Sensitivity of the vitellogenin assay to diagnose exposure of fathead minnows to 17α-ethynylestradiol

Highly sensitive lateral flow immunoassays based on Ag@Au nanoflowers with marine medaka (Oryzias melastigm) vitellogenin as a target analyte

In order to improve the sensitivity of lateral flow immunoassays (LFIAs) for the detection of piscine vitellogenin (Vtg), a well-established biomarker for environmental estrogens, Au coated Ag nanoflowers (Ag@Au NFs) were used as labeling probes to develop a LFIA for marine medaka Vtg. The synthesized Ag@Au NFs with good monodispersity had an average diameter of 44.1 nm and absorbance peak of 524 nm. When the concentration of goat anti-mouse IgG and anti-Vtg polyclonal antibody (anti-Vtg PAbs) were 1.3 and 0.4 mg/mL, respectively, the detection range of the LFIA was 0.19-25 ng/mL, and the visual detection limit was 0.1 ng/mL, which was approximately 80 times lower than that of LFIAs based on other nanoparticles (Au NPs, Ag NPs, Au NFs, and FM). After evaluation of its specificity and robustness, the usefulness of Ag@Au NFs labeled LFIA was validated by measuring Vtg induction in the plasma of marine medaka exposed to bisphenol A, a weak estrogenic chemical. This highly sensitive lateral flow immunoassay could detect Vtg biomarker within 15 min without the need of expensive and complicated instruments, and thus offered an ultrasensitive and robust on-site detection method for estrogenic activity in field environment.

Putative adverse outcome pathway development based on physiological responses of female fathead minnows to model estrogen versus androgen receptor agonists

Several adverse outcome pathways (AOPs) have linked molecular initiating events like aromatase inhibition, androgen receptor (AR) agonism, and estrogen receptor (ER) antagonism to reproductive impairment in adult fish. Estrogen receptor agonists can also cause adverse reproductive effects, however, the early key events (KEs) in an AOP leading to this are mostly unknown. The primary aim of this study was to develop hypotheses regarding the potential mechanisms through which exposure to ER agonists might lead to reproductive impairment in female fish. Mature fathead minnows were exposed to 1 or 10 ng 17α-ethynylestradiol (EE2)/L or 10 or 100 µg bisphenol A (BPA)/L for 14 d. The response to EE2 and BPA was contrasted with the effects of 500 ng/L of 17β-trenbolone (TRB), an AR agonist, as well as TRB combined with the low and high concentrations of EE2 or BPA tested individually. Exposure to 10 ng EE2/L, 100 µg BPA/L, TRB, or the various mixtures with TRB caused significant decreases in plasma concentrations of 17β-estradiol. Exposure to TRB alone caused a significant reduction in plasma vitellogenin (VTG), but VTG was unaffected or even increased in females exposed to EE2 or BPA alone or, in most cases, in mixtures with TRB. Over the course of the 14-d exposure, the only treatments that clearly did not affect egg production were 1 ng EE2/L and 10 µg BPA/L. Based on these results and knowledge of hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis function, we hypothesize an AOP whereby decreased production of maturation-inducing steroid leading to impaired oocyte maturation and ovulation, possibly due to negative feedback or direct inhibitory effects of membrane ER activation, could be responsible for causing adverse reproductive impacts in female fish exposed to ER agonists.

Characterization of vitellogenin concentration in male fathead minnow mucus compared to plasma, and liver mRNA

The objective of this study was to characterize vitellogenin (VTG) protein in male fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) mucus compared with more conventional measures in plasma and mRNA isolated from liver. To assess the intensity and duration of changes in mucus VTG concentrations, male fathead minnows were exposed to 17α-ethinylestradiol (EE2) for 7 days with a subsequent depuration period of 14 days. The experiment was conducted in a flow-through system to maintain a consistent concentration of EE2 at a nominal EC₅₀ concentration of 2.5 ng/L and high concentration of 10 ng/L as a positive control. Mucus, plasma and liver were sampled at regular intervals throughout the study. Relative abundance of vtg mRNA increased after 2 days of exposure and returned to control levels after 4 days of depuration. VTG protein concentration displayed similar induction kinetics in both mucus and plasma, however, it was found to be significantly increased after 2 days of exposure using the mucus-based assays and 7 days with the plasma-based assay. Significantly elevated levels of VTG were detected by both assays throughout the 14-day depuration period. The elimination of the laborious plasma collection step in the mucus-based workflow allowed sampling of smaller organisms where blood volume is limiting. It also resulted in significant gains in workflow efficiency, decreasing sampling time without loss of performance.

Development of omics biomarkers for estrogen exposure using mRNA, miRNA and piRNAs

The number of chemicals requiring risk evaluation exceeds our capacity to provide the underlying data using traditional methodology. This has led to an increased focus on the development of novel approach methodologies. This work aimed to expand the panel of gene expression-based biomarkers to include responses to estrogens, to identify training strategies that maximize the range of applicable concentrations, and to evaluate the potential for two classes of small non-coding RNAs (sncRNAs), microRNA (miRNA) and piwi-interacting RNA (piRNA), as biomarkers. To this end larval Pimephales promelas (96 hpf +/- 1h) were exposed to 5 concentrations of 17α- ethinylestradiol (0.12, 1.25, 2.5, 5.0, 10.0 ng/L) for 48 h. For mRNA-based biomarker development, RNA-seq was conducted across all concentrations. For sncRNA biomarkers, small RNA libraries were prepared only for the control and 10.0 ng/L EE2 treatment. In order to develop an mRNA classifier that remained accurate over the range of exposure concentrations, three different training strategies were employed that focused on 10 ng/L, 2.5 ng/L or a combination of both. Classifiers were tested against an independent test set of individuals exposed to the same concentrations used in training and subsequently against concentrations not included in model training. Both random forest (RF) and logistic regression with elastic net regularizations (glmnet) models trained on 10 ng/L EE2 performed poorly when applied to lower concentrations. RF models trained with either the 2.5 ng/L or combination (2.5 + 10 ng/L) treatments were able to accurately discriminate exposed vs. non-exposed across all but the lowest concentrations. glmnet models were unable to accurately classify below 5 ng/L. With the exception of the 10 ng/L treatment, few mRNA differentially expressed genes (DEG) were observed, however, there was marked overlap of DEGs across treatments. Overlapping DEGs have well established linkages to estrogen and several of the 81 DEGs identified in the 10 ng/L treatment have been previously utilized as estrogenic biomarkers (vitellogenin, estrogen receptor-β). Following multiple test correction, no sncRNAs were found to be differentially expressed, however, both miRNA and piRNA classifiers were able to accurately discriminate control and 10 ng/L exposed organisms with AUCs of 0.83 and 1.0 respectively. We have developed a highly discriminative estrogenic mRNA biomarker that is accurate over a range of concentrations likely to be found in real-world exposures. We have demonstrated that both miRNA and piRNA are responsive to estrogenic exposure, suggesting the need to further investigate their regulatory roles in the estrogenic response.

DNA methylation and expression of estrogen receptor alpha in fathead minnows exposed to 17α-ethynylestradiol

The gene expression response thought to underlie the negative apical effects resulting from estrogen exposure have been thoroughly described in fish. Although epigenetics are believed to play a critical role translating environmental exposures into the development of adverse apical effects, they remain poorly characterized in fish species. This study investigated alterations of DNA methylation of estrogen receptor alpha (esr1) in brain and liver tissues from 8 to 10 month old male fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas) after a 2d exposure to either 2.5 ng/L or 10 ng/L 17α-ethynylestradiol (EE2). Changes in the patterns of methylation were evaluated using targeted deep sequencing of bisulfite treated DNA in the 5' region of esr1. Methylation and gene expression were assessed at 2d of exposure and after a 7 and 14d depuration period. After 2d EE2 exposure, males exhibited significant demethylation in the 5' upstream region of esr1 in liver tissue, which was inversely correlated to gene expression. This methylation pattern reflected what was seen in females. No gene body methylation (GBM) was observed for liver of exposed males. Differential methylation was observed for a single upstream CpG site in the liver after the 14d depuration. A less pronounced methylation response was observed in the upstream region in brain tissue, however, several CpGs were necessarily excluded from the analysis. In contrast to the liver, a significant GBM response was observed across the entire gene body, which was sustained until at least 7d post-exposure. No differential expression was observed in the brain, limiting functional interpretation of methylation changes. The identification of EE2-dependent changes in methylation levels strongly suggests the importance of epigenetic mechanisms as a mediator of the organismal response to environmental exposures and the need for further characterization of the epigenome. Further, differential methylation following depuration indicates estrogenic effects persist well after the active exposure, which has implications for the risk posed by repeated exposures..

Integrated use of biomarkers to evaluate the reproductive physiology of Astyanax fasciatus and Hoplias malabaricus males (Teleostei: Characiformes) in polluted reservoirs

The reproductive physiology of fish can be changed by the presence of pollutants in the water, which act as endocrine disrupting compounds (EDC). We evaluated the impacts of water contaminants in polluted reservoirs acting as possible EDC on the reproductive physiology of Astyanax fasciatus and Hoplias malabaricus males. We used biomarkers with different levels of biological organization. Hoplias malabaricus adult males were collected in the summer and winter at five different sites in the Tietê River Basin: the Ponte Nova reservoir (PN), considered a reference site due to the low anthropogenic influence; the Billings reservoir (BIL) at two different branches; and the Guarapiranga reservoir (GUA) at two different branches. Astyanax fasciatus adult males were collected at PN and BIL. BIL and GUA are subjected to great anthropogenic action. We analyzed gonadal histomorphology, testosterone (T), 11-ketotestosterone (11-KT), estradiol (E₂) plasma levels, and gene expression of hepatic vitellogenin (vtgA) and pituitary follicle stimulating hormone (fshβ). In the PN reservoir (reference), the biomarkers analyzed in both species did not differ between the periods analyzed. This is an evidence that the animals keep the same reproductive activity during both seasons. The changes in the plasma concentration of gonadal steroids in both species in polluted reservoirs suggest the presence of EDC compounds in the water and/or adjusts of the physiological setpoint to allow the reproduction in such adverse conditions. The use of vtgA as biomarker suggests the presence of estrogenic compounds, mainly in BIL, but with a more evident response of H. malabaricus. However, even considering physiological changes, both species present testes during the maturation phase that allow the reproduction in an environment with a high degree of pollution.

Distribution of vitellogenin in Japanese flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) for biomarker analysis of marine environmental estrogens

Estrogen pollution in marine environments has become a research hotspot due to its adverse effects on the reproduction of wild organisms. To early detection of estrogen pollution, this study developed two methods for detecting Japanese flounder vitellogenin (Vtg), a sensitive biomarker for environmental estrogens. Firstly, monoclonal antibodies (mAb) specific to Vtg were prepared using purified lipovitellin (Lv), a main Vtg-derived yolk protein. Anti-Lv mAb (C1F1) had the highest titer (1:256,000) and was labeled with fluorescein isothiocyanate to establish a direct immunofluorescence (DIF) method for histological detection of Vtg in tissues. Additionally, using the purified Lv and mAb, an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was developed and this assay had a detection limit of 0.75 ng/mL and a working range of 1.95-250 ng/mL. Furthermore, Vtg induction in the plasma of Japanese flounder exposed to 17β-estradiol (E₂), 17α-ethinylestradiol (EE₂), and bisphenol A (BPA) were quantified by ELISA, and Vtg induction in the liver of EE₂-exposed Japanese flounder were measured by DIF. Finally, the distribution of Vtg in Japanese flounder was detected using these two methods. The results revealed that Vtg mainly appeared in the terminal tail fin, liver, kidney, intestine, and spleen. Considering the high concentration of Vtg and easy sample collection, the terminal tail fin could be a new alternative to plasma for Vtg quantification, while kidney and liver are suitable for histological detection of Vtg.

New methods for purification of Paralichthys olivaceus lipovitellin and immunoassay-based detection of vitellogenin

Increasing levels of estrogenic pollution in marine environments has made the development of reliable biological detection techniques urgently needed. In this study, Japanese flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) lipovitellin (Lv) was purified and used to establish three immunological methods for the detection of vitellogenin (Vtg), a biomarker for environmental estrogens. Firstly, five different methods were employed to purify Lv, among which water-precipitation was the fastest and easiest way to purify Lv. Japanese flounder Lv was characterized as a phospholipoglycoprotein with a molecular weight of ∼369 kDa. Using purified Lv and its specific polyclonal antibody, a sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was developed. This assay had a working range from 7.8 to 250 ng/mL and a detection limit of 3.1 ng/mL. Furthermore, we developed an immunohistochemistry (IHC) and an immunofluorescence (IF) assay, both of which allowed visual detection of liver Vtg. Finally, Vtg induction in plasma and liver of juvenile Japanese flounders exposed to 17β-ethinylestradiol (EE₂) was measured using these three methods. Exposure to 10 and 50 ng/L EE₂ significantly increased plasma Vtg levels, and obvious positive fluorescence signals were observed near the liver sinusoidal vessels. These results confirmed that the methods developed effectively detected estrogenic activity of exogenous chemicals. Therefore, this study provides reliable methodologies for biomonitoring of estrogenic pollution in marine environments.

Extended fish short term reproduction assays with the fathead minnow and Japanese medaka: No evidence of impaired fecundity from exposure to atrazine

Short-term reproduction assays were conducted with fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) and Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes) to evaluate responses from atrazine exposure at environmentally relevant concentrations and above. Breeding groups of fish with multiple males and females were exposed to atrazine under flow-through conditions. Fathead minnows were exposed to mean measured concentrations of 1.0, 10, 26, 52, and 105 μg atrazine/L for 28 days. Medaka were exposed to mean measured concentrations of 9.4, 48, 74, 97, and 244 μg atrazine/L for 28 or 29 days. Fish were evaluated for survival, fecundity, fertility, total length, wet weight, secondary sex characteristics, gonadosomatic index (GSI) (P. promelas only), plasma or hepatic vitellogenin (VTG), and histopathology of gonads. General observations of health and behaviour were also conducted. There were no statistically significant effects (i.e., p < 0.05) of atrazine on survival, size, reproduction, behaviour, GSI, VTG, or secondary sex characteristics in either species at any exposure level. In fathead minnows, there were no histopathological findings associated with atrazine exposure in male fish, but there was an increased proportion of Stage 4.0 ovaries accompanied by an increase in proportion of Grade 3 post-ovulatory follicles in females of the 105 μg/L treatment group. Without a concomitant increase in oocyte atresia, neither of these findings are considered adverse for the health of the fish. In medaka, there were no significant effects of atrazine exposure on histopathology in either sex. These data support current weight-of-evidence assessments that atrazine does not cause direct adverse effects on fish reproduction at environmentally realistic concentrations.

Evaluation of targeted and untargeted effects-based monitoring tools to assess impacts of contaminants of emerging concern on fish in the South Platte River, CO

Rivers in the arid Western United States face increasing influences from anthropogenic contaminants due to population growth, urbanization, and drought. To better understand and more effectively track the impacts of these contaminants, biologically-based monitoring tools are increasingly being used to complement routine chemical monitoring. This study was initiated to assess the ability of both targeted and untargeted biologically-based monitoring tools to discriminate impacts of two adjacent wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) on Colorado's South Platte River. A cell-based estrogen assay (in vitro, targeted) determined that water samples collected downstream of the larger of the two WWTPs displayed considerable estrogenic activity in its two separate effluent streams. Hepatic vitellogenin mRNA expression (in vivo, targeted) and NMR-based metabolomic analyses (in vivo, untargeted) from caged male fathead minnows also suggested estrogenic activity downstream of the larger WWTP, but detected significant differences in responses from its two effluent streams. The metabolomic results suggested that these differences were associated with oxidative stress levels. Finally, partial least squares regression was used to explore linkages between the metabolomics responses and the chemical contaminants that were detected at the sites. This analysis, along with univariate statistical approaches, identified significant covariance between the biological endpoints and estrone concentrations, suggesting the importance of this contaminant and recommending increased focus on its presence in the environment. These results underscore the benefits of a combined targeted and untargeted biologically-based monitoring strategy when used alongside contaminant monitoring to more effectively assess ecological impacts of exposures to complex mixtures in surface waters.

Cupuaçu (Theobroma grandiflorum) residue and its potential application in the bioremediation of 17-Α-ethinylestradiol as a Pycnoporus sanguineus laccase inducer

Bioremediation is a strategy to mitigate environmental impacts of hazardous pollutants from anthropogenic sources. Natural byproducts, including agroindustrial wastes (AW) can be used to induce enzyme biosynthesis, leading up to enhancement of pollutants degradation process. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the use of cupuaçu, Theobroma grandiflorum AW as Pycnoporus sanguineus Laccase (Lac) inducer in order to promote 17-α-ethinylestradiol (EE2) bioremediation. The macro and micro-nutrients levels of cupuaçu AWs were evaluated in order to establish further correlations with enzymatic biosynthesis induction. The fungus was cultivated for 7 days in temperature of 28 ± 2 °C and agitation of 150 rpm. For bioremediation, Lac enzymatic extract was added to EE2 solution (10 µg mL^-1) and the percentage of removal was evaluated by HPLC after 1-24 hr of reaction. At optimized conditions, the enzyme extract production was remarkably enhanced by adding only 1% (w/v) of cupuaçu AW. Lac activity reached 1642 U mL^-1 on the 6th day of culture, which was higher than positive control (511 U mL^-1). 86% of EE2 removal was reached after 4 hr, and after 8 hr of reaction, 96.5% was removed. Analysis by direct infusion in MS-ESI-TOF exhibited intermediary compounds formed by radical hydroxilation.

Partial mRNA Sequences of the Biomarkers CYP1A, GST, CAT, GR, SOD, GPx, VTG and p53 in Flatfish Syacium gunteri from Gulf of Mexico

The present study reports partial sequences of a group of genes used as exposure and effect biomarkers of organic contaminants and/or heavy metals in Syacium gunteri. In order to isolate these sequences, cDNA was used to amplify fragments between 200 and 800 bp, which were then cloned and sequenced. The sequences presented high percentages of identity with genes involved in the metabolism of xenobiotic biotransformation (cytochrome P4501A and glutathione S-transferase), oxidative stress (catalase, glutathione reductase, glutathione peroxidase and superoxide dismutase), reproductive system (vitellogenin) and with the tumor suppressor protein p53 reported in the GenBank database. Subsequently, from the deduced sequence of amino acids of each fragment, their tridimensional structure was predicted, using homologous proteins from the Protein Data Base. This study generates an important base of molecular biomarkers for the monitoring of environmental health in the Gulf of Mexico.

Are we closer to the vision? A proposed framework for incorporating omics into environmental assessments

Environmental science has benefited a great deal from omics-based technologies. High-throughput toxicology has defined adverse outcome pathways (AOPs), prioritized chemicals of concern, and identified novel actions of environmental chemicals. While many of these approaches are conducted under rigorous laboratory conditions, a significant challenge has been the interpretation of omics data in "real-world" exposure scenarios. Clarity in the interpretation of these data limits their use in environmental monitoring programs. In recent years, one overarching objective of many has been to address fundamental questions concerning experimental design and the robustness of data collected under the broad umbrella of environmental genomics. These questions include: (1) the likelihood that molecular profiles return to a predefined baseline level following remediation efforts, (2) how reference site selection in an urban environment influences interpretation of omics data and (3) what is the most appropriate species to monitor in the environment from an omics point of view. In addition, inter-genomics studies have been conducted to assess transcriptome reproducibility in toxicology studies. One lesson learned from inter-genomics studies is that there are core molecular networks that can be identified by multiple laboratories using the same platform. This supports the idea that "omics-networks" defined a priori may be a viable approach moving forward for evaluating environmental impacts over time. Both spatial and temporal variability in ecosystem structure is expected to influence molecular responses to environmental stressors, and it is important to recognize how these variables, as well as individual factor (i.e. sex, age, maturation), may confound interpretation of network responses to chemicals. This mini-review synthesizes the progress made towards adopting these tools into environmental monitoring and identifies future challenges to be addressed, as we move into the next era of high throughput sequencing. A conceptual framework for validating and incorporating molecular networks into environmental monitoring programs is proposed. As AOPs become more defined and their potential in environmental monitoring assessments becomes more recognized, the AOP framework may prove to be the conduit between omics and penultimate ecological responses for environmental risk assessments.

Environmental pollution affects molecular and biochemical responses during gonadal maturation of Astyanax fasciatus (Teleostei: Characiformes: Characidae)

Endocrine disrupting compounds (EDCs) have the potential to alter fish reproduction at various levels of organization. The aim of this study was to assess the impact of a natural environment with heavily anthropogenic influence on the physiological processes involved in reproduction in the freshwater fish lambari (Astyanax fasciatus) using different biomarkers. Adult males and females were collected in different seasons from two distinct sites in the same watershed: Ponte Nova Reservoir (PN) considered a pristine or small anthropogenic influence reference point; and Billings Reservoir (Bil), subjected to a large anthropogenic impact. Biological indices, such as hepatosomatic index and gonadosomatic index (GSI), gonadal histomorphology, fecundity, and biomarkers such as plasma levels of estradiol (E2) as well as hepatic gene expression of its alfa nuclear receptor (ERα), were analyzed. Hepatic vitellogenin (VTG) gene expression was evaluated in both sexes, as an indicator of xenoestrogen exposure. Females collected at PN presented a typical annual variation reflected in GSI, whereas for those sampled at Bil the index did not change through the seasons. The higher concentration of E2 in males collected at Bil during spring/2013, together with the detection of VTG gene expression, suggest the presence of EDCs in the water. These EDCs may have also influenced fecundity of females from Bil, which was higher during winter and spring/2013. Gene expression of ERα and ovarian morphology did not differ between fish from both sites. Water conditions from Bil reservoir impacted by anthropic activity clearly interfered mainly with biomarkers of biological effect such as plasma E2 levels and absolute and relative fecundity, but also altered biomarkers of exposure as VTG gene expression. These facts support the notion that waterborne EDCs are capable of causing estrogenic activity in A. fasciatus.

Estrogen-responsive gene networks in the teleost liver: What are the key molecular indicators?

An overarching goal of environmental genomics is to leverage sensitive suites of markers that are robust and reliable to assess biological responses in a range of species inhabiting variable environments. The objective of this study was to identify core groups of transcripts and molecular signaling pathways that respond to 17alpha-ethylinestadiol (EE2), a ubiquitous estrogenic contaminant, using transcriptome datasets generated from six independent laboratories. We sought to determine which biomarkers and gene networks were those most robust and reliably detected in multiple laboratories. Six laboratories conducted microarray analysis in pieces of the same liver from male fathead minnows exposed to ∼15ng/L EE2 for 96h. There were common transcriptional networks identified in every dataset. These included down-regulation of gene networks associated with blood clotting, complement activation, triglyceride storage, and xenobiotic metabolism. Noteworthy was that more than ∼85% of the gene networks were suppressed by EE2. Leveraging both these data and those mined from the Comparative Toxicogenomics Database (CTD), we narrowed in on an EE2-responsive transcriptional network. All transcripts in this network responded ∼±5-fold or more to EE2, increasing reliability of detection. This network included estrogen receptor alpha, transferrin, myeloid cell leukemia 1, insulin like growth factor 1, insulin like growth factor binding protein 2, and methionine adenosyltransferase 2A. This estrogen-responsive interactome has the advantage over single markers (e.g. vitellogenin) in that these entities are directly connected to each other based upon evidence of expression regulation and protein binding. Thus, it represents an interacting functional suite of estrogenic markers. Vitellogenin, the gold standard for estrogenic exposures, can show high individual variability in its response to estrogens, and the use of a multi-gene approach for estrogenic chemicals is expected to improve sensitivity. In our case, the coefficient of variation was significantly lowered by the gene network (∼67%) compared to Vtg alone, supporting the use of this transcriptional network as a sensitive alternative for detecting estrogenic effluents and chemicals. We propose that screening chemicals for estrogenicity using interacting genes within a defined expression network will improve sensitivity, accuracy, and reduce the number of animals required for endocrine disruption assessments.

Tools to minimize interlaboratory variability in vitellogenin gene expression monitoring programs

The egg yolk precursor protein vitellogenin is widely used as a biomarker of estrogen exposure in male fish. However, standardized methodology is lacking and little is known regarding the reproducibility of results among laboratories using different equipment, reagents, protocols, and data analysis programs. To address this data gap we tested the reproducibility across laboratories to evaluate vitellogenin gene (vtg) expression and assessed the value of using a freely available software data analysis program. Samples collected from studies of male fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas) exposed to 17α-ethinylestradiol (EE2) and minnows exposed to processed wastewater effluent were evaluated for vtg expression in 4 laboratories. Our results indicate reasonable consistency among laboratories if the free software for expression analysis LinRegPCR is used, with 3 of 4 laboratories detecting vtg in fish exposed to 5 ng/L EE2 (n = 5). All 4 laboratories detected significantly increased vtg levels in 15 male fish exposed to wastewater effluent compared with 15 male fish held in a control stream. Finally, we were able to determine that the source of high interlaboratory variability from complementary deoxyribonucleic acid (cDNA) to quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) analyses was the expression analysis software unique to each real-time qPCR machine. We successfully eliminated the interlaboratory variability by reanalyzing raw fluorescence data with independent freeware, which yielded cycle thresholds and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) efficiencies that calculated results independently of proprietary software. Our results suggest that laboratories engaged in monitoring programs should validate their PCR protocols and analyze their gene expression data following the guidelines established in the present study for all gene expression biomarkers. Environ Toxicol Chem 2017;36:3102-3107. Published 2017 Wiley Periodicals Inc. on behalf of SETAC. This article is a US government work and, as such, is in the public domain in the United States of America.

Vitellogenin levels and others biomarkers show evidences of endocrine disruption in fish species from Iguaçu River - Southern Brazil

The adverse effects of endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) on aquatic wildlife and human health represent a current issue of high public concern. Even so, they are still poorly studied in aquatic environments of South America. The aim of the present study was to investigate the impact of EDCs in five cascading reservoirs from the Iguaçu River, evaluating reproductive endpoints in three native fish species (Astyanax bifasciatus, Chrenicicla iguassuensis and Geophagus brasiliensis). Additionally, a polyclonal antiserum anti-vitellogenin from G. brasiliensis and a capture ELISA assay were developed for detection of estrogenic or anti-estrogenic activities in male and female fish, respectively. Vitellogenin (VTG) levels in male fish from the Iguacu River was observed, as well as decreased levels of vitellogenin and estradiol in the plasma of female fish. These findings were associated with immature gonads and lower gonadosomatic index in G. brasiliensis adult females from the Foz do Areia (FA) Reservoir. Additionally, both endemic species (Astyanax bifasciatus and Chrenicicla iguassuensis) displayed immature gonads and histological changes, such as degeneration of germ cells, in other studied reservoirs. The current results suggest that these reproductive responses may be associated with the bioavailability of EDCs in the Iguaçu River. These impacts are likely related to chemicals released by human activities, especially from sewage and industrial sources and agricultural production, detected in previous studies. Overall, the FA reservoir was potentially the most affected by chemicals with endocrine properties, and further studies are necessary to identify and quantify these chemicals.

Assessing the potential for trace organic contaminants commonly found in Australian rivers to induce vitellogenin in the native rainbowfish (Melanotaenia fluviatilis) and the introduced mosquitofish (Gambusia holbrooki)

In Australia, trace organic contaminants (TrOCs) and endocrine active compounds (EACs) have been detected in rivers impacted by sewage effluent, urban stormwater, agricultural and industrial inputs. It is unclear whether these chemicals are at concentrations that can elicit endocrine disruption in Australian fish species. In this study, native rainbowfish (Melanotaenia fluviatilis) and introduced invasive (but prevalent) mosquitofish (Gambusia holbrooki) were exposed to the individual compounds atrazine, estrone, bisphenol A, propylparaben and pyrimethanil, and mixtures of compounds including hormones and personal care products, industrial compounds, and pesticides at environmentally relevant concentrations. Vitellogenin (Vtg) protein and liver Vtg mRNA induction were used to assess the estrogenic potential of these compounds. Vtg expression was significantly affected in both species exposed to estrone at concentrations that leave little margin for safety (p<0.001). Propylparaben caused a small but statistically significant 3× increase in Vtg protein levels (p=0.035) in rainbowfish but at a concentration 40× higher than that measured in the environment, therefore propylparaben poses a low risk of inducing endocrine disruption in fish. Mixtures of pesticides and a mixture of hormones, pharmaceuticals, industrial compounds and pesticides induced a small but statistically significant increase in plasma Vtg in rainbowfish, but did not affect mosquitofish Vtg protein or mRNA expression. These results suggest that estrogenic activity represents a low risk to fish in most Australian rivers monitored to-date except for some species of fish at the most polluted sites.

Initial development of a multigene 'omics-based exposure biomarker for pyrethroid pesticides

Omics technologies have long since promised to address a number of long standing issues related to environmental regulation. Despite considerable resource investment, there are few examples where these tools have been adopted by the regulatory community, which is in part due to a focus of most studies on discovery rather than assay development. The current work describes the initial development of an omics based assay using 48h Pimephales promelas (FHM) larvae for identifying aquatic exposures to pyrethroid pesticides. Larval FHM were exposed to seven concentrations of each of four pyrethroids (permethrin, cypermethrin, esfenvalerate and bifenthrin) in order to establish dose response curves. Then, in three separate identical experiments, FHM were exposed to a single equitoxic concentration of each pyrethroid, corresponding to 33% of the calculated LC50. All exposures were separated by weeks and all materials were either cleaned or replaced between runs in an attempt to maintain independence among exposure experiments. Gene expression classifiers were developed using the random forest algorithm for each exposure and evaluated first by cross-validation using hold out organisms from the same exposure experiment and then against test sets of each pyrethroid from separate exposure experiments. Bifenthrin exposed organisms generated the highest quality classifier, demonstrating an empirical Area Under the Curve (eAUC) of 0.97 when tested against bifenthrin exposed organisms from other exposure experiments and 0.91 against organisms exposed to any of the pyrethroids. An eAUC of 1.0 represents perfect classification with no false positives or negatives. Additionally, the bifenthrin classifier was able to successfully classify organisms from all other pyrethroid exposures at multiple concentrations, suggesting a potential utility for detecting cumulative exposures. Considerable run-to-run variability was observed both in exposure concentrations and molecular responses of exposed fish across exposure experiments. The application of a calibration step in analysis successfully corrected this, resulting in a significantly improved classifier. Classifier evaluation suggested the importance of considering a number of aspects of experimental design when developing an expression based tool for general use in ecological monitoring and risk assessment, such as the inclusion of multiple experimental runs and high replicate numbers.

Wastewater treatment plant effluent alters pituitary gland gonadotropin mRNA levels in juvenile coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch)

It is well known that endocrine disrupting compounds (EDCs) present in wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluents interfere with reproduction in fish, including altered gonad development and induction of vitellogenin (Vtg), a female-specific egg yolk protein precursor produced in the liver. As a result, studies have focused on the effects of EDC exposure on the gonad and liver. However, impacts of environmental EDC exposure at higher levels of the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonad axis are less well understood. The pituitary gonadotropins, follicle-stimulating hormone (Fsh) and luteinizing hormone (Lh) are involved in all aspects of gonad development and are subject to feedback from gonadal steroids making them a likely target of endocrine disruption. In this study, the effects of WWTP effluent exposure on pituitary gonadotropin mRNA expression were investigated to assess the utility of Lh beta-subunit (lhb) as a biomarker of estrogen exposure in juvenile coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch). First, a controlled 72-h exposure to 17α-ethynylestradiol (EE2) and 17β-trenbolone (TREN) was performed to evaluate the response of juvenile coho salmon to EDC exposure. Second, juvenile coho salmon were exposed to 0, 20 or 100% effluent from eight WWTPs from the Puget Sound, WA region for 72h. Juvenile coho salmon exposed to 2 and 10ng EE2L(-1) had 17-fold and 215-fold higher lhb mRNA levels relative to control fish. Hepatic vtg mRNA levels were dramatically increased 6670-fold, but only in response to 10ng EE2L(-1) and Fsh beta-subunit (fshb) mRNA levels were not altered by any of the treatments. In the WWTP effluent exposures, lhb mRNA levels were significantly elevated in fish exposed to five of the WWTP effluents. In contrast, transcript levels of vtg were not affected by any of the WWTP effluent exposures. Mean levels of natural and synthetic estrogens in fish bile were consistent with pituitary lhb expression, suggesting that the observed lhb induction may be due to estrogenic activity of the WWTP effluents. These results suggest that lhb gene expression may be a sensitive index of acute exposure to estrogenic chemicals in juvenile coho salmon. Further work is needed to determine the kinetics and specificity of lhb induction to evaluate its utility as a potential indicator of estrogen exposure in immature fish.

Interpretation of fish biomarker data for identification, classification, risk assessment and testing of endocrine disrupting chemicals

Chemical induced changes in fish biomarkers vitellogenin (VTG), secondary sex characteristics (SSC), and sex ratio indicate modes/mechanisms of action (MOAs) of EAS (estrogen, androgen and steroidogenesis) pathways. These biomarkers could be used for defining MOAs and the causal link between MOAs and adverse effects in fish for the identification of endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs). This paper compiled data sets of 150 chemicals for VTG, 57 chemicals for SSC and 38 chemicals for sex ratio in fathead minnow, medaka and zebrafish. It showed 1) changes in fish biomarkers can indicate the MOAs as anticipated; 2) in addition to EAS pathways, chemicals with non-EAS pathways induced changes in fish biomarkers; 3) responses of fish biomarkers did not always follow the anticipated patterns of EAS pathways. These responses may result from the interaction of chemical-induced multiple MOAs and confounding factors like fish diet, infection, culture conditions, general toxicity and stress response. The complex response of fish biomarkers to a chemical of interest requires EDC testing at multiple biological levels. Interpretation of fish biomarker data should be combined with relevant information at different biological levels, which is critical for defining chemical specific MOAs. The utility of fish biomarker data for identification, classification, PBT assessment, risk assessment, and testing of EDCs in the regulatory context was discussed. This paper emphasizes the importance of fish biomarker data in the regulatory context, a weight of evidence approach for the interpretation of fish biomarker data and the need for defining levels of evidence for the identification of EDCs.

Defining the role of omics in assessing ecosystem health: Perspectives from the Canadian environmental monitoring program

Scientific reviews and studies continue to describe omics technologies as the next generation of tools for environmental monitoring, while cautioning that there are limitations and obstacles to overcome. However, omics has not yet transitioned into national environmental monitoring programs designed to assess ecosystem health. Using the example of the Canadian Environmental Effects Monitoring (EEM) program, the authors describe the steps that would be required for omics technologies to be included in such an established program. These steps include baseline collection of omics endpoints across different species and sites to generate a range of what is biologically normal within a particular ecosystem. Natural individual variability in the omes is not adequately characterized and is often not measured in the field, but is a key component to an environmental monitoring program, to determine the critical effect size or action threshold for management. Omics endpoints must develop a level of standardization, consistency, and rigor that will allow interpretation of the relevance of changes across broader scales. To date, population-level consequences of routinely measured endpoints such as reduced gonad size or intersex in fish is not entirely clear, and the significance of genome-wide molecular, proteome, or metabolic changes on organism or population health is further removed from the levels of ecological change traditionally managed. The present review is not intended to dismiss the idea that omics will play a future role in large-scale environmental monitoring studies, but rather outlines the necessary actions for its inclusion in regulatory monitoring programs focused on assessing ecosystem health.

Evaluation of whole-mount in situ hybridization as a tool for pathway-based toxicological research with early-life stage fathead minnows

Early-life stage fish can be more sensitive to toxicants than adults, so delineating mechanisms of perturbation of biological pathways by chemicals during this life stage is crucial. Whole-mount in situ hybridization (WISH) paired with quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (QPCR) assays can enhance pathway-based analyses through determination of specific tissues where changes in gene expression are occurring. While WISH has frequently been used in zebrafish (Danio rerio), this technology has not previously been applied to fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas), another well-established small fish model species. The objective of the present study was to adapt WISH to fathead minnow embryos and larvae, and use the approach to evaluate the effects of estrone, an environmentally-relevant estrogen receptor (ER) agonist. Embryos were exposed via the water to 0, 18 or 1800 ng estrone/L (0, 0.067 and 6.7nM) for 3 or 6 days in a solvent-free, flow-through test system. Relative transcript abundance of three estrogen-responsive genes, estrogen receptor-α (esr1), cytochrome P450-aromatase B (cyp19b), and vitellogenin (vtg) was examined in pooled whole embryos using QPCR, and the spatial distribution of up-regulated gene transcripts was examined in individual fish using WISH. After 3 days of exposure to 1800 ng estrone/L, esr1 and cyp19b were significantly up-regulated, while vtg mRNA expression was not affected. After 6 days of exposure to 1800 ng estrone/L, transcripts for all three genes were significantly up-regulated. Corresponding WISH assays revealed spatial distribution of esr1 and vtg in the liver region, an observation consistent with activation of the hepatic ER. This study clearly demonstrates the potential utility of WISH, in conjunction with QPCR, to examine the mechanistic basis of the effects of toxicants on early-life stage fathead minnows.

Comparison of the sensitivity of four native Canadian fish species to 17-α ethinylestradiol, using an in vitro liver explant assay

Exposure to environmental estrogens and other endocrine-active chemicals can impact reproduction of freshwater fishes. While extensive data exists regarding the effect of estrogens on standard laboratory species, little is known about the sensitivity of freshwater fishes native to North America to these compounds. Current testing strategies for the toxicological assessment of contaminants still rely heavily on studies with live animals, which poses increasing concerns from an economical and ethical perspective. Therefore, the aim of the present study was to investigate the sensitivity of four native species, namely, northern pike (Esox lucius), walleye (Sander vitreus), white sucker (Catostomus commersoni), and juvenile white sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus), to an environmental estrogen, 17α-ethinylestradiol (EE2), using an in vitro tissue explant approach. Transcript abundances of vitellogenin (VTG) as well as the estrogen receptors (ER) α and β were used as the measuring endpoints as they represent well established biomarkers previously used to assess exposure to estrogens. Transcript abundance of VTG was upregulated in a concentration-dependent manner in each species. Liver explants of male walleye were found to have the greatest sensitivity to EE2, with a lowest observable effect concentration of 300 ng/L (1.0 nM) for VTG transcript abundance, with juvenile white sturgeon having the greatest magnitude of VTG transcript upregulation in exposed tissue (15-fold relative to control). Exposure of liver explants to EE2 resulted in no alteration in transcript abundance of ERβ, whereas upregulation of ERα was observed in northern pike only. Based on in vitro expression of VTG, the species tested were among the species with greatest sensitivity to environmental estrogens tested to date.

Relationship between biomarkers and endocrine-disrupting compounds in wild Girardnichthys viviparus from two lakes with different degrees of pollution

Despite great efforts worldwide to evaluate the effects of endocrine-disrupting compounds (EDCs) in fish, there is little information available about the interactions of EDCs with the disruption of the sexual endocrine axis in fish species with matrotrophic viviparity and intraluminal gestation. To understand these interactions, six sampling campaigns were performed within a period of 1 year in two lakes with different degrees of pollution. A battery of biomarkers of the oestrogenic response was assessed in the liver [vitellogenin, CYP 1A1, epoxide hydrolase activity, and metallothioneins (MT)] and MT in the head of Girardinichthys viviparus. Linear correlation analysis and canonical correspondence analysis were performed to explore the relationship between the oestrogenic response with EDCs and with metals. The biomarker responses were assessed using the water content of EDCs (oestrone, 17-β-oestradiol, oestriol, 17-α-ethinyl oestradiol, total phenols, bisphenol A, nonyl phenol, octyl phenol), as well as the PAHs indene[1,2,3-c,d]pyrene, naphthalene, pyrene, benzo[a]anthracene, benzo[k]fluoranthene and benzo[a]pyrene) and metals (Cu, Fe, Mn, Pb and Zn). Greater disruption of the sexual endocrine axis occurred in fish of both sexes inhabiting the polluted lake whose effects were apparently influenced by CYP 1A1 activity and by 17-α-ethinyl oestradiol. In addition, non-estrogenic mechanisms in the hypothalamus and pituitary glands in male fish were observed, elicited by endogenous levels and the water concentration of Pb. In contrast, in females from the less polluted lake, VTG induction was related to exogenous oestrogens. The disruption of the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis is a complex process influenced by both endogenous and exogenous factors and contributes to male feminisation by exposure to EDCs.

Natural Variation in Fish Transcriptomes: Comparative Analysis of the Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas) and Zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Fathead minnow and zebrafish are among the most intensively studied fish species in environmental toxicogenomics. To aid the assessment and interpretation of subtle transcriptomic effects from treatment conditions of interest, better characterization and understanding are needed for natural variation in gene expression among fish individuals from lab cultures. Leveraging the transcriptomics data from a number of our toxicogenomics studies conducted over the years, we conducted a meta-analysis of nearly 600 microarrays generated from the ovary tissue of untreated, reproductively mature fathead minnow and zebrafish samples. As expected, there was considerable batch-to-batch transcriptomic variation; this “batch-effect” appeared to differentially impact subsets of fish transcriptomes in a nonsystematic way. Temporally more closely spaced batches tended to share a greater transcriptomic similarity among one another. The overall level of within-batch variation was quite low in fish ovary tissue, making it a suitable system for studying chemical stressors with subtle biological effects. The observed differences in the within-batch variability of gene expression, at the levels of both individual genes and pathways, were probably both technical and biological. This suggests that biological interpretation and prioritization of genes and pathways targeted by experimental conditions should take into account both their intrinsic variability and the size of induced transcriptional changes. There was significant conservation of both the genomes and transcriptomes between fathead minnow and zebrafish. The high degree of conservation offers promising opportunities in not only studying fish molecular responses to environmental stressors by a comparative biology approach, but also effective sharing of a large amount of existing public transcriptomics data for developing toxicogenomics applications.