The role of conditional drug responses in tolerance to the hypothermic effects of ethanol

Cellular signaling pathways as plastic, proto-cognitive systems: Implications for biomedicine

Many aspects of health and disease are modeled using the abstraction of a "pathway"-a set of protein or other subcellular activities with specified functional linkages between them. This metaphor is a paradigmatic case of a deterministic, mechanistic framework that focuses biomedical intervention strategies on altering the members of this network or the up-/down-regulation links between them-rewiring the molecular hardware. However, protein pathways and transcriptional networks exhibit interesting and unexpected capabilities such as trainability (memory) and information processing in a context-sensitive manner. Specifically, they may be amenable to manipulation via their history of stimuli (equivalent to experiences in behavioral science). If true, this would enable a new class of biomedical interventions that target aspects of the dynamic physiological "software" implemented by pathways and gene-regulatory networks. Here, we briefly review clinical and laboratory data that show how high-level cognitive inputs and mechanistic pathway modulation interact to determine outcomes in vivo. Further, we propose an expanded view of pathways from the perspective of basal cognition and argue that a broader understanding of pathways and how they process contextual information across scales will catalyze progress in many areas of physiology and neurobiology. We argue that this fuller understanding of the functionality and tractability of pathways must go beyond a focus on the mechanistic details of protein and drug structure to encompass their physiological history as well as their embedding within higher levels of organization in the organism, with numerous implications for data science addressing health and disease. Exploiting tools and concepts from behavioral and cognitive sciences to explore a proto-cognitive metaphor for the pathways underlying health and disease is more than a philosophical stance on biochemical processes; at stake is a new roadmap for overcoming the limitations of today's pharmacological strategies and for inferring future therapeutic interventions for a wide range of disease states.

Reversible inactivation of rostral nucleus raphe pallidus attenuates acute autonomic responses but not their habituation to repeated audiogenic stress in rats

The medullary nucleus raphe pallidus (RPa) mediates several autonomic responses evoked by acute stress exposure, including tachycardia and hyperthermia. The present study assessed whether the RPa contributes to the decline/habituation of these responses observed during repeated audiogenic stress. Adult male rats were implanted with cannulae aimed at the RPa, and abdominal E-mitters that wirelessly acquire heart rate and core body temperature. After surgical recovery, animals were injected with muscimol or vehicle (aCSF) in the RPa region, followed by 30 min of 95-dBA loud noise or no noise control exposures on 3 consecutive days at 24-h intervals. Forty-eight hours after the third exposure, animals were exposed to an additional, but injection-free, loud noise or no noise test to assess habituation of hyperthermia and tachycardia. Three days later, rats were restrained for 30-min to evaluate their ability to display normal acute autonomic responses following the repeated muscimol injection regimen. The results indicated that the inhibition of cellular activity induced by the GABAA-receptor agonist muscimol centered in the RPa region reliably attenuated acute audiogenic stress-evoked tachycardia and hyperthermia, compared with vehicle-injected rats. Animals in the stress groups exhibited similar attenuated tachycardia and hyperthermia during the injection-free fourth audiogenic stress exposure, and displayed similar and robust increases in these responses to the subsequent restraint test. These results suggest that cellular activity in neurons of the RPa region is necessary for the expression of acute audiogenic stress-induced tachycardia and hyperthermia, but may not be necessary for the acquisition of habituated tachycardic responses to repeated stress.

Persistence of a hyperthermic sign-reversal during nitrous oxide inhalation despite cue-exposure treatment with and without a drug-onset cue

We asked whether chronic tolerance and the hyperthermic sign-reversal induced by repeated 60% N2O exposures could be extinguished using a cue-exposure paradigm. Rats received 18 N2O administrations in a total calorimetry system that simultaneously measures core temperature (Tc), metabolic heat production (HP), and body heat loss (HL). Each exposure entailed a 2-h baseline period followed by a 1.5-h N2O exposure. The 18 drug exposures induced a robust intra-administration hyperthermia in which the initial hypothermic effect of N2O inverted to a significant hyperthermic sign-reversal during N2O inhalation due primarily to an acquired robust increase in HP. The rats were then randomized to one of three extinction procedures (n=8/procedure) over a 20-d interval: 1) a N2O-abstinent home-cage group (HC) that received only the usual animal care; 2) a cue-exposure group (CEXP) in which the animals were placed in the calorimeter 8 times but received no N2O; and 3) a drug-onset-cue group (DOC) in which animals received a brief N2O exposure in the calorimeter that mimicked the first 3 min of an actual 60% N2O trial. Following the extinction sessions, all rats received a 60% N2O test trial and Tc, HP and HL were assessed. The hyperthermic sign-reversal remained fully intact during the test trial, with no significant differences observed among groups in any post-baseline change in any thermal outcome. These data suggest that cue exposure may not be an efficacious strategy to reduce sign-reversals that develop with chronic drug use.

Prepulse inhibition modulation by contextual conditioning of dopaminergic activity

When a neutral stimulus is repeatedly paired with a drug, an association is established between them that can induce two different responses: either an opponent response that counteracts the effect of the drug, or a response that is similar to that induced by the drug. In this paper, we focus on the analysis of the associations that can be established between the contextual cues and the administration of dopamine agonists or antagonists. Our hypothesis suggests that repeated administration of drugs that modulate dopaminergic activity in the presence of a specific context leads to the establishment of an association that subsequently results in a conditioned response to the context that is similar to that induced by the drug. To test this hypothesis, we conducted two experiments that revealed that contextual cues acquired the property to modulate pre-pulse inhibition by prior pairings of such context with the dopamine antagonist haloperidol (Experiment 1), and with the dopamine agonist d-amphetamine (Experiment 2). The implications of these results are discussed both at a theoretical level, and attending to the possibilities that could involve the use of context cues for the therapeutic administration of dopaminergic drugs.

Chronic voluntary alcohol consumption results in tolerance to sedative/hypnotic and hypothermic effects of alcohol in hybrid mice

The continuous two-bottle choice test is the most common measure of alcohol consumption but there is remarkably little information about the development of tolerance or dependence with this procedure. We showed that C57BL/6J × FVB/NJ and FVB/NJ×C57BL/6JF1 hybrid mice demonstrate greater preference for and consumption of alcohol than either parental strain. In order to test the ability of this genetic model of high alcohol consumption to produce neuroadaptation, we examined development of alcohol tolerance and dependence after chronic self-administration using a continuous access two-bottle choice paradigm. Ethanol-experienced mice stably consumed about 16-18 g/kg/day of ethanol. Ethanol-induced withdrawal severity was assessed (after 59 days of drinking) by scoring handling-induced convulsions; withdrawal severity was minimal and did not differ between ethanol-experienced and -naïve mice. After 71 days of drinking, the rate of ethanol clearance was similar for ethanol-experienced and -naïve mice. After 77 days of drinking, ethanol-induced loss of righting reflex (LORR) was tested daily for 5 days. Ethanol-experienced mice had a shorter duration of LORR. For both ethanol-experienced and -naïve mice, blood ethanol concentrations taken at gain of righting reflex were greater on day 5 than on day 1, indicative of tolerance. After 98 days of drinking, ethanol-induced hypothermia was assessed daily for 3 days. Both ethanol-experienced and -naïve mice developed rapid and chronic tolerance to ethanol-induced hypothermia, with significant group differences on the first day of testing. In summary, chronic, high levels of alcohol consumption in F1 hybrid mice produced rapid and chronic tolerance to both the sedative/hypnotic and hypothermic effects of ethanol; additionally, a small degree of metabolic tolerance developed. The development of tolerance supports the validity of using this model of high alcohol consumption in genetic studies of alcoholism.

Conditioned tolerance to the effects of alcohol on inhibitory control in humans

AIMS

To test whether the repeated consumption of alcohol in a particular environment leads to the emergence of a context-specific conditioned compensatory response (CCR) that can counter alcohol's impairment of inhibitory processes.

METHODS

Twenty-four participants consumed an alcoholic drink (males: 0.65 g/kg; females: 0.57 g/kg) in one context on three sessions and a matched placebo drink in a different context on three other sessions. At test, participants were split into two groups and consumed a novel alcoholic drink either in the context previously paired with alcohol or the placebo-paired context. On all sessions, participants were tested on two computer-based tasks that measured response inhibition: an affective go/no-go task and a stop-signal task (SST).

RESULTS

Over the conditioning trials, tolerance developed to alcohol's disinhibitory effects on the go/no-go task; moreover, on the test for conditioned responding, performance was less impaired for participants in the alcohol-paired versus the placebo-paired context. No tolerance was evident on the SST, and no CCR.

CONCLUSION

Repeated consumption of alcohol in a particular environment can lead to the emergence of a context-specific CCR that counters some of alcohol's disinhibitory effects. Therefore, consuming alcohol in an unfamiliar context might produce stronger disinhibitory effects than would be apparent in a familiar drinking environment.

CNS–immune system interactions: Conditioning phenomena

Converging data from different disciplines indicate that central nervous system processes are capable of influencing immune responses. This paper concentrates on recent studies documenting behaviorally conditioned suppression and enhancement of immunity. Exposing rats or mice to a conditioned stimulus previously paired with an immunomodulating agent results in alterations in humoral and cell-mediated immune responses to antigenic stimuli, and unreinforced reexposures to the conditioned stimuli result in extinction of the conditioned response. Although the magnitude of such conditioning effects has not been large, the phenomenon has been independently verified under a variety of experimental conditions. The biological impact of conditioned alterations in immune function is illustrated by studies in which conditioning operations were applied in the pharmacotherapy of autoimmune disease in New Zealand mice. In conditioned animals, substituting conditioned stimuli for active drugs delays the onset of autoimmune disease relative to nonconditioned animals using a dose of immunosuppressive drug that, by itself, is ineffective in modifying the progression of disease. The hypothesis that such conditioning effects are mediated by elevations in adrenocortical steroid levels receives no support from available data. Despite its capacity for self-regulation, it appears that the immune system is integrated with other psychophysiological processes and subject to modulation by the brain.

Autonomic responses to ethanol in adolescent and adult rats: a dose-response analysis

Although the exact cause of the increase in ethanol consumption during adolescence is not known, age differences in sensitivity to some of ethanol's effects may play a contributory role. Prior research has shown little difference in the expression of ethanol-induced tachycardia between adolescents and adults following ethanol inhalation. In contrast, there is mounting evidence of ontogenetic differences in ethanol-induced hypothermia, although the nature of the ontogenetic effect observed has been found to vary across studies and even within labs. Relative ontogenetic differences in body temperature (BT) after ethanol administration appear to be driven in part by the amount of experimental perturbation associated with the test protocol, although differing ethanol exposure levels across studies may also have contributed to the variations in ontogenetic patterns that have been observed. To explore the latter possibility, the present study assessed ethanol-induced hypothermia and tachycardia in adolescent and adult male Sprague-Dawley rats examined in their home cages in the presence of their housing partner following intraperitoneal administration of 0.5, 1.5, or 3.0 g/kg ethanol. The results showed that, although adolescents did not show an adult-typical tachycardic effect at any dose, they proved more sensitive than adults to ethanol's hypothermic effects at the two highest doses. These findings suggest that not only the degree of experimental perturbation, but also the amount of ethanol exposure may differentially effect expression of age differences in ethanol-induced hypothermia, with adolescents showing greater hypothermia than adults at higher doses. Together with previous findings, these data contribute to the emerging picture that age differences in autonomic effects of ethanol appear to be particularly sensitive to dosing parameters and experimental protocols, unlike the generally more consistent ontogenetic findings observed across studies when using behavioral measures of ethanol sensitivity.

Genetic Dissociation Between Ethanol Sensitivity and Rapid Tolerance in Mouse and Rat Strains Selectively Bred for Differential Ethanol Sensitivity

BACKGROUND

The Inbred Long- and Short-Sleep mice (ILS and ISS) and the Inbred High- and Low-Alcohol-Sensitive rats (IHAS and ILAS) were selectively bred for differential alcohol sensitivity with use of the duration of loss-of-righting-reflex test (LORR), with the IHAS and ILS animals being much more sensitive than the ILAS and ISS animals, respectively. The current study was undertaken to determine whether acute sensitivity in these strains is genetically correlated to a rapid tolerance to alcohol, a form of tolerance that is evident 24 hr after a single alcohol dose.

METHODS

Separate groups of animals were administered a single pretreatment dose of alcohol (0-6 g/kg for the mice; 0-4 g/kg for the rats). Alcohol sensitivity was tested 24 hr later with the LORR test, and blood ethanol concentration was tested at regain of righting (BECRR). Alcohol-induced hypothermia also was determined in the mice. Independently derived replicate rat strains were used for all experiments (IHAS1, ILAS1; IHAS2, ILAS2); no such replicates exist for the ILS and ISS strains.

RESULTS

Alcohol pretreatment caused a dose-dependent decrease in LORR duration accompanied by an increase in BECRR in the ILS strain, but LORR increased in the ISS strain with no effect on BECRR. Both strains became hypothermic during the LORR test on day two, but the only significant effect of alcohol pretreatment was in the ISS strain, in which alcohol-induced hypothermia was enhanced. Alcohol pretreatment caused a significant dose-dependent decrease in LORR duration accompanied by an increase in BECRR in the IHAS1 but not in the IHAS2 strain. In contrast, ILAS1 and ILAS2 strains both showed a significant increase in LORR duration and also a significant increase in BECRR.

CONCLUSIONS

Alcohol pretreatment caused a dose-dependent decrease in LORR duration and an increase in BECRR in the IHAS1 and ILS strain, suggesting the development of functional rapid tolerance. In contrast, LORR duration increased in the ILAS1, ILAS2, and ISS groups, but BECRR either increased (ILAS1, ILAS2) or did not change (ISS). These observations suggest that central nervous system sensitivity was decreased in the ILAS1 and ILAS2 groups (i.e., rapid functional tolerance) or unchanged in the ISS strain, but that some pharmacokinetic property also was altered in these strains. Overall, the results do not support a genetic relation between alcohol sensitivity and the development of rapid tolerance.

Regulation of drug taking by sensitization and habituation

The authors argue that drug taking is an operant behavior that is reinforced by the drug itself. The effectiveness of a drug as a reinforcer is modulated by sensitization and habituation to the drug as it is consumed. According to this model, drug taking stops when habituation reduces the ability of the drug to reinforce its own consumption. Drug taking resumes when spontaneous recovery restores the effectiveness of the drug as a reinforcer. This parsimonious model provides a framework for understanding many findings in the drug literature, including acute and chronic tolerance, the effect of deprivation on consumption, the contextual specificity of tolerance, polydrug abuse, cross-sensitization between stress and drugs, behavioral sensitization, priming, and reinstatement. Although this model cannot explain all aspects of drug taking (e.g., the effect of cognitive manipulations), it has many implications for understanding and controlling human drug consumption and addiction.

Assessment of heat production, heat loss, and core temperature during nitrous oxide exposure: a new paradigm for studying drug effects and opponent responses

Studies using core temperature (T(c)) have contributed greatly to theoretical explanations of drug tolerance and its relationship to key features of addiction, including dependence, withdrawal, and relapse. Many theoretical accounts of tolerance propose that a given drug-induced psychobiological disturbance elicits opponent responses that contribute to tolerance development. This proposal and its theoretical extensions (e.g., conditioning as a mechanism of chronic tolerance) have been inferred from dependent variables, such as T(c), which represent the summation of multiple underlying determinants. Direct measurements of determinants could increase the understanding of opponent processes in tolerance, dependence, and withdrawal. The proximal determinants of T(c) are metabolic heat production (HP) and heat loss (HL). We developed a novel system for simultaneously quantifying HP (indirect calorimetry), HL (direct gradient layer calorimetry), and T(c) (telemetry) during steady-state administrations of nitrous oxide (N(2)O), an inhalant with abuse potential that has been previously used to study acute and chronic tolerance development to its hypothermia-inducing property. Rats were administered 60% N(2)O (n = 18) or placebo gas (n = 16) for 5 h after a 2-h placebo baseline exposure. On average, N(2)O rapidly but transiently lowered HP and increased HL, each by approximately 16% (P < 0.001). On average, rats reestablished and maintained thermal equilibrium (HP = HL) at a hypothermic T(c) (-1.6 degrees C). However, some rats entered positive heat balance (HP > HL) after becoming hypothermic such that acute tolerance developed, i.e., T(c) rose despite continued drug administration. This work is the first to directly quantify the thermal determinants of T(c) during administration of a drug of abuse and establishes a new paradigm for studying opponent processes involved in acute and chronic hypothermic tolerance development.

Current state of knowledge about the mechanisms of alcohol tolerance

Far from being a simple homeostatic response to the presence of ethanol in the brain, tolerance is now recognized as a complex process which can develop within various time frames (acute, rapid, chronic) and in which the drug interacts with various environmental and cognitive factors, including associative and operant learning. A major question is whether the acute form is an innate adaptive response, which is converted into the rapid and chronic forms by the action of these external influences. So far, all behavioral and neuropharmacological manipulations that alter chronic tolerance also modify rapid and acute tolerance in similar ways. These include lesions of serotonergic forebrain projections, blockade of NMDA-type glutamate receptors and calcium "L" channels, central or peripheral injection of vasopressin and blockade of vasopressin V1 receptors. Cytochemical and immunofluorescence studies, combined with use of retrograde tracers, indicate the existence of a septohippocampal circuit which may mediate the interactions of these diverse elements in the production and maintenance of tolerance. There is limited evidence that development of tolerance leads to increased consumption of ethanol in experimental animals, but the clinical significance of these findings remains to be proven.

Is behavioral sensitization to ethanol associated with contextual conditioning in mice?

Behavioral sensitization to drugs of abuse seems to involve learning processes. In mice, ethanol-induced locomotor sensitization is potentiated by repeated pairing of ethanol (EtOH) injections and the testing chamber. The present study aimed to test: (1). the association between the performance in a contextual conditioning task and the development of behavioral sensitization to EtOH in mice; (2). whether EtOH sensitization would be expressed in a different testing environment. Male albino Swiss mice (n=72) were initially submitted to a contextual fear conditioning task. After 2 weeks without manipulation, the animals received daily i.p. injections of 2.2 g/kg EtOH (n=52) or saline (n=20), for 21 days. They were tested weekly for locomotor activity in activity cages. After 1 week of withdrawal, all mice received 2.2 g/kg EtOH and had their locomotor activity recorded in an open-field. According to the locomotor behavior displayed along the 21-day treatment, EtOH-treated mice were classified as sensitized (n=15) or non-sensitized (n=15). When these subgroups and saline-treated mice were compared for the freezing response in the conditioning test, sensitized mice displayed a greater freezing time than non-sensitized mice. When challenged with EtOH in the open-field, none of the EtOH-treated subgroups expressed behavioral sensitization. These results suggest that the development of EtOH sensitization seems to be positively associated with contextual learning, and further confirms that the expression of sensitization is highly dependent on contextual cues.

Ethanol effects on three strains of zebrafish: model system for genetic investigations

The effects of acute and chronic ethanol administration on the wild-type (WT), long-fin striped (LFS), and blue long-fin (BLF) strains of zebrafish were investigated. In the LFS strain, acute exposure to 0.25% (v/v) ethanol inhibited the startle reaction and increased both the area occupied by a group of subjects and the average distance between each fish and its nearest neighbor. Similar effects were found in the WT fish although higher concentrations of ethanol were required. No effects on the behavior of the BLF fish were observed with up to 1.0% (v/v) ethanol. Brain alcohol levels were comparable among the three strains precluding a pharmacokinetic explanation for the behavioral results. In LFS zebrafish, behavioral tolerance was observed after 1 week of continual exposure to ethanol. Conversely, chronic ethanol exposure of the WT fish for up to 2 weeks did not result in the development of tolerance, but rather appeared to increase the disruptive action of the drug. The present results suggest the observed strain differences in the effects of ethanol reflect genotypic differences in both the response of the central nervous system (CNS) to ethanol as well as the ability of the CNS to adapt to ethanol exposure. Although preliminary, the present study indicates that the zebrafish is an excellent model system to investigate the genetic determinants involved in regulating the responses to ethanol.

Occasion setting and drug tolerance

There is considerable evidence that drug-paired cues become associated with drug effects. It has been hypothesized that these cues act as Pavlovian conditional stimuli (CSs), and elicit conditional compensatory responses that contribute to tolerance. On the basis of a conditioning analysis of tolerance, we would expect that it should be possible to establish drug-paired cues as occasion setters, as well as conditional stimuli. Using feature-positive discrimination training, we evaluated the contribution of occasion-setting stimuli (as well as CSs) to tolerance to the hypothermic effect of ethanol in rats. The results indicated that a complete associative analysis of drug tolerance should incorporate not only the CS properties of predrug cues, but also the occasion-setting properties of such cues. The findings have implications for interpreting conflicting findings concerning extinction of tolerance and for cue-exposure treatments of addiction.

Conditioned compensatory response to ethanol as indicated by locomotor activity in rats

Spontaneous motor activity (SMA) was used to investigate conditioned tolerance to the depressant effect of ethanol, and conditioned responses to stimuli predicting ethanol injection. Rats were injected with saline or ethanol at 800 or 1600 mg/kg, on alternate days, in two distinctly different locations, over a period of 20 conditioning days. The two ethanol doses were administered to separate groups of rats, but conditioned effects were determined by within-subject comparisons. Conditioned SMA responses (rearing and ambulatory activity) were measured after injection of saline in the location previously paired with ethanol treatment, and conditioned tolerance was determined by observing ethanol effects in rats tested in the environment previously paired with saline treatment. Ethanol-paired stimuli increased SMA (both activity measures, both dose-groups) during the conditioned response test. Absence of these conditioned stimuli during the tolerance test resulted in greater behavioral depression with the 800 mg/kg ethanol dose for both the rearing and ambulation measures; however, this effect was seen with the 1600 mg/kg dose for the rearing measure only. These results provide further evidence that Pavlovian conditioning is involved in tolerance to the depressant action of ethanol on overt behavior, and demonstrate the presence of such conditioned compensatory responses in the absence of ethanol treatment.

The role of US signal value in contingency, drug conditioning, and learned helplessness

In Pavlovian conditioning, organisms can learn that a conditioned stimulus (CS) signals the delivery of an unconditioned stimulus (US). The present paper first reviews research showing that organisms can also learn that a stimulus, normally considered to be a US, signals the delivery of another US. Second, the paper shows how such signal value may contribute to three conditioning phenomena that are of interest to many psychologists: contingency, drug conditioning, and learned helplessness. In addition to showing how such signal value may contribute to these three phenomena, suggestions for further research, as well as current gaps in the knowledge base, are outlined.

Lack of tolerance to ethanol-induced motor impairment on accelerod performance in rats

The effect of ethanol on rats was investigated at increasing rates of acceleration for bar rotation speed. Ethanol was given to rats by a liquid diet starting with 2.4% ethanol (v/v) for 3 days. Then the ethanol concentration was increased to 4.8% (v/v) for 3 days and finally to 7.2% (v/v) for 15 days. Accelerod performance was recorded before and throughout 20 days of ethanol intake. Mean blood ethanol levels were 266.34+/-13.11 and 285.20+/-9.77 mg/dl on the 7th and 15th days of ethanol (7.2% v/v) consumption, respectively, as measured in a parallel group of animals. Ethanol produced significant concentration-dependent impairments in the accelerod performance of rats. The motor impairment effect of ethanol was most prominent in the test using the greatest rate of acceleration (from 0 to 79 rpm within 2 min). The impairment effect of ethanol on accelerod performance occurred throughout the period of ethanol exposure. Our results indicate that motor impairment on the accelerod performance test produced by an ethanol liquid diet depends on the concentration of ethanol and the rate of acceleration. In addition, under free-access conditions accelerod performance may not be a suitable behavioral test for detecting tolerance development to ethanol in rats.

Research on tolerance: what can we learn from history?

The concept of tolerance to ethanol has evolved gradually over the past two centuries, and all of the basic clinical features, as they are now understood, have been clearly recognized for nearly 100 years. The basic mechanisms involved in central nervous system tolerance, however, have been elucidated only in the past 20 to 30 years. Little progress was made as long as tolerance was viewed as a purely cellular or physiological adaptation to alcohol, and researchers used overly simple paradigms based on mere exposure to the drug. With the recognition that learning, both operant and associative, can play a major role in the development of tolerance to alcohol and cross-tolerance to other drugs, a radical change in research approaches became possible. Most of the neural mechanisms related to learning and memory are now known to be involved in the development and retention of tolerance, and the simplistic models used in earlier research must now be abandoned. Nevertheless, a review of the history of past research points to a number of important lessons for future work, including the following: (1) many of the present concepts were enunciated by astute observers many decades ago, and research was hindered because this older literature was forgotten; (2) for many decades progress was slow because of a narrow focus on specific techniques, questions, and hypotheses that overlooked important research in related disciplines; (3) the course of research is often irregular, and past questions may have to be revisited with new approaches--but these are more likely to be fruitful if based on knowledge of past history; and (4) excellent researchers often obtain apparently contradictory findings, but the disagreements may hold the key to deeper understanding of the phenomena, and should not be brushed over by ignoring the minority findings and interpretations. As in all scientific research, the most important requirement for major progress is the formulation of good questions or hypotheses: the results yielded by the best available techniques can be only as good as the questions they are meant to answer.

Metabolic mapping of the effects of chronic voluntary ethanol consumption in rats

The 2-[14C]deoxyglucose method was used to examine the effects of chronic, voluntary ethanol consumption on rates of local cerebral glucose utilization (LCGU). LCGU was measured in male Long-Evans rats immediately following the completion of a 60-min schedule-induced polydipsia drinking session. Three groups of animals were examined: animals with a history of ethanol consumption that received ethanol on the test day (ethanol-ethanol), animals with a similar ethanol history that were presented with water on the test day (ethanol-water), and a control group that received water throughout the experiment (water-water). Ethanol consumption on the test day resulted in a highly discrete pattern of metabolic changes, with significant decreases in glucose utilization in the hippocampal complex, habenula, anterior ventral thalamus, and mammillary bodies, whereas increases were observed in the nucleus accumbens and locus coeruleus. Rates of LCGU in the ethanol-water group were increased throughout all regions of the central nervous system examined, indicating that the long-term consumption of moderate ethanol doses that do not produce physical dependence can cause significant changes in functional brain activity.

Paradoxical conditioning of the plasma copper and corticosterone responses to bacterial endotoxin

The cascade of physiologic mechanisms in response to infection, the acute phase response, is recognized as having a major role in host defense. Two such responses are an increase in plasma copper and activation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, which are consistently reported to occur during bacterial infection. We aimed to determine whether the alterations in plasma copper and corticosterone were conditionable using the conditioned taste aversion paradigm. The regime involved the pairing of a novel-tasting saccharine solution (the conditioned stimulus) with lipopolysaccharide (the unconditioned stimulus). Seven days after the initial pairing of these stimuli (the test day), the saccharine solution was represented. Animals exposed to this condition displayed a significant decrease in plasma copper levels. In addition, these rats experienced a reduction in plasma corticosterone that was time dependent. Paradoxically, the conditioned response of both these variables were in a direction contrary to that reported during bacterial infection. These results suggest that some acute phase responses may condition as a rebound response, or in an opposing trend to that occurring as the initial reaction.

The extinction of naturally occurring conditioned reactions in psychoactive substance users: analog studies

In the present series of studies we develop an analog approach for the study of conditioned reactions to drug stimuli. The analog we study is the naturally occurring conditioned reaction of salivation at the sight of a lemon. We show that this conditioned reaction can be extinguished, that spontaneous recovery occurs, and that the conditioned reaction increases after "relapse." Further, we show that massed extinction trials lead to greater extinction than do spaced trials. This analog provides an approach that can be used to develop cue-exposure treatments that minimize spontaneous recovery from extinction and reduce the likelihood of relapse.

Chronic intragastric infusion produces tolerance to ethanol in LS and SS mice

Tolerance to ethanol's effects is seen after chronic injections and after chronic treatment with ethanol-containing liquid diets. However, tolerance associated with injections is often associated with environmental cuing (learned tolerance) and liquid diets do not allow for careful control of dose. The studies reported here demonstrate that chronic (3 g/kg every 6 h for 7 days) intragastric infusion of ethanol produces tolerance to ethanol in both LS and SS mice, as measured by sleep time and effects on open field activity and body temperature. LS mice developed more tolerance for all measures than the SS. The rate of ethanol elimination was increased slightly in both the LS and SS mouse lines following chronic ethanol infusion, which suggests that both lines developed a modest metabolic tolerance to ethanol. In contrast, the waking blood ethanol levels were altered only in the LS mice, which argues that some of the tolerance to ethanol seen in the LS mice is pharmacodynamic tolerance. Thus, chronic intragastric infusion of ethanol is a reliable method for treating animals chronically with ethanol that allows for the precise control of dose and dose interval, oral administration of ethanol, and minimal animal handling that can be associated with drug delivery, thereby reducing the risk of developing learned tolerance to ethanol.

The NMDA receptor antagonist dizocilpine differentially affects environment-dependent and environment-independent ethanol tolerance

Antagonists of the N-methyl-D-aspartate subtype of glutamate receptor have been reported to block the development of tolerance to various effects of ethanol and opiates, using paradigms in which tolerance is believed to be governed by learning. There is considerable evidence to implicate the N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor in learning processes, and therefore the ability of the antagonists to block tolerance has been attributed to their effects on learning. To evaluate this hypothesis, we compared, in C57BL/6 mice, the effect of the uncompetitive N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor antagonist, dizocilpine, on environment-dependent (associative) tolerance to ethanol, which is governed by learning, and on environment-independent (nonassociative) ethanol tolerance, in which learning plays a minimal role. Environment-dependent tolerance was induced by repeated ethanol injections, and dizocilpine blocked the development of this type of tolerance to the hypothermic and incoordinating effects of ethanol. In contrast, when environment-independent ethanol tolerance was induced by feeding the mice an ethanol-containing liquid diet, dizocilpine treatment had no effect on the development of tolerance to the hypothermic, incoordinating or hypnotic effects of ethanol. The results support the hypothesis that the effect of N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor antagonists on ethanol tolerance reflects the more general role of this receptor in processes involving learning and memory.

Effect of anisomycin on the development of rapid tolerance to ethanol-induced motor impairment

Male Wistar rats given a single moderate dose (1.7 g/kg, IP) of ethanol (EtOH), followed by six trials on the moving belt apparatus during the next hour, showed functional tolerance to the motor-impairing effects of a second dose given 24 h later if the first EtOH was preceded and followed by an injection of saline. The same EtOH dose and intoxicated practice did not produce tolerance if the saline injections were replaced by two doses of anisomycin (60 mg/kg each, SC) 15 min before and 105 min after the first dose of EtOH. This finding suggests that rapid tolerance, like chronic tolerance, requires de novo synthesis of protein during a short period immediately related to the test experience.

Response outcomes affect the retention of behavioral tolerance to alcohol: information and incentive

Twenty-four male undergraduates acquired tolerance during three sessions where they received moderate doses of alcohol (0.62 g/kg) and repeatedly performed a motor skill task with immediate knowledge of results (KR) on each trial. Subjects were assigned to one of four groups (n = 6) before a retention test session where two groups received alcohol and two expected alcohol but received a placebo. The effect on tolerance retention of withholding KR was tested in alcohol group A. The effect of an incentive in the absence of KR was examined in the other alcohol group (AM) that was offered a delayed monetary reward for nonimpaired performance. Both alcohol groups failed to retain tolerance and their impairment did not differ. The effect of substituting the incentive for KR on a drug-compensatory response to placebo was examined in group PM by comparing its performance to group PC where KR was continued. A compensatory response (i.e., performance superior to drug-free baseline) was displayed by the PC group but not by group PM. Thus, despite a monetary incentive to perform well, tolerance to alcohol and a compensatory response to placebo were both disrupted by withholding KR. The results were interpreted in terms of the information about performance conveyed by KR.

A comparison of drug conditioning and craving for alcohol and cocaine

Craving is a potentially important concept that is difficult to define and study in the laboratory. Although alcohol and cocaine are very different pharmacologically, this discussion emphasizes common factors in addiction to these drugs, such as the tendency of alcoholics and cocaine abusers to crave these substances. I review commonalities in drug conditioning and cue reactivity to alcohol and cocaine. Both drugs support Pavlovian conditioning when they are presented as unconditioned stimuli, whether studied in rodents or humans. In addition, both drugs are craved when abusers are presented with stimuli associated with these drugs. Finally, I propose a theoretical definition of craving based on autoshaping and sign-tracking phenomena that suggests a common mechanism of addiction to these drugs. This model defines craving as a reflection of sign tracking to internal and external stimuli that have in the past reliably predicted presentation of these drugs.

Differences in the hypothermic response to ethanol in rats selectively bred for oral ethanol preference and nonpreference

The duration of retention of tolerance to ethanol was tested in the alcohol-preferring (P) and alcohol-nonpreferring (NP) rats lines, using ethanol-induced hypothermia as a measure of tolerance. Rats received two injections of ethanol (3.5 g/kg) body wt, IP) and the time between the injections was 1, 2, or 3 days. When one day separated the two injections, tolerance to the hypothermic effect of a second "test" injection was found in both lines. When 2 or 3 days separated the two injections, the P line showed a loss of tolerance and the NP line showed sensitization to ethanol. Sensitization in the NP line grew stronger when the interval between injections was increased from 2 to 3 days. The duration of retention of tolerance to ethanol-induced hypothermia in the P line was shorter than has previously been reported for motor impairment in this line. It appears that the duration of tolerance retention in the P line depends on the test used to measure tolerance. Sensitization to ethanol in the NP line may be associated with low oral ethanol intake.

Differential development of acute tolerance to the motor impairment and anticonvulsant effects of ethanol

The development of acute tolerance to the motor impairment and anticonvulsant effects of ethanol was examined. Acute tolerance to the motor impairment effect of ethanol was shown by a decrease in the degree of intoxication, as measured on the moving belt task, at higher blood ethanol levels ranging from 206 to 256 mg/dl. There was no evidence of acute tolerance to the anticonvulsant effect of ethanol in rats tested over the same time period. These results indicate that, like chronic tolerance, acute tolerance to ethanol develops at different rates for different effects of the drug. The fact that chronic tolerance to the anticonvulsant effect of ethanol has been well documented raises doubts about the assumption that similar physiological changes underlie acute and chronic tolerance to a drug effect, and support the idea that the relationship between acute and chronic tolerance is more complex than previously thought.

Response expectancies affect the acquisition and display of behavioral tolerance to alcohol

Two experiments demonstrated that a learned expectation of a favourable consequence for drug-compensatory performance enhanced behavioral tolerance to alcohol, and when the expectancy was trained, the subsequent display of tolerance depended upon its consequence. Both experiments involved each of four groups of six male social drinkers each, who drank 0.62 g/kg alcohol on four sessions, and a placebo on a fifth session. Experiment 1 provided two groups with the opportunity to learn the response expectancy by performing a motor task under alcohol with either an informative consequence (IO) or information plus money contingent upon drug-compensatory performance (MI). Two control groups performed with either no outcome (N), or with money for compensatory performance but no information about earnings until the experiment concluded (MO). The effects of learning history were evident on sessions 4 and 5 when the same consequence was contingent upon the performance of all groups. Compared to controls, the groups that had received response expectancy training (MI and IO) displayed significantly more alcohol tolerance and greater compensatory facilitation of performance under placebo. In Experiment 2, all groups received the same response expectancy training, and the effect of the consequence of compensatory performance was demonstrated during subsequent test sessions 4 and 5. An informative consequence (MI or IO) enhanced tolerance and the compensatory response to placebo, whereas performance with no response contingent information (N or MO), revealed little tolerance or compensatory response to placebo. Theoretical and practical implications of the findings were discussed.

Conditioned tolerance to the anorectic and corticosterone-elevating effects of nicotine

We have shown that tolerance to the behavioral effects of nicotine is partially dependent on conditioned environmental cues that predict drug delivery. The present research extends this finding to physiological effects of nicotine by assessing both the appetite-suppressing and adrenocortical-activating effects of nicotine, as measured by plasma corticosterone (CORT). In the first study, male rats on a 22-h food deprivation schedule were injected daily with 0.33 or 0.66 mg/kg (free base) of nicotine bitartrate or saline in a distinctive environment and tested for milk intake. Nicotine initially suppressed milk intake and tolerance developed over 10 days. Changing cues associated with drug administration partially reversed tolerance since injection of nicotine in a new environment reduced milk intake of tolerant animals. Similarly, animals who repeatedly received nicotine in one environment exhibited CORT levels lower than rats injected for the first time, and this tolerance also was partially reversed when administration occurred in the new environment. The second experiment indicated that the increased CORT of Experiment 1 was not a stress response associated with injecting animals in a different environment. These results indicate that tolerance to both behavioral and neuroendocrine effects of nicotine is influenced by conditioning.

Learning factor in rapid tolerance to ethanol-induced motor impairment

Exposure of male Wistar rats to a single moderate dose (1.7 g/kg, IP) of ethanol (EtOH), followed by intensive intoxicated practice on the moving belt apparatus (a total of 12 min during the first hour after EtOH injection), results in functional tolerance to the motor-impairing effects of a second dose given either 8 or 24 h later. In the absence of intoxicated practice, or after a considerably reduced opportunity for it (a total of 4 min during the first hour after EtOH injection), the same dose of EtOH fails to produce tolerance. Thus, not only the opportunity to practice, but also its extent and possibly its quality are important determinants in the rapid development of intersessional tolerance. In contrast to its rapidity of development, no significant loss of this tolerance is evident three weeks after the tolerance acquisition sessions.