Resistance of cytotoxic T lymphocytes to lysis by a clone of cytotoxic T lymphocytes

To Kill But Not Be Killed: Controlling the Activity of Mammalian Pore-Forming Proteins

Pore-forming proteins (PFPs) are present in all domains of life, and play an important role in host-pathogen warfare and in the elimination of cancers. They can be employed to deliver specific effectors across membranes, to disrupt membrane integrity interfering with cell homeostasis, and to lyse membranes either destroying intracellular organelles or entire cells. Considering the destructive potential of PFPs, it is perhaps not surprising that mechanisms controlling their activity are remarkably complex, especially in multicellular organisms. Mammalian PFPs discovered to date include the complement membrane attack complex (MAC), perforins, as well as gasdermins. While the primary function of perforin-1 and gasdermins is to eliminate infected or cancerous host cells, perforin-2 and MAC can target pathogens directly. Yet, all mammalian PFPs are in principle capable of generating pores in membranes of healthy host cells which-if uncontrolled-could have dire, and potentially lethal consequences. In this review, we will highlight the strategies employed to protect the host from destruction by endogenous PFPs, while enabling timely and efficient elimination of target cells.

Cysteine cathepsins: regulators of antitumour immune response

Cysteine cathepsins are lysosomal cysteine proteases that are involved in a number of important biological processes, including intracellular protein turnover, propeptide and hormone processing, apoptosis, bone remodelling and reproduction. In cancer, the cathepsins have been linked to extracellular matrix remodelling and to the promotion of tumour cell motility, invasion, angiogenesis and metastasis, resulting in poor outcome of cancer patients; however, cysteine cathepsins are also involved at different levels of the innate and adaptive immune responses. Their best known role in this aspect is their contribution to major histocompatibility complex class II antigen presentation, the processing of progranzymes into proteolytically active forms, cytotoxic lymphocyte self-protection, cytokine and growth factor degradation and, finally, the induction of cytokine expression and modulation of integrin function. This review is focused on the role of cysteine cathepsins in the antitumour immune response and the evaluation of their pro- and anticancer behaviours during the regulation of these processes.

Estrogen induction of the granzyme B inhibitor, proteinase inhibitor 9, protects cells against apoptosis mediated by cytotoxic T lymphocytes and natural killer cells

Exposure to estrogens is associated with an increased risk of developing breast, cervical, and liver cancer. Estrogens strongly induce the human granzyme B inhibitor, proteinase inhibitor 9 (PI-9). Because cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and natural killer (NK) cells use the granzyme pathway to induce apoptosis of target cells, we tested the ability of activated CTLs and the human NK cell line, YT cells, to lyse human liver cells. Estrogen induction of PI-9 protected the liver cells against CTL and NK cell-mediated, granzyme-dependent, apoptosis. Knockdown of PI-9 by RNA interference blocked the protective effect of estrogen. This work demonstrates that estrogens can act on target cells to control their destruction by immune system cells and shows that induction of PI-9 expression can inhibit both CTL and NK cell-mediated apoptosis. Estrogen induction of PI-9 may reduce the ability of cytolytic lymphocytes-mediated immune surveillance to destroy newly transformed cells, possibly providing a novel mechanism for an estrogen-mediated increase in tumor incidence.

The secretory synapse: the secrets of a serial killer

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) destroy their targets by a process involving secretion of specialized granules. The interactions between CTLs and target can be very brief; nevertheless, adhesion and signaling proteins segregate into an immunological synapse. Secretion occurs in a specialized secretory domain. Use of live and fixed cell microscopy allows this secretory synapse to be visualized both temporally and spatially. The combined use of confocal and electron microscopy has produced some surprising findings, which suggest that the secretory synapse may be important both in delivering the lethal hit and in facilitating membrane transfer from target to CTL. Studies on the secretory synapse in wild-type and mutant CTLs have been used to identify proteins involved in secretion. Further clues as to the signals required for secretion are emerging from comparisons of inhibitory and activating synapses formed by natural killer cells.

Surface cathepsin B protects cytotoxic lymphocytes from self-destruction after degranulation

The granule exocytosis cytotoxicity pathway is the major molecular mechanism for cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) and natural killer (NK) cytotoxicity, but the question of how these cytotoxic lymphocytes avoid self-destruction after secreting perforin has remained unresolved. We show that CTL and NK cells die within a few hours if they are triggered to degranulate in the presence of nontoxic thiol cathepsin protease inhibitors. The potent activity of the impermeant, highly cathepsin B-specific membrane inhibitors CA074 and NS-196 strongly implicates extracellular cathepsin B. CTL suicide in the presence of cathepsin inhibitors requires the granule exocytosis cytotoxicity pathway, as it is normal with CTLs from gld mice, but does not occur in CTLs from perforin knockout mice. Flow cytometry shows that CTLs express low to undetectable levels of cathepsin B on their surface before degranulation, with a substantial rapid increase after T cell receptor triggering. Surface cathepsin B eluted from live CTL after degranulation by calcium chelation is the single chain processed form of active cathepsin B. Degranulated CTLs are surface biotinylated by the cathepsin B-specific affinity reagent NS-196, which exclusively labels immunoreactive cathepsin B. These experiments support a model in which granule-derived surface cathepsin B provides self-protection for degranulating cytotoxic lymphocytes.

Nucleocytoplasmic distribution of the ovalbumin serpin PI-9 requires a nonconventional nuclear import pathway and the export factor Crm1

Proteinase inhibitor 9 (PI-9) is a human serpin present in the cytoplasm of cytotoxic lymphocytes and epithelial cells. It inhibits the cytotoxic lymphocyte granule proteinase granzyme B (graB) and is thought to protect cytotoxic lymphocytes and bystander cells from graB-mediated apoptosis. Following uptake into cells, graB promotes DNA degradation, rapidly translocating to the nucleus, where it binds a nuclear component. PI-9 should therefore be found in cytotoxic lymphocyte and bystander cell nuclei to ensure complete protection against graB. Here we demonstrate by microscopy and subcellular fractionation experiments that PI-9 is present in the nuclei of human cytotoxic cells, endothelial cells, and epithelial cells. We also show that the related serpins, PI-6, monocyte neutrophil elastase inhibitor (MNEI), PI-8, plasminogen activator inhibitor 2 (PAI-2), and the viral serpin CrmA exhibit similar nucleocytoplasmic distributions. Because these serpins lack classical nuclear localization signals and are small enough to diffuse through nuclear pores, we investigated whether import occurs actively or passively. Large (approximately 70 kDa) chimeric proteins comprising PI-9, PI-6, PI-8, MNEI, or PAI-2 fused to green fluorescent protein (GFP) show similar nucleocytoplasmic distributions to the parent proteins, indicating that nuclear import is active. By contrast, CrmA-GFP is excluded from nuclei, indicating that CrmA is not actively imported. In vitro nuclear transport assays show that PI-9 accumulates at a rate above that of passive diffusion, that it requires cytosolic factors but not ATP, and that it does not bind an intranuclear component. Furthermore, PI-9 is exported from nuclei via a leptomycin B-sensitive pathway, implying involvement of the export factor Crm1p. We conclude that the nucleocytoplasmic distribution of PI-9 and related serpins involves a nonconventional nuclear import pathway and Crm1p.

Suicide induced by cytolytic activity controls the differentiation of memory CD8(+) T lymphocytes

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) confer protection against intracellular pathogens, yet the mechanism by which some escape activation induced cell death (AICD) and give rise to long-lived memory cells is unclear. We studied the differentiation of transgenic TCR CD8(+) cells into CTL and memory cells using a novel system that allowed us to control cytolytic activity. The perforin/granzyme granules used to lyse targets induced the apoptosis of CTL in a fratricide-independent manner. After adoptive transfer to antigen-free mice, the ability of CTL to give generate memory cells was determined. We found that the extent of cytolysis by a common pool of CTL controlled the differentiation into memory cells, which were only generated under conditions of minimal cytolytic activity. Thus, the differentiation of naive CD8(+) cells into memory cells may not depend on the presence on a subset of committed CTL precursors, but rather is controlled by the extent of granule-mediated cytolysis.

Crystal structure of the caspase activator human granzyme B, a proteinase highly specific for an Asp-P1 residue

Granzyme B is the prototypic member of the granzymes, a family of trypsin-like serine proteinases localized in the dense cytoplasmic granules of activated natural killer cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Granzyme B directly triggers apoptosis in target cells by activating the caspase pathway, and has been implicated in the etiology of rheumatoid arthritis. Human granzyme B expressed in a baculovirus system has been crystallized without inhibitor and its structure has been determined to 3.1 A resolution, after considerably improving the diffraction power of the crystals by controlled humidity changes. The granzyme B structure reveals an overall fold similar to that found in cathepsin G and human chymase. The guanidinium group of Arg226, anchored at the back of the S1-specificity pocket, can form a salt bridge with the P1-Asp side chain of a bound peptide substrate. The architecture of the substrate binding site of granzyme B appears to be designed to accommodate and cleave hexapeptides such as the sequence Ile-Glu-Thr-Asp-/Ser-Gly present in the activation site of pro-caspase-3, a proven physiological substrate of granzyme B. These granzyme B crystals, with fully accessible active sites, are well suited for soaking with small synthetic inhibitors that might be used for a treatment of chronic inflammatory disorders.

Homeostatic regulation of CD8+ T cells by perforin

To prevent uncontrolled expansion, the massive proliferation of T cells during an acute immune response has to be followed by controlled deletion. Here we show that similar to Fas, perforin is not only an important effector molecule of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) but also involved in down-regulating peripheral T cells. Mice deficient for both the CTL effector molecule perforin and the apoptosis-inducing Fas ligand spontaneously develop infiltration of highly activated CD8(+) T cells in kidney and liver and die between 5 and 12 weeks of age. Injection of staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) into perforin-deficient mice results in dramatically increased selective expansion and prolonged persistence of CD8(+), but not CD4(+), SEB-reactive T cells. Also, secondary immunization of TCR transgenic perforin-deficient mice with the lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus glycoprotein-derived epitope peptide leads to an increased proliferation of transgenic CD8(+) T cells, that is not explained by failure to deplete professional antigen-presenting cells. These results point to a novel mechanism of T cell homeostasis in which the acquisition of perforin-dependent cytotoxic activity regulates the expansion and persistence of CD8(+) effector T cells in vivo.

Regulation of pro-apoptotic leucocyte granule serine proteinases by intracellular serpins

Caspase activation and apoptosis can be initiated by the introduction of serine proteinases into the cytoplasm of a cell. Cytotoxic lymphocytes have evolved at least one serine proteinase with specific pro-apoptotic activity (granzyme B), as well as the mechanisms to deliver it into a target cell, and recent evidence suggests that other leucocyte granule proteinases may also have the capacity to kill if released into the interior of cells. For example, the monocyte/granulocyte proteinase cathepsin G can activate caspases in vitro, and will induce apoptosis if its entry into cells is mediated by a bacterial pore-forming protein. The potent pro-apoptotic activity of granzyme B and cathepsin G suggests that cells producing these (or other) proteinases would be at risk from self-induced death if the systems involved in packaging, degranulation or targeting fail and allow proteinases to enter the host cell cytoplasm. The purpose of the present review is to describe recent work on a group of intracellular serine proteinase inhibitors (serpins) which may function in leucocytes to prevent autolysis induced by the granule serine proteinases.

Mouse lymphoblasts lose their immunogenicity and susceptibility to specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte lysis during maintenance in culture

This study was undertaken to search for possible mechanisms by which T-cell lines become non-immunogenic and refractory to cellular-mediated lysis during culture. We demonstrate that mouse lymphoblasts (LB) lost their susceptibility to specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL)-mediated lysis following culture for more than 5 days in the presence interleukin-2 (IL-2), IL-7 but not IL-4. In contrast, the cultured lymphoblasts (CLB) were efficiently lysed by specific antibody and C' and by CTL in the presence of concanavalin A. In addition, CLB did not inhibit cytotoxicity against LB in a cold target competition assay, indicating that CLB and LB differ in the expression of certain surface molecules. Indeed, a significantly lower expression of H-2D class I antigen, the Fas antigen and the adhesion molecules intracelluar adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) and very late activation antigen-4 (VLA-4) was observed on the CLB surface. Consequently, CLB could not form conjugates with specific CTL, a prerequisite for CTL-mediated lysis. In addition, there was a marked decrease in CLB immunogenicity: the cultured cells were unable to stimulate allogeneic spleen cells in mixed lymphocyte culture nor could they induce a cytotoxic response following their injection into allogeneic mice. The reduced immunogenicity enabled the prolonged survival of active CLB in an allogeneic host. We suggest that the extended survival in an allogeneic tumour-bearing host of cultured, hence weakly immunogenic, anti-tumour CTL, will enable them the in vivo implementation of their anti-tumour activity.

Selective regulation of apoptosis: the cytotoxic lymphocyte serpin proteinase inhibitor 9 protects against granzyme B-mediated apoptosis without perturbing the Fas cell death pathway

Cytotoxic lymphocytes (CLs) induce caspase activation and apoptosis of target cells either through Fas activation or through release of granule cytotoxins, particularly granzyme B. CLs themselves resist granule-mediated apoptosis but are eventually cleared via Fas-mediated apoptosis. Here we show that the CL cytoplasmic serpin proteinase inhibitor 9 (PI-9) can protect transfected cells against apoptosis induced by either purified granzyme B and perforin or intact CLs. A PI-9 P1 mutant (Glu to Asp) is a 100-fold-less-efficient granzyme B inhibitor that no longer protects against granzyme B-mediated apoptosis. PI-9 is highly specific for granzyme B because it does not inhibit eight of the nine caspases tested or protect transfected cells against Fas-mediated apoptosis. In contrast, the P1(Asp) mutant is an effective caspase inhibitor that protects against Fas-mediated apoptosis. We propose that PI-9 shields CLs specifically against misdirected granzyme B to prevent autolysis or fratricide, but it does not interfere with homeostatic deletion via Fas-mediated apoptosis.

A Role for Heat Shock Protein 27 in CTL-Mediated Cell Death

CTL exocytosis of granules containing perforin and granzyme proteases induces apoptotic cell death. Either granzyme A or B can act with perforin to trigger apoptosis. Granzyme B activates a ubiquitous apoptotic cascade induced by caspase cleavage, but the granzyme A pathway is largely unknown. Using affinity chromatography with recombinant mutant inactive granzyme A, we previously isolated two granzyme A-binding proteins, PHAP (putative HLA-associated protein) I and II. PHAP II, a substrate of granzyme A, is degraded within minutes of CTL attack. Two additional cytoplasmic proteins of 27 and 53 kDa bind strongly to the mutant granzyme A column, requiring 6 M urea to elute. Sequencing identified these as the monomer and dimer of hsp27, a small heat shock protein up-regulated by stress and cellular activation. Hsp27 coprecipitates with granzyme A from cytoplasmic lysates and is not a substrate of the enzyme. Hsp27 translocates to the detergent-insoluble fraction of target cells and relocalizes from diffuse cytoplasmic staining to long filamentous fibers, especially concentrated in a perinuclear region, within minutes of CTL attack. Hsp27 may participate in morphologic changes during granule-mediated lysis. Low or absent levels of hsp27 expression in T lymphocytes, even after heat shock, may play a role in CTL resistance to granule-mediated lysis.

Fas-Fas Ligand–Based Interactions Between Tumor Cells and Tumor-Specific Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes: A Lethal Two-Way Street

In the current study, we investigated the repercussions of the interaction between tumor cells (LSA) and the tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) (PE-9) when both expressed Fas and Fas ligand (FasL). The CTL clone, PE-9, expressed high levels of Fas and FasL upon activation through the T-cell receptor (TCR). Furthermore, the activated PE-9 cells used both perforin- and FasL-based pathways to kill Fas-positive (Fas+) LSA tumor cells. Interestingly, LSA tumor cells also constitutively expressed FasL but not perforin, and killed Fas+ PE-9 CTLs and Fas+ but not Fas-negative (Fas−) activated T cells and thymocytes, as detected using the JAM test. PE-9 CTLs, cultured for 24 hours in the presence of cell lysates of FasL-bearing LSA cells but not FasL-deficient P815 cells, exhibited significant apoptosis as detected using the TUNEL method. Moreover, another FasL+ T-cell lymphoma line, EL-4, induced apoptosis in Fas+ but not in Fas− T cells in a similar fashion. The current study demonstrates for the first time that not only can the tumor-specific CTL mediate Fas-based killing of tumor cells, but FasL+ tumor cells can kill the Fas+ tumor-specific CTL. Thus, the survival of the tumor or the host may depend on which cell can accomplish this task more efficiently. The current study also suggests that FasL-based killing of CTLs by specific tumor cells may constitute a major limiting factor in successful immunotherapy.

Recombinant human granzyme A binds to two putative HLA-associated proteins and cleaves one of them

The release of cytotoxic granule contents by cytotoxic T lymphocytes triggers apoptotic target cell death. Cytotoxic granules contain a pore-forming protein, perforin, and a group of serine proteases called granzymes. We expressed human granzyme A in bacteria as a proenzyme capable of in vitro activation by enterokinase. The recombinant activated enzyme has catalytic activity against substrates with Arg, preferably, or Lys at the P1 position, comparable to trypsin. An enzymatically inactive recombinant granzyme A, with the active site Ser mutated to Ala, was produced and used with affinity chromatography to identify potential substrates. Two granzyme A-binding cytoplasmic proteins of molecular mass 33 and 44 kDa were isolated and identified by tryptic fragment sequencing as PHAP I and II, ubiquitous putative HLA-associated proteins, previously coisolated by binding to an HLA class II peptide. PHAP II forms an SDS-stable complex with recombinant mutant granzyme A and coprecipitates with it from cytoplasmic extracts. PHAP II, either purified or in cell lysates, is cleaved by the recombinant enzyme at nanomolar concentrations to a 25-kDa fragment. PHAP II begins to be degraded within minutes of initiation of cytotoxic T lymphocyte attack. PHAP I and II are candidate participants in the granzyme A pathway of cell-mediated cytotoxicity.

Mechanism of lymphocyte-mediated cytolysis: functional cytolytic T cells lacking perforin and granzymes

Involvement of the lytic protein perforin (c. 65,000 MW) and of granule proteases (granzymes) in cell lysis induced by cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) has been suggested, but is still controversial. For example, in vivo-primed peritoneal exudate CTL (PEL) have been found to express perforin and granzyme activity in amounts comparable to those found in non-lytic lymphocytes, although PEL are the most potent of all CTL. Exploiting several cloned CTL hybridomas developed in this laboratory and newly available molecular probes for detecting perforin, granzymes, protein and mRNA, we now directly demonstrate killer T lymphocytes which kill effectively and specifically, but are free from perforin, lytic granules and granzymes, all three of which have been postulated to be involved in lymphocyte-mediated killing. The CTL hybridomas are completely devoid of perforin and granzymes prior to, during, and after activation by antigen, mitogen or interleukin-2 (IL-2). The induction of lytic granules, perforin, and granzymes in the in vivo-primed PEL, but not in the cloned CTL hybridomas, upon cultivation in IL-2, further suggests the involvement of these constituents in antigen/lymphokine-induced CTL activation and differentiation rather than directly in their cytocidal activity. Together, these findings support a perforin- and granzyme-independent CTL lytic mechanism.

Infection of lymphocytes by a virus that aborts cytotoxic T lymphocyte activity and establishes persistent infection

For viruses to establish persistent infections in their hosts, they must possess some mechanism for evading clearance by the immune system. When inoculated into adult immunocompetent mice, wild-type lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV ARM) induces a CD8(+)-mediated cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response that clears the infection within 7-14 d (CTL+ [P-]). By contrast, variant viruses isolated from lymphoid tissues of persistently infected mice fail to induce a CTL response and are thus able to establish a persistent infection in adult mice (CTL- [P+]). This report compares the interaction of CTL+ (P-) and CTL- (P+) viruses with cells of the immune system. Both types of virus initially bind to 2-4% of CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes and replicate within cells of both subsets. The replication of CTL- (P+) and CTL+ (P-) viruses in lymphocytes in vivo is similar for the first 5 d after initiating infection. Thereafter, in mice infected with CTL- (P+) variants, lymphocytes retain viral genetic information, and infectious virus can be recovered throughout the animals' lives. In contrast, when adult mice are infected with wild-type CTL+ (P-) LCMV ARM, virus is not recovered from lymphocytes for greater than 7 d after infection. A CD8(+)-mediated anti-LCMV CTL response is induced in such mice. Clearance of infected lymphocytes is produced by these LCMV-specific CTLs, as shown by their ability to lyse lymphocytes expressing LCMV determinants in vitro and the fact that depletion of CD8+ lymphocytes before infection with CTL+ (P-) viruses results in levels of infected lymphocytes similar to those found in undepleted CTL- (P+)-infected mice. Hence, CTL-mediated lysis of T lymphocytes carrying infectious virus is a critical factor determining whether virus persists or the infection is terminated.

T cell-T cell killing is induced by specific epitopes: evidence for an apoptotic mechanism

Epstein-Barr virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones were shown to be an effective target for their own lysis when incubated in the presence of their specific epitopes but not in the presence of irrelevant epitopes. The mode of cell killing appeared to be by apoptosis and was prevented by previously described inhibitors of the process. Degranulation, as measured by serine esterase activity, was involved in this form of T cell-T cell killing. This is the first report of T cell-T cell killing by apoptosis and is only observed in the presence of a specific epitope. This result may be of significance in the use of peptide-based vaccines.

Immune recognition of HLA molecules downmodulates CD8 expression on cytotoxic T lymphocytes

An HLA-A2+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) line restricted by HLA-A2 in recognition of an influenza B virus nucleoprotein (BNP) peptide uses the CD8 coreceptor in the recognition of this viral peptide. Incubation of these CTL with BNP peptide in the absence of antigen-presenting cells downmodulates CD8 alpha and CD8 beta expression and reduces their ability to lyse target cells without inducing self-lysis. CD8 downmodulation was dependent on peptide concentration, time of exposure, and T cell receptor specificity. Another viral peptide from the influenza A virus matrix protein interacting with HLA-A2 had no effect on CD8 expression. Upon further investigation, an anti-HLA class I monoclonal antibody (mAb), anti-HLA class II mAb, and HLA alloantisera were found to downmodulate CD8 alpha and CD8 beta expression and induce CTL nonresponsiveness without causing degranulation. When CD8 alpha and CD8 beta expression was modulated by viral peptide or anti-HLA mAbs, other cell surface molecules were unchanged. Finally, incubation of peripheral blood lymphocytes with these anti-HLA mAbs induced no change in CD8 expression on resting cells but did downmodulate it on mitogen-activated cells. These results suggest that T cell recognition of the HLA-A2-BNP peptide complex on neighboring CTL may be the mechanism for CD8 downmodulation induced by the BNP viral peptide. This mechanism may be important in clonal anergy.

Selective induction of autocytotoxic activity through the CD3 molecule

In the present study we show that when certain major histocompatibility complex-alloreactive CD8+ T cell clones with natural killer-like activity are stimulated through their CD3 molecules, in the absence of significant cross-linkage (as provided by Fab' fragments of OKT3 antibodies) they lose their interleukin 2 response. This is attributable to an induction of a nonspecific autocytolytic activity. These results suggest that activation of this process in some cytotoxic cells leads to an overall decrease in CTL activity and constitutes a possible mechanism of suppression of the immune response.

Cognate peptides induce self-destruction of CD8+ cytolytic T lymphocytes

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) have been shown to be relatively resistant to cytolytic attack by other CTLs. We show here, however, that cloned CTLs, in the absence of other cells, are destroyed by exposure to their cognate peptides (defined as those that in association with major histocompatibility complex proteins are recognized by the antigen-specific receptor of the T cell). Destruction is proportional to peptide concentration and can be prevented by a second peptide that competes with the cognate peptide for presentation by the class I major histocompatibility complex proteins of the CTLs. The speed and extent of peptide-induced changes in the appearance of CTLs suggest that the destruction may be due primarily to self-recognition and self-destruction of individual CTLs (suicide) rather than to the destruction of some CTLs by others of the same clone in the same culture (fratricide). This effect may also take place in vivo because the appropriately timed injection of a cognate peptide into ovalbumin-immunized mice appeared to deplete their spleens of primed anti-ovalbumin CTLs. The results point to a possible physiologic mechanism for postthymic elimination of cytolytic T cells that recognize their own peptides in association with their own major histocompatibility complex protein. The results also raise the possibility that cognate peptides might eventually prove therapeutically useful for eliminating CTL clones that cause pathological cell destruction, as in some autoimmune diseases and some viral infections.

The lysis of cytotoxic T lymphocytes and their blasts by cytotoxic T lymphocytes

After binding to their targets, cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) deliver a lethal hit signal, ultimately leading to target cell lysis, and then can recycle to lyse additional targets, without themselves being destroyed. If non-specific secreted lytic mediators are involved in such lysis. CTL survival would not be expected unless the effectors are immune to CTL-mediated lysis. Therefore the lytic susceptibilities of alloimmune peritoneal exudate lymphocytes (PEL), containing up to 50% CTL, and of the cytolytic PEL blasts (PEB), obtained by culturing with interleukin-2 (IL-2), were examined. 51Cr-labelled BALB/c (H-2d) anti-EL4 (H-2b) (d alpha b) PEL were lysed 88%, 78%, and 48% by C3H/eb (H-2k) anti-P815 (H-2d) (k alpha d) PEL, C57BL/6 (H-2b) anti-P815 (b alpha d) PEL and b alpha d PEB, respectively. Similarly, b alpha d PEL were lysed 82% and 21% by d alpha b PEL and PEB, respectively. b alpha d PEB were lysed 82%, 28-39% and 39-51% by k alpha d PEL, b alpha d PEL and b alpha d PEB, respectively, b alpha d PEB were lysed 29-55% by d alpha b PEL. Furthermore, the CTL-containing populations were no less susceptible to lysis than normal lymphocytes. Since the majority (80-90%) of cells in these two types of CTL-containing populations can be directly and specifically lysed by appropriately immunized PEL CTL, we conclude that both the lytic granule and perforin lacking (PEL) and containing (PEB) CTL are not a priori immune to CTL-mediated lysis. These findings are in accord with theories proposing lysis to be induced by receptor-mediated contact between effector CTL and target cells, and challenge those suggesting the involvement of secreted lytic mediators.

Membrane channel formation by the lymphocyte pore-forming protein: comparison between susceptible and resistant target cells

The assembly of pores by the pore-forming protein (perforin) of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and natural killer cells on the membranes of different cell lines was studied. Using the patch clamp technique in the whole cell configuration, we measured the conductance increase induced by perforin in susceptible cell lines as well as in resistant CTL lines (CTLLs). The results showed that although the amplitudes of the first observed conductance steps produced in both cell types were comparable, CTLLs required at least 10-fold higher doses of perforin to form membrane pores. Outside-out patches excised from CTLL-R8, on the other hand, appeared to be more susceptible to channel formation by perforin than intact cells, as lower doses were able to induce conductance increases. Once channels were induced in CTL membranes, however, their conductances (greater than 1 nS) were indistinguishable from the ones obtained in susceptible cell lines. Fluorescence measurements with quin-2 showed that perforin induced rapid increases in the intracellular Ca2+ concentration in susceptible EL4 cells. In marked contrast, a perforin dose 60-120-fold higher than the minimal dose required to elicit Ca2+ changes in EL4 cells was not able to induce any measurable Ca2+ increase in CTLL-R8. The data suggest that the resistance of CTLs to lysis mediated by their own mediator perforin is at least in part due to their ability to avoid pore formation by this protein. The mechanism underlying this phenomenon is not yet understood, but the observation that outside-out patches excised from CTLL-R8 are more susceptible to channel formation by perforin than intact cells raises the possibility that an intracellular mechanism may be involved.

Specific killing of cytotoxic T cells and antigen-presenting cells by CD4+ cytotoxic T cell clones. A novel potentially immunoregulatory T-T cell interaction in man

Mycobacterial antigens not only stimulate Th cells that produce macrophage-activating factors, but also CD4+ and CD8+ CTL that lyse human macrophages. The mycobacterial recombinant 65-kD hsp was previously found to be an important target antigen for polyclonal CD4+ CTL. Because of the major role of 65-kD hsp in the immune response to mycobacterial as well as autoantigens, we have studied CTL activity to this protein at the clonal level. HLA-DR or HLA-DQ restricted, CD4+CD8- T cell clones that recognize different peptides of the M. leprae 65-kD hsp strongly lysed EBV-BLCL pulsed with specific but not irrelevant peptide. No bystander lysis of B cells, T cells, or tumor cells was seen. Target cell lysis could not be triggered by PMA + Ca2+ ionophore alone and depended on active metabolism. Interestingly, these CD4+ CTL also strongly lysed themselves and other HLA-class II compatible CD4+ (TCR-alpha/beta or -gamma/delta) or CD8+ CTL clones in the presence of peptide, suggesting that CTL are not actively protected from CTL-mediated lysis. Cold target competition experiments suggested that EBV-BLCL targets were more efficiently recognized than CD4+ CTL targets. These results demonstrate that hsp65 peptide-specific HLA class II-restricted CD4+ T cell clones display strong peptide-dependent cytolytic activity towards both APCs, and, unexpectedly, CD4+ and CD8+ CTL clones, including themselves. Since, in contrast to murine T cells human T cells express class II, CTL-mediated T cell killing may represent a novel immunoregulatory pathway in man.

Influenza peptide-induced self-lysis and down-regulation of cloned cytotoxic T cells

Virus-specific cytotoxic T-cell (Tc) clones can lyse target cells in vitro in the presence of their specific peptide epitopes. The lytic potency of murine influenza nucleoprotein (NP)-specific Tc clones was investigated after observing that target cell killing was reduced in the presence of high (greater than 0.2 microM) concentrations of specific NP peptide antigen. Following incubation of Tc for 16 hr in the presence of a range of peptide concentrations, two effects were observed; (i) a peptide dose-dependent mortality of Tc, which has been attributed to self-lysis by clonal Tc in the presence of specific peptide; (ii) and a reduced ability to specifically lyse NP-expressing target cells whilst retaining lectin-dependent lytic activity in the surviving Tc. This functional down-regulation was reversible after 24 hr incubation in the absence of peptide. Toxic effects were excluded, since inhibition of specific target lysis by Tc was mediated only be pretreatment with specifically recognized peptide.

Resistance of cytolytic lymphocytes to perforin-mediated killing. Induction of resistance correlates with increase in cytotoxicity

CTL and NK cells cultured in vitro are known to produce a cytolytic pore-forming protein (PFP, perforin) localized in their cytoplasmic granules. Using purified perforin, we showed here that both cloned CTL and primary killer cell populations, including allospecific CTL, NK/lymphokine-activated killer cells, and MHC-non-restricted CTL, were more resistant to perforin-mediated killing than other lymphocyte populations and cell types. Similar results were obtained with both murine and human cytolytic lymphocyte populations. Resistance of killer cells to perforin correlated in general with their cytolytic capability. Thus, cells that have acquired competence to kill after stimulation with Con A, IL-2, or leukocyte-conditioned medium, were also the more resistant cells. IL-2-independent CTL lines and hybridomas derived in our laboratories could be triggered to become cytotoxic and perforin resistant by short-term stimulation with various cytokines, indicating that the acquisition of resistance to perforin-mediated lysis was independent of cell proliferation. Activation of one IL-2-independent CTL line with IL-2 also resulted in enhanced production of perforin and in enhanced serine esterase activity. The acquisition of cell resistance to perforin by these IL-2-independent cell lines after activation with stimulatory reagents was independent of protein and RNA neosynthesis: emetine, cycloheximide, and actinomycin D, while effectively blocking the incorporation of [35S]methionine into cell proteins, did not affect the induced increase in perforin resistance.

Mechanisms of lymphocyte-mediated lysis

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and natural killer (NK) cells use multiple mechanisms to destroy their target cells. Pore formation resulting in osmotic lysis of the target is one mechanism; the pore-forming protein (perforin) responsible for this activity has been purified. Antigenically and functionally it resembles proteins of the membrane attack complex of complement. The other known mediators of cytotoxicity appear to be closely interrelated. Tumor necrosis factor (TNF), lymphotoxin (LT), and leukalexin are the three members of this group that have been purified, although their mechanisms of action are still unknown. CTLs fragment the DNA of target cells, as do TNF, LT, and leukalexin; this may be one of the mechanisms of action of these mediators. CTLs and NK cells do not self lyse. The basis of this phenomenon is unclear, although recent advances have shed some light on the problem.

Self-protection of cytotoxic lymphocytes: a soluble form of homologous restriction factor in cytoplasmic granules

A soluble form of homologous restriction factor (HRF) has been isolated from the cytoplasmic granules of human large granular lymphocytes that were cultured in the presence of recombinant interleukin 2 for 2-3 weeks. The granule-derived protein (approximately 65 kDa) is soluble in detergent-free solution and reacts with antibody produced to membrane HRF. HRF was first described as a 65-kDa membrane protein of human erythrocytes capable of inhibiting the formation of transmembrane channels by the membrane attack complex of complement. It has also been isolated from activated human lymphocytes and shown to confer upon these cells relative resistance to lysis by the membrane attack complex and by the complement component C9-related protein of human cytotoxic lymphocytes. The soluble HRF of lymphocyte granules inhibits reactive lysis of erythrocytes by the membrane attack complex of human complement. It was also found to be a potent inhibitor of (i) the cytolytic activity of the C9-related protein of human cytotoxic lymphocytes, (ii) human large granular lymphocyte cytotoxicity, and (iii) the cytotoxic activity of human CD8+ lymphocytes obtained by cell sorting from recombinant interleukin 2-activated peripheral blood mononuclear cells. It is proposed that granule-derived soluble HRF and cell surface-membrane-bound HRF are involved in the mechanism of self-protection of killer lymphocytes.

Perforin-dependent and -independent pathways of cytotoxicity mediated by lymphocytes

There is little doubt at the present time that both perforin-dependent and -independent pathways are important in mediating the cytotoxicity associated with lymphocytes. The cell distribution of perforin, initially thought to include both CTL and NK cells, now must be viewed with caution because all previous biochemical studies on CTL have been conducted with cell lines propagated in long-term cultures in the presence of T cell growth factors (IL-2 and perhaps some still undefined factors). Under these conditions, CTL are known to assume a broader, NK-like specificity in target cell killing and may thus differ significantly from primary CTL generated in the body. Accordingly, perforin does not seem to be present in primary CTL activated directly through mixed lymphocyte reactions. It remains to be shown how primary CTL lyse target cells in vivo. Initial studies conducted in several laboratories have already provided some clues. It now seems that even in cultured, perforin-containing CTL, the perforin pathway is not an obligatory mechanism required for target cell killing. Other pathways, possibly involving TNF/lymphotoxin-like molecules, may play a direct role in this type of cytotoxicity. Other still unidentified factors now also need to be sought, including membrane polypeptides that may develop cytotoxicity directly upon cell contact and binding. Although from the studies reviewed here it is clear now that perforin has a more limited role in cell killing than originally proposed, it is still intriguing that it should share structural and functional homologies with complement proteins, drawing paradoxical analogies between two systems (the cellular and the humoral immune systems) which have evolved to become specialized to carry out separate immunological tasks. The cloning of the genes for perforin and for all the C proteins that comprise the MAC should reveal important information on how these genes originated and then diverged during evolution. The cellular distribution of other granule products, such as serine esterases, also must be viewed with caution. A serine esterase activity was initially thought to be CTL-specific. This information stimulated an intensive research activity in many laboratories that resulted in both the purification of a serine esterase family and the cloning of several serine esterase transcripts. It is becoming clear from recent evidence that this group of enzymes is not truly CTL-specific and therefore would not be expected to develop any function rendered absolutely necessary for cytolysis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The molecular basis of target cell killing by human lymphocytes and of killer cell self-protection

The cytolytic protein (C9RP) of human cytotoxic lymphocytes was isolated from large granular lymphocytes (LGL) and anti-CD3 activated cytotoxic T cells (CTL). It is immunochemically related to the channel-forming proteins of complement. Whereas LGL constitutively contain C9RP, peripheral resting CTL do not. C9RP synthesis is induced, however, in CD8+ cells upon stimulation of the T cell antigen receptor-CD3 structure. Comparison of cellular cytotoxicity and C9RP content at various times during anti-CD3 activation of CTL yielded a coefficient of correlation, r = 0.92. Isolated C9RP (Mr approximately 70,000) readily lysed a large variety of metabolically active cells tested. Certain monoclonal antibodies to C9RP inhibited target cell killing by LGL or activated CD8+ lymphocytes. Homologous restriction factor (HRF) is a normal membrane protein of blood cells that inhibits transmembrane channel formation by the membrane attack complex of complement. It has recently been found that isolated HRF (Mr approximately 65,000), bound to sheep erythrocytes, inhibited their lysis mediated by the antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity reaction or by isolated C9RP. Further, stimulation of resting peripheral lymphocytes with anti-CD3 resulted in increased expression of cell surface HRF. Acquisition of HRF expression conferred upon CTL relative resistance to lysis by C9RP. A soluble form of HRF (Mr approximately 65,000) was isolated from the cytoplasmic granules of LGL, which also contain C9RP, and shown to inhibit cytotoxicity of LGL and CTL. It is conceivable that HRF is opertive in self-protection of cytotoxic lymphocytes.

A comparison of the cytolytic properties of murine primary CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes and cloned cytotoxic T cell lines

Lysates of many highly cytolytic murine primary CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) have no detectable hemolytic activity and only traces of serine esterase activity, indicating a striking paucity or absence of the perforin-rich secretory granules that are abundant in the cytoplasm of murine cloned CTL cell lines. Nevertheless, the primary CTLs are almost as resistant to granule-mediated lysis as CTL cell lines. Moreover, target cells that are lysed by all CTLs so far tested, whether primary or cell lines, show similar rapid and marked increases in intracellular calcium and breakdown of DNA into nucleosome-sized fragments. A parsimonious explanation for all of these findings is that primary CTLs, like the CTL cell lines, exercise their cytolytic activity by means of perforin, but the amounts needed are extremely small and below the level of detection by the current relatively insensitive hemolytic assays.

Calcium ion concentrations and DNA fragmentation in target cell destruction by murine cloned cytotoxic T lymphocytes

To investigate the destruction of target cells by murine CTLs, we examined intracellular Ca2+ concentrations ([Ca2+]i) and DNA fragmentation in target cells. Changes in [Ca2+]i were followed by flow cytometry by loading the cells with indo-1, a Ca2+-binding fluorescent dye, and determining the ration of fluorescence intensities at 405 nm (emission maximum for Ca2+-bound dye) over 480 nm (emission maximum for the free dye). Within minutes after interacting with the cytolytic granule fraction that had been isolated from CTLs, [Ca2+]i in target cells was strikingly increased. A pronounced increase in [Ca2+]i was also observed in target cells when they were specifically recognized by intact CTLs. Since ionomycin, a Ca2+ ionophore, caused a similar increase in [Ca2+]i and lysed cells (provided that extracellular Ca2+ was present), it appears that a sustained high level of [Ca2+]i is cytolytic. In contrast with other cells, CTLs, which have been shown to be refractory to granule-mediated lysis and to be poor targets for other CTLs, did not manifest an elevation in [Ca2+]i when they were similarly loaded with indo-1 and treated with isolated granules. The characteristic cleavage of target cell DNA into nucleosome-sized fragments was also induced by isolated granules as well as by valinomycin, a K+ ionophore, but not by ionomycin. The results support the view that lysis of most target cells by cloned CTLs is due primarily to target cell membrane changes that are fundamentally equivalent to the formation of nonspecific ion channels. The resulting large increase in [Ca2+]i is probably responsible for target cell lysis; and changes in intracellular ion concentrations also appear to be responsible for DNA fragmentation, probably by activating endogenous target cell endonucleases.

Induction of expression of cell-surface homologous restriction factor upon anti-CD3 stimulation of human peripheral lymphocytes

Homologous restriction factor (HRF) is a 65-kDa membrane protein that inhibits transmembrane channel formation by the membrane-attack complex of complement and by the complement component C9-related cytolytic lymphocyte protein. Stimulation of resting peripheral human lymphocytes with the anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody OKT3 has been shown to induce cytotoxicity in the CD8+ subpopulation. As demonstrated here, OKT3 stimulation also induces expression of cell-surface HRF by CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes. The small proportion of Leu 19+ natural killer lymphocytes present in peripheral blood mononuclear cells was found to express HRF prior to stimulation. Whereas unstimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells were susceptible to lysis by the membrane-attack complex or by the C9-related protein, OKT3-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells were relatively resistant to both the membrane-attack complex and C9-related protein. This acquired resistance was abrogated by blocking surface HRF with F(ab')2 anti-HRF, suggesting that resistance was due to lymphocyte-membrane HRF. By using solid-phase anti-HRF, a 65-kDa protein was isolated from the activated peripheral blood mononuclear cells and shown to be capable of conferring upon sheep erythrocytes the characteristic activity of human HRF.

Resistance of mouse cytolytic cells to pore-forming protein-mediated cytolysis

Pore-forming protein (perforin, PFP) was isolated from a mouse large granular lymphocyte (LGL) [natural killer (NK-like)] cell line. Purified PFP lysed a variety of mouse tumor cell lines and helper T lymphocyte cell lines. However, LGL and cytotoxic T lymphocyte cell lines were resistant to PFP-mediated cell lysis. The presence of hemolytic activity in the granule was examined in these resistant cell lines. Four out of five of these resistant cell lines had hemolytically active granules. We determined whether NK cells freshly isolated from BALB/c nude mouse spleens were resistant to PFP-mediated cytolysis. Nylon column-passed spleen cells with an enriched content of NK cells exhibited more resistance than whole spleen cells. Moreover, when spleen cells were treated with PFP the remaining live cells showed enriched NK activity suggesting that normal peripheral cells with NK activity are resistant to PFP. These results indicate that cytolytic cells containing PFP have developed defense mechanisms to inhibit PEP-mediated cell lysis.

Resistance of cytotoxic T lymphocytes to the lytic effects of their toxic granules

A cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) characteristically kills target cells one after the other by releasing toxic granules that contain one or more cytolytic components. To determine how CTLs avoid destroying themselves when they release granules and lyse target cells, 7 murine CD8+ CTL cell lines were compared with 19 other cell lines for susceptibility to lysis by the isolated toxic granules. Murine CD8+ CTLs were clearly the most resistant cells: granules did not lyse them even after they were exposed to azide, cyanide, and 2-deoxyglucose, conditions that were found to enhance the susceptibility of all the other cells tested, including other T cells. Thus, resistance of CD8+ CTLs to cytotoxic granules appears to be independent of cellular ATP. To reconcile these findings with other observations that, under some circumstances, CTLs can be lysed by other CTLs, we suggest a model in which a CTL releases only a limited proportion of its toxic granules at each antigen-specific encounter with a target cell; the amount released is sufficient to kill most target cells but to leave the CTL undamaged and with enough granules to attack other target cells.

Resistance of cloned cytotoxic T lymphocytes to cell-mediated cytotoxicity

Cloned CTLs show an unusually high resistance to lysis by effector CTLs. Several cloned CTL lines in our laboratories are absolutely refractory to lysis by other cloned CTLs, either (a) directly, (b) in the presence of lectin, or (c) by PMA-induced CTLs. They can be lysed to some extent by primary CTL, although they are less than 5% as sensitive as target cells normally used to assay primary CTL lytic activity. Lysis of cloned CTLs by primary CTL effector cells is not enhanced by the presence of lectin, and cloned T cells are also highly resistant to lysis by primary lymphokine-activated killer cells. Cloned CTLs are highly resistant to lysis by isolated CTL granules that contain the membranolytic pore-forming protein (PFP or perforin), while non-CTL targets are highly susceptible to granule-mediated killing, indicating that cloned CTLs resist lysis not only at the intact effector cell level but also when soluble effector proteins are used. This resistance mechanism may explain how CTLs kill but spare themselves from being killed during the cytolytic event.