Clinical trials in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: a systematic review and perspective

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis is a progressive and devastating neurodegenerative disease. Despite decades of clinical trials, effective disease-modifying drugs remain scarce. To understand the challenges of trial design and delivery, we performed a systematic review of Phase II, Phase II/III and Phase III amyotrophic lateral sclerosis clinical drug trials on trial registries and PubMed between 2008 and 2019. We identified 125 trials, investigating 76 drugs and recruiting more than 15 000 people with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. About 90% of trials used traditional fixed designs. The limitations in understanding of disease biology, outcome measures, resources and barriers to trial participation in a rapidly progressive, disabling and heterogenous disease hindered timely and definitive evaluation of drugs in two-arm trials. Innovative trial designs, especially adaptive platform trials may offer significant efficiency gains to this end. We propose a flexible and scalable multi-arm, multi-stage trial platform where opportunities to participate in a clinical trial can become the default for people with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.

An atypical presentation of giant cell arteritis without headache

We describe an unusual case of giant cell arteritis initially manifesting as insidiously progressive spastic quadriparesis, widespread muscle wasting and fasciculations in the absence of headache, followed by a complete left pupil-involving 3rd nerve palsy 10 months later. MRI and CSF analysis revealed evidence of intracranial involvement with established white matter lesions and intrathecal oligoclonal bands, respectively, whilst whole body FDG-PET demonstrated isolated uptake within the descending aorta. The temporal arteries were clinically and radiologically unremarkable but biopsy showed transmural inflammation and multinucleate giant cells. A rapid, complete and sustained improvement followed steroid therapy.

Mutations in the vesicular trafficking protein annexin A11 are associated with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a fatal neurodegenerative disorder. We screened 751 familial ALS patient whole-exome sequences and identified six mutations including p.D40G in the ANXA11 gene in 13 individuals. The p.D40G mutation was absent from 70,000 control whole-exome sequences. This mutation segregated with disease in two kindreds and was present in another two unrelated cases (P = 0.0102), and all mutation carriers shared a common founder haplotype. Annexin A11-positive protein aggregates were abundant in spinal cord motor neurons and hippocampal neuronal axons in an ALS patient carrying the p.D40G mutation. Transfected human embryonic kidney cells expressing ANXA11 with the p.D40G mutation and other N-terminal mutations showed altered binding to calcyclin, and the p.R235Q mutant protein formed insoluble aggregates. We conclude that mutations in ANXA11 are associated with ALS and implicate defective intracellular protein trafficking in disease pathogenesis.

A GENOME-WIDE ASSOCIATION STUDY IN PROGRESSIVE SUPRANUCLEAR PALSY

Background

Progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) is a debilitating Parkinsonian movement disorder characterised by tau protein burden. We aimed to identify common genetic variants influencing PSP susceptibility through a genome-wide association analysis (GWAS) of a multi-centre European study, Neuroprotection and Natural History in Parkinson's Plus Syndromes (NNIPPS), recruiting clinically well-characterised patients. We combined this with a meta-analysis of previously-identified gene variants.

Methods

We genotyped 275,684 single nucleotide polymorphisms using Illumina microarrays in 212 PSP cases from the UK, Germany and France, and compared these with 4,707 matched controls. GWAS was performed using PLINK. Meta-analysis was performed with METAL. Genome-wide significance was defined as p<5×10^–8.

Results

We observed multiple associations on chromosome 17 within or close to the MAPT gene, a well-established risk locus for PSP, confirming the sample and method validity. Of nine other previously reported associations, meta-analysis only confirmed that the MOBP variation (rs1768208) modified PSP risk (p=3.29×10^–13).

Conclusion

In the GWAS and meta-analysis, we found the chromosome 17 inversion region to be associated with PSP susceptibility. Furthermore, we have shown that MOBP can modify the risk of PSP, possibly through influencing oligodendrocyte tau inclusions. These identified gene variants provide novel insights into the underlying genetics of sporadic PSP.

No evidence for shared genetic basis of common variants in multiple sclerosis and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

Genome-wide association studies have been successful in identifying common variants that influence the susceptibility to complex diseases. From these studies, it has emerged that there is substantial overlap in susceptibility loci between diseases. In line with those findings, we hypothesized that shared genetic pathways may exist between multiple sclerosis (MS) and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). While both diseases may have inflammatory and neurodegenerative features, epidemiological studies have indicated an increased co-occurrence within individuals and families. To this purpose, we combined genome-wide data from 4088 MS patients, 3762 ALS patients and 12 030 healthy control individuals in whom 5 440 446 single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were successfully genotyped or imputed. We tested these SNPs for the excess association shared between MS and ALS and also explored whether polygenic models of SNPs below genome-wide significance could explain some of the observed trait variance between diseases. Genome-wide association meta-analysis of SNPs as well as polygenic analyses fails to provide evidence in favor of an overlap in genetic susceptibility between MS and ALS. Hence, our findings do not support a shared genetic background of common risk variants in MS and ALS.

An MND/ALS phenotype associated with C9orf72 repeat expansion: abundant p62-positive, TDP-43-negative inclusions in cerebral cortex, hippocampus and cerebellum but without associated cognitive decline

The transactive response DNA binding protein (TDP-43) proteinopathies describe a clinico-pathological spectrum of multi-system neurodegeneration that spans motor neuron disease/amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (MND/ALS) and frontotemporal lobar degeneration (FTLD). We have identified four male patients who presented with the clinical features of a pure MND/ALS phenotype (without dementia) but who had distinctive cortical and cerebellar pathology that was different from other TDP-43 proteinopathies. All patients initially presented with weakness of limbs and respiratory muscles and had a family history of MND/ALS. None had clinically identified cognitive decline or dementia during life and they died between 11 and 32 months after symptom onset. Neuropathological investigation revealed lower motor neuron involvement with TDP-43-positive inclusions typical of MND/ALS. In contrast, the cerebral pathology was atypical, with abundant star-shaped p62-immunoreactive neuronal cytoplasmic inclusions in the cerebral cortex, basal ganglia and hippocampus, while TDP-43-positive inclusions were sparse. This pattern was also seen in the cerebellum where p62-positive, TDP-43-negative inclusions were frequent in granular cells. Western blots of cortical lysates, in contrast to those of sporadic MND/ALS and FTLD-TDP, showed high p62 levels and low TDP-43 levels with no high molecular weight smearing. MND/ALS-associated SOD1, FUS and TARDBP gene mutations were excluded; however, further investigations revealed that all four of the cases did show a repeat expansion of C9orf72, the recently reported cause of chromosome 9-linked MND/ALS and FTLD. We conclude that these chromosome 9-linked MND/ALS cases represent a pathological sub-group with abundant p62 pathology in the cerebral cortex, hippocampus and cerebellum but with no significant associated cognitive decline.

Management of respiration in MND/ALS patients: an evidence based review

This systematic review comprises an objective appraisal of the evidence in regard to the management of respiration in patients with motor neuron disease (MND/ALS). Studies were identified through computerised searches of 32 databases. Internet searches of websites of drug companies and MND/ALS research web sites, 'snow balling' and hand searches were also employed to locate any unpublished study or other 'grey literature' on respiration and MND/ALS. Since management of MND/ALS involves a number of health professionals and care workers, searches were made across multiple disciplines. No time frame was imposed on the search in order to increase the probability of identifying all relevant studies, although there was a final limit of March 2005. Recommendations for patient and carer-based guidelines for the clinical management of respiration for MND/ALS patients are suggested on the basis of qualitative analyses of the available evidence. However, these recommendations are based on current evidence of best practice, which largely comprises observational research and clinical opinion. There is a clear need for further evidence, in particular randomised and non-randomised controlled trials on the effects of non-invasive ventilation and additional larger scale cohort studies on the issues of initial assessment of respiratory symptoms, and management and timing of interventions.

Integrating preferences into health status assessment for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: the ALS Utility Index

We developed a preference-based measure, the Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis Utility Index (ALSUI), allowing computation of US population-based utility weights for the wide range of health states observed among ALS patients. A multi-attribute utility approach was used. An ALS Health State Classification System was developed comprising the following attributes with different severity levels: Speech and Swallowing (A1); Eating, Dressing, and Bathing (A2); Leg Function (A3); and Respiratory Function (A4). An internet-based survey was administered to a random sample of the US population to assess preferences for ALS health states based on this system using visual analog scale (VAS) and standard gamble (SG) questions. Using the VAS and SG data from 1374 individuals in the general population, utility functions were computed that corresponded to each severity level within A1, A2, A3, and A4. ALSUI scores for a given patient are computed by inputting his corresponding utility functions into the following multiplicative formula: ALSUI score = 1.06 x (A1 x A2 x A3 x A4) - 0.06 on a scale where 0.0 reflects death and 1.0 reflects healthy. This study provides a useful tool for classifying ALS patients and determining a general public-based utility score for ALS health states.

VEGF is a modifier of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis in mice and humans and protects motoneurons against ischemic death

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is an incurable degenerative disorder of motoneurons. We recently reported that reduced expression of Vegfa causes ALS-like motoneuron degeneration in Vegfa(delta/delta) mice. In a meta-analysis of over 900 individuals from Sweden and over 1,000 individuals from Belgium and England, we now report that subjects homozygous with respect to the haplotypes -2,578A/-1,154A/-634G or -2,578A/-1,154G/-634G in the VEGF promoter/leader sequence had a 1.8 times greater risk of ALS (P = 0.00004). These 'at-risk' haplotypes lowered circulating VEGF levels in vivo and reduced VEGF gene transcription, IRES-mediated VEGF expression and translation of a novel large-VEGF isoform (L-VEGF) in vivo. Moreover, SOD1(G93A) mice crossbred with Vegfa(delta/delta) mice died earlier due to more severe motoneuron degeneration. Vegfa(delta/delta) mice were unusually susceptible to persistent paralysis after spinal cord ischemia, and treatment with Vegfa protected mice against ischemic motoneuron death. These findings indicate that VEGF is a modifier of motoneuron degeneration in human ALS and unveil a therapeutic potential of Vegfa for stressed motoneurons in mice.

Stem therapy for ALS: hope and reality

All are agreed that there is pressing need for an effective treatment for Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS; MND). Such treatment may derive from a combination of therapeutic strategies aimed at different aspects of the disorder, and might include drugs directed at the initial, intermediate or terminal cascade of events leading to cell death, as well as the use of stem cells to replace dead motor neurons, or to protect those that remain. The attraction of cell implantation or transplantation is that it might help to overcome the inability of the CNS to replace lost neurons. It is also clear that neural implantation will yield little benefit if the donor cells fail to integrate functionally into the recipient CNS circuitry. In this respect, ALS poses an especially difficult problem. The recent breakthroughs in stem cell research might nevertheless provide possibilities for neural implantation and cell replacement therapy for patients with ALS. The potential impact of these new approaches to neurodegenerative diseases has been emphasised by the many experiments using human foetal cell grafts in patients affected by Parkinson's and Huntington's disease. Clinical benefits in Parkinson's disease seem to be associated with integration of the donor cells into the recipient brain. Despite promising results, however, significant constraints have hampered the use of foetal cells for neural implantation and transplantation. Besides ethical concerns, the viability, purity, and final destiny of the foetal tissue have not been completely defined. Foetal cells are, in addition, post-mitotic and cannot be expanded or stored for long periods, necessitating close synchronisation of tissue donation and neurosurgery.

Ubiquitin-only intraneuronal inclusion in the substantia nigra is a characteristic feature of motor neurone disease with dementia

Two types of ubiquitinated inclusions have been described in motor neurone disease (MND). (1) Skein or globular ubiquitinated inclusions in the motor neurones (more frequently in the lower motor neurones). This is a characteristic feature of all motor neurone disease categories. (2) Dot-shape or crescentric ubiquitinated inclusions in the upper layers of cortex and dentate gyrus described in cases of motor neurone disease with dementia (DMND). We investigated the substantia nigra (SN) in MND cases; two cases of motor neurone disease inclusion body (MND-IB) dementia, six cases of DMND, 14 cases of MND (including one case from Guam and two cases of familial SOD1 mutation), four cases of Parkinson's disease (PD), and 10 cases of age-matched normal controls. SN and spinal cord sections were stained with ubiquitin (alpha-synuclein, tau, PGM1, SMI-31 and SOD1 antibodies). The neuronal density in SN was quantified by using a computer-based image analysis system. Four out of six DMND cases showed rounded ubiquitin positive inclusions with irregular frayed edges, associated with neuronal loss, reactive astrocytosis and a large number of activated microglia cells. These inclusions are negative with antibodies to (alpha-synuclein, tau, SMI-31 and SOD1). The SN in cases from MND-IB dementia and MND showed occasional neuronal loss and no inclusions. The ubiquitin-only inclusions in SN of DMND cases are similar (but not identical) to the ubiquitinated inclusions described previously in the spinal cord of MND cases and are distinct from Lewy bodies (LBs). The degeneration of SN is most likely a primary neurodegenerative process of motor neurone disease type frequently involving the DMND cases. MND disease is a spectrum and multisystem disorder with DMND located at the extreme end of a spectrum affecting the CNS more widely than just the motor system.

Progress in the pathogenesis of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

This decade has seen the discovery of one cause for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)--mutations in the copper/zinc superoxide dismutase (SOD1) gene. Mutant SOD1 has provided an invaluable tool for transgenic and cellular experiments designed to elicit the biochemical pathways that are disturbed in ALS. We highlight recent advances in ALS research, including diagnostic issues, new loci for ALS genes, and progress in understanding the toxicity of mutant SOD1. The evidence for persistant viral infection, glutamate-mediated excitotoxicity, oxidative stress, altered neurofilament and peripherin expression, disrupted axonal transport, neurotrophin deficiency, and mitochondrial dysfunction are critically reviewed. As yet, no consensus has been achieved on the pathways that lead to selective neuronal death, and the underlying causes are still unknown in the vast majority of patients. Further clues about genetic susceptibility and environmental triggers are urgently needed so that more effective treatments for ALS can be developed, with the ultimate goal being prevention.

Cyclin-dependent kinase-5 is associated with lipofuscin in motor neurones in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

We have studied the distribution of cyclin dependent kinase-5 (cdk-5) within spinal cord in sporadic and two superoxide dismutase type 1 (SOD1) familial cases of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Although most neurofilament accumulations in ALS motor neurones did not appear to contain high levels of cdk-5, intense cdk-5 immunoreactivity was observed in perikarya of degenerating neurones in many ALS cases. Here, cdk-5 co-localised with lipofuscin. Co-localisation of cdk-5 with lipofuscin was also observed in some aged non-affected controls although this labelling was less intense than the ALS cases. The biogenesis of lipofuscin is believed to be linked to oxidative stress and oxidative stress and free radical damage have been suggested to be part of the pathogenic process of ALS, possibly involving apoptotic mechanisms. cdk-5 has recently been associated with apoptosis. These observations suggest a role for cdk-5 in the pathogenesis of ALS.

Serum carnosinase activities in central nervous system disorders

Serum carnosinase activity was assayed in five groups of patients with neurological disorders. Enzyme activities in patients with idiopathic epilepsy (mean +/- S.E.M., 148 +/- 11 nmol/ml per min) and motor neurone disease (155 +/- 15 nmol/ml per min) were similar to the control group (161 +/- 7 nmol/ml per min). Reduced serum carnosinase activity was observed in patients with Parkinson's disease (109 +/- 11 nmol/ml per min, P < 0.005), multiple sclerosis (82.5 +/- 10.0 nmol/ml per min, P < 0.005) and patients following a cerebrovascular accident (74.6 +/- 5.4 nmol/ml per min, P < 0.001) compared with the control group. Carnosinase activity, 5-10% of that found in serum, was detected in CSF samples. The cause of reduced serum carnosinase activities in central nervous system disorders is unclear, although anoxic damage to carnosinase-producing cells or disruption of the blood-brain barrier may be responsible.

The relationship between muscle fibre atrophy factor, plasma carnosinase activities and muscle RNA and protein composition in chronic alcoholic myopathy

The relationship between chronic ethanol consumption and muscle biopsy morphometry (i.e. atrophy factor), plasma analytes, including carnosinase activities and tissue composition was investigated. In approximately half of chronic alcohol misusers there was Type II-fibre atrophy, which was correlated with reductions in muscle protein and serum carnosinase activities. The protein composition was also correlated with RNA composition. These results directly implicate defects in protein and RNA turnover as characteristics of chronic alcoholic myopathy and re-affirms the routine diagnostic use of fibre-type morphometry to identify these patients.

Criteria for Diagnosis of Familial Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis

Clinical criteria for the diagnosis of motor neuron disease, agreed at the inaugural meeting of the European Familial Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis Collaborative Group, are described. The criteria are derived from those developed for the study of sporadic amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, and allow the inclusion of certain recognized clinical sub-types of familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. They will require testing for consistency and sensitivity.

MRI appearances of the CNS manifestations of Mycoplasma pneumoniae: a report of two cases

Two patients are reported with Mycoplasma pneumoniae-related cervical myelitis. Magnetic resonance imaging in each case demonstrated clinically silent lesions suggesting more extensive neurological involvement. This supports the concept of widespread immunologically mediated disease occurring as a remote effect of initial M. pneumoniae respiratory infection. Differences from the MRI appearances of a patient with mycoplasma-related Guillian-Barré syndrome imply that more than one antigenic determinant is involved.

Hypophysectomy does not prevent development of striatal dopamine receptor supersensitivity induced by repeated neuroleptic treatment

Hruska et al. (1980) reported that hypophysectomy prevented the onset of dopamine receptor supersensitivity. We have repeated this investigation administering haloperidol (0.75 mg/day) or sulpiride (2 X 15 mg/day) or saline for 17 days, followed by a 3 day drug washout period, to sham-operated or hypophysectomised rats. Haloperidol or sulpiride pretreatment caused an enhancement of apomorphine-induced stereotyped behaviour and increased the number of specific striatal [3H]spiperone binding sites (Bmax) in both hypophysectomised and sham-operated animals compared to their respective saline controls. We conclude that hypophysectomy does not prevent the onset of striatal dopamine receptor supersensitivity induced by repeated neuroleptic treatment in the rat.

Dopamine-mediated circling behaviour does not involve the nigro-tectal pathway

Extensive unilateral or bilateral electrolytic ablation of the rat superior colliculus failed to reduce apomorphine- or amphetamine-induced rotation in animals with a unilateral 6-hydroxydopamine lesion of one nigro-striatal dopaminergic pathway. These findings suggest that a nigro-tectal pathway does not play a crucial role in mediating the circling response caused by striatal dopamine receptor stimulation. However, electrolytic lesions of the dorsal tegmental decussation reduced apomorphine- but not amphetamine-induced rotation in such animals, perhaps by sectioning some commissural pathway between the two nigro-striatal systems.

Turning behaviour induced by injection of muscimol or picrotoxin into the substantia nigra demonstrates dual GABA components

Injection of the GABA agonist muscimol into rat caudal substantia nigra caused contralateral turning, whereas injection into the rostral substantia nigra caused ipsilateral turning. The GABA antagonist picrotoxin had the opposite effect. These findings support the hypothesis that GABA has dual actions in the substantia nigra. Ipsilateral turning induced by injection of muscimol into rostral nigra was abolished by haloperidol pretreatment, indicating the involvement of dopaminergic mechanisms. Haloperidol pre-treatment did not prevent turning induced by muscimol injected into the caudal nigra, supporting the existence of a non-dopaminergic nigral output system.