Selection for B cells with productive IgL gene rearrangements occurs in the bursa of Fabricius during chicken embryonic development

Life cycle of chicken bursal secretory dendritic cell (BSDC)

The transmission electron microscopy revealed a dendritic cell in the medulla of the chicken bursal follicle. This dendritic cell has a classical secretory machinery; therefore, it has been named a bursal secretory dendritic cell (BSDC). The corticomedullary epithelial arch (CMEA) encloses lymphoid-like cells, which can proliferate and after entering the medulla, begin to differentiate to immature, then mature BSDC, which discharges glycoprotein (gp). With the exhaustion of gp production, the BSDC rapidly transforms into a macrophage-like cell (Mal), which is an activated endocytic cell of innate immunity. The Mal drifts through the follicle-associated epithelium (FAE)-supporting cells into the FAE, and via FAE, the Mal is eliminated in the bursal lumen. The infectious bursal disease virus (IBDV) infection accelerates the maturation process of BSDC precursors, which results in acute emptying of CMEA and subsequently, numerous immature BSDC(s) emerge. The IBDV infection stops the gp discharge, and the gp appears in the virus-containing Mal. The Movat pentachrome staining recognizes the gp in the extracellular spaces of the medulla and after infection in the Mal. The BSDC is the primary target of the IBDV. During IBDV infection, a large number of suddenly formed Mal actively migrate into the cortex, initiating cytokine storm and recruiting heterophil granulocytes. During embryogenesis, the vimentin-positive, possibly embryonic dendritic cells provide a microenvironment for carbohydrate switch. Around hatching, these embryonic, temporary dendritic cells get the Fc receptor, which bind maternal IgY. The posthatched forms of BSDC(s) gradually replace the embryonic ones and bind their own IgY.

Full-Length Transcriptome: A Reliable Alternative for Single-Cell RNA-Seq Analysis in the Spleen of Teleost Without Reference Genome

Fish is considered as a supreme model for clarifying the evolution and regulatory mechanism of vertebrate immunity. However, the knowledge of distinct immune cell populations in fish is still limited, and further development of techniques advancing the identification of fish immune cell populations and their functions are required. Single cell RNA-seq (scRNA-seq) has provided a new approach for effective in-depth identification and characterization of cell subpopulations. Current approaches for scRNA-seq data analysis usually rely on comparison with a reference genome and hence are not suited for samples without any reference genome, which is currently very common in fish research. Here, we present an alternative, i.e. scRNA-seq data analysis with a full-length transcriptome as a reference, and evaluate this approach on samples from Epinephelus coioides-a teleost without any published genome. We show that it reconstructs well most of the present transcripts in the scRNA-seq data achieving a sensitivity equivalent to approaches relying on genome alignments of related species. Based on cell heterogeneity and known markers, we characterized four cell types: T cells, B cells, monocytes/macrophages (Mo/MΦ) and NCC (non-specific cytotoxic cells). Further analysis indicated the presence of two subsets of Mo/MΦ including M1 and M2 type, as well as four subsets in B cells, i.e. mature B cells, immature B cells, pre B cells and early-pre B cells. Our research will provide new clues for understanding biological characteristics, development and function of immune cell populations of teleost. Furthermore, our approach provides a reliable alternative for scRNA-seq data analysis in teleost for which no reference genome is currently available.

Anti-S1 MERS-COV IgY Specific Antibodies Decreases Lung Inflammation and Viral Antigen Positive Cells in the Human Transgenic Mouse Model

The Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) was identified in 2012 and causes severe and often fatal acute respiratory illness in humans. No approved prophylactic and therapeutic interventions are currently available. In this study, we have developed egg yolk antibodies (immunoglobulin Y (IgY)) specific for MERS-CoV spike protein (S1) in order to evaluate their neutralizing efficiency against MERS-CoV infection. S1-specific immunoglobulins were produced by injecting chickens with purified recombinant S1 protein of MERS-CoV at a high titer (5.7 mg/mL egg yolk) at week 7 post immunization. Western blotting and immune-dot blot assays demonstrated that the IgY antibody specifically bound to the MERS-CoV S1 protein. Anti-S1 antibodies were also able to recognize MERS-COV inside cells, as demonstrated by an immunofluorescence assay. Plaque reduction and microneutralization assays showed the neutralization of MERS-COV in Vero cells by anti-S1 IgY antibodies and non-significantly reduced virus titers in the lungs of MERS-CoV-infected mice during early infection, with a nonsignificant decrease in weight loss. However, a statistically significant (p = 0.0196) quantitative reduction in viral antigen expression and marked reduction in inflammation were observed in lung tissue. Collectively, our data suggest that the anti-MERS-CoV S1 IgY could serve as a potential candidate for the passive treatment of MERS-CoV infection.

Anti-S1 MERS-COV IgY Specific Antibodies Decreases Lung Inflammation and Viral Antigen Positive Cells in the Human Transgenic Mouse Model

The Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) was identified in 2012 and causes severe and often fatal acute respiratory illness in humans. No approved prophylactic and therapeutic interventions are currently available. In this study, we have developed egg yolk antibodies (immunoglobulin Y (IgY)) specific for MERS-CoV spike protein (S1) in order to evaluate their neutralizing efficiency against MERS-CoV infection. S1-specific immunoglobulins were produced by injecting chickens with purified recombinant S1 protein of MERS-CoV at a high titer (5.7 mg/mL egg yolk) at week 7 post immunization. Western blotting and immune-dot blot assays demonstrated that the IgY antibody specifically bound to the MERS-CoV S1 protein. Anti-S1 antibodies were also able to recognize MERS-COV inside cells, as demonstrated by an immunofluorescence assay. Plaque reduction and microneutralization assays showed the neutralization of MERS-COV in Vero cells by anti-S1 IgY antibodies and non-significantly reduced virus titers in the lungs of MERS-CoV-infected mice during early infection, with a nonsignificant decrease in weight loss. However, a statistically significant (p = 0.0196) quantitative reduction in viral antigen expression and marked reduction in inflammation were observed in lung tissue. Collectively, our data suggest that the anti-MERS-CoV S1 IgY could serve as a potential candidate for the passive treatment of MERS-CoV infection.

In and Out of the Bursa-The Role of CXCR4 in Chicken B Cell Development

In contrast to mammals, early B cell differentiation and diversification of the antibody repertoire in chickens do not take place in the bone marrow but in a specialized gut associated lymphoid tissue (GALT), the bursa of Fabricius. During embryonic development, B cell precursors migrate to the bursa anlage, where they proliferate and diversify their B cell receptor repertoire. Around hatch these diversified B cells start to emigrate from the bursa of Fabricius and populate peripheral lymphoid organs, but very little is known how the migratory processes are regulated. As CXCL12 (syn. SDF-1) and CXCR4 were shown to be essential for the control of B cell migration during the development of lymphoid tissues in mammals, we analyzed expression and function of this chemokine/chemokine-receptor pair in the chicken bursa. We found a strong variation of mRNA abundance of CXCL12 and CXCR4 in different stages of bursa development, with high abundance of CXCL12 mRNA in the bursa anlage at embryonic day 10 (ED10). In situ hybridization demonstrated disseminated CXCL12 expression in the early bursa anlage, which condensed in the developing follicles and was mainly restricted to the follicle cortex post-hatch. Flow cytometric analysis detected CXCR4 protein already on early B cell stages, increasing during bursal development. Post-hatch, a subpopulation with the hallmarks of emigrating B cells became detectable, which had lower CXCR4 expression, suggesting that downregulation of CXCR4 is necessary to leave the CXCL12-high bursal environment. In vivo blockade of CXCR4 using AMD3100 at the time of B cell precursor immigration strongly inhibited follicle development, demonstrating that CXCL12 attracts pre-bursal B cells into the bursal anlage. Altogether, we show that CXCL12 and its receptor CXCR4 are important for both populating the bursa with B cells and emigration of mature B cells into the periphery post hatch, and that CXCR4 function in primary B cell organs is conserved between mammals and birds.

Identification, tissue characterization, and innate immune role of Angiogenin-4 expression in young broiler chickens

Intestinal epithelial cells are major producers of antimicrobial proteins, which play an important role in innate immunity. In addition to defensins, the Ribonuclease A superfamily includes important antimicrobial proteins involved in host-defense mechanisms in vertebrates. Angiogenin-4 (Ang4), a member of this RNase superfamily, has been demonstrated to be secreted by Paneth cells in mice. We have successfully cloned and characterized a new chicken gene (chAng4), found for the first time in a nonmammalian species, from intestinal epithelial and lymphoid cells. Characterization of chAng4 revealed 99% nucleotide and 97% amino acid sequence homology to mouse Ang4. Similar functional regions were identified, suggesting a role in innate immunity and regulation of gut microbiota. Furthermore, the mRNA expression pattern of chAng4 was studied in broilers in the presence or absence of beneficial bacteria (probiotics) and organic acids. The results showed that one-day-old chickens expressed low levels of Ang4 in almost all the evaluated tissues (crop, proventriculus, duodenum, jejunum, ileum, and cecal tonsils), except in the bursa of Fabricius that presented the highest expression level. The addition of probiotics and organic acids for either 7 or 14 consecutive days demonstrated a direct effect of probiotics and organic acids on chAng4 expression; moreover, broilers receiving probiotics and organic acids for only 7 D showed higher levels of chAng4 expression compared with those treated for 14 D. Broilers without treatment had a constant high level of expression in cecal tonsils and bursa. In conclusion, we were able to identify and characterize a new antimicrobial gene in chickens (chAng4) throughout the gastrointestinal tract. chAng4 mRNA gene expression was associated with the presence of naturally occurring and supplemented (probiotic) bacteria. The encoded protein might have a potential bactericidal effect against intestinal nonpathogenic and pathogenic microbes, modulating the intestinal microbiota and the innate immunity, and thereby may help minimize the use of antibiotics in poultry feed.

Zika Virus-Specific IgY Results Are Therapeutic Following a Lethal Zika Virus Challenge without Inducing Antibody-Dependent Enhancement

The Zika virus (ZIKV) is a newly emerged pathogen in the Western hemisphere. It was declared a global health emergency by the World Health Organization in 2016. There have been 223,477 confirmed cases, including 3720 congenital syndrome cases since 2015. ZIKV infection symptoms range from asymptomatic to Gullain⁻Barré syndrome and extensive neuropathology in infected fetuses. Passive and active vaccines have been unsuccessful in the protection from or the treatment of flaviviral infections due to antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE). ADE causes an increased viral load due to an increased monocyte opsonization by non-neutralizing, low-avidity antibodies from a previous dengue virus (DENV) infection or from a previous exposure to ZIKV. We have previously demonstrated that polyclonal avian IgY generated against whole-killed DENV-2 ameliorates DENV infection in mice while not inducing ADE. This is likely due to the inability of the Fc portion of IgY to bind to mammalian Fc receptors. We have shown here that ZIKV oligoclonal IgY is able to neutralize the virus in vitro and in IFNAR-/- mice. The concentration of ZIKV-specific IgY yielding 50% neutralization (NT50) was 25 µg/mL. The exposure of the ZIKV, prior to culture with ZIKV-specific IgY or 4G2 flavivirus-enveloped IgG, demonstrated that the ZIKV-specific IgY does not induce ADE. ZIKV IgY was protective in vivo when administered following a lethal ZIKV challenge in 3-week-old IFNAR-/- mice. We propose polyclonal ZIKV-specific IgY may provide a viable passive immunotherapy for a ZIKV infection without inducing ADE.

SH3 dependent cell death signaling of the avian chB6 alloantigen

In chickens, B cells develop in the bursa of Fabricius, a unique organ for B cell development. Most B cells will die within the bursa, mirroring cell losses seen in mammalian bone marrow as central tolerance is enforced at the transition to mature cells. B cell responses are shaped by a complex interplay of signals. Signals in addition to BCR that impact central tolerance have recently been described. We have been interested in chB6, a novel alloantigen on B cells in the chicken. chB6 is found in close proximity to the BCR and can trigger apoptosis after cross-linking by antibody. chB6 has two Ig domains, placing it within the CD2/SLAM family of molecules, but its cytoplasmic domain is unique. We have used a site-specific mutagenesis approach to show that an SH3 binding site in chB6 is required for the induction of apoptosis, suggesting parallels to CD2 signaling.

Diversification of the Primary Antibody Repertoire by AID-Mediated Gene Conversion

Gene conversion, mediated by activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), has been found to contribute to generation of the primary antibody repertoire in several vertebrate species. Generation of the primary antibody repertoire by gene conversion of immunoglobulin (Ig) genes occurs primarily in gut-associated lymphoid tissues (GALT) and is best described in chicken and rabbit. Here, we discuss current knowledge of the mechanism of gene conversion as well as the contribution of the microbiota in promoting gene conversion of Ig genes. Finally, we propose that the antibody diversification strategy used in GALT species, such as chicken and rabbit, is conserved in a subset of human and mouse B cells.

Ligation of surface Ig by gut-derived antigen positively selects chicken bursal and peripheral B cells

In many mammals and birds, B cell lymphopoiesis takes place in GALT, such as the avian bursa of Fabricius. Although BCR expression is sufficient for bursal colonization, the role of BCR ligation in the later stages of bursal B cell lymphopoiesis remains elusive. To address this directly, we introduced a surface Ig-related construct with defined Ag specificity containing the Ag-binding portion of a lamprey variable lymphocyte receptor specific for PE fused to a truncated chicken μ-chain (VLR(PE)Tμ) into developing chick embryos. VLR(PE)Tμ expression supports bursal follicle colonization, clonal expansion, and Ig V gene diversification. VLR(PE)Tμ-expressing B cells migrate to the periphery in the absence of the Ag starting from day 18 of embryogenesis. VLR(PE)Tμ-expressing B cells declined rapidly in the bursa and periphery in the absence of Ag after hatch; however, intrabursal injection of PE prolonged survival of VLR(PE)Tμ(+) bursal and peripheral B cells. Intrabursal introduction of Ag increased emigration of short-lived LT2(+) B cells. Peripheral VLR(PE)Tμ(+) B cells were maintained following intrabursal PE application and contained both short-lived LT2(+) and long-lived LT2(-) B cells. In the chicken bursa, the later stages of B cell development occur in the presence of gut-derived Ag; therefore, we conclude that Ag-mediated ligation of BCR in bursal B cells acts to positively select bursal B cells into both short-lived and long-lived peripheral B cell populations.

Negative selection of self-reactive chicken B cells requires B cell receptor signaling and is independent of the bursal microenvironment

Although the negative selection of self-reactive B cells in the bone marrow of mammals has been clearly demonstrated, it remains unclear in models of gut-associated B cell lymphopoiesis, such as that of the chicken (Gallus gallus). We have generated chicken surface IgM-related receptors in which the diversity region of the lamprey variable lymphocyte receptor (VLR) has been fused to the C region of chicken surface IgM (Tμ). Expression of a VLR:Tμ receptor with specificity for PE supported normal development of B cells, whereas a VLR:Tμ receptor specific to hen egg lysozyme (a self-antigen with respect to chicken B cells) induced, in vivo, complete deletion of VLR(HEL)Tμ-expressing B cells. In ovo i.v. injection of PE resulted in deletion of VLR(PE)Tμ-expressing Β cells in the embryo spleen, demonstrating that negative selection was independent of the bursal microenvironment. Although chickens transduced with a murine CD8α:chicken Igα fusion protein contained B cells expressing mCD8α:chIgα, cotransfection of the mCD8α:chIgα construct, together with thymus leukemia Ag (a natural ligand for mCD8α), resulted in reduced levels of mCD8α:chIgα-expressing B cells in inverse proportion to the levels of thymus leukemia Ag-expressing cells. Deletion of mCD8α:chIgα-expressing cells was specific for B cells and required active signaling downstream of the mCD8α:chIgα receptor. Ag-mediated negative selection of developing chicken B cells can therefore occur independently of the bursal microenvironment and is dependent on signaling downstream of the BCR.

Growth hormone expression in stromal and non-stromal cells in the bursa of Fabricius during bursal development and involution: Causal relationships?

Growth hormone (GH) is expressed in the chicken bursa of Fabricius (BF), an organ that undergoes three distinct developmental stages: rapid growth (late embryogenesis until 6-8 weeks of age [w]), plateaued growth (between 10 and 15w), and involution (after 18-20w). The distribution and abundance of GH-immunoreactivity (GH-IR) and GH mRNA expression in stromal and non-stromal bursal cells during development, as well as the potential anti-apoptotic effect of GH in bursal cell survival were the focus of this study. GH mRNA expression was mainly in the epithelial layer and in epithelial buds at embryonic day (ED) 15; at 2w it was widely distributed within the follicle and in the interfollicular epithelium (IFE); at 10w it clearly diminished in the epithelium; whereas at 20w it occurred in only a few cortical cells and in the connective tissue. Parallel changes in the relative proportion of GH mRNA expression (12, 21, 13, 1%) and GH-IR (19, 18, 11, <3%) were observed at ED 15, 2w, 10w, and 20w, respectively. During embryogenesis, GH-IR co-localized considerably with IgM-IR, but scarcely with IgG-IR, whereas the opposite was observed after hatching. Significant differences in bursal cell death occurred during development, with 9.3% of cells being apoptotic at ED 15, 0.4% at 2w, 0.23% at 10w, and 21.1% at 20w. Addition of GH increased cultured cell survival by a mechanism that involved suppression (up to 41%) of caspase-3 activity. Results suggest that autocrine/paracrine actions of bursal GH are involved in the differentiation and proliferation of B lymphocytes and in BF growth and cell survival in embryonic and neonatal chicks, whereas diminished GH expression in adults may result in bursal involution.

B-cell development: one problem, multiple solutions

Interspecies variations in the processes of B-cell development and repertoire generation contrast with the greater consistency of T-cell development. B-cell development in mice and humans, with postnatal B-cell generation of new repertoire in the bone marrow throughout life, is regarded as the 'standard' pattern. In contrast, accounts of B cells in birds, sheep, cattle, rabbits and pigs (the 'other' species) describe cessation of gene diversification in the perinatal period, with the gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT) functioning as the primary lymphoid organ thereafter. It has become customary to regard the developmental pathways of T and B cells within any individual species as being as dissimilar as the functions of the two mature cell types. Reinterpretation of B-cell development patterns in different species is overdue in response to two types of reports. The first of these describe T-B 'crossover', specifically the intrathymic production of B cells and the extrathymic production of T cells. The second attests to the extent of sharing of B-cell developmental features across the two groups of species. We propose that, as is a feature of other haematopoietic cells, a menu of alternative B- and T-cell pathways has been retained and shared across species. A single pathway usually predominates in any species, masking alternatives. The observed predominance of any pathway is determined by factors such as placental permeability, extent of maturation of the immune system by birth and the feasibility of direct experimental intervention in development.

IgY: a promising antibody for use in immunodiagnostic and in immunotherapy

Immunoglobulin IgY is the major antibody produced by chickens (Gallus domesticus). After their V-C gene is rearranged in B cells, IgY is continually synthesized, excreted into the blood and transferred to the egg yolk, where it is accumulated. IgY is produced by hens to provide their offspring with an effective humoral immunity against the commonest avian pathogens until full maturation of their own immune system. In this review we aim to give an overview about the generation, structure, properties of IgY, as well as the advantages of chicken antibodies use over mammalian antibodies in immunodiagnostics and immunotherapy.

The BAFF-Interacting receptors of chickens

The TNF superfamily cytokine BAFF has crucial roles in homoeostatic regulation of B cell populations in mammals. Similar effects on peripheral B cells have been reported for chicken as for mammalian BAFF. Unlike mammalian BAFF, chicken BAFF is produced by B cells, implying an autocrine loop and consequent differences in regulation of B cell homoeostasis. Understanding of these mechanisms requires investigation of BAFF-binding receptors in chickens. We identified and characterised chicken receptors BAFFR and TACI, but found that the gene encoding the third BAFF-binding receptor, BCMA, was disrupted, implying differences in mechanisms for maintenance of long-lived antibody responses. A BAFFR-Ig fusion protein expressed in vivo lowered B cell numbers, showing that it was functional under physiological conditions. We found changes in the ratio of BAFFR and TACI mRNAs in the bursa after hatch that may account for the altered requirements for B cell survival at this stage of development.

Expression patterns of the prolactin receptor gene in chicken lymphoid tissues during embryogenesis and posthatch period

Prolactin (PRL) is a pituitary hormone with multiple homeostatic roles among vertebrates. Although it has mainly been studied in relation to its role during the initiation and maintenance of incubation behavior in avian species, it has also been shown to act on the immune system. In this study, levels of PRL receptor (PRLR) mRNA were quantified by real-time PCR, and tissue expression was localized by in situ hybridization in primary and secondary lymphoid organs. Prolactin receptor was shown to be expressed in the bursa follicles, thymus lobules, and splenic pulp at all stages of development examined. Levels of PRLR expression were consistently higher in the bursa of Fabricius when compared with other lymphoid organs, suggesting that PRL acts primarily on bursal development. Furthermore, levels of PRLR mRNA appeared to fluctuate during embryogenesis, with a significant increase observed at embryonic day 19 in the bursa, at 7 d of age in the thymus, and on hatching day in the spleen. Thus, PRL might play an important role during the development of the immune system in chickens.

Ligand-independent signaling during early avian B cell development

Surface immunoglobulin (sIg) expression has been conserved as a critical checkpoint in B lymphocyte development. In the chicken embryo, only sIg+ B cells are selectively expanded in the bursa of Fabricius, a primary lymphoid organ unique to the avian species. We have previously demonstrated that an interaction between the antigen- binding sites of sIg and a specific bursal ligand(s) is not required to regulate this developmental checkpoint. Rather, the requirement for sIg expression can be attributed to the surface expression of the Igalpha/beta heterodimer associated with sIg. More specifically, ligand-independent signaling downstream of the Igalpha cytoplasmic domain drives all bursal stages of B cell development during embryogenesis. We discuss here a site-directed mutagenesis approach to identify the critical membrane proximal events involved in ligand-independent signaling during B cell development.

Antibodies, immunoglobulin genes and the bursa of Fabricius in chicken B cell development

The bursa of Fabricius is critical for the normal development of B lymphocytes in birds. It is productively colonized during embryonic life by a limited number of B cell precursors that have undergone the immunoglobulin gene rearrangements required for expression of cell surface immunoglobulin. Immunoglobulin gene rearrangement occurs in the absence of terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase and generates minimal antibody diversity. In addition, observations that immunoglobulin heavy and light chain variable gene rearrangement occur at the same time and that allelic exclusion of immunoglobulin expression is regulated at the level of variable region gene rearrangement provide a striking contrast to rodent and primate models of immunoglobulin gene assembly. Following productive colonization of the bursa, developing B cells undergo rapid proliferation and the immunoglobulin V region genes that generate the specificity of the B cell surface immunoglobulin receptor undergo diversification. Immunoglobulin diversity in birds is generated by somatic gene conversion events in which sequences derived from upstream families of pseudogenes replace homologous sequences in unique and functionally rearranged immunoglobulin heavy and light chain variable region genes. This mechanism is distinct from and much more efficient than mechanisms of antibody diversification seen in rodents and primates. While the bursal microenvironment is not required for immunoglobulin gene rearrangement and expression, it is essential for the generation of antibody diversity by gene conversion. Following hatch, gut derived antigens are taken up by the bursa. While bursal development prior to hatch occurs in the absence of exogenous antigen, chicken B cell development after hatch may therefore be influenced by the presence of environmental antigen. This review focuses on the differences between B cell development in the chicken as compared to rodent and primate models.

Cell surface immunoglobulin regulated checkpoints in chicken B cell development

The bursa of Fabricius is critical for the normal development of B lymphocytes in avian species. Productive colonization of bursal follicles by B cell precursors requires surface immunoglobulin expression. We have shown using retroviral gene transfer that expression of chimeric receptors containing the extracellular and transmembrane domains of murine CD8alpha and CD8beta fused to the cytoplasmic domains of chicken Igalpha and Igbeta can support productive bursal colonization in the chicken embryo in bursal cells lacking the expression of endogenous sIgM. We show here that chimeric receptor expression does not support continued bursal cell development after hatch. However intrabursal administration of anti-CD8 antibodies that ligate the CD8alpha:Igalpha chimeric receptor results in maintained numbers of bursal cells that express the chimeric receptor in the absence of endogenous sIgM. These results support a model in which sIgM receptor expression is required for productive bursal colonization in the chick embryo but sIgM receptor ligation is required to support later B cell development after hatch.

Dual Requirement for the Igα Immunoreceptor Tyrosine-Based Activation Motif (ITAM) and a Conserved Non-Igα ITAM Tyrosine in Supporting Igαβ-Mediated B Cell Development

Surface Ig (sIg) expression is a critical checkpoint during avian B cell development. Only cells that express sIg colonize bursal follicles, clonally expand, and undergo Ig diversification by gene conversion. Expression of a heterodimer, in which the extracellular and transmembrane domains of murine CD8alpha or CD8beta are fused to the cytoplasmic domains of chicken Igalpha (chIgalpha) or Igbeta, respectively (murine CD8alpha (mCD8alpha):chIgalpha + mCD8beta:chIgbeta), or an mCD8alpha:chIgalpha homodimer supported bursal B cell development as efficiently as endogenous sIg. In this study we demonstrate that B cell development, in the absence of chIgbeta, requires both the Igalpha ITAM and a conserved non-ITAM Igalpha tyrosine (Y3) that has been associated with binding to B cell linker protein (BLNK). When associated with the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta, the Igalpha ITAM is not required for the induction of strong calcium mobilization or BLNK phosphorylation, but is still necessary to support B cell development. In contrast, mutation of the Igalpha Y3 severely compromised calcium mobilization when expressed as either a homodimer or a heterodimer with the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta. However, coexpression of the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta partially complemented the Igalpha Y3 mutation, rescuing higher levels of BLNK phosphorylation and, more strikingly, supporting B cell development.

Biases in Ig lambda light chain rearrangements in human intestinal plasma cells

Human intestinal lamina propria plasma cells are considered to be the progeny of chronically stimulated germinal centers located in organized gut-associated lymphoid tissues such as Peyer's patches and isolated lymphoid follicles. We have sampled human colonic lamina propria plasma cells and naive and memory B cell subsets from human Peyer's patches by microdissection of immunohistochemically stained tissue sections and used PCR methods and sequence analysis to compare IgVlambdaJlambda rearrangements in the plasma cell and B cell populations. Rearrangements that were either in-frame or out-of-frame between V and J were compared. Usage of IgVlambda families in the in-frame rearrangements from the plasma cells resembled that observed in the mantle cells, suggesting that antigenic selection for cellular specificity does not dramatically favor any particular Vlambda segment. However, in marked contrast, out-of-frame rearrangements involving Vlambda1 and Vlambda2 families are rarely observed in intestinal plasma cells, whereas rearrangements involving Vlambda5 are increased. This resulted in significantly biased ratios of in-frame:out-of-frame rearrangements in these Vlambda families. Out-of-frame rearrangements of IgVlambdaJlambda from plasma cells, including those involving the Vlambda5 family, have a significant tendency not to involve Jlambda1, consistent with the hypothesis that this population includes rearrangements generated by secondary recombination events. We propose that modification of out-of-frame rearrangements of IgVlambdaJlambda exists, probably a consequence of secondary rearrangements. This may be a mechanism to avoid translocations to susceptible out-of-frame IgVlambdaJlambda rearrangements during somatic hypermutation.

The avian chB6 alloantigen induces apoptosis in DT40 B cells

In avian species, B-lymphocytes develop in the bursa of Fabricius. Cells developing in the bursa are subject to signals regulating their survival, with the majority of cells dying by apoptosis within the bursa. However, the molecules delivering the signals influencing this life and death decision remain enigmatic. We have previously shown that antibodies against the chB6 alloantigen present on avian B-lymphocytes can induce a rapid form of cell death. Here we extend this finding by showing that anti-chB6 antibodies induce true apoptosis in DT40 cells without visible membrane damage. This apoptosis results in DNA degradation and morphologic changes characteristic of apoptosis. Furthermore, this apoptosis is coincident with a loss of mitochondrial membrane potential and is inhibited by either overexpression of bcl-x(L) or the presence of inhibitors of caspase 8, 9, or 3 activity. Collectively these data argue that chB6 may function as a novel death receptor on avian B-lymphocytes and support the use of DT40 as an amenable model to study the signaling involved in chB6-induced apoptosis.

The Cytoplasmic Domain of Igα Is Necessary and Sufficient to Support Efficient Early B Cell Development

The B cell receptor complex (BcR) is essential for normal B lymphocyte function, and surface BcR expression is a crucial checkpoint in B cell development. However, functional requirements for chains of the BcR during development remain controversial. We have used retroviral gene transfer to introduce components of the BcR into chicken B cell precursors during embryonic development. A chimeric heterodimer, in which the cytoplasmic domains of chicken Igalpha and Igbeta are expressed by fusion with the extracellular and transmembrane domains of murine CD8alpha and CD8beta, respectively, targeted the cytoplasmic domains of the BcR to the cell surface in the absence of extracellular BcR domains. Expression of this chimeric heterodimer supported all early stages of embryo B cell development: bursal colonization, clonal expansion, and induction of repertoire diversification by gene conversion. Expression of the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha, in the absence of the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta, was not only necessary, but sufficient to support B cell development as efficiently as the endogenous BcR. In contrast, expression of the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta in the absence of the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha failed to support B cell development. The ability of the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha to support early B cell development required a functional Igalpha immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif. These results support a model in which expression of surface IgM following productive V(D)J recombination in developing B cell precursors serves to chaperone the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha to the B cell surface, thereby initiating subsequent stages of development.

The avian B-cell receptor complex: distinct roles of Igalpha and Igbeta in B-cell development

The bursa of Fabricius has evolved in birds as a gut-associated site of B-cell lymphopoiesis that is segregated from the development of other hematopoietic lineages. Despite differences in the developmental progression of chicken as compared to murine B-cell lymphopoiesis, cell-surface immunoglobulin (sIg) expression has been conserved in birds as an essential checkpoint in B-cell development. B-cell precursors that express an sIg complex that includes the evolutionarily conserved Igalpha/beta heterodimer colonize lymphoid follicles in the bursa, whereas B-cell precursors that fail to express sIg due to non-productive V(D)J recombination are eliminated. Productive retroviral gene transfer has allowed us to introduce chimeric receptor constructs into developing B-cell precursors in vivo. Chimeric proteins comprising the extracellular and transmembrane regions of murine CD8alpha fused to the cytoplasmic domain of chicken Igalpha efficiently supported B-cell development in precursors that lacked endogenous sIg expression. By contrast, expression of an equivalent chimeric receptor containing the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta actively inhibited B-cell development. Consequently, the cytoplasmic domains of Igalpha and Igbeta play functionally distinct roles in chicken B-cell development.

Cell surface immunoglobulin receptors in B cell development

Expression of surface immunoglobulin (sIg) related receptors has been conserved in phylogenetically distinct species as a critical checkpoint in B cell development. The sIg receptor comprises extracellular IgM heavy and light chains, with the potential for ligand binding, complexed to the Igalpha/Igbeta heterodimer that is responsible for signal transduction through sIg. Experimental systems, from both avian and murine models of B cell development, have been designed to identify the function of individual receptor components in B cell development. In this review, we assess the regulatory functions of different components of the sIg receptor complex during early development in experimental systems from evolutionarily distinct species.

B cell development in gut associated lymphoid tissues

B lymphocyte development can occur in a variety of anatomical sites. While typically considered to be a process that occurs in the bone marrow throughout life, it is becoming clear that gut associates sites of B cell development are critically important in many species of veterinary importance. Among these sites, the bursa of Fabricius in chickens and the ileal Peyer's patches of sheep are among the best studied. In these organs, it has become clear that many of the properties associated with B cell development in rodent and primate bone marrow do not apply. Thus while bone marrow B cell development typically involves an ongoing maturation of mature B cells from immature B lineage precursors that lack the expression of a surface immunoglobulin complex, gut associated lymphoid tissues (GALTs) may be colonized by a single wave of precursor cells during embryo development. Nonetheless, molecular analysis of the requirements for B lymphocyte development in GALTs reveals some striking parallels with requirements identified for B cell development in bone marrow. This article will discuss differences between B cell development in the bone marrow and GALTs and recent evidence emerging that yields insights into how these processes are regulated.

The avian ChB6 alloantigen triggers apoptosis in a mammalian cell line

Many developing B lymphocytes are deleted by apoptosis. However, the mechanism signaling their demise remains poorly understood. Like mammals, chicken B cells are selected during their development; >95% of the cells in the bursa of Fabricius die without entering the secondary immune system. The molecule chB6 (Bu-1) has been used as a marker to identify B cells in the chicken. ChB6 is a type I transmembrane glycoprotein whose function is enigmatic. We have provided evidence that chB6 can induce a rapid form of cell death exhibiting characteristics of apoptosis. Here we further examine cell death induced by chB6 in a transfected mouse cell line. ChB6 is shown to cause apoptosis in this cell line as detected by a TUNEL assay for DNA fragmentation. This apoptosis is subject to regulation by signals from growth factor or by Bcl-x(L). Furthermore, we show that Ab binding to chB6 leads to cleavage of caspase 8, caspase 3, and poly(ADP ribose) polymerase. Overall, these data support the hypothesis that chB6 is a novel death receptor on avian B cells.

Effect of environmental antigens on the Ig diversification and the selection of productive V-J joints in the bursa

In chickens, a single set of unique functional segments of both Ig H and L chain genes is rearranged during early embryogenesis to generate a pool of B cell progenitors that will be diversified in the bursa by gene conversion, forming the preimmune repertoire. After hatching, bursal cells are exposed to environmental Ags in the bursal lumen. We prepared B cells from each single bursal follicle and used PCR-directed Ig L chain gene analysis to study the differentiation of B cells and the effect of antigenic stimulation from the bursal lumen on the neonatal chicken B cell repertoire formation. Selective amplification of B cell clones with a productive V-J joint was observed during the late embryonic stage, possibly by the interaction with ligands expressed on the bursal stroma and further accelerated in the neonatal chicken. Administration of the artificial Ags into the bursal lumen before the isolation of bursa by bursal duct ligation in the embryo caused a significant increase in lymphocytes with a productive V-J joint in the neonatal chicken bursa compared with the isolated bursa. Intra- and interclonal diversity of a complementarity-determining region measured by an evolutionary distance increased during bursal development. Clonal diversification did not require stimulation by artificial Ags from the bursal lumen. Thus, the preimmune repertoire in the bursa is generated by gene conversion during Ag-independent B cell proliferation, and antigenic stimulation from the bursal epithelium to bursal B cells plays roles in the selection of clones with a productive V-J joint.

Influence of antibody diversification on the mechanism of haplotype exclusion of immunoglobulin gene expression

Allelic, or haplotype, exclusion of immunoglobulin gene expression ensures that the products of a single allele or light chain isotype are expressed on the B cell surface. Evidence has accumulated in rodent and primate models to indicate that the products of successful rearrangement regulate this process. In contrast, haplotype exclusion of chicken immunoglobulin gene expression is regulated at the level of variable region gene rearrangement. We discuss here alternative models for ensuring haplotype exclusion that may operate in the chicken and extend the discussion to address the issue as to how two apparently distinct mechanisms may have evolved to yield the same outcome.

Functional restoration of the bursa of Fabricius following in ovo infectious bursal disease vaccination

The primary role of the avian bursa of Fabricius is to provide an essential microenvironment for B-lymphocytes to diversify their immunoglobulin genes by gene hyperconversion. Infectious bursal disease (IBD) vaccination using intermediate plus vaccine strains can temporarily deplete the bursal follicles and interrupt the normal B-cell development, which is generally followed by B-cell repopulation and histological regeneration. To find evidence that functional restoration of the bursa of Fabricius occurs in addition to the histological regeneration, we have analysed the chB1 gene expression, which indicates active bursal B-lymphocytes, and also the surface expression of a carbohydrate structure Lewis(x), a marker which identifies those bursal B-lymphocytes that are undergoing gene hyperconversion. In ovo vaccination with an immune complex vaccine (IBDV-BDA) caused transient bursal destruction in both the SPF and the maternally protected broiler groups with differences evident in the starting time, the severity and the duration of the effect. After the depletion phase, signs of histological regeneration appeared together with chB1- and Lewis(x) expression indicating that B-lymphocytes were functionally active and the bursa of Fabricius was serving again as an efficient primary lymphoid organ providing an appropriate microenvironment for B-cell development.

Perinatal deletion of B cells expressing surface Ig molecules that lack V(D)J-encoded determinants in the bursa of Fabricius is not due to intrafollicular competition

During embryonic development, the avian bursa of Fabricius selects B cell precursors that have undergone productive V(D)J recombination for expansion in oligoclonal follicles. During this expansion, Ig diversity is generated by gene conversion. We have used retroviral gene transfer in vivo to introduce surface Ig molecules that lack V(D)J-encoded determinants into B cell precursors. This truncated mu heavy chain supports both B cell expansion within embryo bursal lymphoid follicles and gene conversion. We show that individual follicles can be colonized exclusively by cells expressing the truncated mu chain and lacking endogenous surface IgM, ruling out a requirement for V(D)J-encoded determinants in the establishment of bursal lymphoid follicles. In striking contrast to their normal development in the embryo, bursal cells expressing the truncated mu-chain exhibit reduced rates of cell division and increased levels of apoptosis after hatching. The level of apoptosis in individual follicles reflects the proportion of cells within the follicle that express the truncated mu-chain. In particular, high levels of apoptosis are associated with follicles containing exclusively cells expressing the truncated micro receptor. Thus, apoptotic elimination of such cells is not due to competition within the follicle by cells expressing endogenous surface IgM receptors. This provides the first direct demonstration that the regulation of B cell development in the avian bursa after hatching differs fundamentally from that seen in the embryo. The requirement for intact IgM expression when the bursa is exposed to exogenous Ag implicates a role for Ag in avian B cell development after hatching.

Development of B cells expressing surface immunoglobulin molecules that lack V(D)J-encoded determinants in the avian embryo bursa of fabricius

Immunoglobulin gene rearrangement in avian B cell precursors generates surface Ig receptors of limited diversity. It has been proposed that specificities encoded by these receptors play a critical role in B lineage development by recognizing endogenous ligands within the bursa of Fabricius. To address this issue directly we have introduced a truncated surface IgM, lacking variable region domains, into developing B precursors by retroviral gene transfer in vivo. Cells expressing this truncated receptor lack endogenous surface IgM, and the low level of endogenous Ig rearrangements that have occurred within this population of cells has not been selected for having a productive reading frame. Such cells proliferate rapidly within bursal epithelial buds of normal morphology. In addition, despite reduced levels of endogenous light chain rearrangement, those light chain rearrangements that have occurred have undergone variable region diversification by gene conversion. Therefore, although surface expression of an Ig receptor is required for bursal colonization and the induction of gene conversion, the specificity encoded by the prediversified receptor is irrelevant and, consequently, there is no obligate ligand for V(D)J-encoded determinants of prediversified avian cell surface IgM receptor.

Tissue expression patterns of chicken octamer-binding proteins

The octamer motif is important in transcriptional regulation of genes of the immune system in many species, including the chicken. Little is known, however, regarding octamer-binding protein expression in chicken tissues. We examined octamer-binding protein expression patterns in multiple chicken tissues (ovary, cerebrum, liver, lung, kidney, spleen, thymus, and bursa of Fabricius) plus two lymphocyte cell lines. Every tissue and cell line had multiple octamer-binding proteins. Seven distinct protein-DNA complexes were identified. Our results demonstrate that multiple octamer-binding proteins, exhibiting differential tissue expression, exist in a wide variety of tissues of the chicken.

Co-existence of somatic hypermutation and gene conversion in hypervariable regions of single Igkappa clones

In the rabbit, recent investigations have provided evidence that gene conversion leads to the generation of diversity of heavy chain rearranged VH-DH-JH genes. No data have been published on a similar mechanism for rabbit light chains. In our laboratory, we initially infected rabbits with Trypanosoma brucei, which stimulates B-cell hyperplasia and hypergammaglobulinaemia. The heterozygous rabbits exhibited the Ckappa1 b4 and b9 kappa light chain allotypes. After reverse transcription of mRNA, and cloning and sequencing of cDNA, the Vkappa-Jkappa-Ckappa genes provided evidence for both somatic hypermutation and gene conversion. We saw that in each of the b4 and b9 kappa light chain cDNA, CDR1 and CDR3 carried both point mutation and provisional gene conversion traits. In the CDR2 region, point mutation and gene conversion inserts were observed in the b4 genes, with only gene conversion in two b9 genes. In the CDR regions, although some genes exhibited only somatic hypermutation or gene conversion, others showed linkage of both somatic hypermutation and gene conversion in the same sequence. This also marks the first time that somatic hypermutation and gene conversion in the same cloned CDR region has been observed in Vkappa1 genes; however, it has been seen earlier in rabbit heavy chain VH sequences. Furthermore, the addition of several codons to the CDR3 segment by gene conversion may have provided a mechanism for length variation. In addition, we demonstrated that Jkappa and framework region segments contained examples of somatic hypermutation. Confirmation of gene conversion necessitates that donor sequences be identified as providing the templated inserts. Thus after cloning two pseudogenes we found putative CDR3 donor segments for two CDR3 rearranged genes. The results offer additional mechanisms for the generation of diversity among rearranged rabbit kappa light chain genes. Whether there is a relationship or influence of gene conversion upon somatic hypermutation or vice versa is not discernable at present.

Immunoglobulin gene diversification in cattle

Research in several species has revealed that different types of mammals have evolved divergent molecular and cellular strategies for generating immunoglobulin diversity. Other chapters in this text have highlighted the specific characteristics unique to chicken, rabbit, mouse, human and sheep B lymphocyte development; namely indicating differences in the mechanisms of diversity and the site of primary B cell development. Studies of the bovine system have indicated that like the sheep system, the ileal Peyer's patch (IPP) is a likely chicken bursal equivalent, and is a site of primary B lymphocyte development. Substantial investigation in sheep has indicated that Ig diversity is created by untemplated somatic mutation and intense selective pressure (Reynaud et al., 1991). The frequency of alteration in the sheep Ig light chain gene locus also is characteristic of the bovine system, however, recent evidence from sequencing of bovine lambda light chain genes indicates that one mechanism that contributes to diversity is gene conversion, utilizing several pseudogenes located in the Ig locus (Parng et al., 1996). The mechanism by which this hyperalteration of Ig genes occurs in both sheep and cattle is poorly understood and is thus the focus of considerable investigation. The study of events in the IPP may also have informative ramifications for secondary diversification of the Ig repertoire by somatic hyperalteration in germinal centers.

Avian B cell development

Development of B cells in chickens proceeds via a series of discrete developmental stages that includes the maturation of committed B cell progenitors in the specialized microenvironment of the bursa of Fabricius. The bursa has been shown to be required for the amplification of the B cell pool and selects for cells with productive immunoglobulin rearrangement events. Other events regulating chicken B cell development such as lymphocyte trafficking and apoptosis are just beginning to be elucidated. Within the bursa, the variable regions of immunoglobulin genes of B cell progenitors are diversified by a process of intrachromosomal gene conversion, where blocks of sequence information are transferred from pseudo-V regions to the recombined variable regions of the immunoglobulin genes. Recently gene conversion has been determined to play a role in the diversification of the immune repertoire in other species. In this review we focus on the current understanding and recent advances of B cell development in the chicken.

Distribution of bursal secretory dendritic cells in the chicken

BACKGROUND

The bursa of Fabricius provided the microenvironment for B-cell differentiation. Continuous contact between lymphoid cells and antigen in the bursa further suggested that antigenic material has an important influence on the maintenance and development of B cells in the bursa. In addition, a dendritic cell, the bursal secretory dendritic cell (BSDC), has been identified in the medulla. The hypothesis that, in the bursal follicles, the contact between the lymphoid cells and the antigen may be mediated by dendritic cells prompted us to identify a bursal dendritic cell that becomes activated after contact with the antigen.

METHODS

A polyclonal antiserum to S-100 protein was used to identify bursal dendritic cells because S-100 protein, a calcium-binding protein, has been shown to be a marker for the identification of chicken dendritic cells following recent contact with antigen.

RESULTS

At every age investigated, S-100-positive cells showed a location and shape identical to those described for BSDCs. Positive cells were found within and under the follicle-associated epithelial cells (FAE), indicating that these cells were strategically placed where they would encounter the antigen. In addition, positive cells were found arranged along the corticomedullary junction, which is a regenerative zone for the BSDC. After 10 weeks of age, the number of positive cells dramatically decreased, suggesting that the endocytic activity of the FAE may become impaired as the bursa regresses.

CONCLUSIONS

The polyclonal antiserum to S-100 protein identified the BSDCs in the bursal follicles. Positive cells may be BSDCs that have undergone a functional activation after contact with the antigen. These cells may have a role as antigen-presenting cells in the bursal follicles. Hence, these cells may be involved in the events that lead to B-cell differentiation.

Current concepts in chicken B cell development

The chicken has provided fundamental insights into the workings of vertebrate immunity. In particular, the development of B cells in a unique organ, the bursa of Fabricius, has provided a novel opportunity to study B cell development. Although chickens generate their Ig repertoire in a different way than mice and humans, there are many striking similarities in the developmental process. In particular, the control of lymphocyte migration and survival is key to the development of an immune system. The evolutionary distance of chickens and mammals underscore how common the problems are as well as how the solutions are often similar. Such commonalities serve to maintain the chicken as a compelling animal in which to study B cell development.

Development of the mouse B-cell repertoire

The mouse B-cell repertoire early in ontogeny contains B cells with receptor immunoglobulins exhibiting high connectivity, multi/self-reactivity, and generally low affinity. This is due structurally to extensive restriction in the germline components used to generate the B-cell receptor. The selective pressure acting on the nascent repetoire has both negative and positive components as seen in our in vivo models. VH81X-bearing B cells from the VH81X transgenic mice (and probably from normal mice) are subject to self-selective pressure with two components: a positive one favoring a certain (self-reactive) specificity in the CD23-IgM+ population and a negative one preventing the entry of B cells with this specificity into the CD23+IgM+ compartment.

Fetal VDJ gene repertoire in rabbit: evidence for preferential rearrangement of VH1

B cells in rabbit preferentially utilize the 3'-most VH gene, VH1, in VDJ genes. To determine whether the preferential utilization of VH1 results from preferential rearrangement, we examined VH gene usage in nonproductive VDJ gene rearrangements, genes that would not be influenced by antigen selection. Since nonproductive VDJ gene rearrangements are found infrequently in neonatal and adult rabbits, we examined the VDJ gene rearrangements during early fetal development. According to nested-primer polymerase chain reaction analyses, VDJ genes in fetal liver appeared around day 14 of gestation and nucleotide sequence analyses of VDJ genes cloned from 14- to 28-day-old fetuses showed that many of the genes were nonproductive. We found that most of these nonproductive genes had utilized VH1 indicating to us that the preferential utilization of VH1 is due to preferential rearrangement. We compared the nucleotide sequence of the promoter region of VH1 with sequences of several other unutilized and infrequently utilized VH genes and found that the core transcriptional factor motifs were similar in all VH promoters examined. We suggest that transcriptional activity of the VH1 promoter region does not explain the preferential rearrangement of VH1.

Chicken B cells undergo discrete developmental changes in surface carbohydrate structure that appear to play a role in directing lymphocyte migration during embryogenesis

The migration of progenitor cells to specific microenvironments is essential for the development of complex organisms. Avian species possess a unique primary lymphoid organ, the bursa of Fabricius, that plays a central role in the development of B cells. B cell progenitors, however, arise outside the bursa of Fabricius and, during embryonic development, must migrate through the vasculature to the bursa of Fabricius. In this report, we demonstrate that these progenitor B cells express the sialyl Lewis × carbohydrate structure previously shown to be a ligand for the selectin family of vascular adhesion receptors. Soon after migration to the bursa of Fabricius, B cell progenitors are induced to undergo a developmental switch and terminate the expression of sialyl Lewis × in a temporal pattern that correlates with the developmental decline in the ability of these cells to home to the bursa of Fabricius upon transplantation. The induction of the developmental switch in the glycosylation pattern of developing B cells requires the bursal environment. In addition, sialyl Lewis × carbohydrate determinants or structurally similar determinants on the surface of immortalized bursal lymphoid stem cells participate in the adherence of these cells to the vascular regions of the bursal microenvironment. These data demonstrate that the carbohydrate structure sialyl Lewis × is developmentally regulated during chicken B cell development and may facilitate the migration of B cell progenitors to the bursal microenvironment by serving as a ligand for a lectin-like adhesion receptor.

Loss of surface immunoglobulin expression precedes B cell death by apoptosis in the bursa of Fabricius

The vast majority of lymphocytes generated daily in the chicken bursa of Fabricius do not emigrate to the periphery but die in situ. Apoptotic cells in the bursa can be readily detected by the presence of fragmented DNA and by the large numbers of condensed cellular nuclei observed by electron microscopy. Consequently, most newly generated lymphocytes die by programmed cell death. We show that bursal cells divide rapidly and apoptotic cells are derived from rapidly dividing precursors. Analysis of the phenotype of bursal cells undergoing apoptosis demonstrated that cell death does not occur in the most mature bursal cell population and is therefore not random. High levels of surface Ig are expressed on bursal cells entering S phase of the cell cycle. In contrast, bursal cells in the early stages of apoptosis in vivo express very low to undetectable levels of surface Ig but were unequivocally confirmed as being of the B lineage by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) detection of rearranged Ig genes. Bursal cells induced to undergo apoptosis in vitro express high levels of surface Ig demonstrating that induction of apoptosis does not in itself induce a loss of surface Ig expression. Consequently, loss of surface Ig expression precedes bursal cell death by apoptosis in vivo, suggesting that maintenance of a threshold level of surface Ig may be a requirement for the continued progression of chicken B lymphocyte development in the bursa.

B cell development in the chicken

A central feature of the vertebrate humoral immune system is that an organism must have a vast repertoire of antibodies to protect it against foreign pathogens. Chickens create a diverse immunological repertoire by intrachromosomal gene conversion of the single variable gene segments of the Ig heavy and light chain genes. This diversification process has been shown to require the bursa of Fabricius. Immature cells commit to the B cell lineage by rearranging their Ig genes prior to migration to the bursa. Recent work has suggested that the ability of a developing B cell to migrate to the bursa may depend on the expression of the carbohydrate structure sialyl Lewis x. Developing B cells in the spleen with the ability to migrate to the bursa have been shown to express sialyl Lewis x. Cells expressing sialyl Lewis x begin appearing in the bursa anlage between embryonic Days 10 and 12. These sialyl Lewis x-positive cells appear to form the nascent bursal follicles and are induced to proliferate. Coincident with the time that B cells initiate the gene conversion process, cells cease expressing sialyl Lewis x and begin expressing the related surface epitope Lewis x. As cells mature further, they undergo another phenotypic change and switch from expressing high levels of Lewis x to become Lewis x-low. At the same time that Lewis x-low cells accumulate in the bursa, cells with this phenotype begin to appear in the spleen. These phenotypic markers may be useful in identifying chicken B cells at different developmental stages.

The bursa of Fabricius: the evolution of a discovery

It has been a joy these past 40 yr to have traveled the "Bursal Road"--a road we helped construct and whose route allowed us to make a variety of observations that contributed either to basic science or indirectly or directly to the role of the bursa of Fabricius in the B cell repertoire. The chicken's bursa of Fabricius introduced me to endocrine, heritability, and growth studies, which allowed serendipity to occur and the revelation of the classical and modification of the classical theses of bursal function. The modification of the classical thesis, presence of immunoglobulin in the absence of the bursa, raised questions that directed us to study hypothalamic control of behavior, which was not directly related to bursal function. This forced us to learn various techniques, e.g., autoradiography, cell labeling, and electron microscopy, that made it possible to study long- and short-lived lymphocytes, lymphokines, labeled cells, and the fine structure and function of the bursa of Fabricius, cecal tonsil, Harderian gland, lymph nodes, Meckel's diverticulum, Pineal gland, and spleen. In an attempt to use cyclophosphamide to understand how the spleen acquired the ability to produce antibodies, we revealed a dendritic cell in the bursa, the bursal-secretory dendritic cell (BSDC), and in the spleen, the ellipsoid-associated cell (EAC). The BSDC is a novel cell in the bursal microenvironment and may be involved in an interaction with prebursal or bursal stem cells, leading to the differentiation or selection of the B cell repertoire of the chicken.