Structural insights into the mechanism and E2 specificity of the RBR E3 ubiquitin ligase HHARI

RNF43 Inactivation Enhances the B-RAF/MEK Signaling and Creates a Combinatory Therapeutic Target in Cancer Cells

RING finger 43 (RNF43), a RING-type E3 ubiquitin ligase, is a key regulator of WNT signaling and is mutated in 6-10% of pancreatic tumors. However, RNF43-mediated effects remain unclear, as only a few in vivo substrates of RNF43 are identified. Here, it is found that RNF43-mutated pancreatic cancer cells exhibit elevated B-RAF/MEK activity and are highly sensitive to MEK inhibitors. The depletion of RNF43 in normal pancreatic ductal cells also enhances MEK activation, suggesting that it is a physiologically regulated process. It is confirmed that RNF43 ubiquitinates B-RAF at K499 to promote proteasome-dependent degradation, resulting in reduced MEK activity and proliferative ability in cancer cells. In addition, phosphorylation of B-RAF at T491 suppresses B-RAF ubiquitination by decreasing the interaction between RNF43 and B-RAF. Mutations at K499 in B-RAF are identified in various cancer types. MEK and WNT inhibitors synergistically suppress the growth of RNF43-mutated pancreatic cancer cells in vitro and in vivo. Collectively, the research reveals a novel mechanism by which RNF43 inhibits B-RAF/MEK signaling to suppress tumor growth and provide a new strategy for the treatment of RNF43-inactivated pancreatic cancer.

Parkin-mediated ubiquitination inhibits BAK apoptotic activity by blocking its canonical hydrophobic groove

BAK permeabilizes the mitochondrial outer membrane, causing apoptosis. This apoptotic activity of BAK is stimulated by binding prodeath activators within its canonical hydrophobic groove. Parkin, an E3 ubiquitin (Ub) ligase, can ubiquitinate BAK, which inhibits BAK apoptotic activity. However, the molecular mechanism underlying the inhibition of ubiquitination remains structurally uncharacterized. Here, we utilize truncated and soluble BAK to construct a mimetic of K113-ubiquitinated BAK (disulfide-linked UbG76C ~ BAKK113C) and further present its NMR-derived structure model. The classical L8-I44-H68-V70 hydrophobic patch of the conjugated Ub subunit binds within the canonical hydrophobic groove of BAK. This Ub occludes the binding of prodeath BID activators in the groove and impairs BID-triggered BAK activation and membrane permeabilization. Reduced interaction between Ub and BAK subunits allows BID to activate K113-ubiquitinated BAK. These mechanistic insights suggest a nonsignaling function of Ub in that it directly antagonizes stimuli targeting Ub-modified proteins rather than by recruiting downstream partners for cellular messaging.

Catalysis of non-canonical protein ubiquitylation by the ARIH1 ubiquitin ligase

Protein ubiquitylation typically involves isopeptide bond formation between the C-terminus of ubiquitin to the side-chain amino group on Lys residues. However, several ubiquitin ligases (E3s) have recently been identified that ubiquitylate proteins on non-Lys residues. For instance, HOIL-1 belongs to the RING-in-between RING (RBR) class of E3s and has an established role in Ser ubiquitylation. Given the homology between HOIL-1 and ARIH1, an RBR E3 that functions with the large superfamily of cullin-RING E3 ligases (CRLs), a biochemical investigation was undertaken, showing ARIH1 catalyzes Ser ubiquitylation to CRL-bound substrates. However, the efficiency of ubiquitylation was exquisitely dependent on the location and chemical environment of the Ser residue within the primary structure of the substrate. Comprehensive mutagenesis of the ARIH1 Rcat domain identified residues whose mutation severely impacted both oxyester and isopeptide bond formation at the preferred site for Ser ubiquitylation while only modestly affecting Lys ubiquitylation at the physiological site. The results reveal dual isopeptide and oxyester protein ubiquitylation activities of ARIH1 and set the stage for physiological investigations into this function of emerging importance.

Cryo-EM structures of Uba7 reveal the molecular basis for ISG15 activation and E1-E2 thioester transfer

ISG15 plays a crucial role in the innate immune response and has been well-studied due to its antiviral activity and regulation of signal transduction, apoptosis, and autophagy. ISG15 is a ubiquitin-like protein that is activated by an E1 enzyme (Uba7) and transferred to a cognate E2 enzyme (UBE2L6) to form a UBE2L6-ISG15 intermediate that functions with E3 ligases that catalyze conjugation of ISG15 to target proteins. Despite its biological importance, the molecular basis by which Uba7 catalyzes ISG15 activation and transfer to UBE2L6 is unknown as there is no available structure of Uba7. Here, we present cryo-EM structures of human Uba7 in complex with UBE2L6, ISG15 adenylate, and ISG15 thioester intermediate that are poised for catalysis of Uba7-UBE2L6-ISG15 thioester transfer. Our structures reveal a unique overall architecture of the complex compared to structures from the ubiquitin conjugation pathway, particularly with respect to the location of ISG15 thioester intermediate. Our structures also illuminate the molecular basis for Uba7 activities and for its exquisite specificity for ISG15 and UBE2L6. Altogether, our structural, biochemical, and human cell-based data provide significant insights into the functions of Uba7, UBE2L6, and ISG15 in cells.

Parkin and mitochondrial signalling

Aging, toxic chemicals and changes to the cellular environment are sources of oxidative damage to mitochondria which contribute to neurodegenerative conditions including Parkinson's disease. To counteract this, cells have developed signalling mechanisms to identify and remove select proteins and unhealthy mitochondria to maintain homeostasis. Two important proteins that work in concert to control mitochondrial damage are the protein kinase PINK1 and the E3 ligase parkin. In response to oxidative stress, PINK1 phosphorylates ubiquitin present on proteins at the mitochondrial surface. This signals the translocation of parkin, accelerates further phosphorylation, and stimulates ubiquitination of outer mitochondrial membrane proteins such as Miro1/2 and Mfn1/2. The ubiquitination of these proteins is the key step needed to target them for degradation via the 26S proteasomal machinery or eliminate the entire organelle through mitophagy. This review highlights the signalling mechanisms used by PINK1 and parkin and presents several outstanding questions yet to be resolved.

The unifying catalytic mechanism of the RING-between-RING E3 ubiquitin ligase family

The RING-between-RING (RBR) E3 ubiquitin ligase family in humans comprises 14 members and is defined by a two-step catalytic mechanism in which ubiquitin is first transferred from an E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme to the RBR active site and then to the substrate. To define the core features of this catalytic mechanism, we here structurally and biochemically characterise the two RBRs HOIL-1 and RNF216. Crystal structures of both enzymes in their RBR/E2-Ub/Ub transthiolation complexes capturing the first catalytic step, together with complementary functional experiments, reveal the defining features of the RBR catalytic mechanism. RBRs catalyse ubiquitination via a conserved transthiolation complex structure that enables efficient E2-to-RBR ubiquitin transfer. Our data also highlight a conserved RBR allosteric activation mechanism by distinct ubiquitin linkages that suggests RBRs employ a feed-forward mechanism. We finally identify that the HOIL-1 RING2 domain contains an unusual Zn2/Cys6 binuclear cluster that is required for catalytic activity and substrate ubiquitination.

Characterisation of HOIP RBR E3 ligase conformational dynamics using integrative modelling

Multidomain proteins composed of individual domains connected by flexible linkers pose a challenge for structural studies due to their intrinsic conformational dynamics. Integrated modelling approaches provide a means to characterise protein flexibility by combining experimental measurements with molecular simulations. In this study, we characterise the conformational dynamics of the catalytic RBR domain of the E3 ubiquitin ligase HOIP, which regulates immune and inflammatory signalling pathways. Specifically, we combine small angle X-ray scattering experiments and molecular dynamics simulations to generate weighted conformational ensembles of the HOIP RBR domain using two different approaches based on maximum parsimony and maximum entropy principles. Both methods provide optimised ensembles that are instrumental in rationalising observed differences between SAXS-based solution studies and available crystal structures and highlight the importance of interdomain linker flexibility.

Cullin-independent recognition of HHARI substrates by a dynamic RBR catalytic domain

RING-between-RING (RBR) E3 ligases mediate ubiquitin transfer through an obligate E3-ubiquitin thioester intermediate prior to substrate ubiquitination. Although RBRs share a conserved catalytic module, substrate recruitment mechanisms remain enigmatic, and the relevant domains have yet to be identified for any member of the class. Here we characterize the interaction between the auto-inhibited RBR, HHARI (AriH1), and its target protein, 4EHP, using a combination of XL-MS, HDX-MS, NMR, and biochemical studies. The results show that (1) a di-aromatic surface on the catalytic HHARI Rcat domain forms a binding platform for substrates and (2) a phosphomimetic mutation on the auto-inhibitory Ariadne domain of HHARI promotes release and reorientation of Rcat for transthiolation and substrate modification. The findings identify a direct binding interaction between a RING-between-RING ligase and its substrate and suggest a general model for RBR substrate recognition.

A robust CD8+ T cell-related classifier for predicting the prognosis and efficacy of immunotherapy in stage III lung adenocarcinoma

Patients with stage III lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD) have significant survival heterogeneity, meanwhile, CD8⁺ T cell has a remarkable function in immunotherapy. Therefore, developing novel biomarkers based on CD8⁺ T cell can help evaluate the prognosis and guide the strategy of immunotherapy for patients with stage III LUAD. Thus, we abstracted twelve datasets from multiple online databases and grouped the stage III LUAD patients into training and validation sets. We then used WGCNA and CIBERSORT, while univariate Cox analysis, LASSO analysis, and multivariate Cox analysis were performed. Subsequently, a novel CD8⁺ T cell-related classifier including HDFRP3, ARIH1, SMAD2, and UPB1 was developed, which could divide stage III LUAD patients into high- and low-risk groups with distinct survival probability in multiple cohorts (all P < 0.05). Moreover, a robust nomogram including the traditional clinical parameters and risk signature was constructed, and t-ROC, C-index, and calibration curves confirmed its powerful predictive capacity. Besides, we detected the difference in immune cell subpopulations and evaluated the potential benefits of immunotherapy between the two risk subsets. Finally, we verified the correlation between the gene expression and CD8⁺ T cells included in the model by immunohistochemistry and validated the validity of the model in a real-world cohort. Overall, we constructed a robust CD8⁺ T cell-related risk model originally which could predict the survival rates in stage III LUAD. What’s more, this model suggested that patients in the high-risk group could benefit from immunotherapy, which has significant implications for accurately predicting the effect of immunotherapy and evaluating the prognosis for patients with stage III LUAD.

Crystal structures reveal catalytic and regulatory mechanisms of the dual-specificity ubiquitin/FAT10 E1 enzyme Uba6

The E1 enzyme Uba6 initiates signal transduction by activating ubiquitin and the ubiquitin-like protein FAT10 in a two-step process involving sequential catalysis of adenylation and thioester bond formation. To gain mechanistic insights into these processes, we determined the crystal structure of a human Uba6/ubiquitin complex. Two distinct architectures of the complex are observed: one in which Uba6 adopts an open conformation with the active site configured for catalysis of adenylation, and a second drastically different closed conformation in which the adenylation active site is disassembled and reconfigured for catalysis of thioester bond formation. Surprisingly, an inositol hexakisphosphate (InsP6) molecule binds to a previously unidentified allosteric site on Uba6. Our structural, biochemical, and biophysical data indicate that InsP6 allosterically inhibits Uba6 activity by altering interconversion of the open and closed conformations of Uba6 while also enhancing its stability. In addition to revealing the molecular mechanisms of catalysis by Uba6 and allosteric regulation of its activities, our structures provide a framework for developing Uba6-specific inhibitors and raise the possibility of allosteric regulation of other E1s by naturally occurring cellular metabolites.

Mechanism and Disease Association With a Ubiquitin Conjugating E2 Enzyme: UBE2L3

Ubiquitin conjugating enzyme E2 is an important component of the post-translational protein ubiquitination pathway, which mediates the transfer of activated ubiquitin to substrate proteins. UBE2L3, also called UBcH7, is one of many E2 ubiquitin conjugating enzymes that participate in the ubiquitination of many substrate proteins and regulate many signaling pathways, such as the NF-κB, GSK3β/p65, and DSB repair pathways. Studies on UBE2L3 have found that it has an abnormal expression in many diseases, mainly immune diseases, tumors and Parkinson’s disease. It can also promote the occurrence and development of these diseases. Resultantly, UBE2L3 may become an important target for some diseases. Herein, we review the structure of UBE2L3, and its mechanism in diseases, as well as diseases related to UBE2L3 and discuss the related challenges.

PROTAC targeted protein degraders: the past is prologue

Targeted protein degradation (TPD) is an emerging therapeutic modality with the potential to tackle disease-causing proteins that have historically been highly challenging to target with conventional small molecules. In the 20 years since the concept of a proteolysis-targeting chimera (PROTAC) molecule harnessing the ubiquitin-proteasome system to degrade a target protein was reported, TPD has moved from academia to industry, where numerous companies have disclosed programmes in preclinical and early clinical development. With clinical proof-of-concept for PROTAC molecules against two well-established cancer targets provided in 2020, the field is poised to pursue targets that were previously considered 'undruggable'. In this Review, we summarize the first two decades of PROTAC discovery and assess the current landscape, with a focus on industry activity. We then discuss key areas for the future of TPD, including establishing the target classes for which TPD is most suitable, expanding the use of ubiquitin ligases to enable precision medicine and extending the modality beyond oncology.

Targeting SARS-CoV-2 Proteases for COVID-19 Antiviral Development

The emergence of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS-CoV-2) in 2019 marked the third occurrence of a highly pathogenic coronavirus in the human population since 2003. As the death toll surpasses 5 million globally and economic losses continue, designing drugs that could curtail infection and disease progression is critical. In the US, three highly effective Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-authorized vaccines are currently available, and Remdesivir is approved for the treatment of hospitalized patients. However, moderate vaccination rates and the sustained evolution of new viral variants necessitate the ongoing search for new antivirals. Several viral proteins have been prioritized as SARS-CoV-2 antiviral drug targets, among them the papain-like protease (PLpro) and the main protease (Mpro). Inhibition of these proteases would target viral replication, viral maturation, and suppression of host innate immune responses. Knowledge of inhibitors and assays for viruses were quickly adopted for SARS-CoV-2 protease research. Potential candidates have been identified to show inhibitory effects against PLpro and Mpro, both in biochemical assays and viral replication in cells. These results encourage further optimizations to improve prophylactic and therapeutic efficacy. In this review, we examine the latest developments of potential small-molecule inhibitors and peptide inhibitors for PLpro and Mpro, and how structural biology greatly facilitates this process.

The von Hippel-Lindau Cullin-RING E3 ubiquitin ligase regulates APOBEC3 cytidine deaminases

The 7 members of the A3 family of cytidine deaminases (A3A to A3H) share a conserved catalytic activity that converts cytidines in single-stranded (ss) DNA into uridines, thereby inducing mutations. After their initial identification as cell-intrinsic defenses against HIV and other retroviruses, A3s were also found to impair many additional viruses. Moreover, some of the A3 proteins (A3A, A3B, and A3H haplotype I) are dysregulated in cancer cells, thereby causing chromosomal mutations that can be selected to fuel progression of malignancy. Viral mechanisms that increase transcription of A3 genes or induce proteasomal degradation of A3 proteins have been characterized. However, only a few underlying biological mechanisms regulating levels of A3s in uninfected cells have been described. Here, we characterize that the von Hippel-Lindau tumor suppressor (pVHL), via its CRL^pVHL, induces degradation of all 7 A3 proteins. Two independent lines of evidence supported the conclusion that the multiprotein CRL^pVHL complex is necessary for A3 degradation. CRL^pVHL more effectively induced degradation of nuclear, procancer A3 (A3B) than the cytoplasmic, antiretroviral A3 (A3G). These results identify specific cellular factors that regulate A3s post-translationally.

Chain reactions: molecular mechanisms of RBR ubiquitin ligases

Ubiquitination is a fundamental post-translational modification that regulates almost all aspects of cellular signalling and is ultimately catalysed by the action of E3 ubiquitin ligases. The RING-between-RING (RBR) family of E3 ligases encompasses 14 distinct human enzymes that are defined by a unique domain organisation and catalytic mechanism. Detailed characterisation of several RBR ligase family members in the last decade has revealed common structural and mechanistic features. At the same time these studies have highlighted critical differences with respect to autoinhibition, activation and catalysis. Importantly, the majority of RBR E3 ligases remain poorly studied, and thus the extent of diversity within the family remains unknown. In this mini-review we outline the current understanding of the RBR E3 mechanism, structure and regulation with a particular focus on recent findings and developments that will shape the field in coming years.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis protein kinase G acts as an unusual ubiquitinating enzyme to impair host immunity

Upon Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) infection, protein kinase G (PknG), a eukaryotic-type serine-threonine protein kinase (STPK), is secreted into host macrophages to promote intracellular survival of the pathogen. However, the mechanisms underlying this PknG-host interaction remain unclear. Here, we demonstrate that PknG serves both as a ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1) and a ubiquitin ligase (E3) to trigger the ubiquitination and degradation of tumor necrosis factor receptor-associated factor 2 (TRAF2) and TGF-β-activated kinase 1 (TAK1), thereby inhibiting the activation of NF-κB signaling and host innate responses. PknG promotes the attachment of ubiquitin (Ub) to the ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (E2) UbcH7 via an isopeptide bond (UbcH7 K82-Ub), rather than the usual C86-Ub thiol-ester bond. PknG induces the discharge of Ub from UbcH7 by acting as an isopeptidase, before attaching Ub to its substrates. These results demonstrate that PknG acts as an unusual ubiquitinating enzyme to remove key components of the innate immunity system, thus providing a potential target for tuberculosis treatment.

Crystal structures of an E1-E2-ubiquitin thioester mimetic reveal molecular mechanisms of transthioesterification

E1 enzymes function as gatekeepers of ubiquitin (Ub) signaling by catalyzing activation and transfer of Ub to tens of cognate E2 conjugating enzymes in a process called E1-E2 transthioesterification. The molecular mechanisms of transthioesterification and the overall architecture of the E1-E2-Ub complex during catalysis are unknown. Here, we determine the structure of a covalently trapped E1-E2-ubiquitin thioester mimetic. Two distinct architectures of the complex are observed, one in which the Ub thioester (Ub(t)) contacts E1 in an open conformation and another in which Ub(t) instead contacts E2 in a drastically different, closed conformation. Altogether our structural and biochemical data suggest that these two conformational states represent snapshots of the E1-E2-Ub complex pre- and post-thioester transfer, and are consistent with a model in which catalysis is enhanced by a Ub(t)-mediated affinity switch that drives the reaction forward by promoting productive complex formation or product release depending on the conformational state.

Tools for the discovery of biopolymer producing cysteine relays

Cysteine relays, where a protein or small molecule is transferred multiple times via transthiolation, are central to the production of biological polymers. Enzymes that utilise relay mechanisms display broad substrate specificity and are readily engineered to produce new polymers. In this review, I discuss recent advances in the discovery, engineering and biophysical characterisation of cysteine relays. I will focus on eukaryotic ubiquitin (Ub) cascades and prokaryotic polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA) synthesis. These evolutionarily distinct processes employ similar chemistry and are readily modified for biotechnological applications. Both processes have been studied intensively for decades, yet recent studies suggest we do not fully understand their mechanistic diversity or plasticity. I will discuss the important role that activity-based probes (ABPs) and other chemical tools have had in identifying and delineating Ub cysteine-relays and the potential for ABPs to be applied to PHA synthases. Finally, I will offer a personal perspective on the potential of engineering cysteine-relays for non-native polymer production.

Ubiquitin ligation to F-box protein targets by SCF-RBR E3-E3 super-assembly

E3 ligases are typically classified by hallmark domains such as RING and RBR, which are thought to specify unique catalytic mechanisms of ubiquitin transfer to recruited substrates1,2. However, rather than functioning individually, many neddylated cullin-RING E3 ligases (CRLs) and RBR-type E3 ligases in the ARIH family-which together account for nearly half of all ubiquitin ligases in humans-form E3-E3 super-assemblies3-7. Here, by studying CRLs in the SKP1-CUL1-F-box (SCF) family, we show how neddylated SCF ligases and ARIH1 (an RBR-type E3 ligase) co-evolved to ubiquitylate diverse substrates presented on various F-box proteins. We developed activity-based chemical probes that enabled cryo-electron microscopy visualization of steps in E3-E3 ubiquitylation, initiating with ubiquitin linked to the E2 enzyme UBE2L3, then transferred to the catalytic cysteine of ARIH1, and culminating in ubiquitin linkage to a substrate bound to the SCF E3 ligase. The E3-E3 mechanism places the ubiquitin-linked active site of ARIH1 adjacent to substrates bound to F-box proteins (for example, substrates with folded structures or limited length) that are incompatible with previously described conventional RING E3-only mechanisms. The versatile E3-E3 super-assembly may therefore underlie widespread ubiquitylation.

CUL5-ARIH2 E3-E3 ubiquitin ligase structure reveals cullin-specific NEDD8 activation

An emerging mechanism of ubiquitylation involves partnering of two distinct E3 ligases. In the best-characterized E3-E3 pathways, ARIH-family RING-between-RING (RBR) E3s ligate ubiquitin to substrates of neddylated cullin-RING E3s. The E3 ARIH2 has been implicated in ubiquitylation of substrates of neddylated CUL5-RBX2-based E3s, including APOBEC3-family substrates of the host E3 hijacked by HIV-1 virion infectivity factor (Vif). However, the structural mechanisms remained elusive. Here structural and biochemical analyses reveal distinctive ARIH2 autoinhibition, and activation on assembly with neddylated CUL5-RBX2. Comparison to structures of E3-E3 assemblies comprising ARIH1 and neddylated CUL1-RBX1-based E3s shows cullin-specific regulation by NEDD8. Whereas CUL1-linked NEDD8 directly recruits ARIH1, CUL5-linked NEDD8 does not bind ARIH2. Instead, the data reveal an allosteric mechanism. NEDD8 uniquely contacts covalently linked CUL5, and elicits structural rearrangements that unveil cryptic ARIH2-binding sites. The data reveal how a ubiquitin-like protein induces protein-protein interactions indirectly, through allostery. Allosteric specificity of ubiquitin-like protein modifications may offer opportunities for therapeutic targeting.

Structural basis for RING-Cys-Relay E3 ligase activity and its role in axon integrity

MYCBP2 is a ubiquitin (Ub) E3 ligase (E3) that is essential for neurodevelopment and regulates axon maintenance. MYCBP2 transfers Ub to non-lysine substrates via a newly discovered RING-Cys-Relay (RCR) mechanism where Ub is relayed from an upstream cysteine to a downstream substrate esterification site. The molecular bases for E2-E3 Ub transfer and Ub relay are unknown. Whether these activities are linked to the neural phenotypes is also unclear. We describe the crystal structure of a covalently trapped E2-Ub:MYCBP2 transfer intermediate revealing key structural rearrangements upon E2-E3 Ub transfer and Ub relay. Our data suggest that transfer to the dynamic upstream cysteine, whilst mitigating lysine activity, requires a closed-like E2-Ub conjugate with tempered reactivity, and Ub relay is facilitated by a helix-coil transition. Furthermore, neurodevelopmental defects and delayed injury-induced degeneration in RCR-defective knock-in mice suggest its requirement, and that of substrate esterification activity, for normal neural development and programmed axon degeneration.

Solution structure of the zinc finger domain of human RNF144A ubiquitin ligase

RNF144A is involved in protein ubiquitination and functions as an ubiquitin-protein ligase (E3) via its RING finger domain (RNF144A RING). RNF144A is associated with degradation of heat-shock protein family A member 2 (HSPA2), which leads to the suppression of breast cancer cell proliferation. In this study, the solution structure of RNF144A RING was determined using nuclear magnetic resonance. Moreover, using a metallochromic indicator, we spectrophotometrically determined the stoichiometry of zinc ions and elucidated that RNF144A RING binds two zinc atoms. This structural analysis provided the position and range of the active site of RNF144A RING at the atomic level, which contributes to the creation of artificial RING fingers having the specific ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (E2)-binding capability.

Modes of allosteric regulation of the ubiquitination machinery

Ubiquitination is a post-translational modification crucial for cellular signaling. A diverse range of enzymes constitute the machinery that mediates attachment of ubiquitin onto target proteins. This diversity allows the targeting of various proteins in a highly regulated fashion. Many of the enzymes have multiple domains or subunits that bind allosteric effectors and exhibit large conformational rearrangements to facilitate regulation. Here we consider recent examples of ubiquitin itself as an allosteric effector of RING and RBR E3 ligases, as well as advances in the understanding of allosteric regulatory elements within HECT E3 ligases.

1H, 13C, 15N backbone and side-chain resonance assignment of the native form of UbcH7 (UBE2L3) through solution NMR spectroscopy

Ubiquitination is a post-translational modification that regulates a plethora of processes in cells. Ubiquitination requires three type of enzyme: E1 ubiquitin (Ub) activating enzymes, E2 Ub conjugating enzymes and E3 ubiquitin ligases. The E2 enzymes perform a variety of functions, as Ub chain initiation, elongation and regulation of the topology and the process of chain formation. The E2 enzymes family is mainly characterized by a highly conserved ubiquitin conjugating domain (UBC), which comprises the binding region for the activated Ub, E1 and E3 enzymes. The E2 enzyme UbcH7 (UBE2L3) is a known interacting partner for different types of E3 Ub ligases such as HECT, RING and RBR. A structural analysis of the apo form of the native UbcH7 will provide the structural information to understand how this E2 enzyme is implicated in a wide range of diseases and how it interacts with its partners. In the present study we present the high yield expression of the native UbcH7 E2 enzyme and its preliminary analysis via solution NMR spectroscopy. The E2 enzyme is folded in solution and nearly a complete backbone assignment was achieved. Additionally, TALOS+ analysis was performed and the results indicated that UbcH7 adopts a αββββααα topology which is similar to that of the majority of E2 enzymes.

Single-Domain Antibodies as Crystallization Chaperones to Enable Structure-Based Inhibitor Development for RBR E3 Ubiquitin Ligases

Protein ubiquitination plays a key role in the regulation of cellular processes, and misregulation of the ubiquitin system is linked to many diseases. So far, development of tool compounds that target enzymes of the ubiquitin system has been slow and only a few specific inhibitors are available. Here, we report the selection of single-domain antibodies (single-dAbs) based on a human scaffold that recognize the catalytic domain of HOIP, a subunit of the multi-component E3 LUBAC and member of the RBR family of E3 ligases. Some of these dAbs affect ligase activity and provide mechanistic insight into the ubiquitin transfer mechanism of different E2-conjugating enzymes. Furthermore, we show that the co-crystal structure of a HOIP RBR/dAb complex serves as a robust platform for soaking of ligands that target the active site cysteine of HOIP, thereby providing easy access to structure-based ligand design for this important class of E3 ligases.

Structural insights into E1 recognition and the ubiquitin-conjugating activity of the E2 enzyme Cdc34

Ubiquitin (Ub) signaling requires the sequential interactions and activities of three enzymes, E1, E2, and E3. Cdc34 is an E2 that plays a key role in regulating cell cycle progression and requires unique structural elements to function. The molecular basis by which Cdc34 engages its E1 and the structural mechanisms by which its unique C-terminal extension functions in Cdc34 activity are unknown. Here, we present crystal structures of Cdc34 alone and in complex with E1, and a Cdc34~Ub thioester mimetic that represents the product of Uba1-Cdc34 Ub transthiolation. These structures reveal conformational changes in Uba1 and Cdc34 and a unique binding mode that are required for transthiolation. The Cdc34~Ub structure reveals contacts between the Cdc34 C-terminal extension and Ub that stabilize Cdc34~Ub in a closed conformation and are critical for Ub discharge. Altogether, our structural, biochemical, and cell-based studies provide insights into the molecular mechanisms by which Cdc34 function in cells.

Enzymatic Logic of Ubiquitin Chain Assembly

Protein ubiquitination impacts virtually every biochemical pathway in eukaryotic cells. The fate of a ubiquitinated protein is largely dictated by the type of ubiquitin modification with which it is decorated, including a large variety of polymeric chains. As a result, there have been intense efforts over the last two decades to dissect the molecular details underlying the synthesis of ubiquitin chains by ubiquitin-conjugating (E2) enzymes and ubiquitin ligases (E3s). In this review, we highlight these advances. We discuss the evidence in support of the alternative models of transferring one ubiquitin at a time to a growing substrate-linked chain (sequential addition model) versus transferring a pre-assembled ubiquitin chain (en bloc model) to a substrate. Against this backdrop, we outline emerging principles of chain assembly: multisite interactions, distinct mechanisms of chain initiation and elongation, optimal positioning of ubiquitin molecules that are ultimately conjugated to each other, and substrate-assisted catalysis. Understanding the enzymatic logic of ubiquitin chain assembly has important biomedical implications, as the misregulation of many E2s and E3s and associated perturbations in ubiquitin chain formation contribute to human disease. The resurgent interest in bifunctional small molecules targeting pathogenic proteins to specific E3s for polyubiquitination and subsequent degradation provides an additional incentive to define the mechanisms responsible for efficient and specific chain synthesis and harness them for therapeutic benefit.

Zinc finger domain of the human DTX protein adopts a unique RING fold

The Deltex (DTX) family is involved in ubiquitination and acts as Notch signaling modifiers for controlling cell fate determination. DTX promotes the development of the ubiquitin chain via its RING finger (DTX_RING). In this study, the solution structure of DTX_RING was determined using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). Moreover, by experiments with a metallochromic indicator, we spectrophotometrically estimated the stoichiometry of zinc ions and found that DTX_RING possesses zinc-binding capabilities. The Simple Modular Architecture Research Tool database predicted the structure of DTX_RING as a typical RING finger. However, the actual DTX_RING structure adopts a novel RING fold with a unique topology distinct from other RING fingers. We unveiled the position and the range of the DTX_RING active site at the atomic level. Artificial RING fingers (ARFs) are made by grafting active sites of the RING fingers onto cross-brace structure motifs. Therefore, the present structural analysis could be useful for designing a novel ARF.

Molecular mechanism of a covalent allosteric inhibitor of SUMO E1 activating enzyme

E1 enzymes activate ubiquitin (Ub) and ubiquitin-like modifiers (Ubls) in the first step of Ub/Ubl conjugation cascades and represent potential targets for therapeutic intervention in cancer and other life-threatening diseases. Here, we report the crystal structure of the E1 enzyme for the Ubl SUMO in complex with a recently discovered and highly specific covalent allosteric inhibitor (COH000). The structure reveals that COH000 targets a cryptic pocket distinct from the active site that is completely buried in all previous SUMO E1 structures and that COH000 binding to SUMO E1 is accompanied by a network of structural changes that altogether lock the enzyme in a previously unobserved inactive conformation. These structural changes include disassembly of the active site and a 180° rotation of the catalytic cysteine-containing SCCH domain, relative to conformational snapshots of SUMO E1 poised to catalyze adenylation. Altogether, our study provides a molecular basis for the inhibitory mechanism of COH000 and its SUMO E1 specificity, and also establishes a framework for potential development of molecules targeting E1 enzymes for other Ubls at a cryptic allosteric site.

Crystal structure of a human ubiquitin E1-ubiquitin complex reveals conserved functional elements essential for activity

Ubiquitin (Ub) signaling plays a key regulatory role in nearly every aspect of eukaryotic biology and is initiated by E1 enzymes that activate and transfer Ub to E2 Ub-conjugating enzymes. Despite Ub E1's fundamental importance to the cell and its attractiveness as a target for therapeutic intervention in cancer and other diseases, its only available structural information is derived from yeast orthologs of human ubiquitin-like modifier-activating enzyme 1 (hUBA1). To illuminate structural differences between yeast and hUBA1 structures that might be exploited for the development of small-molecule therapeutics, we determined the first crystal structure of a hUBA1-Ub complex. Using structural analysis, molecular modeling, and biochemical analysis, we demonstrate that hUBA1 shares a conserved overall structure and mechanism with previously characterized yeast orthologs, but displays subtle structural differences, particularly within the active site. Computational analysis revealed four potential ligand-binding hot spots on the surface of hUBA1 that might serve as targets to inhibit hUBA1 at the level of Ub activation or E2 recruitment or that might potentially be used in approaches such as protein-targeting chimeric molecules. Taken together, our work enhances our understanding of the hUBA1 mechanism, provides an improved framework for the development of small-molecule inhibitors of UBA1, and serves as a stepping stone for structural studies that involve the enzymes of the human Ub system at the level of both E1 and E2.

The ubiquitin ligase SspH1 from Salmonella uses a modular and dynamic E3 domain to catalyze substrate ubiquitylation

SspH/IpaH bacterial effector E3 ubiquitin (Ub) ligases, unrelated in sequence or structure to eukaryotic E3s, are utilized by a wide variety of Gram-negative bacteria during pathogenesis. These E3s function in a eukaryotic environment, utilize host cell E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes of the Ube2D family, and target host proteins for ubiquitylation. Despite several crystal structures, details of Ube2D∼Ub binding and the mechanism of ubiquitin transfer are poorly understood. Here, we show that the catalytic E3 ligase domain of SspH1 can be divided into two subdomains: an N-terminal subdomain that harbors the active-site cysteine and a C-terminal subdomain containing the Ube2D∼Ub-binding site. SspH1 mutations designed to restrict subdomain motions show rapid formation of an E3∼Ub intermediate, but impaired Ub transfer to substrate. NMR experiments using paramagnetic spin labels reveal how SspH1 binds Ube2D∼Ub and targets the E2∼Ub active site. Unexpectedly, hydrogen/deuterium exchange MS shows that the E2∼Ub-binding region is dynamic but stabilized in the E3∼Ub intermediate. Our results support a model in which both subunits of an Ube2D∼Ub clamp onto a dynamic region of SspH1, promoting an E3 conformation poised for transthiolation. A conformational change is then required for Ub transfer from E3∼Ub to substrate.

Synergistic recruitment of UbcH7~Ub and phosphorylated Ubl domain triggers parkin activation

The E3 ligase parkin ubiquitinates outer mitochondrial membrane proteins during oxidative stress and is linked to early‐onset Parkinson's disease. Parkin is autoinhibited but is activated by the kinase PINK1 that phosphorylates ubiquitin leading to parkin recruitment, and stimulates phosphorylation of parkin's N‐terminal ubiquitin‐like (pUbl) domain. How these events alter the structure of parkin to allow recruitment of an E2~Ub conjugate and enhanced ubiquitination is an unresolved question. We present a model of an E2~Ub conjugate bound to the phospho‐ubiquitin‐loaded C‐terminus of parkin, derived from NMR chemical shift perturbation experiments. We show the UbcH7~Ub conjugate binds in the open state whereby conjugated ubiquitin binds to the RING1/IBR interface. Further, NMR and mass spectrometry experiments indicate the RING0/RING2 interface is re‐modelled, remote from the E2 binding site, and this alters the reactivity of the RING2(Rcat) catalytic cysteine, needed for ubiquitin transfer. Our experiments provide evidence that parkin phosphorylation and E2~Ub recruitment act synergistically to enhance a weak interaction of the pUbl domain with the RING0 domain and rearrange the location of the RING2(Rcat) domain to drive parkin activity.

Mechanism of parkin activation by phosphorylation

Mutations in the ubiquitin ligase parkin are responsible for a familial form of Parkinson's disease. Parkin and the PINK1 kinase regulate a quality-control system for mitochondria. PINK1 phosphorylates ubiquitin on the outer membrane of damaged mitochondria, thus leading to recruitment and activation of parkin via phosphorylation of its ubiquitin-like (Ubl) domain. Here, we describe the mechanism of parkin activation by phosphorylation. The crystal structure of phosphorylated Bactrocera dorsalis (oriental fruit fly) parkin in complex with phosphorylated ubiquitin and an E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme reveals that the key activating step is movement of the Ubl domain and release of the catalytic RING2 domain. Hydrogen/deuterium exchange and NMR experiments with the various intermediates in the activation pathway confirm and extend the interpretation of the crystal structure to mammalian parkin. Our results rationalize previously unexplained Parkinson's disease mutations and the presence of internal linkers that allow large domain movements in parkin.

RBR ligase-mediated ubiquitin transfer: a tale with many twists and turns

RBR ligases are an enigmatic class of E3 ubiquitin ligases that combine properties of RING and HECT-type E3s and undergo multilevel regulation through autoinhibition, post-translational modifications, multimerization and interaction with binding partners. Here, we summarize recent progress in RBR structures and function, which has uncovered commonalities in the mechanisms by which different family members transfer ubiquitin through a multistep process. However, these studies have also highlighted clear differences in the activity of different family members, suggesting that each RBR ligase has evolved specific properties to fit the biological process it regulates.

Determinants of E2-ubiquitin conjugate recognition by RBR E3 ligases

RING-between-RING (RBR) ubiquitin ligases work with multiple E2 enzymes and function through an E3-ubiquitin thioester intermediate. The RBR module comprises three domains, RING1, IBR and RING2 that collaborate to transfer ubiquitin from the E2~Ub conjugate, recognised by RING1, onto a catalytic cysteine in RING2 and finally onto the substrate in a multi-step reaction. Recent studies have shown that RING1 domains bind E2~Ub conjugates in an open conformation to supress ubiquitin transfer onto lysine residues and promote formation of the E3 thioester intermediate. However, how the nature of the E2 influences the ubiquitin transfer process is currently unclear. We report here a detailed characterization of the RBR/E2-conjugate recognition step that indicates that this mechanism depends on the nature of the E2 enzyme and differs between UbcH5 and UbcH7. In the case of UbcH5~Ub an interaction with ubiquitin is necessary to stabilize the transfer complex while recognition of UbcH7~Ub is driven primarily by E2-RING1 contacts. Furthermore our analysis suggests that RBRs, in isolation and in complex with ubiquitin-loaded E2s, are dynamic species and that their intrinsic flexibility might be a key aspect of their catalytic mechanism.

Strategies to Trap Enzyme-Substrate Complexes that Mimic Michaelis Intermediates During E3-Mediated Ubiquitin-Like Protein Ligation

Most cellular functions rely on pathways that catalyze posttranslational modification of cellular proteins by ubiquitin (Ub) and ubiquitin-like (Ubl) proteins. Like other posttranslational modifications that require distinct writers, readers, and erasers during signaling, Ub/Ubl pathways employ distinct enzymes that catalyze Ub/Ubl attachment, Ub/Ubl recognition, and Ub/Ubl removal. Ubl protein conjugation typically relies on parallel but distinct enzymatic cascades catalyzed by an E1-activating enzyme, an E2 carrier protein, and an E3 ubiquitin-like protein ligase. One major class of E3, with ca. 600 members, harbors RING or the RING-like SP-RING or Ubox domains. These RING/RING-like domains bind and activate the E2-Ubl thioester by stabilizing a conformation that is optimal for nucleophilic attack by the side chain residue (typically lysine) on the substrate. These RING/RING-like domains typically function together with other domains or protein complexes that often serve to recruit particular substrates. How these RING/RING-like E3 domains function to activate the E2-Ubl thioester while engaged with substrate remains poorly understood. We describe a strategy to generate and purify a unique E2_Ubc9-Ubl_SUMO thioester mimetic that can be cross-linked to the Substrate_PCNA at Lys164, a conjugation site that is only observed in the presence of E3_Siz1. We describe two techniques to cross-link the E2_Ubc9-Ubl_SUMO thioester mimetic active site to the site of modification on PCNA and the subsequent purification of these complexes. Finally, we describe the reconstitution and purification of the E2_Ubc9-Ubl_SUMO-PCNA complex with the E3_Siz1 and purification that enabled its crystallization and structure determination. We think this technique can be extended to other E2-Ubl-substrate/E3 complexes to better probe the function and specificity of RING-based E3 Ubl ligases.

Characterization of RING-Between-RING E3 Ubiquitin Transfer Mechanisms

Protein ubiquitination is an essential posttranslational modification that regulates nearly all cellular processes. E3 ligases catalyze the final transfer of ubiquitin (Ub) onto substrates and thus are important temporal regulators of ubiquitin modifications in the cell. E3s are classified by their distinct transfer mechanisms. RING E3s act as scaffolds to facilitate the transfer of Ub from E2-conjugating enzymes directly onto substrates, while HECT E3s form an E3~Ub thioester intermediate prior to Ub transfer. A third class, RING-Between-RING (RBR) E3s, are classified as RING/HECT hybrids based on their ability to engage the E2~Ub conjugate via a RING1 domain while subsequently forming an obligate E3~Ub intermediate prior to substrate modification. RBRs comprise the smallest class of E3s, consisting of only 14 family members in humans, yet their dysfunction has been associated with neurodegenerative diseases, susceptibility to infection, inflammation, and cancer. Additionally, their activity is suppressed by auto-inhibitory domains that block their catalytic activity, suggesting their regulation has important cellular consequences. Here, we identify technical hurdles faced in studying RBR E3s and provide protocols and guidelines to overcome these challenges.