Sonic hedgehog promotes stem-cell potential of Müller glia in the mammalian retina

Müller glia have been demonstrated to display stem-cell properties after retinal damage. Here, we report this potential can be regulated by Sonic hedgehog (Shh) signaling. Shh can stimulate proliferation of Müller glia through its receptor and target gene expressed on them, furthermore, Shh-treated Müller glia are induced to dedifferentiate by expressing progenitor-specific markers, and then adopt cell fate of rod photoreceptor. Inhibition of signaling by cyclopamine inhibits proliferation and dedifferentiation. Intraocular injection of Shh promotes Müller glia activation in the photoreceptor-damaged retina, Shh also enhances neurogenic potential by producing more rhodopsin-positive photoreceptors from Müller glia-derived cells. Together, these results provide evidences that Müller glia act as potential stem cells in mammalian retina, Shh may have therapeutic effects on these cells for promoting the regeneration of retinal neurons.

The Xenopus ortholog of the nuclear hormone receptor Nr2e3 is primarily expressed in developing photoreceptors

Nr2e3 is a nuclear hormone receptor that is involved in rod photoreceptor differentiation. The Nr2e3 gene was previously identified in humans, mice, zebrafish and chicken. In all species, Nr2e3 expression is restricted to the retina and is believed to have a role in rod photoreceptor specification and maintenance. Here we report the identification and characterization of the Xenopus Nr2e3. We found that Nr2e3 is primarily expressed in developing rod photoreceptors. In contrast to other species, Nr2e3 is also expressed in the notochord and pineal gland during Xenopus laevis development.

Phototransduction in mouse rods and cones

Phototransduction is the process by which light triggers an electrical signal in a photoreceptor cell. Image-forming vision in vertebrates is mediated by two types of photoreceptors: the rods and the cones. In this review, we provide a summary of the success in which the mouse has served as a vertebrate model for studying rod phototransduction, with respect to both the activation and termination steps. Cones are still not as well-understood as rods partly because it is difficult to work with mouse cones due to their scarcity and fragility. The situation may change, however.

The CNTF/LIF signaling pathway regulates developmental programmed cell death and differentiation of rod precursor cells in the mouse retina in vivo

Natural cell death is critical for normal development of the nervous system, but the extracellular regulators of developmental cell death remain poorly characterized. Here, we studied the role of the CNTF/LIF signaling pathway during mouse retinal development in vivo. We show that exposure to CNTF during neonatal retinal development in vivo retards rhodopsin expression and results in an important and specific deficit in photoreceptor cells. Detailed analysis revealed that exposure to CNTF during retinal development causes a sharp increase in cell death of postmitotic rod precursor cells. Importantly, we show that blocking the CNTF/LIF signaling pathway during mouse retinal development in vivo results in a significant reduction of naturally occurring cell death. Using retroviral lineage analysis, we demonstrate that exposure to CNTF causes a specific reduction of clones containing only rods without affecting other clone types, whereas blocking the CNTF/LIF receptor complex causes a specific increase of clones containing only rods. In addition, we show that stimulation of the CNTF/LIF pathway positively regulates the expression of the neuronal and endothelial nitric oxide synthase (NOS) genes, and blocking nitric oxide production by pre-treatment with a NOS inhibitor abolishes CNTF-induced cell death. Taken together, these results indicate that the CNTF/LIF signaling pathway acts via regulation of nitric oxide production to modulate developmental programmed cell death of postmitotic rod precursor cells.

Mosaic Eyes is a novel component of the Crumbs complex and negatively regulates photoreceptor apical size

Establishment of apical-basal cell polarity has emerged as an important process during development, and the Crumbs complex is a major component of this process in Drosophila. By comparison, little is known about the role of Crumbs (Crb) proteins in vertebrate development. We show that the FERM protein Mosaic Eyes (Moe) is a novel regulatory component of the Crumbs complex. Moe coimmunoprecipitates with Ome/Crb2a and Nok (Pals1) from adult eye and in vitro interaction experiments suggest these interactions are direct. Morpholino knockdown of ome/crb2a phenocopies the moe mutations. Moe and Crumbs proteins colocalize apically and this apical localization requires reciprocal protein function. By performing genetic mosaic analyses, we show that moe- rod photoreceptors have greatly expanded apical structures, suggesting that Moe is a negative regulator of Crumbs protein function in photoreceptors. We propose that Moe is a crucial regulator of Crumbs protein cell-surface abundance and localization in embryos.

Morphogenesis of the different types of photoreceptors of the chicken (Gallus domesticus) retina and the effect of amblyopia in neonatal chicken

Despite the great variety in chicken photoreceptors, existing morphogenetic studies only deal with two types: rods and cones. We have therefore examined by scanning electron microscopy the first appearance and maturation of different retinal photoreceptors in 36 chicken embryos (Gallus domesticus), aged 5-19 days prehatching. On day 5 of incubation, chicken retinae were only composed of proliferating ventricular cells devoid of photoreceptors. On day 8, outer mitotic cells were separated from inner differentiating photoreceptors, by the transient layer of Chievitz. Ball-like protrusions appeared at the ventricular surface, representing the first signs of photoreceptor inner segment formation. From day 10 onward, double cones, single cones, and rods could be clearly distinguished, and occasional cilia were detected at their tip. On day 12, inner segments had increased in length and diameter, and frequently carried a cilium representing the beginning of outer segment formation. On day 14, most photoreceptors displayed a distinct outer segment. On day 19, photoreceptors had essentially assumed adult morphology. Based on the shape of their outer segments, two subtypes of cones and three subtypes of double cones could be distinguished. Throughout development, we observed microvilli close to maturing photoreceptors, either originating from their lateral sides, from their tip, or from Müller cells. Microvillus density peaked between day 12 and 14, indicating an important role in photoreceptor morphogenesis. Unilateral occlusion of the eyes of posthatching chicken reduced the proportion of double cones to single cones in the retina, indicating dependence of retinal morphogenesis upon functional activity of visual cells.

The rod photoreceptor pattern is set at the optic vesicle stage and requires spatially restricted cVax expression

How and when positional identities in the neural retina are established have been addressed primarily with respect to the topographic projections of retinal ganglion cells onto their targets in the brain. Although retinotectal map formation is a prominent manifestation of retinal patterning, it is not the only one. Photoreceptor subtypes are arranged in distinct, species-specific patterns. The mechanisms used to establish photoreceptor patterns have been relatively unexplored at the mechanistic level. We performed ablations of the eye anlage in chickens and found that removal of the anterior or dorsal optic vesicle caused loss of the area centralis, which is a rod-free central area of the retina, and severely disorganized other aspects of the rod pattern. These observations indicate that the anteroposterior and dorsoventral distribution of rods is determined by the optic vesicle stage. To investigate the molecular mechanisms involved, the rod distribution was analyzed after viral misexpression of several patterning genes that were previously shown to be important in positional specification of retinal ganglion cells. Ectopic expression of FoxG1, SOHo1,or GH6 transcription factors expressed in the anterior optic vesicle and/or optic cup, respectively, did not affect the rod pattern. This pattern therefore appears to be specified by an activity acting before, or in parallel with, these factors. In contrast, misexpression of the ventrally restricted transcription factor, cVax, severely disturbed the rod pattern.

Transgenic mice expressing Cre-recombinase specifically in retinal rod bipolar neurons

PURPOSE

To establish a transgenic mouse line that expresses Cre-recombinase in retinal rod bipolar cells for the generation of rod bipolar cell-specific knockout mutants.

METHODS

The IRES-Cre-cDNA fragment was inserted into a 173-kb bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) carrying the intact Pcp2 gene, by using red-mediated recombineering. Transgenic mice were generated with the modified BAC and identified. The Cre-transgenic mice were crossed with ROSA26 and Z/EG reporter mice to detect Cre-recombinase activity.

RESULTS

X-gal staining showed that strong Cre-recombinase activities were present in retinal inner nuclear layers and cerebellar Purkinje cells. Double staining with an anti-GFP antibody and an anti-PKCalpha antibody (specific for retinal rod bipolar cells) revealed that Cre-recombinase activity localized exclusively to the rod bipolar cells in the retina.

CONCLUSIONS

A mouse BAC-Pcp2-IRES-Cre transgenic line that expresses Cre-recombinase in retinal rod bipolar neurons has been established. Because mutations in some ubiquitously expressed genes may result in retinal degenerative diseases, the mouse strain BAC-Pcp2-IRES-Cre will be a useful new tool for investigating the effects of retinal rod bipolar cell-specific gene inactivation.

GDF11 controls the timing of progenitor cell competence in developing retina

The orderly generation of cell types in the developing retina is thought to be regulated by changes in the competence of multipotent progenitors. Here, we show that a secreted factor, growth and differentiation factor 11 (GDF11), controls the numbers of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs), as well as amacrine and photoreceptor cells, that form during development. GDF11 does not affect proliferation of progenitors-a major mode of GDF11 action in other tissues-but instead controls duration of expression of Math5, a gene that confers competence for RGC genesis, in progenitor cells. Thus, GDF11 governs the temporal windows during which multipotent progenitors retain competence to produce distinct neural progeny.

Notch-Delta signaling is required for spatial patterning and Müller glia differentiation in the zebrafish retina

Notch-Delta signaling has been implicated in several alternative modes of function in the vertebrate retina. To further investigate these functions, we examined retinas from zebrafish embryos in which bidirectional Notch-Delta signaling was inactivated either by the mind bomb (mib) mutation, which disrupts E3 ubiquitin ligase activity, or by treatment with gamma-secretase inhibitors, which prevent intramembrane proteolysis of Notch and Delta. We found that inactivating Notch-Delta signaling did not prevent differentiation of retinal neurons, but it did disrupt spatial patterning in both the apical-basal and planar dimensions of the retinal epithelium. Retinal neurons differentiated, but their laminar arrangement was disrupted. Photoreceptor differentiation was initiated normally, but its progression was slowed. Although confined to the apical retinal surface as in normal retinas, the planar organization of cone photoreceptors was disrupted: cones of the same spectral subtype were clumped rather than regularly spaced. In contrast to neurons, Müller glia failed to differentiate suggesting an instructive role for Notch-Delta signaling in gliogenesis.

Developmental regulation of calcium-dependent feedback in Xenopus rods

The kinetics of activation and inactivation in the phototransduction pathway of developing Xenopus rods were studied. The gain of the activation steps in transduction (amplification) increased and photoresponses became more rapid as the rods matured from the larval to the adult stage. The time to peak was significantly shorter in adults (1.3 s) than tadpoles (2 s). Moreover, adult rods recovered twice as fast from saturating flashes than did larval rods without changes of the dominant time constant (2.5 s). Guanylate cyclase (GC) activity, determined using IBMX steps, increased in adult rods from ∼1.1 s⁻¹ to 3.7 s⁻¹ 5 s after a saturating flash delivering 6,000 photoisomerizations. In larval rods, it increased from 1.8 s⁻¹ to 4.0 s⁻¹ 9 s after an equivalent flash. However, the ratio of amplification to the measured dark phosphodiesterase activity was constant. Guanylate cyclase–activating protein (GCAP1) levels and normalized Na⁺/Ca²⁺, K⁺ exchanger currents were increased in adults compared with tadpoles. Together, these results are consistent with the acceleration of the recovery phase in adult rods via developmental regulation of calcium homeostasis. Despite these large changes, the single photon response amplitude was ∼0.6 pA throughout development. Reduction of calcium feedback with BAPTA increased adult single photon response amplitudes threefold and reduced its cutoff frequency to that observed with tadpole rods. Linear mathematical modeling suggests that calcium-dependent feedback can account for the observed differences in the power spectra of larval and adult rods. We conclude that larval Xenopus maximize sensitivity at the expense of slower response kinetics while adults maximize response kinetics at the expense of sensitivity.

The transcription factor Bhlhb4 is required for rod bipolar cell maturation

Retinal bipolar cells are essential to the transmission of light information. Although bipolar cell dysfunction can result in blindness, little is known about the factors required for bipolar cell development and functional maturation. The basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) transcription factor Bhlhb4 was found to be expressed in rod bipolar cells (RB). Electroretinograms (ERGs) in the adult Bhlhb4 knockout (Bhlhb4(-/-)) showed that the loss of Bhlhb4 resulted in disrupted rod signaling and profound retinal dysfunction resembling human congenital stationary night blindness (CSNB), characterized by the loss of the scotopic ERG b-wave. A depletion of inner nuclear layer (INL) cells in the adult Bhlhb4 knockout has been ascribed to the abolishment of the RB cell population during postnatal development. Other retinal cell populations including photoreceptors were unaltered. The timing of RB cell depletion in the Bhlhb4(-/-) mouse suggests that Bhlhb4 is essential for RB cell maturation.

The Expression of the Leber Congenital Amaurosis Protein AIPL1 Coincides with Rod and Cone Photoreceptor Development

PURPOSE

The Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA) protein AIPL1 is present only in the rod photoreceptors of the adult human retina and is excluded from the cone photoreceptors. LCA, however, is characterized by an absence of both rod and cone function at birth or shortly thereafter. Therefore, this study was conducted to determine whether AIPL1 is present in the rod and cone photoreceptors of the developing human retina. In addition, the expression of NUB1, a putative AIPL1-interacting partner, was examined.

METHODS

A comprehensive spatiotemporal examination of AIPL1 distribution during development was performed by immunohistochemistry, using a previously characterized AIPL1 anti-serum. Immunofluorescence confocal microscopy was used to examine the coexpression of AIPL1 with the long/medium (L/M) and short (S) wavelength-sensitive cone photoreceptors in the developing human retina. The spatiotemporal distribution of NUB1 was also examined by immunohistochemistry, using a newly developed anti-serum to the C terminus of NUB1.

RESULTS

AIPL1 protein was detected by 11.8 fetal weeks in the central fetal human retina. With continued development, AIPL1 expression spread gradually toward peripheral retina. AIPL1 was expressed in the L/M and S cone photoreceptors in addition to the rods of the developing human retina. NUB1 was localized in cell nuclei throughout the human fetal and adult eye at all time points.

CONCLUSIONS

The pattern of AIPL1 expression closely follows the centroperipheral gradient in photoreceptor development. The data suggest that AIPL1 is essential for the normal development of both rod and cone photoreceptor cells and that mutations in the AIPL1 gene cause the death or dysfunction of photoreceptors early in development resulting in blindness or severely impaired vision at birth.

Investigation of the migration path for new rod photoreceptors in the adult cichlid fish retina

In the retina of adult teleost, precursor cells divide in the outer nuclear layer and give rise to new rod photoreceptors. These new rods migrate from the outer limiting membrane to the inner edge of the outer nuclear layer (ONL) before differentiating. In order to understand which cues these cells use during migration and insertion at the appropriate location we combined cell-specific stains in the retina of the cichlid fish Haplochromis burtoni, viewed with confocal laserscan microscopy: Dividing cells were labeled with bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU), Müller glial cells, cone photoreceptors, and horizontal cells were detected by specific antibodies. During the migration phase (24 to 48 h after BrdU uptake) up to 46% of BrdU-labeled cells were spindle shaped and radially oriented. Most of them were in direct proximity to Müller cell processes. Four days after BrdU-uptake, most labeled cells (91%) were found in the inner portion of the ONL and displayed a spherical shape. This marks the end of the movement of the new rods. At this stage, the labeled cells showed no preference to lie near glial fibers but were often found close to the pedicles of double cones. The leading edge of migrating cells reached into the outer plexiform layer (OPL) but not further than processes of horizontal cells. This is beyond the location of mature rods. We hypothesize that the cells are repelled in the OPL and insert back in the ONL to differentiate as rods.

GDNF regulates chicken rod photoreceptor development and survival in reaggregated histotypic retinal spheres

PURPOSE

To investigate the role of glial-cell-line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) on proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis of different retinal cell types--in particular, photoreceptor cells.

METHODS

Reaggregated histotypic spheres, derived from retinal cells of the E6 chicken embryo were used. Under rotation, so-called rosetted spheroids arose by aggregation of dissociated retinal cells, followed by the proliferation, migration, differentiation and programmed cell death of particular cell types. Rosetted spheroids were cultured under serum-reduced conditions, either in the absence or presence of 50 ng/mL GDNF. At appropriate stages, rosetted spheroids were analyzed by using conventional staining and immunolabeling with antibodies against different retinal cell types.

RESULTS

At early stages of culture, the application of GDNF to rosetted spheroids significantly increased and sustained the rate of proliferation. In particular, a de novo production of rod photoreceptors was observed, whereas cone photoreceptors and amacrine, horizontal, ganglion, and Müller cells were not affected. In addition, in GDNF-treated cultures, rod photoreceptors differentiated earlier than in nontreated cultures. In older rosetted spheroids raised in absence of GDNF, rod but not cone photoreceptors underwent apoptosis. By supplementation with GDNF, the percentage of dying rod photoreceptors was dramatically reduced (31%-6% at 8 days in culture, 71%-3% at 10 days in culture). Both the mitogenic and survival promoting effect of GDNF were dose dependent.

CONCLUSIONS

The results strongly suggest that GDNF, at least in vitro, affects rod photoreceptors. Depending on the developmental stage, GDNF regulates their proliferation, differentiation, and survival.

Visualization of rod photoreceptor development using GFP-transgenic zebrafish

Zebrafish retina contains five morphologically distinct classes of photoreceptors, each expressing a distinct type of opsin gene. Molecular mechanisms underlying specification of opsin expression and differentiation among the cell types are largely unknown. This is partly because mutants affected with expression of a particular class of opsin gene are difficult to find. In this study we established the transgenic lines of zebrafish carrying green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene under the 1.1-kb and 3.7-kb upstream regions of the rod-opsin gene. In transgenic fish, GFP expression initiated and proceeded in the same spatiotemporal pattern with rod-opsin gene. The retinal section from adult transgenic fish showed GFP expression throughout the rod cell layer. These results indicate that the proximal 1.1-kb region is sufficient to drive gene expression in all rod photoreceptor cells. These transgenic fish should facilitate screening of mutants affected specifically with rod-opsin expression or rod cell development by visualization of rod cells by GFP.

Photoreceptor plasticity in reaggregates of embryonic chick retina: rods depend on proximal cones and on tissue organization

Plasticity of photoreceptors and their integration into epithelial structures homologous to an outer nuclear layer (ONL), was investigated in embryonic chick retinal cell reaggregates by immunohistochemistry using an antibody specific for red plus green cones (RG-cones) and an antibody for rods. If reaggregates are raised in the presence of pigmented epithelium (RPE), completely reconstructed, stratified retinal spheres are produced, where all rods and cones are integrated into an outer laminar ONL, similar to a normal retina. In the absence of RPE, 'rosetted' spheres form which contain internal rosettes homologous to an ONL. Only a minor fraction of cones and rods of 'rosetted' spheres are located within rosettes, while a larger fraction is diffusely displaced in nonorganized areas, thus, not contributing to an ONL-like epithelium. In both types of spheres, the total percentage of RG-cones was similar to the in vivo retina, indicating that expression of cones is autonomous. Following cones, after about one day, rods developed only within already existing RG-cone clusters. Thereby, the ratio of rods to RG-cones increases as the tissue organization decreases: for stratified spheres this ratio is, 0.50 (1 rod/2 cones; similar to mature retina); for rosettes, 0.74 (3 rods/4 cones) and for nonorganized areas, 1.09 (1 rod/1 cone) -- a higher ratio under our conditions has never been detected. Thus, rod expression depends strictly on the presence of nearby cones; their relative numbers are distinctively adjusted according to the cytoarchitecture of the tissue environment. The biomedical implications of these findings are briefly discussed.

Fra-1 replaces c-Fos-dependent functions in mice

Structure-function analysis as well as studies with knock-out and transgenic mice have assigned distinct functions to c-Fos and Fra-1, two components of the transcription factor AP-1 (activator protein-1). To test whether Fra-1 could substitute for c-Fos, we generated knock-in mice that express Fra-1 in place of c-Fos. Fra-1 rescues c-Fos-dependent functions such as bone development and light-induced photoreceptor apoptosis. Importantly, rescue of bone cell differentiation, but not photoreceptor apoptosis, is gene-dosage dependent. Moreover, Fra-1 fails to substitute for c-Fos in inducing expression of target genes in fibroblasts. These results show that c-Fos and Fra-1 have maintained functional equivalence during vertebrate evolution.

The bHLH gene Hes6, an inhibitor of Hes1, promotes neuronal differentiation

We have isolated the basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) gene Hes6, a novel member of the family of mammalian homologues of Drosophila hairy and Enhancer of split. Hes6 is expressed by both undifferentiated and differentiated cells, unlike Hes1, which is expressed only by the former cells. Hes6 alone does not bind to the DNA but suppresses Hes1 from repressing transcription. In addition, Hes6 suppresses Hes1 from inhibiting Mash1-E47 heterodimer and thereby enables Mash1 and E47 to upregulate transcription in the presence of Hes1. Furthermore, misexpression of Hes6 with retrovirus in the developing retina promotes rod photoreceptor differentiation, like Mash1, in sharp contrast to Hes1, which inhibits cell differentiation. These results suggest that Hes6 is an inhibitor of Hes1, supports Mash1 activity and promotes cell differentiation. Mutation analysis revealed that Hes1- and Hes6-specific functions are, at least in part, interchangeable by alteration of the loop region, suggesting that the loop is not simply a nonfunctional spacer but plays an important role in the specific functions.

The subcellular localization of Otx2 is cell-type specific and developmentally regulated in the mouse retina

Recent evidence implicates homeodomain-containing proteins in the specification of cell fates in the central nervous system. Here we report that in the embryonic mouse eye Otx2, a paired homeodomain transcription factor, was found in retinal pigment epithelial cells and a restricted subset of retinal neurons, including ganglion cells. In the postnatal and adult eye, however, both the cellular and subcellular distribution of the Otx2 protein were cell type-specific. Otx2 was detected only in the nuclei of retinal pigment epithelial and bipolar cells, but was present in the cytoplasm of rod photoreceptors. Immunohistochemical studies of retinal explants and transfected cell lines both suggested that the retention of Otx2 in the cytoplasm of immature rods is a developmentally regulated process. The differential distribution of Otx2 in the cytoplasm of rods and the nucleus of other cell types, suggests that subcellular localization of this transcription factor may participate cell fate determination during specific phases of retinal development.

Function for Hedgehog genes in zebrafish retinal development

The hedgehog (hh) genes encode secreted signaling proteins that have important developmental functions in vertebrates and invertebrates. In Drosophila, expression of hh coordinates retinal development by propagating a wave of photoreceptor differentiation across the eye primordium. Here we report that two vertebrate hh genes, sonic hedgehog (shh) and tiggy-winkle hedgehog (twhh), may perform similar functions in the developing zebrafish. Both shh and twhh are expressed in the embryonic zebrafish retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE), initially in a discrete ventral patch which then expands outward in advance of an expanding wave of photoreceptor recruitment in the subjacent neural retina. A gene encoding a receptor for the hedgehog protein, ptc-2, is expressed by retinal neuroepithelial cells. Injection of a cocktail of antisense (alphashh/alphatwhh) oligonucleotides reduces expression of both hh genes in the RPE and slows or arrests the progression of rod and cone photoreceptor differentiation. Zebrafish strains known to have mutations in Hh signaling pathway genes similarly exhibit retardation of photoreceptor differentiation. We propose that hedgehog genes may play a role in propagating photoreceptor differentiation across the developing eye of the zebrafish.

Late retinal progenitor cells show intrinsic limitations in the production of cell types and the kinetics of opsin synthesis

The seven major cell classes of the vertebrate neural retina arise from a pool of multipotent progenitor cells. Several studies suggest a model of retinal development in which both the environment and the progenitor cells themselves change over time (). To test this model, we used a reaggregate culture system in which a labeled population of progenitor cells from the postnatal rat retina were cultured with an excess of embryonic retinal cells. The labeled cells were then assayed for their cell fate choices and their kinetics of rod differentiation, as measured by opsin synthesis. The kinetics of opsin synthesis remained unchanged, but fewer postnatal cells adopted the rod cell fate when cultured with embryonic cells. There was an increase in the percentage of bipolar cells produced by postnatal progenitor cells, indicating a possible respecification of fate. The increase in bipolar cells could occur even after progenitor cells had completed their terminal mitoses. These alterations in cell fates appeared to be caused at least in part by a secreted factor released by the embryonic cells that requires the LIFRbeta/gp130 complex for signaling. Finally, although surrounded by 20-fold more embryonic cells, the postnatal cells did not choose to adopt any fates normally produced only by embryonic cells.

Soluble factors and the development of rod photoreceptors

Photoreceptors are the most abundant cell type in the vertebrate neural retina. Like the other retinal neurons and the Müller glia, they arise from a population of precursor cells that are multipotent and intrinsic to the retina. Approximately 10 years ago, several studies demonstrated that retinal precursor cells (RPCs) are competent to respond to environmental factors that promote cell type determination and differentiation. Since those studies, significant effort has been directed at identifying the molecular nature of these environmental signals and understanding the precise mechanisms they employ to drive RPCs towards the different retinal fates. In this review, we describe the recent progress toward understanding how environmental factors influence the development of vertebrate rod photoreceptors.

Activin A promotes progenitor differentiation into photoreceptors in rodent retina

Activins are TGF beta-like proteins that were first discovered for their actions on the reproductive system, but have subsequently been shown to play a role in a variety of developmental processes. Previous studies have demonstrated that activins and their receptors are present in the developing retina, as well as other regions of the embryonic nervous system. We used both in vitro and in vivo approaches to test for functions of activin during retinal development. We found that activin A treatment of embryonic day 18 rat retinal cultures causes the progenitor cells in the cultures to exit the cell cycle and differentiate into rod photoreceptors. This effect is dose-dependent and the promotion of rod photoreceptor differentiation is specific, since the other primary retinal neurons generated in these cultures, the C1+ amacrine cells, are not affected by activin A treatment. Mice with homozygous deletion of the activin betaA gene show a specific decrease in the number of rod photoreceptors compared to wild-type or heterozygous littermates. These data demonstrate that activin A is an important regulator of photoreceptor differentiation in the developing retina.

Role of nitric oxide in photoreceptor survival in embryonic chick retinal cell culture

The presence of nitric oxide synthase (NOS) in chick retina during development has allowed us to study the role of nitric oxide (NO) during retinal differentiation in dissociated chick retinal cell culture from embryonic day 6. We have demonstrated the presence of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate diaphorase staining in these cultures after 3 days in vitro (Div), with a maximal intensity after 8 Div, corresponding to embryonic day 14. Immunohistochemistry studies confirmed the presence of the two isoforms of NOS, NOS-I and -III, in dissociated retinal cell cultures at 8 Div. Addition of NG-monomethyl-L-arginine, a NOS inhibitor, to retinal cell cultures prevented NO production but did not modify the appearance and the survival of ganglion and amacrine cells. However, immunohistochemical analysis with distinct markers for photoreceptor cells (rods and cones) showed that inhibition of endogenous NOS in retinal cell cultures prevented the developmental decrease of rod number between 5 and 8 Div, thus supporting the hypothesis that NO may be involved in the cell death of rods during the development of the retina.

A transient role for ciliary neurotrophic factor in chick photoreceptor development

Previous studies suggest that ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) may represent one of the extrinsic signals controlling the development of vertebrate retinal photoreceptors. In dissociated cultures from embryonic chick retina, exogenously applied CNTF has been shown to act on postmitotic rod precursor cells, resulting in an two- to fourfold increase in the number of cells acquiring an opsin-positive phenotype. We now demonstrate that the responsiveness of photoreceptor precursors to CNTF is confined to a brief phase between their final mitosis and their terminal differentiation owing to the temporally restricted expression of the CNTF receptor (CNTFR alpha). As shown immunocytochemically, CNTFR alpha expression in the presumptive photoreceptor layer of the chick retina starts at embryonic day 8 (E8) and is rapidly down-regulated a few days later prior to the differentiation of opsin-positive photoreceptors, both in vivo and in dissociated cultures from E8. We further show that the CNTF-dependent in vitro differentiation of rods is followed by a phase of photoreceptor-specific apoptotic cell death. The loss of differentiated rods during this apoptotic phase can be prevented by micromolar concentrations of retinol. Our results provide evidence that photoreceptor development depends on the sequential action of different extrinsic signals. The time course of CNTFR alpha expression and the in vitro effects suggest that CNTF or a related molecule is required during early stages of rod differentiation, while differentiated rods depend on additional protective factors for survival.

Cell death precedes rod neurogenesis in embryonic teleost retinal development

We measured cell death in the retinas of embryonic and adult teleost fish using TUNEL staining. Following a wave of cell birth during embryogenesis that generates all retinal cell types except rods, cell death occurs in all three nuclear layers. The lack of a corresponding pattern of cell death in the growing adult margin suggests different roles for death during embryogenesis and adult neurogenesis.

The role of NeuroD as a differentiation factor in the mammalian retina

NeuroD, a vertebrate homolog of Drosophila atonal gene, plays an important role in the differentiation of neuronal precursors (Lee et al., 1995). We have investigated whether NeuroD subserves a similar function in mammalian retinal neurogenesis. Expression of NeuroD is detected in successive stages of retinal neurogenesis and is associated with a differentiating population of retinal cells. The association of NeuroD predominantly with postmitotic precursors in early as well as late neurogenesis suggests that NeuroD expression plays an important role in the terminal differentiation of retinal neurons. The notion is supported by observations that overexpression of NeuroD during late neurogenesis promotes premature differentiation of late-born neurons, rod photoreceptors, and bipolar cells, and that NeuroD can interact specifically with the E-box element in the proximal promoter of the phenotype-specific gene, opsin.

Photoreceptor morphogenesis in the human retina: a scanning electron microscopic study

There are a number of scanning electron microscopic (SEM) studies on retinal photoreceptors of vertebrates. However, most of these are concerned with the adult retina, and only a very few deal with developing photoreceptors. In man, SEM studies have not been carried out on photoreceptor morphogenesis during fetal or postnatal stages. Hence, the present study was undertaken to examine the sequential morphological changes in developing photoreceptors during different gestational ages in the human retina. Retinas of human fetuses of gestational ages of 10-25 weeks and from autopsy of a 5-month-old infant were processed for SEM. The observations show some new information on the morphogenesis of photoreceptors. At 10-11 weeks, the outer and inner neuroblastic zones are well developed and separated from each other by the layer of Chievitz. By 15-16 weeks, the photoreceptor precursors appear as spherical inner segments on the scleral surface of the outer neuroblastic zone. Cilia develop as small protrusions from the apical ends of the inner segments. Photoreceptor inner segments become arranged in mosaic pattern by 18-19 weeks. In the mosaic, large cone inner segments (putative blue cones) stand out prominently from the remaining small cone inner segments (prospective red/green cones). The rod inner segments are identifiable and show cilia. Between 19-20 and 24-25 weeks, the cone inner segments elongate and change in shape from spherical to oval. At 24-25 weeks, the outer segments develop from the distal ends of rod cilia. At this period, the inner segments of rods and cones are interconnected by protoplasmic projections. Although the precursors of both rods and cones appear to be in a similar state of development at 14-15 weeks gestation, the rods undergo morphological maturation earlier than do the cones. Photoreceptor development in the anterior retina lags behind that of the posterior retina by about 10 weeks. At 5 months after birth, the posterior retina possesses fully developed photoreceptors that are comparable to those of the adult. However, the photoreceptors in the ora serrata resemble those in the posterior retina of 24-25 weeks gestation.

The embryogenesis of rod photoreceptors in the teleost fish retina, Haplochromis burtoni

Development of the retina, like that of other tissues, occurs via an orderly sequence of cell division and differentiation, producing the functional retina. In teleost fish, however, cell division and differentiation in the retina continue throughout the life of the animal in two distinct ways. Stem cells in a circumferential germinal zone at the periphery of the retina give rise to all retinal cell types and progenitor cells located throughout the retina in the outer nuclear layer (ONL) produce new rod photoreceptors. These processes in adult retina recapitulate in space the embryonic events responsible for forming the retina. Analysis of these events in an African cichlid fish, Haplochromis burtoni, confirmed that cone photoreceptors differentiate first, followed by rod photoreceptors. Correspondingly, at the margin of the eye, cone photoreceptors differentiate nearer to the margin than do rods. Control of photoreceptor production is not understood. Here we present the time of appearance and distribution pattern of GABA and vimentin which are candidates for the control of retinal cell division and differentiation. Antibody staining reveals that both GABA and vimentin exhibit unique patterns of expression during embryonic retinal development. Vimentin immunoreactivity is evident throughout the retina in a spoke-like pattern between developmental Days 4 and 7, as both cone and rod photoreceptors are being formed. GABA is expressed in horizontal cells between Days 5 and 7, corresponding to the onset of rod differentiation in time and in position within the retina. Moreover, the wave of GABAergic staining in the horizontal cells parallels the wave of rod differentiation across the embryonic retina of H. burtoni. Thus, GABA may play a role in the development of rod photoreceptors.

Muller-cell-derived leukaemia inhibitory factor arrests rod photoreceptor differentiation at a postmitotic pre-rod stage of development

In the present study, we examine rod photoreceptor development in dissociated-cell cultures of neonatal mouse retina. We show that, although very few rhodopsin+ rods develop in the presence of 10% foetal calf serum (FCS), large numbers develop in the absence of serum, but only if the cell density in the cultures is high. The rods all develop from nondividing rhodopsin- cells, and new rods continue to develop from rhodopsin- cells for at least 6–8 days, indicating that there can be a long delay between when a precursor cell withdraws from the cell cycle and when it becomes a rhodopsin+ rod. We show that FCS arrests rod development in these cultures at a postmitotic, rhodopsin-, pre-rod stage. We present evidence that FCS acts indirectly by stimulating the proliferation of Muller cells, which arrest rod differentiation by releasing leukaemia inhibitory factor (LIF). These findings identify an inhibitory cell-cell interaction, which may help to explain the long delay that can occur both in vitro and in vivo between cell-cycle withdrawal and rhodopsin expression during rod development.

Subsets of retinal progenitors display temporally regulated and distinct biases in the fates of their progeny

Cell fate determination in the developing vertebrate retina is characterized by the sequential generation of seven classes of cells by multipotent progenitor cells. Despite this order of genesis, more than one cell type is generated at any time; for example, in the rat, several cell types are born during the prenatal period, while others are born postnatally. In order to examine whether there are classes of progenitor cells with distinct developmental properties contributing to this developmental progression, we examined antigen expression in progenitor cells during rat retinal development. Two markers of amacrine and horizontal cells, the VC1.1 epitope and syntaxin, were found to be expressed on a subset of progenitors in a temporally regulated manner that closely paralleled the birthdays of these cell types. In order to investigate which cell types were produced by the progenitors expressing these markers, fluorescent latex microspheres covalently coupled to VC1.1 antibodies were used to indelibly label VC1.1+ progenitor cells and their progeny. Early in retinal development, VC1.1+ progenitors generated a high percentage of amacrine and horizontal cells, but no cone photoreceptors. During this same period, a comparable number of cone photoreceptors were generated by VC1.1- progenitors. In the late embryonic and early postnatal period, VC1.1+ progenitors continued to generate predominantly amacrine cells, but also gave rise to an increasing number of rod photoreceptors. These findings demonstrate that expression of these two markers by progenitors is highly correlated with a bias towards the production of amacrine and horizontal cells. The fact that subsets of progenitors with temporally regulated and distinct biases are intermingled within the retinal neuroepithelium provides a basis for understanding how different cell types are generated both simultaneously and in a particular order by multipotent progenitors during retinal development.

Retinoic acid alters photoreceptor development in vivo

Application of exogenous retinoic acid (RA) to zebrafish during the initial stages of photoreceptor differentiation results in a precocious development of rod photoreceptors and an inhibition of cone photoreceptor maturation. The acceleration of rod differentiation is observed initially within the ventral retina 3 days after fertilization, following 24 hr of RA application, and within the dorsal retina 4 days after fertilization, following 48 hr of RA application. The differentiation of rods was impeded significantly when the synthesis of endogenous retinoic acid was inhibited by citral prior to the initial stage of rod differentiation. RA-treated embryos labeled for bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) uptake revealed that RA exerts its effect on a postmitotic cell population within the developing retina. During normal development in zebrafish, rod differentiation is most robust within the ventral retina, a region previously shown to be rich in RA. Our data suggest that the RA signaling pathway is involved in the differentiation and maturation of both the rod and cone photoreceptors within the developing zebrafish retina.

Developmental expression of laminin beta 2 in rat retina. Further support for a role in rod morphogenesis

PURPOSE

The authors previously hypothesized that laminin beta 2 (S-laminin) plays a role in directing photoreceptor development. The aim of this study was to examine the temporal and spatial expression pattern of beta 2 laminins in rat retina to test this hypothesis.

METHODS

Retinas from Sprague-Dawley rats were harvested on embryonic days (E) 14, 16, and 21, as well as on postnatal days (P) 2, 5, and 10. Cryostat sections were probed with antibodies directed against beta 2 laminin, laminin-1 (alpha 1-beta 1-gamma 1), and von Willebrand factor.

RESULTS

At the onset of rod photoreceptor birth (E14), laminin beta 2 surrounds the cells of the retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE) and is present on the apical surface of the retinal neuroepithelium. At E16, laminin beta 2 persists on the apical surface of the neuroepithelium and the subjacent apical surface of the RPE. At birth, laminin beta 2 fills the matrix between the juxtaposed surfaces of the RPE and neuroepithelium; moreover, laminin beta 2 immunoreactivity penetrates the neural retina. Throughout postnatal development, laminin beta 2 immunoreactivity surrounds maturing inner and outer segments. Laminin beta 2 also is found in association with blood vessels in the neural retina itself, as well as with choroidal blood vessels; in both places, it is co-localized with an endothelial marker, von Willebrand factor, and laminin-1.

CONCLUSIONS

The spatial and temporal expression of laminin beta 2 is consistent with its hypothesized role in rod development. Laminin beta 2 is in a unique position to interact with mitotically active cells (in early retinal development), uncommitted progenitors (in late embryonic development), developing rods (in early postnatal development), and mature outer segments (throughout adulthood). Together with our earlier functional data, these data support our hypothesis that this molecule is an important component of the interphotoreceptor matrix.

Cell fate determination in the vertebrate retina

In the vertebrate central nervous system, the retina has been a useful model for studies of cell fate determination. Recent results from studies conducted in vitro and in vivo suggest a model of retinal development in which both the progenitor cells and the environment change over time. The model is based upon the notion that the mitotic cells within the retina change in their response properties, or "competence", during development. These changes presage the ordered appearance of distinct cell types during development and appear to be necessary for the production of the distinct cell types. As the response properties of the cells change, so too do the environmental signals that the cells encounter. Together, intrinsic properties and extrinsic cues direct the choice of cell fate.

The appearance of rod opsin during monkey retinal development

PURPOSE

To determine the temporal and spatial pattern of rod opsin appearance in Macaca monkey retina.

METHODS

Frozen sections from fetal day (Fd) 55 to adulthood (birth = Fd168) containing the entire horizontal meridian were stained using Rho4D2 monoclonal antiserum visualized with immunofluorescent labeling. At Fd66, Fd79, and Fd89, retinal samples taken at known eccentricities were studied from the opposite eye using standard electron microscope methods.

RESULTS

Rod opsin was detected at Fd66 in or near the fovea, and a second focus appeared at Fd75 to Fd77 near the optic disc in the nasal rod ring. The earliest opsin appeared in the apical stubs, which resembled the apical connecting cilium in the electron microscope. Staining of the entire cell body membrane, including the synaptic spherule, was present 4 to 7 days later. Opsin expression had a nasal bias with rods at the nasal ora labeled at Fd140, whereas temporal ora was not labeled until Fd155. Cell body labeling disappeared by Fd132 across central retina but persisted into the first postnatal year in far peripheral retina. Outer segment (OS) length measurements showed that rods in the rod ring had the longest OS between Fd115 and postnatal week 9. Rod OS at all retinal eccentricites continued to elongate between 11 months of age and adulthood.

CONCLUSIONS

Rod opsin expression follows a foveal-to-peripheral gradient beginning at Fd66 and ending near birth. Rod opsin is detected first in the connecting cilium and slightly later in the entire cell membrane, and then cell membrane labeling disappears as the heavily labeled OS elongates. Although the first OS appear on rods near the fovea, these OS still are short at birth and do not reach adult length until after 2 years of age. The longest OS at birth are found on rods at the rod ring, suggesting that this region could have higher scotopic sensitivity than central retina at birth.

Ciliary neurotrophic factor promotes chick photoreceptor development in vitro

Previous in vitro studies have convincingly demonstrated the involvement of diffusible factors in the regulation of photoreceptor development. We now provide evidence that ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) represents one of these regulatory molecules. In low density monolayer cultures prepared from embryonic day 8 chick retina, photoreceptor development was studied using the monoclonal antiopsin antibody rho-4D2 as a differentiation marker. The number of cells acquiring opsin immunoreactivity, determined after 3 days in vitro, was increased up to 4-fold in the presence of CNTF to maximally 10.5% of all cells. Basic fibroblast growth factor or taurine both of which have been reported to stimulate opsin expression in rat retinal cultures and other neurotrophic factors tested (nerve growth factor, brain derived neurotrophic factor) had no effect. The EC50 of the CNTF effect (2.6 pM) was virtually identical to that measured for other CNTF receptor mediated cellular responses. Conditioned medium produced by cultured retinal cells (most likely glial cells) exhibited opsin stimulating activity identical to that of CNTF. Stimulation of opsin expression was specific for morphologically less mature photoreceptors and obviously restricted to rods, since changes in the number of identifiable cone photoreceptors expressing opsin immunoreactivity (10% of all cones) were not detectable. Measurement of the kinetics of the CNTF response revealed that the factor acted on immature opsin-negative progenitors and that CNTF effects were unlikely to reflect enhanced cell survival. Proliferation of photoreceptors was also unaffected, as demonstrated by [3H]thymidine autoradiography. With prolonged culture periods a gradual decrease in the number of opsin-positive cells was observed both in controls and in the continuous presence of CNTF. This decrease could be partly prevented by the addition of 1 mM taurine. Our results suggest that CNTF acted as an inductive signal for uncommitted progenitor cells or during early stages of rod photoreceptor differentiation, whereas other extrinsic stimulatory activities seemed to be required for further maturation.

Retinoic acid promotes differentiation of photoreceptors in vitro

The results of several recent studies have demonstrated that cell commitment and differentiation in the developing vertebrate retina are influenced by cell-cell interactions within the microenvironment. Retinoic acid has been shown to influence cell fates during development of the nervous system, and retinoic acid has been detected in the embryonic retina. To determine whether retinoic acid mediates the differentiation of specific neuronal phenotypes during retinal histogenesis, we treated dissociated cell cultures of embryonic and neonatal rat retina with varying concentrations of all-trans or 9-cis retinoic acid and analyzed the effects on cell fate using neuron and photoreceptor-specific antibodies. Addition of exogenous retinoic acid caused a dose-dependent, specific increase in the number of cells that developed as photoreceptors in culture throughout the period of retinal neurogenesis. In the same cultures, retinoic acid also caused a dose-dependent decrease in the number of cells that developed as amacrine cells. Also, results of double-labeled immunohistochemical studies using bromodeoxyuridine demonstrated that the primary effect of retinoic acid was to influence progenitor cells to develop as newly generated rod photoreceptors. Since retinoic acid and at least one of the retinoic acid receptors (RAR alpha) have been localized to the developing neural retina, these results suggest that retinoic acid may play a role in the normal development of photoreceptor cells in vivo.

Parallel regulation of fetal gene expression in different photoreceptor cell types

Transcriptional induction for multiple bovine rod-specific photoreceptor genes has been shown to coincide with the first emergence of rod outer segments (two-thirds gestation) suggesting a coordinate regulation of these genes. Since cone visual transduction proteins are encoded for by distinct genes and mammalian cone cell genesis has been found to precede rod cell genesis it is important to determine when induction of photoreceptor-specific gene expression occurs in cone cells and how the timing of this event compares to that in rods. RNase protection assays specific for each cell type-specific gene were used to compare mRNA levels for bovine rod and blue cone gamma subunits of cGMP phosphodiesterase and rhodopsin and red cone opsin from before transcriptional induction (4 months gestation) to the adult. Both pairs of rod and cone visual transduction mRNAs exhibit indistinguishable transcriptional induction points at around 6 months of gestation. Before this time, transcripts of all four genes are present at low, but detectable levels. Thus, although rod and cone cells are distinct cell types and cone cells may be committed well before rod cells early in development, during the final trimester when elaboration of outer segments begins, there appears to be a coordinated regulation of both rod- and cone-specific visual transduction genes.