Impact of erythromycin on a non-target organism: Cellular effects on the freshwater microalga Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata

A Novel Method for the Assessment of Feeding Rate as a Phenotypic Endpoint for the Impact of Pollutants in Daphnids

Traditional approaches for monitoring aquatic pollution primarily rely on chemical analysis and the detection of pollutants in the aqueous environments. However, these methods lack realism and mechanistic insight and, thus, are increasingly supported by effect-based methods, which offer sensitive endpoints. In this context, daphnids, a freshwater species used extensively in molecular ecotoxicology, offer fast and noninvasive approaches to assess the impact of pollutants. Among the phenotypic endpoints used, feeding rate is a highly sensitive approach because it provides evidence of physiological alterations even in sublethal concentrations. However, there has been no standardized method for measuring feeding rate in daphnids, and several approaches follow different protocols. There is a diversity among tests employing large volumes, extensive incubation times, and high animal densities, which in turn utilize measurements of algae via fluorescence, radiolabeling, or counting ingested cells. These tests are challenging and laborious and sometimes require cumbersome instrumentation. In the present study, we optimized the conditions of a miniaturized fast, sensitive, and high-throughput assay to assess the feeding rate based on the ingestion of fluorescent microparticles. The protocol was optimized in neonates in relation to the concentration of microplastic and the number of animals to increase reproducibility. Daphnids, following exposures to nonlethal concentrations, were incubated with microplastics; and, as filter feeders, they ingest microparticles. The new approach revealed differences in the physiology of daphnids in concentrations below the toxicity limits for a range of pollutants of different modes of action, thus proving feeding to be a more sensitive and noninvasive endpoint in pollution assessment. Environ Toxicol Chem 2024;00:1-11. © 2024 The Author(s). Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of SETAC.

Chronic toxic effects of erythromycin and its photodegradation products on microalgae Chlorella pyrenoidosa

The photodegradation products (PDPs) of antibiotics in the aquatic environment received increasing concern, but their chronic effects on microalgae remain unclear. This study initially focused on examining the acute effects of erythromycin (ERY), then explored the chronic impacts of ERY PDPs on Chlorella pyrenoidosa. ERY of 4.0 - 32 mg/L ERY notably inhibited the cell growth and chlorophyll synthesis. The determined 96 h median effective concentration of ERY to C. pyrenoidosa was 11.78 mg/L. Higher concentrations of ERY induced more serious oxidative damage, antioxidant enzymes alleviated the oxidative stress. 6 PDPs (PDP749, PDP747, PDP719, PDP715, PDP701 and PDP557) were identified in the photodegradation process of ERY. The predicted combined toxicity of PDPs increased in the first 3 h, then decreased. Chronic exposure showed a gradual decreasing inhibition on microalgae growth and chlorophyll content. The acute effect of ERY PDPs manifested as growth stimulation, but the chronic effect manifested as growth inhibition. The malonaldehyde contents decreased with the degradation time of ERY at 7, 14 and 21 d. However, the malonaldehyde contents of ERY PDPs treatments were elevated compared to those in the control group after 21 d. Risk assessment still need to consider the potential toxicity of degradation products under long-term exposure.

Features of the microalga Raphidocelis subcapitata: physiology and applications

The microalga Raphidocelis subcapitata was isolated from the Nitelva River (Norway) and subsequently deposited in the collection of the Norwegian Institute of Water Research as "Selenastrum capricornutum Printz". This freshwater microalga, also known as Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata, acquired much of its notoriety due to its high sensitivity to different chemical species, which makes it recommended by different international organizations for the assessment of ecotoxicity. However, outside this scope, R. subcapitata continues to be little explored. This review aims to shed light on a microalga that, despite its popularity, continues to be an "illustrious" unknown in many ways. Therefore, R. subcapitata taxonomy, phylogeny, shape, size/biovolume, cell ultra-structure, and reproduction are reviewed. The nutritional and cultural conditions, chronological aging, and maintenance and preservation of the alga are summarized and critically discussed. Applications of R. subcapitata, such as its use in aquatic toxicology (ecotoxicity assessment and elucidation of adverse toxic outcome pathways) are presented. Furthermore, the latest advances in the use of this alga in biotechnology, namely in the bioremediation of effluents and the production of value-added biomolecules and biofuels, are highlighted. To end, a perspective regarding the future exploitation of R. subcapitata potentialities, in a modern concept of biorefinery, is outlined. KEY POINTS: • An overview of alga phylogeny and physiology is critically reviewed. • Advances in alga nutrition, cultural conditions, and chronological aging are presented. • Its use in aquatic toxicology and biotechnology is highlighted.

Metabolomic Response of Thalassiosira weissflogii to Erythromycin Stress: Detoxification Systems, Steroidal Metabolites, and Energy Metabolism

Erythromycin, a macrolide antibiotic, is a prioritized pollutant that poses a high risk to environmental health. It has been detected in different environmental matrices and can cause undesired effects in aquatic organisms, particularly freshwater algae, which are primary producers. However, the impact of erythromycin on marine algae remains largely unexplored. Erythromycin has been reported to induce hormetic effects in the marine diatom Thalassiosira weissflogii (T. weissflogii). These effects are associated with the molecular pathways and biological processes of ribosome assembly, protein translation, photosynthesis, and oxidative stress. However, the alterations in the global gene expression have yet to be validated at the metabolic level. The present study used non-targeted metabolomic analysis to reveal the altered metabolic profiles of T. weissflogii under erythromycin stress. The results showed that the increased cell density was possibly attributed to the accumulation of steroidal compounds with potential hormonic action at the metabolic level. Additionally, slight increases in the mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP) and viable cells were observed in the treatment of 0.001 mg/L of erythromycin (an environmentally realistic level). Contrarily, the 0.75 and 2.5 mg/L erythromycin treatments (corresponding to EC20 and EC50, respectively) showed decreases in the MMP, cell density, and viable algal cells, which were associated with modified metabolic pathways involving ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters, the metabolism of hydrocarbons and lipids, thiamine metabolism, and the metabolism of porphyrin and chlorophyll. These findings suggest that metabolomic analysis, as a complement to the measurement of apical endpoints, could provide novel insights into the molecular mechanisms of hormesis induced by antibiotic agents in algae.

Sub-lethal toxicity of five disinfection by-products on microalgae determined by flow cytometry - Lines of evidence for adverse outcome pathways

Standardised tests are often used to determine the ecotoxicity of chemicals and focus mainly on one or a few generic endpoints (e.g. mortality, growth), but information on the sub-cellular processes leading to these effects remain usually partial or missing. Flow cytometry (FCM) can be a practical tool to study the physiological responses of individual cells (such as microalgae) exposed to a stress via the use of fluorochromes and their morphology and natural autofluorescence. This work aimed to assess the effects of five chlorine-based disinfection by-products (DBPs) taken individually on growth and sub-cellular endpoints of the green microalgae Raphidocelis subcapitata. These five DBPs, characteristic of a chlorinated effluent, are the following monochloroacetic acid (MCAA), dichloroacetic acid (DCAA), trichloroacetic acid (TCAA), bromochloroacetic acid (BCAA) and 1,1-dichloropropan-2-one (1,1-DCP). Results showed that 1,1-DCP had the strongest effect on growth inhibition (EC50 = 1.8 mg.L-1), followed by MCAA, TCAA, BCAA and DCAA (EC50 of 10.1, 15.7, 27.3 and 64.5 mg.L-1 respectively). Neutral lipid content, reactive oxygen species (ROS) formation, red autofluorescence, green autofluorescence, size and intracellular complexity were significantly affected by the exposure to the five DBPs. Only mitochondrial membrane potential did not show any variation. Important cellular damages (>10%) were observed for only two of the chemicals (BCAA and 1,1-DCP) and were probably due to ROS formation. The most sensitive and informative sub-lethal parameter studied was metabolic activity (esterase activity), for which three types of response were observed. Combining all this information, an adverse outcome pathways framework was proposed to explain the effect of the targeted chemicals on R. subcapitata. Based on these results, both FCM sub-cellular analysis and conventional endpoint of algal toxicity were found to be complementary approaches.

Palmelloid-like phenotype in the alga Raphidocelis subcapitata exposed to pollutants: A generalized adaptive strategy to stress or a specific cellular response?

This work focuses on the formation of palmelloid-like phenotype in the freshwater alga Raphidocelis subcapitata (formerly known as Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata and Selenastrum capricornutum), when exposed to adverse conditions generated by the presence of organic [the antibiotic erythromycin (ERY) and the herbicide metolachlor (MET)] or inorganic [the heavy metals, cadmium (Cd) and zinc (Zn)] pollutants, at environmentally relevant concentrations. This alga in absence of stress or when exposed to ERY or Zn, up to 200 µg/L, essentially showed a single-nucleus state, although algal growth was reduced or stopped. R. subcapitata "switched" to a multinucleated state (palmelloid-like morphology) and accumulated energy-reserve compounds (neutral lipids) when stressed by 100-200 µg/L MET or 200 µg/L Cd; at these concentrations of pollutants, growth was arrested, however, the majority of the algal population (≥83 %) was alive. The formation of palmelloid-like phenotype, at sub-lethal concentrations of pollutants, was dependent on the pollutant, its concentration and exposure time. The multinucleated structure is a transitory phenotype since R. subcapitata population was able to revert to a single-nucleus state, with normal cell size, within 24-96 h (depending on the impact of the toxic in the alga), after being transferred to fresh OECD medium, without pollutants. The obtained results indicate that the formation of a palmelloid-like phenotype in R. subcapitata is dependent on the mode of action of toxics and their concentration, not constituting a generalized defense mechanism against stress. The observations here shown contribute to understanding the different strategies used by the unicellular alga R. subcapitata to cope with severe stress imposed by organic and inorganic pollutants.

Mechanistic insights into hormesis induced by erythromycin in the marine alga Thalassiosira weissflogii

Erythromycin (ERY) is a typical macrolide antibiotic with large production and extensive use on a global scale. Detection of ERY in both freshwaters and coaster seawaters, as well as relatively high ecotoxicity of ERY have been documented. Notably, hormesis has been reported on several freshwater algae under ERY stress, where growth was promoted at relatively lower exposures but inhibited at higher treatment levels. On the contrary, there is limited information of ERY toxicity in marine algae, hampering the risk assessment on ERY in the coaster waters. The presence of hormesis may challenge the current concept of dose-response adopted in chemical risk assessment. Whether and how exposure to ERY can induce dose-dependent toxicity in marine algae remain virtually unknown, especially at environmentally relevant concentrations. The present study used a model marine diatom Thalassiosira weissflogii (T. weissflogii) to reveal its toxicological responses to ERY at different biological levels and decipher the underlying mechanisms. Assessment of multiple apical endpoints shows an evident growth promotion following ERY exposure at an environmentally relevant concentration (1 µg/L), associated with increased contents reactive oxygen species (ROS) and chlorophyll-a (Chl-a), activated signaling pathways related to ribosome biosynthesis and translation, and production of total soluble protein. By contrast, growth inhibition in the 750 and 2500 µg/L treatments was attributed to reduced viability, increased ROS formation, reduced content of total soluble protein, inhibited photosynthesis, and perturbed signaling pathways involved in xenobiotic metabolism, ribosome, metabolism of amino acid, and nitrogen metabolism. Measurements of multiple apical endpoints coupled with de novo transcriptomics analysis applied in the present study, a systems biology approach, can generate detailed mechanistic information of chemical toxicity including dose-response and species sensitivity difference used in environmental risk assessment.

Treatment of antibiotic-containing wastewater with self-suspended algae-bacteria symbiotic particles: Removal performance and reciprocal mechanism

Emerging contaminants such as antibiotics in wastewater have posed a challenge on conventional biological treatment processes. Algae-bacteria symbiotic mode could improve the performance of biological treatment processes. Self-suspended algae-bacteria symbiotic particles (ABSPs) were prepared with Chlorella vulgaris and Bacillus subtilis using the sol-gel method and hollow glass microspheres in this study. The removal effect of nitrogen and phosphorus as well as the feedback mechanism of ABSPs under tetracycline stress were investigated through three-cycles wastewater treatment experiments. The antioxidant enzyme activity and phycosphere extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) content were identified as well. The results indicated that the removal rates of NH₄⁺-N, TP, COD, and tetracycline in the ABSPs group finally reached 96.18%, 95.44%, 81.36%, and 74.20%, respectively, which were higher than the single algae group apparently. The phycosphere EPS content increased by 20.41% and algae cell structure maintained integrity in ABSPs group as compared with that in single algae group. This study demonstrates that the self-suspended ABSPs can improve contaminants removal performance and alleviate the antioxidant stress response of algae through algal-bacterial reciprocity mechanism.

How do freshwater microalgae and cyanobacteria respond to antibiotics?

Antibiotic pollution is an emerging environmental challenge. Residual antibiotics from various sources, including municipal and industrial wastewater, sewage discharges, and agricultural runoff, are continuously released into freshwater environments, turning them into reservoirs that contribute to the development and spread of antibiotic resistance. Thus, it is essential to understand the impacts of antibiotic residues on aquatic organisms, especially microalgae and cyanobacteria, due to their crucial roles as primary producers in the ecosystem. This review summarizes the effects of antibiotics on major biological processes in freshwater microalgae and cyanobacteria, including photosynthesis, oxidative stress, and the metabolism of macromolecules. Their adaptive mechanisms to antibiotics exposure, such as biodegradation, bioadsorption, and bioaccumulation, are also discussed. Moreover, this review highlights the important factors affecting the antibiotic removal pathways by these organisms, which will promote the use of microalgae-based technology for the removal of antibiotics. Finally, we offer some perspectives on the opportunities for further studies and applications.

Metabolomic profiles in a green alga (Raphidocelis subcapitata) following erythromycin treatment: ABC transporters and energy metabolism

A recent study showed that erythromycin (ERY) exposure caused hormesis in a model alga (Raphidocelis subcapitata) where the growth was promoted at an environmentally realistic concentration (4 µg/L) but inhibited at two higher concentrations (80 and 120 µg/L), associated with opposite actions of certain signaling pathways (e.g., xenobiotic metabolism, DNA replication). However, these transcriptional alterations remain to be investigated and verified at the metabolomic level. This study uncovered metabolomic profiles and detailed toxic mechanisms of ERY in R. subcapitata using untargeted metabolomics. The metabolomic analysis showed that metabolomic pathways including ABC transporters, fatty acid biosynthesis and purine metabolism were associated with growth promotion in algae treated with 4 µg/L ERY. An overcompensation was possibly activated by the low level of ERY in algae where more resources were reallocated to efficiently restore the temporary impairments, ultimately leading to the outperformance of growth. By contrast, algal growth inhibition in the 80 and 120 µg/L ERY treatments was likely attributed to the dysfunction of metabolomic pathways related to ABC transporters, energy metabolism and metabolism of nucleosides. Apart from binding of ERY to the 50S subunit of ribosomes to inhibit protein translation as in bacteria, the data presented here indicate that inhibition of protein translation and growth performance of algae by ERY may also result from the suppression of amino acid biosynthesis and aminoacyl-tRNA biosynthesis. This study provides novel insights into the dose-dependent toxicity of ERY on R. subcapitata.

Antibiotic Pollution of Planktonic Ecosystems: A Review Focused on Community Analysis and the Causal Chain Linking Individual- and Community-Level Responses

Antibiotic pollution has become one of the most challenging environmental issues in aquatic ecosystems, with adverse effects on planktonic organisms that occupy the base of the aquatic food chain. However, research regarding this topic has not been systematically reviewed, especially in terms of community-level responses. In this review, we provide an overview of current antibiotic pollution in aquatic environments worldwide. Then, we summarize recent studies concerning the responses of planktonic communities to antibiotics, ranging from individual- to community-level responses. Studies have shown that extremely high concentrations of antibiotics can directly harm the growth and survival of plankton; however, such concentrations are rarely found in natural freshwater. It is more likely that environmentally relevant concentrations of antibiotics will affect the physiological, morphological, and behavioral characteristics of planktonic organisms; influence interspecific interactions among plankton species via asymmetrical responses in species traits; and thus alter the structure and function of the entire planktonic ecosystem. This review highlights the importance of community analysis in revealing antibiotic toxicity. We also encourage the establishment of the causal relationships between impacts at multiple scales in the future for predicting the community-level consequences of antibiotics based on the currently available individual-level evidence.

Antibiotic Toxicity Isolated and as Binary Mixture to Freshwater Algae Raphidocelis subcapitata: Growth Inhibition, Prediction Model, and Environmental Risk Assessment

Antibiotics in aqueous environments can have extremely adverse effects on non-targeted organisms. However, many research projects have only focused on the toxicological evaluation of individual antibiotics in various environments. In the present work, individual and binary mixture toxicity experiments have been conducted with the model organism Raphidocelis subcapitata (R. subcapitata), and a mixture concentration-response curve was established and contrasted with the estimated effects on the basis of both the concentration addition (CA) and the independent action (IA) models. In addition, different risk assessment methods were used and compared to evaluate the environmental risk of binary mixtures. The toxic ranking of the selected antibiotics to R. subcapitata was erythromycin (ERY) > sulfamethoxazole (SMX) > sulfamethazine (SMZ). In general, the conclusion of this study is that the adverse effects of binary mixtures are higher than the individual antibiotics. The CA model and RQSTU are more suitable for toxicity prediction and risk assessment of binary mixtures. This study reveals the potential ecological risks that antibiotics and their mixtures may pose to water ecosystems, thus providing scientific information for environmental quality regulation.

Removal mechanisms of erythromycin by microalgae Chlorella pyrenoidosa and toxicity assessment during the treatment process

Microalgae-based biotechnology for antibiotic removal has received increasing attention as an economical and green method. This study investigated the removal mechanism of erythromycin by Chlorella pyrenoidosa and its correlation with the ecotoxic responses of microalgae. The degradation products (DPs) were identified, and their toxicity was predicted. The results indicated that only 4.04 %, 6.28 % and 23.53 % of erythromycin were left after 21-day microalgae treatment in 0.1, 1.0 and 10 mg/L treatments, respectively. Biodegradation contributed 48.62-67.01 %, 16.67-52.32 % and 6.42-24.82 %, while abiotic degradation contributed 8.76-29.61 %, 5.19-41.39 %, and 16.55-51.22 % to erythromycin attenuation in 0.1, 1.0, and 10 mg/L treatments, respectively. The growth and physiological-biochemical parameters of microalgae were slightly affected in low concentration treatment, which may be the main reason that biodegradation was the prominent removal mechanism. By contrast, oxidative damage in high concentration treatment inhibited the cell growth and chlorophyll content of microalgae, which hindered erythromycin biodegradation. In addition, eleven erythromycin degradation products (DPs) were identified during microalgae treatment of 21 days. Seven DPs including DP717, DP715, DP701A, DP701B, DP657, DP643, and DP557, represented higher toxicity to aquatic organisms than erythromycin.

Advanced insights on removal of antibiotics by microalgae-bacteria consortia: A state-of-the-art review and emerging prospects

Antibiotics abuse has triggered a growing environmental problem, posing a major threat to both ecosystem and human health. Unfortunately, there are still several shortcomings to current antibiotics removal technologies. Microalgae-bacteria consortia have been shown to be a promising antibiotics treatment technology owing to advantages of high antibiotics removal efficiency, low operational cost, and carbon emission reduction. This review aims to introduce the removal mechanisms, influencing factors, and future research perspectives for using microalgae-bacteria consortia to remove antibiotics. The interaction mechanisms between microalgae and bacteria are comprehensively revealed, and their exclusive advantages have been summarized in a "Trilogy" strategy, including "reinforced physical contact", "upgraded substance utilization along with antibiotics degradation", and "robust biological regulation". What's more, the relationship between different interaction mechanisms is emphatically analyzed. The important influencing factors, including concentration and classes of antibiotics, environmental conditions, and operational parameters, of antibiotics removal were also assessed. Three innovative treatment systems (microalgae-bacteria fuel cells (MBFCs), microalgae-bacteria membrane photobioreactors (MB-MPBRs), and microalgae-bacteria granular sludge (MBGS)) along with three advanced techniques (metabolic engineering, machine learning, and molecular docking and dynamics) are then introduced. In addition, concrete implementing schemes of the above advanced techniques are also provided. Finally, the current challenges and future research directions in using microalgae-bacteria consortia to remove antibiotics have been summarized. Overall, this review addresses the current state of microalgae-bacteria consortia for antibiotics treatment and provides corresponding recommendations for enhancing antibiotics removal efficiency.

Evolution of antibiotic resistance genes and bacterial community during erythromycin fermentation residue composting

The removal efficiency of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) is the biggest challenge for the treatment of erythromycin fermentation residue (EFR). In the current research, 0% (control), 10% (T1), and 30% (T2) spray-dried EFR were composted with bulking materials, consisting of cattle manure and maize straw, for 30 days. Environmental factors and bacterial community on the behaviors of ARGs were further investigated. Apart from the high levels of erythromycin, the electrical conductivities were also increased by 66.7% and 291.7% in the samples of T1 and T2, respectively. After 30 days of composting, total ARGs in the samples of control were decreased by 78.1%-91.2%, but those of T1 and T2 were increased 14.5-16.7- and 38.5-68.7-fold. ARGs related to ribosomal protection (erm) dominated the samples of T1 and T2 at D 13 and 30, especially that ermF accounted for more than 80% of the total ARGs. Furthermore, the results of bacterial community revealed that EFR promoted the growth of Proteobacteria and Bacteroidetes, but inhibited that of Actinobacteria, Verrucomicrobia and Chloroflexi. Network analysis revealed that the enriched ARGs had strong correlation with seven bacterial genera, including Halomonas, Oceanobacillus, and Alcaligenes, most of which are halotolerant. Above all, erythromycin combined with high salinity can have synergistic effect on the enrichment of ARGs and their hosts.

Toxicological Effects of Microplastics and Sulfadiazine on the Microalgae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Despite the fact that microplastics (MPs) facilitate the adsorption of environmental organic pollutants and influence their toxicity for organisms, more study is needed on the combination of MPs and antibiotics pollutant effects. In this study, polystyrene MPs (1 and 5 μm) and sulfadiazine (SDZ) were examined separately and in combination on freshwater microalga, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. The results suggest that both the MPs and SDZ alone and in combination inhibited the growth of microalgae with an increasing concentration of MPs and SDZ (5–200 mg l^–1); however, the inhibition rate was reduced by combination. Upon exposure for 7 days, both the MPs and SDZ inhibited algal growth, reduced chlorophyll content, and enhanced superoxide dismutase (SOD) activities, whereas glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px) activity was elevated only with the exposure of 1 μm MPs. Fluorescence microscopy and scanning electron microscopy also indicated that particle size contributed to the combined toxicity by aggregating MPs with periphery pollutants. Further, the amount of extracellular secretory protein increased in the presence of MPs and SDZ removal ratio decreased when MPs and SDZ coexisted, suggesting that MPs affected SDZ metabolism by microalgae. The particle size of microplastics affected the toxicity of MPs on microalgae and the combined effect of MPs and SDZ could be mitigated by MPs adsorption. These findings provide insight into microalgae responses to the combination of MPs and antibiotics in water ecosystems.

Integral Valorization of Two-Phase Olive Mill Solid Waste (OMSW) and Related Washing Waters by Anaerobic Co-digestion of OMSW and the Microalga Raphidocelis subcapitata Cultivated in These Effluents

This study evaluates the comprehensive valorization of the byproducts derived from the two-phase olive oil elaboration process [i.e., olive washing water (OWW), olive oil washing water (OOWW), and olive mill solid waste (OMSW)] in a closed-loop process. Initially, the microalga Raphidocelis subcapitata was grown using a mixture of OWW and OOWW as the culture medium, allowing phosphate, nitrate, sugars, and soluble chemical oxygen demand removal. In a second step, the microalgal biomass grown in the mixture of washing waters was used as a co-substrate together with OMSW for an anaerobic co-digestion process. The anaerobic co-digestion of the combination of 75% OMSW-25% R. subcapitata enhanced the methane yield by 7.0 and 64.5% compared to the anaerobic digestion of the OMSW and R. subcapitata individually. This schedule of operation allowed for integration of all of the byproducts generated from the two-phase olive oil elaboration process in a full valorization system and the establishment of a circular economy concept for the olive oil industry.

Azithromycin induces dual effects on microalgae: Roles of photosynthetic damage and oxidative stress

Antibiotics are frequently detected in aquatic ecosystems, posing a potential threat to the freshwater environment. However, the response mechanism of freshwater microalgae to antibiotics remains inadequately understood. Here, the impacts of azithromycin (a broadly used antibiotic) on microalgae Chlorella pyrenoidosa were systematically studied. The results revealed that high concentrations (5-100 μg/L) of azithromycin inhibited algal growth, with a 96-h half maximal effective concentration of 41.6 μg/L. Azithromycin could weaken the photosynthetic activities of algae by promoting heat dissipation, inhibiting the absorption and trapping of light energy, impairing the reaction centre, and blocking electron transfer beyond Q_A. The blockage of the electron transport chain in the photosynthetic process further induced the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). The increases in the activities of superoxide dismutase, peroxidase and glutathione played important roles in antioxidant systems but were still not enough to scavenge the excessive ROS, thus resulting in the oxidative damage indicated by the elevated malondialdehyde level. Furthermore, azithromycin reduced the energy reserves (protein, carbohydrate and lipid) and impaired the cellular structure. In contrast, a hormesis effect on algal growth was found when exposed to low concentrations (0.5 and 1 μg/L) of azithromycin. Low concentrations of azithromycin could induce the activities of the PSII reaction centre by upregulating the mRNA expression of psbA. Additionally, increased chlorophyll b and carotenoids could improve the absorption of light energy and decrease oxidative damage, which further contributed to the increase in energy reserves (protein, carbohydrate and lipid). The risk quotients of azithromycin calculated in this study were higher than 1, suggesting that azithromycin could pose considerable ecological risks in real environments. The present work confirmed that azithromycin induced dual effects on microalgae, which provided new insight for understanding the ecological risk of antibiotics.

Combined Effects of Sulfamethoxazole and Erythromycin on a Freshwater Microalga, Raphidocelis subcapitata: Toxicity and Oxidative Stress

This study investigated the environmental effects of two familiar emerging contaminants, sulfamethoxazole (SMX) and erythromycin (ERY), and their mixture (10:1 w/w) using a green microalga, R. subcapitata. The cell density, pigment content, and the activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT), glutathione (GSH) glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px), and glutathione S-transferase (GST) were analyzed. The calculated EC₅₀ values of SMX, ERY, and their mixture after 96 h were 0.49, 0.044, and 0.06 mg/L, respectively. High concentrations of antibiotics lead to a decrease in chlorophyll a and total carotenoid content, affecting the ability to photosynthesize ROS scavenging capacity. This may be a factor leading to the inhibition of algal growth. When R. subcapitata was exposed to SMX and the mixture, SOD and CAT increased to resist oxidative damage, while the activities of GSH and GST decreased, suggesting that this algae’s antioxidant system was unbalanced due to oxidative stress. R. subcapitata reduced the ERY-induced ROS by increasing the activities of SOD, GSH, and GST. The difference in the contents of nonenzymatic antioxidants and enzyme antioxidants in R. subcapitata indicated the antioxidant mechanisms to SMX and ERY were not identical. This study provides insights into the oxidative stress process in R. subcapitata under different antibiotics.

Attenuation pathways of erythromycin and biochemical responses related to algal growth and lipid synthesis in a microalga-effluent system

Microalgal cultivation in municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) can realize the coupling of wastewater treatment and microalgae energy utilization, however, the residual antibiotics in effluents from WWTPs affect the growth of microalgae. In this study, green alga (Scenedesmus obliquus) cells were inoculated into the effluents to ascertain the attenuation pathways of erythromycin (ERY) and the biochemical responses of microalga in a microalga-effluent system. Results showed that hydrolysis, photolysis, and biodegradation (including bioadsorption) cause the attenuation of ERY in a microalga-effluent system, and the biodegradation (including bioadsorption) has the greatest removal rate (reaching a maximum of 57.87%), followed by hydrolysis (reaching a maximum of 34.13%), and photolysis (less than 5%) after five days. The photosynthetic pigment contents in cells of microalga decreased the most (by 35.66% for chlorophyll a), and the production of ROS was stimulated (by 33.75%) after five-day exposure to ERY at an initial concentration of 100 μg/L. Meanwhile, the activity of ribulose-1,5-biphosphate carboxylase (RuBPCase) decreased by 55.65%, and the activity of acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACCase) increased by 55.65%. The ROS level, photosynthetic pigment content, and RuBPCase activity were extremely significantly correlated with each other (P < 0.01), indicating that exposure to ERY changed those biochemical responses related to the rate of photosynthesis of microalga, inhibiting the growth thereof. On the other hand, exposure to ERY increased lipid production by microalga through the induced ACCase activity.

The Toxic Effects of Antibiotics on Freshwater and Marine Photosynthetic Microorganisms: State of the Art

Antibiotic residues have been commonly detected worldwide in freshwater, estuarine, and marine ecosystems. The review summarizes the up-to-date information about the toxic effects of over 60 antibiotics on nontarget autotrophic microorganisms with a particular focus on marine microalgae. A comprehensive overview of the available reports led to the identification of significant knowledge gaps. The data on just one species of freshwater green algae (Raphidocelis subcapitata) constitute 60% of the total information on the toxicity of antibiotics, while data on marine species account for less than 14% of the reports. Moreover, there is a clear knowledge gap regarding the chronic effects of antibiotic exposure (only 9% of studies represent exposition time values longer than 7 days). The review summarizes the information on different physiological endpoints, including processes involved in photosynthesis, photoprotective and antioxidant mechanisms. Currently, the hazard assessment is mostly based on the results of the evaluation of individual chemicals and acute toxicity tests of freshwater organisms. Future research trends should involve chronic effect studies incorporating sensitive endpoints with the application of environmentally relevant concentrations, as well as studies on the mixture effects and combined environmental factors influencing toxicity.

Effects of three antibiotics on growth and antioxidant response of Chlorella pyrenoidosa and Anabaena cylindrica

Antibiotics are essential for treatments of bacterial infection and play important roles in the fields of aquaculture and animal husbandry. Antibiotics are accumulated in water and soil due to the excessive consumption and incomplete treatment of antibiotic wastewater. The accumulation of antibiotics in ecological systems leads to global environmental risks. The toxic effects of spiramycin (SPI), tigecycline (TGC), and amoxicillin (AMX) on Chlorella pyrenoidesa and Anabaena cylindrica were evaluated based on growth inhibition experiments, and determinations of ROS production and antioxidant enzyme activities (catalase, superoxide dismutase, and malondialdehyde). Half maximal effective concentrations (EC50) of TGC, SPI, and AMX for A. cylindrica were 62.52 μg/L, 38.40 μg/L, and 7.66 mg/L, respectively. Those were 6.20 mg/L, 4.58 mg/L, and > 2 g/L for C. pyrenoidesa, respectively. It was shown that A. cylindrica was much more sensitive to these antibiotics than C. pyrenoidesa. In addition, EC50 values of SPI and TGC were lower than that of AMX. It was indicated that SPI and TGC had higher toxic than AMX to C. pyrenoidesa and A. cylindrica. The current study is helpful to evaluating possible ecological risks of TGC, SPI, and AMX by green microalgae and cyanobacteria.

Identification of potential toxicants in sediments from an industrialized area in Pohang, South Korea: Application of a cell viability assay of microalgae using flow cytometry

Potential toxicants in sediments collected from an industrialized bay of Korea were identified by use of effect-directed analysis (EDA). Three marine microalgal bioassays (Dunaliella tertiolecta, Isochrysis galbana, and Phaeodactylum tricornutum) with diverse endpoints were employed. Initial screening of raw organic extracts of sediments indicated large variations among locations and species in a traditional endpoint "inhibition of growth". After fractionation, inhibition of growths increased significantly, particularly in some fractions containing aromatics with log K_OW 5-6 (F2.6). While viabilities of cells were adversely affected in more fractions, including F2.6-F2.7 (log K_OW 5-7) and F3.5-F3.6 (log K_OW 4-6). Among the several endpoints of viability, esterase activity seemed to be more sensitive, followed by integrity of cell membranes, chlorophyll a, cell size, and intracellular complexity. Instrumental analyses indicated that toxicities to microalgae observed in F2.7 could not be fully explained by target PAHs. Full-scan screening analysis using GC-QTOFMS identified 58 compounds in F2.7 with matching scores ≥90%. Based on toxic potencies for these compounds predicted by ECOSAR, several causative agents, including 1-phenylpyrene, dibenz[a,c]anthracene, and picene were suggested. Overall, viability of microalgae provided sensitive and high-resolution toxicity screening of samples into integrative assessment of sediment.

Influence of polystyrene microplastic and nanoplastic on copper toxicity in two freshwater microalgae

There has been increasing concern over the toxic effects of microplastics (MP), nanoplastics (NP), and copper (Cu) on microalgae. However, the combined toxicity of the metal in the presence of polystyrene (PS) MP/NP on microalgae has not been well studied, particularly after long-term exposure (i.e., longer than 4 days). The primary aim of the present study was to investigate the effect of PS MP and NP on Cu toxicity on two freshwater microalgae, namely Chlorella sp. TJ6-5 and Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata NIES-35 after acute exposure for 4 days and up to 16 days. The results showed that both microalgae were sensitive to Cu, but tolerant to MP/NP. However, MP/NP increased the toxicity of Cu at EC50 in both microalgae, which was only noticeable in chronic exposure. Single and combined treatment of MP/NP and Cu induced higher oxidative stress and caused morphological and ultrastructural changes in both microalgae. The adsorption of Cu to MP and NP was low (0.23-14.9%), with most of the Cu present in free ionic form (81.6-105.8%). The findings on different sensitivity of microalgae to Cu in the presence of MP/NP may have significant implication as microalgae are likely to be exposed to a mixture of both MP/NP and Cu in the environment. For example, in air-blasting technology, MP and NP are used as abrasive medium to remove Cu-containing antifouling paints on hulls of ship and submerged surfaces. Wastewater treatment plants receive household wastes containing MP and NP, as well as stormwater runoffs and industrial wastes contaminated with heavy metals.

Transcriptomic analysis of Raphidocelis subcapitata exposed to erythromycin: The role of DNA replication in hormesis and growth inhibition

The occurrence of hormesis in the algal growth inhibition test is a major challenge in the dose-response characterization, whereas the molecular mechanism remains unraveled. The aim of this study is therefore to investigate the changes in the molecular pathways in a model green alga Raphidocelis subcapitata treated with erythromycin (ERY; 4, 80, 120 μg L^-1) by transcriptomic analysis. After 7 day exposure, ERY at 4 μg L^-1 caused hormetic effects (21.9 %) on cell density, whereas 52.0 % and 65.4 % were inhibited in two higher exposures. By using adj p < 0.05 and absolute log₂ fold change> 1 as a cutoff, we identified 218, 950, and 2896 differentially expressed genes in 4, 80, 120 μg L^-1 treatment groups, respectively. In two higher ERY treated groups, genes involved in phases I, II & III metabolism processes and porphyrin and chlorophyll metabolism pathway were consistently suppressed. Interestingly, genes (e.g., pri2, mcm2, and mcm6) enriched in DNA replication process were up-regulated in 4 μg L^-1 group, whereas these genes were all repressed in 120 μg L^-1 group. Alteration trend in gene expression was consistent with algal growth. Taken together, our results unveiled the molecular mechanism of action in ERY- stimulated/ inhibited growth in green alga.

Analysis and occurrence of macrolide residues in stream sediments and underlying alluvial aquifer downstream from a pharmaceutical plant

Macrolide antibiotics azithromycin (AZI), erythromycin (ERY) and clarithromycin (CLA) have been recently included in the EU Watch List of contaminants of emerging concern in the aquatic environment. However, their comprehensive assessment in different environmental compartments, by including synthesis intermediates, by-products and transformation products, is still missing. In this work, a novel method, based on pressurized liquid extraction and liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry, was developed and validated for the determination of such an extended range of macrolide residues in sediment and soil samples at low ng/g levels. The method was applied to determine distribution of 13 macrolides in surface and alluvial aquifer sediments collected in a small stream with a history of chronic exposure to wastewater discharges from AZI production. The total concentrations of the target macrolide compounds in surface sediments were up to 29 μg/g and the most prominent individual macrolides were parent AZI, its synthesis intermediate N-demethyl AZI and transformation products decladinosyl AZI and N'-demethyl AZI. Some ERY-related compounds, originating from AZI synthesis, were also frequently detected, though at lower concentration levels (up to 0.31 ng/g in total). The distribution of macrolide residues in surface sediments indicated their active longitudinal transport by resuspension and redeposition of the contaminated sediment particles. The vertical concentration profiles in stream sediments and the underlying alluvial aquifer revealed that macrolide residues reached deeper alluvial sediments (up to 5 m). Moreover, significant levels of macrolides were found in groundwater samples below the streambed, with the total concentrations reaching up to 1.7 μg/L. This study highlights the importance of comprehensive chemical characterization of the macrolide residues, which were shown to persist in surface and alluvial aquifer sediment more than ten years after their discharge into the aquatic environment.

Removal of antibiotic from the water environment by the adsorption technologies: a review

Antibiotics are known as emergent pollutants because of their toxicological properties. Due to continuous discharge and persistence in the aquatic environment, antibiotics are detected almost in every environmental matrix. Therefore antibiotics that are polluting the aquatic environment have gained significant research interest for their removal. Several techniques have been used to remove pollutants, but appropriate technology is still to be found. This review addresses the use of modified and cheap materials for antibiotic removal from the environment.

Effects of florfenicol on growth, photosynthesis and antioxidant system of the non-target organism Isochrysis galbana

Florfenicol (FFC) is one of the most universally used antibiotics in aquaculture, which is substitute for chloramphenicol extensively, while the massive residues in aquatic environment were assumed to threaten the non-target organisms. Present research investigated the effects of florfenicol on growth, chlorophyll content, photosynthesis, and antioxidant ability of Isochrysis galbana. The results showed that FFC at 0.001-1 mg/L stimulated the growth of I. galbana and increased the content of chlorophyll. In addition, photosynthesis of I. galbana was inhibited and the photosynthetic parameters were uplifted with the increased exposure duration and FFC concentration. Furthermore, superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT) activity significantly dropped at 0.01-20 mg/L FFC, while the contents of malondialdehyde (MDA), glutathione (GSH) and reactive oxygen species (ROS) increased after 72 h exposure, indicating that FFC at high concentrations caused a serious oxidative stress on algae. The simultaneous increase of ROS disrupted the equilibration between oxidants and antioxidant systems. Under the high concentration of FFC, the excessive of ROS was generated in algae which affected the membrane permeability and further decreased the cell biomass. Present study showed that acute exposure (72 h) at the environmental relevant concentration (0.01 mg/L) cannot induce the physiological dysfunction of the microalgae I. galbana, but the feeding concentration (20 mg/L) can. Additionally, this study hinted the possible negative impacts on ecosystems with the chronic exposure even at low FFC concentration or with the uncontrolled use of FFC.

Resistance of cyanobacteria Microcystis aeruginosa to erythromycin with multiple exposure

Here we report a set of experiments in which water blooming cyanobacteria Microcystis aeruginosa was repeatedly exposed to erythromycin. Growth inhibition increased with increasing erythromycin concentration (1-150 μg/L) upon first exposure. Maximum inhibition rate (76.06%), occurred under 150 μg/L erythromycin. Moreover, 96-h 50% effective concentration (EC₅₀) was 22.97 μg/L, indicating that the growth of M. aeruginosa was affected by erythromycin under common environmental concentrations. Photosynthesis was hindered by chlorophyll and photosystem II limitations. Malondialdehyde, reactive oxygen species, and superoxide dismutase contents increased significantly under certain concentrations of erythromycin, but superoxide dismutase was suppressed by 150 μg/L erythromycin. Synthesis of intracellular and extracellular microcystins was promoted by 10-60 and by 20-60 μg/L erythromycin, respectively, but both were inhibited by 100-150 μg/L. Principal component analysis and Pearson's correlation revealed the accumulation of reactive oxygen species as the dominant mechanism of erythromycin toxicity to cells. M. aeruginosa repeatedly subjected to erythromycin exposure showed obvious resistance against the antibiotic, especially when treated twice with 60 μg/L erythromycin. The 96-h EC₅₀ was 81.29 μg/L. As compared to the first exposure to erythromycin, photosynthetic and antioxidant activities increased, while growth inhibition and oxidation stress decreased upon multiple exposures. Production and release of microcystins were enhanced by repeated exposure to the antibiotic. Thus, erythromycin persistence in water should be examined, as repeated exposure may lead to serious environmental and human health hazards.

Reproductive cycle progression arrest and modification of cell morphology (shape and biovolume) in the alga Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata exposed to metolachlor

Metolachlor (MET) is an herbicide widely used and frequently found (at μg L^-1) in aquatic systems. This work aimed to study the modes of action of MET on the green microalga Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata. Algae exposed to 115 or 235 μg L^-1 MET, for 48 or 72 h, presented a reduction of metabolic activity, chlorophyll a and b content and photosynthetic efficiency. The exposure to 115 or 235 μg L^-1 MET also induced growth yield reduction, mean cell biovolume increase and alteration of the typical algae shape (cells lunate or helically twisted) to "French croissant"-type; at these MET concentrations, algal population was mainly composed by multinucleated cells (≥ 4 nuclei), which suggest that MET impairs the normal progression of the reproductive cycle but did not hinder nuclear division. The accumulation of multinucleated cells seems to be the consequence of the incapacity of the parent cell to release the autospores. In conclusion, MET disrupts the physiology of P. subcapitata cells; the disturbance of the progression of the reproductive cycle should be in the origin of growth slowdown (or even its arrest), increase of mean cell biovolume and modification of algal shape. This work contributed to elucidate, in a systematically and integrated way, the toxic mechanism of MET on the non-target organism, the alga P. subcapitata.

Comparison of oxidative stress induced by clarithromycin in two freshwater microalgae Raphidocelis subcapitata and Chlorella vulgaris

Clarithromycin (CLA), a macrolide antibiotic, has been frequently detected in the global surface waters. Concerns have been raised over the potential impacts of CLA on the non-target aquatic species, particularly algae acting as the primary producers in the ecosystem. This study therefore evaluated the toxicological effects of CLA at a range of concentration levels (0, 5, 20, 40, 80 μg L^-1) on two green algae, Raphidocelis subcapitata (R. subcapitata) and Chlorella vulgaris (C. vulgaris). The algal growth, photosynthetic pigment contents, lipid peroxidation biomarker malondialdehyde (MDA), responses of antioxidants including superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT), glutathione (GSH), glutathione peroxidase (GP), and glutathione S-transferase (GST) were measured. After 7 d exposure, the growth of R. subcapitata was inhibited with the CLA exposure levels higher than 20 μg L^-1, whereas the inhibition in C. vulgaris was detected at the concentration level of 80 μg L^-1. The MDA contents in both species were elevated. To cope with the increased levels of ROS, the activities of enzymatic antioxidants (SOD, CAT, GP, and GST) and the content of non-enzymatic antioxidant (GSH) in R. subcapitata were all enhanced. However, in C. vulgaris, enhancement was detected only in the activities of antioxidant enzymes (SOD, CAT, and GP). In addition, chlorophyll a, b, and carotenoid contents were all significantly increased in R. subcapitata but decreased in C. vulgaris. The results suggested that R. subcapitata is more sensitive to CLA exposure than C. vulgaris. This study provides insights into the CLA - oxidative stress process in two algae.