Generation of lytic natural killer 1.1+, Ly-49- cells from multipotential murine bone marrow progenitors in a stroma-free culture: definition of cytokine requirements and developmental intermediates

Cord blood stem cell-generated KIR+NK cells effectively target leukemia cell lines

Acute lymphoid (ALL) and myeloid leukemia (AML) are known to be invasive and highly lethal hematological malignancies. Because current treatments are insufficient and have a variety of side effects, researchers are looking for new and more effective therapeutic methods. Interestingly, ongoing efforts to find the best approach to optimize NK cell anti-leukemia potential shed light on the successful treatment of cancer. Mature KIR⁺NK cells ability to remove HLA Class-I deficient cells has been exploited in cancer immunotherapy. Here, we generated KIR⁺NK cells from cord blood stem cells using IL-2 and IL-15 cytokines. Our finding underlined the importance of KIR expression in the cytotoxic function of NK cells. Taken together, this study presented an effective in vitro method for the expansion and differentiation of KIR⁺NK cells using cytokines without any feeder cells. Furthermore, the presented culture condition could be useful for the generation of mature and pure NK cells from limited numbers of CD34⁺ cord blood cells and might be used as a novel method to improve the current state of cancer therapy.

Identification of aceNKPs, a committed common progenitor population of the ILC1 and NK cell continuum

The development of innate lymphoid cell (ILC) transcription factor reporter mice has shown a previously unexpected complexity in ILC hematopoiesis. Using novel polychromic mice to achieve higher phenotypic resolution, we have characterized bone marrow progenitors that are committed to the group 1 ILC lineage. These common ILC1/NK cell progenitors (ILC1/NKP), which we call "aceNKPs", are defined as lineage-Id2+IL-7Rα+CD25-α4β7-NKG2A/C/E+Bcl11b-. In vitro, aceNKPs differentiate into group 1 ILCs, including NK-like cells that express Eomes without the requirement for IL-15, and produce IFN-γ and perforin upon IL-15 stimulation. Following reconstitution of Rag2-/-Il2rg-/- hosts, aceNKPs give rise to a spectrum of mature ILC1/NK cells (regardless of their tissue location) that cannot be clearly segregated into the traditional ILC1 and NK subsets, suggesting that group 1 ILCs constitute a dynamic continuum of ILCs that can develop from a common progenitor. In addition, aceNKP-derived ILC1/NK cells effectively ameliorate tumor burden in a model of lung metastasis, where they acquired a cytotoxic NK cell phenotype. Our results identify the primary ILC1/NK progenitor that lacks ILC2 or ILC3 potential and is strictly committed to ILC1/NK cell production irrespective of tissue homing.

Molecular Regulation of NK Cell Maturation

Natural killer (NK) cells are innate lymphocytes specialized in immune surveillance against tumors and infections. To reach their optimal functional status, NK cells must undergo a process of maturation from immature to mature NK cells. Genetically modified mice, as well as in vivo and in vitro NK cell differentiation assays, have begun to reveal the landscape of the regulatory network involved in NK cell maturation, in which a balance of cytokine signaling pathways leads to an optimal coordination of transcription factor activity. An increased understanding of NK cell maturation will greatly promote the development and application of NK cell-based clinical therapy. Thus, in this review, we summarize the dynamics of NK cell maturation, describe recently identified factors involved in the regulation of the NK cell maturation process, including cytokines and transcription factors, and discuss the importance of NK cell maturation in health and disease.

Cross talk between natural killer cells and mast cells in tumor angiogenesis

Natural killer (NK) cells are large granular lymphocytes of the innate immune system, responsible for direct targeting and killing of both virally infected and transformed cells. Under pathological conditions and during inflammation, NK cells extravasate into the lymph nodes and accumulate at inflammatory or tumor sites. The activation of NK cells depends on an intricate balance between activating and inhibitory signals that determines if a target will be susceptible to NK-mediated lysis. Many experimental evidences indicate that NK cells are also involved in several immunoregulatory processes and have the ability to modulate the adaptive immune responses. Many other important aspects about NK cell biology are emerging in these last years. The aim of this review is to elucidate the role of NK cells in tumor angiogenesis and their interaction with mast cells. In fact, it has been observed that NK cells produce pro-angiogenic factors and participate alone or in cooperation with mast cells to the regulation of angiogenesis in both physiological and pathological conditions including tumors.

Ezh2 regulates differentiation and function of natural killer cells through histone methyltransferase activity

Changes of histone modification status at critical lineage-specifying gene loci in multipotent precursors can influence cell fate commitment. The contribution of these epigenetic mechanisms to natural killer (NK) cell lineage determination from common lymphoid precursors is not understood. Here we investigate the impact of histone methylation repressive marks (H3 Lys27 trimethylation; H3K27(me3)) on early NK cell differentiation. We demonstrate that selective loss of the histone-lysine N-methyltransferase Ezh2 (enhancer of zeste homolog 2) or inhibition of its enzymatic activity with small molecules unexpectedly increased generation of the IL-15 receptor (IL-15R) CD122(+) NK precursors and mature NK progeny from both mouse and human hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells. Mechanistic studies revealed that enhanced NK cell expansion and cytotoxicity against tumor cells were associated with up-regulation of CD122 and the C-type lectin receptor NKG2D. Moreover, NKG2D deficiency diminished the positive effects of Ezh2 inhibitors on NK cell commitment. Identification of the contribution of Ezh2 to NK lineage specification and function reveals an epigenetic-based mechanism that regulates NK cell development and provides insight into the clinical application of Ezh2 inhibitors in NK-based cancer immunotherapies.

TNF-α-dependent hematopoiesis following Bcl11b deletion in T cells restricts metastatic melanoma

Using several tumor models, we demonstrate that mice deficient in Bcl11b in T cells, although having reduced numbers of T cells in the peripheral lymphoid organs, developed significantly less tumors compared with wild-type mice. Bcl11b(-/-) CD4(+) T cells, with elevated TNF-α levels, but not the Bcl11b(-/-) CD8(+) T cells, were required for the reduced tumor burden, as were NK1.1(+) cells, found in increased numbers in Bcl11b(F/F)/CD4-Cre mice. Among NK1.1(+) cells, the NK cell population was predominant in number and was the only population displaying elevated granzyme B levels and increased degranulation, although not increased proliferation. Although the number of myeloid-derived suppressor cells was increased in the lungs with metastatic tumors of Bcl11b(F/F)/CD4-Cre mice, their arginase-1 levels were severely reduced. The increase in NK cell and myeloid-derived suppressor cell numbers was associated with increased bone marrow and splenic hematopoiesis. Finally, the reduced tumor burden, increased numbers of NK cells in the lung, and increased hematopoiesis in Bcl11b(F/F)/CD4-Cre mice were all dependent on TNF-α. Moreover, TNF-α treatment of wild-type mice also reduced the tumor burden and increased hematopoiesis and the numbers and activity of NK cells in the lung. In vitro treatment with TNF-α of lineage-negative hematopoietic progenitors increased NK and myeloid differentiation, further supporting a role of TNF-α in promoting hematopoiesis. These studies reveal a novel role for TNF-α in the antitumor immune response, specifically in stimulating hematopoiesis and increasing the numbers and activity of NK cells.

Differential Ly49e expression pathways in resting versus TCR-activated intraepithelial γδ T cells

The Ly49 NK receptor family in mice is composed of several members that recognize MHC class I (MHC-I) or MHC-I-related molecules. We and others have shown before that Ly49E is a unique member, with a different expression pattern on NK cells and being triggered by the non-MHC-I-related protein urokinase plasminogen activator. Among the entire Ly49 receptor family, Ly49E is the only Ly49 member expressed by epidermal-localized γδ T cells and their fetal thymic TCRγδ precursors, and it is the most abundantly expressed member on intestinal intraepithelial γδ T cell lymphocytes. In this study, we provide mechanistic insights into the regulation of Ly49e expression in γδ T cells. First, we demonstrate that TCR-mediated activation of intraepithelial γδ T cells significantly increases Ly49E expression. This results from de novo Ly49E expression and is highly selective, because no other Ly49 family members are induced. TCR-mediated Ly49E induction is a conserved feature of skin- and gut-residing intraepithelial-localized γδ T cell subsets, whereas it is not observed in spleen γδ T cells. By investigating Ly49e promoter activities and lymphotoxin (LT) αβ dependency in resting versus TCR-activated intraepithelial γδ T cells, we reveal two separate regulatory pathways for Ly49E expression, as follows: a LTαβ-dependent pathway leading to basal Ly49E expression in resting cells that is induced by Pro2-mediated Ly49e transcription, and a LTαβ-independent pathway leading to elevated, Pro3-driven Ly49E expression in TCR-stimulated cells.

Impairment of hepatic NK cell development in IFN-γ deficient mice

It is already clearly demonstrated that IFN-γ plays important roles in differentiation and maturation of T cells, B cells and macrophages; however, it is not clear whether NK cell development is regulated by IFN-γ. In our study by using IFN-γ-deficient mice (GKO), we observed that the percentage and number of NK1.1(+)CD3(-) cells were declined significantly in the liver, but not in the spleen, bone marrow and lymph node, of adult IFN-γ(-/-) mice. However, Lin(-)CD122(+) NK progenitor cells developed normally both in liver and bone marrow in IFN-γ(-/-) mice. Moreover, more mature CD27(-)CD11b(+) NK cells accumulated in the liver of IFN-γ(-/-) mice. Deficiency of IFN-γ resulted in the lower expression of CD69, GranzymeB and TRAIL by hepatic NK1.1(+)CD3(-) cells and the phenotypes of IFN-γ(-/-) hepatic NK1.1(+)CD3(-) cells were altered from WT hepatic NK cells. When stimulated with Poly (I:C) in vivo, attenuated accumulating in the liver and weaker expression of GranzymeB, TRAIL and FasL of NK1.1(+)CD3(-) cells were observed of IFN-γ(-/-) mice. Accordingly, these results demonstrate that IFN-γ plays important role in mounting liver environment for development of hepatic NK cells.

Generation of natural killer cells from hematopoietic stem cells in vitro for immunotherapy

Natural killer (NK) cells are part of the innate immune system and are an alluring option for immunotherapy due to their ability to kill infected cells or cancer cells without prior sensitization. Throughout the past 20 years, different groups have been able to reproduce NK cell development in vitro, and NK cell ontogeny studies have provided the basis for the establishment of protocols to produce NK cells in vitro for immunotherapy. Here, we briefly discuss NK cell development and NK cell immunotherapy approaches. We review the factors needed for NK cell differentiation in vitro, which stem cell sources have been used, published protocols, challenges and future directions for Good Manufacturing Practice protocols.

Eri1 regulates microRNA homeostasis and mouse lymphocyte development and antiviral function

Natural killer (NK) cells play a critical role in early host defense to infected and transformed cells. Here, we show that mice deficient in Eri1, a conserved 3'-to-5' exoribonuclease that represses RNA interference, have a cell-intrinsic defect in NK-cell development and maturation. Eri1(-/-) NK cells displayed delayed acquisition of Ly49 receptors in the bone marrow (BM) and a selective reduction in Ly49D and Ly49H activating receptors in the periphery. Eri1 was required for immune-mediated control of mouse CMV (MCMV) infection. Ly49H(+) NK cells deficient in Eri1 failed to expand efficiently during MCMV infection, and virus-specific responses were also diminished among Eri1(-/-) T cells. We identified miRNAs as the major endogenous small RNA target of Eri1 in mouse lymphocytes. Both NK and T cells deficient in Eri1 displayed a global, sequence-independent increase in miRNA abundance. Ectopic Eri1 expression rescued defective miRNA expression in mature Eri1(-/-) T cells. Thus, mouse Eri1 regulates miRNA homeostasis in lymphocytes and is required for normal NK-cell development and antiviral immunity.

Development of thymic NK cells from double negative 1 thymocyte precursors

The differentiation of natural killer (NK) cells and a subpopulation of NK cells which requires an intact thymus, that is, thymic NK cells, is poorly understood. Previous in vitro studies indicate that double negative (CD4⁻CD8⁻, DN) thymocytes can develop into cells with NK cell markers, but these cells have not been well characterized. Herein, we generated and characterized NK cells differentiating from thymic DN precursors. Sorted DN1 (CD44⁺CD25⁻) CD122⁻NK1.1⁻ thymocytes from Rag1(⁻/⁻) mice were adoptively transferred into Rag1(⁻/⁻)Ly5.1 congenic mice. After intrathymic injection, donor-derived cells phenotypically resembling thymic NK cells were found. To further study their differentiation, we seeded sorted DN1 CD122⁻)NK1.1⁻ thymocytes on irradiated OP9 bone marrow stromal cells with IL-15, IL-7, Flt3L, and stem cell factor. NK1.1⁺ cells emerged after 7 days. In vitro differentiated NK cells acquired markers associated with immature bone marrow-derived NK cells, but also expressed CD127, which is typically found on thymic NK cells. Furthermore, we found that in vitro cells generated from thymic precursors secreted cytokines when stimulated and degranulated on target exposure. Together, these data indicate that functional thymic NK cells can develop from a DN1 progenitor cell population.

Transcriptional control of natural killer cell development and function

Natural killer (NK) cells play an important role in host defense against tumors and viruses and other infectious diseases. NK cell development is regulated by mechanisms that are both shared with and separate from other hematopoietic cell lineages. Functionally, NK cells use activating and inhibitory receptors to recognize both healthy and altered cells such as transformed or infected cells. Upon activation, NK cells produce cytokines and cytotoxic granules using mechanisms similar to other hematopoietic cell lineages especially cytotoxic T cells. Here we review the transcription factors that control NK cell development and function. Although many of these transcription factors are shared with other hematopoietic cell lineages, they control unexpected and unique aspects of NK cell biology. We review the mechanisms and target genes by which these transcriptional regulators control NK cell development and functional activity.

Shared dependence on the DNA-binding factor TOX for the development of lymphoid tissue-inducer cell and NK cell lineages

TOX is a DNA-binding factor required for development of CD4(+) T cells, natural killer T cells and regulatory T cells. Here we document that both natural killer (NK) cell development and lymphoid tissue organogenesis were also inhibited in the absence of TOX. We found that the development of lymphoid tissue-inducer cells, a rare subset of specialized cells that has an integral role in lymphoid tissue organogenesis, required TOX. Tox was upregulated considerably in immature NK cells in the bone marrow, consistent with the loss of mature NK cells in the absence of this nuclear protein. Thus, many cell lineages of the immune system share a TOX-dependent step for development.

Use of stem cell radiation chimeras to analyze how domains of specific proteins impact on murine NK cell development in vivo

Although the use of mutant mice has been extremely useful in identifying those proteins and molecules specifically required for the development of NK cells, the establishment of a well-defined protocol to replicate in vitro the major steps corresponding to the process of NK cell differentiation and maturation has enabled us to dissect the molecular events governing certain aspects of NK cell development. This chapter describes a protocol that combines both the use of mutant mice and the in vitro bone marrow (BM) culture system for examining the role of proteins and their putative signaling domains in NK cell development. BM-derived Lin-c-kit(+) stem cells expressing the protein of interest are first cultured for 6 days in a cocktail of cytokines that promote lymphoid development. The semi-differentiated cells are then transplanted into mice to complete their development in vivo. While all hematopoietic lineages can develop from these transplanted cells, we focus primarily on assessing the effect of the protein on the production of NK cells, as well as the acquisition of Ly49 receptors. The most prevalent advantage of this method is the ability to potentially link signaling regulators to known aspects of NK cell development.

Development of functional human NK cells in an immunodeficient mouse model with the ability to provide protection against tumor challenge

Studies of human NK cells and their role in tumor suppression have largely been restricted to in vitro experiments which lack the complexity of whole organisms, or mouse models which differ significantly from humans. In this study we showed that, in contrast to C57BL/6 Rag2^−/−/γ_c^−/− and NOD/Scid mice, newborn BALB/c Rag2^−/−/γ_c^−/− mice can support the development of human NK cells and CD56+ T cells after intrahepatic injection with hematopoietic stem cells. The human CD56⁺ cells in BALB/c Rag2^−/−/γ_c^−/− mice were able to produce IFN-γ in response to human IL-15 and polyI:C. NK cells from reconstituted Rag2^−/−/γ_c^−/− mice were also able to kill and inhibit the growth of K562 cells in vitro and were able to produce IFN-γ in response to stimulation with K562 cells. In vivo, reconstituted Rag2^−/−/γ_c^−/− mice had higher survival rates after K562 challenge compared to non-reconstituted Rag2^−/−/γ_c^−/− mice and were able to control tumor burden in various organs. Reconstituted Rag2^−/−/γ_c^−/− mice represent a model in which functional human NK and CD56+ T cells can develop from stem cells and can thus be used to study human disease in a more clinically relevant environment.

The Notch ligands Jagged2, Delta1, and Delta4 induce differentiation and expansion of functional human NK cells from CD34+ cord blood hematopoietic progenitor cells

Notch receptor signaling is required for T cell development, but its role in natural killer (NK) cell development is poorly understood. We compared the ability of the 5 mammalian Notch ligands (Jagged1, Jagged2, Delta1, Delta3, or Delta4) to induce NK cell development from human hematopoietic progenitor cells (HPCs). CD34(+) HPCs were cultured with OP9 stromal cell lines transduced with 1 of the Notch ligands or with OP9 stromal cells alone, in the presence of IL-7, Flt3L, and IL-15. Differentiation and expansion of CD56(+)CD3(-) cells were greatly accelerated in the presence of Jagged2, Delta-1, or Delta-4, versus culture in the absence of ligand or in the presence of Jagged1 or Delta3. At 4 weeks, cultures containing Jagged2, Delta1, or Delta4 contained 80% to 90% NK cells, with the remaining cells being CD33(+) myelogenous cells. Notch-induced NK (N-NK) cells resembled CD56(bright) NK cells in that they were CD16(-), CD94(-), CD117(+), and killer immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIR(-)). They also expressed NKp30, NKp44, NKp46, 2B4, and DNAM-1, with partial expression of NKG2D. The N-NK cells displayed cytotoxic activity against the K562 and RPMI-8226 cell lines, at levels similar to activated peripheral blood (PB) NK cells, although killing of Daudi cells was not present. N-NK cells were also capable of interferon (IFN)-gamma secretion. Thus, Notch ligands have differential ability to induce and expand immature, but functional, NK cells from CD34(+) HPCs. The use of Notch ligands to generate functional NK cells in vitro may be significant for cellular therapy purposes.

Dendritic cells support the in vivo development and maintenance of NK cells via IL-15 trans-presentation

IL-15 is a key component that regulates the development and homeostasis of NK cells and is delivered through a mechanism termed trans-presentation. During development, multiple events must proceed to generate a functional mature population of NK cells that are vital for tumor and viral immunity. Nevertheless, how IL-15 regulates these various events and more importantly what cells provide IL-15 to NK cells to drive these events is unclear. It is known dendritic cells (DC) can activate NK cells via IL-15 trans-presentation; however, the ability of DC to use IL-15 trans-presentation to promote the development and homeostatic maintenance of NK cell has not been established. In this current study, we show that IL-15 trans-presentation solely by CD11c(+) cells assists the in vivo development and maintenance of NK cells. More specifically, DC-mediated IL-15 trans-presentation drove the differentiation of NK cells, which included the up-regulation of the activating and inhibitory Ly49 receptors. Although these cells did not harbor a mature CD11b(high) phenotype, they were capable of degranulating and producing IFN-gamma upon stimulation similar to wild-type NK cells. In addition, DC facilitated the survival of mature NK cells via IL-15 trans-presentation in the periphery. Thus, an additional role for NK-DC interactions has been identified whereby DC support the developmental and homeostatic niche of NK cells.

Interleukin-21 induces the differentiation of human umbilical cord blood CD34-lineage- cells into pseudomature lytic NK cells

Background

Umbilical cord blood (UCB) is enriched with transplantable CD34⁺ cells. In addition to CD34-expressing haematopoietic stem cells (HSC), human UCB contains a rare population of CD34^-lineage^- cells endowed with the ability to differentiate along the T/NK pathway in response to interleukin (IL)-15 and a stromal cell support. IL-21 is a crucial regulator of NK cell function, whose influence on IL-15-induced differentiation of CD34^-lineage^- cells has not been investigated previously. The present study was designed and conducted to address whether IL-21 might replace the stromal cell requirements and foster the IL-15-induced NK differentiation of human UCB CD34^-lineage^- cells.

Results

CD34^-lineage^- cells were maintained in liquid culture with Flt3-L and SCF, with the addition of IL-15 and IL-21, either alone or in combination. Cultures were established in the absence of feeder cells or serum supplementation. Cytokine-treated cells were used to evaluate cell surface phenotype, expression of molecular determinants of lymphoid/NK cell differentiation, secretion of IFN-γ, GM-CSF, TNF-α and CCL3/MIP-1α, and cytolytic activity against NK-sensitive tumour cell targets. CD34^-lineage^- cells proliferated vigorously in response to IL-15 and IL-21 but not to IL-21 alone, and up-regulated phosphorylated Stat1 and Stat3 proteins. CD34^-lineage^- cells expanded by IL-21 in combination with IL-15 acquired lymphoid morphology and killer-cell immunoglobulin-like receptor (KIR)^-CD56⁺CD16^-/+ phenotype, consistent with pseudo-mature NK cells. IL-21/IL-15-differentiated cells expressed high levels of mRNA for Bcl-2, GATA-3 and Id2, a master switch required for NK-cell development, and harboured un-rearranged TCRγ genes. From a functional standpoint, IL-21/IL-15-treated cells secreted copious amounts of IFN-γ, GM-CSF and CCL3/MIP-1α, and expressed cell surface CD107a upon contact with NK-sensitive tumour targets, a measure of exocytosis of NK secretory granules.

Conclusion

This study underpins a novel role for IL-21 in the differentiation of pseudo-mature lytic NK cells in a synergistic context with IL-15, and identifies a potential strategy to expand functional NK cells for immunotherapy.

Murine endometrial and decidual NK1.1+ natural killer cells display a B220+CD11c+ cell surface phenotype

Uterine natural killer (uNK) cells accumulate at the maternal-fetal interface during gestation and are thought to have an important role during pregnancy in both mice and humans. While the cell surface phenotype of human uNK cells is increasingly well defined, less is known regarding the cell surface expression profile of murine uNK cells both before and during gestation. Herein, we demonstrate that murine NK1.1(+) (KLRB1C) endometrial NK (eNK) cells, derived from virgin mice, and NK1.1(+) decidual NK (dNK) cells, obtained from pregnant mice, belong to the B220(+) (PTPRC) CD11c(+) (ITGAX) subset of NK cells. While B220 expression was low on NK1.1(+) eNK cells, it was increased on a subset of NK1.1(+) dNK cells at Embryonic Day 10.5. Endometrial NK and dNK cells also differed somewhat in their expression patterns of two activation markers, namely, CD69 and inducible costimulator (ICOS). The eNK cells acquired a B220(hi)ICOS(+) dNK cell surface phenotype when cultured in vitro in the presence of uterine cells and murine interleukin 15. Thus, the cell surface profiles generated for both NK1.1(+) eNK cells and dNK cells demonstrate that they belong to the recently described B220(+)CD11c(+) subset of NK cells, which are potent cytokine producers.

Unique receptor repertoire in mouse uterine NK cells

Uterine NK (uNK) cells are a prominent feature of the uterine mucosa and regulate placentation. NK cell activity is regulated by a balance of activating and inhibitory receptors, however the receptor repertoire of mouse uNK cells is unknown. We describe herein two distinct subsets of CD3(-)CD122(+) NK cells in the mouse uterus (comprising decidua and mesometrial lymphoid aggregate of pregnancy) at mid-gestation: a small subset indistinguishable from peripheral NK cells, and a larger subset that expresses NKp46 and Ly49 receptors, but not NK1.1 or DX5. This larger subset reacts with Dolichus biflores agglutinin, a marker of uNK cells in the mouse, and is adjacent to the invading trophoblast. By multiparametric analysis we show that the phenotype of uNK cells is unique and unprecedented in terms of adhesion, activation, and MHC binding potential. Thus, the Ly49 repertoire and the expression of other differentiation markers strikingly distinguish uNK cells from peripheral NK cells, suggesting that a selection process shapes the receptor repertoire of mouse uNK cells.

Tumor growth decreases NK and B cells as well as common lymphoid progenitor

BACKGROUND

It is well established that chronic tumor growth results in functional inactivation of T cells and NK cells. It is less clear, however, whether lymphopoeisis is affected by tumor growth.

PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

In our efforts of analyzing the impact of tumor growth on NK cell development, we observed a major reduction of NK cell numbers in mice bearing multiple lineages of tumor cells. The decrease in NK cell numbers was not due to increased apoptosis or decreased proliferation in the NK compartment. In addition, transgenic expression of IL-15 also failed to rescue the defective production of NK cells. Our systematic characterization of lymphopoeisis in tumor-bearing mice indicated that the number of the common lymphoid progenitor was significantly reduced in tumor-bearing mice. The number of B cells also decreased substantially in tumor bearing mice.

CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE

Our data reveal a novel mechanism for tumor evasion of host immunity and suggest a new interpretation for the altered myeloid and lymphoid ratio in tumor bearing hosts.

Extrinsic and intrinsic regulation of early natural killer cell development

Natural killer (NK) cells are lymphocytes that play a critical role in both adaptive and innate immune responses. These cells develop from multipotent progenitors in the embryonic thymus and neonatal or adult bone marrow and recent evidence suggests that a subset of these cells may develop in the thymus. Thymus- and bone marrow-derived NK cells have unique phenotypes and functional abilities supporting the hypothesis that the microenvironment dictates the outcome of NK cell development. A detailed understanding of the mechanisms controlling this developmental program will be required to determine how alterations in NK cell development lead to disease and to determine how to harness this developmental program for therapeutic purposes. In this review, we discuss some of the known extrinsic stromal-cell derived factors and cell intrinsic transcription factors that function in guiding NK cell development.

Measurement of natural killer cell progenitor activity in culture

Natural killer cells are morphologically related to and have progenitors in common with B and T lymphocytes. In this unit, protocols describe how to induce natural killer cell differentiation from prolymphocytes. Since NK cell differentiation cultures also support B cell differentiation, this protocol is extremely useful for seeking the B and NK cell branch point in their differentiation pathway.

Spleen but not tumor infiltration by dendritic and T cells is increased by intravenous adenovirus-Flt3 ligand injection

Dendritic cell (DC) expansion is regulated by the hematopoietic growth factor fms-like tyrosine kinase 3 ligand (Flt3L). DCs are critical to the control of tumor growth and metastasis, and there is a positive correlation between intratumoral DC infiltration and clinical outcome. In this report, we first demonstrate that single intravenous (i.v.) injections of adenovirus (Adv)-Flt3L significantly increased splenic dendritic, B, T and natural killer (NK) cell numbers in both normal and mammary tumor-bearing mice. In contrast, the numbers of DCs and T cells infiltrating the tumors were not increased. Consistent with the minimal effect on immune cell infiltration, i.v. Adv-Flt3L injections had no therapeutic activity against orthotopic mammary tumors. In addition, we noted tumor and Adv-Flt3L expansion of Gr1(+)CD11b(+) immature myeloid suppressor cells (IMSCs), which may inhibit the therapeutic efficacy of Adv-Flt3L-expanded DCs.

Human natural killer cell development

Our understanding of human natural killer (NK) cell development lags far behind that of human B- or T-cell development. Much of our recent knowledge of this incomplete picture comes from experimental animal models that have aided in identifying fundamental in vivo processes, including those controlling NK cell homeostasis, self-tolerance, and the generation of a diverse NK cell repertoire. However, it has been difficult to fully understand the mechanistic details of NK cell development in humans, primarily because the in vivo cellular intermediates and microenvironments of this developmental pathway have remained elusive. Although there is general consensus that NK cell development occurs primarily within the bone marrow (BM), recent data implicate secondary lymphoid tissues as principal sites of NK cell development in humans. The strongest evidence stems from the observation that the newly described stages of human NK cell development are naturally and selectively enriched within lymph nodes and tonsils compared with blood and BM. In the current review, we provide an overview of these recent findings and discuss these in the context of existing tenets in the field of lymphocyte development.

Bone marrow versus thymic pathways of natural killer cell development

Understanding natural killer (NK) cell developmental pathways is crucial for harnessing the potential therapeutic benefits of this specialized lymphocyte subset. The bone marrow (BM) plays a major role in NK cell development, providing the appropriate environmental cues for NK cell commitment and subsequent NK cell differentiation. Nevertheless, the molecular signals provided in this context remain enigmatic. It is widely assumed that BM seeds the periphery with NK cells. However, the precise origins of NK cells found in lymphoid organs and tissues are not defined. Recently, we found that thymic NK cells bear molecular markers and functional attributes that distinguish them from most peripheral NK cells. We find that NK cells are actively exported from the thymus to the periphery, suggesting that thymus-derived NK cells may have unique roles both intrathymically and in secondary lymphoid organs. Here we compare the properties of thymic NK cells with properties of other NK cell subsets that have been identified in the mouse. We propose that heterogeneity in NK cell function can be achieved through distinct thymic and bone marrow pathways of NK cell development.

T-cell development, doing it in a dish

The thymus provides a unique environment for the development of T lymphocytes from bone marrow-derived progenitor cells. Several environmental factors have been identified that influence the development of T cells in the thymus. In particular, the Notch pathway has emerged as critical for the induction of T-lineage commitment and differentiation. Until recently, however, the precise nature of the thymus-derived signals that drive T-cell development were unclear, and the only reliable in vitro culture system that supported T-cell differentiation required the use of thymus organ cultures. Here, we discuss recent advances in the identification of critical Notch receptor ligands that have facilitated the development of a simple in vitro model for the differentiation of T cells 'in a dish', providing an alternate approach for studying T lymphopoiesis.

Positive and negative regulation of Natural Killer cells: therapeutic implications

Natural Killer (NK) cells can mediate numerous anti-tumor and anti-viral effector functions as well as play important immunoregulatory roles in various disease states. Promoting the ability of NK cells to respond in an immunotherapeutic setting has often been sought by the addition of NK cell-stimulating factors. However, such therapies are often found to be insufficient, which may in part be due to the presence of inhibitory influences on the NK cell. NK cells can respond to a plethora of cytokines which are generated by numerous cell types and these interactions can markedly affect NK cell survival and activity. NK cells also possess multiple activating and inhibiting receptors which can alter their function. Whether the NK cell will become activated or not can depend on a complex balance of activating and inhibitory signals received by the cell and modulation of these signals may shift the balance on NK activation. This review discusses the various activating and inhibitory stimuli which can act on NK cells, and suggests that future NK cell-based therapies consider not only activating stimuli but also removal of possible inhibitory elements which could prevent optimal NK cell function and/or survival.

Natural killer cell developmental pathways: a question of balance

NK cells sit at the crossroads of innate and adaptive immunity and help coordinate tumor immunosurveillance and the immune response against pathogens. Balancing signals to NK cell precursors is crucial for their early development, when transcription factors compete to specify the different lymphocyte subsets. Despite an elaborate schema for NK cell development and differentiation, several major issues remain to be addressed, such as identifying the sites for NK cell maturation and defining the peripheral NK cell niche.

Evidence for discrete stages of human natural killer cell differentiation in vivo

Human natural killer (NK) cells originate from CD34(+) hematopoietic progenitor cells, but the discrete stages of NK cell differentiation in vivo have not been elucidated. We identify and functionally characterize, from human lymph nodes and tonsils, four NK cell developmental intermediates spanning the continuum of differentiation from a CD34(+) NK cell progenitor to a functionally mature NK cell. Analyses of each intermediate stage for CD34, CD117, and CD94 cell surface expression, lineage differentiation potentials, capacity for cytokine production and natural cytotoxicity, and ETS-1, GATA-3, and T-BET expression provide evidence for a new model of human NK cell differentiation in secondary lymphoid tissues.

Diverse functions of IL-2, IL-15, and IL-7 in lymphoid homeostasis

IL-2, IL-15, and IL-7 are cytokines that are critical for regulating lymphoid homeostasis. These cytokines stimulate similar responses from lymphocytes in vitro, but play markedly divergent roles in lymphoid biology in vivo. Their distinct physiological functions can be ascribed to distinct signaling pathways initiated by proprietary cytokine receptor chains, differential expression patterns of the cytokines or their receptor chains, and/or signals occurring in distinct physiological contexts. Recently, the discovery of a novel mechanism of cytokine signaling, trans-presentation, has provided further insights into the different ways these cytokines function. Trans-presentation also raises several novel cell biological and cellular implications concerning how cytokines support lymphoid homeostasis.

Stage-dependent gene expression profiles during natural killer cell development

Natural killer (NK) cells develop from hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) in the bone marrow. To understand the molecular regulation of NK cell development, serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE) was applied to HSCs, NK precursor (pNK) cells, and mature NK cells (mNK) cultured without or with OP9 stromal cells. From 170,464 total individual tags from four SAGE libraries, 35,385 unique genes were identified. A set of genes was expressed in a stage-specific manner: 15 genes in HSCs, 30 genes in pNK cells, and 27 genes in mNK cells. Among them, lipoprotein lipase induced NK cell maturation and cytotoxic activity. Identification of genome-wide profiles of gene expression in different stages of NK cell development affords us a fundamental basis for defining the molecular network during NK cell development.

Immunotherapy in multiple myeloma - possibility or probability?

In a small number of patients with multiple myeloma (MM), long-term disease-free survival has been achieved by harnessing the immune phenomenon, 'graft-versus-tumour' effect, induced by allogeneic haemopoietic stem cell transplantation. This has prompted many investigators to examine ways in which a patient's own immune system can be more effectively directed against their disease, with the ultimate aim of tumour eradication. In this review we assess the current understanding of immunobiology in MM, and how the different components of the immune system, such as dendritic cells, T cells and natural killer cells, may be harnessed using in-vitro and in-vivo priming techniques. We look at the clinical immunotherapy trials reported to date and whether, in light of the current information, immunotherapy for MM is an achievable goal.

A human CD34(+) subset resides in lymph nodes and differentiates into CD56bright natural killer cells

In humans, T cells differentiate in thymus and B cells develop in bone marrow (BM), but the natural killer (NK) precursor cell(s) and site(s) of NK development are unclear. The CD56bright NK subset predominates in lymph nodes (LN) and produces abundant cytokines compared to the cytolytic CD56dim NK cell that predominates in blood. Here, we identify a novel CD34dimCD45RA(+) hematopoietic precursor cell (HPC) that is integrin alpha4beta7bright. CD34dimCD45RA(+)beta7bright HPCs constitute <1% of BM CD34(+) HPCs and approximately 6% of blood CD34(+) HPCs, but >95% of LN CD34(+) HPCs. They reside in the parafollicular T cell regions of LN with CD56bright NK cells, and when stimulated by IL-15, IL-2, or activated LN T cells, they become CD56bright NK cells. The data identify a new NK precursor and support a model of human NK development in which BM-derived CD34dimCD45RA(+)beta7bright HPCs reside in LN where endogenous cytokines drive their differentiation to CD56bright NK cells in vivo.

The role of natural killer cells in tumor control—effectors and regulators of adaptive immunity

Natural killer (NK) cells are the primary effector cells of the innate immune system and have a well-established role in tumor rejection in a variety of spontaneous and induced cancer models. NK cell function is regulated by a complex balance of inhibitory and activating signals that allow them to selectively target and kill cells that display an abnormal pattern of cell surface molecules, while leaving normal healthy cells unharmed. In this review we discuss NK cell function, the role of NK cells in cancer therapies, the emerging concept of bi-directional cross-talk between NK cells and dendritic cells, and the implications of these interactions for tumor immunotherapy.

Peripheral NK cell phenotypes: multiple changing of faces of an adapting, developing cell

We have defined the existence of developmental relationships among human peripheral NK cells with distinct phenotypic and functional characteristics. These findings closely parallel the changes that occur in vivo during NK cell development, and in vitro in experimental culture systems supporting NK cell generation from hematopoietic progenitors. These new insights provide a simplified framework to understand NK cell immunobiology and the cellular bases for their roles in innate immunity, initiation and maintenance of immune responses via regulation of adaptive and accessory cell functions, and immune pathologies.

Interleukin-2, Interleukin-15, and Their Roles in Human Natural Killer Cells

Natural killer (NK) cells are CD56+CD3- large granular lymphocytes that constitute a key component of the human innate immune response. In addition to their potent cytolytic activity, NK cells elaborate a host of immunoregulatory cytokines and chemokines that play a crucial role in pathogen clearance. Furthermore, interactions between NK and other immune cells are implicated in triggering the adaptive, or antigen-specific, immune response. Interleukin-2 (IL-2) and IL-15 are two distinct cytokines with partially overlapping properties that are implicated in the development, homeostasis, and function of NK cells. This review examines the pervasive effects of IL-2 and IL-15 on NK cell biology, with an emphasis on recent discoveries and lingering challenges in the field.

Activation of natural killer cells: underlying molecular mechanisms revealed

Natural killer (NK) cells, the third major lymphocyte population, are important effector cells against certain infections and tumours. They have also been implicated as a link between innate and adaptive immune responses. In recent years, much attention has been paid to the NK cell inhibitory receptors and their interaction with major histocompatibility complex class I molecules on target cells. This review summarizes recent findings on regulation of NK cell activity with an emphasis on NK cell stimulatory receptors. A particular emphasis is devoted to the receptor NKG2D that is expressed on all NK cells.

The dynamic life of natural killer cells

Natural killer (NK) cells play important roles in immunological processes, including early defense against viral infections. This review provides an overview of the dynamic in vivo life of NK cells from their development in the bone marrow to their mature peripheral responses and their ultimate demise, with particular emphasis on mouse NK cells and viral infections.

Murine viral hepatitis involves NK cell depletion associated with virus-induced apoptosis

Mouse hepatitis virus type 3 (MHV3), a coronavirus, is an excellent animal model for the study of immunological disorders related to acute and chronic hepatitis. In this study, we have verified if the fulminant hepatitis induced by MHV3 could be related to an impairment of innate immunity. Groups of three C57BL/6 mice were infected with the pathogenic L2-MHV3 or attenuated YAC-MHV3 viruses, and the natural killer (NK) cell populations from liver, spleen and bone marrow were analysed. The percentage of intrahepatic NK1.1(+)T cell receptor (TCR)- cells did not increase while NK1.1(+)TCR(inter) cells decreased in both L2-MHV3- and YAC-MHV3-infected mice. Concurrently, splenic and myeloid NK1.1+ cells decreased in L2-MHV3-infected mice. However, the cytotoxic activity of NK cells increased in liver and decreased in bone marrow from pathogenic L2-MHV3-infected mice while no modification was detected in YAC-MHV3-infected mice. Flow cytometric analysis revealed that both normal and larger splenic or myeloid NK cells decreased more in pathogenic L2-MHV3-infected mice than in attenuated YAC-MHV3-infected mice. In vitro viral infections of interleukin (IL)-15-stimulated lymphoid cells from liver and bone marrow revealed that L2-MHV3 induced higher decreases in cell viability of NK1.1+ cells than the YAC-MHV3 variant. The NK cell decreases were due to the viral permissivity leading to cytopathic effects characterized by cell rounding, syncytia formation and apoptosis. Larger NK+ syncytia were observed in L2-MHV3-infected cells than in YAC-MHV3-infected cells. These results suggest that NK cell production is impaired by viral infection favouring fulminant hepatitis.

Murine hepatocyte cell lines promote expansion and differentiation of NK cells from stem cell precursors

While fetal liver is a major hematopoietic organ, normal adult liver provides a suitable microenvironment for a variety of immune cells and, in several pathological conditions, may become a site of extramedullary hematopoiesis. The direct influence of hepatocytes on hematopoietic cell differentiation is poorly understood. We have previously reported that the Met murine hepatocyte (MMH) untransformed hepatocytic lines retain several morphological and functional features of hepatocytes in vivo and are able to support the survival, self-renewal, and differentiation of hematopoietic precursors in a cell-cell contact system. Here we report the effects of soluble factors released by MMH lines on bone marrow-derived cells. Lymphohematopoietic cells were cultured in two different cell contact-free systems: transwell inserts on MMH feeder layers, and MMH conditioned medium (MMH-CM). Both culture systems were able to promote a substantial expansion of bone marrow-derived cells and their differentiation to natural killer (NK) cells that express the NK1.1 and U5A2-13 markers. Purified hematopoietic stem cells (Sca-1+Lin-), either plated as a bulk population or as single cells, were also able to differentiate into NK cells, when cultured in MMH-CM; thus, soluble factors secreted by MMH lines promote the expansion and differentiation of NK precursor cells. MMH-CM-derived NK cells are functionally active; stimulation by interleukin (IL)-12 together with IL-18 was required to induce interferon-gamma (IFNgamma) expression and to enhance their cytotoxic activity. In conclusion, our findings may imply a direct role of hepatocytes in NK cell development, and the system we have used may provide a tool for studying the molecular mechanisms of NK cell differentiation.

2B4 Acts As a Non–Major Histocompatibility Complex Binding Inhibitory Receptor on Mouse Natural Killer Cells

Natural killer (NK) cells are critical in the immune response to tumor cells, virally infected cells, and bone marrow allografts. 2B4 (CD244) is expressed on all NK cells and the ligand for 2B4, CD48, is expressed on hematopoietic cells. Cross-linking 2B4 on NK cells with anti-2B4 monoclonal antibody leads to NK cell activation in vitro. Therefore, 2B4 is considered to be an activating receptor. Surprisingly, we have found, using antibody-blocking and 2B4-deficient NK cells, that NK lysis of CD48⁺ tumor and allogeneic targets is inhibited by 2B4 ligation. Interferon γ production by NK cells is also inhibited. Using a peritoneal tumor clearance assay, it was found that 2B4^−/− mice have increased clearance of CD48⁺ tumor cells in vivo. Retroviral transduction of 2B4 was sufficient to restore inhibition in 2B4^−/− primary NK cells. It was found that although mature NK cells express SH2D1A, in vitro–derived NK cells do not. However, both populations are inhibited by 2B4 ligation. This indicates that 2B4 inhibitory signaling occurs regardless of the presence of SH2D1A. These findings reveal a novel role for 2B4 as a non–major histocompatibility complex binding negative regulator of NK cells.

Distinct cell types control lymphoid subset development by means of IL-15 and IL-15 receptor alpha expression

IL-15 and the IL-15 receptor (IL-15R)alpha chain are essential for normal development of naive CD8 T cells, intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes (IEL), and natural killer (NK)/NK/T cells. However, whether IL-15R alpha expression by these subsets is necessary for their production and which cell type needs to produce IL-15 to drive development are unknown. We analyzed the requirements for IL-15 and IL-15R alpha expression by bone marrow-derived or parenchymal cells for mediating lymphocyte subset development. Naive CD8 T cell development required IL-15R alpha expression by both bone marrow-derived and parenchymal cells, whereas memory-phenotype CD8 T cells required IL-15R alpha expression only by hematopoietic cells. In contrast and surprisingly, the development of IEL subsets, particularly CD8 alpha alpha Thy1(-)V gamma 5(+) T cell antigen receptor gamma delta and the CD8 alpha alpha Thy1(-) T cell antigen receptor alpha beta IEL populations, depended completely on parenchymal cell expression of IL-15R alpha and IL-15 but not IL-15R beta. In the case of NK and NK/T cell generation and maturation, expression of IL-15 and IL-15R alpha by both parenchymal and hematopoietic cells was important, although the latter played the greatest role. These results demonstrated dichotomous mechanisms by which IL-15 regulated lymphoid development, interacting with distinct cell types depending on the developmental pathway.

Surface translocation of pactolus is induced by cell activation and death, but is not required for neutrophil migration and function

Pactolus is a cell surface protein expressed by murine neutrophils. Pactolus is similar to the beta integrins, except it lacks a functional metal ion-dependent adhesion site domain and is expressed without an alpha-chain partner. The majority of the Pactolus protein is held within the cell in dense granules in a highly glycosylated form. This intracellular form of Pactolus can be released to the cell surface following inflammatory activation or ligation of Pactolus on the cell surface. In addition, intracellular Pactolus translocates to the neutrophil surface following induction of apoptosis. Neutrophil activation studies suggest that Pactolus does not serve as an activating or phagocytic receptor for the neutrophil. To further define the function of Pactolus, a Pactolus-null mouse was generated. Pactolus-deficient animals mature appropriately and possess normal numbers of neutrophils, display appropriate migration into sites of inflammation, and combat introduced infections efficiently. These data suggest that Pactolus does not function as a neutrophil phagocytic or adhesion receptor, but may instead serve as a sugar-bearing ligand for lectin recognition by other cells.

Natural killer lymphocytes: biology, development, and function

Natural killer (NK) lymphocytes represent the first line of defense against virally infected cells and tumor cells. The role of NK cells in immune responses has been markedly explored, mainly due to the identification of NK cell receptors and their ligands, but also through the analysis of mechanisms underlying the effects of various cytokines on NK cell development and function. A population of lymphocytes that shares function and receptors with NK cells is represented by natural killer T (NKT) cells. NKT lymphocytes are regulators of both innate and adaptive immune responses, but have also been reported to function as effector antitumor cells. The marked progress in our understanding of the biology, development, and function of NK/NKT cells has provided the basis for their potential application in tumor clinical trials.

IL-15 and IL-2 oppositely regulate expression of the chemokine receptor CX3CR1

The chemokine receptor CX3CR1 (CX3C chemokine receptor 1) is expressed in mouse blood on natural killer (NK) cells and on monocytes. Because interleukin-15 (IL-15) is an essential cytokine for NK cell development and maintenance, we hypothesized that it may induce CX3CR1 expression on this cell type. In contrast, we found that in primary mouse bone marrow-derived NK cells IL-15 specifically inhibited CX3CR1 protein and mRNA accumulation, whereas the related cytokine IL-2 did not inhibit but instead increased CX3CR1 expression. Consistent with this finding, intravenous injection of a single dose of recombinant IL-15 into C57BL/6 mice decreased steady-state CX3CR1 levels 24 hours after injection in freshly isolated peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs), splenocytes, and bone marrow cells, and treatment of mouse PBMCs with IL-15 in vitro inhibited CX3CL1 (ligand for CX3CR1)-induced chemotaxis. These data suggest that IL-15 may be a negative regulator of innate immunity by inhibiting CX3CR1 expression. These data also suggest that IL-15 inhibition of CX3CR1 may subvert potential cell immunotherapy strategies in which IL-15 is used to expand NK cell populations in vivo or ex vivo. Finally, our results provide additional evidence for differential signaling by IL-2 and IL-15, despite usage of common beta gamma c receptor chains.

Differential Roles for IL-15R α-Chain in NK Cell Development and Ly-49 Induction

IL-15Ralpha-deficient (IL-15Ralpha(-/-)) mice lack NK cells. However, when bone marrow (BM) progenitors from IL-15Ralpha(-/-) mice were cultured with IL-7, stem cell factor and flt3 ligand, followed by IL-15, they were able to differentiate into functional NK cells, indicating that IL-15Ralpha is not critical for NK cell development. Whereas NK cells generated in vitro from IL-15Ralpha(-/-) BM progenitors expressed CD94/NKG2, they failed to express Ly-49 receptors. In keeping with this, when IL-15Ralpha(-/-) BM cells were transferred into wild type recipients, they gave rise to NK cells in vivo, but with greatly reduced expression of Ly-49 receptors. Furthermore, the small numbers of NK cells found in IL-15(-/-) as well as IL-15Ralpha(-/-) but not flt3 ligand(-/-) mice expressed much lower levels of Ly-49 receptors than those from wild type mice. These results indicate a novel role for IL-15Ralpha-chain in Ly-49 induction on developing NK cells.

Cytokine requirements for the growth and development of mouse NK cells in vitro

Natural killer (NK) cells arise from immature progenitors present in fetal tissues and adult bone marrow, but the factors responsible for driving the proliferation and differentiation of these progenitors are poorly understood. Mouse NK cells had previously been thought not to express interleukin (IL)-2Ralpha chains, but we show here that immature and mature mouse NK cells express IL-2Ralpha chain mRNA and that low levels of IL-2Ralpha chains can be detected on the surface of immature and mature NK cells provided they are cultured in the absence of IL-2. Despite their potential expression of high-affinity IL-2 receptors, immature NK cells only proliferate if IL-2 is present at extremely high concentrations. Surprisingly, IL-15 can also only support the growth of immature NK cells at high, presumably nonphysiological concentrations. Although NK cells express mRNA for the high-affinity IL-15Ralpha chain, they also express a variety of alternately spliced transcripts whose protein products could potentially disrupt signaling through IL-15 receptors. The requirement for high concentrations of IL-2 and IL-15 suggests that if these cytokines play any role in the proliferative expansion of NK cells in vivo, they act indirectly via other cells or in cooperation with other factors. In support of the latter possibility, we report that the recently described cytokine IL-21 can markedly enhance the proliferation of immature (and mature) NK cells in the presence of doses of IL-2 and IL-15 that by themselves have little growth-promoting activity.

Ly49E expression points toward overlapping, but distinct, natural killer (NK) cell differentiation kinetics and potential of fetal versus adult lymphoid progenitors

Using a new antibody, we found previously that contrary to adult natural killer (NK) cells, fetal NK cells have a unique phenotype, as they exclusively express Ly49E. This can be explained by an intrinsic different NK differentiation potential of fetal versus adult lymphoid progenitors, by immaturity of fetal NK cells or by instability of Ly49E expression. Here, we show that adult progenitor cells were still capable of differentiating into Ly49E-expressing NK cells but at a much lower frequency. Surprisingly, Ly49E expression in vitro did not require stromal cells. Kinetic analysis in vivo showed that Ly49E was expressed early, together with CD94/NKG2 and Ly49G2, followed by Ly49C, and finally Ly49D. Transfer of sorted Ly49E-positive fetal NK cells showed stable Ly49E expression, and later, part of these cells up-regulated other Ly49 members. These data indicate that although there are intrinsic differences, there is no strict fetal and adult wave of NK cell differentiation.