Cardiovascular health of offspring conceived by assisted reproduction technology: a comprehensive review

Recently, the use of assisted reproductive technology (ART) has rapidly increased. As a result, an increasing number of people are concerned about the safety of offspring produced through ART. Moreover, emerging evidence suggests an increased risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) in offspring conceived using ART. In this review, we discuss the epigenetic mechanisms involved in altered DNA methylation, histone modification, and microRNA expression, as well as imprinting disorders. We also summarize studies on cardiovascular changes and other risk factors for cardiovascular disease, such as adverse intrauterine environments, perinatal complications, and altered metabolism following assisted reproductive technology (ART). Finally, we emphasize the epigenetic mechanisms underlying the increased risk of CVD in offspring conceived through ART, which could contribute to the early diagnosis and prevention of CVD in the ART population.

Anthropometric measurements of term singletons at 6 years of age born from fresh and frozen embryo transfer: A multicenter prospective study in Japan

Purpose

The purpose of this study is to compare anthropometric measurements between term singletons conceived via fresh embryo transfer (FreET) and frozen embryo transfer (FET) and those born via natural conception (NC) or fertility treatments milder than assisted reproductive technology (non-ART) at 6 years of age.

Methods

A total of 8149 children were enrolled, and questionnaires about anthropometric measures (weight, height, BMI) were addressed to parents, when the children were 1.5, 3, and 6 years of age. A total of 3299 term singletons were enrolled at birth: 533, 476, 916, and 1374 in the NC, non-ART, FreET, and FET groups, respectively.

Results

A total of 1635 term singletons (290, 176, 467, and 702 in the NC, non-ART, FreET, and FET groups respectively) were enrolled until 6 years of age (follow-up rate, approximately 50%). When non-ART group was used as control, the FreET children were 1.0 cm taller than the non-ART children at 6 years of age, after adjusting for confounding factors. However, no differences were observed in the anthropometric data among the non-ART, ART, and NC children at 6 years of age.

Conclusion

At 6 years of age, term singletons were taller in the FreET group than in the non-ART group, after adjusting for confounders.

Comparative study on risk of birth defects in singleton ART birth under high levels of estrogen after fresh embryo transfer and frozen embryo transfer

OBJECTIVE

To investigate whether high estrogen (E2) levels caused by controlled ovarian hyperstimulation affect the birth defect rate in singleton assisted reproductive technology (ART) birth after conceived by fresh embryo transfer and frozen embryo transfer (FET).

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study. A total of 581 women with singletons, as well as those who have become pregnant and have had an unwanted abortion under high E2 levels on trigger day were divided into three groups. Group A received FET and the E2 levels on trigger day were higher than 5000 pg/ml. Group B received fresh embryo transfer and the E2 levels were between 3000 and 5000 pg/ml. Group C received FET and the E2 levels were between 3000 and 5000 pg/ml.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in birth weight, delivery mode, preterm birth rate, and fetal sex between the three groups (p > .05). Birth defect rate in Group B was higher than that in Group A and C, and the rate between Group B and C had significant differences (p < .05). After adjusting for maternal age, BMI, and type of infertility, only a FET cycle is significantly associated with decreased birth defect rate.

CONCLUSION

Fresh embryo transfer under supraphysiological level of estrogen exposure may increase the birth defect rate of ART singletons. Even after prenatal screening and diagnosis, a part of birth defect could not be detected during pregnancy. When the estrogen levels on trigger day were no lower than 3000 pg/ml, FET should be advocated to reduce the occurrence of such risk.

Risk of Higher Blood Pressure in 3 to 6 Years Old Singleton Born From OHSS Patients Undergone With Fresh IVF/ICSI

BACKGROUND

A large registry-based study found the increasing disorders of cardiovascular and metabolism in IVF children but underlying mechanism is still unknown. Few studies have investigated any association between OHSS and cardiovascular or metabolic function in subsequent children.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effect of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS) on blood pressure of singletons after in vitro fertilization (IVF) with or without intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI).

STUDY DESIGN

The singlet-center corhort study included 1780 singletons born with IVF/ICSI and 83 spontaneously conceived children from 2003 to 2014. Follow-up has lasted more than 10 years, and is still ongoing. This study analyzed data from follow-up surveys at 3 to 6 years of age.

PARTICIPANTS SETTING AND METHODS

We recruited 83 children (Group E) spontaneously conceived (SC) as control group and 1780 children born with IVF/ICSI including 126 children born to OHSS-fresh embryo transfer (ET) women (Group A), 1069 children born to non OHSS-ET women (Group B), 98 children conceived by women who developed into moderate or severe OHSS after oocyte retrieval and selected the frozen-thawed embryo transfer (FET) (Group C), 487 children conceived with non OHSS-FET (Group D). We evaluated cardiometabolic function, assessed BP in mmHg, heart rate, anthropometrics, and metabolic index including glucose, serum lipid (triglyceride, total cholesterol, low density lipoprotein, high density lipoprotein), thyroid function, of those children. The BP and heart rate were measured twice on the same day. We applied several multiple regression analyses to investigate the effect of OHSS in the early pregnancy.

MAIN FINDINGS

By the single factor analysis, the SBP and DBP in the SC group (SBP: 99.84 ± 8.9; DBP: 55.27 ± 8.8) were significantly lower than OHSS-ET group's, while the blood pressure was similar between the SC group and other three ART groups. Children had higher BP in the OHSS-ET group (SBP: 101.93 ± 8.17; DBP: 58.75 ± 8.48) than in the non OHSS-ET (SBP: 99.49 ± 8.91; DBP: 56.55 ± 8.02) or OHSS-FET group (SBP: 99.38 ± 8.17; DBP: 55.72 ± 7.94). After using multiple regression analysis to adjust current, early life, parental and ART characteristics, the differences in the SBP and DBP (B (95% confidence interval)) between OHSS-ET and non OHSS-ET remained significant (SBP: 3.193 (0.549 to 2.301); DBP: 3.440 (0.611 to 2.333)). And the BP showed no significant difference complementarily when compared non OHSS-FET group with non OHSS-ET group. In addition, the anthropometrics, fast glucose, serum lipid, and thyroid index did not differ among the ART groups.

PRINCIPAL CONCLUSIONS

OHSS might play an independent key role on offspring's BP even cardiovascular function. Electing frozen-thawed embryo transfer for high risk of OHSS population may reduce the risk of the high BP trend.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

It is a large sample study to investigate the effect of OHSS on offspring's health. These findings provide a clinic evidence of the impact of early environment (embryo even oocyte stage) on the offspring's cardiovascular health. Our study emphasis the importance of the accuracy of IVF clinic strategy and preventing the OHSS after fresh embryo transfer.

High Dosages of Equine Chorionic Gonadotropin Exert Adverse Effects on the Developmental Competence of IVF-Derived Mouse Embryos and Cause Oxidative Stress-Induced Aneuploidy

Gonadotropins play vital roles in the regulation of female reproductive ability and fertility. Our study aimed to determine the effects of superovulation induced by increasing doses of equine chorionic gonadotropin [eCG; also referred to as pregnant mare serum gonadotropin (PMSG)] on the developmental competence of mouse embryos and on aneuploidy formation during in vitro fertilization (IVF). eCG dose-dependently enhanced the oocyte yield from each mouse. Administration of 15 IU eCG significantly reduced the fertilization rate and the formation of four-cell embryos and blastocysts and increased the risk of chromosome aneuploidy. The IVF-derived blastocysts in the 15 IU eCG treatment group had the fewest total cells, inner cell mass (ICM) cells and trophectoderm (TE) cells. Moreover, more blastocysts and fewer apoptotic cells were observed in the 0, 5, and 10 IU eCG treatment groups than in the 15 IU eCG treatment group. We also investigated reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels and variations in several variables: mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP); active mitochondria; mitochondrial superoxide production; adenosine triphosphate (ATP) content; spindle structures; chromosome karyotypes; microfilament distribution; and the expression of Aurora B [an important component of the chromosomal passenger complex (CPC)], the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) protein mitotic arrest deficient 2 like 1 (MAD2L1), and the DNA damage response (DDR) protein γH2AX. Injection of 15 IU eCG increased ROS levels, rapidly reduced MMP, increased active mitochondria numbers and mitochondrial superoxide production, reduced ATP content, increased abnormal spindle formation rates, and induced abnormalities in chromosome number and microfilament distribution, suggesting that a high dose of eCG might alter developmental competence and exert negative effects on IVF-obtained mouse embryos. Additionally, the appearance of γH2AX and the significantly increased expression of Aurora B and MAD2L1 suggested that administration of relatively high doses of eCG caused Aurora B-mediated SAC activation triggered by ROS-induced DNA damage in early mouse IVF-derived embryos for self-correction of aneuploidy formation. These findings improve our understanding of the application of gonadotropins and provide a theoretical basis for gonadotropin treatment.

Ovarian stimulated cycles reduce protection of follicular fluid against free radicals

Controlled ovarian hyperstimulation cycle with exogenous gonadotropins (COH) is associated with clinical complications. The aim of this work was to determine whether COH alters the physiological antioxidant status of follicular fluid in women with no reproductive dysfunction, compared to the natural cycle (NC). In this longitudinal study, forty-one women (oocyte donors) consecutively underwent NC and COH. Follicular fluid was collected at oocyte retrieval and different redox biomarkers were determined: total antioxidant activity (TAA), oxygen radical absorbance capacity (ORAC), nitric oxide, α- and γ-tocopherol, the fatty acid composition, activities of superoxide dismutase, catalase, total and Se-dependent glutathione peroxidases, and the antioxidant paraoxonase (PON) family. Results showed that TAA (1.70 ± 0.03 mM versus 1.86 ± 0.03 mM, p < 0.05), α-tocopherol (4.37 ± 0.26 μM versus 5.74 ± 0.30 μM, p < 0.05), PON1 paraoxonase (245 ± 24 nmol/min/ml versus 272 ± 27 nmol/min/ml, p < 0.05), PON1 arylesterase (87.2 ± 4.6 μmol/min/ml versus 99.3 ± 4.8 μmol/min/ml, p < 0.05), and PON3 simvastatinase (13.48 ± 0.52 nmol/min/ml versus 16.29 ± 0.72 nmol/min/ml, p < 0.001) were significantly lower in COH versus NC. Fatty acids from COH were more saturated, increasing palmitate and decreasing the n-6 and total polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs). Docosahexaenoic acid also increased (p < 0.05). Results suggest that COH could lead to premature ovarian aging and provide new insights into the possible prevention of the adverse effects of ovarian hyperstimulation by directing therapeutic applications to the maintenance of the redox balance and fatty acid status, with special attention to paraoxonase proteins and docosahexaenoic acid.

The effects of intrauterine insemination and single embryo transfer or modified natural cycle in vitro fertilization on offspring's health-Follow-up of a randomized clinical trial

OBJECTIVE

Does ovarian hyperstimulation and/or the in vitro procedure of assisted reproduction affect neurodevelopmental and physical health of the offspring?

STUDY DESIGN

Infertile couples were randomly allocated to intrauterine insemination with controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (IUI-COH), modified natural cycle in vitro fertilization (IVF-MNC) or single embryo transfer IVF (IVF-SET). We compared neurodevelopmental and physical health in childhood (4-7 years). We used age-appropriate questionnaires to assess behavioral problems (Child Behavior Check List (CBCL)) and executive functioning (Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function (BRIEF)). We measured body mass index Z-score, waist- and hip-circumference, body fat percentage, blood pressure Z-scores, pulse wave velocity, glucose, insulin, insulin resistance, total cholesterol, high- and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, triglycerides, and high sensitivity c-reactive protein. We compared groups by analysis of variance.

RESULTS

We examined 191 (57%) of the 333 children born in the study at a mean age of 5.5 years (range 4.0-7.6 years). We found no statistically significant differences between randomization groups in children's neurodevelopmental or physical health indices (all p-values > 0.05). Comparing the outcomes between actual method of conception, including a naturally conceived group, also did not show statistically significant differences.

CONCLUSIONS

Although this follow-up study was not powered on childhood outcomes and limited power due to attrition may have hampered detection of subtle effects, we found no indications of differences in neurodevelopmental and physical health between ovarian hyperstimulation and/or the in vitro procedure of assisted reproduction. Future trials should be powered on child outcomes, and aim to optimize follow-up rates to provide answers that are more definitive.

Transitioning from Infertility-Based (ART 1.0) to Elective (ART 2.0) Use of Assisted Reproductive Technologies and the DOHaD Hypothesis: Do We Need to Change Consenting?

The use of assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs) has increased significantly in recent years. While this is partially due to improved access for infertile patients, another contribution to the growth of ART utilization is represented by individuals without infertility, who electively chose to freeze their gametes and embryos for future use, before ever attempting conception spontaneously. Overall, the safety of ART for parents and children is well described and the risks are modest. However, while long-term health consequences for offspring as postulated by the Developmental Origin of Health and Disease (DOHaD) hypothesis are unknown, numerous animal studies suggest a predisposition for chronic diseases like hypertension and glucose intolerance. In this article, we argue that a key difference exists between infertile patients, who need to use ART as the only means to achieve pregnancy, and (likely) fertile patients who elect to use ART techniques as a family planning option. We believe that these two sets of patients are different and their risks-benefit ratios are different. We propose that while all patients should be aware of the risks, patients planning to utilize ART techniques without a diagnosis of infertility should be encouraged to think critically about the additional risks, particularly the "potential" long-term risks that may be imposed from these elective procedures.

Developmental outcome of 9-year-old children born after PGS: follow-up of a randomized trial

STUDY QUESTION

Does Day-3 cleavage-stage PGS affect neurodevelopment of 9-year-old IVF offspring?

SUMMARY ANSWER

We did not find evidence of adverse consequences of Day-3 cleavage-stage PGS on neurodevelopment of 9-year-old IVF offspring, although children born after IVF with or without PGS often had a non-optimal neurological condition.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Knowledge on long-term sequelae for development and health of children born following PGS is lacking. This is striking as evidence accumulates that IVF itself is associated with increased risk for impaired health and development in the offspring.

STUDY DESIGN SIZE, DURATION

This prospective, assessor-blinded, multicentre, follow-up study evaluated development and health of 9-year-old IVF children born to women who were randomly assigned to IVF with PGS (PGS group) or without PGS (control group). The follow-up examination at 9 years took place between March 2014 and May 2016.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

In total, 408 women were included and randomly assigned to IVF with or without Day-3 cleavage-stage PGS. This resulted in 52 ongoing pregnancies in the PGS group and 74 in the control group. In the PGS group, 59 children were born alive; in the control group, 85 children were born alive. At the age of 9 years, 43 children born after PGS and 56 control children participated in the study. Our primary outcome was the neurological optimality score, a sensitive measure of neurological condition assessed with a standardized, age-specific test (Touwen test). Secondary outcomes were adverse neurological condition (neurologically abnormal and the complex form of minor neurological dysfunction), cognitive development (intelligence quotient and specific domains), behaviour (parental and teacher's questionnaires), blood pressure and anthropometrics.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Neurodevelopmental outcome of PGS children did not differ from that of controls; the neurological optimality scores (mean values [(95% CI]: PGS children 51.5 [49.3; 53.7], control children 53.1 [50.5; 55.7]) were not significantly different. The prevalences of adverse neurological outcome (in all but one child implying the presence of the complex form of minor neurological dysfunction) did not differ between the groups (PGS group 17/43 [40%], control group 19/56 [34%]), although the prevalence of complex minor neurological dysfunction in both groups was rather high. Also intelligence quotient scores of the two groups were not significantly different (PGS group 114 [108; 120]); control group 117 [109; 125]), and the behaviour, blood pressure and anthropometrics of both groups did not differ. Mean blood pressures of both groups were above the 60th percentile.

LIMITATIONS REASONS FOR CAUTION

The power analysis of the study was not based on the number of children needed for the follow-up study, but on the number of women who were needed to detect an increase in ongoing pregnancy rates after PGS. In addition, our study evaluated embryo biopsy in the form of PGS at cleavage stage (Day-3 embryo biopsy), while currently PGS at blastocyst stage (Day-5 embryo biopsy) is recommended and increasingly being used.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

Our findings indicate that PGS in cleavage stage embryos is not associated with adverse effects on neurological, cognitive and behavioural development, blood pressure and anthropometrics of offspring at 9 years. This is a reassuring finding as embryo biopsy in the forms of PGS and PGD is increasingly applied. However, both groups of IVF offspring showed high prevalences of the clinically relevant form of minor neurological dysfunction, which is a point of concern for the IVF community. In addition, our study confirms findings of others that IVF offspring may be at risk of an unfavourable cardiovascular outcome. These findings are alarming and highlight the importance of research on the underlying mechanisms of unfavourable neurodevelopmental and cardiovascular outcomes in IVF offspring.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

The randomized controlled trial was financially supported by the Organization for Health Research and Development (ZonMw), The Netherlands (Grant number 945-03-013). The follow-up was financially supported by the University Medical Center Groningen (Grant number: 754510), the Cornelia Foundation, and the graduate schools BCN and Share, Groningen, The Netherlands. The sponsors of the study had no role in study design, data collection, data analysis, data interpretation or writing of the report. There are no conflicts of interest.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

ISRCTN76355836.

Cardiovascular health of 9-year-old IVF offspring: no association with ovarian hyperstimulation and the in vitro procedure

STUDY QUESTION

Are the in vitro procedure, ovarian hyperstimulation or a combination of these two associated with blood pressure (BP) of 9-year-old IVF children born to subfertile couples?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Our study demonstrates that ovarian hyperstimulation and the in vitro procedure are not associated with BP values in 9-year-old children born to subfertile couples.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Possible long-term effects of IVF on child health and development have been studied relatively little. This is surprising, as it is known that environmental conditions may influence embryonic and foetal development which may result in health related problems in later life. Some studies suggested that IVF is associated with higher BP at pre-school age. Yet, it is unclear whether this may be also true for older children and if so, which component of IVF, i.e. the ovarian hyperstimulation, the embryo culture or a combination of these, attributes to this potentially less favourable BP.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

The Groningen Assisted Reproductive Technology cohort-study is a prospective assessor-blinded study of children followed from before birth onwards. In total, 170 children were assessed at the age of 9 years. The attrition rate up until the 9-year-old assessment was 21%.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

We evaluated cardiovascular health, focusing on BP (in mmHg and the internationally recognized percentiles of the US National High BP Education Program), heart rate and anthropometrics of 57 children born following controlled ovarian hyperstimulation-IVF/ICSI (COH-IVF/ICSI); 47 children born after modified natural cycle-IVF/ICSI (MNC-IVF/ICSI); and 66 children who were conceived naturally by subfertile couples (Sub-NC). Cardiovascular parameters were measured multiple times on one day. In addition, anthropometric data, including BMI and skinfold thickness, were collected.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Systolic BP in mmHg did not differ between the COH-IVF/ICSI (mean 106.9, SD 6.7), MNC-IVF/ICSI (mean 104.8, SD 5.9) and Sub-NC (mean 106.3, SD 5.3) groups. In addition, systolic BP percentiles did not differ between the groups: COH-IVF/ICSI (mean 62.4, SD 20.2); MNC-IVF/ICSI (mean 56.3, SD 19.3); and Sub-NC (mean 62.3, SD17.8). Also, after adjustment for confounders BP in the three groups was similar. Heart rate and anthropometric values in the three groups did not differ. For instance, BMI values in the COH-IVF/ICSI-children were 16.3 (median value, range 13.0-24.7), in MNC-IVF/ICSI-children 16.1 (range 12.7-22.5) and in Sub-NC children 16.3 (range 12.7-24.0).

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The size of our study groups does not allow for pertinent conclusions on the effect of ovarian hyperstimulation and the in vitro procedure. The lack of a fertile control group may be regarded as another limitation.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

Our study suggests that ovarian hyperstimulation and in vitro procedures are not associated with cardiovascular health in 9-year-old. Yet, BP percentiles of the three groups were higher than the expected 50th percentile. This might indicate that children of subfertile couples have a higher BP than naturally conceived children.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

The study was financially supported by the University Medical Center Groningen (UMCG), the two graduate schools of the UMCG, BCN, SHARE and the Cornelia Stichting. The sponsors of the study had no role in study design, data collection, data analysis, data interpretation or writing of the report. The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.

Postnatal persistence of fetal cardiovascular remodelling associated with assisted reproductive technologies: a cohort study

OBJECTIVE

To assess the postnatal persistence of fetal cardiovascular remodelling associated with assisted reproductive technologies (ART) in children at 3 years of age.

DESIGN

A cohort study of children conceived by ART.

SETTING

Maternal-Fetal Medicine Unit, Hospital Clinic Barcelona, Spain.

POPULATION SAMPLE

Eighty singleton pregnancies conceived by ART and 80 spontaneously conceived (controls) followed from fetal life up to childhood.

METHODS

Cardiovascular evaluation was performed at 3 years of corrected age, including echocardiography, carotid intima-media (cIMT) by ultrasound, and blood pressure.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Postnatal persistence of cardiovascular changes in children conceived by ART.

RESULTS

Compared with controls, children conceived by ART showed larger atria (right atrial area: control 4.9 cm² (0.9) versus ART 5.5 cm² (0.9), P < 0.001), more globular ventricles (right ventricular sphericity index: control mean 1.8 (SD 0.5) versus ART 1.6 (0.2), P < 0.001), and signs of systolic (tricuspid annular plane systolic excursion: control 18 mm (2) versus ART 16 mm (3), P < 0.001) and diastolic dysfunction (isovolumic relaxation time: control 68 ms (12) versus ART 79 ms (12), P < 0.001). ART children also presented increased systolic blood pressure (control 90 mmHg (6) versus ART 94 mmHg (5), P < 0.003) and cIMT (control 0.52 μm (0.14) versus ART 0.60 μm (0.16), P < 0.001) as compared with those spontaneously conceived.

CONCLUSIONS

Cardiovascular changes previously reported in ART fetuses persist postnatally at 3 years of age. These results underscore the importance of future studies for assessing the long-term cardiovascular health associated with ART.

TWEETABLE ABSTRACT

Cardiovascular changes described in fetuses conceived by ART, persist in children at 3 years of age.

In Vitro fertilization and adverse obstetric and perinatal outcomes

Most IVF-conceived children are healthy, but IVF has also been associated with adverse obstetric and perinatal outcomes as well as congenital anomalies. There is also literature suggesting an association between IVF and neurodevelopmental disorders as well as potentially long-term metabolic outcomes. The main driver for adverse outcomes is the higher risk of multiple gestations in IVF, but as the field moves toward single embryo transfer, the rate of multiple gestations is decreasing. Studies have shown that singleton IVF pregnancies still have a higher incidence of adverse outcomes compared to unassisted singleton pregnancies. Infertility itself may be an independent risk factor. Animal models suggest that epigenetic changes in genes involved in growth and development are altered in IVF during the hormonal stimulation and embryo culture. Further animal research and prospective human data are needed to elucidate the mechanisms by which IVF may contribute to adverse outcomes and to decrease risks.

Effect of controlled ovarian hyperstimulation on puberty and estrus in mice offspring

Controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (COH) is widely used for the treatment of infertility, while the long-term effects of COH on the reproductive function in female offspring are currently unknown. Based on the fact that COH could cause high E2 levels in women throughout pregnancy and excess estrogenic exposure during fetal development is harmful to subsequent adult ovarian function, we assumed the hypothesis that COH disrupts reproductive function in female offspring. To test this hypothesis, COH was induced in mice to obtain female offspring by pregnant mare serum gonadotropin (PMSG) and HCG, and then we evaluated pubertal transition, serum levels of E2, anti-Mullerian hormone (AMH), FSH and LH, mRNA expressions of Esr1, Amhr2, Fshr and Lhcgr in ovaries, number of follicles and ovarian histology. We also investigated the apoptosis of follicles by TUNEL; the mRNA expressions of Fas, FasL, Bax, Bcl2, and caspase 3, 8 and 9 by quantitative real-time PCR; and the protein expressions of cleaved-caspase (CASP) 3, 8 and 9 by Western blot. Moreover, we further observed estrous cyclicity in young adult offspring, performed follicle counting and measured the level of AMH in both serum and ovary. COH could induce detrimental pregnancy outcomes, as well as delayed pubertal transition and irregular estrous cycle due to the aberrant growth and maturation of follicles in female offspring. Our novel findings add new evidence to better understand the potential risks of COH on the reproductive function in female offspring, raising the awareness that COH could exert adverse effects on female offspring, rather than just obtain more oocytes for fertilization.

The epigenetic effects of assisted reproductive technologies: ethical considerations

The use of assisted reproductive technologies (ART) has increased significantly, allowing many coping with infertility to conceive. However, an emerging body of evidence suggests that ART could carry epigenetic risks for those conceived through the use of these technologies. In accordance with the Developmental Origins of Health and Disease hypothesis, ART could increase the risk of developing late-onset diseases through epigenetic mechanisms, as superovulation, fertilization methods and embryo culture could impair the embryo’s epigenetic reprogramming. Such epigenetic risks raise ethical issues for all stakeholders: prospective parents and children, health professionals and society. This paper focuses on ethical issues raised by the consideration of these risks when using ART. We apply two key ethical principles of North American bioethics (respect for autonomy and non-maleficence) and suggest that an ethical tension may emerge from conflicting duties to promote the reproductive autonomy of prospective parents on one hand, and to minimize risks to prospective children on the other. We argue that this tension is inherent to the entire enterprise of ART and thus cannot be addressed by individual clinicians in individual cases. We also consider the implications of the ‘non-identity problem’ in this context. We call for additional research that would allow a more robust evidence base for policy. We also call upon professional societies to provide clinicians with guidelines and educational resources to facilitate the communication of epigenetic risks associated with ART to patients, taking into consideration the challenges of communicating risk information whose validity is still uncertain.

The Use of Proteomics in Assisted Reproduction

Despite the explosive increase in the use of Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART) over the last 30 years, their success rates remain suboptimal. Proteomics is a rapidly-evolving technology-driven science that has already been widely applied in the exploration of human reproduction and fertility, providing useful insights into its physiology and leading to the identification of numerous proteins that may be potential biomarkers and/or treatment targets of a successful ART pregnancy. Here we present a brief overview of the techniques used in proteomic analyses and attempt a comprehensive presentation of recent data from mass spectrometry-based proteomic studies in humans, regarding all components of ARTs, including the male and female gamete, the derived zygote and embryo, the endometrium and, finally, the ART offspring both pre- and postnatally.

The influence of in vitro fertilization and embryo culture on the embryo epigenetic constituents and the possible consequences in the bovine model

Medically assisted reproductive technologies, such as in vitro embryo production, are increasingly being used to palliate infertility. Eggs are produced following a hormonal regimen that stimulates the ovaries to produce a large number of oocytes. Collected oocytes are then fertilized in vitro and allowed to develop in vitro until they are either frozen or transferred to mothers. There are controversial reports on the adverse impacts of these technologies on early embryos and their potential long-term effects. Using newly developed technological platforms that enable global gene expression and global DNA methylation profiling, we evaluated gene perturbations caused by such artificial procedures. We know that cells in the early embryo produce all cells in the body and are able to respond to their in vitro environment. However, it is not known whether gene perturbations are part of a normal response to the environment or are due to distress and will have long-term impacts. While the mouse is an established genetic model used for quality control of culture media in clinics, the bovine is a large mono-ovulating mammal with similar embryonic kinetics as humans during the studied developmental window. These model systems are critical to understand the effects of assisted reproduction without the confounding impact of infertility and without the limitations imposed by the scarcity of donated human samples and ethical issues. The data presented in this review come mostly from our own experimentation, publications, and collaborations. Together they demonstrate that the in vitro environment has a significant impact on embryos at the transcriptomic level and at the DNA methylation level.

Cardiovascular and metabolic profiles of offspring conceived by assisted reproductive technologies: a systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate cardiovascular and metabolic features of offspring conceived by in vitro fertilization/intracytoplasmic sperm injection (IVF-ICSI).

DESIGN

Literature review and meta-analysis.

SETTING

Not applicable.

PATIENT(S)

Offspring from IVF-ICSI versus natural conception.

INTERVENTION(S)

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Systolic and diastolic blood pressure (SBP and DBP), cardiovascular function, body mass index (BMI), and lipid and glucose profiles.

RESULT(S)

We included 19 studies that had recruited 2,112 IVF-ICSI and 4,096 naturally conceived offspring, ranging from childhood to early adulthood. The blood pressure levels of IVF-ICSI offspring were statistically significantly higher than those of naturally conceived offspring (weighted mean differences and confidence intervals: 1.88 mm Hg [95% CI, 0.27, 3.49] for SBP and 1.51 mm Hg [95% CI, 0.33, 2.70] for DBP). In addition, cardiac diastolic function was suboptimal and vessel thickness was higher among IVF-ICSI offspring. Compared with the metabolism of naturally conceived offspring, IVF-ICSI offspring displayed comparable BMI, lower low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels, and higher fasting insulin levels.

CONCLUSION(S)

Children conceived by IVF-ICSI manifested a minor yet statistically significant increase in blood pressure without the clustering of increased BMI or impaired lipid metabolism by early adulthood. Our findings indicate a risk of cardiovascular disease among IVF-ICSI offspring, which calls for longer-term follow-ups and further investigation.

Health and functioning of adolescents conceived by assisted reproductive technology

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the general health, mental health, and cognitive ability of assisted reproductive technology (ART)-conceived adolescents.

DESIGN

A nested case-control study within a historic cohort.

SETTING

Not applicable.

PATIENT(S)

A total of 253 ART-conceived adolescents born between 1982 and 1993 and 253 matched references according to birth year, gender, and the high-school they attended.

INTERVENTION(S)

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Medical and psychiatric diagnoses, and cognitive ability recorded at the military preinduction screening (ages 16-17 years) and doctor's appointments throughout the military service.

RESULT(S)

No differences were detected in general and mental health of ART adolescents or cognitive ability, compared with the reference group. Similar results were obtained after stratification for gender and singleton births. The ART adolescents had fewer cases of discharge from military service due to health reasons (4% vs. 8.3%). Follow-up during the military service revealed that male ART adolescents had significantly more doctor's appointments compared with the reference group (23.80 ± 15.59 vs. 19.95 ± 13.79).

CONCLUSION(S)

Our preliminary results provide reassurance that in the long-run health and functioning of ART-conceived adolescents is not compromised. Further studies with larger cohorts are needed to confirm these results.

Can assisted reproductive technologies cause adult-onset disease? Evidence from human and mouse

Millions of children have been born worldwide though assisted reproductive technologies (ART). Consistent with the Developmental Origins of Health and Disease hypothesis, there is concern that ART can induce adverse effects, especially because procedures coincide with epigenetic reprogramming events. Although the majority of studies investigating the effects of ART have focused on perinatal outcomes, more recent studies demonstrate that ART-conceived children may be at increased risk for postnatal effects. Here, we present the current epidemiological evidence that ART-conceived children have detectable differences in blood pressure, body composition, and glucose homeostasis. Similar effects are observed in the ART mouse model, which have no underlying infertility, suggesting that cardiometabolic effects are likely caused by ART procedures and not due to reasons related to infertility. We propose that the mouse system can, consequently, be used to adequately study, modify, and improve outcomes for ART children.

Extending prematuration with cAMP modulators enhances the cumulus contribution to oocyte antioxidant defence and oocyte quality via gap junctions

STUDY QUESTION

Can bovine oocyte antioxidant defence and oocyte quality be improved by extending the duration of pre-in vitro maturation (IVM) with cyclic adenosine mono-phosphate (cAMP) modulators?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Lengthening the duration of cAMP-modulated pre-IVM elevates intra-oocyte reduced glutathione (GSH) content and reduces hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) via increased cumulus cell-oocyte gap-junctional communication (GJC), associated with an improvement in subsequent embryo development and quality.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Oocytes are susceptible to oxidative stress and the oocyte's most important antioxidant glutathione is supplied, at least in part, by cumulus cells. A temporary inhibition of spontaneous meiotic resumption in oocytes can be achieved by preventing a fall in cAMP, and cyclic AMP-modulated pre-IVM maintains cumulus-oocyte GJC and improves subsequent embryo development.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

This study consisted of a series of 10 experiments using bovine oocytes in vitro, each with multiple replicates. A range of pre-IVM durations were examined as the key study treatments which were compared with a control. The study was designed to examine if one of the oocyte's major antioxidant defences can be enhanced by pre-IVM with cAMP modulators, and to examine the contribution of cumulus-oocyte GJC on these processes.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Immature bovine cumulus-oocyte complexes were treated in vitro without (control) or with the cAMP modulators; 100 µM forskolin (FSK) and 500 µM 3-isobutyl-1-methyxanthine (IBMX), for 0, 2, 4 or 6 h (pre-IVM phase) prior to IVM. Oocyte developmental competence was assessed by embryo development and quality post-IVM/IVF. Cumulus-oocyte GJC, intra-oocyte GSH and H2O2 were quantified at various time points during pre-IVM and IVM, in the presence and the absence of functional inhibitors: carbenoxolone (CBX) to block GJC and buthionine sulfoximide (BSO) to inhibit glutathione synthesis.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Pre-IVM with FSK + IBMX increased subsequent blastocyst formation rate and quality compared with standard IVM (P < 0.05), regardless of pre-IVM duration. The final blastocyst yields (proportion of blastocysts/immature oocyte) were 26.3% for the control, compared with 39.2, 35.2 and 34.2%, for the 2, 4 and 6 h pre-IVM FSK + IBMX treatments, respectively. In contrast to standard IVM (control), pre-IVM with cAMP modulators maintained open gap junctions between cumulus cells and oocytes for the duration (6 h) of pre-IVM examined, and persisted for a further 8 h in the IVM phase. Cyclic AMP-modulated pre-IVM increased intra-oocyte GSH levels at the completion of both pre-IVM and IVM, in a pre-IVM duration-dependent manner (P < 0.05), which was ablated when GJC was blocked using CBX (P < 0.05). By 4 h of pre-IVM treatment with cAMP modulators, oocyte H2O2 levels were reduced compared the control (P < 0.05), although this beneficial effect was lost when oocytes were co-treated with BSO. Inhibiting glutathione synthesis with BSO during pre-IVM ablated any positive benefits of cAMP-mediated pre-IVM on oocyte developmental competence (P < 0.01).

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

It is unclear if the improvement in oocyte antioxidant defence and developmental competence reported here is due to direct transfer of total and/or reduced glutathione from cumulus cells to the oocyte via gap junctions, or whether a GSH synthesis signal and/or amino acid substrates are supplied to the oocyte via gap junctions. Embryo transfer experiments are required to determine if the cAMP-mediated improvement in blastocyst rates leads to improved live birth rates.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

IVM offers significant benefits to infertile and cancer patients and has the potential to significantly alter ART practice, if IVM efficiency in embryo production could be improved closer to that of conventional IVF (using ovarian hyperstimulation). Pre-IVM with cAMP modulators is a simple and reliable means to improve IVM outcomes.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTERESTS

This work was supported by grants and fellowships from the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia (1007551, 627007, 1008137, 1023210) and by scholarships from the Chinese Scholarship Council (CSC) awarded to H.J.L. and the Japanese Society for the Promotion of Science Postdoctoral Fellowship for Research Abroad awarded to S.S. The Fluoview FV10i confocal microscope was purchased as part of the Sensing Technologies for Advanced Reproductive Research (STARR) facility, funded by the South Australian Premier's Science and Research Fund. We acknowledge partial support from the Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Nanoscale BioPhotonics (CE140100003). We declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research reported.

The first 50 live births after autologous oocyte vitrification in France

PURPOSE

The study aims to describe the newborn health parameters of the 50 first children conceived after autologous oocyte vitrification in France.

METHODS

The 50 children born after autologous oocyte vitrification/warming cycle (VAO children) have been retrospectively compared with 364 children conceived by micromanipulation using freshly recovered non-vitrified oocytes (ICSI children). Children included in the study were born between 2011 and 2015. Maternal characteristics (age, body mass index, smoking habits), obstetric outcomes (diabetes, hypertension, placenta previa, parity, mode of delivery), and perinatal outcome (twinning, sex, birth weight, macrosomia, birth defects) were analyzed. The generalized estimating equation for correlated data was performed to evaluate perinatal outcomes and caesarean section.

RESULTS

No statistically significant difference was found between VAO children and ICSI children, even after adjusting confounding factors (low birth weigh odds ratio (OR) 0.8, 95 % confident interval (CI) 0.3-2.2, adjusted (AOR) 0.5, 95 % CI 0.2-1.7; large for gestational age OR 1.5, 95 % CI 0.3-7.0, AOR 1.6, 95 % CI 0.3-7.5; birth defects OR 0.4, 95 % CI 0.1-3.2, AOR 0.5, 95 % CI 0.1-3.7; caesarean section OR 1.8, 95 % CI 0.9-3.4, AOR 1.8, 95 % CI 0.9-3.7).

CONCLUSIONS

According to our results, newborn health parameters of children conceived in our center by micromanipulation using vitrified/warmed autologous oocytes seem not to be different from children born after micromanipulation on freshly recovered oocytes.

High Maternal Serum Estradiol Levels Induce Dyslipidemia in Human Newborns via a Hepatic HMGCR Estrogen Response Element

While the intrauterine environment is essential for the health of offspring, the impact of high maternal serum estradiol (E₂) on lipid metabolism in offspring and the mechanisms are unknown. We found that ovarian stimulation (OS) could result in high E₂ levels in women throughout pregnancy. Strikingly, their newborns showed elevated total cholesterol (TC) and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) levels that were positively related with E₂ in newborns. In vitro, E₂ dose-dependently stimulated TC and LDL-C secretion, and increased expression of the cholesterol synthesis rate-limiting enzyme 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl-CoA reductase (HMGCR) in HepG2 cells and mouse fetal hepatocytes. In vivo, high maternal E₂ was detected and fetal livers also showed significantly higher HMGCR expression in an OS mouse model. Notably, an estrogen response element (ERE) was identified in the HMGCR promoter, indicating that high maternal serum E₂ could up-regulate HMGCR expression in fetal hepatocytes via an ERE that in turn induces elevated levels of TC and LDL-C in offspring. Conclusion: OS can induce a high maternal E₂ environment, which up-regulates HMGCR expression in fetal hepatocytes via an ERE in the promoter, and induces elevated levels of TC and LDL-C in newborns that may be related to increased risk of metabolic disease in adulthood.

Preliminary proteomic analysis on the alterations in follicular fluid proteins from women undergoing natural cycles or controlled ovarian hyperstimulation

PURPOSE

To study the differences in protein expression profiles of follicular fluid (FF) between controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (COH) and natural ovulatory cycles.

METHODS

Twelve infertile women undergoing in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer (IVF-ET), with matched clinical information, were retrospectively recruited in the IVF center of our university hospital, including six undergoing COH and another six with natural cycles. FF was sampled from dominant follicles with mature oocytes. Protein expression profiles in each FF sample were analyzed respectively using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Differentially expressed proteins were identified using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) and validated by western blotting. Differentially expressed proteins were further analyzed using Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA) software.

RESULTS

Two proteins were downregulated and 11 proteins were upregulated (change ≥1.5-fold, P < 0.05) in the COH group. We identified one down-egulated and seven upregulated proteins using MALDI-TOF MS. Four differentially expressed proteins, including transferrin, complement component C3 (C3), haptoglobin and alpha-1-antitrypsin (AAT), were further validated by rate nephelometry and western blotting analyses. The IPA analysis revealed a significant network involved in the humoral immune and inflammatory responses.

CONCLUSIONS

The eight differentially expressed proteins were related to immune and inflammatory responses in the ovary. Our results provide new insights into the influence of COH on follicular (spp) development and IVF outcomes.

Subfertility and assisted reproduction techniques are associated with poorer cardiometabolic profiles in childhood

The effects of artificial reproductive techniques and subfertility on cardiovascular and metabolic profiles of children aged 5-6 years were investigated using data from the Amsterdam Born Children and their Development study. Of the 2577 children, 34 were conceived through ovulation induction, 51 through artificial insemination and 28 through IVF or intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). Two hundred and twenty children were born to couples who conceived after more than 12 months and 2244 were born to couples who conceived within 12 months of unprotected intercourse ('subfertile' and 'fertile', respectively). At the age of 5-6 years, fasting glucose levels were higher among children conceived through ovulation induction and IVF-ICSI compared with those of children of fertile couples (adjusted difference: ovulation induction: 0.4 mmol/l, 95% CI 0.2 to 0.6; IVF-ICSI: 0.2 mmol/l, 95% CI 0.0 to 0.5). Blood pressure was higher in children of subfertile couples compared with that of children of fertile couples (adjusted difference systolic blood pressure: 0.8 mmHg, 95% CI -0.2 to 1.8; diastolic blood pressure: 1.4 mmHg, 95% CI 0.6 to 2.3). Subfertility and conception through ovulation induction and IVF-ICSI each contributed to aspects of an adverse cardiovascular and metabolic profile in childhood.

The phenotype of an IVF child is associated with peri-conception measures of follicular characteristics and embryo quality

STUDY QUESTION

Are childhood measures of phenotype associated with peri-conception parental, IVF treatment and/or embryonic characteristics of IVF children?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Birthweight, childhood body mass index (BMI) and height of pre-pubertal IVF children were strongly associated with peri-conception factors, including follicular and embryonic characteristics.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

A growing number of studies have identified a range of phenotypic differences between IVF and naturally conceived pre-pubertal children; for example, birthweights are lower following a fresh compared with a thawed embryo transfer.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

This retrospective cohort study included IVF children (n = 96) born at term (>37 weeks) after a singleton pregnancy from the transfer of either fresh or thawed embryos in New Zealand. Between March 2004 and November 2008, these children were subjected to clinical assessment before puberty.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Clinical assessment provided anthropometric measures of children aged 3.5-11 years old. Peri-conception factors (n = 36) derived retrospectively from parental, treatment, laboratory and embryonic variables (n = 69) were analysed using multiple stepwise regression with respect to standard deviation scores (SDSs) of the birthweight, mid-parental corrected BMI and height of the IVF children. Data from children conceived from fresh (n = 60) or thawed (n = 36) embryos, that met inclusion criteria and had high-quality data with >90% completeness, were analysed.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Embryo treatment at transfer was identified as a predictor of birthweight with thawed embryos resulting in heavier birthweights than fresh embryos [P = 0.02, 95% confidence interval (CI) fresh minus thawed: -1.047 to -0.006]. Birthweight SDS was positively associated with mid-parental corrected BMI SDS (P = 0.003, slope 0.339 ± 0.100). Four factors were related (P < 0.05) to mid-parental corrected height SDS. In particular, child height was inversely associated with the diameter of lead follicles at oocyte retrieval (P < 0.0001, slope -0.144 ± 0.040) and with the quality score of embryos at transfer (P = 0.0008, slope -0.425 ± 0.157), and directly associated with the number of follicles retrieved (P = 0.05, slope 1.011 ± 0.497). Child height was also positively associated with the transfer of a fresh as opposed to thawed embryo (P < 0.001, 95% CI 0.275-0.750).

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

More than one embryo was transferred in most cycles so mean development and quality data were used. The large number of variables measured was on a relatively small sample size. Large cohorts from multiple clinics using a variety of treatment protocols and embryology methods are needed to confirm the associations identified and ultimately to test these factors as possible predictors of phenotype.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This is the first study to directly associate peri-conception measures of IVF treatment with a pre-pubertal child's phenotype. Demonstration that peri-conception measures relate to a pre-pubertal child's phenotype extends the range of factors that may influence growth and development. These findings, if corroborated by larger studies, would provide invaluable information for practitioners, who may want to consider the impact of ovarian stimulation protocols as well as the quality of the embryo transferred on a child's growth and development, in addition to their impact on pregnancy rate.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTERESTS

This work was supported by grants from the National Research Centre of Growth and Development New Zealand (grant 3682065) and the Australasian Paediatric Endocrine Group (APEG; grant 3621994), as well as a fellowship from Fertility Associates New Zealand awarded to M.P.G. In terms of competing interest, J.C.P is a shareholder of Fertility Associates. M.P.G. currently holds the position of Merck Serono Lecturer in Reproductive Biology. W.S.C. and P.L.H. have also received grants and non-financial support from Novo Nordisk, as well as personal fees from Pfizer that are unrelated to the current study. The other authors have no conflict of interest to declare.