A minimal and optimal cytotoxic T cell epitope within hepatitis C virus nucleoprotein

Immune response of cytotoxic T lymphocytes and possibility of vaccine development for hepatitis C virus infection

Immune responses of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are implicated in viral eradication and the pathogenesis of hepatitis C. Weak CTL response against hepatitis C virus (HCV) may lead to a persistent infection. HCV infection impairs the function of HCV-specific CTLs; HCV proteins are thought to actively suppress host immune responses, including CTLs. Induction of a strong HCV-specific CTL response in HCV-infected patients can facilitate complete HCV clearance. Thus, the development of a vaccine that can induce potent CTL response against HCV is strongly expected. We investigated HCV-specific CTL responses by enzyme-linked immuno-spot assay and/or synthetic peptides and identified over 40 novel CTL epitopes in the HCV protein. Our findings may contribute to the development of the HCV vaccine. In this paper, we describe the CTL responses in HCV infection and the attempts at vaccine development based on recent scientific articles.

Magnitude of CD8 T-cell responses against hepatitis C virus and severity of hepatitis do not necessarily determine outcomes in acute hepatitis C virus infection

AIM

We investigated the relationship between the magnitude of comprehensive hepatitis C virus (HCV)-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses and the clinical course of acute HCV infection.

METHODS

Six consecutive patients with acute HCV infection were studied. Analysis of HCV-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses was performed using an interferon-gamma-based enzyme-linked immunospot assay using peripheral CD8(+) T-cells, monocytes and 297 20-mer synthetic peptides overlapping by 10 residues and spanning the entire HCV sequence of genotype 1b.

RESULTS

Five patients presented detectable HCV-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses against a single and different peptide, whereas 1 patient showed responses against three different peptides. Neither the magnitude of HCV-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses nor the severity of hepatitis predicts the outcome of acute hepatitis. The maximum number of HCV-specific CD8(+) T-cells correlated with maximum serum alanine aminotransferase level during the course (r = 0.841, P = 0.036).

CONCLUSIONS

HCV-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses were detectable in all 6 patients with acute HCV infection, and 6 novel HCV-specific CTL epitopes were identified. Acute HCV infection can resolve with detectable HCV-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses, but without development of antibody against HCV.

Immune responses in hepatitis C virus infection and mechanisms of hepatitis C virus persistence

Immune responses against hepatitis C virus (HCV) play a crucial role in the pathogenesis of chronic hepatitis C. HCV infection often persists and leads to chronic hepatitis and eventually cirrhosis. Accumulated data suggest that HCV proteins suppress host immune responses through the suppression of functions of immune cells, such as cytotoxic T lymphocytes, natural killer cells, and dendritic cells. They also suppress the type 1 interferon signaling system. The resulting insufficient immune responses against HCV lead to the sustained infection. The appropriate control of immune responses would contribute to the eradication of HCV and the improvement of hepatitis, but there are still many issues to be clarified. This review describes the scientific evidence to support these emerging concepts, and will touch on the implications for improving antiviral therapy.

Immunopathogenesis in hepatitis C virus cirrhosis

HCV (hepatitis C virus) has a high propensity to persist and to cause chronic hepatitis C, eventually leading to cirrhosis. Since HCV itself is not cytopathic, liver damage in chronic hepatitis C is commonly attributed to immune-mediated mechanisms. HCV proteins interact with several pathways in the host's immune response and disrupt pathogen-associated pattern recognition pathways, interfere with cellular immunoregulation via CD81 binding and subvert the activity of NK (natural killer) cells as well as CD4(+) and CD8(+) T-cells. Finally, HCV-specific T-cells become increasingly unresponsive and apparently disappear, owing to several possible mechanisms, such as escape mutations in critical viral epitopes, lack of sufficient help, clonal anergy or expansion of regulatory T-cells. The role of neutralizing antibodies remains uncertain, although it is still possible that humoral immunity contributes to bystander damage of virally coated cells via antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. Cytotoxic lymphocytes kill HCV-infected cells via the perforin/granzyme pathway, but also release Fas ligand and inflammatory cytokines such as IFNgamma (interferon gamma). Release of soluble effector molecules helps to control HCV infection, but may also destroy uninfected liver cells and can attract further lymphocytes without HCV specificity to invade the liver. Bystander damage of these non-specific inflammatory cells will expand the tissue damage triggered by HCV infection and ultimately activate fibrogenesis. A clear understanding of these processes will eventually help to develop novel treatment strategies for HCV liver disease, independent from direct inhibition of HCV replication.

Biomedicines to reduce inflammation but not viral load in chronic HCV--what's the sense?

Although cytokines and cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are among the predominant mechanisms of host defense against viral pathogens, they can induce an inflammatory response that often leads to tissue injury. Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection, a major cause of liver-related disease, results in the induction of proinflammatory cytokines, such as tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), and CTL activity, followed by liver injury. Although inflammation facilitates the wound healing process, chronic persistence over several decades results in scar accumulation, fibrosis and often cirrhosis. This review summarizes biological data implicating a cause-and-effect relationship between TNF-alpha levels and the progression of fibrosis in chronic HCV infections, in contrast to the role of TNF-alpha in hepatitis B virus infections. Furthermore, an overview of therapeutic approaches to halting the inflammatory cascade in individuals with chronic HCV, including the use of agents to reduce the level of TNF-alpha, is presented.

Processing of hepatitis C virus core protein is regulated by its C-terminal sequence

Polyprotein processing of plus-strand RNA viruses is important in the regulation of gene production and replication. The core protein of hepatitis C virus (HCV), constructing the viral particle, is processed from its precursor polyprotein and observed as two forms, p23 and p21. Production of p21 by cleavage at the C-terminus of p23 is considered crucial to viral assembly and replication. In this study, this processing step was compared between clones isolated from two patients with fulminant hepatitis and from five patients with chronic hepatitis by an in vitro translation assay and cell transfection assay. The p21 core protein was predominant from the clone isolated from one of the fulminant hepatitis patient (p21 core protein production was 65.98%), while p23 was abundant with clones from five chronic hepatitis patients (p21 core protein production was 7.11+/-1.62%) and clone from another fulminant hepatitis patient (p21 core protein production was 13.36%). Investigations with chimeric and mutation-introduced constructs revealed that four amino acid residues in the C-terminus of the core region are responsible for this difference. The data suggest that core protein processing is regulated by C-terminus mutations.

Comprehensive analysis of CD8(+)-T-cell responses against hepatitis C virus reveals multiple unpredicted specificities

The hepatitis C virus (HCV)-specific CD8(+)-T-cell response is thought to play a critical role in HCV infection. Studies of these responses have largely relied on the analysis of a small number of previously described or predicted HCV epitopes, mostly restricted by HLA A2. In order to determine the actual breadth and magnitude of CD8(+)-T-cell responses in the context of diverse HLA class I alleles, we performed a comprehensive analysis of responses to all expressed HCV proteins. By using a panel of 301 overlapping peptides, we analyzed peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from a cohort of 14 anti-HCV-positive, HLA A2-positive individuals in an enzyme-linked immunospot assay. Only four subjects had detectable HLA A2-restricted responses in PBMC, and only 3 of 19 predicted A2 epitopes were targeted, all of which were confirmed by tetramer analysis. In contrast, 9 of 14 persons showed responses with more comprehensive analyses, with many responses directed against previously unreported epitopes. These results indicate that circulating HCV-specific CD8(+)-T-cell responses can be detected in PBMC in the majority of infected persons and that these responses are heterogeneous with no immunodominant epitopes consistently recognized. Since responses to epitopes restricted by single HLA alleles such as HLA A2 do not predict the overall response in an individual, more comprehensive approaches, as shown here, should facilitate definition of the role of the CD8(+)-T-cell response in HCV infection. Moreover, the low level or absence of responses to many predicted epitopes provides a rationale for immunotherapeutic interventions to broaden cytotoxic-T-lymphocyte recognition.

Cellular immune responses against hepatitis C virus: the evidence base 2002

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) is an RNA virus which is estimated to persistently infect about 170 million people worldwide. After acute infection, there is an initial period during which long-term outcome is decided. There is strong evidence that the cellular immune responses, involving both CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes, are involved at this stage and it is their effectiveness which determines outcome. What is not understood is what determines their effectiveness. The most important component of this is likely to be some aspect of epitope selection, itself dictated by host MHC. Thus, to understand host immunity to HCV, we need to have a detailed understanding of the peptides involved in T lymphocyte responses. In this review, we discuss the peptide epitopes that have been identified so far, and their potential significance. We relate this to a scheme of host defence which may be useful for understanding natural and vaccine-induced immunity.

Development and characterisation of recombinant hepatitis delta virus-like particles

Injection of particulate hepatitis B virus surface antigen (HBsAg) in mice leads to the induction of a HBsAg-specific class-I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response. It is proposed that any protein internal to HBsAg will also be able to elicit a specific CTL response. In this study, several carboxy-terminal truncations of hepatitis C virus (HCV) core protein were fused to varying lengths of amino-terminal truncated large hepatitis delta antigen (L-HDAg). These constructs were analysed for their ability to be expressed and the particles secreted in the presence of HBsAg after transfection into HuH-7 cells. The secretion efficiency of the various HCV core-HDAg chimeric proteins was generally poor. Constructs containing full length HDAg appeared to be more stable than truncated versions and the length of the inserted protein was restricted to around 40 amino acids. Thus, the use of L-HDAg as a chimera to package foreign proteins is limited. Consequently, a polyepitope (polytope) containing a B-cell epitope from human papillomavirus (HPV 16) and multiple T-cell epitopes from the HCV polyprotein was used to create the construct, L-HDAg-polyB. This chimeric protein was shown to be reliant on the co-expression of HBsAg for secretion into the cell culture fluid and was secreted more efficiently than the previous HCV core-HDAg constructs. These L-HDAg-polyB virus-like particles (VLPs) had a buoyant density of approximately 1.2 g/cm3 in caesium chloride and approximately 1.15 g/cm3 in sucrose. The VLPs were also immunoprecipitated using an anti-HBs but not an anti-HD antibody. Thus, these recombinant VLPs have similar biophysical properties to L-HDAg VLPs.

Identification of the immunodominant H-2K(k)-restricted cytotoxic T-cell epitope in the Borna disease virus nucleoprotein

Borna disease virus (BDV)-induced immunopathology in mice is most prominent in strains carrying the major histocompatibility complex H-2k allele and is mediated by CD8(+) T cells that are directed against the viral nucleoprotein p40. We now identified the highly conserved octamer peptide TELEISSI, located between amino acid residues 129 and 136 of BDV p40, as a potent H-2K(k)-restricted cytotoxic T-cell (CTL) epitope. When added to the culture medium of L929 target cells, TELEISSI conferred sensitivity to lysis by CTLs isolated from brains of BDV-infected MRL mice with acute neurological disease. Vaccinia virus-mediated expression of a p40 variant with mutations in the two K(k)-specific anchor residues of the TELEISSI peptide (p40(E130K,I136T)) did not sensitize L929 target cells for lysis by BDV-specific CTLs, whereas expression of wild-type p40 did. Furthermore, unlike vaccination with wild-type p40, vaccination of persistently infected symptomless B10.BR mice with p40(E130K,I136T) did not result in central nervous system inflammation and neurological disease. These results demonstrate that TELEISSI is the immunodominant CTL epitope of BDV p40 in H-2k mice.

Characterization of an immunologically conserved epitope from hepatitis C virus E2 glycoprotein recognized by HLA-A2 restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Identification of epitopes recognized by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in hepatitis C virus (HCV) proteins is of importance because they can be used for vaccination, treatment of infection or monitoring of immune responses. Our purpose was to characterize new CTL epitopes in HCV structural proteins.

METHODS

Peptides were synthesized and tested in HLA-A2 binding assays. Binder peptides were used to stimulate peripheral blood mononuclear cells from HCV+ patients and controls, and activity measured in chromium release and ELISPOT assays.

RESULTS

Twenty binder peptides were found, and stimulation of HCV+ patient cells with nine peptides showing high binding ability led to the growth of CD8+ CTL recognizing peptide E2(614-622) in association with HLA-A2. Peptide E2(614-622) was recognized by 30% of HLA-A2+ patients with chronic HCV infection, but no responses were observed in control groups. Five peptides derived from region E2(614-622) from 26 different viral isolates bound to HLA-A2 molecules, and all of them but one, containing Phe at position 622, were recognized by E2(614-622) specific CTL.

CONCLUSIONS

These results show that peptide E2(614-622) belongs to a highly conserved region of HCV E2, and might be a good candidate to induce anti-HCV CTL responses in HLA-A2+ subjects.

Detection of diverse hepatitis C virus (HCV)-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes in peripheral blood of infected persons by screening for responses to all translated proteins of HCV

Broadly directed hepatitis C virus (HCV)-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) have been identified from liver-infiltrating lymphocytes but have been more difficult to assess in peripheral blood of infected persons. To enhance the detection of CTL from peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), we cocultured PBMC with autologous Epstein-Barr virus-transformed B-lymphoblastoid cell lines that had been infected with recombinant vaccinia virus constructs so that they expressed the entire translated polyprotein of HCV-H, a type 1a strain. These stimulated cells from HCV-infected as well as exposed seronegative persons were then cloned at limiting dilution and tested for HCV-specific CTL activity using a standard (51)Cr release assay. HCV-specific CTL were detected in PBMC from seven of nine persons with chronic hepatitis, including five of seven in whom CTL had previously been detected from liver biopsy specimens but not PBMC. In a single person with chronic HCV infection, CTL directed against as many as five different epitopes were detected in peripheral blood and were similar in specificity to those detected in liver tissue. This technique was used to evaluate eight subjects identified to be at high risk for HCV exposure due to continued injection drug abuse; no evidence of CTL in PBMC was found. We conclude that CTL can be detected in PBMC from the majority of persons with chronic HCV infection but are present at lower levels or absent in exposed but persistently seronegative persons. The high degree of concordance of HCV epitopes identified from liver and PBMC suggests that this strategy is a reasonable alternative to liver biopsy for characterizing the CTL response to HCV in chronically infected persons.

Human leukocyte antigen DRB1 1302 protects against bile duct damage and portal lymphocyte infiltration in patients with chronic hepatitis C

BACKGROUND/AIMS

To confirm the immune reaction of hosts in chronic hepatitis C, we examined the association of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) DR with the histopathological outcome including bile duct damage and steatosis, which are characteristic of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection.

METHODS

One hundred and fifty-five patients with chronic HCV infection were examined. The pathological appearance of liver biopsy specimens was evaluated by both Knodell's histological activity index and examination of bile duct damage and steatosis. HLA DRB1 was determined by the polymerase chain reaction sequence-specific oligonucleotide probe method.

RESULTS

HLA DRB1 1302 was found with significantly higher frequency in patients without than with bile duct damage (34.8% vs. 4.7%, p=0.0001, p corrected by Bonferroni's inequality method=0.002). It was also found more frequently in patients without marked portal lymphocyte infiltration (28.6% vs. 7.7%, p=0.0015, p corrected by Bonferroni's method=0.03). HLA DRB1 1101 was found more frequently in patients without than with piecemeal necrosis (p=0.004). In contrast, the frequency of HLA DRB1 1502 tended to be higher in patients with than without piecemeal necrosis and marked portal lymphocyte infiltration (p=0.015 and p=0.03, respectively). HLA DRB1 1201 and 0802 were seen more frequently in bile duct damage-negative (p=0.02) and piecemeal necrosis-negative patients (p=0.03), respectively. Interestingly, serum HCV levels of HLA DRB1 1302-positive patients were significantly higher than those of 1302-negative patients (mean: 7.7 Meq/ml vs. 3.1 Meq/ml, p=0.0007).

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest that some histopathological changes in chronically HCV-infected livers could be caused by the host's immune reaction regulated by HLA DR.

Hepatitis C virus core protein binds to apolipoprotein AII and its secretion is modulated by fibrates

Several lines of evidence suggest that hepatitis C virus (HCV) core protein may modulate cellular transduction signals and alter lipid metabolism. We have investigated the binding of HCV core protein to cellular proteins by combining 2 yeast hybrid, confocal, and surface plasmon resonance assays. Our results show the direct binding of the viral protein to apolipoprotein AII (apoAII) and map the interaction domain to the C-terminal of HCV core protein. To investigate the biological relevance of the interaction between HCV core and lipid metabolism, we took advantage of the well-established increase in apoAII expression caused by fibrates in HepG2 cells. After fenofibric acid treatment, we show a parallel increase in apoAII and core protein secretion, this effect being abolished by brefeldin A. Our study identifies apoAII as one of the cellular targets for HCV core protein. We also show that the intervention of fenofibric acid in cellular lipid metabolism directly affects the expression pattern of HCV core protein.

Pathogenesis of chronic hepatitis C: immunological features of hepatic injury and viral persistence

The immune response to viral antigens is thought to be responsible for viral clearance and disease pathogenesis during hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection. In chronically infected patients, the T-cell response to the HCV is polyclonal and multispecific, although it is not as strong as the response in acutely infected patients who display a more vigorous T-cell response. Importantly, viral clearance in acutely infected patients is associated with a strong CD4(+) helper T-cell response. Thus, the dominant cause of viral persistence during HCV infection may be the development of a weak antiviral immune response to the viral antigens, with corresponding inability to eradicate infected cells. Alternatively, if clearance of HCV from the liver results from the antiviral effect of T-cell-derived cytokines, as has been demonstrated recently for the hepatitis B virus, chronic HCV infection could occur if HCV is not sensitive to such cytokines or if insufficient quantities of cytokines are produced. Liver cell damage may extend from virally infected to uninfected cells via soluble cytotoxic mediators and recruitment and activation of inflammatory cells forming the necroinflammatory response. Additional factors that could contribute to viral persistence are viral inhibition of antigen processing or presentation, modulation of the response to cytotoxic mediators, immunological tolerance to HCV antigens, mutational inactivation of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) epitopes, mutational conversion of CTL epitopes into CTL antagonists, and infection of immunologically privileged tissues. Analysis of the basis for viral persistence is hampered because the necessary cell culture system and animal model to study this question do not yet exist.

Targeting of hepatitis C virus core protein for MHC I or MHC II presentation does not enhance induction of immune responses to DNA vaccination

We analyzed different vaccine approaches aimed at enhancing CD4(+)- and CD8(+)-dependent responses against hepatitis C virus (HCV) core antigen. Specific DNA vectors expressing various forms of the core in fusion with the ubiquitin or the lysosome-associated membrane protein (LAMP) were generated. These expressed the full-length wildtype core; the full-length core expressed as a covalent fusion with the ubiquitin; the full-length core expressed as a noncovalent fusion with the ubiquitin and containing a N-stabilizing or N-destabilizing residue; and the full-length core expressed as a fusion with the LAMP sequence. In vitro expression levels of the different plasmids differed by as much as tenfold. After injection into mice, none of the plasmids yielded a detectable antibody response, whereas core-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) activity could be observed with all plasmids as long as 21 weeks postimmunization. No increase in CTL activity (ranging from 7% to 34% specific lysis) was observed with the ubiquitin-fusion-expressed core antigens compared with the wildtype core. The lowest CTL activity (< 5% specific lysis) was observed with the LAMP fusion. This vector was nonetheless unable to induce a detectable proliferative response. Screening of 10 different putative CTL peptide epitopes failed to reveal newly targeted epitopes when the core-fusion plasmids were used compared with the wildtype core-expressing plasmid. These data underline the difficulty in optimizing anti-core cellular immune response using molecular targeting strategies in DNA-based vaccination.

Fluctuations of hepatitis C virus load are not related to amino acid substitutions in hypervariable region 1 and interferon sensitivity determining region

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) load is one of the most important predictive factors of response to interferon treatment. However, little is known about the mode and determinants of viremia. The mode of viremia was investigated in 78 patients with chronic HCV genotype 1b infection during 1-2 years follow up. Virus load, determined by a branched chain DNA amplification assay, was stable in 73 of 78 (93.6%) patients, whereas 5 (6.4%) showed marked fluctuation (from undetectable level to more than 10 Meq/ml) in viral titer. To study the mechanisms mediating fluctuations in viral titer, amino acid sequences of two regions were examined; hypervariable region (HVR) 1 and the interferon sensitivity determining region (ISDR). Multiple amino acid substitutions were observed in HVR 1 but no relationship was evident between substitutions and virus titers. In contrast, no amino acid substitutions were observed in the ISDR in any patients with stable virus titer during a follow-up period of 12-24 months (7-24 samples) or in one patient who was observed for 15 years. Interestingly, multiple amino acid substitutions in the ISDR appeared in only two of the five patients with marked titer fluctuation, when the virus decreased markedly. Alanine aminotransferase levels in these five patients correlated with viral load. The data suggest that amino acid substitutions in HVR1 and ISDR are not essential for changes in viral titer. Possible mechanisms of fluctuations of viral titer and amino acid substitutions in the ISDR accompanying marked reductions in viral load are discussed.

The native form and maturation process of hepatitis C virus core protein

The maturation and subcellular localization of hepatitis C virus (HCV) core protein were investigated with both a vaccinia virus expression system and CHO cell lines stably transformed with HCV cDNA. Two HCV core proteins, with molecular sizes of 21 kDa (p21) and 23 kDa (p23), were identified. The C-terminal end of p23 is amino acid 191 of the HCV polyprotein, and p21 is produced as a result of processing between amino acids 174 and 191. The subcellular localization of the HCV core protein was examined by confocal laser scanning microscopy. Although HCV core protein resided predominantly in the cytoplasm, it was also found in the nucleus and had the same molecular size as p21 in both locations, as determined by subcellular fractionation. The HCV core proteins had different immunoreactivities to a panel of monoclonal antibodies. Antibody 5E3 stained core protein in both the cytoplasm and the nucleus, C7-50 stained core protein only in the cytoplasm, and 499S stained core protein only in the nucleus. These results clearly indicate that the p23 form of HCV core protein is processed to p21 in the cytoplasm and that the core protein in the nucleus has a higher-order structure different from that of p21 in the cytoplasm. HCV core protein in sera of patients with HCV infection was analyzed in order to determine the molecular size of genuinely processed HCV core protein. HCV core protein in sera was found to have exactly the same molecular weight as the p21 protein. These results suggest that p21 core protein is a component of native viral particles.

Liver-Derived CTL in Hepatitis C Virus Infection: Breadth and Specificity of Responses in a Cohort of Persons with Chronic Infection

Hepatitis C virus (HCV)-specific CTL have been found within the inflammatory infiltrate of the liver of chronically infected individuals, but the breadth and specificity of the CTL response in relation to viral load are less well characterized. In this study, we analyzed the intrahepatic CTL response in liver biopsy specimens from 44 chronically infected subjects. Liver-infiltrating lymphocytes were expanded polyclonally in bulk cultures, and multiple clones were derived by limiting dilution. HCV-specific CTL responses directed at genotype 1a structural proteins were assessed in all subjects, and 22 subjects were tested more comprehensively using vectors expressing all structural and nonstructural HCV Ags. CTL responses were further characterized to determine the HLA restriction and optimal epitopes recognized. In those persons screened for recognition of all HCV Ags, HLA class I-restricted CTL were detected in 45%. Nineteen different CTL epitopes were identified, which were distributed throughout the genome; only one epitope was targeted by more than one person. In those persons with CTL responses, the breadth of response ranged from one to five epitopes. There was no correlation between the presence of a detectable CTL response and viral load. These results indicate considerable heterogeneity in detectable HCV-specific CTL responses in chronically infected persons. The mechanisms by which HCV persists during chronic infection remain to be clarified.

Impaired induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes by antagonism of a weak agonist borne by a variant hepatitis C virus epitope

An epitope that acted as a weak agonist in the cytotoxicity assay was identified as part of the capsid protein of a hepatitis C virus (HCV) variant. In a low concentration, the variant epitope also had a weak antagonistic effect. When a minute amount of this variant epitope was added to the culture for induction, it selectively attenuated the expansion of major cytotoxic T cell populations and drastically reduced the cytotoxic responses against the wild-type epitope. Thus, antagonism to induction suppressed immune responses against both the wild type and the variant, thereby helping the persistence of not only variant itself but also the wild-type HCV. Because this variant was a weak agonist, most cytotoxic T cells induced with the wild-type epitope were cross-reactive with the variant and susceptible to the antagonism to induction. Only the T cells which were not cross-reactive with the variant and not susceptible to the antagonism survived the antagonism in induction. This implied that the specificity of the remaining immune response, if any, was directed exclusively to the wild-type epitope after the emergence of the variant. For viruses like HCV, being heterogeneous itself may contribute significantly toward persistent infection through antagonism to induction.

Characteristics of the intrahepatic cytotoxic T lymphocyte response in chronic hepatitis C virus infection

Based on our CTL studies of over 44 persons with chronic HCV infection, we are able to arrive at a number of conclusions. Clearly this cellular immune response is heterogeneous among infected persons. We have not identified any specific HCV protein which appears to be immunodominant for CTL responses, but rather we have detected diverse responses to both structural and non-structural proteins. Using an identical stimulation strategy for all persons studied, we have been able to detect responses in only approximately one third of persons with chronic infection. Among these persons, the responses among liver-infiltrating lymphocytes are greater than those detected in fresh peripheral blood, suggesting that the CTL are homing to the site of maximal viral burden in these persons. Some viral proteins contain overlapping epitopes presented by more than one HLA class I molecule, and we have also found cases where peptides in the same HLA superfamily, such as the HLA A3 superfamily which contains A11, for which the same peptide can be presented by both alleles (manuscript in preparation). Although sequence variation between the infecting strain and the vaccinia constructs used to test for responses may lead to non-recognition of some variants, even the highly conserved core protein appears to be an inconsistent and actually infrequent target for detectable CTL responses. The magnitude of the CTL response appears to vary greatly, from being undetectable to being so vigorous that it an be detected in stimulated peripheral blood. The breadth of the response also varies widely, ranging from the detection of a response to a single epitope in some persons, to the simultaneous recognition of up to five different epitopes in others. Even in persons of the same HLA type, we have not seen consistent targeting of the same epitopes except in rare cases. Despite the detection of over 20 epitopes and their restricting class I alleles using CTR derived from liver-infiltrating lymphocytes, we have identified only one epitope that has been shown to be targeted by more than one person of the same HLA type. These findings lead us to speculate that the CTL response may be submaximal in the majority of infected persons. The reasons for this are presently obscure, but could relate to a number of factors. The epitopes targeted are found within variable regions of the virus, such that immune escape from established CTL responses has to be considered a real possibility. Sequence variation may also lead to antagonism of CTL responses, as has been demonstrated for both HIV and HBV infections. Furthermore, sequence variation either within or adjacent to regions containing CTL epitopes can lead to altered antigen processing, either due to alteration of proteolytic processing of the viral peptides in the cytoplasm or to altered transport and altered association with class I molecules. A number of issues regarding the CTL response in HCV infection still require substantial attention. The apparent inability of CTL to clear this virus needs to be addressed, as does the potential role for viral immunomodulatory molecules in HCV persistence. Although we and others have shown CTL responses to be present in persons with chronic infection, the role of CTL in acute HCV infection needs to be determined. The best studied chronic human viral infection is HIV infection, in which expanding data indicate that the early events following primary infection predict the subsequent course of illness. Viral load in the first 1-2 years after infection is highly predictive of the subsequent disease course in HIV infection, and recent experimental data in humans suggest that early immune responses may be predictive of subsequent disease course. Such studies in HCV infection have been difficult to achieve, since primary HCV infection is often asymptomatic, and transfusion-related cases are now rare. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)

Comparative features of hepatitis C virus infection in humans and chimpanzees

Several features of human HCV infection are recapitulated in the chimpanzee model. Most importantly, the frequency of persistent infection is high in both species, and virus replication occurs despite evidence of cellular and humoral immune responses. A key difference is that necroinflammatory lesions in chronically infected chimpanzees are almost always mild, whereas in humans the disease spectrum is very wide, ranging from mild to severe hepatitis and end-stage cirrhosis requiring transplantation. Understanding the basis for both the similarities and differences in persistent hepatitis C in the two species will probably be important for the development of effective prevention and therapy of HCV infection.