectrometrists alike, with a main goal of deciphering interaction networks operative in cellular pathways. Here we outline recent approaches and applications of top-down mass spectrometry as well as an outlook for its future.

Performance Characteristics of Electron Transfer Dissociation Mass Spectrometry

We performed a large scale study of electron transfer dissociation (ETD) performance, as compared with ion trap collision-activated dissociation (CAD), for peptides ranging from approximately 1000 to 5000 Da (n approximately 4000). These data indicate relatively little overlap in peptide identifications between the two methods ( approximately 12%). ETD outperformed CAD for all charge states greater than 2; however, regardless of precursor charge a linear decrease in percent fragmentation, as a function of increasing precursor m/z, was observed with ETD fragmentation. We postulate that several precursor cation attributes, including peptide length, charge distribution, and total mass, could be relevant players. To examine these parameters unique ETD-identified peptides were sorted by length, and the ratio of amino acid residues per precursor charge (residues/charge) was calculated. We observed excellent correlation between the ratio of residues/charge and percent fragmentation. For peptides of a given residue/charge ratio, there is no correlation between peptide mass and percent fragmentation; instead we conclude that the ratio of residues/charge is the main factor in determining a successful ETD outcome. As charge density decreases so does the probability of non-covalent interactions that can bind a newly formed c/z-type ion pair. Recently we have described a supplemental activation approach (ETcaD) to convert these non-dissociative electron transfer product ions to useful c- and z-type ions. Automated implementation of such methods should remove this apparent precursor m/z ceiling. Finally, we evaluated the role of ion density (both anionic and cationic) and reaction duration for an ETD experiment. These data indicate that the best performance is achieved when the ion trap is filled to its space charge limit with anionic reagents. In this largest scale study of ETD to date, ETD continues to show great promise to propel the field of proteomics and, for small- to medium-sized peptides, is highly complementary to ion trap CAD.

ProSight PTM 2.0: improved protein identification and characterization for top down mass spectrometry

ProSight PTM 2.0 (http://prosightptm2.scs.uiuc.edu) is the next generation of the ProSight PTM web-based system for the identification and characterization of proteins using top down tandem mass spectrometry. It introduces an entirely new data-driven interface, integrated Sequence Gazer for protein characterization, support for fixed modifications, terminal modifications and improved support for multiple precursor ions (multiplexing). Furthermore, it supports data import and export for local analysis and collaboration.