Stabilisation of neurone number in the inferior olivary complex of aged 'Purkinje cell degeneration' mutant mice

The Childhood-Onset Neurodegeneration with Cerebellar Atrophy (CONDCA) Disease Caused by AGTPBP1 Gene Mutations: The Purkinje Cell Degeneration Mouse as an Animal Model for the Study of this Human Disease

Recent reports have identified rare, biallelic damaging variants of the AGTPBP1 gene that cause a novel and documented human disease known as childhood-onset neurodegeneration with cerebellar atrophy (CONDCA), linking loss of function of the AGTPBP1 protein to human neurodegenerative diseases. CONDCA patients exhibit progressive cognitive decline, ataxia, hypotonia or muscle weakness among other clinical features that may be fatal. Loss of AGTPBP1 in humans recapitulates the neurodegenerative course reported in a well-characterised murine animal model harbouring loss-of-function mutations in the AGTPBP1 gene. In particular, in the Purkinje cell degeneration (pcd) mouse model, mutations in AGTPBP1 lead to early cerebellar ataxia, which correlates with the massive loss of cerebellar Purkinje cells. In addition, neurodegeneration in the olfactory bulb, retina, thalamus and spinal cord were also reported. In addition to neurodegeneration, pcd mice show behavioural deficits such as cognitive decline. Here, we provide an overview of what is currently known about the structure and functional role of AGTPBP1 and discuss the various alterations in AGTPBP1 that cause neurodegeneration in the pcd mutant mouse and humans with CONDCA. The sequence of neuropathological events that occur in pcd mice and the mechanisms governing these neurodegenerative processes are also reported. Finally, we describe the therapeutic strategies that were applied in pcd mice and focus on the potential usefulness of pcd mice as a promising model for the development of new therapeutic strategies for clinical trials in humans, which may offer potential beneficial options for patients with AGTPBP1 mutation-related CONDCA.

The inferior olive of the C57BL/6J mouse: a chemoarchitectonic study

We have used the histochemical and immunohistochemical staining methods and maps of gene expression to analyze the structure of the inferior olive of the C57BL mouse. As in other mammals, the inferior olive of the C57BL mouse contains three major nuclei, the medial nucleus, the principal nucleus, and the dorsal nucleus. The medial nucleus can be divided into a rostral medial nucleus and a more complex caudal part, which is formed by subnuclei C, B, A, the cap of Kooy, and the beta subnucleus. The principal nucleus includes the major principal nucleus and the arcuate subnucleus. Most of the inferior olive neurons are small to medium size, the smallest of which are found in the arcuate subnucleus. Calbindin and the vesicular glutamate transporter 2 gene are expressed in nearly all inferior olive neurons, but acetylcholinesterase, glutamate decarboxylase 1 gene, cocaine- and amphetamine-regulated transcript protein prepropeptide gene, galanin gene, and calretinin are selectively expressed within different subnuclei. These findings are consistent with a pattern of extensive functional differentiation among the neuron groups of the inferior olive.

Spontaneous and induced mouse mutations with cerebellar dysfunctions: behavior and neurochemistry

Grid2(Lc) (Lurcher), Grid2(ho) (hot-foot), Rora(sg) (staggerer), nr (nervous), Agtpbp1(pcd) (Purkinje cell degeneration), Reln(rl) (reeler), and Girk2(Wv) (Weaver) are spontaneous mutations with cerebellar atrophy, ataxia, and deficits in motor coordination tasks requiring balance and equilibrium. In addition to these signs, the Dst(dt) (dystonia musculorum) spinocerebellar mutant displays dystonic postures and crawling. More recently, transgenic models with human spinocerebellar ataxia mutations and alterations in calcium homeostasis have been shown to exhibit cerebellar anomalies and motor coordination deficits. We describe neurochemical characteristics of these mutants with respect to regional brain metabolism as well as amino acid and biogenic amine concentrations, uptake sites, and receptors.

Neuronal replacement and integration in the rewiring of cerebellar circuits

Repair of CNS injury or degeneration by cell replacement may lead to significant functional recovery only through faithful reconstruction of the original anatomical architecture. This is particularly relevant for point-to-point systems, where precisely patterned connections have to be re-established to regain adaptive function. Despite the major interest recently drawn on cell therapies, little is known about the mechanisms and the potentialities for specific integration of new neurons in the mature CNS. Major findings and concepts about this issue will be reviewed here, with special focus on work dealing with the Purkinje cell transplantation in the rodent cerebellum. These studies show that the adult CNS may provide some efficient information to direct cell engraftment and process outgrowth. On their side, immature cells may be able to induce adaptive changes in their adult partners to facilitate their incorporation in the recipient network. Despite the rather high degree of specific integration achieved in several different CNS regions, these processes are usually defective and long-distance connections are not rewired. Thus, although some potentialities for cell replacement exist in the mature CNS, full incorporation of new neurons in adult circuits is rarely observed. Indeed, intrinsic mechanisms for growth control as well as injury-induced changes in the properties and architecture of the nervous tissue contribute to hamper repair processes. As a consequence, crucial to obtain successful cell replacement and integration in the mature CNS is a deep understanding of the basic biological mechanisms that regulate the interactions between newly added elements and the recipient environment.

Selective rather than inductive mechanisms favour specific replacement of Purkinje cells by embryonic cerebellar cells transplanted to the cerebellum of adult Purkinje cell degeneration (pcd) mutant mice

Cell replacement after neuronal degeneration in the adult CNS depends on the availability of specific cues to direct specification, differentiation and integration of newly born neurons into mature circuits. Following recent reports indicating that neurogenic signals may be reactivated in the adult injured CNS, here we asked whether such signals are expressed in the cerebellum after Purkinje cell degeneration. Thus, we compared the fate of embryonic cerebellar cells transplanted to the cerebella of adult wild-type and Purkinje cell degeneration (pcd) mutant mice. Donor cells were dissected from beta-actin-enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) transgenic mice and transplanted as a single cell suspension. In both hosts, grafted cells generated all major cerebellar phenotypes, with a precise localization in the recipient cortex or white matter. Nevertheless, the phenotypic distributions showed striking quantitative differences. Most notably, in the pcd cerebellum there was a higher amount of Purkinje cells, while other phenotypes were less frequent. Analysis of cell proliferation by 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrDU) incorporation revealed that in both hosts mitotic activity was strongly reduced shortly after transplantation, and virtually all donor Purkinje cells were actually generated before grafting. Together, these results indicate that some compensatory mechanisms operate in the pcd environment. However, the very low mitotic rate of transplanted cells suggests that the adult cerebellum, either wild-type or mutant, does not provide instructive neurogenic cues to direct the specification of uncommitted progenitors. Rather, specific replacement in mutant hosts is achieved through selective mechanisms that favour the survival and integration of donor Purkinje cells at the expense of other phenotypes.

Reparative mechanisms in the cerebellar cortex

In the adult brain, different neuronal populations display different degrees of plasticity. Here, we describe the highly different plastic properties of inferior olivary neurones and Purkinje cells. Olivary neurones show a basal expression of growth-associated proteins, such as GAP-43 and Krox24/EGR-1, and remarkable remodelling capabilities of their terminal arbour. They also regenerate their transected neurites into growth-permissive territories and may reinnervate the lost target. Sprouting and regrowing olivary axons are able to follow specific positional information cues to establish new connections according to the original projection map. In addition, they set a strong cell body reaction to injury, which in specific olivary subsets is regulated by inhibitory target-derived cues. In contrast, Purkinje cells do not have a constitutive level of growth-associated genes, and show little cell body reaction, no axonal regeneration after axotomy, and weak sprouting capabilities. Block of myelin-derived signals allows terminal arbour remodelling, but not regeneration, while selective over-expression of GAP-43 induces axonal sprouting along the axonal surface and at the level of the lesion. We suggest that the high constitutive intrinsic plasticity of the inferior olive neurones allows their terminal arbour to sustain the activity-dependent ongoing competition with the parallel fibres in order to maintain the post-synaptic territory, and possibly underlies mechanisms of learning and memory. Such a plasticity is used also as a reparative mechanism following axotomy. In contrast, in Purkinje cells, poor intrinsic regenerative capabilities and myelin-derived signals stabilise the mature connectivity and prevent axonal regeneration after lesion.

The effects of cerebellar damage on maze learning in animals

The role of the cerebellum in spatial learning has recently been investigated in genetically and non-genetically lesioned animal models, particularly in water mazes, in view of the minimal impact such lesions exert on swimming movements. A dissociation between place and cued learning in the Morris water maze has been observed in several models, including cerebellar mutant mice (Rora(sg), Nna1(pcd-1J), nervous), rats with lesions of either the lateral cerebellar cortex or the dentate nucleus, and rats with selective Purkinje cell loss caused by intracerebroventricular injections of OX-7-saporin, confirming the hypothesis that cerebellar damage may cause a cognitive deficit independently of fine motor control. In addition, the results of hemicerebellectomized rats indicate the probable involvement of the cerebellum in working memory and the procedural aspect of maze learning. The findings of impaired maze learning in cerebellar-lesioned mice and rats are concordant with those of deficient visuospatial functions in patients with cerebellar atrophy. The spatial deficits may be ascribed to altered metabolic activity in cerebellar-related pathways.

Patterned Purkinje cell death in the cerebellum

The object of this review is to assemble much of the literature concerning Purkinje cell death in cerebellar pathology and to relate this to what is now known about the complex topography of the cerebellar cortex. A brief introduction to Purkinje cells, and their regionalization is provided, and then the data on Purkinje cell death in mouse models and, where appropriate, their human counterparts, have been arranged according to several broad categories--naturally-occurring and targeted mutations leading to Purkinje cell death, Purkinje cell death due to toxins, Purkinje cell death in ischemia, Purkinje cell death in infection and in inherited disorders, etc. The data reveal that cerebellar Purkinje cell death is much more topographically complex than is usually appreciated.

Extrinsic regulation of injury/growth-related gene expression in the inferior olive of the adult rat

Successful axon regeneration relies on the capability of the lesioned neurons to up-regulate a specific set of injury/growth-associated genes. In the adult central nervous system, the strength of the cell body response is generally related to the distance of the injury site from the perikaryon, being stronger for proximal lesions. Nevertheless, inferior olive (IO) cells react to injury and regenerate their axons even after distal transections. To investigate the mechanisms that regulate the IO growth properties, we examined the expression of injury/growth markers (nitric oxide synthase, growth-associated protein 43 and c-Jun) after target deletion or axotomy performed at different sites along the olivocerebellar pathway. Both axon injury and target loss disclose two subsets of IO neurons distributed within precise subnuclei: one subset up-regulates all markers in all conditions, whereas the other shows a mild c-Jun expression but remains unresponsive even after a very proximal axotomy. These observations indicate that distinct subpopulations of IO cells respond to different regulatory strategies. Unresponsive neurons appear insensitive to environmental positive or negative cues, suggesting that they are intrinsically unable to set up a cellular reaction to injury. In contrast, cell body changes in reactive neurons are elicited after the removal of retrogradely transported target-derived inhibitory signals. Target loss also induces degeneration of IO cells, whose survival remains partially dependent on Purkinje targets in adulthood. Thus, the intrinsic regenerative potential of a functionally homogeneous population is regulated by multiple mechanisms, specific for distinct neuronal subsets.

Pretraining enhances recovery from visuospatial deficit following cerebellar dentate nucleus lesion

Following bilateral lesions targeting lateral deep cerebellar nuclei, rats were subjected to a bridge test as a measure of visuomotor coordination and were trained on the Morris water maze (MWM) as a measure of visuospatial processing. Lesioned rats were significantly impaired in visuospatial processing, but not visuomotor coordination, relative to sham rats. In a 2nd experiment, rats were pretrained on a delayed spatial alternation task (T maze) before MWM training. Pretraining reversed the visuospatial deficit caused by the lesions as compared with nonpretrained rats. Results suggest that lateral deep cerebellar nuclei contribute to visuospatial processing with a negligible contribution to visuomotor skills and that visuospatial deficits resulting from lateral nuclei damage can be reversed with pretraining on aspatial working memory task.

Horizontal vestibuloocular reflex (VOR) head velocity estimation in Purkinje cell degeneration (pcd/pcd) mutant mice

The horizontal vestibuloocular reflex (VOR) of Purkinje cell degeneration (pcd/pcd) mutant mice, which lack a functional cerebellar cortex, was compared in darkness to that of wild-type animals during constant velocity yaw rotations about an earth-horizontal axis and during sinusoidal yaw rotations about an earth-vertical axis. Both wild-type and pcd/pcd mice showed a compensatory average VOR eye velocity, or bias, during constant velocity horizontal axis rotations, evidence of central neural processing of otolith afferent signals to create a signal proportional to head angular velocity. Eye velocity bias was greater in pcd/pcd mice than in wild-type mice at a low rotational velocity (32 degrees/s), but less at higher velocities (128 and 200 degrees/s). Lesion of the medial nodulus severely attenuated eye velocity bias in two wild-type mice, without attenuating VOR during sinusoidal vertical axis yaw rotations at 0.2 Hz. These results show that while head velocity estimation in mice, as in primates, depends on the cerebellum, pcd/pcd mutant mice develop velocity estimation without a functional cerebellar cortex. We conclude that neural circuits that exclude cerebellar cortex are capable of the signal processing necessary for head angular velocity estimation, but that these circuits are insufficient for normal estimation at high velocities.

Mutant mice as a model for cerebellar ataxia

Not later than two synapses after their arrival in the cerebellar cortex all excitatory afferent signals are subsequently transformed into inhibitory ones. Guaranteed by the exceedingly ordered and stereotyped synaptic arrangement of its cellular elements, the cerebellar cortex transmits this inhibitory result of cerebellar integration exclusively via Purkinje cells (PCs) in a precise temporal succession directly onto the target neurons of the deep cerebellar and vestibular nuclei. Thus the cerebellar cortex seems to produce a temporal pattern of inhibitory influence on these target neurons that modifies their excitatory action in such a way that an activation of muscle fibers occurs which progressively integrates the intended motion into the actual condition of the motoric inventory. In consequence, disturbances that affect this cerebellar inhibition will cause uncoordinated, decomposed and ataxic movements, commonly referred to as cerebellar ataxia. Electrophysiological investigations using different cerebellar mouse mutants have shown that alterations in the cerebellar inhibitory input in the target nuclei lead to diverse neuronal responses and to different consequences for the behavioural phenotype. A dependence between the reconstitution of inhibition and the behavioural outcome seems to exist. Obviously two different basic mechanisms are responsible for these observations: (1) ineffective inhibition on target neurons by surviving PCs; and (2) enhancement of intranuclear inhibition in the deep cerebellar and vestibular nuclei. Which of the two strategies evolves is dependent upon the composition of the residual cell types in the cerebellum and on the degree of PC input loss in a given area of the target nuclei. Motor behaviour seems to deteriorate under the first of these mechanisms whereas it may benefit from the second. This is substantiated by stereotaxic removal of the remaining PC input, which eliminates the influence of the first mechanism and is able to induce the second strategy. As a consequence, motor performance improves considerably. In this review, results leading to the above conclusions are presented and links forged to human cerebellar diseases.

Modulation of GABA(A) receptor subunit mRNA levels in olivocerebellar neurons of purkinje cell degeneration and weaver mutant mice

In olivocerebellar circuits, changes in the subunit composition of GABA(A) receptors occur at a time of extensive synaptic remodeling. In the deep cerebellar nuclei, GABA(A) receptor alpha1, beta2, and gamma2 subunit mRNA expression increases throughout neonatal development, whereas in the inferior olivary complex, the perinatal combination of alpha3, alpha5, beta3, and gamma2 mRNAs switches to the adult combination of alpha2, alpha4, beta3 and gamma1 during postnatal week 2. In situ hybridization was used to examine changes in subunit expression in the olivocerebellar nuclei of Purkinje cell degeneration and weaver mutant mice. In Purkinje cell degeneration, subunit transcripts decreased below control levels in olivary neurons; however, alpha1, beta2, and gamma2 transcript levels were slightly increased in the medial nucleus of the deep cerebellar nuclei. In weaver olivary neurons, although the switch from early- to late-onset subunit mRNAs occurred as in normal mice, transcript levels were differentially modulated by the mutation. Our studies indicate that major alterations in synaptic connectivity do not prevent developmentally programmed switches in GABA(A) receptor gene expression but can modulate the timing and level of transcript expression in afferent and efferent neurons.

Transplanted neurons alter the course of neurodegenerative disease in Lurcher mutant mice

Embryonic cerebellar, neocortical, and striatal tissues derived from NSE-LacZ transgenic mice were transplanted into the right cerebellar hemisphere of 8- to 10-day-old Lurcher or wild-type mice. Host mice survived for 30-90 days and the transplanted tissue was examined by light microscopy using Nissl staining, X-gal histochemistry, and immunohistochemistry for calcium binding protein and glutamic acid decarboxylase. Transplantation of cerebellar tissue, but not neocortical or striatal progenitors, resulted in robust infiltration of the lurcher mutant host cerebellar cortex by transgenic Purkinje neurons. Deep to the infiltrated molecular layer, the host granular layer was thicker and denser than the mutant granular layer, but transgenic cells did not contribute to the spared granular layer. The host inferior olivary complex consistently exhibited a noticeable bilateral asymmetry in Nissl-stained sections. A quantitative analysis of the olivary complex was performed in 10 90-day-old host mice. The results indicate that the left inferior olivary complex of 90-day-old host mice contained more neurons than the right inferior olive of the host mice and contained more neurons than was observed in 90-day-old Lurcher control mice. Analysis by olivary subdivision indicates that increased neuron numbers were present in all subdivisions of the host left inferior olive. These studies confirm the specific attractive effect of the mutant cerebellar cortex on transplanted Purkinje neuron progenitors and indicate that neural transplants may survive the neurodegenerative period to interact with developing host neural systems. The unilateral rescue of Lurcher inferior olivary neurons in cerebellar transplant hosts indicates that transplanted neurons may interact with diseased host neural circuits to reduce transneuronal degeneration in the course of a neurodegenerative disease.

Degenerative phenomena and reactive modifications of the adult rat inferior olivary neurons following axotomy and disconnection from their targets

Adult olivocerebellar axons are capable of vigorous regeneration when provided with growth-permissive environmental conditions. To elucidate the contribution of intrinsic properties to the regenerative capabilities of inferior olivary neurons, we have examined the cellular modifications occurring in these neurons following axotomy and target deprivation in the absence of exogenous growth-promoting influences. Axotomized inferior olivary neurons undergo perikaryal shrinkage, dendritic atrophy and a loss of anti-calbindin immunoreactivity. A conspicuous cell death occurs during the first few weeks after lesion, but about 35% of the affected neurons survive up to 60 days. Coincidentally, a subset of the injured nerve cells become strongly reactive for NADPH diaphorase histochemistry, and this expression is correlated with survival in the medial accessory olive and in the principal olive. In addition, the affected neurons express or maintain the expression of several markers related to regenerative processes, including transcription factors c-Jun, JunD and Krox-24, the growth-associated protein GAP-43 and the developmentally regulated calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP). The expression of all these markers is sustained up to two months after lesion, the longest survival time examined. These results show that although adult axotomized inferior olivary neurons undergo severe regressive modifications leading to a conspicuous cell loss, at least a subset of them is resistant to the lesion. In addition, the long-lasting expression of several axon-growth associated markers expressed in these neurons in response to injury reveals that they are endowed with a strong intrinsic regenerative potential.

Visuospatial abilities

The importance of the hippocampus and its anatomical connections, including the medial septum, thalamic nuclei, and neocortical regions in many spatial tasks including the Morris water maze, has been emphasized. Studies in mutant mice with cerebellar atrophy and in rats with electrolytic lesions of the cerebellum have indicated that the cerebellum has a role in visuospatial and visuomotor processes in the Morris maze. Directional deficits in the water have also been noted in rats whose cerebellum was exposed to X-rays during different developmental stages. Cerebellar interactions with the superior colliculus, the hippocampus, and the neocortex via thalamic nuclei are suggested to be the basis of the cerebellar modulation of directional sense in maze tests.

A model of Pavlovian eyelid conditioning based on the synaptic organization of the cerebellum

We present a model based on the synaptic and cellular organization of the cerebellum to derive a diverse range of phenomena observed in Pavlovian eyelid conditioning. These phenomena are addressed in terms of critical pathways and network properties, as well as the sites and rules for synaptic plasticity. The theory is based on four primary hypotheses: (1) Two cerebellar sites of plasticity are involved in conditioning: (a) bidirectional long-term depression/potentiation at granule cell synapses onto Purkinje cells (gr-->Pkj) in the cerebellar cortex and (b) bidirectional plasticity in the interpositus nucleus that is controlled by inhibitory inputs from Purkinje cells; (2) climbing fiber activity is regulated to an equilibrium level at which the net strength of gr-->Pkj synapses remains constant unless an unexpected unconditioned stimulus (US) is presented or an expected US is omitted; (3) a time-varying representation of the conditioned stimulus (CS) in the cerebellar cortex permits the temporal discrimination required for conditioned response timing; and (4) the ability of a particular segment of the CS to be represented consistently across trials varies as a function of time since CS onset. This variation in across-trials consistency is thought to contribute to the ISI function. The model suggests several empirically testable predictions, some of which have been tested recently.

The cerebellar model of neural grafting: structural integration and functional recovery

A synopsis is presented of the recent history of cerebellar tissue transplantation over the past 25 years. The properties of growth and differentiation of cerebellar grafts placed intraocularly or intracranially are reviewed, as well as the interaction of heterotopic and orthotopic grafts with the host brain. Particular emphasis is placed on the use of ataxic mouse mutants as recipients of donor cerebellar tissue for the correction of their structural deficits and the functional recovery of behavioural responses.

Serotonin-immunoreactivity in the cerebellum of two neurological mutant mice and the corresponding wild-type genetic stocks

Using a serotonin (5-HT)-specific antibody, we examined the 5-HTergic innervation of the cerebellum in the normal mouse (+/+) and in two neurological mutants: weaver (wv/wv), which are characterized by a genetically determined loss of granule cells, and 'Purkinje cell degeneration' (pcd/pcd), which are characterized by a genetically determined loss of Purkinje cells. In normal cerebellum, serotonin-immunoreactive (5-HT-ir) fibers are discrete and ascend to all three layers of the cerebellar cortex. Serotonin-immunoreactive fibers have a much higher density in the atrophic cerebella of both weaver and pcd mutants, where they form multidirectional contours. These anatomical findings provide a profile of 5-HT axon innervation of mouse cerebellum and extend previous neurochemical observations on the metabolic state of cerebellar 5-HT in neurological mutants.