The use of precision diagnostics for monogenic diabetes: a systematic review and expert opinion

BACKGROUND

Monogenic diabetes presents opportunities for precision medicine but is underdiagnosed. This review systematically assessed the evidence for (1) clinical criteria and (2) methods for genetic testing for monogenic diabetes, summarized resources for (3) considering a gene or (4) variant as causal for monogenic diabetes, provided expert recommendations for (5) reporting of results; and reviewed (6) next steps after monogenic diabetes diagnosis and (7) challenges in precision medicine field.

METHODS

Pubmed and Embase databases were searched (1990-2022) using inclusion/exclusion criteria for studies that sequenced one or more monogenic diabetes genes in at least 100 probands (Question 1), evaluated a non-obsolete genetic testing method to diagnose monogenic diabetes (Question 2). The risk of bias was assessed using the revised QUADAS-2 tool. Existing guidelines were summarized for questions 3-5, and review of studies for questions 6-7, supplemented by expert recommendations. Results were summarized in tables and informed recommendations for clinical practice.

RESULTS

There are 100, 32, 36, and 14 studies included for questions 1, 2, 6, and 7 respectively. On this basis, four recommendations for who to test and five on how to test for monogenic diabetes are provided. Existing guidelines for variant curation and gene-disease validity curation are summarized. Reporting by gene names is recommended as an alternative to the term MODY. Key steps after making a genetic diagnosis and major gaps in our current knowledge are highlighted.

CONCLUSIONS

We provide a synthesis of current evidence and expert opinion on how to use precision diagnostics to identify individuals with monogenic diabetes.

Second international consensus report on gaps and opportunities for the clinical translation of precision diabetes medicine

Precision medicine is part of the logical evolution of contemporary evidence-based medicine that seeks to reduce errors and optimize outcomes when making medical decisions and health recommendations. Diabetes affects hundreds of millions of people worldwide, many of whom will develop life-threatening complications and die prematurely. Precision medicine can potentially address this enormous problem by accounting for heterogeneity in the etiology, clinical presentation and pathogenesis of common forms of diabetes and risks of complications. This second international consensus report on precision diabetes medicine summarizes the findings from a systematic evidence review across the key pillars of precision medicine (prevention, diagnosis, treatment, prognosis) in four recognized forms of diabetes (monogenic, gestational, type 1, type 2). These reviews address key questions about the translation of precision medicine research into practice. Although not complete, owing to the vast literature on this topic, they revealed opportunities for the immediate or near-term clinical implementation of precision diabetes medicine; furthermore, we expose important gaps in knowledge, focusing on the need to obtain new clinically relevant evidence. Gaps include the need for common standards for clinical readiness, including consideration of cost-effectiveness, health equity, predictive accuracy, liability and accessibility. Key milestones are outlined for the broad clinical implementation of precision diabetes medicine.

A Systematic Review of the use of Precision Diagnostics in Monogenic Diabetes

Monogenic forms of diabetes present opportunities for precision medicine as identification of the underlying genetic cause has implications for treatment and prognosis. However, genetic testing remains inconsistent across countries and health providers, often resulting in both missed diagnosis and misclassification of diabetes type. One of the barriers to deploying genetic testing is uncertainty over whom to test as the clinical features for monogenic diabetes overlap with those for both type 1 and type 2 diabetes. In this review, we perform a systematic evaluation of the evidence for the clinical and biochemical criteria used to guide selection of individuals with diabetes for genetic testing and review the evidence for the optimal methods for variant detection in genes involved in monogenic diabetes. In parallel we revisit the current clinical guidelines for genetic testing for monogenic diabetes and provide expert opinion on the interpretation and reporting of genetic tests. We provide a series of recommendations for the field informed by our systematic review, synthesizing evidence, and expert opinion. Finally, we identify major challenges for the field and highlight areas for future research and investment to support wider implementation of precision diagnostics for monogenic diabetes.

Loss of RREB1 in pancreatic beta cells reduces cellular insulin content and affects endocrine cell gene expression

AIMS/HYPOTHESIS

Genome-wide studies have uncovered multiple independent signals at the RREB1 locus associated with altered type 2 diabetes risk and related glycaemic traits. However, little is known about the function of the zinc finger transcription factor Ras-responsive element binding protein 1 (RREB1) in glucose homeostasis or how changes in its expression and/or function influence diabetes risk.

METHODS

A zebrafish model lacking rreb1a and rreb1b was used to study the effect of RREB1 loss in vivo. Using transcriptomic and cellular phenotyping of a human beta cell model (EndoC-βH1) and human induced pluripotent stem cell (hiPSC)-derived beta-like cells, we investigated how loss of RREB1 expression and activity affects pancreatic endocrine cell development and function. Ex vivo measurements of human islet function were performed in donor islets from carriers of RREB1 type 2 diabetes risk alleles.

RESULTS

CRISPR/Cas9-mediated loss of rreb1a and rreb1b function in zebrafish supports an in vivo role for the transcription factor in beta cell mass, beta cell insulin expression and glucose levels. Loss of RREB1 also reduced insulin gene expression and cellular insulin content in EndoC-βH1 cells and impaired insulin secretion under prolonged stimulation. Transcriptomic analysis of RREB1 knockdown and knockout EndoC-βH1 cells supports RREB1 as a novel regulator of genes involved in insulin secretion. In vitro differentiation of RREB1KO/KO hiPSCs revealed dysregulation of pro-endocrine cell genes, including RFX family members, suggesting that RREB1 also regulates genes involved in endocrine cell development. Human donor islets from carriers of type 2 diabetes risk alleles in RREB1 have altered glucose-stimulated insulin secretion ex vivo, consistent with a role for RREB1 in regulating islet cell function.

CONCLUSIONS/INTERPRETATION

Together, our results indicate that RREB1 regulates beta cell function by transcriptionally regulating the expression of genes involved in beta cell development and function.

Genome-edited zebrafish model of ABCC8 loss-of-function disease

ATP-sensitive potassium channel (KATP)gain- (GOF) and loss-of-function (LOF) mutations underlie human neonatal diabetes mellitus (NDM) and hyperinsulinism (HI), respectively. While transgenic mice expressing incomplete KATP LOF do reiterate mild hyperinsulinism, KATP knockout animals do not exhibit persistent hyperinsulinism. We have shown that islet excitability and glucose homeostasis are regulated by identical KATP channels in zebrafish. SUR1 truncation mutation (K499X) was introduced into the abcc8 gene to explore the possibility of using zebrafish for modeling human HI. Patch-clamp analysis confirmed the complete absence of channel activity in β-cells from K499X (SUR1-/-) fish. No difference in random blood glucose was detected in heterozygous SUR1+/- fish nor in homozygous SUR1-/- fish, mimicking findings in SUR1 knockout mice. Mutant fish did, however, demonstrate impaired glucose tolerance, similar to partial LOF mouse models. In paralleling features of mammalian diabetes and hyperinsulinism resulting from equivalent LOF mutations, these gene-edited animals provide valid zebrafish models of KATP -dependent pancreatic diseases.

ATP-sensitive potassium channels in zebrafish cardiac and vascular smooth muscle

ATP-sensitive potassium channels (K_ATP channels) are hetero-octameric nucleotide-gated ion channels that couple cellular metabolism to excitability in various tissues. In the heart, K_ATP channels are activated during ischaemia and potentially during adrenergic stimulation. In the vasculature, they are normally active at a low level, reducing vascular tone, but the ubiquitous nature of these channels leads to complex and poorly understood channelopathies as a result of gain- or loss-of-function mutations. Zebrafish (ZF) models of these channelopathies may provide insights to the link between molecular dysfunction and complex pathophysiology, but this requires understanding the tissue dependence of channel activity and subunit specificity. Thus far, direct analysis of ZF K_ATP expression and functional properties has only been performed in pancreatic β-cells. Using a comprehensive combination of genetically modified fish, electrophysiology and gene expression analysis, we demonstrate that ZF cardiac myocytes (CM) and vascular smooth muscle (VSM) express functional K_ATP channels of similar subunit composition, structure and metabolic sensitivity to their mammalian counterparts. However, in contrast to mammalian cardiovascular K_ATP channels, ZF channels are insensitive to potassium channel opener drugs (pinacidil, minoxidil) in both chambers of the heart and in VSM. The results provide a first characterization of the molecular properties of fish K_ATP channels and validate the use of such genetically modified fish as models of human Cantú syndrome and ABCC9-related Intellectual Disability and Myopathy syndrome. KEY POINTS: Zebrafish cardiac myocytes (CM) and vascular smooth muscle (VSM) express functional K_ATP channels of similar subunit composition, structure and metabolic sensitivity to their mammalian counterparts. In contrast to mammalian cardiovascular K_ATP channels, zebrafish channels are insensitive to potassium channel opener drugs (pinacidil, minoxidil) in both chambers of the heart and in VSM. We provide a first characterization of the molecular properties of fish K_ATP channels and validate the use of such genetically modified fish as models of human Cantú syndrome and ABCC9-related Intellectual Disability and Myopathy syndrome.

100 YEARS OF INSULIN: A brief history of diabetes genetics: insights for pancreatic beta-cell development and function

Since the discovery of insulin 100 years ago, our knowledge and understanding of diabetes have grown exponentially. Specifically, with regards to the genetics underlying diabetes risk, our discoveries have paralleled developments in our understanding of the human genome and our ability to study genomics at scale; these advancements in genetics have both accompanied and led to those in diabetes treatment. This review will explore the timeline and history of gene discovery and how this has coincided with progress in the fields of genomics. Examples of genetic causes of monogenic diabetes are presented and the continuing expansion of allelic series in these genes and the challenges these now cause for diagnostic interpretation along with opportunities for patient stratification are discussed.

Beta-cell excitability and excitability-driven diabetes in adult Zebrafish islets

Islet β-cell membrane excitability is a well-established regulator of mammalian insulin secretion, and defects in β-cell excitability are linked to multiple forms of diabetes. Evolutionary conservation of islet excitability in lower organisms is largely unexplored. Here we show that adult zebrafish islet calcium levels rise in response to elevated extracellular [glucose], with similar concentration-response relationship to mammalian β-cells. However, zebrafish islet calcium transients are nor well coupled, with a shallower glucose-dependence of cytoplasmic calcium concentration. We have also generated transgenic zebrafish that conditionally express gain-of-function mutations in ATP-sensitive K+ channels (KATP -GOF) in β-cells. Following induction, these fish become profoundly diabetic, paralleling features of mammalian diabetes resulting from equivalent mutations. KATP -GOF fish become severely hyperglycemic, with slowed growth, and their islets lose glucose-induced calcium responses. These results indicate that, although lacking tight cell-cell coupling of intracellular Ca2+ , adult zebrafish islets recapitulate similar excitability-driven β-cell glucose responsiveness to those in mammals, and exhibit profound susceptibility to diabetes as a result of inexcitability. While illustrating evolutionary conservation of islet excitability in lower vertebrates, these results also provide important validation of zebrafish as a suitable animal model in which to identify modulators of islet excitability and diabetes.