Sources identification of antibiotic pollution combining land use information and multivariate statistics

Rapid determination and risk evaluation of multi-class antibiotics in aquatic products by one-step purification process coupled with ultra-high performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry

A sensitive and robust multiclass analytical method was established to simultaneously determine 55 antibiotics in aquatic products through liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. A simple one-step purification process was successfully developed, which combined post-acidic acetonitrile extraction directly by an enhanced matrix removal cartridge. This approach eliminated the need for solvent transition. The established method for 55 antibiotics achieved an excellent linear relationship with R2 values ≥ 0.9921 in the range of 0.05-200 μg/L. The quantitation limits ranged within 0.04-5.0 μg/kg. Satisfactory recoveries (76.2%-99.7 %) were achieved with the relative standard deviations below 13.9 %. Furthermore, the antibiotic residues in aquatic products were analyzed, and the health and antibiotic resistance risk assessments were conducted. Although the health risks of target antibiotics were acceptable, a resistance risk was observed. Therefore, monitoring antibiotic residue levels in aquatic products requires considerable attention and further research to ensure the quality of marine products and consumer safety.

Multi-pathway on peroxymonosulfate activation by single cobalt atoms incorporated on CuO with enriched oxygen vacancies for high-efficient oxidation of tetracycline

The development of single atom catalysts (SACs) with superior catalytic performance is a long-term goal for peroxymonosulfate (PMS) activation in advanced oxidation processes (AOPs). A novel SACs that single Co atoms anchored on CuO with enriched oxygen vacancies (Ov) is synthesized successfully by choosing a metal oxide as the carrier creatively. 100% of tetracycline (TC) can be removed by Co-CuO (Ov)/PMS system within 3 min. The corresponding reaction rate constant is 3.1068 min-1, which is much higher than that of CuO (Ov), ZIF-CoN4-C, Co-CuO (without Ov) and CoNP-CuO (Ov), respectively. Co(II) is the primary source of radical pathway (·OH and SO4·-), and its regeneration is promoted by Cu(Ⅰ). The enriched Ov is the major contribution to the nonradical pathway, which promotes the singlet oxygen (1O2) generation together with accelerates the electron transfer from TC to catalyst-PMS*. Besides, the Co-CuO (Ov) exhibits an excellent stability and anti-interference capability. This study highlights a novel strategy to promote PMS activation by incorporating the single metal atoms on a metal oxide carrier with defects to accelerate the redox of dominate metal and stabilize the metal atoms simultaneously, which may inform the design for the next generation of SACs in AOPs.

Toxicity of emerging contaminant antibiotics in soil to Capsicum annuum L. growth and their effects on it accumulating copper

Antibiotics are a kind of emerging contaminant in soil. Tetracycline (TC) and oxytetracycline (OTC) in soil are often detected, even with very high concentration in the soils of facility agriculture due to their good effect, low price and large usage. Copper (Cu) is common heavy metal pollutant in soil. The toxicity roles of TC, OTC and/or Cu in soil on a commonly consumed vegetable Capsicum annuum L. and its Cu accumulation were not clear till now. The results of pot experiment showed that the TC or OTC added in soil alone didn't produce poison effects for C. annuum after 6 weeks and 12 weeks growth reflected by some physiological index like SOD, CAT and APX activities changes, while the biomass changes affirmed them either. Cu contaminated soil significantly inhibited the growth of C. annuum. Furthermore, combined pollution of Cu with TC or OTC was with more serious suppression of C. annuum growth. The suppression role of OTC was heavier than TC in Cu and TC or OTC contaminated soil. Such phenomenon was relevant with the role of TC or OTC increased Cu concentration in C. annuum. The improvement role of TC or OTC on Cu accumulation in C. annuum caused by the increased extractable Cu concentration in soil. The study demonstrated that TC or OTC added in soil alone was without any toxicity to C. annuum. But they may aggravate the hurt of C. annuum caused by Cu through increased its accumulation from soil. Thus, such combine pollution should be avoided in safe agricultural product.

Ecology, more than antibiotics consumption, is the major predictor for the global distribution of aminoglycoside-modifying enzymes

Antibiotic consumption and its abuses have been historically and repeatedly pointed out as the major driver of antibiotic resistance emergence and propagation. However, several examples show that resistance may persist despite substantial reductions in antibiotic use, and that other factors are at stake. Here, we study the temporal, spatial, and ecological distribution patterns of aminoglycoside resistance, by screening more than 160,000 publicly available genomes for 27 clusters of genes encoding aminoglycoside-modifying enzymes (AME genes). We find that AME genes display a very ubiquitous pattern: about 25% of sequenced bacteria carry AME genes. These bacteria were sequenced from all the continents (except Antarctica) and terrestrial biomes, and belong to a wide number of phyla. By focusing on European countries between 1997 and 2018, we show that aminoglycoside consumption has little impact on the prevalence of AME-gene-carrying bacteria, whereas most variation in prevalence is observed among biomes. We further analyze the resemblance of resistome compositions across biomes: soil, wildlife, and human samples appear to be central to understand the exchanges of AME genes between different ecological contexts. Together, these results support the idea that interventional strategies based on reducing antibiotic use should be complemented by a stronger control of exchanges, especially between ecosystems.

Insights into antibiotic stewardship of lake-rivers-basin complex systems for resistance risk control

Antibiotic stewardship is hindered by a lack of consideration for complicated environmental fate of antibiotics and their role in resistance development, while the current methodology of eco-toxicological risk assessment has not been fully protective against their potential to select for antibiotic resistance. To address this problem, we established a novel methodologic framework to perform comprehensive environmental risk assessment of antibiotics in terms of resistance development, which was based on selection effect, phenotype resistance level, heteroresistance frequency, as well as prevalence and stability of antibiotic resistance genes. We tracked the contribution of antibiotic load reduction to the mitigation of environmental risk of resistance development by fate and transport modeling. The method was instantiated in a lake-river network-basin complex system, taking the Taihu Basin as a case study. Overall, antibiotic load posed no eco-toxicological risk but an average medium-level environmental risk for resistance development in Taihu Lake. The effect of antibiotic load on resistance risk was both seasonal-dependent and category-dependent, while quinolones posed the greatest environmental risk for resistance development. Mass-flow analysis indicated that temporal-spatial variation in hydrological regime and antibiotic fate together exerted a significant effect on antibiotic load in the system. By apportioning antibiotic load to riverine influx, we identified the hotspots for load reduction and predicted the beneficial response of resistance risk under load-reduction scenarios. Our study proposed a risk-oriented strategy of basin-scaled antibiotic load reduction for environmental risk control of resistance development.

Vermont-wide assessment of anthropogenic background concentrations of perfluoroalkyl substances in surface soils

Shallow surface soils from 66 suburban sampling locations across Vermont were analyzed for 17 different perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAA). PFAA were detected in all 66 surface soils, with a total concentration of PFAA ranging from 540 to 36,000 ng/kg dry soil weight (dw). Despite the complexity of site-specific factors, some general trends and correlations in PFAA concentrations were observed. For instance, perfluoro-1-octanesulfonate (PFOS) dominated in all soil samples while seven other PFAA, including perfluoro-n-nonanoic acid, perfluoro-n-octanoic acid, perfluoro-n-hexanoic acid, perfluoro-n-heptanoic acid, perfluoro-n-decanoic acid, perfluoro-n-undecanoic acid, perfluoro-1-butanesulfonate, and perfluoro-1-hexanesulfonate (PFNA, PFOA, PFHxA, PFHpA, PFDA, PFUnDA, and PFBS, respectively), were identified at more than 50 % of the locations. Perfluoroalkyl carboxylic acids (PFCA) showed a positive correlation with total organic carbon, whereas no clear correlation was observed for perfluoroalkyl sulfonate acids (PFSA). In addition, variations in geographical distributions of PFAA were observed, with relatively higher total PFAA in northern regions when compared to Southern Vermont. Moreover, PFHxA, PFNA, PFDA, PFUnDA, PFOS, and total PFAA were positively correlated to land-use types in Northern Vermont. These results are useful for understanding unique behaviors of PFCA vs. PFSA in geospatially distributed surface soils and for providing anthropogenic background data for setting PFAS cleanup standards for surface soils.

Water Environment Quality Evaluation and Pollutant Source Analysis in Tuojiang River Basin, China

A water environment quality evaluation and pollution source analysis can quantitatively examine the relationship among water pollution, resources, and the economy, and investigate the main factors affecting water quality. This paper took COD, NH3-N, and TP of the Tuojiang River as the research objects. The water environment quality evaluation and pollution source analysis of the Tuojiang River Basin were conducted based on the grey water footprint, decoupling theoretical model, and correlation analysis method. The results showed that grey water footprint decreased, and the water environment quality improved. Among the pollution sources of the grey water footprint, TP accounted for the highest proportion. Moreover, the economic development level and the water environment were generally in a state of high-quality coordination. Farmland and stock breeding pollution accounted for the largest proportion of agricultural pollution and were thus the main source of the grey water footprint. The results of Pearson’s correlation analysis indicated that the source of the pollutants were the imported pollution from the tributaries and agricultural pollution (especially stock breeding and farmland irrigation). These results showed that the quality of the water environment was improving, and the main factors affecting the water environment were stock breeding and farmland pollution in agriculture. This study presents a decision-making basis for strengthening the ecological barrier in the Yangtze River.

Key role of suspended particulate matter in assessing fate and risk of endocrine disrupting compounds in a complex river-lake system

Endocrine-disrupting compounds (EDCs) enter lakes mainly through river inflow. However, the occurrence, transport and fate of EDCs in the overlying water, suspended particulate matter (SPM) and sediment of inflowing rivers remain unclear. This study investigated the load of seven EDCs in a complex river-lake system of the Taihu Lake Basin during different seasons, with the aims of revealing the transport routes of EDCs and identifying the contributions from different sources. The results indicated that the levels of the seven EDCs in the wet season with high temperature and dilution effects were generally lower than those in the other seasons. EDC enrichment in the sediment was largely affected by the transport and fate of SPM. Moreover, the estrogenic activity and risks of EDCs were the highest in SPM. The mass loadings of particulate EDCs carried by SPM were 2.6 times that of overlying water. SPM plays a vital role in the transport and fate of EDCs in complex river-lake systems and thereby deserves more attention. Nonpoint sources, particularly animal husbandry activities and untreated domestic sewage, were the main sources of EDCs, amounting to 61.5% of the total load.

Sedimentary spectrum and potential ecological risks of residual pharmaceuticals in relation to sediment-water partitioning and land uses in a watershed

Pharmaceutical residues in river surficial sediment are prone to anthropogenic impacts and environmental factors in watershed, but the mechanisms remain unclear. This study attempted to reveal surficial sediment-water pseudo-partitioning and anthropogenic (land use) patterns of pharmaceutical residues in surficial sediment among 23 subwatersheds of Jiulong River, southeast China with a gradient of urban land use percentile in dry and wet seasons. Thirty-eight out of target 86 compounds from six-category pharmaceuticals were quantified and ranged from below the quantification limits (0.001 mg kg^-1 dry mass) up to 8.19 mg kg^-1 dry mass (chlortetracycline) using a developed SPE-HPLC-MS/MS protocol. Antibiotics and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) collectively dominated sedimentary pharmaceutical residues for 34.5-99.8% of the total quantified compounds (median at 92%). Land uses in subwatersheds showed high consistency with sedimentary pharmaceutical residues in the dry season rather than the wet season, especially for human use only and veterinary use only compounds. Surficial sediment-water partitioning of pharmaceutical compounds influenced their sedimentary residues regardless of season, which were determined by properties of compound and surficial sediment interactively. All tetracycline compounds, trimethoprim (sulfonamides synergist), caffeine (central nervous system drug), and oxfendazole (antiparasitic drug) were quantified to pose high potential ecological risks to aquatics. Findings of this study suggest that pseudo-persistent legacy of human and veterinary pharmaceuticals requires a wider coverage of pharmaceutical compounds for a comprehensive ecological assessment in the environment and more involvement of anthropogenic impacts and socioeconomic factors in the future studies.

Occurrence, source apportionment and source-specific risk assessment of antibiotics in a typical tributary of the Yellow River basin

The spatial distributions, sources, and source-specific risk apportionments of 26 antibiotics (5 categories) in the Fenhe River basin were determined based on sample data. The results showed that antibiotics were widely distributed in the surface water. There were significant differences between the different types of antibiotics, and the highest mean concentration was that of the sulfonamide category (33.74 ng/L), accounting for 36% of the total antibiotic concentration. Spatially, all antibiotics were mainly detected in the middle and downstream areas. The ecological risk assessment results showed that the significant risk rate of antibiotics accounted for 70% and was mainly distributed in the downstream area; however, the risks differed between the 5 categories. Quinolone antibiotics exhibited the highest significant risk rate, reaching 100%. The ecological risk associated with sulfamethoxazole was the highest among all detected antibiotics. The following five main factors influenced the antibiotic concentrations: aquaculture, pharmaceutical wastewater, livestock discharges, domestic sewage, and sewage treatment plants. Among these, pharmaceutical wastewater sources contributed the most (35%) to the total antibiotic concentration, and were distributed throughout the river. Although livestock discharges were not the main reason for the high level of ecological risk, these discharges were highest at certain sites in the midstream region. Different pollution sources posed different levels of ecological risk to the Fenhe River basin, the highest of which was pharmaceutical wastewater with a significant risk rate of 58%.

A review of the toxicity in fish exposed to antibiotics

Antibiotics are widely used in the treatment of human and veterinary diseases and are being used worldwide in the agriculture industry to promote livestock growth. However, a variety of antibiotics that are found in aquatic environments are toxic to aquatic organisms. Antibiotics are not completely removed by wastewater treatment plants and are therefore released into aquatic environments, which raises concern about the destruction of the ecosystem owing to their non-target effects. Since antibiotics are designed to be persistent and work steadily in the body, their chronic toxicity effects have been studied in aquatic microorganisms. However, research on the toxicity of antibiotics in fish at the top of the aquatic food chain is relatively poor. This paper summarizes the current understanding of the reported toxicity studies with antibiotics in fish, including zebrafish, to date. Four antibiotic types; quinolones, sulfonamides, tetracyclines, and macrolides, which are thought to be genetically toxic to fish have been reported to bioaccumulate in fish tissues, as well as in aquatic environments such as rivers and surface water. The adverse effects of these antibiotics are known to cause damage to developmental, cardiovascular, and metabolic systems, as well as in altering anti-oxidant and immune responses, in fish. Therefore, there are serious concerns about the toxicity of antibiotics in fish and further research and strategies are needed to prevent them in different regions of the world.

Spatial and temporal variations of antibiotics in a tidal river

Estuary is an important route for the transport of terrestrial contaminants to the ocean. Its unique hydrodynamic properties may influence the fate and distribution of pollutants. Previous studies have shown that severe pollution because of antibiotics has occurred in many inland surface waterbodies; however, the behavior of antibiotic residuals remains poorly understood in estuarine environments. In this study, the occurrence and spatiotemporal distribution of seven selected antibiotics (i.e., sulfamethazine, sulfamethoxazole, trimethoprim, ofloxacin, ciprofloxacin, erythromycin, and roxithromycin) in a tidal river were investigated through one continuous and four synoptic sampling events. Results show that the concentrations of most antibiotics are in the nanogram per liter level, except for trimethoprim with the highest concentration up to 12,440 ng L^-1 during the wet season. Except for sulfamethazine, the other six antibiotics showed high concentrations (i.e., > 100 ng L^-1) in at least one sampling campaign. Different temporal distribution patterns of these antibiotics indicated that they were mainly controlled by source loading, flow condition, and discharge amounts. Spatial distribution indicated that the main pollution source of trimethoprim was located in lower reaches, while the other six antibiotics mainly came from the upstream sources. Based on the theoretical dilution line, erythromycin and roxithromycin degraded in the tidal river, whereas the other five types of antibiotics showed a conservative behavior. Tide has important effects on the spatial distribution of antibiotics, especially those with a wide concentration range, in estuarine environments. Furthermore, risk assessment based on the calculated risk quotients showed that five types of antibiotics pose high risks to aquatic organisms. These observations provided new insight into the distribution and transport of common antibiotics in estuarine environments.

The removal of tetracycline, oxytetracycline, and chlortetracycline by manganese oxide-doped copper oxide: the behaviors and insights of Cu-Mn combination for enhancing antibiotics removal

Adsorption process is suitable to the advanced treatment of tetracycline antibiotics (TCs; including tetracycline (TTC), oxytetracycline (OTC), and chlortetracycline (CTC)) in poultry wastewater. In this research, Mn oxide-doped Cu oxide (MODCO) was synthesized and used for the removal of TTC, OTC, and CTC. According to the XRD and SEM analysis results, MODCO has an amorphous crystal structure and is formed by the aggregation of nano-sized particles with a uniform distribution of Cu and Mn elements. In addition, MODCO has a BET surface area of 67.7 m²/g and a pH_IEP value of 7.8. The results of batch experiments illustrated that the reaction rates for the removal of three TCs were in the order of OTC > CTC > TTC. In addition, the theoretical maximum amounts of TTC, OTC, and CTC adsorbed on MODCO were determined to be 2.90 mmol/g, 4.15 mmol/g, and 2.20 mmol/g via the Langmuir model, respectively. The optimal removal performances of TCs were achieved in the pH range of 6~9, and the coexistence of anions posed an unnoticeable effect on the removal efficiencies. The spectroscopic analysis results demonstrated that the removal mechanism of TCs was mainly attributed to surface complexation. Furthermore, a part of TCs may be decomposed by Mn oxides during the removal process according to the UV spectrogram results. Overall, MODCO has exhibited a great potential for the removal of TCs from aqueous solution.

Spectrum and environmental risks of residual pharmaceuticals in stream water with emphasis on its relation to epidemic infectious disease and anthropogenic activity in watershed

Pharmaceuticals vastly consumed by modern human for health and food might track anthropogenic impacts on aquatic ecosystem via their wide residual spectrum. This study investigated the spectrum of pharmaceutical residuals in stream water at confluence point of each subwatershed with various land use pattern in Jiulong River watershed, southeastern China. Stream water was sampled in both wet and dry seasons of 2016. Results showed that 59 out of the selected 94 compounds from 6 pharmaceutical categories were quantified among these stream water samples, up to 1488 ng L^-1 for caffeine (CAF). Antibiotics and central nervous system drugs (CNs) collectively dominated the quantified instream pharmaceutical residuals. Outbreaks of epidemic infectious diseases for human and livestock partially but significantly matched seasonality of instream pharmaceutical residuals. Anthropogenic impact as land use composition of subwatersheds was significant on instream pharmaceutical loadings, especially urban land use. Cocktail risk of instream pharmaceutical residuals to aquatic organisms was assessed ranging from low to medium among the subwatersheds except high risk for the W-01 subwatershed in the dry season. Evidence from this study indicated that seasonality and wide spectrum of instream pharmaceutical residual determination could reveal anthropogenic impacts to aquatic ecosystem, such as epidemic disease and land use.

Characterization and source identification of tetracycline antibiotics in the drinking water sources of the lower Yangtze River

The occurrence and spatio-temporal patterns of five tetracyclines (TCs) and six of their degradation products were investigated in twenty-eight drinking water sources along the lower Yangtze River (LYR) over dry, normal and flood seasons. Tetracycline (TC), oxytetracycline (OTC) and doxytetracycline (DXC) were the dominant antibiotics detected with the highest occurrence. The maximum concentrations of TC, OTC and DXC were found in dry season as 11.16, 18.98, and 56.09 ng/L, respectively, because of the low dilution, low degradation, and high consumption in this season. Cluster analysis indicated distinct variations in the TCs' compositional profiles in both space and time. OTC and its metabolites contributed 18.5-59.6% of the TC load in dry season, possibly due to the seasonally increased release of pharmaceutical OTCs from sewage effluents, but they were seldom detected in other seasons. Pollution load index analysis showed that tributaries carrying large amounts of veterinary TCs derived from breeding wastewater and untreated rural sewage contributed larger proportions of the TC load for most drinking water sources than sewage outlets. The contribution ratio of the TC load from tributaries (74.5%) was approximately three times higher than that from sewage discharges (25.5%). The study demonstrated that the control of load from tributaries is the key to mitigating TC pollution of the drinking water sources in the LYR. An effective source tracking method for evaluating the contribution of antibiotic load from multiple diffuse pollution origins and identifying the high-risk contamination sources was established for antibiotic management and control.

Induced-fit adsorption of diol-based porous organic polymers for tetracycline removal

Adsorption is recognized as one of the most efficient approaches for antibiotics removal from water. Inspired by the enzyme-substrate interaction model, we proposed induced-fit adsorption (IFA) model, and rationally designed and fabricated diol-based porous organic polymers (POPs) as adsorbents for tetracycline (TC) removal. For 2,3-naphthalenediol-based POP (NTdiol-POP), the preferable geometry of diol-groups contributed to the high binding energy with TC species and flexible methylene linkages between neighboring rigid naphthalene rings gave rise to precisely matching between TC species and adsorbents, that is, the induced-fit conformation change. As a result, NTdiol-POP exhibited a high saturated adsorption capacity of 155.8 mg g^-1. More importantly, NTdiol-POP exhibited excellent TC removal efficiencies in both concentrated solution (96% for 4 p.p.m) and trace level solution (97% for 250 p.p.b).

Co-contamination of antibiotics and metals in peri-urban agricultural soils and source identification

To identify the dominant sources of contamination in peri-urban land, this study investigated the concentrations and distributions of antibiotics and metals in agricultural soil of this area. An index of landscape development intensity (LDI) was used to characterize the distribution of human disturbance-related land use. The results showed that total antibiotic concentration in the soil reached 395.55 μg/kg and that chlortetracycline was the predominant antibiotic compound, with a relatively high mean concentration of 30.62 μg/kg. In soils, the mean concentrations of Cu, Zn, and Pb were 38.41, 127.88, and 56.61 mg/kg and those of Al, Fe, and K were 83.73, 24.17, and 23.42 g/kg, respectively. A redundancy analysis showed that the landscape pattern in a 300-m buffer zone can well explain the variation in the concentrations of antibiotics and metals (24%, p < 0.05). The LDI in the 300-m buffer zone significantly correlated with the concentrations of total antibiotics and total amounts of Cu and Zn in the soil, suggesting that the risk of soil contamination increases with the intensity of anthropogenic activities. A structural equation modeling analysis indicated that Al, Cu, and Zn could significantly aggravate accumulation of tetracycline antibiotics in the soil, whereas there were only significantly direct paths from Cu to ciprofloxacin and norfloxacin. Overall, the results showed that aggravated co-contamination of antibiotics and metals occurs in agricultural soil under intensive human disturbance.

Urbanization gradient of selected pharmaceuticals in surface water at a watershed scale

Ubiquitous detection of pharmaceuticals in the aquatic environment around the world raises a great public concern. Aquatic residuals of pharmaceuticals have been assumed to relate to land use patterns and various human activities within a catchment or watershed. This study generated a gradient of human activity in the Jiulong River watershed, southeastern China by urban land use percentage in 20 research subwatersheds. Thirty-three compounds from three-category pharmaceuticals [26 compounds of 5 antibiotic groups, 6 compounds of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), and 1 compound of respiratory system drugs (RSDs)] were quantified in stream water before the research subwatershed confluences with two sampling events in dry and wet seasons. In total, 27 out of the 33 pharmaceutical compounds of interest were found in stream waters. Seasonality of instream pharmaceuticals was observed, with less compounds and lower concentrations in the wet season sampling event than in the dry season one. Urban land use in the research subwatershed was identified as the main factor influencing in stream pharmaceutical concentrations and composition regardless of season. Rural land uses contributed a mixture of human and veterinary pharmaceuticals possibly from agricultural application of manure and sewage sludge and aquaculture in the research subwatersheds. Erythromycin in both sampling events showed medium to high risks to aquatic organisms. Results of this study suggest that urban pharmaceutical management, such as a strict prescription regulations and high-efficient removal of pharmaceuticals in wastewater treatment, is critical in reducing aquatic pharmaceutical loads.