Heterogeneity of type I diabetes: analysis of monozygotic twins in Great Britain and the United States

Extreme genetic risk for type 1A diabetes in the post-genome era

A series of genes and loci influencing the genetic risk of type 1A (immune-mediated) diabetes are now well characterized. These include genes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), polymorphisms 5' of the insulin gene, and PTPN22, as well as more recently defined loci from genome-wide association studies. By far the major determinants of risk for type 1A diabetes are genes within or linked to the MHC and in particular alleles of class II genes (HLA-DR, DQ, and DP). There is evidence that MHC class I alleles contribute and there are additional MHC-linked influences such that for a major subset of relatives of patients there is a risk as high as 80% for siblings, and for the general population a risk as high as 20% can be defined at birth just by analyzing the MHC. We believe the search for additional MHC loci will require analysis of the remarkable long-range identity (up to 9 million base pairs) of extended MHC haplotypes. Current prediction algorithms will likely be greatly improved for the general population when the additional contributing loci of the MHC are defined.

The natural history of type 1A diabetes

We can now predict the development of Type 1A (Immune Mediated) diabetes primarily through the determination of four biochemically characterized islet autoantibodies [insulin, GAD65, IA-2 (ICA512) and (Znt8)]. Prediction is possible because beta-cell destruction is chronically progressive and very slow in most, but not all individuals. We can also prevent type 1A diabetes in animal models and a major goal is the prevention of type 1A diabetes in man with multiple clinical trials underway.

SUMO4 and its role in type 1 diabetes pathogenesis

Susceptibility to type 1 diabetes (T1D) is determined by interactions of multiple genes with unknown environmental factors. Despite the characterization of over 20 susceptibility regions for T1D, identification of specific genes in these regions is still a formidable challenge. In 2004, we first reported the cloning of a novel, small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) gene, SUMO4, in the IDDM5 interval on chromosome 6q25, and presented strong genetic and functional evidence suggesting that SUMO4 is a T1D susceptibility gene. Subsequent studies have consistently confirmed this association in multiple Asian populations despite controversial observations in Caucasians. In this review, we will update the genetic evidence supporting SUMO4 as a T1D susceptibility gene and discuss the possible explanations for the discrepant associations observed in Caucasians. We will then discuss the mechanisms through which SUMO4 contributes to the pathogenesis of T1D.

Further evidence of a primary, causal association of the PTPN22 620W variant with type 1 diabetes

OBJECTIVE

The minor allele of the nonsynonymous single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) +1858C>T within the PTPN22 gene is positively associated with type 1 diabetes and other autoimmune diseases. Genetic and functional data underline its causal effect, but some studies suggest that this polymorphism does not entirely explain disease association of the PTPN22 region. The aim of this study was to evaluate type 1 diabetes association within this gene in the Sardinian population.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

We resequenced the exons and potentially relevant portions of PTPN22 and detected 24 polymorphisms (23 SNPs and 1 deletion insertion polymorphism [DIP]), 8 of which were novel. A representative set of 14 SNPs and the DIP were sequentially genotyped and assessed for disease association in 794 families, 490 sporadic patients, and 721 matched control subjects.

RESULTS

The +1858C>T variant, albeit rare in the general Sardinian population (allele frequency 0.014), was positively associated with type 1 diabetes (P(one tail) = 3.7 x 10(-3)). In contrast, the background haplotype in which this mutation occurred was common (haplotype frequency 0.117) and neutrally associated with disease. We did not confirm disease associations reported in other populations for non +1858C>T variants (rs2488457, rs1310182, and rs3811021), although they were present in appreciable frequencies in Sardinia. Additional weak disease associations with rare variants were detected in the Sardinian families but not confirmed in independent case-control sample sets and are most likely spurious.

CONCLUSIONS

We provide further evidence that the +1858C>T polymorphism is primarily associated with type 1 diabetes and exclude major contributions from other purportedly relevant variants within this gene.

Group B coxsackievirus diabetogenic phenotype correlates with replication efficiency

Group B coxsackieviruses can initiate rapid onset type 1 diabetes (T1D) in old nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice. Inoculating high doses of poorly pathogenic CVB3/GA per mouse initiated rapid onset T1D. Viral protein was detectable in islets shortly after inoculation in association with beta cells as well as other primary islet cell types. The virulent strain CVB3/28 replicated to higher titers more rapidly than CVB3/GA in the pancreas and in established beta cell cultures. Exchange of 5'-nontranslated regions between the two CVB3 strains demonstrated a variable impact on replication in beta cell cultures and suppression of in vivo replication for both strains. While any CVB strain may be able to induce T1D in prediabetic NOD mice, T1D onset is linked both to the viral replication rate and infectious dose.

14th International HLA and Immunogenetics Workshop: report on the HLA component of type 1 diabetes

The type 1 diabetes (T1D) component of the 13th International Histocompatibility Workshop (IHW) obtained microsatellite (msat) and human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DR/DQ data on case/control and family samples through an international collaboration. The aim was to detect the effects of susceptibility loci on the HLA complex independent of the primary determinants in the class II region (HLA-DR/DQ). As part of the activity of the 14th International HLA and Immunogenetics Workshop (14th IHIWS), a T1D workshop was held to present analyses of the 13th IHW data and to discuss the current status of knowledge about the genetics of T1D. These data are now available online through dbMHC, a web-based resource established by the National Center for Biotechnology. Continuing work since the 13th IHW has resulted in published work showing heterogeneity of DR3 haplotypes in data sets from the 13th IHW and Human Biological Data Interchange (HBDI). In addition, we identified markers that define DRB1*1501 DQB1*0602 haplotypes conferring reduced protection from diabetes in a Swedish 13th IHW data set. Further analyses of the 13th IHW data set not only showed some significant results but also demonstrated extensive heterogeneity reminiscent of non-HLA genes. The haplotype analysis in HBDI families identified two msats with significant effects on susceptibility and statistically significant age of onset effects at class III markers that are not because of linkage disequilibrium, with class I alleles known to affect age of onset. The above studies underscore the importance of refining our understanding of susceptibility associated with genes in the HLA complex.

Control of T Cell-mediated autoimmunity by metabolite flux to N-glycan biosynthesis

Autoimmunity is a complex trait disease where the environment influences susceptibility to disease by unclear mechanisms. T cell receptor clustering and signaling at the immune synapse, T cell proliferation, CTLA-4 endocytosis, T(H)1 differentiation, and autoimmunity are negatively regulated by beta1,6GlcNAc-branched N-glycans attached to cell surface glycoproteins. Beta1,6GlcNAc-branched N-glycan expression in T cells is dependent on metabolite supply to UDP-GlcNAc biosynthesis (hexosamine pathway) and in turn to Golgi N-acetylglucosaminyltransferases Mgat1, -2, -4, and -5. In Jurkat T cells, beta1,6GlcNAc-branching in N-glycans is stimulated by metabolites supplying the hexosamine pathway including glucose, GlcNAc, acetoacetate, glutamine, ammonia, or uridine but not by control metabolites mannosamine, galactose, mannose, succinate, or pyruvate. Hexosamine supplementation in vitro and in vivo also increases beta1,6GlcNAc-branched N-glycans in naïve mouse T cells and suppresses T cell receptor signaling, T cell proliferation, CTLA-4 endocytosis, T(H)1 differentiation, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis, and autoimmune diabetes in non-obese diabetic mice. Our results indicate that metabolite flux through the hexosamine and N-glycan pathways conditionally regulates autoimmunity by modulating multiple T cell functionalities downstream of beta1,6GlcNAc-branched N-glycans. This suggests metabolic therapy as a potential treatment for autoimmune disease.

Oxidative stress biology and cell injury during type 1 and type 2 diabetes mellitus

Diabetes mellitus (DM) affects approximately 170 million individuals worldwide and is expected to alter the lives of at least 366 million individuals within a future span of 25 years. Of even greater concern is the premise that these projections are underestimated since they assume obesity levels will remain constant. Type 1 insulin-dependent DM accounts for only 5-10 percent of all diabetics but represents a highly significant health concern, since this disorder begins early in life and leads to long-term complications. In contrast, Type 2 DM is recognized as the etiology of over 80 percent of all diabetics and is dramatically increasing in incidence as a result of changes in human behavior and increased body mass index. Yet, the pathological consequences of these disorders that involve the both the neuronal and vascular systems are intimately linked through the pathways that mediate oxidative stress. Here we highlight some of the relevant oxidative pathways that determine insulin resistance through reactive oxygen species, mitochondrial dysfunction, uncoupling proteins, and endoplasmic reticulum stress. These pathways are ultimately linked to protein kinase B (Akt) and the insulin signaling pathways that determine the initial onset of glucose intolerance and the subsequent course to apoptotic cell injury. Through the elucidation of these targets, improvement in current strategies as well as the development of future clinical applications can move forward for both the prevention and treatment of Type 1 and Type 2 DM.

TLR9-signaling pathways are involved in Kilham rat virus-induced autoimmune diabetes in the biobreeding diabetes-resistant rat

Viral infections are associated epidemiologically with the expression of type 1 diabetes in humans, but the mechanisms underlying this putative association are unknown. To investigate the role of viruses in diabetes, we used a model of viral induction of autoimmune diabetes in genetically susceptible biobreeding diabetes-resistant (BBDR) rats. BBDR rats do not develop diabetes in viral-Ab-free environments, but approximately 25% of animals infected with the parvovirus Kilham rat virus (KRV) develop autoimmune diabetes via a mechanism that does not involve beta cell infection. Using this model, we recently documented that TLR agonists synergize with KRV infection and increase disease penetrance. We now report that KRV itself activates innate immunity through TLR ligation. We show that KRV infection strongly stimulates BBDR splenocytes to produce the proinflammatory cytokines IL-6 and IL-12p40 but not TNF-alpha. KRV infection induces high levels of IL-12p40 by splenic B cells and Flt-3-ligand-induced bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (DCs) but only low levels of IL-12p40 production by thioglycolate-elicited peritoneal macrophages or GM-CSF plus IL-4-induced bone marrow-derived DCs. KRV-induced cytokine production is blocked by pharmacological inhibitors of protein kinase R and NF-kappaB. Genomic KRV DNA also induces BBDR splenocytes and Flt-3L-induced DCs from wild-type but not TLR9-deficient mice to produce IL-12p40; KRV-induced up-regulation of B lymphocytes can be blocked by TLR9 antagonists including inhibitory CpG and chloroquine. Administration of chloroquine to virus-infected BBDR rats decreases the incidence of diabetes and decreases blood levels of IL-12p40. Our data implicate the TLR9-signaling pathway in KRV-induced innate immune activation and autoimmune diabetes in the BBDR rat.

Mechanistic insights into diabetes mellitus and oxidative stress

Diabetes mellitus (DM) is a significant healthcare concern worldwide that affects more than 165 million individuals leading to cardiovascular disease, nephropathy, retinopathy, and widespread disease of both the peripheral and central nervous systems. The incidence of undiagnosed diabetes, impaired glucose tolerance, and impaired fasting glucose levels raises future concerns in regards to the financial and patient care resources that will be necessary to care for patients with DM. Interestingly, disease of the nervous system can become one of the most debilitating complications and affect sensitive cognitive regions of the brain, such as the hippocampus that modulates memory function, resulting in significant functional impairment and dementia. Oxidative stress forms the foundation for the induction of multiple cellular pathways that can ultimately lead to both the onset and subsequent complications of DM. In particular, novel pathways that involve metabotropic receptor signaling, protein-tyrosine phosphatases, Wnt proteins, Akt, GSK-3beta, and forkhead transcription factors may be responsible for the onset and progression of complications form DM. Further knowledge acquired in understanding the complexity of DM and its ability to impair cellular systems throughout the body will foster new strategies for the treatment of DM and its complications.

Altered monocyte cyclooxygenase response to lipopolysaccharide in type 1 diabetes

Type 1 diabetes is caused by adaptive immune responses, but innate immunity is important because monocytes infiltrate islets. Activated monocytes express cyclooxygenase (COX)-2, promoting prostaglandin-E(2) (PGE(2)) secretion, whereas COX-1 expression is constitutive. We aimed to define monocyte COX expression in type 1 diabetes basally and after lipopolysaccharide (LPS) stimulation. Isolated CD14(+) monocytes were analyzed for COX mRNA and protein expression from identical twins (discordant for type 1 diabetes) and control subjects. Basal monocyte COX mRNA, protein expression, and PGE(2) secretion were normal in type 1 diabetic subjects. After LPS, twins and control subjects showed a COX mRNA isoform switch with decreased COX-1 mRNA (P < 0.01), increased COX-2 mRNA (P < 0.01), and increased COX-2 protein expression (P < 0.01). Compared with control subjects, both diabetic and nondiabetic twins showed greater LPS-induced downregulation of monocyte COX-1 mRNA (P = 0.02), reduced upregulation of COX-2 mRNA and protein (P < 0.03), and greater inhibition by the COX-2 inhibitor di-isopropylfluorophosphate (DFP) of monocyte PGE(2) (P < 0.007). We demonstrate an alteration in monocyte COX mRNA expression as well as monocyte COX-2 and PGE(2) production after LPS in type 1 diabetic patients and their nondiabetic twins. Because COX-2 response to LPS is proinflammatory, an inherited reduced response would predispose to chronic inflammatory diseases such as type 1 diabetes.

The insulin gene in type 1 diabetes

Insulin is a key autoantigen in the autoimmune process leading to the development of type 1 diabetes. Recent studies in both humans and mice have shown that variation in the expression of the insulin gene, in the thymus rather than the pancreas, contributes to disease susceptibility by affecting self-tolerance to insulin. These findings have brought about a paradigm-shift in our understanding of self-tolerance and autoimmunity to molecules with tissue-restricted expression, which are often the target of autoimmune disease.

Putting the pieces of the puzzle together - a series of hypotheses on the etiology and pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes

This paper presents a series of 10 hypotheses on the etiology of type 1 diabetes. We begin with the hypothesis that wheat gluten is one of the elusive environmental triggers in type 1 diabetes. Habitual consumption of wheat gluten increases the intestinal synthesis of dipeptidyl peptidase IV. This enzyme helps to shape the repertoire of peptides released into the small intestine following the ingestion of wheat gluten by catalyzing the release of X-Pro dipeptides from the N-terminus of the proline-rich glutenins and gliadins in wheat gluten. The release of gluten-derived peptides causes the tight junctions of the small intestine to open through a zonulin-dependent mechanism, which allows these peptides to enter the lamina propria where they get presented as antigens by HLA-DQ, -DR and CD1d molecules. Binding of one or more gluten peptides by CD1d leads to abrogation of oral tolerance, and a marked increase in peripheral immune responses to wheat proteins. Furthermore, it is our contention, that in response to beta cell apoptosis during normal remodeling of the pancreas and CCL19/CCL21 expression within the pancreatic lymph nodes (PLNs), gluten-loaded dendritic cells migrate from the small intestine to the PLNs. These dendritic cells present gluten-derived antigens on the surface of the PLNs, which leads to migration of CD4(-)CD8(-) gammadelta and CD4(-)CD8(+) alphabeta T cells to the pancreas where they mediate Fas and perforin dependent cytotoxicity. We also hypothesize that at least one of the type 1 diabetes associated HLA-DR molecules that bind and present wheat-derived peptide(s) also bind and present an islet cell antigen(s), activating plasma cell synthesis of islet cell autoantibodies and irrevocable, complement-dependent destruction of islet cells. Our final two hypotheses state that type 1 diabetes morbidity is reduced in those areas of globe where genetically susceptible individuals get adequate amounts of vitamin D, in the diet and/or through exposure to sunlight, and in areas where people are exposed to bacterial, viral, or parasitic infections in early childhood.

Incomplete penetrance of susceptibility genes for MHC-determined immunoglobulin deficiencies in monozygotic twins discordant for type 1 diabetes

Incomplete intrinsic penetrance is the failure of some genetically susceptible individuals (e.g., monozygotic twins of those who have a trait) to exhibit that trait. For the first time, we examine penetrance of susceptibility genes for multiple MHC gene-determined traits in the same subjects. Serum levels of IgA, IgD, IgG3, but not IgG4, in 50 pairs of monozygotic twins discordant for type 1 diabetes (T1D) correlated more closely in the twins than in random paired controls. The frequencies of subjects deficient in IgA (6%), IgD (33%) and IgG4 (12%), but not in IgG3, were higher in the twins than in controls. We postulate that this was because the MHC haplotypes (and possible non-MHC genes) that predispose to T1D also carry susceptibility genes for certain immunoglobulin deficiencies. Immunoglobulin deficiencies were not associated with T1D. Pairwise concordance for the deficiencies in the twins was 50% for IgA, 57% for IgD and 50% for IgG4. There were no significant associations among the specific immunoglobulin deficiencies except that all IgA-deficient subjects had IgD deficiency. Thus, intrinsic penetrance is a random process independently affecting different MHC susceptibility genes. Because multiple different external triggers would be required to explain the results, differential environmental determinants appear unlikely.

Identical twins discordant for type 1 diabetes show a different pattern of in vitro CD56+ cell activation

BACKGROUND

Recent studies in animal models indicate a role for natural killer (NK) cells in the protection against type 1 diabetes. In humans, a reduction of NK cell numbers has been reported in identical twins discordant for type 1 diabetes, irrespective of whether they have the disease. Here we have tested whether the activation and expansion of human NK cells with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) reveals differences between these twins.

METHODS

Proportions of CD56(+) NK cells and T-cells and Va24Vb11(+) NK-T cells from diabetic and non-diabetic twins was assessed before and after activation using flow cytometry. NK receptor usage was monitored by PCR and flow cytometry.

RESULTS

The profile of the expressed Killer Cell immunoglobulin-like receptor (KIR) repertoire (using mRNA) in freshly isolated NK cells was identical in pairs of identical twins, despite marked variation among individual twins as well as controls. Basal numbers of CD56(+) and CD94(+) (CD3(-) and CD3(+)) cells and Valpha24(+)Vbeta11(+) NK-T cells were similarly strongly correlated between identical twins (p < 0.006 for all correlations). Following LPS stimulation, the pattern of KIR mRNA expression remained unaltered in twins and the proportion of NK cells and Valpha24(+)Vbeta11(+) NK-T cells remained correlated between pairs of twins. However, there was a significant reduction in the proportion of CD56(+) cells and CD94(+) cells (whether defined as CD3(-) or CD3(+)) responding to LPS in the diabetic compared to the non-diabetic twin (p = 0.031 and 0.025, respectively).

CONCLUSION

This reduction in NK cell expansion in response to LPS in patients with type 1 diabetes is consistent with a non-genetically determined alteration in the innate immune response either predisposing to or resulting from the disease.

HLA Class II molecules on haplotypes associated with type 1 diabetes exhibit similar patterns of binding affinities for coxsackievirus P2C peptides

Enteroviruses such as coxsackievirus B4 (CVB4) are proposed as possible environmental triggers or accelerants of the autoimmune process that leads to type 1 diabetes mellitus. One putative mechanism to account for this association is mimicry between virus components and islet autoantigens. Particular interest has focused on the CVB4 non-structural protein P2C, which we previously showed to be a major target of the effector memory anti-CVB4 CD4 T-cell response, and which harbours a region of sequence similarity with the islet autoantigen, glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD65). Since several distinct human leucocyte antigen (HLA) Class II molecules are associated with development of type 1 diabetes, we hypothesized that for functional mimicry to be important, any potential region(s) of mimicry in P2C should bind to each of these susceptibility molecules. In the present study therefore we examined the affinity of 20-mer overlapping P2C peptides for soluble HLA-DR4, -DR3, -DQ2 and -DQ8. We identified one discrete region of P2C with high binding affinities for all of these HLA Class II molecules. Moreover, the binding affinity of P2C peptides was significantly correlated between HLA molecules present on the same susceptibility haplotype (e.g. DR4 and DQ8, P =0.0076; DR3 and DQ2 P = 0.002). We conclude that possession of these haplotypes favours restricted presentation of viral epitopes, and speculate that this could promote the potential for mimicry between microbial proteins and islet autoantigens.

Multifaceted therapeutic approaches for a multigenic disease

Diabetes is a severe chronic disease that affects approximately 200 million individuals worldwide, with extremely debilitating effects and considerably high health care costs. The two major classes of diabetes, known as type 1 (previously known as insulin-dependent or juvenile-onset diabetes) and type 2 (non-insulin-dependent diabetes), share common symptoms such as hyperglycemia and the development of long-term complications, but they differ in many aspects, including their etiopathogenesis. New insights suggest that overlapping factors, formerly considered typical hallmarks of each specific type, can coexist in the same diabetic patient, making it difficult to support a sharp distinction between the two classes and, more importantly, to adopt appropriate therapeutic solutions. In type 1 and type 2 diabetic subjects, but even more in patients with combined types, multiple genetic factors play a role in determining susceptibility or resistance to the disease, and perhaps also the time of onset, the severity of the symptoms, the possibility of developing complications and, ultimately, the response to therapy. In this review, the therapeutic treatments currently under investigation, as well as the curative strategies envisioned for future applications, are reanalyzed considering the multifaceted and complex aspects of a continuum that can be just defined as "diabetes."

The role of HLA class I gene variation in autoimmune diabetes

The use of DNA-based genetic typing has enabled the identification of type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) susceptible and protective major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II alleles and haplotypes. The application of this approach has also progressed to locate MHC class I alleles that contribute to the clinicopathology of T1DM. Recent studies have shown a widespread involvement of genes from the MHC class I gene region in the clinicopathology of T1DM. These genes are shown to be involved in contributing to progression from the preclinical stage of the disease, which is characterized by the occurrence of islet-specific antibodies, to clinical disease and also to the occurrence of autoimmunity. They can either contribute directly to disease development or indirectly in concert with other susceptible MHC class II alleles or haplotypes via linkage disequilibrium. Class I alleles may also be negatively associated with T1DM. These findings are useful for the development of future strategies in designing tolerogenic approaches for the prevention or even reversal of T1DM. In this article, the latest evidence for the different kinds of participation of HLA class I genes in the etiology of T1DM is reviewed. A meta-analysis which included existing association studies was also carried out in order to re-assess the relevance of class I genes in diabetes development. The analysis of an enlarged heterogeneous sample confirmed the involvement of previously detected serotypes in the etiology of T1DM, such as A24, B8 and B18, and revealed hitherto unknown associations with B60 and B62. The analysis points out that much of the conflicting results of previous association studies originate from inadequate sample sizes and accentuate the value of future investigations of larger samples for identifying linkage in multigenic diseases.

The stages of type 1A diabetes: 2005

Type 1A diabetes is a chronic autoimmune disease usually preceded by a long prodrome during which autoantibodies to islet autoantigens are present. These antibodies are directed to a variety of antigens, but the best characterized are glutamic acid decarboxylase-65, insulinoma-associated antigen-2, and insulin. We hypothesize that the natural history of type 1A diabetes can be represented by several stages, starting from genetic susceptibility and ending in complete beta-cell destruction and overt diabetes. Type 1A diabetes probably results from a balance between genetic susceptibility and environmental influences. In both humans and animal models, the major determinants of the disease are genes within the major histocompatibility complex. The next best-characterized susceptibility locus is the insulin gene, the variable nucleotide tandem repeat locus. This gene affects the expression of insulin in the thymus and thus may play a role in the modulation of tolerance to this molecule. In a subset of genetically susceptible individuals, the activation of autoimmunity may be triggered by environmental factors such as viruses and/or diet. However, no conclusive association has been established between type 1A diabetes and specific environmental triggers. In this review, we provide evidence that insulin has a fundamental role in anti-islet autoimmunity.

Genetic analysis of families with autoimmune diabetes and thyroiditis: evidence for common and unique genes

CONTEXT

Epidemiological data suggest a common genetic susceptibility to type 1 diabetes (T1D) and autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD).

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to identify the joint susceptibility genes for T1D and AITD.

DESIGN

We conducted a family-based linkage and association study.

SETTING

The study took place at an academic medical center.

PARTICIPANTS

Participants included 55 multiplex families (290 individuals) in which T1D and AITD clustered (T1D-AITD families).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

We conducted tests for linkage and family-based associations (transmission disequilibrium test) with four candidate genes: human leukocyte antigen (HLA), cytotoxic T lymphocyte-associated antigen 4 (CTLA-4), insulin variable number of tandem repeats (VNTR), and thyroglobulin.

RESULTS

Linkage evidence to HLA appeared when subjects with either T1D or AITD were considered affected [maximum LOD score (MLS), 2.2]. The major HLA haplotype contributing to the shared susceptibility was DR3-DQB1*0201, with DR3 conferring most of the shared risk. The CTLA-4 gene showed evidence for linkage only when individuals with both T1D and AITD were considered affected (MLS, 1.7), and the insulin VNTR showed evidence for linkage when individuals with either T1D or AITD were considered affected (MLS, 1.9); i.e. it may contribute to the familial aggregation of T1D and AITD.

CONCLUSIONS

The HLA class II locus contributes to the shared risk for T1D and AITD, and the major HLA haplotype contributing to this association is DR3-DQB1*0201. Additional non-HLA loci contribute to the joint susceptibility to T1D and AITD, and two potential candidates include the CTLA-4 and insulin VNTR loci.

The challenge of type 1 diabetes mellitus

Diabetes mellitus is a heterogeneous group of diseases characterized by high blood glucose levels due to defects in insulin secretion, insulin action, or both. With the number of cases expected to increase rapidly in the years to come, diabetes is a growing health challenge worldwide. Of the approximately 16 million diabetics in the United States, about 1.5 million suffer from type 1 diabetes. In this catabolic disorder afflicting predominantly young individuals, blood insulin is almost completely absent, leading to hyperglycemia and alterations in lipid metabolism. Type 1 diabetes is thought to be induced by a toxic or infectious insult that occurs in genetically predisposed individuals. With recent advances in the understanding of the involved immunology and cellular and molecular mechanisms, researchers strive to battle the disease with new preventive and corrective strategies.

Rat models of type 1 diabetes: genetics, environment, and autoimmunity

For many years, the vast amount of data gathered from analysis of nonobese diabetic (NOD) and congenic NOD mice has eclipsed interest in the rat for the study of type 1 diabetes. The study of rat models has continued, however, and recently there has been a reanimation of interest for several reasons. First, genetic analysis of the rat has accelerated. Ian4L1, cblb, and Iddm4 are now known to play major roles in rat autoimmunity. Second, rats are amenable to study the interactions of genetics and environment that may be critical for disease expression in humans. Environmental perturbants that predictably enhance the expression of rat autoimmune diabetes include viral infection, toll-like receptor ligation, and depletion of regulatory T cell populations. Finally, data generated in the rat have correctly predicted the outcome of several human diabetes prevention trials, notably the failure of nicotinamide and low dose parenteral and oral insulin therapies.

HLA and disease

Association of HLA and diseases is well known. Several population studies are available suggesting evidence of association of HLAs in more than 40 diseases. HLA found across various populations vary widely. Some of the reasons attributed for such variation are occurrence of social stratification based on geography, language and religion, consequences of founder effect, racial admixture or selection pressure due to environmental factors. Hence certain HLA alleles that are predominantly associated with disease susceptibility or resistance in one population may or may not show any association in other populations for the same disease. Despite of these limitations, HLA associations are widely studied across the populations worldwide and are found to be important in prediction of disease susceptibility, resistance and of evolutionary maintenance of genetic diversity. This review consolidates the HLA data on some prominent autoimmune and infectious diseases among various ethnic groups and attempts to pinpoint differences in Indian and other population.

No evidence for genetically determined alteration in insulin secretion or sensitivity predisposing to type 1 diabetes: a study of identical twins

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether inherited changes in insulin secretion or sensitivity could predispose to type 1 diabetes, we studied identical twins of type 1 diabetic patients.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

We studied prospectively a consecutive series of 27 identical twins of patients with type 1 diabetes who were initially nondiabetic, as well as 14 control subjects, over a period of 18 years. Of these 27 twins, 15 remain nondiabetic (now estimated at low disease risk) and 12 developed diabetes (pre-diabetic twins). Subjects were tested when not diabetic on at least two occasions with an intravenous glucose tolerance test (IVGTT), and we estimated insulin secretion as first-phase insulin response (FPIR), glucose clearance (K(g)), and insulin sensitivity both by homeostasis model assessment of insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) and relative to insulin response by the basal HOMA-IR-to-FPIR ratio.

RESULTS

Twins now at low risk and control subjects had similar fasting blood glucose and insulin levels, FPIR, K(g), HOMA-IR, and HOMA-IR-to-FPIR ratio. In contrast, pre-diabetic twins compared with control twins had higher fasting insulin levels (10.3 +/- 6.0 vs. 4.6 +/- 4.0 mIU/ml), lower FPIR (245 +/- 129 vs. 796 +/- 622 mIU . ml(-1) . 10 min(-1)), lower K(g) (1.5 +/- 0.6 vs. 2.6 +/- 0.8% per min), and higher HOMA-IR-to-FPIR ratio (0.007 +/- 0.005 vs. 0.001 +/- 0.0009) (all P < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

These observations in low-risk nondiabetic identical twins failed to identify a familial alteration in either insulin secretion or sensitivity predisposing to type 1 diabetes.

Functional polymorphism in Z-DNA-forming motif of promoter of SLC11A1 gene and type 1 diabetes in Japanese subjects: association study and meta-analysis

The association of the polymorphism of the Z-DNA-forming repeats in the promoter region of SLC11A1 (solute carrier family 11 member 1), formerly designated NRAMP1 (natural resistance associated macrophage protein 1), with type 1 diabetes was studied in a total of 244 Japanese subjects. Three alleles were detected in Japanese subjects. In diabetic patients, allele 2 was less frequent and allele 3 was more frequent, albeit not significantly, than in control subjects. Allele 2 was significantly ( P < .024) less frequent whereas allele 3 was more, albeit not significantly, frequent in the younger onset group than in the control subjects. In patients with a susceptible HLA allele, DRB1*0405 or DRB1*0901 , the frequency of allele 2 was significantly ( P < .013) lower and that of allele 3 tended to be higher than that in patients without either DRB1*0405 or DRB1*0901 . The protective effect of allele 2 against type 1 diabetes and other autoimmune diseases was confirmed by meta-analysis (summary odds ratio, 0.71, 95% confidence interval, 0.53-0.96). Because allele 2 was shown to be associated with low expression of SLC11A1 and protection against another autoimmune disease, rheumatoid arthritis, the negative association of allele 2 with autoimmune type 1 diabetes in the present study suggests that a less active immune system in subjects with allele 2 may protect individuals from autoimmune diseases.

TLR activation synergizes with Kilham rat virus infection to induce diabetes in BBDR rats

Virus infection is hypothesized to be an important environmental "trigger" of type 1 diabetes in humans. We used the BBDR rat model to investigate the relationship between viral infection and autoimmune diabetes. BBDR rats are diabetes-free in viral Ab-free housing, but the disease develops in approximately 30% of BBDR rats infected with Kilham rat virus (KRV) through a process that does not involve infection of pancreatic beta cells. Pretreatment with polyinosinic-polycytidylic (poly(I:C)), a ligand of TLR3, acts synergistically to induce diabetes in 100% of KRV-infected rats. The mechanisms by which KRV induces diabetes and TLR3 ligation facilitates this process are not clear. In this study, we demonstrate that activation of the innate immune system plays a crucial role in diabetes induction. We report that multiple TLR agonists synergize with KRV infection to induce diabetes in BBDR rats, as do heat-killed Escherichia coli or Staphylococcus aureus (natural TLR agonists). KRV infection increases serum IL-12 p40 in a strain-specific manner, and increases IL-12 p40, IFN-gamma-inducible protein-10, and IFN-gamma mRNA transcript levels, particularly in the pancreatic lymph nodes of BBDR rats. Infection with vaccinia virus or H-1 parvovirus induced less stimulation of the innate immune system and failed to induce diabetes in BBDR rats. Our results suggest that the degree to which the innate immune system is activated by TLRs is important for expression of virus-induced diabetes in genetically susceptible hosts.

Expression of beta-cell autoimmunity does not differ between potential dizygotic twins and siblings of patients with type 1 diabetes

Twin studies help to elucidate the contribution of genes and environment to type 1 diabetes (T1DM). The Diabetes Prevention Trial-1 (DPT-1) tested for anti-islet autoantibodies: 34,765 non-diabetic non-twin siblings of patients with T1DM, and 896 non-diabetic potential twins of patients with T1DM. Zygosity (being monozygotic [MZ] or dizygotic [DZ]) was unknown except for 357 non-diabetic subjects with opposite gender to their diabetic twin, who must be DZ. Expression of cytoplasmic islet cell (ICA), GAD65, ICA512 and insulin autoantibodies in 357 different-sex (DZ) potential non-diabetic twins of T1DM patients was, respectively, 4.5%, 4.7%, 3.0% and 2.4%, which was lower than in 539 same-sex potential non-diabetic twins (including MZ and DZ) of T1DM patients for ICA (7.8%, p < 0.05), GAD65 (13.4%, p < 0.0001) and ICA512 (6.5%, p < 0.03). In contrast, expression of ICA, GAD65, ICA512 and insulin autoantibodies was not significantly different in different-sex (DZ) potential twins versus all siblings (respectively, 4.2%, 4.8%, 2.2%, 2.5%), different-sex siblings (3.9%, 4.9%, 2.2%, 2.5%) or same-sex siblings (4.4%, 4.7%, 2.2%, 2.5%) of T1DM patients. In conclusion, anti-islet autoimmunity is not increased in non-diabetic DZ twins of T1DM patients compared to non-diabetic siblings of T1DM patients, suggesting that the greater environmental sharing by twins does not increase risk of anti-islet autoimmunity.

Coxsackievirus B3 infection and type 1 diabetes development in NOD mice: insulitis determines susceptibility of pancreatic islets to virus infection

Group B coxsackieviruses (CVB) are believed to trigger some cases of human type 1 diabetes (T1D), although the mechanism by which this may occur has not been shown. We demonstrated previously that inoculation of young nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice with any of several different CVB strains reduced T1D incidence. We also observed no evidence of CVB replication within islets of young NOD mice, suggesting no role for CVB in T1D induction in the NOD mouse model. The failure to observe CVB replication within islets of young NOD mice has been proposed to be due to interferon expression by insulin-producing beta cells or lack of expression of the CVB receptor CAR. We found that CAR protein is detectable within islets of young and older NOD mice and that a CVB3 strain, which expresses murine IL-4, can replicate in islets. Mice inoculated with the IL-4 expressing CVB3 chimeric strain were better protected from T1D onset than were mock-infected control mice despite intraislet viral replication. Having demonstrated that CVB can replicate in healthy islets of young NOD mice when the intraislet environment is suitably altered, we asked whether islets in old prediabetic mice were resistant to CVB infection. Unlike young mice in which insulitis is not yet apparent, older NOD mice demonstrate severe insulitis in all islets. Inoculating older prediabetic mice with different pathogenic CVB strains caused accelerated T1D onset relative to control mice, a phenomenon that was preceded by detection of virus within islets. Together, the results suggest a model for resolving conflicting data regarding the role of CVB in human T1D etiology.

The effect of innate immunity on autoimmune diabetes and the expression of Toll-like receptors on pancreatic islets

Viral infections have previously been implicated as a trigger of autoimmune diabetes. In this study, we compared a viral mimic with other microbial components derived from bacteria in triggering diabetes development in C57BL/6-rat insulin promoter-B7.1 mice that do not normally develop diabetes. It is striking that only the viral mimic induced the development of diabetes in our model system. Further mechanistic studies suggest that diabetes is induced, in part, by the combination of direct recognition of this virus-like stimulus by pancreatic islets through the expression of the innate immune receptor, Toll-like receptor 3. In addition, the functions of APCs are up-regulated, and this could stimulate islet Ag-reactive T cells that will attack beta cells leading to autoimmune diabetes.

Autoimmune diabetes and the circle of tolerance

The concept of immunological tolerance is central to our understanding of type 1 diabetes and the development of strategies for its prediction, prevention, and cure. Tolerance simply refers to the absence of an immune response. Most of us are born with an immune system that develops tolerance to all the other systems of our bodies as well as to the things that we eat. It is the loss of immunological tolerance that leads to autoimmunity. And when that autoimmune response directly or indirectly targets the beta-cell, type 1 diabetes is the result. In the U.S., 1 in 600 of us loses tolerance to pancreatic beta-cells. Interference with T-cell function after the loss of tolerance, as can be achieved with immunosuppressive drugs like cyclosporin, arrests the disease, but the cost in side effects is high. Clearly, stopping the loss of tolerance would be preferable. If we can stop the loss of tolerance, we can prevent the disease. We and many others have investigated both approaches. But what of the people who already have diabetes? For them a separate but related strategy, tolerance induction, is required. Specifically, islet transplantation tolerance induction holds out the promise of being able to cure the disease. This has been the ultimate goal of our laboratory's work for the past two decades.

Insulin autoimmunity: immunogenetics/immunopathogenesis of type 1A diabetes

We can now predict the development of type 1A diabetes in humans and prevent the disorder in animal models, but we cannot at present safely prevent type 1A diabetes in humans, although a series of clinical trials are under way and planned. A major lack in our current trial design is the inability to measure T lymphocytes directly responsible for beta cell destruction. Given the immunogenetics of type 1A diabetes and increasing knowledge of pathogenesis in the NOD mouse, we believe the disorder results from immune reactivity to a limited set of islet peptides, with reactivity to insulin a major determinant of disease. Insulin autoantibodies precede the development of diabetes in both humans and the NOD mouse. T lymphocytes isolated from the islets of the NOD mouse that recognize insulin peptide B:9-23 can transfer diabetes. Insulin expression within the thymus is correlated with genetic susceptibility, and insulin peptides can be used to induce diabetes and as an immunologic vaccine to prevent the disorder. Nevertheless, at present, routine measurement of anti-insulin T lymphocytes is not standardized. Better assays to monitor such autoreactivity are likely to be essential for the development and evaluation of preventive therapies.

Enteroviruses and type 1 diabetes

The development of type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) has been linked to exposure to environmental triggers, with Enteroviruses (EV) historically considered the prime suspects. Early serological studies suggested a link between EV infections and the development of T1DM and, though controversial, have been bolstered by more recent studies using more sensitive techniques such as direct detection of the EV genome by RT-PCR in peripheral blood. In this review, we consider the weight of evidence that EV can be considered a candidate trigger of T1DM, using three major criteria: (1) is EV infection associated with clinical T1DM, (2) can EV trigger the development of autoimmunity and (3) what would explain the putative association?

Genetics of type 1A (immune mediated) diabetes

Type 1A (immune mediated) diabetes is genetically heterogeneous with important examples for man and animal models with major mutations (autosomal recessive and X-linked recessive) identified as well as oligogenic/polygenic inheritance. For the most common forms of type 1A diabetes alleles of DQ and DR within the major histocompatibility complex are important determinants of disease and allow identification of high risk individuals at birth. Further understanding of both common and rare genetic determinants of type 1A diabetes will contribute to understanding the pathogenesis of diabetes and of autoimmunity.

Prediabetes in children: natural history, diagnosis, and preventive strategies

The clinical manifestation of type 1 diabetes mellitus is preceded by an asymptomatic prodromal period called prediabetes or preclinical diabetes. It may last from a few months to several years, during which the autoimmune destruction of the insulin-producing beta-cells in the pancreas progresses. The genes on the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) and insulin gene region are major genetic determinants for genetic disease susceptibility, while dietary compounds and viral infections are the most likely environmental factors contributing to the etiopathogenesis. T cells are thought to be the effector cells for the beta-cell destruction, and glutamic acid decarboxylase, insulinoma-associated protein 2 and insulin represent the three major autoantigens. Autoantibodies are early detectable markers of an ongoing disease process and are used to diagnose prediabetes. Among first-degree relatives of patients with type 1 diabetes, the risk for clinical disease can be graded from <5% in those with one or no antibodies to >90% in individuals who carry the HLA-DQB1*02/0302 risk genotype and are positive for multiple autoantibodies. beta-Cell function may also be tested in autoantibody-positive individuals and low first-phase insulin response is highly predictive for rapid progression to the clinical disease. However, dynamic course and individual variation of the disease process complicates the disease prediction, and it is not known whether all individuals with signs of prediabetes will inevitably progress to clinical type 1 diabetes. Until clinically applicable prevention for the condition exists, the screening for the risk markers of type 1 diabetes should actively be undertaken only in the context of research projects. Several major national and international multicenter studies are ongoing to test the potential of various agents (e.g. insulin and nicotinamide) or early elimination of dietary compounds (e.g. cow's milk proteins) to delay or prevent the onset of clinical type 1 diabetes.

Genetic epidemiology of type 1 diabetes

Family and twin studies indicate that a substantial fraction of susceptibility to type 1 diabetes is attributable to genetic factors. These and other epidemiologic studies also implicate environmental factors as important triggers. Although the specific environmental factors that contribute to immune-mediated diabetes remain unknown, several of the relevant genetic factors have been identified using two main approaches: genome-wide linkage analysis and candidate gene association studies. This article reviews the epidemiology of type 1 diabetes, the relative merits of linkage and association studies, and the results achieved so far using these two approaches. Prospects for the future of type 1 diabetes genetics research are considered.

Genetic liability of type 1 diabetes and the onset age among 22,650 young Finnish twin pairs: a nationwide follow-up study

Finland has the world's highest incidence of type 1 diabetes, and it is steadily increasing. We determined concordance rates and estimated heritability for type 1 diabetes in the Finnish Twin Cohort, a population-based twin cohort of 22,650 twin pairs. In addition, we studied age of onset in the first affected twin and discordance time between concordant twin pairs. Finnish twins born between 1958 and 1986 were followed for type 1 diabetes until 1998. We identified 228 twin pairs with type 1 diabetes: 44 monozygotic (MZ), 183 dizygotic (DZ), and 1 pair with unknown zygosity. The pairwise concordance for type 1 diabetes was 27.3% (95% CI 22.8-31.8) in MZ and 3.8% (2.7-4.9) in DZ twins. The probandwise concordance was 42.9% (26.7-59.2) and 7.4% (2.2-12.6), respectively. The longest discordance times were 6.9 years among concordant MZ twins and 23.6 years among DZ twins. The risk for type 1 diabetes was highest in cotwins of the index twins diagnosed at a very young age. The model with additive genetic and individual environmental effects was the best-fitting liability model, with 88% of phenotypic variance due to genetic factors and the remaining variance due to unshared environmental factors. In conclusion, these nationwide twin data demonstrated high genetic liability for type 1 diabetes. Early-onset diabetes increases the risk in cotwins. However, the majority of affected MZ twin pairs remain discordant for type 1 diabetes.

A role for innate immunity in type 1 diabetes?

Two arms of the immune system, innate and adaptive immunity, differ in their mode of immune recognition. The innate immune system recognizes a few highly conserved structures on a broad range of microorganisms. On the other hand, recognition of self or autoreactivity is generally confined to the adaptive immune response. Whilst autoimmune features are relatively common, they should be distinguished from autoimmune disease that is infrequent. Type 1 diabetes is an immune-mediated disease due to the destruction of insulin secreting cells mediated by aggressive immune responses, including activation of the adaptive immune system following genetic and environmental interaction. Hypotheses for the cause of the immune dysfunction leading to type 1 diabetes include self-reactive T-cell clones that (1) escape deletion in the thymus, (2) escape from peripheral tolerance or (3) escape from homeostatic control with an alteration in the immune balance leading to autoimmunity. Evidence, outlined in this review, raises the possibility that changes in the innate immune system could lead to autoimmunity, by either priming or promoting aggressive adaptive immune responses. Hostile microorganisms are identified by genetically determined surface receptors on innate effector cells, thereby promoting clearance of these invaders. These innate effectors include a few relatively inflexible cell populations such as monocytes/macrophages, dendritic cells (DC), natural killer (NK) cells, natural killer T (NKT) cells and gammadelta T cells. Recent studies have identified abnormalities in some of these cells both in patients with type 1 diabetes and in those at risk of the disease. However, it remains unclear whether these abnormalities in innate effector cells predispose to autoimmune disease. If they were to do so, then modulation of the innate immune system could be of therapeutic value in preventing immune-mediated diseases such as type 1 diabetes.

Molecular aspects of type 1 diabetes

Type 1 diabetes is a T cell mediated autoimmune disease, characterised by the selective destruction of pancreatic beta cells, and susceptibility is determined by a combination of genetic and environmental factors. The environmental agents implicated include viruses and dietary factors, although none has yet been shown to be directly responsible for triggering beta cell autoimmunity. The genetic factors that influence disease risk have been subjected to more intensive study and two gene regions of major importance have been identified: the human leucocyte antigen locus and the insulin gene. This review will focus on the mechanisms by which these genes might influence the risk of developing type 1 diabetes.

Modulation of insulitis and type 1 diabetes by transgenic HLA-DR3 and DQ8 in NOD mice lacking endogenous MHC class II

To evaluate the contributions of DR3 and DQ8 to the etiopathogenesis of type 1 diabetes in a diabetes-predisposing milieu, we developed human leukocyte antigen (HLA) transgenic mice on the nonobese diabetic (NOD) background in the absence of the endogenous class II molecule, I-A(g7) and studied the incidence of both spontaneous and experimental (induced) autoimmune diabetes. Transgenic expression of HLA-DR3 and -DQ8 (either alone or in combination) did not confer susceptibility to spontaneous or cyclophosphamide-induced type 1 diabetes. Expression of I-A(g7) was mandatory for development of spontaneous or cyclophosphamide-induced diabetes. However, multiple low doses of streptozotocin could induce diabetes in all groups of mice independent of the class II molecules expressed. In unmanipulated mice, only islets from I-A(g7+/+) mice revealed significant intra-islet infiltration. Although a characteristic peri-insulitis/peri-ductulitis was present in Abeta(0)/NOD mice, islets from DR3, DQ8 and DR3 x DQ8 double transgenic mice demonstrated significantly less infiltration. In conclusion, transgenic expression of HLA-DR3 and -DQ8 associated with predisposition to type 1 diabetes alone is not sufficient to induce spontaneous diabetes in NOD mice lacking endogenous class II molecules.

Islet abnormalities in the pathogenesis of autoimmune diabetes

Type 1 diabetes mellitus is a T-cell-mediated autoimmune disease that results in the destruction of the insulin-producing beta cells in the pancreatic islets of Langerhans. In spite of extensive genetic and immunological studies, mainly performed in the non-obese diabetic (NOD) spontaneous mouse model, the etiology of the autoimmune attack remains unknown. Several autoantigens have been identified and numerous studies have suggested a role for defective regulation of immune function. However, this account does not explain why the autoimmune process specifically affects the insulin-producing beta cells. Thus, abnormal immune regulation might explain the predisposition to autoimmunity in general, but additional factors should then determine the target of the autoimmune attack. Here, we review the evidence that abnormalities in islet cell differentiation and function exist that might trigger the immune system towards beta-cell autoimmunity in humans and NOD mice.