Differential response of rapid eye movement sleep to cholinergic blockade by scopolamine in currently depressed, remitted, and normal control subjects

Methods for REM Sleep Density Analysis: A Scoping Review

Rapid eye movements (REM) sleep density is the parameter proposed to explain the variability in the amount of eye movements during REM sleep. Alterations in REM sleep density have been proposed as a screening criterion for individuals with depression and other mental health conditions, but its accuracy has not been properly evaluated. The lack of consensus and the variability of the methods used to score it reduces the external validity of the results, hindering an adequate analysis of its diagnostic accuracy and clinical applicability. This scoping review aimed to identify and quantify the methods used to score REM sleep density, describing their main characteristics. A literature search was conducted in PubMed, Scopus, PsycInfo, and Web of Science. Only studies with objective measures for REM sleep density analysis in individuals with depression were considered eligible. The final sample comprised 57 articles, covering 64 analyses of REM sleep density. The relative frequency methods were the predominant measurement parameter for analyzing REM sleep density across studies. The most frequently adopted REM estimation unit was the number of REM events followed by mini-epochs containing REM. The most common unit of measurement were frequency/time measures. The results demonstrate that there is no consistency in the methods used to calculate REM sleep density in the literature, and a high percentage of studies do not describe their methods in sufficient detail. The most used method was the number of REM episodes per minute of REM sleep, but its use is neither unanimous nor consensual. The methodological inconsistencies and omissions among studies limit the replicability, comparability, and clinical applicability of REM sleep density. Future guidelines should discuss and include a specific methodology for the scoring of REM sleep density, so it can be consensually implemented in clinical services and research.

Clinical Effectiveness of Muscarinic Receptor-Targeted Interventions in Neuropsychiatric Disorders: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

For decades, treatment of mood disorders, psychoses, anxiety and dementia have been confounded by limited efficacy and high rates of treatment resistance. Preclinical and clinical evidence have highlighted disruption of cholinergic signalling in several neuropsychiatric conditions and examined intervention strategies including acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and nicotinic receptor-targeted intervention. However, the effectiveness of these approaches is often curtailed by on-target side effects. Post mortem studies implicate muscarinic receptor dysregulation in neuropsychiatric pathophysiology; therefore, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to investigate the therapeutic efficacy and safety of muscarinic receptor-targeted interventions in adults with neuropsychiatric disorders.

METHODS

PubMed, EMBASE, PsycINFO, EBSCO and Web of Science were searched using relevant keywords from database inception to 7 August 2022. Randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies were included if they investigated the effect of muscarinic receptor-targeted intervention in adults with a diagnosis of a neuropsychiatric disorder and were published in English. A narrative synthesis approach was adopted to describe the findings. Wherever three or more studies with a similar intervention were available, effect sizes were calculated, and a meta-analysis was performed. Cochrane risk-of-bias-2 tool was utilised to assess the risk of bias, and sensitivity analyses were performed to identify publication bias. Certainty analysis (high, moderate, low and/or very low) was conducted using GRADE criteria.

RESULTS

Overall, 33 studies met the inclusion criteria and 5 were included in the meta-analysis. Despite a limited pool with several different interventions, we found therapeutic efficacy of xanomeline (M₁/M₄ agonist) in primary psychotic disorders plus behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia. Scopolamine showed a significant antidepressant effect in a combined cohort of major depressive and bipolar disorders in the short-term outcome measure, but no effect following cessation of treatment. Results from bias assessments suggest "very low" certainty in the antidepressant effect of scopolamine. Critical limitations of the current literature included low power, high heterogeneity in the patient population and a lack of active comparators.

CONCLUSION

While the results are not definitive, findings on muscarinic receptor-targeted interventions in several mental disorders are promising in terms of efficacy and safety, specifically in treating schizophrenia, mood disorders, and behavioural and psychiatric symptoms of Alzheimer's disease. However, orthosteric muscarinic receptor-targeted interventions are associated with a range of peripheral adverse effects that are thought to be mediated via M₂/M₃ receptors. The orthosteric binding site of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors is remarkably conserved, posing a challenge for subtype-selective interventions; nonetheless allosteric ligands with biased signalling pathways are now in development. We conclude that adequately powered prospective studies with subtype-selective interventions are required to determine the clinical effectiveness of muscarinic-receptor targeted interventions for the treatment of neuropsychiatric disorders.

Sleep, Narcolepsy, and Sodium Oxybate

Sodium oxybate (SO) has been in use for many decades to treat narcolepsy with cataplexy. It functions as a weak GABAB agonist but also as an energy source for the brain as a result of its metabolism to succinate and as a powerful antioxidant because of its capacity to induce the formation of NADPH. Its actions at thalamic GABAB receptors can induce slow-wave activity, while its actions at GABAB receptors on monoaminergic neurons can induce or delay REM sleep. By altering the balance between monoaminergic and cholinergic neuronal activity, SO uniquely can induce and prevent cataplexy. The formation of NADPH may enhance sleep’s restorative process by accelerating the removal of the reactive oxygen species (ROS), which accumulate during wakefulness. SO improves alertness in normal subjects and in patients with narcolepsy. SO may allay severe psychological stress - an inflammatory state triggered by increased levels of ROS and characterized by cholinergic supersensitivity and monoaminergic deficiency. SO may be able to eliminate the inflammatory state and correct the cholinergic/ monoaminergic imbalance.

Cholinergic regulation of mood: from basic and clinical studies to emerging therapeutics

Mood disorders are highly prevalent and are the leading cause of disability worldwide. The neurobiological mechanisms underlying depression remain poorly understood, although theories regarding dysfunction within various neurotransmitter systems have been postulated. Over 50 years ago, clinical studies suggested that increases in central acetylcholine could lead to depressed mood. Evidence has continued to accumulate suggesting that the cholinergic system has a important role in mood regulation. In particular, the finding that the antimuscarinic agent, scopolamine, exerts fast-onset and sustained antidepressant effects in depressed humans has led to a renewal of interest in the cholinergic system as an important player in the neurochemistry of major depression and bipolar disorder. Here, we synthesize current knowledge regarding the modulation of mood by the central cholinergic system, drawing upon studies from human postmortem brain, neuroimaging, and drug challenge investigations, as well as animal model studies. First, we describe an illustrative series of early discoveries which suggest a role for acetylcholine in the pathophysiology of mood disorders. Then, we discuss more recent studies conducted in humans and/or animals which have identified roles for both acetylcholinergic muscarinic and nicotinic receptors in different mood states, and as targets for novel therapies.

Sleep at baseline and after electroconvulsive therapy in patients with major depression

Sleep in major depressive disorder is frequently altered and possibly indicative for treatment outcomes. For example, increased rapid eye movement (REM-) sleep density seems to predict worse treatment outcomes of psychotherapy. We therefore investigated pre-treatment sleep and sleep changes after termination of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). Sleep was polysomnographically recorded. The analysed sample consisted of 15 inpatients with ages ranging from 30 to 80 (mean 59 years). ECT was applied two times a week up to 7 weeks. Stable remission of depressive symptoms was defined by a score in the Hamilton Rating Scale of Depression <8 at six months after ECT. The main results were an increase in sleep efficiency and a decrease in the number of awakenings within the course of ECT in the entire patient group. Significant increases in slow wave sleep and REM sleep duration and a significant decrease in REM density were only seen in stable remitters and not in non-remitters. In pre-treatment baseline sleep a higher REM density of the first REM sleep period was significantly associated with better ECT outcome. In conclusion, REM density of the first REM sleep period seems to be an interesting candidate as putative predictor of stable treatment outcome of ECT.

Bupropion response on sleep quality in patients with depression: implications for increased cardiovascular disease risk

Depression could be an independent risk factor for cardiovascular disease. We assessed bupropion response in depressed patients by polysomnography (PSG) and cardiopulmonary coupling (CPC) variables. Nineteen subjects participated in a two-session, two consecutive night PSG protocol. Participants received either placebo or bupropion-SR 150 mg, orally, in a randomized, double-blind cross-over fashion on night two. Outcome variables were: sleep stages, REM latency, stable, unstable sleep and very low frequency coupling (VLFC). CPC analysis uses heart rate variability and the electrocardiogram's R-wave amplitude fluctuations associated with respiration to generate frequency maps. Bupropion increased REM latency (p=0.043) but did not impact PSG sleep continuity, architecture and CPC variables. A trend (p=0.092) was observed towards increasing VLFC duration. Bupropion increased the number of stable-unstable sleep transitions (p=0.036). Moderate to strong correlations between PSG and CPC variables were found on placebo and bupropion nights. Limitations include a small sample size, limited power to detect CPC changes and lack of normal controls for comparison. Increased stable-unstable sleep transitions and VLFC duration may indicate vulnerability to cardiovascular disease due to their association with low heart rate variability that has been associated with increased mortality raising the question whether the beneficial effects of the antidepressant medication outweighs the impact on cardiopulmonary dynamics.

A meta-analysis of electroencephalographic sleep in depression: evidence for genetic biomarkers

BACKGROUND

Research on whether any electroencephalographic (EEG) sleep abnormalities observed among individuals with major depressive disorder (MDD) represent genetic biomarkers remains inconclusive. We aimed to identify EEG-based biomarkers of MDD through a review of studies from three populations: individuals with MDD, individuals with MDD under remission, and never depressed high-risk probands (HRPs) of individuals with MDD.

METHODS

We searched databases such as MEDLINE and PsycINFO for EEG studies published since 1970. Of the 886 records, our selection criteria identified 56 studies that employed standardized EEG scoring procedures and addressed confounds such as participant reactivity and drug effects. We then used fixed-effects models to calculate average weighted mean differences in EEG parameters between clinical groups across these studies.

RESULTS

Individuals with MDD differed significantly from control subjects on several EEG variables. However, remitted individuals showed normalization of all affected EEG parameters except rapid eye movement (REM) density and slow-wave sleep (SWS). Surprisingly, proportion of SWS was significantly shorter during remission than depression. Never-depressed HRPs also exhibited significantly elevated REM density and reduced SWS. Finally, these parameters constituted the only two EEG variables that were not moderated by depression severity.

CONCLUSIONS

Individuals experiencing MDD and those in remission exhibit increased REM density and shortened SWS, as do HRPs with no history of MDD. Thus, this combination of EEG features may represent a genetic biomarker of MDD. Further, SWS appears to be shorter during remission than depression, suggesting its role as both a genetic marker as well as a biological scar of the disorder.

Risk markers for depression in adolescents: sleep and HPA measures

Previous work has demonstrated reliable electroencephalographic (EEG) sleep and hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) changes associated with adult major depressive disorder. These changes might be evident before clinical manifestation of the illness in at-risk persons. The aim of the study was to identify depression-related EEG sleep and HPA changes in healthy adolescents at high risk for depression, and to examine the relationship between EEG sleep (or HPA) changes and the onset of depression. Forty-eight adolescent volunteers with no personal history of a psychiatric illness, including depression, but who were at high risk for developing depression by virtue of parental depression (high-risk group), and 48 adolescent volunteers with no personal or family history of a psychiatric disorder (normal controls) were recruited. EEG sleep and HPA measures were collected on three consecutive evenings and nights at baseline. Clinical follow-up evaluations were conducted at regular intervals over a 5-year period. Compared with normal controls, adolescents at high risk for depression had shorter latency to rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, increased phasic REM sleep, more REM sleep and elevated nocturnal urinary-free cortisol (NUFC) excretion at baseline. Shorter REM latency, higher REM density and elevated NUFC (measured at baseline) were associated with the development of depression during follow-up. The findings that REM sleep abnormalities and elevated HPA activity occur before the onset of depression in at-risk adolescents suggest that these variables serve as vulnerability markers for the illness.

Electroencephalographic sleep and hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal changes from episode to recovery in depressed adolescents

OBJECTIVE

The study examined electroencephalographic (EEG) sleep and hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) changes associated with depressive episode and during recovery in adolescent depression.

METHODS

Sixteen adolescents with major depressive disorder and 16 volunteers with no personal or family history of psychiatric disorder participated in a three-night EEG sleep protocol along with nocturnal urinary free cortisol (NUFC). Depressed subjects also were restudied during stable remission from the depressive episode.

RESULTS

Compared with controls, depressed adolescents had significantly reduced sleep efficiency, shorter latency to rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, increased phasic REM sleep, and elevated NUFC excretion. Among depressed subjects, EEG sleep values did not change significantly from episode to remission. NUFC excretion reduced significantly during remission from the depressive episode.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings that EEG sleep measures are independent of clinical state, whereas HPA variables are state dependent, suggest that sleep and HPA measures make a differential contribution to our understanding of the pathophysiology and prognosis of mood disorders in adolescent patients.

Psychological stress-induced changes in sleep patterns and their generation mechanism

Recent findings have increasingly shown that sleep patterns are significantly influenced by psychological stress, such as social defeat, novelty stress, contextual fear stress, and psychological stress induced by the communication box. However, the exact association between psychological stress and sleep is still poorly understood. Therefore, in the present paper we will review related work based on our recent investigations. We have previously reported that total rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, but not non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep that is enhanced by psychological stress induced by the communication box in rats (Cui et al., 2007). In past decades strong evidence showed that neurotransmitters play a key role in the variations of the sleep patterns, such as acetylcholine, GABA and others. In addition to neurotransmitters, the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis is another important factor which influences sleep patterns. Therefore, this review will focus on the involvement of the neurotransmitters and the HPA axis in the changes of sleep patterns in response to psychological stress.

HPA axis and sleep: identifying subtypes of major depression

It is increasingly acknowledged that the diagnosis of major depression encompasses patients who do not necessarily share the same disease biology. Though the diagnostic criteria allow the specification of different subtypes, e.g. melancholic and atypical features, a consensus still has to be reached with regard to the clinical symptoms that clearly delineate these subtypes. Beside clinical characteristics, biological markers may help to further improve identification of biologically distinct endophenotypes and, ultimately, to devise more specific treatment strategies. Alterations of the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis and sleep architecture are not only commonly observed in patients with major depression, but the nature and extent of these alterations can help to identify distinct subtypes. Thus, a HPA overdrive, due to enhanced secretion of corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH) and an impaired negative feedback via glucocorticoid receptors, seems to be most consistently observed in patients with melancholic features. These patients also show the clearest sleep-electroencephalogram (EEG) alterations, including disrupted sleep, low amounts of slow wave sleep (SWS), a short rapid eye movement (REM) latency and a high REM density. In contrast, patients with atypical features are characterized by reduced activity of the HPA axis and ascending noradrenergic neurons in the locus coeruleus. Though sleep-EEG alterations have been less thoroughly examined in these patients, there are data to suggest that SWS is not reduced and that REM sleep parameters are not consistently altered. While the atypical and melancholic subtypes of major depression may represent the extremes of a spectrum, the distinct clinical features provide an opportunity to further explore biological markers, as well as environmental factors, contributing to these clinical phenotypes. Moreover, dysregulations of the HPA axis and sleep-EEG alterations can also be induced in rodents, thereby allowing alignment of critical biological aspects of a human disease subtype with an animal model. Such "Translational Research" efforts should help to develop targeted therapies for distinct patient populations.

REM sleep in depression is influenced by ethnicity

The influence of ethnicity on the manifestation of EEG sleep changes in depression was studied in 95 patients (21 African-Americans [AA], 17 Asians [AS], 37 Caucasians [C] and 20 Hispanics [H]) with unipolar major depression. Subjects were studied twice for 2 consecutive nights. On the second night of each 2-night session, placebo or scopolamine (1.5 microg/kg, IM, at 23.00 h) was administered. On the baseline (placebo) night, sleep architecture, sleep continuity and rapid eye movement (REM) sleep variables were generally comparable among the groups. However, REM sleep was less in AA and AS subjects than in C and H subjects. Furthermore, the distribution of REM sleep over the course of the night in AA and AS subjects differed significantly from that in the C and H groups. Although scopolamine significantly affected sleep continuity and REM sleep measures, no significant differential effects of scopolamine were observed. Because many antidepressants suppress REM sleep, the differences in baseline REM sleep observed might be related to the greater sensitivity of some ethnic-minority depressed patients to pharmacotherapy.

Relationship between ethnicity and sleep patterns in normal controls: implications for psychopathology and treatment

The purpose of the study was to examine ethnic influences on sleep regulation. Seventy-three normal volunteers from four ethnic groups (17 African-Americans, 10 Asians, 30 Caucasians and 16 Hispanics) were studied for two consecutive nights with sleep polysomnography recordings in the laboratory. The subjects were in good physical and psychological health, and were asymptomatic with respect to sleep/wake complaints or sleep disorders. With the exception of minor differences, sleep continuity, sleep architecture and rapid eye movement (REM) sleep patterns were comparable among the four groups. African-Americans had evidence of more stages 1 and 2 and diminished stage 4 sleep, whereas the Hispanics had higher REM density. These preliminary findings suggest that sleep patterns are remarkably similar across cultures. There are, however, important cross-ethnic differences, specifically in the depth of sleep and in phasic REM measures. Because sleep disturbances are common symptoms of emotional disorders and since many psychoactive agents affect sleep, cross-ethnic differences in sleep patterns may have potential implications for the treatment and prevention of psychiatric disorders.