Side effects of retroviral gene transfer into hematopoietic stem cells

KLN-5: a safe monocationic lipophosphoramide to transfect efficiently haematopoietic cell lines and human CD34+ cells

The safe and efficient delivery of nucleic acids into haematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) has a wide range of therapeutic applications. Although viruses are being used in most clinical trials owing to their high transfection efficacy, recent results highlight many concerns about their use. Synthetic transfection reagents, in contrast, have the advantage of being safe and easy to manage while their low transfection efficiency remains a hurdle that needs to be addressed before they can be widely used. Using information on transfection mechanisms, a new family of monocationic lipids called lipophosphoramides was synthesized. Their efficiency to transfer genes into haematopoietic cell lines (K562, Jurkat and Daudi) and CD34+ cells was assessed. In this study, we report that one of these new compounds, KLN-5, leads to more efficient transfection activity than one of our previously most efficient reagents (EG-308) and the commercially available monocationic lipids (DC-CHOL and DOTAP/DOPE) (P<0.05). In addition, only a slight toxicity related to the chemical structure of the new compounds is observed. Moreover, we show that KLN-5 can successfully carry the transgene into haematopoietic progenitor cells (CD34+). These results demonstrate that synthetic transfection reagents represent a viable alternative to viruses and could have potential practical utility in a number of applications.

Strategies to expand transduced hematopoietic stem cells in vivo

Data in mice suggest that in vivo selection strategies will expand the numbers of transduced hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) to levels sufficient for clinical therapies, and it is argued that comparable strategies will benefit larger animals and humans. To test this assumption, we performed virtual gene therapy in mouse and cat, species in which the in vivo kinetics of HSC are defined. In the simulated experiments, 10% of HSC and 50% of short-term repopulating cells were transduced with a gene allowing a conditional replication or apoptosis advantage. After transplantation, differentiation proceeded stochastically and contributions of transduced cells were tracked for 2 years. Fifty independent transplantations were simulated per species for each analysis. When transduced HSC had a 2-fold increased chance of replication (self-renewal) extending for 4, 10, or 20 weeks after transplantation, or a 5-fold replication advantage extending for 4 weeks, results in mice were far better than in cat, a larger animal, with slower baseline HSC cell cycle kinetics. Similarly, when transduced HSC had a 2-, 4-, or 10-fold decreased chance of apoptosis, extending for 20 or more weeks after transplantation, the murine studies were poor predictors of feline results. Simulation may allow one to optimize and/or understand the limitations of a gene therapy strategy.

Distinct genomic integration of MLV and SIV vectors in primate hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells

Murine leukemia virus (MLV)-derived vectors are widely used for hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) gene transfer, but lentiviral vectors such as the simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) may allow higher efficiency transfer and better expression. Recent studies in cell lines have challenged the notion that retroviruses and retroviral vectors integrate randomly into their host genome. Medical applications using these vectors are aimed at HSCs, and thus large-scale comprehensive analysis of MLV and SIV integration in long-term repopulating HSCs is crucial to help develop improved integrating vectors. We studied integration sites in HSCs of rhesus monkeys that had been transplanted 6 mo to 6 y prior with MLV- or SIV-transduced CD34⁺ cells. Unique MLV (491) and SIV (501) insertions were compared to a set of in silico-generated random integration sites. While MLV integrants were located predominantly around transcription start sites, SIV integrants strongly favored transcription units and gene-dense regions of the genome. These integration patterns suggest different mechanisms for integration as well as distinct safety implications for MLV versus SIV vectors.

A primate model of gene transfer into hematopoietic stem cells demonstrated MLV integration around transcription start sites whereas SIV integrated into gene-dense regions, indicating distinct safety implications for each

Lenti in red: progress in gene therapy for human hemoglobinopathies

Hemoglobinopathies are caused by abnormal structure or synthesis of hemoglobin chains and represent serious monogenic disorders. A new study demonstrates that lentiviral vectors can express clinically relevant levels of human transgenic beta-globin in red cells of xenografted mice. While some safety concerns must be addressed, this study is an important step toward potential clinical trials of gene therapy for hemoglobinopathies.

Efficient engraftment of in utero transplanted mice with retrovirally transduced hematopoietic stem cells

Using an experimental mouse model, we have investigated the kinetics of hematopoietic reconstitution of recipients transplanted during fetal development with fresh and transduced hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs). Total bone marrow (BM) and purified Lin(-)Sca-1(+) cells, either fresh or transduced ex vivo with enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP)-encoding retroviral vectors, were in utero transplanted (IUT) into fetal mice. Data obtained 2 months after transplantation showed a similar proportion of engrafted animals, regardless of the fact that samples were purified or not on HSCs, and subjected or not to ex vivo transduction with retroviral vectors. The transplantation of grafts enriched in HSCs, either fresh or transduced, always improved the levels of donor chimerism of IUT mice in comparison with results obtained in mice transplanted with unpurified BM grafts (6.8 and 7.3% versus 1.15% median values, respectively). Significantly, engrafted recipients that were transplanted with the transduced graft always contained transduced EGFP(+) cells in peripheral blood (around 5% of donor cells were EGFP(+) at 2 months post-transplantation). This proportion was essentially maintained at longer times post-transplantation, as well as in secondary recipients transplanted with the BM of IUT mice. Our study describes for the first time a significant and stable engraftment of unconditioned mice subjected to IUT with HSCs transduced with retroviral vectors.

Construction of retroviral vectors with enhanced efficiency of transgene expression

Retroviral vectors have been widely used in gene therapy due to their simple genomic structure and high transduction efficiency. We report a construction of Moloney murine sarcoma virus (MoMSV) and Moloney murine leukemia virus (MoMLV) hybrid-based retroviral vectors with significantly improved efficiency of transgene expression after stable incorporation into the host genome. In these vectors, the residual gag gene coding sequence located in the extended region of packaging signal was removed. These vectors, therefore, contain no coding sequence for the gag, pol, or env gene that can be used for homologous recombination with sequences introduced in the packaging system for a recombinant competent retrovirus (RCR) generation. A strong splice acceptor site obtained from the exon/intron junction of either the chimpanzee EF1-alpha gene or the human CMV major immediate early gene was placed downstream of the MoMSV packaging signal (Psi), significantly improving the efficiency of transgene expression. The 5' LTR U3 sequence was replaced with an extended human CMV major immediate early gene enhancer/promoter for a strong expression of full-length messages from the viral backbone, helping to maintain high levels of viral titer. These newly developed retroviral vectors should facilitate RCR-free gene transfer with significantly improved efficacy in clinical gene therapy trials.

The regulated long-term delivery of therapeutic proteins by using antigen-specific B lymphocytes

Memory lymphocytes are important mediators of the immune response. These cells are long-lived and undergo clonal expansion upon reexposure to specific antigen, differentiating into effector cells that secrete Ig or cytokines while maintaining a residual pool of memory T and B lymphocytes. Here, the ability of antigen-specific lymphocytes to undergo repeated cycles of antigen-driven clonal expansion and contraction is exploited in a therapeutic protocol aimed at regulating protein delivery. The principle of this strategy is to introduce genes encoding proteins of therapeutic interest into a small number of antigen-specific B lymphocytes. Output of therapeutic protein can then be regulated in vivo by manipulating the size of the responder population by antigen challenge. To evaluate whether such an approach is feasible, we developed a mouse model system in which Emu- and Iglambda-based vectors were used to express human erythropoietin (hEPO) gene in B lymphocytes. These mice were then immunized with the model antigen phycoerythrin (PE), and immune splenocytes (or purified PE-specific B lymphocytes) were adoptively transferred to normal or mutant (EPO-deficient) hosts. High levels of hEPO were detected in the serum of adoptively transferred normal mice after PE administration, and this responsiveness was maintained for several months. Similarly, in EPO-deficient anemic recipients, antigen-driven hEPO expression was shown to restore hematocrit levels to normal. These results show that antigen-mediated regulation of memory lymphocytes can be used as a strategy for delivering therapeutic proteins in vivo.

Stem cell clonality and genotoxicity in hematopoietic cells: Gene activation side effects should be avoidable

Two serious adverse events involving activation of the LMO2 oncogene through retrovirus vector insertion in the otherwise extremely successful first gene therapy trial for X-linked severe combined immunodeficieny type 1 (SCID-X1) had initially caused widespread concern in the patient and research communities. Careful consideration 1 year after diagnosis of the second case still finds 12 of the treated patients clearly benefiting from gene therapy (freedom from treatment failure, 80%; survival 100%), a situation that should not portend the end of gene therapy for this disease, and is, in fact encouraging. While current approaches are justified to treat patients with otherwise life-threatening disorders, a broad consensus has developed that systematic basic research is required to further understand the pathophysiology of these serious adverse events and to provide new insights, enabling safer and more effective gene therapy strategies. With the continued success of SCID-X1 gene therapy in the majority of patients treated, it is of even greater importance to understand exactly which vector element or combination of elements predispose to toxicity. An in-depth study of the mechanisms behind the activation of the LMO2 and gammac genes will be highly instructive for the development of safer procedures and vectors. We summarize the central observations, ongoing experimental approaches, new concepts, and developments relevant to understanding, interpreting, and eventually overcoming the real and perceived obstacles posed by insertional mutagenesis due to gene transfer vectors.

Chance or necessity? Insertional mutagenesis in gene therapy and its consequences

Recently, unusual forms of leukemias have developed as complications following retroviral transfer of potentially therapeutic genes into hematopoietic cells. A crucial component in the pathogenesis of these complications was the upregulation of a cellular proto-oncogene by random insertion of the retroviral gene transfer vector. These findings have great implications for the genetic manipulation of somatic stem cells in medicine. This review discusses the extent to which the random oncogene activation may have required disease-specific stimuli of the transgene and the hematopoietic milieu to become leukemogenic. Based on these considerations, we propose approaches to risk prediction and prevention.

Safety and efficacy in retrovirally modified haematopoietic cell therapy

The enormous therapeutic potential of haematopoietic stem cells may be realized if we acquire the ability to control their survival in vitro and their behaviour in vivo. While extrinsic approaches using drugs are unlikely to be developed for this purpose in the near future, altering the intrinsic pool of biological information of stem cells by somatic gene transfer is more likely to succeed. Using the first generations of retroviral gene transfer vectors, we are confronted with the first examples of both successful therapeutic interventions and severe adverse events. The latter are related to the incomplete precision of the existing technologies. Concerted safety and efficiency evaluation has been enforced to further improve the prospects of this field. This review summarizes the current state of the debate, proposing future research directions towards understanding the complex interplay of risk factors related to random transgene insertion, unphysiological transgene expression and additional contributory factors of the specific therapeutic setting.

Gene transfer into human T lymphocytes and natural killer cells by Ad5/F35 chimeric adenoviral vectors

OBJECTIVE

Genetic modification of effector lymphocytes, such as T cells and natural killer (NK) cells, is essential for many approaches to gene-based immunotherapy of cancer. However, transduction of lymphocytes has proven difficult by currently available gene transfer methods. Previous studies have shown that chimeric fiber-modified Ad5/F35 adenoviral vectors are able to efficiently transduce hematopoietic cells including immature progenitors. In this study, we examined the gene transfer into T lymphocytes and NK cells using Ad5/F35 compared with conventional Ad5 adenovectors.

METHODS

Primary T and NK cells were isolated from healthy donors' peripheral blood leukocytes by immunomagnetic selection. Cell lines and primary lymphocytes were transduced with replication-defective Ad5/F35 and Ad5, both containing a GFP reporter gene under the control of a CMV promoter. Transduction efficiencies were monitored by flow cytometry. The function of transduced lymphocytes was assessed by analysis of proliferative responses to mitogenic agents and in mixed leukocyte reactions.

RESULTS

Transgene expression was detected in up to 45% of primary CD3+ T lymphocytes and in up to 60% of primary NK cells using Ad5/F35. In contrast, conventional Ad5 transduced less than 8% and 5% of primary T cells and NK cells, respectively. Transduction efficiencies were similar in CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes, and transgene expression could be detected for up to seven days. Activation of T cells significantly enhanced the efficiency of Ad5/F35-mediated gene transfer. Adenoviral transduction of lymphocytes did not result in any impairment of proliferative functions.

CONCLUSION

The results of this study demonstrate that both T lymphocytes and NK cells can be transduced by chimeric Ad5/F35 adenoviral vectors.

Dynamics of transgene expression in a neural stem cell line transduced with lentiviral vectors incorporating the cHS4 insulator

Transplantation of genetically manipulated cells to the central nervous system holds great promise for the treatment of several severe neurological disorders. The success of this strategy relies on sufficient levels of transgene expression after transplantation. This has been difficult to achieve, however, due to transgene silencing. In this study, we transduced the neural stem cell line RN33B with self-inactivating lentiviral vectors and analyzed transgenic expression of green fluorescent protein (GFP) in several different settings both in vitro and after transplantation to the brain. We found that the transgene was affected of silencing both when transduced cells were proliferating and after differentiation. To prevent silencing, the cHS4 insulator was incorporated into the lentiviral vector. We found that a vector carrying the cHS4 insulator was partially protected against differentiation-dependent downregulation in vitro and in vivo. However, in proliferating cells, we found evidence for variegation and positional effects that were not prevented by the cHS4 insulator, suggesting that the mechanism behind silencing in proliferating cells is not the same mechanism influencing differentiation-dependent silencing. Taken together, these findings favor vector optimization as a strategy for achieving efficient ex vivo gene transfer in the central nervous system.

Antisense-mediated inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) replication by use of an HIV type 1-based vector results in severely attenuated mutants incapable of developing resistance

We have constructed a human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)-based lentiviral vector expressing a 937-base antisense sequence against the HIV-1 envelope gene. Transduction of CD4(+) T lymphocytes with this vector results in expression of the therapeutic antisense sequence and subsequent inhibition of productive HIV-1 replication. In this report, we examined the effect of antisense-mediated suppression on the potential development of virus escape mutants using a permissive T-cell line cultured under conditions that over serial passages specifically allowed for generation and amplification of mutants selected for by antisense pressure. In the resulting virus clones, we found a significant increase in the number of deletions at the envelope target region (91% compared to 27.5% in wild-type HIV). Deletions were most often greater than 1 kb in length. These data demonstrate for the first time that during antisense-mediated suppression of HIV, mutants develop as a direct result of selective pressure on the HIV genomic RNA. Interestingly, in clones where deletions were not observed, there was a high rate of A-G transitions in mutants at the antisense target region but not outside this region, which is consistent with those mutations that are predicted as a result of antisense-mediated modification of double-stranded RNA by the enzyme double-stranded RNA-specific adenosine deaminase. These clones were not found to be escape mutants, as their replicative ability was severely attenuated, and they did not replicate in the presence of vector.

Extended beta-globin locus control region elements promote consistent therapeutic expression of a gamma-globin lentiviral vector in murine beta-thalassemia

Since increased fetal hemoglobin diminishes the severity of beta-thalassemia and sickle cell anemia, a strategy using autologous, stem cell-targeted gene transfer of a gamma-globin gene may be therapeutically useful. We previously found that a gamma-globin lentiviral vector utilizing the beta-globin promoter and elements from the beta-globin locus control region (LCR) totaling 1.7 kb could correct murine beta-thalassemia. However, therapeutic consistency was compromised by chromosomal position effects on vector expression. In contrast, we show here that the majority of animals that received transplants of beta-thalassemic stem cells transduced with a new vector containing 3.2 kb of LCR sequences expressed high levels of fetal hemoglobin (17%-33%), with an average vector copy number of 1.3. This led to a mean 26 g/L (2.6 g/dL) increase in hemoglobin concentration and enhanced amelioration of other hematologic parameters. Analysis of clonal erythroid cells of secondary spleen colonies from mice that underwent transplantation demonstrated an increased resistance of the larger LCR vector to stable and variegating position effects. This trend was also observed for vector insertion sites located inside genes, where vector expression was often compromised, in contrast to intergenic sites, where higher levels of expression were observed. These data emphasize the importance of overcoming detrimental position effects for consistent therapeutic globin vector expression.

Efficient lentiviral gene transfer to canine repopulating cells using an overnight transduction protocol

The use of lentiviral vectors for the transduction of hematopoietic stem cells has evoked much interest owing to their ability to stably integrate into the genome of nondividing cells. However, published large animal studies have reported highly variable gene transfer rates of typically less than 1%. Here we report the use of lentiviral vectors for the transduction of canine CD34+ hematopoietic repopulating cells using a very short, 18-hour transduction protocol. We compared lentiviral transduction of hematopoietic repopulating cells from either stem cell factor (SCF)– and granulocyte-colony stimulating factor (G-CSF)–primed marrow or mobilized peripheral blood in a competitive repopulation assay in 3 dogs. All dogs engrafted rapidly within 9 days. Transgene expression was detected in all lineages (B cells, T cells, granulocytes, and red blood cells as well as platelets) indicating multilineage engraftment of transduced cells, with overall long-term marking levels of up to 12%. Gene transfer levels in mobilized peripheral blood cells were slightly higher than in primed marrow cells. In conclusion, we show efficient lentiviral transduction of canine repopulating cells using an overnight transduction protocol. These results have important implications for the design of stem cell gene therapy protocols, especially for those diseases in which the maintenance of stem cells in culture is a major limitation.

Characterization of CD20-transduced T lymphocytes as an alternative suicide gene therapy approach for the treatment of graft-versus-host disease

We have previously proposed the CD20 molecule as a novel suicide gene for T lymphocytes in the context of allogeneic bone marrow transplantation, because CD20 can be used both as a selection marker and as a killer gene after exposure to the anti-CD20 therapeutic antibody rituximab. We now report on preclinical studies using this novel system, in which the best transduction protocol, reproducibility, yield, feasibility, and functionality of the transduced T lymphocytes have been investigated with a large donor series. Wild-type human CD20 cDNA was transduced into human T lymphocytes, using a Moloney-derived retroviral vector. Alternative protocols were tested by employing either one or four spinoculations (in which cells are centrifuged in the presence of retroviral vector supernatant) and stimulating T cells with phytohemagglutinin (PHA) or anti-CD3/CD28. One spinoculation alone was sufficient to obtain approximately 30% CD20-positive cells within four experimental days. Four spinoculations significantly increased transduction to 60%. A small difference in transduction efficiency was observed between the two stimulation methods, with PHA being superior to anti-CD3/CD28. Transduced cells could be purified on immunoaffinity columns, with purity reaching 98% and yield being on average 50%. Finally, 86-97% of immunoselected T lymphocytes could be killed in vitro with rituximab and complement. More importantly, the CD20 transgene did not alter the functionality of T lymphocytes with respect to allogeneic recognition and cytotoxic response, anti-Epstein-Barr virus cytotoxic response, antigenic response to tetanus toxoid antigen, interleukin 2 (IL-2), IL-4, and interferon gamma production; chemotaxis in the presence of stromal cell-derived factor 1, phenotype for several activation markers including HLA-DR, CD25, CD69, and CD95, and T cell repertoire.

Long-Term Clinical and Molecular Follow-up of Large Animals Receiving Retrovirally Transduced Stem and Progenitor Cells: No Progression to Clonal Hematopoiesis or Leukemia

There has been significant progress toward clinically relevant levels of retroviral gene transfer into hematopoietic stem cells (HSC), and the therapeutic potential of HSC-based gene transfer has been convincingly demonstrated in children with severe combined immunodeficiency syndrome (SCID). However, the subsequent development of leukemia in two children with X-linked SCID who were apparently cured after transplantation of retrovirally corrected CD34+ cells has raised concerns regarding the safety of gene therapy approaches utilizing integrating vectors. Nonhuman primates and dogs represent the best available models for gene transfer safety and efficacy and are particularly valuable for evaluation of long-term effects. We have followed 42 rhesus macaques, 23 baboons, and 17 dogs with significant levels of gene transfer for a median of 3.5 years (range 1-7) after infusion of CD34+ cells transduced with retroviral vectors expressing marker or drug-resistance genes. None developed abnormal hematopoiesis or leukemia. Integration site analysis confirmed stable, polyclonal retrovirally marked hematopoiesis, without progression toward mono- or oligoclonality over time. These results suggest that retroviral integrations using replication-incompetent vectors, at copy numbers achieved using standard protocols, are unlikely to result in leukemogenesis and that patient- or transgene-specific factors most likely contributed to the occurrence of leukemia in the X-SCID gene therapy trial.

Immortalization of hepatic progenitor cells

Development of cell therapy-based strategies for the treatment of liver failures and of inherited metabolic diseases has become a necessity because of the limitations of orthotopic liver transplantation, including shortage of donor livers. This shortage limits also the availability for hepatocytes and these terminally differentiated cells cannot be expanded in vitro. Thus, other alternative sources of hepatocytes have to be explored such as hepatic stem cells. Foetal hepatic cells have specific intrinsic properties compared to adult hepatocytes that should overcome some of their limitations. Thus, the availability of in vitro expandable progenitor cells by means of immortalization and without inducing a transformed phenotype and disrupting their differentiation potential would facilitate studies on cell engraftment and differentiation within the hepatic parenchyma. A temporally controlled expression of the immortalizing transgene would also permit to revert the immortalized phenotype prior to cell transplantation. Since characteristics of murine stem cells cannot readily be extrapolated to their human or other primate counterparts, we have immortalized one clone of primate hepatic progenitor cells using a retroviral vector expressing SV40 Large T flanked by lox P sites. These hepatic cells were bipotent, expressing markers of both hepatocytic and biliary lineages. After transplantation into athymic mice, approximately 50% of immortalized cells engrafted, stopped proliferating after a few days and differentiated in adult hepatocytes, suggesting that the hepatic microenvironment plays an important role in such regulations. Upon infection with a retrovirus expressing the CRE recombinase, immortalized cells stopped growing and died, showing that immortalization was dependant on SV40 Large T. These studies suggest new approaches to expand hepatic progenitor cells, analyse their fate in animal models aiming at cell therapy of hepatic diseases.

Efficient gene transfer into rhesus repopulating hematopoietic stem cells using a simian immunodeficiency virus-based lentiviral vector system

High-titer, HIV-1-based lentiviral vector particles were found to transduce cytokine-mobilized rhesus macaque CD34(+) cells and clonogenic progenitors very poorly (< 1%), reflecting the postentry restriction in rhesus cells to HIV infection. To overcome this barrier, we developed a simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV)-based vector system. A single exposure to a low concentration of amphotropic pseudotyped SIV vector particles encoding the green fluorescent protein (GFP) resulted in gene transfer into 68% +/- 1% of rhesus bulk CD34(+) cells and 75% +/- 1% of clonogenic progenitors. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of DNA from individual hematopoietic colonies confirmed these relative transduction efficiencies. To evaluate SIV vector-mediated stem cell gene transfer in vivo, 3 rhesus macaques underwent transplantation with transduced, autologous cytokine-mobilized peripheral blood CD34(+) cells following myeloablative conditioning. Hematopoietic reconstitution was rapid, and an average of 18% +/- 8% and 15% +/- 7% GFP-positive granulocytes and monocytes, respectively, were observed 4 to 6 months after transplantation, consistent with the average vector copy number of 0.19 +/- 0.05 in peripheral blood leukocytes as determined by real-time PCR. Vector insertion site analysis demonstrated polyclonal reconstitution with vector-containing cells. SIV vectors appear promising for evaluating gene therapy approaches in nonhuman primate models.

Predictable and efficient retroviral gene transfer into murine bone marrow repopulating cells using a defined vector dose

OBJECTIVE

Current protocols of retroviral gene transfer into murine hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) result in variable gene transfer efficiency and involve various procedures that are not clinically applicable. We developed and evaluated a reliable transduction protocol that is more related to clinical methods.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

HSC were enriched from steady-state bone marrow by magnetic cell sorting (lineage depletion) and cultured in defined serum-free medium containing an improved growth factor cocktail (Flt3-ligand, stem cell factor, interleukin-3, interleukin-11). Cell-free ecotropic retroviral vector particles, generated by transient transfection of human 293T-based packaging cells, were preloaded at defined titers on CH296-coated tissue culture plates, thus largely avoiding serum contamination. These conditions were evaluated in 17 experiments involving 29 transduction cultures and 185 recipient mice.

RESULTS

After two rounds of infection, the gene marking rates in cultured mononuclear cells and stem/progenitor cells (Lin(-)c-Kit(+)) were 15 to 85% (53.7%+/-21.7%, n=23) and 30 to 95% (69.8%+/-20.4%, n=17), respectively. Even after one round of infection, gene transfer was efficient (31.2%+/-15.1%, n=12). Using identical conditions, gene transfer rates were highly reproducible. Average transgene expression in reconstituted animals correlated well with pretransplant data. Using a moderate multiplicity of infection, the majority of transduced cells carried less than three transgene copies. In addition, coinfection was possible to establish two different vectors in single cells.

CONCLUSION

The protocol described here achieves efficient retroviral transduction of murine bone marrow repopulating cells with a defined gene dosage, largely avoiding procedures that decrease stem cell output and repopulating capacity. This protocol may help to improve the predictive value of preclinical efficiency/toxicity studies for gene therapeutic interventions and basic research.

Averting abnormal inheritance: potential of gene therapy and preimplantation diagnosis

Serious inherited disease in children can be averted by preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) and potentially by gene therapy in addition to prenatal diagnosis. PGD is now well established and provides a secure, if expensive and complex form of care. Gene therapy has been practised only in animals, although its success in alleviating various conditions in adults and newborns, together with the scientific drive of the genome project, make it a highly likely approach over coming years. Pros and cons of both approaches are contrasted and compared. Newer reproductive techniques such as somatic cell hybridization promise to add new dimensions to gene therapy, and could be combined with PGD. This paper discusses the finer details of these options, their safety and the ethical issues they have raised.

Gene therapy progress and prospects: gene therapy for severe combined immunodeficiency

Severe combined immunodeficiencies have long been targeted as a group of disorders amenable to gene therapy because of their defined molecular biology and pathophysiology, and the prediction that corrected cells would have profound growth and survival advantage. Recently, several clinical studies have shown that conventional gene transfer technology can produce major beneficial therapeutic effects in these patients, but, as for all cellular and pharmacological treatment approaches, with a finite potential for toxicity.

Dose finding with retroviral vectors: correlation of retroviral vector copy numbers in single cells with gene transfer efficiency in a cell population

Retroviral vectors are commonly used in clinical gene therapy, but recent observations of insertional oncogene activation in preclinical and clinical settings have forced a discussion of their safety. Here we investigated the relationship between retroviral transduction efficiency in mass cultures and the actual number of integrated vector copies in single cells using K562 leukemia and primary CD34+ cells. We found an exponential increase of integration numbers correlated to gene transfer rates and a linear increase of expression levels with insertion frequency. On average we detected one vector insertion per transduced cell for a gene transfer of less than 30%, 3 for 60%, and approximately 9 for 90% (in K562). Clonal analysis revealed strikingly increased variations of both transgene copy numbers (more than 20-fold in primary cells) and expression levels associated with higher transduction. Therefore, limiting retroviral gene transfer to approximately 30% may be suggested to avoid generating clones containing multiple insertions.

Gene therapy targeting hematopoietic cells: better not leave it to chance

Gene therapy targeting hematopoietic cells has arrived at a new stage of potency. While the potential for curing inherited disorders of the immune system has been demonstrated in clinical trials, we were also confronted with the first serious adverse events related to random insertion of foreign DNA into cellular chromosomes. As it is likely that the manifestation of severe side effects results from a multifactorial process, it will be of crucial importance to define the significance of the individual risk factors involved. The future of the field will depend on our ability to define risk classifications of clinical approaches, to continuously improve transgene technologies, and to introduce new concepts for targeted selection of transgenic cells. Interestingly, correction of genetic disorders by homologous gene repair in defined stem cell clones is on the horizon, but far from being available for clinical use.

Medicine. Gene therapy--new challenges ahead

The successful use of retroviral gene transfer to treat 10 patients with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID-X1) has been welcomed as evidence of the therapeutic potential of gene therapy. However, as Williams and Baum suggest in their Perspective, the discovery that 2 of the 10 patients developed leukemia within 3 years of gene therapy (Hacein-Bey-Abina et al.) reinforces the need to develop even more specific gene therapy interventions.

Defects in T-cell-mediated immunity to influenza virus in murine Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome are corrected by oncoretroviral vector-mediated gene transfer into repopulating hematopoietic cells

The Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS) is an X-linked disorder characterized by immune dysfunction, thrombocytopenia, and eczema. We used a murine model created by knockout of the WAS protein gene (WASP) to evaluate the potential of gene therapy for WAS. Lethally irradiated, male WASP- animals that received transplants of mixtures of wild type (WT) and WASP- bone marrow cells demonstrated enrichment of WT cells in the lymphoid and myeloid lineages with a progressive increase in the proportion of WT T-lymphoid and B-lymphoid cells. WASP- mice had a defective secondary T-cell response to influenza virus which was normalized in animals that received transplants of 35% or more WT cells. The WASP gene was inserted into WASP- bone marrow cells with a bicistronic oncoretroviral vector also encoding green fluorescent protein (GFP), followed by transplantation into irradiated male WASP- recipients. There was a selective advantage for gene-corrected cells in multiple lineages. Animals with higher proportions of GFP+ T cells showed normalization of their lymphocyte counts. Gene-corrected, blood T cells exhibited full and partial correction, respectively, of their defective proliferative and cytokine secretory responses to in vitro T-cell-receptor stimulation. The defective secondary T-cell response to influenza virus was also improved in gene-corrected animals.

Genetic modification of hematopoietic stem cells: recent advances in the gene therapy of inherited diseases

Hematopoietic stem cells constitute a rare population of precursor cells with remarkable properties for being used as targets in gene therapy protocols. The last years have been particularly productive both in the fields of gene therapy and stem cell biology. Results from ongoing clinical trials have shown the first unquestionable clinical benefits of immunodeficient patients transplanted with genetically modified autologous stem cells. On the other hand, severe side effects in a few patients treated with gene therapy have also been reported, indicating the usefulness of further improving the vectors currently used in gene therapy clinical trials. In the field of stem cell biology, evidence showing the plastic potential of adult hematopoietic stem cells and data indicating the multipotency of adult mesenchymal precursor cells have been presented. Also, the generation of embryonic stem cells by means of nuclear transfer techniques has appeared as a new methodology with direct implications in gene therapy.

Pharmacologically regulated Fas-mediated death of adoptively transferred T cells in a nonhuman primate model

Conditional suicide genes derived from pathogens have been developed to confer drug sensitivity and enhance safety of cell therapy, but this approach is limited by immune responses to the transgene product. We examined a strategy to regulate survival of transferred cells based on induction of apoptosis through oligomerization of a modified human Fas receptor by a bivalent drug (AP1903). Three macaques (Macaca nemestrina) received autologous T cells retrovirally engineered to express a Fas suicide-construct (LV'VFas). High levels of transduced cells were present in blood following cell transfer, but LV'VFas(+) cells declined rapidly after AP1903 administration. A small fraction of LV'VFas(+) cells resisted elimination by AP1903, in part due to insufficient levels of transgene expression in resting T cells, because reactivation of these cells in vitro enhanced sensitivity to AP1903. An immune response to the transgene product was observed, but epitope mapping indicated the response was directed to discrete components of human LV'VFas that were variant with the corresponding macaque sequences. These data demonstrate that chemically induced dimerization can be used to regulate survival of adoptively transferred T cells in vivo.

Transduction and selection of human T cells with novel CD34/thymidine kinase chimeric suicide genes for the treatment of graft-versus-host disease

Clinical trials evaluating the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-tk)/ganciclovir (GCV) suicide gene therapy system for the control of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) have been limited by low transduction efficiencies and inefficient selection procedures. In this study, we designed and evaluated a novel chimeric suicide gene consisting of the extracellular and transmembrane domains of human CD34 and full-length HSV-tk (DeltaCD34-tk). High-efficiency transfer of DeltaCD34-tk to primary human T cells was accomplished after a single exposure to VSV-G-pseudotyped, Moloney murine leukemia virus-based retrovirus 48 h after activation of human PBMCs with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies immobilized on magnetic beads. Using an optimized 5-day transduction and selection procedure, transduction efficiencies averaged 71%, with isolation purities greater than 95% and yields exceeding 90%. The immunoselected T cells were selectively eliminated by GCV (IC(50) approximately 3 nM), maintained a normal subset composition, exhibited a polyclonal TCR Vbeta family repertoire, and contained 5 or 6 vector copies per transduced cell when optimally transduced. No increase in GCV sensitivity was observed upon incorporation of highly active mutant HSV-tk enzymes into the DeltaCD34-tk suicide gene. T cells modified with the DeltaCD34-tk gene using the optimized protocol should improve the overall efficacy of the HSV-tk/GCV suicide gene therapy method of GVHD control.

Human nerve growth factor receptor and cytosine deaminase fusion genes

Cytosine deaminase (CD) converts 5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) to the toxic metabolite 5-fluorouracil (5-FU), and has been investigated extensively as a potential tool for selective cellular eradication. In this paper, genetic constructs were designed to express the CD enzyme fused to the transmembrane and extracellular domains of the human nerve growth factor receptor (NGFR), thus allowing for positive identification of transduced cells by flow cytometry and positive selection by magnetic bead technology. Constructs were designed to encode a [Gly(4)Ser](2) flexible linker between the nucleic acid coding sequences for the NGFR and CD genes. Retroviral vectors constructed with wild-type CD and NG/CD fusion genes were used to transduce 3T3 fibroblasts and the human T cell line CEM. The function of CD fusion genes was comparable to that of wild-type genes as determined in cytotoxicity assays. By flow cytometry, the NGFR antigen was detectable after expression of the fusion gene derived from either Escherichia coli (NG/CDe) or Saccharomyces cerevisiae (NG/CDs), but the greatest antigen density was observed in cells transduced with the NG/CDs vector. Similarly, superior 5-FC sensitivity was observed with NG/CDs fusion gene in both murine fibroblasts and human T cells. In addition, CEM cells expressing NG/CDs were more efficiently eliminated in vivo. Engineering of cells utilizing the chimeric NG/CD genes provides a new modality in gene therapy allowing positive and negative selection using a single protein-coding sequence.

Development of gene therapy for hemoglobin disorders

The hemoglobin disorders, severe beta-thalassemia and sickle cell anemia, are prevalent monogenetic disorders which cause severe morbidity and mortality worldwide. Gene therapy approaches to these disorders envision stem cell targeted gene transfer, autologous transplantation of gene-corrected stem cells, and functional, phenotypically corrective globin gene expression in developing erythroid cells. Lentiviral vector systems potentially appear to afford adequately efficient gene transfer into stem cells and are capable, with appropriate genetic engineering, of transferring a globin gene with the regulatory elements required to achieve high-level, erythroid-specific expression. Herein are results obtained in use of lentiviral vectors to insert a gamma-globin gene into murine stem cells with phenotypic correction of the thalassemia phenotype. Further, we have developed a drug-selection system for genetically modified stem cells based on a mutant form of methylguanine, methyltransferase, which allows selective amplification of genetically modified stem cells with phenotypic correction even in the absence of myeloablation prior to stem cell transplantation. These advances provide essential preclinical data which build toward the development of effective gene therapy for the severe hemoglobin disorders.

Progress and problems with the use of viral vectors for gene therapy

Gene therapy has a history of controversy. Encouraging results are starting to emerge from the clinic, but questions are still being asked about the safety of this new molecular medicine. With the development of a leukaemia-like syndrome in two of the small number of patients that have been cured of a disease by gene therapy, it is timely to contemplate how far this technology has come, and how far it still has to go.

Current developments in the design of onco-retrovirus and lentivirus vector systems for hematopoietic cell gene therapy

Over the past dozen years, the majority of clinical gene therapy trials for inherited genetic diseases and cancer therapy have been performed using murine onco-retrovirus as the gene delivery vector. The earliest systems used were relatively inefficient in both the rates of transduction and expression of the transgene. Formidable obstacles inherent in the cell biology and/or the immunology of the target cell systems limited the efficacy of gene therapy for many target diseases. Development of novel retrovirus gene transfer systems that are in progress have begun to overcome these obstacles. Evidence of this progress is the recent successful functional correction of the immune T and B lymphocyte deficiency in patients with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (X-SCID) and adenosine deaminase (ADA)-deficient SCID following onco-retrovirus vector ex vivo transduction of autologous marrow stem cells [Science 296 (2002) 2410; Science 288 (2000) 669; N. Engl. J. Med. 346 (2002) 1185]. These achievements of prolonged clinical benefit from gene therapy were tempered by the finding of insertional mutageneses in two of the treated X-SCID patients [N. Engl. J. Med. 348 (2003) 255].