Vaccinia virus complement-control protein prevents antibody-dependent complement-enhanced neutralization of infectivity and contributes to virulence

Antibody-induced internalization of viral glycoproteins and gE-gI Fc receptor activity protect pseudorabies virus-infected monocytes from efficient complement-mediated lysis

Pseudorabies virus (PRV)-infected blood monocytes are able to transport virus throughout the body of vaccination-immune pigs. PRV-infected monocytes express viral glycoproteins in their plasma membrane that can be recognized by virus-specific antibodies. Recently, it has been shown that addition of PRV-specific polyclonal immunoglobulins to PRV-infected monocytes at 37 degrees C induces internalization of the majority of plasma membrane-expressed viral glycoproteins. This study investigated whether this process may interfere with efficient antibody-dependent complement-mediated lysis (ADCML) of infected monocytes. Therefore, an ADCML assay was set up in vitro. A significant decrease in the percentage of cells lysed by ADCML was observed when antibody-induced internalization of PRV glycoproteins occurred (P<0.005). Furthermore, it is shown (i) that the PRV gE-gI complex, which, like certain other alpha herpesvirus orthologues, possesses IgG-binding capacity, aids in avoiding efficient ADCML of PRV-infected monocytes and (ii) that the efficiency of PRV gE-gI-mediated evasion of ADCML can be decreased by the presence of gE-gI-specific antibodies.

Vaccinia complement control protein: multi-functional protein and a potential wonder drug

Vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP) was one of the first viral molecules demonstrated to have a role in blocking complement and hence in the evasion of host defense. Structurally it is very similar to the human C4b-BP and the other members of complement control protein. Functionally it is most similar to the CR1 protein. VCP blocks both major pathways of complement activation. The crystal structure of VCP was determined a little over a year ago and it is the only known structure of an intact and complete complement control protein. In addition to binding complement, VCP also binds to heparin. These two binding abilities can take place simultaneously and contribute to its many function and to its potential use in several inflammatory diseases, e.g. Alzheimer's disease (AD), CNS injury, xenotransplantation, etc. making it a truly fascinating molecule and potential drug.

Viral mimicry of the complement system

The complement system is a potent innate immune mechanism consisting of cascades of proteins which are designed to fight against and annul intrusion of all the foreign pathogens. Although viruses are smaller in size and have relatively simple structure, they are not immune to complement attack. Thus, activation of the complement system can lead to neutralization of cell-free viruses, phagocytosis of C3b-coated viral particles, lysis of virus-infected cells, and generation of inflammatory and specific immune responses. However, to combat host responses and succeed as pathogens, viruses not only have developed/adopted mechanisms to control complement, but also have turned these interactions to their own advantage. Important examples include poxviruses, herpesviruses, retroviruses, paramyxoviruses and picornaviruses. In this review, we provide information on the various complement evasion strategies that viruses have developed to thwart the complement attack of the host. A special emphasis is given on the interactions between the viral proteins that are involved in molecular mimicry and the complement system.

Virus complement evasion strategies

The immune system has a variety of tools at its disposal to combat virus infections. These can be subdivided roughly into two categories: 'first line defence', consisting of the non-specific, innate immune system, and 'adaptive immune response', acquired over time following virus infection or vaccination. During evolution, viruses have developed numerous, and often very ingenious, strategies to counteract efficient recognition of virions or virus-infected cells by both innate and adaptive immunity. This review will focus on the different strategies that viruses use to avoid recognition by one of the components of the immune system: the complement system. Complement evasion is of particular importance for viruses, since complement activation is a crucial component of innate immunity (alternative and mannan-binding lectin activation pathway) as well as of adaptive immunity (classical, antibody-dependent complement activation).

Immune evasion strategies of Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus

To establish lifelong infection in the presence of an active host immune system, herpesviruses have acquired an impressive array of immune modulatory mechanisms that contribute to their success as long-term parasites. Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus (KSHV) is the most recently discovered human tumor virus and is associated with the pathogenesis of Kaposi's sarcoma, primary effusion lymphoma, and multicentric Castleman's disease. KSHV has acquired a battery of genes to assist in viral survival against the host immune response. These viral gene products target a variety of host immune surveillance mechanisms, including the cytokine-mediated immune response, apoptosis, natural killer (NK) cell killing and T cell-mediated responses. This review summarizes our understanding of the role of these viral proteins in the escape from host immune surveillance, which ultimately contributes to lifelong infection and pathogenesis of KSHV.

Poxvirus immune modulators: functional insights from animal models

Poxviruses express several different classes of immune modulators that suppress the host response to infection, including soluble cytokine binding proteins, serpins, chemokine binding proteins, a complement control protein, and members of the semaphorin and Toll/IL-1 receptor families. Biochemical activity of these proteins has been demonstrated by many in vitro studies. Conservation in evolution of poxvirus immune modulators implies that these genes are functional in vivo, but the results of infecting animals with knockout viruses have not always been clear cut. Studies involving different animal models are reviewed, and the criteria for suitable models are discussed. Challenges include finding an appropriate animal host, and using an inoculation route that resembles the process of natural infection. The fact that multiple immune modulators can target the same pathway at different steps may explain why single knockout mutants are not always attenuated in animals.

Antibody to a lytic cycle viral protein decreases gammaherpesvirus latency in B-cell-deficient mice

While antiviral antibody plays a key role in resistance to acute viral infection, the contribution of antibody to the control of latent virus infection is less well understood. Gammaherpesvirus 68 (gammaHV68) infection of mice provides a model well suited to defining contributions of specific immune system components to the control of viral latency. B cells play a critical role in regulating gammaHV68 latency, but the mechanism(s) by which B cells regulate latency is not known. In the experiments reported here, we determined the effect of passively transferred antibody on established gammaHV68 latency in B-cell-deficient (B-cell(-/-)) mice. Immune antibody decreased the frequency of cells reactivating ex vivo from latency in splenocytes (>10-fold) and peritoneal cells (>100-fold) and the frequency of cells carrying latent viral genome in splenocytes (>5-fold) and peritoneal cells (>50-fold). This effect required virus-specific antibody and was observed when total and virus-specific serum antibody concentrations in recipient B-cell(-/-) mice were <8% of those in normal mice during latent infection. Passive transfer of antibody specific for the lytic cycle gammaHV68 RCA protein, but not passive transfer of antibody specific for the v-cyclin protein or the latent protein M2, decreased both the frequency of cells reactivating ex vivo from latency and the frequency of cells carrying the latent viral genome. Therefore, antibody specific for lytic cycle viral antigens can play an important role in the control of gammaherpesvirus latency in immunocompromised hosts. Based on these findings, we propose a model in which ongoing productive replication is essential for maintaining high levels of latently infected cells in immunocompromised hosts. We confirmed this model by the treatment of latently infected B-cell(-/-) mice with the antiviral drug cidofovir.

Critical role of complement and viral evasion of complement in acute, persistent, and latent gamma-herpesvirus infection

Several gamma-herpesviruses encode homologs of host regulators of complement activation (RCA) proteins, suggesting that they have evolved immune evasion strategies targeting complement. We evaluated the role of complement factor C3 (C3) and the murine gamma-herpesvirus 68 (gammaHV68) RCA protein in viral pathogenesis. Deletion of the gammaHV68 RCA protein decreased virulence during acute CNS infection, and this attenuation was specifically reversed by deletion of host C3. The gammaHV68 RCA protein was also important for persistent viral replication and virulence in IFNgammaR(-/-) mice. In addition, C3 played a role in regulating latency, but this was not counteracted by the gammaHV68 RCA protein. We conclude that complement is a key host defense against gamma-herpesvirus infection and that gamma-herpesviruses have evolved an immune evasion strategy that is effective against complement-mediated antiviral responses during acute but not latent infection.

Variola virus immune evasion design: expression of a highly efficient inhibitor of human complement

Variola virus, the most virulent member of the genus Orthopoxvirus, specifically infects humans and has no other animal reservoir. Variola causes the contagious disease smallpox, which has a 30-40% mortality rate. Conversely, the prototype orthopoxvirus, vaccinia, causes no disease in immunocompetent humans and was used in the global eradication of smallpox, which ended in 1977. However, the threat of smallpox persists because clandestine stockpiles of variola still exist. Although variola and vaccinia share remarkable DNA homology, the strict human tropism of variola suggests that its proteins are better suited than those of vaccinia to overcome the human immune response. Here, we demonstrate the functional advantage of a variola complement regulatory protein over that of its vaccinia homologue. Because authentic variola proteins are not available for study, we molecularly engineered and characterized the smallpox inhibitor of complement enzymes (SPICE), a homologue of a vaccinia virulence factor, vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP). SPICE is nearly 100-fold more potent than VCP at inactivating human C3b and 6-fold more potent at inactivating C4b. SPICE is also more human complement-specific than is VCP. By inactivating complement components, SPICE serves to inhibit the formation of the C3/C5 convertases necessary for complement-mediated viral clearance. SPICE provides the first evidence that variola proteins are particularly adept at overcoming human immunity, and the decreased function of VCP suggests one reason why the vaccinia virus vaccine was associated with relatively low mortality. Disabling SPICE may be therapeutically useful if smallpox reemerges.

Heparin-protein interactions

Heparin, a sulfated polysaccharide belonging to the family of glycosaminoglycans, has numerous important biological activities, associated with its interaction with diverse proteins. Heparin is widely used as an anticoagulant drug based on its ability to accelerate the rate at which antithrombin inhibits serine proteases in the blood coagulation cascade. Heparin and the structurally related heparan sulfate are complex linear polymers comprised of a mixture of chains of different length, having variable sequences. Heparan sulfate is ubiquitously distributed on the surfaces of animal cells and in the extracellular matrix. It also mediates various physiologic and pathophysiologic processes. Difficulties in evaluating the role of heparin and heparan sulfate in vivo may be partly ascribed to ignorance of the detailed structure and sequence of these polysaccharides. In addition, the understanding of carbohydrate-protein interactions has lagged behind that of the more thoroughly studied protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions. The recent extensive studies on the structural, kinetic, and thermodynamic aspects of the protein binding of heparin and heparan sulfate have led to an improved understanding of heparin-protein interactions. A high degree of specificity could be identified in many of these interactions. An understanding of these interactions at the molecular level is of fundamental importance in the design of new highly specific therapeutic agents. This review focuses on aspects of heparin structure and conformation, which are important for its interactions with proteins. It also describes the interaction of heparin and heparan sulfate with selected families of heparin-binding proteins.

Species-specific differences in the structure of orthopoxvirus complement-binding protein

Vaccinia virus complement-binding protein (VCP) is secreted from the cells infected with the virus and controls the complement activation reactions. This protein contains four short consensus repeats (SCR), typical of the protein family of complement activation regulators. Organization of the VCP genes/proteins of orthopoxviruses-monkeypox (MPV), variola, cowpox and vaccinia viruses-and their cellular homologues (DAF and C4BP) were studied comparatively. For this purpose, VCP genes of three MPV strains were sequenced. VCP gene sequences of other human-pathogenic orthopoxvirus species and strains determined earlier were involved in the analysis. It has been demonstrated that a premature termination of the MPV VCP open reading frame results in a truncated protein sequence carrying a deletion of the C-terminal SCR4. This is an essential distinction of MPV from other orthopoxvirus species.

Poxvirus homologues of cellular genes

Over the course of time poxviruses have acquired or "captured" numerous homologues of cellular genes and incorporated them into their large DNA genomes. With more poxvirus genome sequencing data becoming available, the number of newly discovered poxviral cellular homologues is constantly increasing. A common feature of these genes is that they are nonessential for virus replication in vitro and they confer selective advantages in dealing with host cell differentiation and immune defense mechanisms in vivo. Poxviral cellular homologues are reviewed in this synopsis considering the specific viral habitats of different poxviruses and the immune defence capabilities of their respective hosts. Possible mechanisms of cellular gene acquisition by poxviruses as suggested by the analysis of mobile genetic elements in large DNA viruses are discussed. The investigation of poxvirus homologues of cellular genes is essential for our understanding of the mechanisms that regulate virus/host interactions on the cellular level and the host response against infection.

Virokines: novel immunomodulatory agents

Since the discovery of virokines in the 1980s, much time and research has been dedicated to exploring their potential use as therapeutic agents. Simply put, virokines are virally encoded proteins that are secreted from the infected host cell. Most of these proteins possess the ability to modulate different aspects of the host immune system, to better maintain a suitable habitat for viral replication. These proteins are often highly homologous to host immune proteins but are often smaller and more powerful. Examples of virokines include viral secreted proteins that: block components of the complement system, act as serine protease inhibitors, function as chemokine and cytokine agonists or antagonists and contribute to cell proliferation. Many of these proteins are currently being investigated for use as novel therapeutic immunomodulators to manage immune disorders, inflammation after trauma, graft rejection and autoimmune diseases.

Vaccinia virus complement control protein is capable of protecting xenoendothelial cells from antibody binding and killing by human complement and cytotoxic cells

BACKGROUND

Vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP) was the first secretory microbial protein shown to have structural similarity to the family of complement control proteins. VCP can block both the classical and alternate complement pathways. Recently, VCP has been shown to bind to heparin, and this property contributes to separate functions, making the molecule a multifunctional protein.

METHODS

VCP prepared from a natural infection of RK-13 cells with vaccinia virus was purified to homogeneity. Cultured pig aortic endothelial cells (PAECs) were mixed with human serum, anti-Gal alpha1,3 Gal antibody, neutrophils, or natural killer (NK) cells in the presence or absence of VCP and either direct binding of FITC-labeled antibody or killing by cytotoxic cells was estimated.

RESULTS

Our cell culture studies demonstrate that VCP blocks complement-mediated killing of PAECs by human serum in a dose-dependent manner. We also demonstrate that VCP is capable of blocking Gal alpha1,3 Gal binding sites on PAECS. Surprisingly, VCP effectively blocked interactions between PAECs and cytotoxic cells such as human naive neutrophils and NK cells.

CONCLUSION

VCP is a novel protein amongst the complement control protein family and can, not only block xenorejection by inhibiting complement but also by blocking killing by cytotoxic cells.

Solution structure and dynamics of the central CCP module pair of a poxvirus complement control protein

The complement control protein (CCP) module (also known as SCR, CCP or sushi domain) is prevalent amongst proteins that regulate complement activation. Functional and mutagenesis studies have shown that in most cases two or more neighbouring CCP modules form specific binding sites for other molecules. Hence the orientation in space of a CCP module with respect to its neighbours and the flexibility of the intermodular junction are likely to be critical for function. Vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP) is a complement regulatory protein composed of four tandemly arranged CCP modules. The solution structure of the carboxy-terminal half of this protein (CCP modules 3 and 4) has been solved previously. The structure of the central portion (modules 2 and 3, VCP approximately 2,3) has now also been solved using NMR spectroscopy at 37 degrees C. In addition, the backbone dynamics of VCP approximately 2,3 have been characterised by analysis of its (15)N relaxation parameters. Module 2 has a typical CCP module structure while module 3 in the context of VCP approximately 2,3 has some modest but significant differences in structure and dynamics to module 3 within the 3,4 pair. Modules 2 and 3 do not share an extensive interface, unlike modules 3 and 4. Only two possible NOEs were identified between the bodies of the modules, but a total of 40 NOEs between the short intermodular linker of VCP approximately 2,3 and the bodies of the two modules determines a preferred, elongated, orientation of the two modules in the calculated structures. The anisotropy of rotational diffusion has been characterised from (15)N relaxation data, and this indicates that the time-averaged structure is more compact than suggested by (1)H-(1)H NOEs. The data are consistent with the presence of many intermodular orientations, some of which are kinked, undergoing interconversion on a 10(-8)-10(-6) second time-scale. A reconstructed representation of modules 2-4 allows visualisation of the spatial arrangement of the 11 substitutions that occur in the more potent complement inhibitor from Variola (small pox) virus.

Immunology 101 at poxvirus U: immune evasion genes

Poxviruses, unlike some other large DNA viruses, do not undergo a latent stage but rely on the expression of viral proteins to evade host immune responses. Of the many poxviral evasion genes identified, most target cytokines or other innate immune defenses. Resistance to interferons appears to be a priority as there are viral proteins that prevent their induction, receptor binding, and action. Additional poxviral proteins inhibit complement activation, chemokines, IL-1 beta and tumor necrosis factor. The identification of viral immune evasion genes and the determination of their roles in virus survival and spread contribute to our understanding of immunology and microbiology.

RETRACTED: Crystal structure of a complement control protein that regulates both pathways of complement activation and binds heparan sulfate proteoglycans

This article has been retracted: please see Elsevier Policy on Article Withdrawal (https://www.elsevier.com/about/our-business/policies/article-withdrawal). This article has been retracted at the request of request of the editors. Cell is retracting this paper reporting structures of a poxvirus protein, VCP, that inhibits the complement system. The paper presents a structural model derived from two crystal forms of the protein (PDB: 1G40 and 1G44) that defines an interaction surface implicated in inhibition of complement C3 proteins and visualizes heparin binding sites. We were contacted by the University of Alabama, Birmingham (UAB), the corresponding author's institution, with a report detailing concerns about the veracity of the structures and recommending that the structures be retracted from the Protein Data Bank. We then conducted an assessment with input from experts in the field who found that the structures as presented in the paper were not consistent with available data, including spatial packing and structure (B) factors. These findings were consistent with issues contained in the UAB report. A subsequent investigation by the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Research Integrity (https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/04/16/2018-07782/findings-of-research-misconduct) has concluded that the corresponding author, Krishna H.M. Murthy, engaged in research misconduct and that the structures were falsified and/or fabricated. Given the results of our own assessment and the institutional investigations, the most appropriate course of action is to retract the paper. Co-authors Nick Mullin, Paul N. Barlow, and Craig M. Ogata support this retraction.

Vaccinia virus vectors with an inactivated gamma interferon receptor homolog gene (B8R) are attenuated In vivo without a concomitant reduction in immunogenicity

The vaccinia virus (VV) B8R gene encodes a secreted protein with homology to the gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) receptor. In vitro, the B8R protein binds to and neutralizes the antiviral activity of several species of IFN-gamma, including human and rat IFN-gamma; it does not, however, bind significantly to murine IFN-gamma. Here we report on the construction and characterization of recombinant VVs (rVVs) lacking the B8R gene. While the deletion of this gene had no effect on virus replication in vitro, rVVs lacking the B8R gene were attenuated for mice. There was a significant decrease in weight loss and mortality in normal mice, and nude mice survived significantly longer than did controls inoculated with parental virus. This is a surprising result considering the minimal binding of the B8R protein to murine IFN-gamma and its failure to block the antiviral activity of this cytokine in vitro. Such reduction in virulence could not be determined in rats, since they are considerably more resistant to VV infection than are mice. Finally, deletion of the B8R gene had no detectable effects on humoral immune responses. Mice and rats vaccinated with the rVVs showed identical humoral responses to both homologous and heterologous genes expressed by VV. This study demonstrates that the deletion of the VV B8R gene leads to enhanced safety without a concomitant reduction in immunogenicity.

Conservation in decay accelerating factor (DAF) structure among primates

The decay accelerating factor (DAF, CD55) protects self cells from activation of autologous complement on their surfaces. It functions to disable the C3 convertases, the central amplification enzymes of the cascade. Its active site(s) are contained within four approximately 60 amino acid long units, termed complement control protein repeats (CCPs), which are suspended above the cell surface on a 68 amino acid long serine/threonine (S/T)-rich cushion that derives from three exons. We previously proposed a molecular model of human DAF's four CCPs in which certain amino acids were postulated to be recognition sites for the interaction between DAF and the C3 convertases. In the current study, we characterized DAF in five non-human primates: the great apes, gorilla and common chimpanzee, and the Old World monkeys: hamadryas baboon, Rhesus macaque, and patas monkey. Amino acid homology to human DAF was approximately 98% for the two great apes and 83% for the three Old World monkeys. The above cited putative ligand interactive residues were found to be fully conserved in all of the non-human primates, although there were amino acid changes outside of these areas. In the chimpanzee, alternative splicing of the S/T region was found potentially to be the source of multiple protein isoforms in erythrocytes, whereas in the patas monkey, similar alternative splicing was observed but only one protein band was seen. Interestingly, a Rhesus macaque was found to exhibit a phenomenon paralleling the human Cromer Dr(a-) blood group, in which a 44-base pair deletion in CCP3 leads to a frameshift and early STOP codon.

Novel mechanism of antibody-independent complement neutralization of herpes simplex virus type 1

The envelope surface glycoprotein C (gC) of HSV-1 interferes with the complement cascade by binding C3 and activation products C3b, iC3b, and C3c, and by blocking the interaction of C5 and properdin with C3b. Wild-type HSV-1 is resistant to Ab-independent complement neutralization; however, HSV-1 mutant virus lacking gC is highly susceptible to complement resulting in > or =100-fold reduction in virus titer. We evaluated the mechanisms by which complement inhibits HSV-1 gC null virus to better understand how gC protects against complement-mediated neutralization. C8-depleted serum prepared from an HSV-1 and -2 Ab-negative donor neutralized gC null virus comparable to complement-intact serum, indicating that C8 and terminal lytic activity are not required. In contrast, C5-depleted serum from the same donor failed to neutralize gC null virus, supporting a requirement for C5. EDTA-treated serum did not neutralize gC null virus, indicating that complement activation is required. Factor D-depleted and C6-depleted sera neutralized virus, suggesting that the alternative complement pathway and complement components beyond C5 are not required. Complement did not aggregate virus or block attachment to cells. However, complement inhibited infection before early viral gene expression, indicating that complement affects one or more of the following steps in virus replication: virus entry, uncoating, DNA transport to the nucleus, or immediate early gene expression. Therefore, in the absence of gC, HSV-1 is readily inhibited by complement by a C5-dependent mechanism that does not require viral lysis, aggregation, or blocking virus attachment.

Factor H binding to bone sialoprotein and osteopontin enables tumor cell evasion of complement-mediated attack

Metastatic cancer cells, like trophoblasts of the developing placenta, are invasive and must escape immune surveillance to survive. Complement has long been thought to play a significant role in the tumor surveillance mechanism. Bone sialoprotein (BSP) and osteopontin (OPN, ETA-1) are expressed by trophoblasts and are strongly up-regulated by many tumors. Indeed, BSP has been shown to be a positive indicator of the invasive potential of some tumors. In this report, we show that BSP and OPN form rapid and tight complexes with complement Factor H. Besides its key role in regulating complement-mediated cell lysis, Factor H also appears to play a role when "hijacked" by invading organisms in enabling cellular evasion of complement. We have investigated whether BSP and OPN may play a similar role in tumor cell complement evasion by testing to see whether these glycoproteins could promote tumor cell survival. Recombinant OPN and BSP can protect murine erythroleukemia cells from attack by human complement as well as human MCF-7 breast cancer cells and U-266 myeloma cells from attack by guinea pig complement. The mechanism of this gain of function by tumor cell expression of BSP or OPN has been defined using specific peptides and antibodies to block BSP and OPN protective activity. The expression of BSP and OPN in tumor cells provides a selective advantage for survival via initial binding to alpha(V)beta(3) integrin (both) or CD44 (OPN) on the cell surface, followed by sequestration of Factor H to the cell surface and inhibition of complement-mediated cell lysis.

Conserved surface-exposed K/R-X-K/R motifs and net positive charge on poxvirus complement control proteins serve as putative heparin binding sites and contribute to inhibition of molecular interactions with human endothelial cells: a novel mechanism for evasion of host defense

Vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP) has been shown to possess the ability to inhibit both classical and alternative complement pathway activation. The newly found ability of this protein to bind to heparin has been shown in previous studies to result in uptake by mast cells, possibly promoting tissue persistence. It has also been shown to reduce chemotactic migration of leukocytes by blocking chemokine binding. In addition, this study shows that VCP-through its ability to bind to glycosaminoglycans (heparin-like molecules) on the surface of human endothelial cells-is able to block antibody binding to surface major histocompatibility complex class I molecules. Since heparin binding is critical for many functions of this protein, we have attempted to characterize the molecular basis for this interaction. Segments of this protein, generated by genetic engineering of the DNA encoding VCP into the Pichia pastoris expression system, were used to localize the regions with heparin binding activity. These regions were then analyzed to more specifically define their properties for binding. It was found that the number of putative binding sites (K/R-X-K/R), the overall positive charge, and the percentage of positively charged amino acids within the protein were responsible for this interaction.

Poxviral mimicry of complement and chemokine system components: what's the end game?

Numerous viral proteins mimic host immunoregulatory proteins, both structurally and functionally. This phenomenon appears to underlie viral evasion of host defense. These viral immunomodulatory proteins block viral neutralization and destruction of infected cells, and are also able to influence their habitat, preserving habitats that favor their growth and that of their progeny. The end game seems to vary widely among viruses.

In vivo role of complement-interacting domains of herpes simplex virus type 1 glycoprotein gC

Immune evasion is critical for survival of viruses that establish persistent or recurrent infections. However, at the molecular level, little is known about how viruses evade immune attack in vivo. Herpes simplex virus (HSV)-1 glycoprotein gC has two domains that are involved in modulating complement activation; one binds C3, and the other is required for blocking C5 and properdin (P) binding to C3. To evaluate the importance of these regions in vivo, HSV-1 gC mutant viruses were constructed that lacked one or both gC domains and studied in a murine model of infection. Each gC region of complement regulation contributed to virulence; however, the C3 binding domain was far more important, as virus lacking this domain was much less virulent than virus lacking the C5/P inhibitory domain and was as attenuated as virus lacking both domains. Studies in C3 knockout mice and mice reconstituted with C3 confirmed that the gC domains are inhibitors of complement activation, accounting for a 50-fold difference in virulence between mutant and wild-type viruses. We conclude that the C3 binding domain on gC is a major contributor to immune evasion and that this site explains at a molecular level why wild-type virus resists complement attack.

Murine gammaherpesvirus 68 encodes a functional regulator of complement activation

Sequence analysis of the murine gammaherpesvirus 68 (gammaHV68) genome revealed an open reading frame (gene 4) which is homologous to a family of proteins known as the regulators of complement activation (RCA proteins) (H. W. Virgin, P. Latreille, P. Wamsley, K. Hallsworth, K. E. Weck, A. J. Dal Canto, and S. H. Speck, J. Virol. 71:5894-5904, 1997). The predicted gene 4 product has homology to other virally encoded RCA homologs, as well as to the complement-regulatory proteins decay-accelerating factor and membrane cofactor protein. Analyses by Northern blotting and rapid amplification of cDNA ends revealed that gene 4 is transcribed as a 5.2-kb bicistronic transcript of the late kinetic class. Three gammaHV68 RCA protein isoforms (60 to 65 kDa, 50 to 55 kDa, and 40 to 45 kDa) were detected by Western blotting of infected murine NIH 3T12 fibroblast cells. A soluble 40- to 45-kDa isoform was detected in the supernatants of virally infected cells. Flow cytometric analysis revealed that the gammaHV68 RCA protein was expressed on the surfaces of infected cells. Supernatants from virally infected cells contained an activity that inhibited murine complement activation as measured by inhibition of C3 deposition on activated zymosan particles. Recombinant gammaHV68 RCA protein, containing the four conserved short consensus repeats, inhibited murine C3 deposition on zymosan via both classical and alternative pathways and inhibited deposition of human C3 on activated zymosan particles. Expression of this inhibitor of complement activation, both at the cell surface and in the fluid phase, may be important for gammaHV68 pathogenesis via the inhibition of innate and adaptive immunity.

Complement-resistance mechanisms of bacteria

Despite more than a century of parallel research on bacteria and the complement system, relatively little is known of the mechanisms whereby pathogenic bacteria can escape complement-related opsonophagocytosis and direct killing. It is likely that pathogenicity in bacteria has arisen more accidentally than in viruses, and on the basis of selection from natural mutants rather than by outright stealing or copying of genetic codes from the host. In this review we will discuss complement resistance as one of the features that makes a bacterium a pathogen.

Functional characterization of soluble and membrane-bound forms of vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP)

Vaccinia virus secretes a 35 kD protein, vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP), that inhibits the classical and alternative pathways of complement at several points, indicating that it may be a viral analogue of human complement receptor type 1 (CR1; CD35). Structurally, however, CR1 is composed of 30 short consensus repeats (SCRs), whereas VCP consists entirely of four SCRs. We have begun a structure-function analysis of VCP to define the minimum number of SCRs necessary for function, the functional differences between VCP and CR1, and the potential therapeutic roles for VCP. We addressed these questions by creating and characterizing recombinant soluble and membrane-bound forms of VCP. We have determined that (1) VCP requires all four SCRs to bind C3b, (2) whereas CR1 binds C3b and iC3b, VCP binds C3b but not iC3b, and (3) although normally secreted, if expressed on the membrane of mammalian cells, VCP effectively protects the cells from complement-mediated lysis. Thus, VCP appears to be a compact and unique complement regulatory protein with the ability to inhibit both arms of the complement cascade, but lacking affinity for iC3b. By releasing rather than capturing iC3b-bearing complexes following inactivation of C3b, VCP may 'recycle' its active site locally among infected cells, and thereby enable the virus to evade more efficiently host immune and inflammatory responses. The unique function, compact structure, and capacity of VCP to protect mammalian cells from complement-mediated attack, suggests that it could be used both to better understand the structure-function relationship of complement regulatory proteins, in general, and also to rationally design and develop novel therapeutic agents.

Viral complement regulatory proteins

The inactivation of complement provides cells and tissues critical protection from complement-mediated attack and decreases the associated recruitment of other inflammatory mediators. In an attempt to evade the host immune response, viruses have evolved two mechanisms to acquire complement regulatory proteins. They can directly seize the host cell complement regulators onto their outer envelope and/or they can produce their own proteins which are either secreted into the neighboring intercellular space or expressed as membrane-bound proteins on the infected host cell. The following review will concentrate on the viral homologues of the mammalian complement regulatory proteins, specifically those containing complement control protein (CCP) repeats.

In Vitro Analysis of Complement-Dependent HIV-1 Cell Infection Using a Model System

Previous studies based on the use of human serum as a source of C have provided evidence for the C-dependent enhancement of cell infection by HIV-1. The present study was undertaken to distinguish C from other serum factors and to identify the proteins and the mechanisms involved in C-dependent cell infection by HIV-1. The classical C activation pathway was reconstituted from the proteins C1q, C1r, C1s, C4, C2, C3, factor H, and factor I; each were purified to homogeneity. A mixture of these proteins at physiological concentrations was shown to reproduce the ability of normal human serum to enhance the infection of MT2 cells by HIV-1 at low doses of virus. This enhancing effect was abolished when heat-inactivated serum and C2- or C3-depleted serum were used, and was restored upon addition of the corresponding purified proteins. A mixture of two synthetic peptides corresponding to positions 10–15 and 90–97 of human C receptor type 2 (CD21) as well as soluble CD4 both inhibited the C-dependent infection process. These data provide unambiguous evidence that HIV-1 triggers a direct activation of the classical C pathway in vitro and thereby facilitates the infection of MT2 cells at low doses of virus. These findings are consistent with a mechanism involving increased interaction between the virus opsonized by C3b-derived fragment(s) and the CD21 cell receptors and subsequent virus entry through CD4 receptors.

Subversion of cytokine networks by viruses

Viruses and the immune system have been competitors throughout their co-evolution. It is therefore not surprising that the viruses in circulation today possess a variety of strategies to counteract those aspects of the immune system that are involved in virus clearance. Examination of these virus encoded functions provides an important view of immune function and an appreciation of the complexity of the virus-host interaction. It is clear that viruses, seeking to subvert the immune system, have become adept in blocking the communication channels of the immune system. There are numerous examples of viral proteins that target the cytokine networks, disrupting the processes by which the delicately balanced immune system is regulated. This review focuses on the gene products of poxviruses, adenoviruses and herpesviruses that function primarily as immune-modulators.

Herpes simplex virus type 1 glycoprotein gC mediates immune evasion in vivo

Many microorganisms encode proteins that interact with molecules involved in host immunity; however, few of these molecules have been proven to promote immune evasion in vivo. Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) glycoprotein C (gC) binds complement component C3 and inhibits complement-mediated virus neutralization and lysis of infected cells in vitro. To investigate the importance of the interaction between gC and C3 in vivo, we studied the virulence of a gC-null strain in complement-intact and C3-deficient animals. Using a vaginal infection model in complement-intact guinea pigs, we showed that gC-null virus grows to lower titers and produces less severe vaginitis than wild-type or gC rescued virus, indicating a role for gC in virulence. To determine the importance of complement, studies were performed with C3-deficient guinea pigs; the results demonstrated significant increases in vaginal titers of gC-null virus, while wild-type and gC rescued viruses showed nonsignificant changes in titers. Similar findings were observed for mice where gC null virus produced significantly less disease than gC rescued virus at the skin inoculation site. Proof that C3 is important was provided by studies of C3 knockout mice, where disease scores of gC-null virus were significantly higher than in complement-intact mice. The results indicate that gC-null virus is approximately 100-fold (2 log10) less virulent that wild-type virus in animals and that gC-C3 interactions are involved in pathogenesis.

The inflammation modulatory protein (IMP) of cowpox virus drastically diminishes the tissue damage by down-regulating cellular infiltration resulting from complement activation

Vaccinia virus (VV) and other pathogenic poxviruses encode for a complement control protein. The VV complement control protein or VCP, was one of the first soluble microbial proteins postulated to have an active role in the immunomodulation of the host defense. Since then, 2 other poxviruses, including variola virus and cowpox virus (CPV), were found to have corresponding proteins. Based upon earlier studies which demonstrated the role of the CPV complement control protein in modulating the specific tissue responses in BALB/c and congenic-matched C5-sufficient and C5-deficient mice, the CPV equivalent has been renamed the inflammation modulatory protein (IMP), so as to specifically reflect its function. In this study, the in vivo cellular response of mice injected with CPV or a recombinant virus lacking the IMP sequence (CPV-IMP) was examined using a connective tissue air pouch model. Microscopic examination revealed that CPV-IMP caused a significant mononuclear cell infiltration into the connective tissue and adjacent dermal tissue of the skin. To characterize IMP's ability to regulate the observed cellular infiltration through both complement derived and non-complement derived chemotactic factors, footpad and skin connective tissue of C3 knockout mice and footpad of MIP-1alpha knockout mice received injections of CPV and CPV-IMP. In comparison to the matched control, significantly greater footpad specific swelling response was seen in C3 -/- mice injected with CPV. This indicates an important role for C3 in poxvirus pathogenesis. However, MIP-1 alpha -/- mice injected with CPV-IMP recovered earlier than mice injected with CPV alone. This indicates that the function of IMP in vivo in mice with a complete repertoire of immune components is to limit cellular infiltration by down regulating the complement derived chemotactic analphylotoxins, thereby modulating the inflammatory response contributing to a diminished tissue pathology and preservation of viral habitat.

Extracellular enveloped vaccinia virus is resistant to complement because of incorporation of host complement control proteins into its envelope

Vaccinia virus (VV) produces two antigenically and structurally distinct infectious virions, intracellular mature virus (IMV) and extracellular enveloped virus (EEV). Here we have investigated the resistance of EEV and IMV to neutralization by complement in the absence of immune antibodies. When EEV is challenged with complement from the same species as the cells used to grow the virus, EEV is resistant to neutralization by complement, whereas IMV is not. EEV resistance was not a result of EEV protein B5R, despite its similarity to proteins of the regulators of complement activation (RCA) family, or to any of the other EEV proteins tested (A34R, A36R, and A56R gene products). EEV was sensitive to complement when the virus was grown in one species and challenged with complement from a different species, suggesting that complement resistance might be mediated by host RCA incorporated into the EEV outer envelope. This hypothesis was confirmed by several observations: (i) immunoblot analysis revealed that cellular membrane proteins CD46, CD55, CD59, CD71, CD81, and major histocompatibility complex class I antigen were detected in purified EEV but not IMV; (ii) immunoelectron microscopy revealed cellular RCA on the surface of EEV retained on the cell surface; and (iii) EEV derived from rat cells expressing the human RCA CD55 or CD55 and CD59 were more resistant to human complement than EEV derived from control rat cells that expressed neither CD55 nor CD59. These data justify further analysis of the roles of these (and possible other) cellular proteins in EEV biology.

Interaction of Vaccinia Virus Complement Control Protein with Human Complement Proteins: Factor I-Mediated Degradation of C3b to iC3b1 Inactivates the Alternative Complement Pathway

Vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP) is a virulence determinant of vaccinia virus that helps protect the virus from the complement attack of the host. To characterize the interaction of VCP with C3 and C4 and understand the mechanism by which VCP inactivates complement, we have expressed VCP in a yeast expression system and compared the biologic activity of the purified protein to that of human factor H and complement receptor 1 (CR1). Recombinant VCP bound to C3 and the proteolytically cleaved form of C3 (C3b), but not to the 135,300-m.w. fragment of C3 generated using elastase (C3c) and the 35,000-m.w. fragment of C3 generated using elastase (C3d) and inhibited both the classical and alternative pathways of complement activation. Although rVCP was less effective at inhibiting the alternative pathway than factor H or CR1, it was more effective than factor H at inhibiting the classical pathway. Unlike factor H, rVCP was unable discriminate between alternative pathway-mediated lysis of rabbit and sheep E. A comparison of the cofactor activity in factor I-mediated cleavage of C3b suggested that in contrast to factor H and CR1, which displayed cofactor activity for the three sites, rVCP displayed cofactor activity primarily for the first site, leading to generation of C3b cleaved by factor I between Arg1281-Ser1282 (iC3b1). Its cofactor activity for C4b cleavages was similar to that of soluble complement receptor type 1. Purification and functional analysis of iC3b1 showed that it was unable to interact with factor B to form the alternative pathway C3 convertase, C3b,Bb. These results suggest that the interaction of VCP with C3 is different from that of factor H and CR1 and that VCP-supported first cleavage of C3b by factor I is sufficient to render C3b nonfunctional.

The genomic sequence analysis of the left and right species-specific terminal region of a cowpox virus strain reveals unique sequences and a cluster of intact ORFs for immunomodulatory and host range proteins

Sequencing and computer analysis of the left (52,283 bp) and right (49,649 bp) variable DNA regions of the cowpox virus strain GRI-90 (CPV-GRI) has revealed 51 and 37 potential open reading frames (ORFs), respectively. Comparison of the structure-function organization of these DNA regions of CPV-GRI with those previously published for corresponding regions of genomes of vaccinia virus, strains Copenhagen (VAC-COP) and Western Reserve (VAC-WR); and variola major virus, strains India-1967 (VAR-IND), Bangladesh-1975 (VAR-BSH); and alastrim variola minor virus, strain Garcia-1966 (VAR-GAR), was performed. Within the left terminal region under study, an extended DNA sequence (14,171 bp), unique to CPV, has been found. Within the right region of the CPV-GRI genome two segments, which are unique to CPV DNA (1579 and 3585 bp) have been found. Numerous differences have been revealed in the genetic structure of CPV-GRI DNA regions, homologous to fragments of the genomes of the above-mentioned orthopoxvirus strains. A cluster of ORFs with structural similarity ot immunomodulatory and host range function of other poxviruses have also been detected. A comparison of the sequences of ORF B, crmA, crmB, crmC, IMP, and CHO hr genes of CPV Brighton strain (CPV-BRI) with the corresponding genes in strain GRI-90 have revealed an identity at the amino acid level ranging from 82 to 96% between the two strains. The findings are significant in light of the recent demonstration of CPV as an important poxvirus model system to probe the precise in vivo role(s) of the unique virally encoded immunomodulatory proteins. Also, the presence of a complete and intact repertoire of immunomodulatory proteins, ring canal proteins family, and host range genes indicates that CPV may have been the most ancient of all studied orthopoxviruses.

Functional analysis of vaccinia virus B5R protein: essential role in virus envelopment is independent of a large portion of the extracellular domain

Vaccinia virus has two forms of infectious virions: the intracellular mature virus and the extracellular enveloped virus (EEV). EEV is critical for cell-to-cell and long-range spread of the virus. The B5R open reading frame (ORF) encodes a membrane protein that is essential for EEV formation. Deletion of the B5R ORF results in a dramatic reduction of EEV, and as a consequence, the virus produces small plaques in vitro and is highly attenuated in vivo. The extracellular portion of B5R is composed mainly of four domains that are similar to the short consensus repeats (SCRs) present in complement regulatory proteins. To determine the contribution of these putative SCR domains to EEV formation, we constructed recombinant vaccinia viruses that replaced the wild-type B5R gene with a mutated gene encoding a B5R protein lacking the SCRs. The resulting recombinant viruses produced large plaques, indicating efficient cell-to-cell spread in vitro, and gradient centrifugation of supernatants from infected cells confirmed that EEV was formed. In contrast, phalloidin staining of infected cells showed that the virus lacking the SCR domains was deficient in the induction of thick actin bundles. Thus, the highly conserved SCR domains present in the extracellular portion of the B5R protein are dispensable for EEV formation. This indicates that the B5R protein is a key viral protein with multiple functions in the process of virus envelopment and release. In addition, given the similarity of the extracellular domain to complement control proteins, the B5R protein may be involved in viral evasion from host immune responses.

Vaccinia virus immune evasion

Vaccinia virus and other poxviruses express a wide variety of proteins which are non-essential for virus replication in culture but help the virus to evade the host response to infection. Examples include proteins which oppose apoptosis, synthesise steroids, capture chemokines, counteract complement, interfere with interferon and intercept interleukins. This review provides an overview of such proteins, with an emphasis on work from our laboratory, and illustrates how the study of these proteins can increase our understanding of virus pathogenesis, the function of the immune system and how to make safer and more immunogenic poxvirus-based vaccines.

Complement and immunity to viruses

Complement is one of the first lines of host defence to be faced and countered by viruses as they struggle to establish an infection. As an important arm of the humoral immune response, the complement system is immediately ready to target and eliminate virus particles and to interact with the surface of virus-infected cells to mark them for destruction by other branches of the immune response. Nevertheless, some viruses are still very successful human pathogens. This article will discuss the role of complement in antiviral immunity, the mechanisms by which complement may be activated by viruses or virus-infected cells, and explore some of the strategies which viruses have evolved to subvert the immune response, including mechanisms by which complement activation may be prevented or aborted.

NMR studies of a viral protein that mimics the regulators of complement activation

Vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP) is a 243-residue protein that is similar in sequence to the regulators of complement activation; its role is to defend the virus against attack by the host complement system. A fragment of this protein spanning the two complement protein (CP)-modules (residues 126 to 243) which make up the C-terminal half of VCP has been expressed in Pichia pastoris. A 15N-labelled sample was purified for the purposes of structure determination and measurements of dynamics in solution using NMR. Structures were calculated on the basis of 1767 NMR-derived distance and angle restraints, with a longer than normal high-temperature simulated annealing (SA) protocol which improved convergence. The viral CP-modules are structurally very similar to the 15th and 16th CP-modules of human factor H (fH; average r.m.s.d., for invariant Trp and Cys, four pair-wise comparisons,=1.2 A) but less similar to the fifth CP-module of fH (average r.m.s.d.=2.2 A). In the VCP fragment, the orientation of one module with respect to the other is clearly defined by the experimental data, and T1 measurements are consistent with only limited flexibility at the module-module interface. The r.m.s.d. over all of the 118 residues (backbone atoms) is 0.73 A. The intermodular orientation is better defined than, and significantly different from, that observed in a CP-module pair from fH (re-calculated using the extended SA protocol). In VCP the long axis of the second module is tilted by 59(+/-4) degrees with respect to the first module (50(+/-13) degrees in the fH pair), and twisted with respect to the first module by 22(+/-6) degrees (223(+/-17) degrees in fH). The differences between the human and viral proteins may be rationalised in terms of the lack of hydrogen-bond stabilised secondary structure in the N-terminal portion of fH module 16, and the number and type of amino acid side-chains which make up the interface. A similar intermodular interface may be predicted between the third and fourth module of human C4 binding protein and, probably, between the third and fourth modules of the guinea pig acrosomal matrix protein 67; but the formulation of general rules for predicting the structure of interfaces between CP-modules awaits further experimental data.

The cowpox virus-encoded homolog of the vaccinia virus complement control protein is an inflammation modulatory protein

Vaccinia virus complement control protein (VCP) is encoded by vaccinia virus, with its homolog encoded by other pathogenic poxviruses including variola virus. Since rodents are the primary reservoir hosts of cowpox virus (CPV) and since CPV encodes a highly conserved functional homolog of VCP, termed here the inflammation modulatory protein (IMP), the effects of injection of CPV into the footpads of mice was determined in order to study the precise in vivo effects of IMP. Macroscopic examination of the site of injection with a recombinant virus lacking IMP (CPV-IMP) showed greater tissue damage, with more hemorrhage and induration, than sites injected with the wild-type cowpox virus. In addition, the measurement of the specific swelling response carried out for several weeks revealed significantly greater swelling in mice injected with CPV-IMP. Thus, IMP modulates the complement-activated inflammatory response in vivo. Furthermore, the diminished destruction of host tissue observed in the presence of IMP indicates symbiosis in which the virus ensures the preservation of surrounding host tissue, possibly to support the growth of its progeny.

Masters of deception: a review of herpesvirus immune evasion strategies

Herpesviruses have acquired a variety of different mechanisms to avoid the damaging effects of host immunity. Frequently, these viruses subvert normal immune regulatory functions utilized by the host. The focus of this review is upon herpesvirus genes encoding known or potential immunomodulatory proteins. Areas covered include inhibition of complement and antibody function, herpesvirus-encoded homologues of cytokines and chemokine receptors, and potential disruption of cellular recognition of virally infected targets.

Genetically engineered poxviruses for recombinant gene expression, vaccination, and safety

Vaccinia virus, no longer required for immunization against smallpox, now serves as a unique vector for expressing genes within the cytoplasm of mammalian cells. As a research tool, recombinant vaccinia viruses are used to synthesize and analyze the structure-function relationships of proteins, determine the targets of humoral and cell-mediated immunity, and investigate the types of immune response needed for protection against specific infectious diseases and cancer. The vaccine potential of recombinant vaccinia virus has been realized in the form of an effective oral wild-life rabies vaccine, although no product for humans has been licensed. A genetically altered vaccinia virus that is unable to replicate in mammalian cells and produces diminished cytopathic effects retains the capacity for high-level gene expression and immunogenicity while promising exceptional safety for laboratory workers and potential vaccine recipients.