Combination induction therapy with monoclonal antibodies specific for CD80, CD86, and CD154 in nonhuman primate renal transplantation

MDA5 with Complete CARD2 Region Inhibits the Early Replication of H9N2 AIV and Enhances the Immune Response during Vaccination

Chicken melanoma differentiation-associated gene 5 (MDA5) is a member of the RLRs family that recognizes the viral RNAs invading cells and activates downstream interferon regulatory pathways, thereby inhibiting viral replication. The caspase activation and recruitment domain (CARD) is the most important region in MDA5 protein. However, the antiviral and immune enhancement of MDA5 with the CARD region remains unclear. In this study, two truncated MDA5 genes with different CARD regions, namely MDA5-1 with CARD1 plus partial CARD2 domain and MDA5-2 with CARD1 plus complete CARD2 domain, were cloned via reverse transcription PCR and ligated into plasmid Flag-N vector to be Flag-MDA5-1 and Flag-MDA5-2 plasmids. DF-1 cells were transfected with two plasmids for 24 h and then inoculated with H9N2 virus (0.1 MOI) for 6 h to detect the levels of IFN-β, PKR, MAVS, and viral HA, NA, and NS proteins expression. The results showed that MDA5-1 and MDA5-2 increased the expression of IFN-β and PKR, activated the downstream molecule MAVS production, and inhibited the expression of HA, NA, and NS proteins. The knockdown of MDA5 genes confirmed that MDA5-2 had a stronger antiviral effect than that of MDA5-1. Furthermore, the recombinant proteins MDA5-1 and MDA5-2 were combined with H9N2 inactivated vaccine to immunize SPF chickens subcutaneously injected in the neck three times. The immune response of the immunized chicken was investigated. It was observed that the antibody titers and expressions of immune-related molecules from the chicken immunized with MDA5-1 and MDA5-2 group were increased, in which the inducing function of MDA5-2 groups was the highest among all immunization groups. These results suggested that the truncated MDA5 recombinant proteins with complete CARD2 region could play vital roles in antiviral and immune enhancement. This study provides important material for the further study of the immunoregulatory function and clinical applications of MDA5 protein.

The Inhibition of CD40/CD154 Costimulatory Signaling in the Prevention of Renal Transplant Rejection in Nonhuman Primates: A Systematic Review and Meta Analysis

The prevention of allograft transplant rejection by inhibition of the CD40/CD40L costimulatory pathway has been described in several species. We searched pubmed for studies reporting the prevention of kidney transplant rejection in nonhuman primates utilizing either anti CD40 or anti CD40L (CD154) treatment. Inclusion of data required treatment with anti CD40 or anti CD154 as monotherapy treatment arms, full text available, studies conducted in nonhuman primate species, the transplant was renal transplantation, sufficient duration of treatment to assess long term rejection, and the reporting of individual graft survival or survival duration. Eleven publications were included in the study. Rejection free survival was calculated using the Kaplan-Meier (KM) life test methods to estimate the survival functions. The 95% CI for the medians was also calculated. A log-rank test was used to test the equality of the survival curves between control and treatment arms (CD40 and CD154). The hazard ratio for CD154 compared to CD40 and 95% CI was calculated using a Cox proportional-hazards model including treatment as the covariate to assess the magnitude of the treatment effect. Both anti CD40 and anti CD154 treatments prevented acute and long term graft rejection. The median (95% CI) rejection free survival was 131 days (84,169 days) in the anti CD40 treated animals and 352 days (173,710 days) in the anti CD154 treated animals. Median survival in the untreated animals was 6 days. The inhibition of transplant rejection was more durable in the anti CD154 group compared to the anti CD40 group after cessation of treatment. The median (95% CI) rejection free survival after cessation of treatment was 60 days (21,80 days) in the anti CD40 treated animals and 230 days (84,552 days) in the anti CD154 treated animals.

Secondary lymphoid tissue and costimulation-blockade resistant rejection: A nonhuman primate renal transplant study

Naïve T cell activation requires antigen presentation combined with costimulation through CD28, both of which optimally occur in secondary lymphoid tissues such as lymph nodes and the spleen. Belatacept impairs CD28 costimulation by binding its ligands, CD80 and CD86, and in doing so, impairs de novo alloimmune responses. However, in most patients belatacept is ineffective in preventing allograft rejection when used as a monotherapy, and adjuvant therapy is required for control of costimulation-blockade resistant rejection (CoBRR). In rodent models, impaired access to secondary lymphoid tissues has been demonstrated to reduce alloimmune responses to vascularized allografts. Here we show that surgical maneuvers, lymphatic ligation, and splenectomy, designed to anatomically limit access to secondary lymphoid tissues, control CoBRR and facilitate belatacept monotherapy in a nonhuman primate model of kidney transplantation without adjuvant immunotherapy. We further demonstrate that animals sustained on belatacept monotherapy progressively develop an increasingly naïve T and B cell repertoire, an effect that is accelerated by splenectomy and lost at the time of belatacept withdrawal and rejection. These pilot data inform the role of secondary lymphoid tissues on the development of CoBRR and the use of costimulation molecule-focused therapies.

Addition of Anti-CD40 Monoclonal Antibody to Nonmyeloablative Conditioning With Belatacept Abrogated Allograft Tolerance Despite Induction of Mixed Chimerism

BACKGROUND

We recently reported anti-CD40 monoclonal antibody and rapamycin (aCD40/rapa) to be a reliable, nontoxic, immunosuppressive regimen for combined islet and kidney transplantation (CIKTx) in nonhuman primates. In the current study, we attempted to induce allograft tolerance through the mixed chimerism approach using a conditioning regimen with aCD40 and belatacept (Bela).

METHODS

Five CIKTx or kidney transplant alone recipients were treated with aCD40/rapa for 4 months. All recipients then received a conditioning regimen including horse antithymocyte globulin and aCD40/Bela. The results were compared with previous reports of recipients treated with Bela-based regimens.

RESULTS

All 3 CIKTx recipients developed mixed chimerism, which was significantly superior to that observed in the previous Bela-based studies. Nevertheless, all CIKTx recipients in this study lost their islet and renal allografts as a result of cellular and humoral rejection on days 140, 89, and 84. The 2 kidney transplant-alone recipients were treated with the same conditioning regimen and suffered rejection on days 127 and 116, despite the development of excellent chimerism. B lymphocyte reconstitution dominated by memory phenotypes was associated with early development of donor-specific antibodies in 4 of 5 recipients. In vitro assays showed no donor-specific regulatory T cell expansion, which has been consistently observed in tolerant recipients with our mixed chimerism approach.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite displaying excellent immunosuppressive efficacy, costimulatory blockade with anti-CD40 monoclonal antibody (2C10R4) may inhibit the induction of renal or islet allograft tolerance via a mixed chimerism approach.

Development of transplant immunosuppressive agents - considerations in the use of animal models

INTRODUCTION

The development of all immunosuppressant agents to date has involved the experimental use of large and small animal models. Over the last half-century, immunosuppressive drugs have extended the lives of transplant patients worldwide. However, the use of animal models in the development of these drugs is not perfect, and this has brought to light a number of issues including idiosyncratic reactions that are found in animal models but not in humans. The 2006 highly publicized case of the 'elephant man' TGN 1412 drug trial highlights the importance of being cogent of the limitations of animal models. Areas covered: This review covers the utility and limitations of the use of animal models for the development of immunosuppressant agents. This includes both large and small animal models, particularly rodent models in the transplant setting. Expert opinion: The use of animal models represents a critical stage in the development of immunosuppressive drugs. Limitations include physiological differences to humans; this is especially true of immunologically naïve lab rodents with small memory cell populations. Toxic drug levels may differ widely between species. Animal models are also costly and raise ethical concerns. However, there is currently no way to recreate the complex environment of the human immune system purely in vitro.

Belatacept As an Alternative to Calcineurin Inhibitors in Patients with Solid Organ Transplants

The goal of immunosuppression in transplantation has shifted to improving long-term outcomes, reducing drug-induced toxicities while preserving the already excellent short-term outcomes. Long-term gains in solid organ transplantation have been limited at least partly due to the nephrotoxicity and metabolic side effects of calcineurin inhibitors (CNIs). The alloimmune response requires activation of the costimulatory pathway for T cell proliferation and amplification. Belatacept is a molecule that selectively blocks T cell costimulation. In June 2011, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration approved it for maintenance immunosuppression in kidney transplantation based on two open-label, randomized, phase III trials. Since its introduction, belatacept has shown promise in both short- and long-term renal transplant outcomes in several other trials. It exhibits a superior side effect profile compared to CNIs with a comparable efficacy. Across all solid organ transplants, the burden of chronic kidney disease, its associated cardiovascular morbidity, mortality, and inferior patient/allograft survival is a well-documented problem. In this review, we aim to discuss the evidence behind the use of belatacept in solid organ transplants as an effective alternative to CNIs for renal rescue in patients with acute and/or chronic kidney injury.

Renal transplant immunology in the last 20 years: A revolution towards graft and patient survival improvement

To deride the hope of progress is the ultimate fatuity, the last word in poverty of spirit and meanness of mind. There is no need to be dismayed by the fact that we cannot yet envisage a definitive solution of our problems, a resting-place beyond which we need not try to go. -P.B. Medawar, 1969 * Thomas E. Starlz, also known as the Father of Clinical Transplantation, once said that organ transplantation was the supreme exception to the rule that most major advances in medicine spring from discoveries in basic science [Starzl T. The mystique of organ transplantation. J Am Coll Surg 2005 Aug;201(2):160-170]. In fact, the first successful identical-twin kidney transplantation performed by Murray's team in December 1954 (Murray J et al. Renal homotransplantations in identical twins. Surg Forum 1955;6:432-436) was the example of an upside down translation medicine: Human clinical transplantation began and researchers tried to understand the underlying immune response and how to control the powerful rejection pathways through experimental models. In the last 20 years, we have witnessed an amazing progress in the knowledge of immunological mechanisms regarding alloimmune response and an outstanding evolution on the identification and characterization of major and minor histocompatibility antigens. This review presents an historical and clinical perspective of those important advances in kidney transplantation immunology in the last 20 years, which contributed to the improvement in patients' quality of life and the survival of end-stage renal patients. In spite of these significant progresses, some areas still need substantial progress, such as the definition of non-invasive biomarkers for acute rejection; the continuous reduction of immunosuppression; the extension of graft survival, and finally the achievement of real graft tolerance extended to HLA mismatch donor: recipient pairs.

Pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of ASKP1240, a fully human anti-CD40 antibody, in normal and renal transplanted Cynomolgus monkeys

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the serum concentration of ASKP1240 (pharmacokinetics [PK]) and the CD40 occupancy of ASKP1240 (pharmacodynamics [PD]) in normal and renal transplanted Cynomolgus monkeys to clarify the PK/PD relationship.

METHODS

In a 70-day study, two ASKP1240 doses (2 and 5 mg/kg) were evaluated in normal and transplanted monkeys. Full doses were administered during the induction phase, and half doses were administered during the maintenance phase. The PK and PD were assessed using ELISA and FACS assays.

RESULTS

The serum concentration and receptor occupancy of ASKP1240 reached their maximum levels rapidly after the first dose and remained at an almost saturated rate during the induction phase. They then decreased gradually during the maintenance phase in all of the groups. The serum concentration and duration of full receptor occupancy were dose dependent in the normal and transplanted monkeys. On day 70 after therapy with 5 mg/kg ASKP1240, the transplanted monkeys presented a significantly lower occupancy of the CD40 receptors compared with the normal animals (5.5%±14.1% vs. 72.8%±3.4%). The serum concentration of ASKP1240 was also strongly correlated with the occupancy of the ASKP1240 receptors.

CONCLUSION

This study showed strong positive PK/PD relationships in renal transplanted and normal monkeys. The results may thus serve as a guide for optimal dosage and timing of ASKP1240 therapy in clinical trials and will propel the translation of ASKP1240 therapeutics from the bench to preclinical and clinical trials.

Primate models in organ transplantation

Large animal models have long served as the proving grounds for advances in transplantation, bridging the gap between inbred mouse experimentation and human clinical trials. Although a variety of species have been and continue to be used, the emergence of highly targeted biologic- and antibody-based therapies has required models to have a high degree of homology with humans. Thus, the nonhuman primate has become the model of choice in many settings. This article will provide an overview of nonhuman primate models of transplantation. Issues of primate genetics and care will be introduced, and a brief overview of technical aspects for various transplant models will be discussed. Finally, several prominent immunosuppressive and tolerance strategies used in primates will be reviewed.

Gene transfer of human CD40Ig does not prevent rejection in a non-human primate kidney allotransplantation model

BACKGROUND

Blockade of costimulation signaling required for immune response, such as CD40/CD40L and CD28/B7, is a reasonable strategy to prevent rejection and in defined combinations may allow donor specific tolerance. Indeed, in rodents, costimulation blockade with CD28/B7 antagonists or with CD40Ig was able to induce regulatory T cells and transplant tolerance whereas in primates, anti-CD40 antibodies, anti-CD40L antibodies or CTLA4Ig, used as monotherapy, significantly delayed graft rejection.

METHODS

Using an adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector mediated gene transfer of a human CD40Ig fusion protein (hCD40Ig) in primates, we evaluated the capacity of this costimulation blockade molecule interfering with CD40/CD40L signaling in prolonging kidney transplants in cynomolgus monkeys.

RESULTS

This gene transfer strategy allowed for maintaining a plateau of hCD40Ig production within two months and avoided a high-scale production phase of this molecule. Although the hCD40Ig was able to bind efficiently to human and macaque CD40L and high (>200 μg/ml) transgene expression was obtained, no effect on graft survival was observed. In addition, there was no inhibition of humoral response to vaccination. In vitro, hCD40Ig strongly increased mixed lymphocyte reaction, and when compared to the anti-CD40L antibody h5C8, was not as potent to induce complement-dependent cytotoxicity.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest that CD40/CD40L blockade using a non-depleting CD40Ig fusion protein, a therapeutic strategy that showed efficacy in rodents, is not able to modulate the immune response in primates. These data highlight important biological differences between rodent and primate models to evaluate therapeutic strategies at the preclinical level.

CTLA4Ig prevents alloantibody formation following nonhuman primate islet transplantation using the CD40-specific antibody 3A8

Islet transplantation to treat type 1 diabetes has been limited in part by toxicities of current immunosuppression and recipient humoral sensitization. Blockade of the CD28/CD80/86 and CD40/CD154 pathways has shown promise to remedy both these limitations, but translation has been hampered by difficulties in translating CD154-directed therapies. Prior CD40-directed regimens have led to prolonged islet survival, but fail to prevent humoral allosensitization. We therefore evaluated the addition of CTLA4Ig to a CD40 blockade-based regimen in nonhuman primate (NHP) alloislet transplantation. Diabetic rhesus macaques were transplanted allogeneic islets using the CD40-specific antibody 3A8, basiliximab induction, and sirolimus with or without CTLA4Ig maintenance therapy. Allograft survival was determined by fasting blood glucose levels and flow cytometric techniques were used to test for donor-specific antibody (DSA) formation. CTLA4Ig plus 3A8, basiliximab and sirolimus was well tolerated and induced long-term islet allograft survival. The addition of CTLA4Ig prevented DSA formation, but did not facilitate withdrawal of the 3A8-based regimen. Thus, CTLA4Ig combines with a CD40-specific regimen to prevent DSA formation in NHPs, and offers a potentially translatable calcineurin inhibitor-free protocol inclusive of a single investigational agent for use in clinical islet transplantation without relying upon CD154 blockade.

Profile of belatacept and its potential role in prevention of graft rejection following renal transplantation

The last several decades have witnessed a substantial decrease in the incidence of acute allograft rejection following kidney transplantation, although commensurate improvements in long-term graft function have not been realized. As a result, the primary focus of new immunosuppressive drug development has expanded to include ease of use and improved side effect profile, including reduced nephrotoxicity, in addition to the more traditional goal of improved short-term outcomes. A number of novel drugs are currently under investigation in Phase I, II, or III clinical trials, primarily to replace the nephrotoxic but highly effective calcineurin inhibitors. Belatacept is a humanized antibody that inhibits T cell costimulation and has shown encouraging results in multiple Phase II and III trials. This article reviews the mechanism of action of belatacept, as well as published and preliminary results of the Phase I-III clinical trials involving this novel immunosuppressive agent.

A human anti-CD40 monoclonal antibody, 4D11, for kidney transplantation in cynomolgus monkeys: induction and maintenance therapy

Blockade of CD40-CD154 signaling pathway is an attractive strategy to induce potent immunosuppression and tolerance in organ transplantation. Due to its strong immunosuppressive effect shown in nonhuman primate experiments, anti-CD154 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) have been tried in clinical settings, but it was interrupted by unexpected thromboembolic complications. Thus, inhibition of the counter molecule, CD40, has remained an alternative approach. In the previous preliminary study, we have shown that 4D11, a novel fully human anti-CD40 mAb, has a fairly potent immunosuppressive effect on kidney allograft in nonhuman primates. In this study, we aimed to confirm the efficacy and untoward events of the 2-week induction and 180-day maintenance 4D11 treatments. In both, 4D11 significantly suppressed T-cell-mediated alloimmune responses and prolonged allograft survival. Addition of weekly 4D11 administration after the induction treatment further enhanced graft survival. Complete inhibition of both donor-specific Ab and anti-4D11 Ab productions was obtained only with higher-dose maintenance therapy. No serious side effect including thromboembolic complications was noted except for a transient reduction of hematocrit in one animal, and decrease of peripheral B-cell counts in all. These results indicate that the 4D11 appears to be a promising candidate for immunosuppression in clinical organ transplantation.

Evaluation of CD86/CD28 and CD40/CD154 pathways in regulating monocyte-derived CD80 expression during their interaction with allogeneic endothelium

This study was designed to examine the role of monocyte-derived CD80 in providing costimulation to CD4+ cells, and to determine whether monocyte-derived CD80 expression is regulated by CD86/CD28 and CD40/CD154 pathways during allogeneic immunoresponses. Human endothelial cells (EC) and purified monocytes cocultured with or without CD4+ cells were analyzed by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and florescence-activated cell scanning (FACS). Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC)-EC cocultures with or without costimulation blockade were analyzed by FACS. The effects of CD154 and CD28 blockade to inhibit lymphocyte proliferation were evaluated by mixed lymphocyte-EC reaction (MLER). RT-PCR demonstrated upregulation of CD80 transcripts in EC-stimulated monocytes in the absence of CD4+ cells. However, the surface expression of CD80 was undetectable. The expression of CD80 was restored in the presence of CD4+ cells. Additionally, CD80 blockade partially inhibited CD4+ cell proliferation induced by EC-conditioned monocytes. Monocytes demonstrated upregulation of CD80 on the surface during PBMC-EC interaction. CD86, CD28, and CD154 blockade did not prevent upregulation of monocyte-derived CD80 expression. CD28 and CD154 blockade partially inhibited lymphocyte proliferation of MLER. In summary, EC-stimulated monocytes upregulated CD80 expression at the transcript level but not on their surface in the absence of T cells. The surface expression of monocyte-derived CD80 is upregulated on EC-stimulated monocytes in the presence of T cells. CD154/CD40 and CD28/CD86 blockade cannot prevent monocyte-derived CD80 expression, suggesting that CD80 upregulation is through a CD154- or CD86-independent pathway. Specific therapy to prevent monocyte activation may be required for successful allograft transplantation.

Differential effects of donor-specific alloantibody

Alloantigen exposure typically provokes an adaptive immune response that can foster rejection of transplanted organs, and these responses present the most formidable biological barrier to kidney transplantation. Although most cellular alloimmune responses can be therapeutically controlled with T-cell-specific immunosuppressants, humoral alloimmune responses remain relatively untamed. Importantly, humoral immunity, typically manifesting as allospecific antibody production, is increasingly recognized for its variable appearance after kidney transplantation. Indeed, the appearance of alloantibody can herald the onset of rapid and destructive antibody-mediated rejection or have no demonstrable acute effects. The factors determining the end result of alloantibody formation remain poorly understood. This review will discuss the breadth of alloantibody responses seen in clinical kidney transplantation and provide an overview of potential factors explaining the phenotypic variability associated with humoral alloimmunity. We propose several avenues ripe for future investigation including the influence of innate immune components and the potential influence of heterologous immune responses in determining the ultimate clinical import of an alloantibody response.

A novel fully human anti-CD40 monoclonal antibody, 4D11, for kidney transplantation in cynomolgus monkeys

BACKGROUND

CD40-CD154 pathway blockade by anti-CD154 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) significantly prolongs allograft survival in nonhuman primates. However, thromboembolic complications have prevented clinical application. Thus, blockade of the counter molecule by a novel fully human anti-CD40 mAb, 4D11, is an attractive alternative.

METHODS

Kidney transplantations were performed between outbred cynomolgus monkeys (stimulation index >3 in a mixed lymphocyte reaction). The animals were divided into five groups: nontreatment control (Group 1, n=3), 10-week treatment with either 10 mg/kg (Group 2, n=3), 20 mg/kg (Group 3, n=3), or 40 mg/kg (Group 4, n=1), and 4-week treatment (Group 5, n=1 each) with 10 mg/kg, 20 mg/kg, or 40 mg/kg followed by monthly administration. Graft survival, biochemistry, complete blood counts, lymphocyte phenotypes, blood drug levels, antidonor and antidrug antibodies, and renal histology were examined.

RESULTS

Survival (days) was as follows: Group 1 (5, 6, 7), Group 2 (150, 108, 108), Group 3 (84, 108, 379), Group 4 (147), and Group 5 (147, 102, 112). Two animals in Group 3 with normal graft function were killed upon development of hydronephrosis and cerebral infarction. B lymphocytes fell to one-third of the preoperative value at 4 weeks after transplantation in all animals. Antidonor antibodies developed in most of the animals after stopping drug treatment or at the time of death. No animals except for one formed anti-4D11 antibody.

CONCLUSION

4D11 appears to be a promising agent for antirejection treatment in clinical organ transplantation.

Central role of ILT3 in the T suppressor cell cascade

CD8+ T suppressor cells differentiate both in vivo and in vitro upon chronic exposure of responding T cells to allogeneic APC. These Ts are allospecific and exhibit their function interacting directly with priming APC which they render tolerogenic. Tolerogenicity of professional and non-professional human APC, such as dendritic cells and endothelial cells, respectively is due to the upregulation of the inhibitory receptors ILT3 and ILT4. ILT3 signals both intracellularly, inhibiting NF-kappaB activation, and transcription of costimulatory molecules, and extracellularly, inducing anergy and regulatory function in T cells with cognate specificity. Both membrane and soluble ILT3 are proteins with potent immunosuppressive activity which are of importance for treatment of rejection, autoimmunity and cancer.

Monovalent antibody scFv fragments selected to modulate T-cell activation by inhibition of CD86–CD28 interaction

Beside the interaction of the antigen-presenting major histocompatibility complex with the T-cell receptor, a co-stimulatory signal is required for T-cell activation in an immune response. To reduce immune-mediated graft rejection in corneal transplantation, where topical application of drugs in ointments or eye-drops may be possible, we selected single-chain antibody fragments (scFv) with binding affinity to rat CD86 (B7.2) that inhibit the co-stimulatory signal. We produced the IgV-like domain of rat CD86 as a fusion protein in Escherichia coli by refolding from inclusion bodies. This protein was used as a target for phage display selection of scFv from HuCAL-1, a fully artificial human antibody library. Selected binding molecules were shown to specifically bind to rat CD86 and inhibit the interaction of CD86 with CD28 and CTLA4 (CD152) in flow cytometry experiments. In an assay for CD86-dependent co-stimulation, the selected scFv fragment successfully inhibited the proliferation of T-cells induced by CD86-expressing P815 cells.

Tolerance in Heart Transplantation: The Holy Grail, or an Attainable Goal?

The father of cardiac transplantation, Norman Shumway, famously predicted that tolerance was the future of the field, and always would be. Although his prediction remains true to date, significant progress has been made toward this goal, the "Holy Grail" for transplant clinicians. Current efforts are fueled by disappointing long-term outcomes associated with chronic immunosuppression, and the promise that partial or complete tolerance will impact long-term results favorably. This article provides a clinical definition of tolerance primarily based on lessons learned from animal heart allograft models. It reviews several promising strategies for inducing tolerance and detecting its presence through the use of biomarkers in peripheral blood or the graft, and outlines a possible path toward making this vision a clinical reality.

Transplant tolerance in non-human primates: progress, current challenges and unmet needs

Given the significant morbidity associated with current post-transplant immunosuppressive regimens, induction of immune tolerance continues to be an important goal of clinical organ transplantation. While many strategies for inducing tolerance have been successfully applied in murine models, significant barriers are faced when translating these approaches to the clinic. This has necessitated pre-clinical studies in the more closely related model system, the non-human primates (NHP). In this review, we will discuss the four most prominent strategies for inducing transplantation tolerance and highlight their relative success and shortcomings in NHP. These strategies are: (1) T-cell costimulation blockade (2) mixed chimerism induction (3) T-cell depletion and (4) tolerance induction through regulatory T-cells. After discussing the progress that has been made with each of these strategies, we will identify this field's most pressing unmet needs and discuss how we may best overcome the resulting barriers to tolerance induction.

Recombinant Ig-like transcript 3-Fc modulates T cell responses via induction of Th anergy and differentiation of CD8+ T suppressor cells

The Ig-like transcript (ILT)3 is crucial to the tolerogenic activity acquired by dendritic cells exposed to allospecific T suppressor (Ts) cells. We have explored the immunomodulatory property of the extracellular region of ILT3 using a cytoplasmic deletion mutant of ILT3 (ILT3delta), expressed as membrane-bound ILT3 on KG1 cells, and a rILT3-Fc fusion protein. We found that both membrane-bound and soluble ILT3 inhibited T cell proliferation in primary and secondary MLC inducing anergy in CD4+ Th cells and suppressing the differentiation of IFN-gamma-producing CD8+ CTL. Furthermore, membrane-bound and soluble ILT3 induced the differentiation of CD8+ FOXP3+ Ts cells in primary 7-day MLC. The suppressive activity of these CD8+ Ts cells is alloantigen specific and mediated by their capacity to induce the up-regulation of ILT3 and down-regulation of costimulatory molecules such as CD86 in APC from the stimulator used for priming, but not on control HLA-mismatched APC. Our finding that ILT3-Fc has potent immunosuppressive activity in vitro and that it acts on T cells only upon activation suggests the possibility that this agent may be of use for specific suppression of the immune response in autoimmunity or transplantation.

Induction of transplantation tolerance in non-human primate preclinical models

Short-term outcomes following organ transplantation have improved considerably since the availability of cyclosporine ushered in the modern era of immunosuppression. In spite of this, many of the current limitations to progress in the field are directly related to the existing practice of relatively non-specific immunosuppression. These include increased risks of opportunistic infection and cancer, and toxicity associated with long-term immunosuppressive drug exposure. In addition, long-term graft loss continues to result in part from a failure to adequately control the anti-donor immune response. The development of a safe and reliable means of inducing tolerance would ameliorate these issues and improve the lives of transplant recipients, yet given the improving clinical standard of care, the translation of new therapies has become appropriately more cautious and dependent on increasingly predictive preclinical models. While convenient and easy to use, rodent tolerance models have not to date been reliably capable of predicting a therapy's potential efficacy in humans. Non-human primates possess an immune system that more closely approximates that found in humans, and have served as a more rigorous preclinical testing ground for novel therapies. Prior to clinical adaptation therefore, tolerance regimens should be vetted in non-human primates to ensure that there is sufficient potential for efficacy to justify the risk of its application.

Challenges in therapeutic strategies for transplantation: Where now from here?

The current standard of care in transplantation reliably achieves acceptable graft and patient survival but still depends on life long immunosuppression in most patients. Current strategies employ medications that, in general, inhibit distal events mediating rejection, namely T cell activation and cytotoxicity. They do not typically interfere with initial allorecognition or the factors that influence the direction of an immune response (towards cytotoxicity as opposed to anergy or regulation). Given the exponential amplification of immune responses, these proximal targets may be more efficient in preventing rejection. Recent laboratory investigations have identified several approaches, e.g., costimulation blockade, depletion, and hematopoietic chimerism, that influence the initial stages of the alloimmune response, or establish self-perpetuating means of eliminating rejection without chronic immunosuppression. This manuscript reviews methods of immune manipulation that the authors view as promising for future exploitation and transfer to the clinic. These therapies are similar in that they are viewed as attempts to influence the ability of the body to mount an immune response and its subsequent direction, as opposed to supplying late effector phase inhibition. While it is recognized as unlikely that any one therapy will universally lead to tolerance, the authors propose that these concepts will make immunosuppressive drug minimization more readily successful.

Quantitative mRNA expression analysis of co-stimulatory molecules in sequential biopsies from heart allografts

Allograft-specific T-cell activation requires two signals, "signal one" via the T-cell receptor and "signal two" via costimulatory pathways. Animal models provide promising data that blockade of costimulatory signals can lead to T-cell anergy and tolerance. We analyzed 72 formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded sequential heart allograft biopsies from 22 patients by quantitative real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction for the mRNA expression of the costimulatory molecules CD28, CD80, CD86, CD40, and CD154. mRNA expression levels were correlated to histological grade and time-point of rejection. mRNA expression of costimulatory molecules predominantly expressed by antigen-presenting cells (CD80, CD86, CD40), correlated with histological grade of cell-mediated acute rejection. Costimulatory molecules were up-regulated not only during rejection episodes early after transplantation, but also at late occurring rejection. The present results suggest a simultaneous and long-term therapeutical blockade of more than one costimulatory pathway for the prevention of repetitive T-cell mediated acute rejection episodes after heart transplantation.

Strategies for Tolerance Induction in Nonhuman Primates

Recent advances in the field of reconstructive surgery and immunology resulted in increased interest in composite tissue allograft (CTA) transplantation. Up to date, more than 50 CTA transplants have been reported in humans. A significant number of experimental studies on CTA transplants under different protocols of tolerance-inducting strategies have been reported in small-animal models. There is however, a limited number of CTA transplants performed in nonhuman primates. To reach the ultimate clinical success in CTA transplantation, more experimental studies on tolerance induction in nonhuman primates are needed to apply these immunomodulatory protocols to CTA transplants in humans. In this review, strategies for tolerance induction in the nonhuman primate model in solid organ and CTA transplants are presented in 3 major categories: chimerism induction, T-cell depletion, and costimulatory receptor blockade.

Renal allograft rejection is prevented by adoptive transfer of anergic T cells in nonhuman primates

Anergic T cells generated ex vivo are reported to have immunosuppressive effects in vitro and in vivo. Here, we tested this concept in nonhuman primates. Alloreactive T cells were rendered anergic ex vivo by coculture with donor alloantigen in the presence of anti-CD80/CD86 mAbs before adoptive transfer via renal allograft to rhesus monkey recipients. The recipients were briefly treated with cyclophosphamide and cyclosporine A during the preparation of the anergic cells. Thirteen days after renal transplantation, the anergic T cells were transferred to the recipient, after which no further immunosuppressive agents were administered. Rejection-free survival was prolonged in all treated recipients, and 3 of 6 animals survived long term (410-880 days at study's end). In the long-surviving recipients, proliferative responses against alloantigen were inhibited in a donor-specific manner, and donor-type, but not third-party, skin allografts were also accepted, which demonstrated that antigen-specific tolerance had been induced. We conclude that anergic T cells generated ex vivo by blocking CD28/B7 costimulation can suppress renal allograft rejection after adoptive transfer in nonhuman primates. This strategy may be applicable to the design of safe clinical trials in humans.

Costimulation Blockade followed by a 12-Week Period of Cyclosporine A Facilitates Prolonged Drug-Free Survival of Rhesus Monkey Kidney Allografts

Costimulation blockade as a single immunosuppressive treatment modality is not sufficient to prevent graft rejection. Here, we report an induction therapy using antagonistic antibodies against CD40 and CD86, given twice weekly from day -1 until day 56, followed by a delayed 12-week course of low-dose cyclosporine A (CsA) treatment in the rhesus monkey kidney-allograft model. Low-dose CsA treatment was initiated on day 42 and tapered until total cessation of all treatment on day 126. Treatment with anti-CD40/86 alone resulted in graft survival of 61, 71, 75, 78, and 116 days. Costimulation blockade followed by CsA resulted in more than 3-year drug-free survival in two of four animals. None of the animals developed donor-specific alloantibodies. Transforming growth factor-beta producing cells are present in early as well as in late kidney-graft biopsies and could play a role in the observed long-term drug-free graft survival.

Organ transplantation—how much of the promise has been realized?

Since the introduction of organ transplantation into medical practice, progress and optimism have been abundant. Improvements in immunosuppressive drugs and ancillary care have led to outstanding short-term (1--3-year) patient and graft survival rates. This success is mitigated by several problems, including poor long-term (>5-year) graft survival rates, the need for continual immunosuppressive medication and the discrepancy between the demand for organs and the supply. Developing methods to induce transplant tolerance, as a means to improve graft outcomes and eliminate the requirement for immunosuppression, and expanding the pool of organs for transplantation are the major challenges of the field.

IDEC-131 (anti-CD154), sirolimus and donor-specific transfusion facilitate operational tolerance in non-human primates

CD154-specific antibody therapy prevents allograft rejection in many experimental transplant models. However, initial clinical transplant trials with anti-CD154 have been disappointing suggesting the need for as of yet undetermined adjuvant therapy. In rodents, donor antigen (e.g., a donor blood transfusion), or mTOR inhibition (e.g., sirolimus), enhances anti-CD154's efficacy. We performed renal transplants in major histocompatibility complex-(MHC) mismatched rhesus monkeys and treated recipients with combinations of the CD154-specific antibody IDEC-131, and/or sirolimus, and/or a pre-transplant donor-specific transfusion (DST). Therapy was withdrawn after 3 months. Triple therapy prevented rejection during therapy in all animals and led to operational tolerance in three of five animals including donor-specific skin graft acceptance in the two animals tested. IDEC-131, sirolimus and DST are highly effective in preventing renal allograft rejection in primates. This apparently clinically applicable regimen is promising for human renal transplant trials.

Lessons learned from anti-CD40L treatment in systemic lupus erythematosus patients

The CD40-CD40L system has pleiotropic effects in a variety of cells and biological processes including immune response, thrombosis and atherogenesis. Within the immune system, these molecules represent a critical link between its humoral and cellular arms. As a result of these attributes and based on preclinical data in animals, anti-CD40L antibodies were tested in a variety of immunologic diseases including idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura, psoriasis, Crohn's disease, systemic lupus erythematosus and transplantation. Phase I/II studies in humans with lupus nephritis demonstrated reduction of anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) antibodies but not of protective antibodies. Reduction of anti-DNA was associated with increased serum complement levels and reduced glomerular inflammation. As a result of thrombotic effects, observed even in patients negative for anti-cardiolipin antibodies, there is a temporary halt on further human studies. The reasons for the prothrombotic effects are not clear at present but may represent effects on platelets and/or the endothelium. In view of the significant immunomodulatory effects of anti-CD40L treatment in patients with lupus nephritis, the increasing realization of the importance of premature atherosclerosis in lupus and an increasing amount of data supporting a role for the CD40-CD40L interactions in this process, inhibition of this pathway deserves further exploration in lupus.

Development of a Chimeric Anti-CD40 Monoclonal Antibody That Synergizes with LEA29Y to Prolong Islet Allograft Survival

In recent years, reagents have been developed that specifically target signals critical for effective T cell activation and function. Manipulation of the CD28/CD80/86 and CD40/CD154 pathways has exhibited extraordinary efficacy, particularly when the pathways are blocked simultaneously. Despite the reported efficacy of anti-CD154 in rodents and higher models, its future clinical use is uncertain due to reported thromboembolic events in clinical trials. To circumvent this potential complication, we developed and evaluated a chimeric Ab targeting CD40 (Chi220, BMS-224819) as an alternative to CD154. Although Chi220 blocks CD154 binding, it also possesses partial agonist properties and weak stimulatory potential. The anti-CD40 was tested alone and in combination with a rationally designed, high affinity variant of CTLA4-Ig, LEA29Y (belatacept), in a nonhuman primate model of islet transplantation. Although either agent alone only modestly prolonged islet survival (Chi220 alone: 14, 16, and 84 days; LEA29Y alone: 58 and 60 days), their combination (LEA29Y and Chi220) dramatically facilitated long term survival (237, 237, 220, >185, and 172 days). We found that the effects of Chi220 treatment were not mediated solely through deletion of CD20-bearing cells and that the combined therapy did not significantly impair established antiviral immunity.

Use of anti-CD40 ligand monoclonal antibody as antirejection therapy in a murine peripheral nerve allograft model

Monoclonal antibody directed against CD40 ligand prevents acute allograft rejection in several models of solid-organ transplantation. This study describes the use of CD40 ligand as antirejection therapy in a mouse peripheral nerve allograft model. C3H mice received 8-mm nerve isografts (n = 2) or nerve allografts from C57BL donors. Treated animals (n = 11) received anti-CD40 ligand antibody applied to the graft and by intraperitoneal injections postoperatively. At 3 weeks, nerve histology from treated animals was comparable to isografts, whereas untreated allografts demonstrated virtually no signs of regeneration. Walking-track analysis demonstrated a trend toward improved functional recovery in treated animals. In conclusion, blockade of the CD40 pathway suppresses nerve allograft rejection in mice, and facilitates regeneration comparable to isografts.

Tolerance induction in clinical transplantation

Introduction of modern immunosuppressive agents has led to great success of allotransplantation in humans, and survival rates for all solid organs have been dramatically improved. However, a constant proportion of organs is lost every year due to chronic allograft rejection and immunosuppressive drug toxicity. This has led to a situation where, despite the of donor organ shortage, about one third of the patients on the kidney transplant waiting list are listed for a retransplant. The induction of donor-specific tolerance has the potential of at least partially resolving this problem, since it might prevent chronic rejection and drug toxicity at the same time. For a variety of protocols, successful tolerance induction has been demonstrated in rodent models. However, translation of such protocols to large animal models and on clinical trials has turned out to be very difficult. This review briefly describes mechanisms and barriers to transplantation tolerance, and then focuses on pre-clinical and clinical studies in non-human primates and humans. We have divided the strategies into two groups, based on the principle mechanisms of tolerance induction: the first group are protocols not using hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HCT) as part of there regimen. They rely mainly on intensive T cell depletion (either by total body irradiation, total lymphoid irradiation or treatment with T cell-depleting agents such as anti-thymocyte globulin, anti-CD52 antibody or CD3 immunotoxin), which have been combined with costimulatory blockade, signaling blockade or donor antigen infusion. The second group are HCT-based protocols combining HCT with T cell-depleting agents and cytoreductive treatment. So far, only two protocols (one with total lymphoid irradiation and anti-thymocyte globulin, but no HCT; one with HCT, cyclophosphamide, anti-thymocyte globulin and thymic irradiation) have been translated into successful human studies. We summarize and discuss the results of these trials and suggest goals for further studies for the development tolerance protocols applicable for a broad population of allograft recipients.

The road to tolerance: renal transplant tolerance induction in nonhuman primate studies and clinical trials

Organ transplantation has become a standard life-saving therapy for many causes of end stage organ failure. Although valuable, it remains hampered by the requirement for, and complications of, immunosuppression to prevent immune rejection of the transplanted organ. It is now clear that rejection can be avoided in some experimental systems without a requirement of immunosuppressive medication, and these experimental concepts are now making their way into the clinic in the form of early transplantation tolerance trials. This manuscript will discuss the most promising techniques for tolerance induction, namely, costimulation blockade, lymphocyte depletion, and mixed chimerism. Seminal preclinical studies will be cited and the results of initial clinical trials will be reviewed. The data to date indicate that while tolerance remains elusive, immunosuppression minimization is a feasible near-term alternative.

Human T cell activation by costimulatory signal-deficient allogeneic cells induces inducible costimulator-expressing anergic T cells with regulatory cell activity

Although immunoregulation by several types of regulatory T cells is now clearly established in mice, the demonstration of such regulatory T cells in humans has been proven more difficult. In this study we demonstrate the induction of anergic regulatory T cells during an MLR performed in the presence of blocking mAb to the costimulatory molecules CD40, CD80, and CD86. Despite this costimulation blockade, which totally blocks T cell proliferation and cytokine production, a nonproliferating T cell subpopulation was activated to express inducible costimulator (ICOS). These ICOS(+) cells were anergic when restimulated with unmanipulated allogeneic stimulator cells at the level of proliferation and Th1 and Th2 cytokine production, but they did produce IL-10. These ICOS-expressing cells also blocked the capacity of reciprocal ICOS-negative cells to proliferate and to produce cytokines. ICOS(+) anergic cells could suppress allogenic responses of either primed or naive T cells through inhibition of IL-2 gene transcription. Suppression was not mediated by IL-10 and did not require ICOS-ICOS ligand interaction, but depended on cell-cell contact. Thus, a subtype of regulatory T cells in human blood can be activated in the absence of costimulatory signals from CD40, CD80, and CD86, and they can be identified by expression of ICOS after activation.

Crossing the bridge: large animal models in translational transplantation research

Many methods for reducing the immunosuppressive requirements of allotransplantation have been proposed based on a growing understanding of physiological and allospecific immunity. As these regimens are developed for clinical application, they require validation in models that are reasonably predictive of their performance in humans. This article provides an overview of the large animal models commonly used to test immunomodulatory organ transplant protocols. The rationale for the use of large animals and the effects of common immunosuppressants in the dog, pig, and non-human primate are reviewed. Promising methods for the induction of allospecific tolerance are surveyed with references to early human trials where appropriate.

Evaluating the validity of animal models for research into therapies for immune-based disorders

The last few decades of the 20th century have shown an intensified search for safer and more effective medications against chronic diseases that burden ageing societies of the western world. The impressive development of biotechnological production techniques has greatly facilitated the pharmaceutical development of relatively non-toxic biological molecules. However, despite the huge investments, only a few effective therapies for immune-based diseases have reached the clinic. In this article we use examples from monoclonal antibody trials to discuss the validity and predictive strength of the animal models currently used for the development of effective therapies.

Anti-CD40 ligand monoclonal antibody induces a permissive state, but not tolerance, for murine peripheral nerve allografts

Anti-CD40 ligand monoclonal antibody prevents the interaction between CD40 and its T-cell-based ligand, thereby resulting in selective inhibition of T cell costimulation without pan-T-cell suppression. This antibody has found application in several animal models of solid organ transplantation. This study investigated use of anti-CD40 ligand antibody to promote acceptance of nerve allografts. In Experiment 1, 40 BALB/cj mice with tibial nerve transplants were administered anti-CD40 ligand antibody, a control antibody, or no treatment. In Experiment 2, 40 BALB/cj mice underwent the same regimen as in Experiment 1, but were later challenged with a second nerve allograft 3 weeks after discontinuation of treatment. Animals treated with anti-CD40 ligand antibody in Experiment 1 exhibited improved functional recovery and greater mean fiber count, fiber density, and percent nerve fiber than animals treated with control antibody or no antibody (P < 0.05). These permissive effects on nerve regeneration were associated with immune unresponsiveness on Elispot assay. The benefit of anti-CD40 ligand therapy did not persist after withdrawal of treatment (Experiment 2). Active blockade of the CD40 costimulatory pathway with murine anti-CD40 ligand antibody therefore induces a permissive state conducive to nerve regeneration across allografts but does not establish long-term tolerance.

Tolerance: is it achievable in pediatric solid organ transplantation?

Significant advances have been made in the understanding of allograft rejection. There is growing awareness that allograft acceptance, or tolerance, is also an active process rather than a passive absence of rejection. Mechanistic awareness of this process has spawned many preclinical strategies for the prevention of allograft rejection without the need for chronic immunosuppression. These therapies are currently entering clinical trials. This article reviews the prevailing therapies that hold promise for future clinical application. In particular, their application in children is discussed, as are biologic aspects of childhood immunity that may play a role in the success or failure of these strategies.

Effects of combined treatment with CD25- and CD154-specific monoclonal antibodies in non-human primate allotransplantation

The CD154-specific monoclonal antibody (Mab) hu5c8 greatly prolongs allograft survival in primates. The CD25-specific Mab daclizumab has not, to date, been paired with hu5c8. We evaluated the effects of hu5c8 in vitro, alone and in combination with daclizumab on rhesus-mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLRs). We then evaluated therapy with hu5c8 and daclizumab in four monkey renal allograft recipients compared with monkeys untreated or contemporaneously treated with hu5c8 alone. Lymphocyte proliferation in MLR was reduced by both daclizumab and hu5c8, and their combined effects were additive. Rejection-free allograft survival in monkeys treated with both hu5c8 and daclizumab (74-479 days) was not significantly better than animals treated with hu5c8 alone (257-587 days), and one combined therapy animal rejected while still on hu5c8 therapy, a condition not typically seen with hu5c8 monotherapy. Although daclizumab and hu5c8 are additively effective in MLR, they do not appear to be synergistic in vivo in rhesus monkeys.

The new immunosuppression

New knowledge on how lymphocytes become tolerant to antigens is now enabling novel tolerance-harnessing strategies to enter the clinical arena. In the field of transplantation, monoclonal antibodies used either to deplete lymphocytes or to block T-cell function can induce tolerance in mice and non-human primates. Understanding the mechanisms underlying tolerance should enable application to the clinic. Harnessing of tolerance mechanisms may enable more judicious use of conventional immunosuppressive agents even to the point of maintenance monotherapy, so limiting drug side effects and ensuring compliance.